Seeking Health Care from a General Hospital in Uganda
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Elsevier - Publisher Connector African Journal of Emergency Medicine (2016) 6, 174–179 African Federation for Emergency Medicine African Journal of Emergency Medicine www.afjem.com www.sciencedirect.com ORIGINAL RESEARCH ARTICLES Seeking health care from a general hospital in Uganda following a fracture or a dislocation La recherche de soins de sante´ aupre`s d’un hoˆpital ge´ne´ral en Ouganda suite a` une fracture ou une luxation Isaac Kajja a,*, Cees Th. Smit Sibinga b a Department of Orthopedics, School of Medicine, College of Health Sciences, Makerere University, PO Box 7072, Kampala, Uganda b International Development of Transfusion Medicine, University of Groningen, Netherlands Received 28 January 2016; revised 25 April 2016; accepted 23 May 2016 Available online 25 July 2016 Introduction: Selecting a treatment approach and a facility to get treated from, poses a challenge in musculoskeletal injuries in Africa. The study aimed at determining demographic and injury characteristics of patients with musculoskeletal injuries and how these impact the time and reason for presenting to a general hospital in Uganda. Methods: An observational study was carried out at Entebbe general hospital on patients presenting with musculoskeletal injuries between 1 November 2014 and 28 February 2015. The patient demographics, injury characteristics, duration of injury to presentation for treatment and reason for seeking treatment from this hospital were noted. Results: A total of 101 patients were recruited. Of these, 95 had fractures while six had dislocations. Patients took an average of 96 h before presenting for care, females taking significantly longer than males (191.2 and 58.6 h respectively, p = 0.005). The fractured segment of bone significantly influenced the patients’ choice for care at this hospital (p = 0.02). Discussion: Entebbe General Hospital serves a young and unemployed population for musculoskeletal injuries. These patients present late for care, especially females. Patients base their choice for care from this hospital on the character of the injury. Introduction: La se´ lection d’une approche de traitement et d’un e´ tablissement ou` l’on peut se faire soigner pose un proble` me en matie` re de le´ sions musculosquelettiques en Afrique. L’e´ tude visait a` de´ terminer les caracte´ ristiques de´ mographiques et des blessures des patients atteints de le´ sions musculosquelettiques et leur incidence sur le de´ lai et le motif de la consultation dans un hoˆpital ge´ ne´ ral en Ouganda. Me´thodes: Une e´ tude d’observation a e´ te´ effectue´ ea` l’hoˆpital ge´ ne´ ral d’Entebbe sur des patients pre´ sentant des le´ sions musculosquelettiques entre le 1er novembre 2014 et le 28 fe´ vrier 2015. Les donne´ es de´ mographiques des patients, les caracte´ ristiques des blessures, le de´ lai entre la blessure et la consultation en vue de se faire traiter, et le motif de la recherche de traitement aupre` s cet hoˆpital ont e´ te´ enregistre´ s. Re´sultats: Au total, 101 patients ont e´ te´ e´ tudie´ s. Parmi ceux-ci, 95 souffraient de fractures alors que 6 souffraient de luxations. Les patients ont mis en moyenne 96 heures a` consulter pour se faire soigner, les femmes prenant bien plus de temps que les hommes (191,2 et 58,6 heures respectivement, p = 0,005). Le segment fracture´ de l’os a influence´ de fac¸on significative le choix des patients de se faire soigner dans cet hoˆpital (p = 0,02). Discussion: L’hoˆpital ge´ ne´ ral d’Entebbe a pour patients une population jeune et sans emploi en ce qui concerne les le´ sions musculosquelettiques. Ceux-ci se pre´ sentent de fac¸on tardive pour obtenir des soins, en particulier les femmes. Les patients fondent leur choix de prise en charge par cet hoˆpital en fonction de la nature de la blessure. African relevance Introduction The study provides insight into the patterns of injury that present to poorly resourced hospitals. Selecting a treatment approach and setting to get treatment Local governments should disseminate information on following trauma possess a challenge to the patient in available health facilities to their populations. Africa.1,2 The Anderson and Newman framework3 states that More research is required in African health financing. health service utilization is governed by three main factors: predisposition, enablement and perception of need for care. * Correspondence to Isaac Kajja. [email protected] In Uganda, health care following musculoskeletal (MSK) Peer review under responsibility of African Federation for Emergency Medicine. injury (in this study representing a fracture and/or a disloca- tion) is provided either by the western biomedical approaches (WBA) or by traditional bone setters (TBS). The patient with Production and hosting by Elsevier MSK injury haphazardly seeks for WBA care since Uganda http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.afjem.2016.05.008 2211-419X Ó 2016 African Federation for Emergency Medicine. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Seeking health care following a fracture or a dislocation 175 has no established guidelines disseminated to the general pop- reduction and splinting of closed fractures. Additionally, the ulation showing which health facility handles what type of medical officers and surgeons debride open fractures, screen injuries. Given the staff crisis in Sub-Sahara African Hospi- and refer patients requiring definitive orthopedic surgical inter- tals,4 the number and level of training of staff at a given level vention to hospitals with orthopedic surgeons. of health facilities are not uniform. Here, some general hospi- Following ethics clearance from the research and ethics tals have two or three general doctors while others have one or committee of Makerere University School of Medicine, a ver- none. Worse still, some groups of service providers are not reg- bal consent from the patient or the guardian of a child was ulated by any legal body (Table 1). These factors put doubt in sought. A pretested questionnaire was used to collect data. the patients’ minds as to whether the accessible facilities have Data were collected at the time when the patient had received the appropriate staff, supplies and equipment necessary to the appropriate orthopedic care. A non-randomized procedure manage their injuries. It is postulated that the above challenges was used to consecutively recruit 101 patients. Patients with lead to delays in presentation for WBA care and poor clinical dislocations, and open or closed fractures were included. outcomes of MSK injuries. Additionally, the pattern of injury Unconscious patients without a caretaker to answer key ques- may influence the patient’s decision to seek for WBA care from tions in the questionnaire were excluded. a particular hospital. Patient demographics noted included age, sex, level of edu- Therefore, the study aimed at a) defining the demographics cation, occupation, distance between the patient’s home and of patients and how these relate to the former’s decision to the hospital, whether a patient had received initial treatment seek for WBA care at a selected general hospital, b) establish- from any other hospital before seeking care from the hospital ing how demographics and injury characteristics relate to the under study and the cause of injury. The time interval between time of presentation for care and c) identifying the factors onto injury and presentation for care was noted. which patients base their decisions to seek WBA care from this Injury characteristics noted included injury type (disloca- hospital. tion or fracture), fracture pattern (simple, segmental or com- minuted), fracture location (upper limb, spine, pelvis or Methods lower limb), bone fractured, segment of bone involved in frac- ture (shaft, proximal peri-articular or distal peri-articular), The study was conducted from 1st November 2014 to 28th joint dislocated and the time of day when injury occurred. February 2015 in Entebbe General Hospital (a mid-level hos- The reasons onto which patients based their decisions to pital) in Uganda. This public hospital is situated on the high- seek treatment from this hospital were also noted. way from Entebbe International Airport to Kampala city. For Analysis was done using SPSS, version 21.0; SPSS Inc. Chi- purposes of this study, Ugandan health facilities were grouped cago, IL, USA. Cross tabulations of variables were con- into three levels: (i) national and regional referral hospitals- structed and Fisher’s exact test and chi-square with p-values higher level facilities, that have orthopedic surgeons in their were calculated to determine statistical significance, if any. A staff establishment, (ii) general hospitals- mid-level facilities, one way analysis of variation (ANOVA) was performed to that have medical officers, general surgeons and orthopedic compare means between groups and Pearson’s correlation assistants in their staff establishment, and (iii) Health Center index was performed to identify relationships between contin- IV with a general doctor, Health Center III with a medical uous variables. A p-value was predetermined at p < 0.05. assistant, Health Center II with a nurse in their staff establish- ment and can give emergency care to MSK injuries, consti- Results tuted the lower level. As stipulated in the Ministry of Health Human Resource Information System (HRIS) Strengthening From 1st November 2014 to 28th February 2015, 101 patients Plan 2010/11–2014/15,5 this hospital provides preventive, pro- were recruited in the study. These included 72 (71.3%) males motive, curative, maternity, in-patient health services, surgery, and 29 (28.7%) females. Their ages ranged from three to blood transfusion, laboratory and medical imaging services. 79 years, with a mean of 24.8 (SD 16.7) years. During the study However, its operations are limited by factors like a small staff period, four unconscious patients without a caretaker were (it serves a population of about 500,000 people but has two excluded.