Columbus Avenue and the Upper West Side Oral History Project
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`(#%$F]$*(&/!E#/!M%5$!`(#%$F]A,2&$*!@$&%%$5!4%$)%%#!1,.23425!6'%#2%! E#/!635$%&/E3!6'%#2%!E#/!:&%E$%/!E!:,332#($F!)($*!5*E&%/!,2$/,,&!58E:%K!@*%!&%:E..5!&,20*! F%E&5!(#!$*%!#%(0*4,&*,,/!E#/!E.5,!E!5$&,#0!:,332#($F!$*E$!5*%!#%'%&!:,#5(/%&%/!.%E'(#0K! ! -./&(/0%!E.5,!$E.U5!E4,2$!*%&!A(&5$!P,4!QE$!17@S!E#/!*%&!),&U!E5!E!58%:(E.!E55(5$E#$!(#!$*%!G(#/5EF! E/3(#(5$&E$(,#J!)*%&%!5*%!*%.8%/!)($*!E&&E#0%3%#$5!A,&!$*%!1*&(5$,8*%&!@$&%%$!G(4%&E$(,#!XE&:*! (#!=>a<!E#/!/%E.$!)($*!:,#/($(,#5!(#!@+N5!Q5(#0.%!&,,3!,::28E#:F!&%5(/%#:%5S!E#/!EAA,&/E4.%! *,25(#0!A,&!8,,&!`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b8&%55%/!(#!$*(5!,&E.!*(5$,&F!(#$%&'(%)!E&%!$*%!(#$%&'(%)%%_5!E.,#%!E#/!/,!#,$! #%:%55E&(.F!&%A.%:$!$*,5%!,A!$*%!1,.23425!6'%#2%!725(#%55!"38&,'%3%#$!9(5$&(:$K! ! ! ! ! ! -./&(/0%!?!@%55(,#!=!,A!;! R! ! "#$%&'(%)%%*!+,##(%!-./&(/0%! "#$%&'(%)%&*!G%F.E!H2&E.! "#$%&'(%)!+,$%*!C%4&2E&F!=IJ!;<=>! -%..(/#*!=!,A!;! 0/1,$(/#*!`%)![,&UJ!`K[K!! ! ! 23&,4*!c<<d<<d<=e!NUEFJ!($_5!D*2&5/EFJ!C%4&2E&F!=I$*J!;<=>K!D*(5!(5!G%F.E!H2&E.!(#$%&'(%)(#0! +,##(%!-./&(/0%!(#!*%&!E8E&$3%#$!A,&!$*%!1,.23425!6'%#2%!E#/!L88%&!M%5$!@(/%!N&E.!O(5$,&F! B&,P%:$K!D*E#U!F,2J!+,##(%K! 54+&(+6%*!c<<d<<d=Ie![,2_&%!)%.:,3%!c:*2:U.%5eK! 23&,4*!c<<d<<d=^e!M*E$!"_3!&%E..F!(#$%&%5$%/!(#!(5!5,&$!,A!F,2&!5$,&(%5!E#/!3%3,&(%5!,A!$*%!L88%&! M%5$!@(/%!E5!F,2_'%!%b8%&(%#:%/!($!8%&5,#E..F!E#/!$*%!),&U!$*E$!F,2_'%!/,#%!)($*!E#/!A,&!$*%! #%(0*4,&*,,/K! 54+&(+6%*!c<<d<<d;Te!"$_5!E!.,$K![,2!U#,)J!"_3!,./J!5,!($_5!E!.,$!,A!F%E&5!c:*2:U.%5eK!"_'%!.('%/!,#! $*%!M%5$!@(/%!)($*!$*%!%b:%8$(,#!,A!E!A%)!F%E&5!$*E$!"!/,#_$!E/3($J!42$!)*%#!"!)E5f"!02%55!A&,3! 5%:,#/!0&E/%!$,!5(b$*!0&E/%J!)%!3,'%/!E&,2#/!E!.,$K!"!)E5!4,&#!(#!=>R=J!E$!E!*,58($E.!$*E$!)E5!,#! M%5$!-#/!6'%#2%!E#/!E&,2#/!@(b$F]5%:,#/!@$&%%$K!"$!.E$%&!4%:E3%!$*%!B,)%&!X%3,&(E.!"#5$($2$%! ,&!5,3%$*(#0J!*(0*!5:*,,.!,&!5,3%$*(#0J!E#/!#,)!"!$*(#U!($_5!E!:,#/,3(#(23K!6#/!"_'%!.('%/! 4E5(:E..F!E5!AE&!#,&$*!E5!`(#%$F]$*(&/!@$&%%$!E#/!#,)!E5!AE&!5,2$*!E5!C(A$F]5%'%#$*!@$&%%$K!! c<<d<=d<ae!"!)E5!*%&%!/2&(#0!M,&./!ME&!""f4%A,&%!E:$2E..FK!"!)E5!4,&#!(#!=>R=K!@,J!$*E$!)E5!"! 02%55!$*%!*%(0*$!,A!$*%!9%8&%55(,#!E#/!5$,&(%5!E4,2$J!F,2!U#,)J!E!5*E#$F$,)#!(#!+('%&5(/%!BE&U! E#/!E..!,A!$*E$K!"!)%#$f)*%#!)%!3,'%/!4E:U!*%&%!A&,3!B*(.E/%.8*(EJ!"!.('%/!(#!-.U(#5!BE&UJ! B%##5F.'E#(EK!XF!AE$*%&!*E/!:*E#0%/!P,45!E!.,$J!5,!)%!3,'%/!E!.,$!(#!$*%!A(&5$!:,28.%!,Af(#! $*,5%!3(/]F%E&5!)*%#!"!)E5#_$!*%&%K!"!)%#$!$,!B@!cB24.(:!@:*,,.e!=VV!E#/!$*%#!"!)%#$!$,!W,E#!,A! 6&:!W2#(,&!O(0*!@:*,,.J!)*(:*!)E5!,#!`(#%$F]$*(&/!@$&%%$K!D*%#!"!)%#$!$,!$*%!O(0*!@:*,,.!,A! ! ! -./&(/0%!?!@%55(,#!=!,A!;! I! ! X25(:!Y!6&$J!)*(:*!)E5!28!#%E&!1($F!1,..%0%!cD*%!1($F!1,..%0%!,A!`%)![,&UeJ!E#/!$*%#!"! .E#/%/!28!E$!7E&#E&/!1,..%0%K!@,!($_5!E.)EF5!4%%#!,#!$*%!M%5$!@(/%K!! c<<d<=dI>e!"!25%/!$,!0,!$,!*(0*!5:*,,.!,#!E!$&,..%F!:E&!$*E$!&E#!28!7&,E/)EFJ!:.,5%!$,!$*%!(5.E#/5J! E#/!"!&%3%34%&f($!5%%35!(38,55(4.%f42$!)%!5$,,/!#%b$!$,!EfF,2!U#,)J!$*%!$&,..%F!:E&!),2./! 4%!$*%&%!E#/!$*%#!)%!)%&%!,#!$*%!5(/%!#%E&!$*%!5(/%)E.UJ!42$!)%_/!5$E#/!(#!$*%!3(//.%!,A!$*%! 5$&%%$!A,&!$*%!$&,..%F!:E&K!D*%&%!),2./!4%!E!8,5$!(#!E!)*($%!:,#:&%$%!4E5%!E#/!$*E$_5!)*%&%!)%! 8(:U%/!$*%!$&,..%F!:E&!28K!M%!*E/!$,!$&E#5A%&!E$!=;^$*!@$&%%$!$,!0%$!28!$,!=Ra$*!@$&%%$K!"$_5!*E&/!A,&! 3F!U(/5!$,!2#/%&5$E#/!$*%&%!)E5!E!$&,..%F!:E&K!6#/!,A!:,2&5%!E.5,!$*%&%!)%&%!$*%!/,24.%]/%:U%&! 425%5K!! c<<d<;d;Ve!M%!E.)EF5!.('%/!)%5$!,A!7&,E/)EFJ!E#/!"!0,$!(#$,!E!.,$!,A!$&,24.%!F%E&5!.E$%&!)*%#!"! 5E(/!$*E$!$*%f%58%:(E..F!$*%!W%)(5*!:*(./&%#!)%&%fE.$*,20*!"!)%#$!$,!B@!=VV!E#/!W,E#!,A!6&:! $*E$!)%&%!4%$)%%#!635$%&/E3!c6'%#2%e!E#/!1,.23425!c6'%#2%ef)%!#%'%&!)E.U%/!,'%&!$,! 1%#$&E.!BE&U!,#!,#%!,A!$*%!53E..%&!5$&%%$5f)%_/!0,!$,!-(0*$F]5(b$*!@$&%%$f4%:E25%!$*%!"&(5*! U(/5!),2./!4%E$!25!28K! c<<d<;d^Te!@,J!)*%#!"!A(&5$!)%#$!$,!),&U!A,&!W,*#!G(#/5EF!(#!=>a<J!$*%&%!)E5!E#!(#$%&'(%)!)($*! 3%!(#!!"#$%#&$'()*$+(,-.$W2/F!X(:*E%.5,#J!E#/!5*%fE$!5,3%!8,(#$!"!325$!*E'%!$,./!$*%!5$,&F! $*E$!"!)E5!EA&E(/!)%_/!4%!4%E$%#!28K!@,J!F%E&5!.E$%&J!)*%#!W(33F!7&%5.(#!E#/!"!3E&&(%/J!E!A&(%#/! ,A!*(5!:E..%/f5,3%4,/F!"!U#%)f"!3%E#J!E#!"&(5*3E#!)*,!),&U%/!E$!$*%!1($F!1,2#:(.J!(#!$*%! 8,.(:%!/%8E&$3%#$f*%!:E..%/!W(33F!E#/!*%!5E(/J!Z6&%!F,2!3E&&F(#0!+,##(%!-./&(/0%g!9,#_$! F,2!U#,)!5*%!*E$%5!1E$*,.(:5h\!c1*2:U.%5e!@,J!($_5!$*E$!U(#/!,A!$&E/($(,#K! cB*,#%!&(#05e! c<<d<RdR=e!"!$*,20*$!"!/(5:,##%:$%/!($J!"_3!5,!5,&&FK!! ! ! -./&(/0%!?!@%55(,#!=!,A!;! ^! ! c"`D-++LBD"N`e! c<<d<RdR;e!f5$&%%$5J!E#/!)(/%!5$&%%$5!)%&%!E.)EF5!$*%!/('(5(,#5!4%$)%%#!#%(0*4,&*,,/5K!@,J!3F! /('(5(,#!),2./!4%!4%$)%%#!-(0*$F]5(b$*!E#/!`(#%$F]5(b$*K!6#/!"!&%3%34%&!U(/5!25%/!$,!8.EF! 3E&4.%5!,#!$*%5%!5$&%%$5!E#/!F,2!:,2./#_$!&%E..F!)E.U!5,3%$(3%5!,#!$*%!5(/%)E.U!4%$)%%#!:%&$E(#! 4.,:U5K!D*%&%_/!4%!3E&4.%5K!! c<<d<Rd^;e!6$!W,E#!,A!6&:!W2#(,&!O(0*!@:*,,.J!)%!25%/!$,!*E'%!.(#%!28!,2$5(/%!E#/!)%!)%&%#_$! E..,)%/!$,!$E.U!(#!$*%!:.E55&,,35!E#/!($!)E5!E!.($$.%!,88&%55('%J!5,!$*E$_5!)*F!"!)%#$!$,!X25(:!Y! 6&$!E$!$*%!%#/!,A!%(0*$*!0&E/%K!72$!E$!W,E#!,A!6&:J!"!*E/!E!:('(:5!$%E:*%&!(#!5%'%#$*!0&E/%!)*,! )E5!&%3E&UE4.%K!O%!.E$%&!4%:E3%!E!8&(#:(8E.!E$!E#,$*%&!5:*,,.J!O%&4%&$!-'E#!cgeK!6#/!*%!)E5! &%E..F!&%58,#5(4.%!A,&!%#&(:*(#0J!,&!8(:U(#0!28!,#J!3F!(#$%&%5$!(#!8,.($(:5!E#/!P25$!3E/%!3%!/%%8.F! (33%&5%/!(#!8,.($(:5K!O%!),2./!$EU%f*%!*E/!5,3%$*(#0!:E..%/![,2$*!72(./%&5J!)*(:*!)E5!E#! -.%E#,&!+,,5%'%.$!8&,P%:$J!E#/!)%!%'%#!3%$!)($*!-.%E#,&!+,,5%'%.$K!O%_/!$EU%!25!$,!$*%!D,)#! OE..J!)*(:*!(5!E!42(./(#0!/,)#!,#!$*%!cM%5$e!C,&$(%5J!$,!$*%!D,)#!OE..!X%%$(#0!,A!$*%!6(&! c63%&(:E_5!D,)#!X%%$(#0!,A!$*%!6(&eK!D*%F!),2./!*E'%!E!A,&23!%'%&F!)%%UJ!"!$*(#U!($!)E5J!E#/! )%!),2./!4%!E4.%!5,3%$(3%5!$,!E5U!i2%5$(,#5K! c<<d<IdIae!"$!)E5!/2&(#0!$*%!)E&!%AA,&$J!5,!($!)E5!&%E..F!E!)*,.%!%38*E5(5!,#!:('(:5!E#/!F,2&!&,.%! E5!E!:($(j%#!E#/!F,2&!8E&$(:(8E$(,#J!)*(:*!*E5!&%E..F!5$EF%/!)($*!3%!$*&,20*!3F!)*,.%f$*E$_5! )*E$!3,$('E$%/!3%K! c<<d<^d<Re!M%!)%#$!$,!$*%!c1*E&.%5!XKe!@:*)E4!3E#5(,#J!"!&%3%34%&K!D*%&%_5!E#!E8E&$3%#$! 42(./(#0!:E..%/!@:*)E4!O,25%K!"$_5!E!)*,.%!5i2E&%!4.,:UK!72$!(#!$*%!%E&.F!/EF5J!($!*E/!E!3E#5(,#! ,#!($!E#/!$*%!)*,.%!4.,:U!)E5!$*%!52&&,2#/(#0!,#%K!6#/!E!A&(%#/!,A!3(#%!E#/!"!)%#$!E#/!&E#0!$*%! ! ! -./&(/0%!?!@%55(,#!=!,A!;! V! ! A&,#$!/,,&4%..!E#/!$*%!:E&%$EU%&!:E3%J!4%:E25%!#,4,/F!)E5!.('(#0!$*%&%J!E#/!)%!0,$!E!)*,.%! 42#:*!,A!U%F5!A,&!$*%!)E&!%AA,&$!c:*2:U.%5eK!! c<<d<^d;ae!6#/J!F,2!U#,)J!)%!*E/!&E$(,#!5$E385K!O%E/.(0*$5!,#!$*%!:E&5!)%&%!E..!*E.A!8E(#$%/! 4.E:UK!D*%!5$&%%$.E385!)%&%!*E.A!8E(#$%/!4.E:UJ!5,3%$(3%5!)%&%#_$!,#K!D*%&%!)%&%#_$!3E#F!:E&5! 4%:E25%!$*%&%!)E5!0E5!&E$(,#(#0K!@,J!)%!25%/!$,!8.EF!(#!$*%!3(//.%!,A!$*%!5$&%%$!,#!E#F!,A!$*%! 5$&%%$5K! c<<d<^dIae!M%!*E/!E(&]&E(/!/&(..5!(#!5:*,,.J!42$!)%!#%'%&!&%E..F!A%E&%/!$*E$!)%!)%&%!0,(#0!$,!4%! E$$E:U%/f,&!E$!.%E5$!"!/(/#_$K!"!/(/#_$!A%%.!$*E$!5%#5%K!72$!($!)E5!%%&(%K!M%_/!*E'%!E(&]&E(/!/&(..5K! XF!AE$*%&!4,20*$!E!.(0*$!$*E$!($!)E5!02E&E#$%%/!$*E$!F,2!:,2./!U%%8!,#!/2&(#0!$*%!E(&!&E(/J!E#/!$*%! E(&]&E(/!)E&/%#5J!)*,!)%&%!E..!',.2#$%%&5J!),2./!4.,)!$*%(&!)*(5$.%5!E#/!5EFJ!ZD2&#!,2$!$*E$!.(0*$! (#!68E&$3%#$!R6h\!E#/!*%!),2./!5EFJ!ZD*%F!:E#_$!5%%!($K\![,2!U#,)J!5,!($!)E5!$*E$!U(#/!,A! 5$&%55K!72$!$*E$!)E5!E4,2$!($K! c<<d<Vd;Ie!M%_/!5$E#/!,#!.(#%!$,!42Ff$*%&%!)E5!E!5$,&%f$*%&%!25%/!$,!4%!E!524)EF!E$!>=5$!E#/! 7&,E/)EF!E#/!$*E$!0,$!:.,5%/!/,)#K!`,)!)%!0,!A&,3!-(0*$F]5(b$*!$,!`(#%$F]$*(&/f8E&$!,A!$*%!