Arxiv:1511.03031V2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
submitted to acta physica slovaca 1– 133 A BRIEF ACCOUNT OF THE ISING AND ISING-LIKE MODELS: MEAN-FIELD, EFFECTIVE-FIELD AND EXACT RESULTS Jozef Streckaˇ 1, Michal Jasˇcurˇ 2 Department of Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics, Faculty of Science, P. J. Saf´arikˇ University, Park Angelinum 9, 040 01 Koˇsice, Slovakia The present article provides a tutorial review on how to treat the Ising and Ising-like models within the mean-field, effective-field and exact methods. The mean-field approach is illus- trated on four particular examples of the lattice-statistical models: the spin-1/2 Ising model in a longitudinal field, the spin-1 Blume-Capel model in a longitudinal field, the mixed-spin Ising model in a longitudinal field and the spin-S Ising model in a transverse field. The mean- field solutions of the spin-1 Blume-Capel model and the mixed-spin Ising model demonstrate a change of continuous phase transitions to discontinuous ones at a tricritical point. A con- tinuous quantum phase transition of the spin-S Ising model driven by a transverse magnetic field is also explored within the mean-field method. The effective-field theory is elaborated within a single- and two-spin cluster approach in order to demonstrate an efficiency of this ap- proximate method, which affords superior approximate results with respect to the mean-field results. The long-standing problem of this method concerned with a self-consistent deter- mination of the free energy is also addressed in detail. More specifically, the effective-field theory is adapted for the spin-1/2 Ising model in a longitudinal field, the spin-S Blume-Capel model in a longitudinal field and the spin-1/2 Ising model in a transverse field. The particular attention is paid to a comprehensive analysis of tricritical point, continuous and discontinu- ous phase transitions of the spin-S Blume-Capel model. Exact results for the spin-1/2 Ising chain, spin-1 Blume-Capel chain and mixed-spin Ising chain in a longitudinal field are ob- tained using the transfer-matrix method, the crucial steps of which are also reviewed when deriving the exact solution of the spin-1/2 Ising model on a square lattice. The critical points of the spin-1/2 Ising model on several planar (square, honeycomb, triangular, kagom´e, deco- rated honeycomb, etc.) lattices are rigorously obtained with the help of dual, star-triangle and decoration-iteration transformations. The mapping transformation technique [Continued on next page] PACS: 05.50.+q; 05.70.Jk; 75.10.-b; 75.10.Hk; 75.10.Jm; 75.30.Kz; 75.40.Cx Ising model, Blume-Capel model, Mean-field theory, Effective-field KEYWORDS: theory, Exact results, Mapping transformations, Critical behavior, Mixed spins, Transverse field 1E-mail address: [email protected] arXiv:1511.03031v2 [cond-mat.stat-mech] 11 Nov 2015 2E-mail address: [email protected] Institute of Physics, SAS, Bratislava, Slovakia 1 2 J. Streˇcka and M. Jaˇsˇcur is subsequently adapted to obtain exact results for the critical temperature and spontaneous magnetization of the mixed-spin Ising model on decorated planar lattices and three-coordi- nated archimedean (honeycomb, bathroom-tile and square-hexagon-dodecagon) lattices. It is shown that an increase in the coordination number of the mixed-spin Ising model on deco- rated planar lattices gives rise to reentrant phase transitions, while the critical temperature of the mixed-spin Ising model on a regular honeycomb lattice is always greater than the critical temperature of the same model on two semi-regular archimedean lattices with the same co- ordination number. The effect of selective site dilution of the mixed-spin Ising model on a honeycomb lattice upon phase diagrams is also examined in detail. Last but not least, the re- view affords a brief account of the Ising-like models previously solved within the mean-field, effective-field and exact methods along with a few comments on their future applicability. Contents 1 Introduction 4 2 Mean-field theory 7 2.1 Spin-1/2Isingmodelinalongitudinalfield . ......... 7 2.2 Spin-1Blume-Capelmodelinalongitudinalfield . .......... 10 2.3 Mixed-spinIsingmodelinalongitudinalfield . .......... 15 2.4 Spin-S Isingmodelinatransversefield . 18 2.5 Historicalsurveyandfutureperspectives . ........... 24 3 Effective-field theory 25 3.1 Callen-Suzukiidentity . .... 25 3.2 Spin-1/2 Ising model within a single-spin cluster approach ............ 28 3.2.1 Spontaneous magnetization and critical temperature ........... 32 3.2.2 Initialmagneticsusceptibility . ...... 34 3.3 Internalenergy,enthalpyandspecificheat . .......... 36 3.4 HelmholtzandGibbsfreeenergy.Entropy . ........ 39 3.5 Exactresultsforaspin-1/2Isingchain . ......... 42 3.6 Spin-1/2 Ising model in a transverse field within a single-spinclusterapproach . 45 3.7 Spin-1 Blume-Capel model within a single-spin cluster approach. 50 3.7.1 Continuous phase transitions and tricritical point . ............ 53 3.7.2 Discontinuousphasetransitions . ..... 55 3.8 Exact van der Waerden identities for higher-spin Ising models .......... 55 3.9 Approximate van der Waerden identities for higher-spin Isingmodels . 57 3.10 Spin-S Ising model in a transverse field within a single-spin clusterapproach . 61 3.11 Spin-1/2 Ising model within a two-spin cluster approach ............. 63 3.12 Historicalsurveyandfutureperspectives . ............ 69 A brief account of the Ising and Ising-like models 3 4 Exact results 71 4.1 One-dimensionalIsingmodels . ..... 71 4.1.1 Spin-1/2Isingchaininalongitudinalfield . ........ 71 4.1.2 Spin-1Blume-Capelchaininalongitudinalfield . ........ 78 4.1.3 Mixed-spinIsingchaininalongitudinalfield . ........ 80 4.2 Two-dimensionalIsingmodels . ..... 82 4.2.1 Duallatticeanddualtransformation . ...... 82 4.2.2 Star-TriangleTransformation. ..... 88 4.2.3 Decoration-IterationTransformation . ........ 92 4.2.4 Critical points of spin-1/2 Ising archimedean lattices ........... 96 4.2.5 Transfer-MatrixApproach . .. 98 4.2.6 Mixed-spin Ising model on decorated planar lattices . ..........104 4.2.7 Mixed-spin Ising model on three-coordinated planar lattices . .108 4.2.8 Selectivelydilutedmixed-spinIsingmodel . ........112 4.3 Historicalsurveyandfutureperspectives . ...........115 5 Conclusion 119 Acknowledgement 120 Appendix: Gibbs-Bogoliubov inequality 121 References 123 4 J. Streˇcka and M. Jaˇsˇcur 1 Introduction The Ising model represents one of the simplest but at the same time also one of the most fre- quently studied models of cooperative phenomena in statistical mechanics. An early history of the Ising model dates back to pioneering works by Lenz [1] and Ising [2], which have introduced and exactly solved one-dimensional(1D) version of this lattice-statistical model originally aimed at a theoretical description of a magnetic phase transition of ferromagnetic materials. However, the exact solution has refuted an existence of finite-temperature phase transition in the spin- 1/2 Ising linear chain, whereas the same conclusion was erroneously drawn also for its higher- dimensional versions [2]. This faulty conjecture has significantly suppressed an investigation of the Ising model over subsequent two decades during which it became of marginal research interest. The situation has dramatically changed after Onsager found the exact solution for the spin-1/2 Ising model on a rectangular lattice [3], which has rigorously proved an intriguing phase transition at finite temperature notwithstanding of an extremely short-ranged character of the in- teraction potential. The two-dimensional (2D) Ising model has accordingly gained a prominent place in statistical mechanics as paradigmatic example of exactly solved lattice-statistical model with a remarkable phase transition. It is beyond the scope of the present work to review here all crucial aspects of historical development of the Ising model and its various extensions, which have been exhaustively described in several previous review papers [4,5] to which the interested readers are referred to for further details. By contrast, the primary goal of the present work is to provide a comprehensive description of mean-field, effective-field and exact methods when applying them to different variants of the Ising model. Before doing this, it might be quite useful to recall some elementary facts about possible applications of the Ising model. The Ising model and its various extensions have an extraordinary capability of elucidating co- operative phenomena of seemingly diverse physical origin in spite of the fact that the model was originally proposed for a theoretical description of insulating magnetic materials. In this regard, let us at first briefly comment on traditional applications of the Ising model in magnetism. It is quite curious that it took almost a half century from the early development of the Ising model until the first experimental realizations of it were found in magnetism. For many years, the Ising model was therefore regarded more as a mathematical curiosity without any detailed corre- spondence to a specific magnetic material, because this model totally disregards quantum effects closely related to a non-commutability of spin operators. There are three principal requirements for a magnetic substance in order to be identified as the Ising-like material: 1. The dominant interaction between magnetic ions, which governs the overall magnetic be- havior, must be extremely short-ranged. 2. The ground state of magnetic ion must be a doublet, which is well separated in energy from all other excited states (typically magnetic ions with Kramer’s doublet ground