An Assessment of the Value of Souvenirs Penny Grennan

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

An Assessment of the Value of Souvenirs Penny Grennan Your Trash, My Treasure: An assessment of the value of souvenirs Penny Grennan PhD A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the University of Northumbria at Newcastle for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Faculty of Arts, Design and Social Sciences January 2015 1 Abstract. Your Trash, My Treasure: An assessment of the value of souvenirs. The importance of the object as a means of understanding the human world is an area of enquiry in Academic and Arts Practice. It spans a range of disciplines, particularly the new cross disciplinary area of Material Culture Studies, which reflects the increasing interest in the object and its role in our lives. The aim of this study is to identify the qualities of the souvenir that give it value, in order to add to the discourse surrounding the role of objects in understanding our world. This thesis considers the qualities of souvenirs in the light of critical theory, case studies, my Fine Art practice and exhibitions, and contemporary Fine Artists. I posit that the souvenir is an object with particular distinguishing features and that these distinct qualities are what give it its value. I will argue that the ‘narrative of origins’ of souvenirs (Stewart, 2007) is what gives them their value and I use the term ‘value’ in relation to their emotional, material, cultural and personal currency. The souvenir is often regarded as a ‘fallen object’ (MacCannell, 1976), but I will argue that in terms of personal narrative and social resonance the souvenir is a neglected area of study that enters value systems at every level. My practice comprises painting and film making, and through this I have investigated and articulated my relationship with my own souvenirs. During the case study interviews I devised the terms Object Plus, Souvenir Moment and Souvenir Dynamic to encode our relationship to souvenirs. These are important new terms which help to articulate the unique qualities of souvenirs. The study of the souvenir, as an object in its own right, has mainly been confined to its relationship with tourism and fictional writing and, with the exception of Susan Stewart’s work, has been largely neglected. This thesis argues that souvenirs, despite their associations with cheapness, ubiquity and kitsch, are our most potent objects and are therefore deserving of greater attention. 2 Contents Abstract 2 Contents 3 List of Figures 6 Acknowledgements 9 Declaration 10 Chapter 1. Introduction 11 1.1. Background and Context 12 1.2. My Practice 15 1.3. Methodology 16 1.4. Chapter Outlines 18 Chapter 2. The Souvenir in Theory 20 2.1. What is an Object? 21 2.1.1. Producing Things 22 2.1.2. Taste/Value 23 2.1.3. Attachment 24 2.1.4. Sign Value 24 2.2. The Personal 26 2.2.1. Literature and Things 29 2.2.2. Personal Contamination 30 2.3. The Object and the Souvenir 32 3 Chapter 3. Practice in Practice 37 3.1. My Home and My Collection 37 3.2. Painting the Souvenir 44 3.2.1. The Painting as Object 50 3.2.2. Commentary on Paintings 51 3.3. Film Making 64 3.4. Photography 71 Chapter 4. Multiple Narratives and Memory 73 4.1. Multiple Narratives: Recognising Objects 73 4.2. Activating Memory: The relationship between Memory and Narrative 74 4.2.1. The Role of External and Internal Memories in my Paintings 78 4.3. Narrating the Archive: Archiving the Narrative. 81 Chapter 5. Collectors and Collecting 90 5.1. Collecting 90 5.2. How Collectors Regard Themselves 93 5.2.1. Interview with a Collector 93 5.3. Gallery and Museum Collections: Changing Narratives 100 Chapter 6. Style and Value 105 6.1. Your Kitsch, My Souvenir 105 6.1.2 1950’s and 60’s Kitsch: The Individual and the Mass Produced 107 4 6.1.3. Kitsch and Hierarchies of Taste and Value 109 6.2. Value and Authenticity 112 6.3. Value and Display 114 Chapter 7. Cultural Currency and Cultural Seepage 118 7.1. Made in China 118 7.2. Making Souvenirs in Haiti 127 7.3. Cultural Seepage in Lamu 130 Chapter 8. Case Study Evaluation and Conclusion 133 8.1. Case Study Evaluation 133 8.2. Conclusion 148 References 153 Appendices 164 5 List of Figures Chapter 3 Figure 1: My Souvenirs 38 Figure 2: My Souvenirs 38 Figure 3: My Souvenirs 39 Figure 4: My Souvenirs 39 Figure 5: My Souvenirs 40 Figure 6: My Souvenirs 40 Figure 7: My Souvenirs 41 Figure 8: My Souvenirs 41 Figure 9: My Souvenirs 42 Figure 10: My Souvenirs 42 Figure 11: The Photograph (2011) 45 Figure 12: The Painting (2011) 45 Figure 13: Kookaburras (2010 On a shelf with other objects). 46 Figure 14: Figure 14: Snow Globe (2010 Wiping the paint, animating the object, obscuring the past). 46 Figure 15: Elephant. (2010 Blurring the background) 46 Figure 16: Garden Gnome (2013 A plain flat ground 47 Figure 17: Commentary on Paintings 52 Figure 18: Commentary on Paintings 53 Figure 19: Commentary on Paintings 54 Figure 20: Commentary on Paintings 55 6 Figure 21: Commentary on Painting 56 Figure 22: Commentary on Paintings 57 Figure 23: Commentary on Paintings 58 Figure 24: Commentary on Paintings 59 Figure 25: Commentary on Paintings 60 Figure 26: Commentary on Paintings 61 Figure 27: Commentary on Paintings 62 Figure 28: Paul Housley. The Roses in Blackpool (2005) 63 Figure 29: Mechanical Birds on a Branch view 1 70 Figure 30: Mechanical Birds on a Branch view 2 70 Figure 31: Mechanical Bird in a Cage view 1 70 Figure 32: Mechanical Bird in a Cage view 2 70 Figure 33: Duck Egg Cup view 1 70 Figure 34: Duck Egg Cup view 2 70 Figure 35: Plastic Parrot view 1 71 Figure 36: Plastic Parrot view 2 71 Figure 37: Votive Offerings at St. Roch Cemetery 72 Chapter 4 Figure 38: L with his Hedge Pig 77 Figure 39: Painting 1 78 Figure 40: Painting 2 79 Figure 41: Lisa Milroy: Personal Items. (1984) 80 Figure 42: The Consolation of Objects. Vitrine 28 82 7 Figure 43: 4213 Cigarette ends. Vitrine 68 86 Figure 44: Coffee Pot from Istanbul. 88 Chapter 5 Figure 45: My religious souvenirs 1. 90 Figure 46: My religious souvenirs 2. 91 Figure 47: Open shelf display of glass 94 Figure 48: Whitefriars Glass 96 Figure 49: A mixed display of glass on open shelves 97 Figure 50: The Narrative of Origins at the Gallery of Wonder. (2011) 103 Chapter 6 Figure 51: Examples of a Gallery Hang 1. 116 Figure 52: Examples of a Gallery Hang 2. 116 Chapter 7 Figure 53: New York Taxi 120 Figure 54: Made in China 1 120 Figure 55: Sydney Snow Globe 121 Figure 56: Made In China 2 121 Figure 57: Roman Centurion Pencil Sharpener 122 Figure 58: Made in China 3 123 8 Acknowledgements This study would not have been possible without the support and involvement of Claire and Oasis School of Human Development and those that I interviewed there. I would also like to thank Rick and Simon for agreeing to be interviewed and for being so open. I would like to say thank you to my friends and family, particularly Rosemary, and Simon for their knowledge, wisdom and encouragement, and to Clare for painstakingly proof reading my thesis. Thank you to my friends for their steadfast interest over, what must have felt like, a very long time. I would like to thank The Cherry Pickers for providing regular opportunities for me to sing my heart out. I would like to thank Northumbria University for giving me the chance to change direction in my life and to take it this far. Thank you to them, and to the AHRC, for funding my academic journey and for giving me the opportunity to assess the value of my souvenirs. I would like to thank my supervisory team. Helen Baker, who encouraged me to make films and guided my studio practice, Ysanne Holt who took over from Helen and who provided an appreciated critical eye, and to David Campbell who has seen me through the whole endeavour and who has been encouraging, supportive, perceptive and humorous throughout. For all their expertise and time and help, thank you very much. 9 Declaration. I declare that the work contained in this thesis has not been submitted for any other award and that it is all my own work. I also confirm that this work fully acknowledges opinions, ideas and contributions from the work of others. Any ethical clearance for the research presented in this thesis has been approved. Approval has been sought and granted by the School Ethics Committee on 11th July 2012. Penny Grennan Signature: Date: 10 Chapter 1. Introduction The aim of this PhD is to re-evaluate the souvenir both theoretically and through Fine Art Practice. I aim to reassess the value of souvenirs and to rehabilitate the souvenir as an object with distinct qualities acting as a window on the narrative of human relationships to others and self. I demonstrate that souvenirs evidence attitudes, fashions, cultural stereotyping, a human disposition to loss, longing, love, memory, memorial, conquest, attachment, narrative, context, and decoration in a way that no other category of objects do. I hope to contribute to the discourse surrounding Material Culture and our relationship with objects particularly through the framing of new terms to describe the unique qualities of souvenirs and our relationship with them. This will be achieved through: 1. Examining the nature of the souvenir in the context of theoretical writing and literature 2.
Recommended publications
  • How to Collect Coins a Fun, Useful, and Educational Guide to the Hobby
    $4.95 Valuable Tips & Information! LITTLETON’S HOW TO CCOLLECTOLLECT CCOINSOINS ✓ Find the answers to the top 8 questions about coins! ✓ Are there any U.S. coin types you’ve never heard of? ✓ Learn about grading coins! ✓ Expand your coin collecting knowledge! ✓ Keep your coins in the best condition! ✓ Learn all about the different U.S. Mints and mint marks! WELCOME… Dear Collector, Coins reflect the culture and the times in which they were produced, and U.S. coins tell the story of America in a way that no other artifact can. Why? Because they have been used since the nation’s beginnings. Pathfinders and trendsetters – Benjamin Franklin, Robert E. Lee, Teddy Roosevelt, Marilyn Monroe – you, your parents and grandparents have all used coins. When you hold one in your hand, you’re holding a tangible link to the past. David M. Sundman, You can travel back to colonial America LCC President with a large cent, the Civil War with a two-cent piece, or to the beginning of America’s involvement in WWI with a Mercury dime. Every U.S. coin is an enduring legacy from our nation’s past! Have a plan for your collection When many collectors begin, they may want to collect everything, because all different coin types fascinate them. But, after gaining more knowledge and experience, they usually find that it’s good to have a plan and a focus for what they want to collect. Although there are various ways (pages 8 & 9 list a few), building a complete date and mint mark collection (such as Lincoln cents) is considered by many to be the ultimate achievement.
    [Show full text]
  • WILDLIFE WATCHING and TOURISM a Study on the Benefits and Risks of a Fast Growing Tourism Activity and Its Impacts on Species IMPRINT
    WILDLIFE WATCHING AND TOURISM A study on the benefits and risks of a fast growing tourism activity and its impacts on species IMPRINT Published by United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the Secretariat of the Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS). Wildlife Watching and Tourism: A study on the benefits and risks of a fast growing tourism activity and its impacts on species UNEP / CMS Secretariat, Bonn, Germany. 68 pages. Produced by UNEP / CMS Convention on Migratory Species and TUI Author Richard Tapper, Environment Business & Development Group, E-mail: [email protected] Editing & Coordinator Paola Deda, CMS Secretariat, E-mail: [email protected] Publishing Manager Muriel M. Mannert Design Karina Waedt © 2006 United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) / Convention on Migratory Species (CMS). This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part and in any form for educational or non-profit purposes without special permission from the copyright holder, provided acknowledgement of the source is made. UNEP would appreciate receiving a copy of any publication that uses this publication as a source. No use of this publication may be made for resale or for any other commercial purpose whatsoever without prior permis- sion in writing from the United Nations Environment Programme. DISCLAIMER The contents of this volume do not necessarily reflect the views of UNEP or contributory organizations.The designations employed and the presentations do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNEP or contri- butory organizations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area in its authority, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
    [Show full text]
  • 2016 Pub Rpt HOBBY COLLECTIONS Revised
    Publicity Report - Premium Placing State Fair of Texas Page 1 Standard Sept. 30 - Oct. 23, 2016 Department - F HOBBY COLLECTIONS Place / Rank Name City/State Club/Farm Name Department F - HOBBY COLLECTIONS Class F - Lot 100 - ADVERTISING ITEMS HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st DENNIS BARDIN Quinlan, TX 2nd BOB CHAMBLEE Prosper, TX 3rd LAURA MCCARTHY Dallas, TX HM LOU ANNA CHAMBERS Dallas, TX Lot 101 - AMERICAN GLASS, ANY TYPE HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st LOU ANNA CHAMBERS Dallas, TX 2nd LESLIE WALLIS DURHAM Dallas, TX 3rd BRAD PATTERSON Keller, TX Lot 102 - AMERICAN POTTERY HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st JAN WIER Dallas, TX 2nd MIKE JAMES Dallas, TX 3rd FREDERICK STANWISE Dallas, TX Lot 103 - APOTHECARY ITEMS HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st MISTY ALLEN-GUINN Garland, TX 2nd ANGELA KING Arlington, TX 3rd PATTI BREWER Dallas, TX Lot 104 - BANKS - STILL HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st CHARLES BERG DALLAS, TX 2nd EVELYN CHEEK Mesquite, TX HM CAROL A GRIMES Mc Kinney, TX Lot 105 - BARBER ITEMS HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st RICK LEAL Grand Prairie, TX 2nd COLLIN PITTMAN Dallas, TX 3rd JANET L BLACKWELL Richardson, TX Lot 106 - BASKETS-CRYSTAL OR GLASS ONLY HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st JUDY SPENCER CREED Euless, TX Lot 107 - BELT BUCKLES HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st ERNEST CARR Duncanville, TX 2nd ANN PERDUE Carrollton, TX 3rd SUE TURNER FERRIS, TX Printed At 09/06/2016 12:59:42 PM Publicity Report - Premium Placing State Fair of Texas Page 2 Standard Sept. 30 - Oct. 23, 2016 Department - F HOBBY COLLECTIONS Place / Rank Name City/State Club/Farm Name Lot 108 - BOOKS, CHILDREN'S HOBBY COLLECTIONS 1st LINDA ROE
    [Show full text]
  • Creative Industries
    KEY INDUSTRY CREATIVE INDUSTRIES Colorado is a global leader in the creative INDUSTRY FACTS industries, which include six creative sub-groups: design, film and media, heritage, literary and publishing, performing arts, and visual arts and crafts: • Design applies artistic content to commercial products, services and the $300 environment, and includes companies that purchase fabrics, design, cut, sew and assemble garments and other sewn products ranging from footwear to handbags and luggage. Companies that provide design-related services (such as architectural, MILLION home interiors, graphic, and advertising-related agencies) are also included. EXPORTS 2013 TOTAL • Film and media companies provide technical and distributive elements of EXPORT Colorado’s entertainment industry, including companies that provide technical TOP 3 MARKETS production support systems such as sound, lighting, digital art, animation, sets and studios, broadcasting and distribution channels via motion picture, video and music 1. Canada production companies. • Heritage includes Colorado’s historical sites, museums and botanical gardens. 2. Mexico • Literary and publishing companies print newspapers, books, labels, stationary 3. Japan and other materials, and perform support activities such as data imaging and bookbinding. Companies that wholesale and publish newspapers, magazines, books, directories and mailing lists, and software are also included. • Performing arts includes actors, musicians, promoters, producers and directors and the venues at which they perform. Musical instrument and supply stores are also NUMBER OF included. COMPANIES • Visual arts and crafts companies manufacture metal, wood, jewelry, silverware, dolls and stuffed toys, games, musical instruments, wholesale toy and hobby goods, jewelry and precious metals. Photography studios, galleries, photofinishing laboratories, fine arts schools, art dealers, and sewing and needlework stores are also included.
    [Show full text]
  • 2021 Outdoor Participation Trends Report Table of Contents
    2021 OUTDOOR PARTICIPATION TRENDS REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Outdoor Participant Diversity The Next A Detailed Methodology Summary Participation Profile Generation Look Snapshot EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In 2020, 53 percent of Americans ages 6 and over participated in outdoor recreation at least once, the highest participation rate on record. As the COVID-19 pandemic ravaged communities and forced a nationwide shutdown, outdoor spaces became places of refuge to safely socialize, improve physical and mental health, connect with family and recover from screen fatigue. Remarkably, 7.1 million more Americans participated in outdoor recreation in 2020 than in the year prior. Despite these gains, nearly half of the U.S. population did not share in the proven, positive health outcomes of outdoor physical activity. COVID-19 inspired huge TERMINOLOGY participation growth, as detailed throughout this report. These PARTICIPANT A survey respondent who reported one-year gains, however, did Outdoor Foundation’s Thrive Outside participating in at least one outdoor activity not fundamentally alter the initiative is focused on reversing the in calendar year 2020. Participants often report undertaking multiple activities long-term challenges faced declining trend of outdoor engagement. multiple times throughout the year. by the outdoor industry. To build and strengthen networks that provide children and families with The outdoor industry and its PARTICIPATION RATE repeat and reinforcing experiences in partners are positioned to The proportion of a group that participated the outdoors, Thrive Outside awards in outdoor recreation or in an outdoor champion new ways to engage multiyear, capacity-building grants to activity. For example, if 6 in 10 teenagers outdoor participants and invest diverse communities.
    [Show full text]
  • The Creative Economy of Houston
    JULY 2012 THECREATIVE ECONOMY OF HOUSTON A comprehensive sTUDY OF creaTIVE-SECTor INDUStrieS and their IMPACT ON THE HOUSTON ECONOMY Commissioned by Houston Arts Alliance and University of Houston in partnership with Greater Houston Partnership Data and Analysis by EMSI Thank you to all of the many thoughtful participants in bringing this study to a reality. Nearly three years WELCOME LETTER ago, Houston Arts Alliance and University of Houston convened a group of creative, academic and policy leaders to discuss the broad creative sector in Houston. A few preliminary take-aways have informed the work since then. Among them is the sense that the delineation between the for-profit creative sectors and the non-profit arts is now highly porous. Artists and other creatives move fluidly between work in major arts institutions, community-based organizations, film, design and other creative endeavors. The “arts” today are about creative expression and creative experience, and don’t fall neatly within for-profit and non-profit parameters. We need to shift the perception from the arts as a quality of life attraction for a well-qualified workforce, to the creative sectors as a tremendously powerful component of the economy unto itself. I believe this study reflects these early ideas. This is a conservative study. By design, we asked our colleagues at EMSI to mirror the study as much as possible to successful studies in other major US cities, but to tailor it to Houston. The result are findings that are defendable, easy to grasp, and are presented within the context of Houston’s job sectors.
    [Show full text]
  • Economic Analysis of Outdoor Recreation in Washington State 2020
    ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF OUTDOOR RECREATION IN WASHINGTON STATE 2020 UPDATE AUTHORS Johnny Mojica Project Director, Earth Economics Angela Fletcher Project Director (Ecosystem Services), Earth Economics Suggested Citation: Mojica, J., Fletcher, A., 2020. Economic Analysis of Outdoor Recreation in Washington State, 2020 Update. Earth Economics. Tacoma, WA. The authors are responsible for the content of this report. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Research support was provided by Ken Cousins, Trygve Madsen, and Will Golding (Earth Economics) Report design by Cheri Jensen (Earth Economics) Map design by Corrine Armistead (Earth Economics) Project Oversight by Maya Kocian (Earth Economics) Funding provided by: Washington State Recreation and Conservation Office, Washington State Department of Natural Resources, Recreational Equipment, Inc. (REI) We would also like to thank: Wendy Brown (RCO), Kaleen Cottingham (RCO), Jon Snyder (Office of the Governor), Brock Milliern (DNR), Leah Dobey (DNR), Cassie Bordelon (DNR), Tom Bugert (DNR), and Marc Berejka (REI). Earth Economics’ Board of Directors Morgan Collins, David Cosman, Judy I. Massong, Nan McKay, Craig Muska, Ingrid Rasch, and Molly Seaverns. 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Executive Summary 3 2 Introduction 7 Report Overview 7 Background on Washington State 7 3 Concepts and Methods 9 The Outdoor Recreation Economy 10 Consumer Surplus and Environmental Benefits 11 Recreation Expenditure Flow 12 4 Expenditures and Economic Contribution of Outdoor Recreation in Washington State 13 Outdoor Recreation Participation and Spending
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Essential Facts About the Computer and Video Game Industry
    2019 ESSENTIAL FACTS About the Computer and Video Game Industry Foreword Table of Contents 2018 was a record-breaking year for our industry, with total video game sales exceeding $43.4 billion. Over 164 million adults in the United States play video games, and three-quarters of all Americans have at least one gamer in their Foreword 3 household. It’s now more important than ever to understand who America’s video At-A-Glance 5 game players really are and what’s driving them. Average Gamer 6 That’s why I’m thrilled to share the 2019 Essential Facts About the Computer and Video Game Industry. For the first time, we at the Entertainment Software Social & Lifestyle 9 Association have taken a comprehensive look at the individual Americans who enjoy video games and their lifestyles in order to better understand their profiles Parents of Gamers 10 and interests. Households with Children 13 The resulting data speaks for itself. Video game players represent a diverse cross- Who Plays 15 section of the American population spanning every age, gender, and ethnicity. They live healthy lives, are civically engaged, and are socially active. More than Purchasing 20 three-quarters report that video games provide them with mental stimulation (79%) as well as relaxation and stress relief (78%). The role of video games in the ESA Partners 22 American family is also changing: nearly three-quarters (74%) of parents believe video games can be educational for their children, and more than half (57%) enjoy ESA Members 23 playing games with their child at least weekly.
    [Show full text]
  • America's Creative Economy: a Study of Recent Conceptions, Definitions, and Approaches to Measurement Across the USA
    America's Creative Economy: A Study of Recent Conceptions, Definitions, and Approaches to Measurement Across the USA Christine Harris Christine Harris Connections Margaret Collins Center for Creative Economy Dennis Cheek National Creativity Network This project was supported in part or in whole by an award from the Research: Art Works program at the National Endowment for the Arts: Grant# 12-3800-7015. The opinions expressed in this paper are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the views of the Office of Research & Analysis or the National Endowment for the Arts. The NEA does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information included in this report and is not responsible for any consequence of its use. AMERICA’S CREATIVE ECONOMY A STUDY OF RECENT CONCEPTIONS, DEFINITIONS, AND APPROACHES TO MEASUREMENT ACROSS THE USA A REPORT FROM THE CREATIVE ECONOMY COALITION (CEC) A WORKING GROUP OF THE NATIONAL CREATIVITY NETWORK CHRISTINE HARRIS MARGARET COLLINS DENNIS CHEEK NATIONAL CREATIVITY NETWORK, OKLAHOMA CITY, OK, IN COLLABORATION WITH CREATIVE ALLIANCE MILWAUKEE, AUGUST 2013 AMERICA’S CREATIVE ECONOMY A STUDY OF RECENT CONCEPTIONS, DEFINITIONS, AND APPROACHES TO MEASUREMENT ACROSS THE USA A Report from the Creative Economy Coalition (CEC), a Working Group of the National Creativity Network ! Oklahoma City, OK: National Creativity Network Reproduction Rights: in collaboration with Creative Alliance Milwaukee, Organizations and individuals may freely August 2013 reproduce this report in whole or in part subject to the following requirements: 1) No copies may be sold, and 2) Excerpts must contain the full Christine Harris, M.Sc. citation of the report as follows: “Reproduced Principal Researcher and Lead Author with permission from America’s Creative Economy: Founder and CEO, Christine Harris Connections A Study of Recent Conceptions, Definitions, and Milwaukee, WI Approaches to Measurement across the USA.
    [Show full text]
  • Towards a Classification of Cultural Tourists
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TOURISM RESEARCH Int. J. Tourism Res. 4, 29±38 +2002) DOI: 10.1002/jtr.346 Towards a Classi®cation of Cultural Tourists Bob McKercher* Department of Hotel and Tourism Management, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Hong Kong, SAR ABSTRACT consumer base, without considering that dif- ferent types of cultural tourists may seek This paper proposes a model to segment the qualitatively different experiences or may be cultural tourism market according to two capable of engaging attractions at different dimensions: i) the importance of cultural levels. motives in the decision to visit a destination This paper proposes a model to segment the and ii) depth of experience. The model is cultural tourism market according to two tested empirically using Hong Kong as a case dimensions: +i) the importance of cultural study. The test identi®ed ®ve discrete motives in the decision to visit a destination cultural tourism market segments that and +ii) depth of experience.The model is exhibited substantially different behaviour. tested empirically using Hong Kong as a case Copyright # 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. study.The model has been proposed to advance the examination of cultural tourism as a tourism activity. Received 8 September 2000; revised 6 December 2000; accepted In this paper, terms such as shallow, deep, 12 December 2000 super®cial and meaningful are used to de- scribe different types of experiences engaged Keywords: cultural tourism; classi®cation in by cultural tourists.The terms are used as system; segmentation; Hong Kong. descriptors only; they are not used in a judgmental sense to imply that one type of INTRODUCTION activity is preferable to another or that one type of tourist is a more worthy type of cultural n spite of the fact that it has been recognised tourist than another.
    [Show full text]
  • Assessing Vermont's Creative Economy
    Assessing Vermont’s Creative Economy December 2019 PURPOSE document the critical importance of Vermont’s creative businesses, individuals and institutions, and demonstrate the substantial potential in the creative sector to boost the economy and to revitalize Vermont’s communities 2 DEFINING THE CREATIVE ECONOMY “the enterprises, organizations, and individuals whose products and services are rooted in artistic and creative content” 3 CREATIVE SEGMENTS design performing arts graphic design services, architecture, performing arts companies, promoters of landscape architecture, interior performing arts, music and dance schools, design, industrial design services, musical instrument manufacturing and printing, other specialized design supplies stores, self-employed actors, dancers, directors, musicians visual arts & fine crafts photography, sculpting, painting, culture and heritage jewelry, pottery, textiles, pressed and museums, historical sites, libraries/archives, blown glass, art dealers, galleries, antiques, preservation craft making, craft stores artisan foods film & media retail and commercial bakeries, breweries, motion picture and video industries, spice and extract companies, specialty sound recording, radio and television canning, chocolate and confectionary broadcasting, internet publishing, manufacturing, cheese manufacturing newspapers, advertising, public relations agencies, video game literary arts developers writers, publishers, bookstores, printing 4 VT CREATIVE ECONOMY Research Methods 5 RESEARCH METHODS economic data analysis
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 8: Tourism and Traveler Services 252
    Route 116 Scenic Byway Corridor Management Plan July 2013 Tourism and Traveler Services C H A P T E R 8 Route 116 Scenic Byway Introduction Visitors are drawn to the Route 116 Byway corridor for the many scenic, natural, recreational, historic, and cultural resources. Travelers experience a wide array of activities and a diverse landscape. With the changing seasons, the types of activities and attractions differ throughout the year. In many ways the Route 116 Scenic Byway embodies a classic New England experience. The goals of this chapter are to provide information on existing resources, services, and attractions available to the Byway traveler; to identify unmet needs related to tourism; and to propose recommendations or identify potential projects to enhance and improve tourism along the Byway. The chapter contains an inventory of the existing tourism services including the location of visitor centers and information agencies, as well as websites and publications that provide additional traveler information. A summary of attractions and resources along the Byway, including scenic and natural attractions, outdoor recreation opportunities, historic and cultural resources, events and festivals, and public restroom facilities, is also provided. Resources that have not been detailed in previous chapters of the Corridor Management Plan are included in this chapter. The resources that are located directly on or within a half-mile radius of the Route 116 Scenic Byway are noted with the “America’s Byway” symbol. While the Corridor Management Plan focuses on resources within a half‐mile radius of the Byway (Route 116), this chapter of the report also includes attractions that are located outside of the study area boundary, but within the towns along the Byway.
    [Show full text]