Arxiv:1710.02991V3 [Cond-Mat.Str-El] 4 Oct 2020 Entanglement Dances to the Stage of Real Materials

Evidences for the topological order in a kagome antiferromagnet Yuan Wei,1, 2 Zili Feng,1, 2 Wiebke Lohstroh,3 D. H. Yu,4 Duc Le,5 Clarina dela Cruz,6 Wei Yi,7 Z. F. Ding,8 J. Zhang,8 Cheng Tan,8 Lei Shu,8, 9 Yan-Cheng Wang,10 Han-Qing Wu,11 Jianlin Luo,1, 2, 12 Jia-Wei Mei,13 Fang Yang,14 Xian-Lei Sheng,14 Wei Li,14, 15 Yang Qi,16, 9 Zi Yang Meng,1, 17, 12, ∗ Youguo Shi,1, 18, 12, y and Shiliang Li1, 2, 12, z 1Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics, Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China 2School of Physical Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China 3Heinz Maier-Leibnitz Zentrum (MLZ), Technische Universita¨t Mu¨nchen, Garching D-85747, Germany 4Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organization, Lucas Heights, New South Wales 2232, Australia 5ISIS Facility, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Chilton, Didcot OX11 0QX, United Kingdom 6Neutron Scattering Division, Neutron Sciences Directorate, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37831, USA 7International Center for Materials Nanoarchitectonics, National Institute for Materials Science, 1-1 Namiki, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0044, Japan 8State Key Laboratory of Surface Physics, Department of Physics, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China 9Collaborative Innovation Center of Advanced Microstructures, Nanjing 210093, China 10School of Physical Science and Technology, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou Jiangsu, 221116, People's Republic of China 11School of Physics, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China 12Songshan Lake Materials Laboratory , Dongguan, Guangdong 523808, China 13Shenzhen Institute for Quantum Science and Engineering, and Department of Physics, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen 518055, China 14School of Physics, Key Laboratory of Micro-Nano Measurement-Manipulation and Physics (Ministry of Education), Beihang University, Beijing 100191, China 15International Research Institute of Multidisciplinary Science, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, China 16Center for Field Theory and Particle Physics, Department of Physics, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China 17Department of Physics and HKU-UCAS Joint Institute of Theoretical and Computational Physics, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong, China 18Center of Materials Science and Optoelectronics Engineering, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China A Z2 quantum spin liquid hosts one of the simplest topological orders and exhibits many exotic properties due to long-range quantum entanglements. Its elementary excitations are anyons such as spinons carrying fractionalized spin quantum number and visons carrying emergent Z2 gauge flux. However, experimental detection of these anyons remains elusive. The difficulties lie not only in the fact that there exists few candidates for Z2 quantum spin liquids but also in that visons are magnetically inert hence immune to available experimental techniques. Here we have studied the spin excitations and specific heats of kagome-lattice antiferromagnet Cu4(OH)6FBr and 2+ 2+ 2+ Cu3Zn(OH)6FBr, which consists of two-dimensional Cu kagome layers with either Cu or Zn ions in between. By combining the first principle calculations and inelastic neutron scattering data in the former, we show that the dominate couplings in magnetically ordered Cu4(OH)6FBr are between the nearest neighbor spins within the kagome planes, and the kagome and interlayer spin systems are essentially decoupled above the antiferromagnetic transition temperature. The intrinsic spin excitations and specific heats of the kagome layers for Cu3Zn(OH)6FBr are thus derived by removing the contributions from the residual interlayer Cu2+ magnetic impurities. Accordingly, the kagome spin system exhibits spin continuum with momentum-dependent spin gap and a large magnetic entropy at low temperature that is insensitive to magnetic field, which can be understood as the evidences of spinons and visons in this kagome quantum spin liquid candidate. Our results suggest the existence of the Z2 anyons in the material, and therefore provide a comprehensive set of evidences for the Z2 topological order in kagome quantum spin liquid and bring their choreographed arXiv:1710.02991v3 [cond-mat.str-el] 4 Oct 2020 entanglement dances to the stage of real materials. I. INTRODUCTION Topological insulators and superconductors have at- tracted great attentions in condensed matter physics and ∗ [email protected] material sciences [1, 2]. These states are associated y [email protected] with classical topology and denoted as the symmetry pro- z [email protected] tected topological states. There is another class of states, 2 dubbed topological orders, which has also been intensely gapless at the first place [20]. Later, it is from nuclear studied in theory [3{6]. It is referred to as quantum magnetic resonance (NMR) experiment that the spin ex- topology, since it results from long-range quantum en- citations are gapped [22]. However, since the analysis tanglement and features fractionalized excitations, which is rather complicated due to the presence of five peaks are called anyons because they carry fractionalized statis- of 17O in the NMR spectra, it has also been suggested tics [6]. This exotic class of matter does not require the that the ground state of the herbertsmithite is gapless labeling of order parameter and spontaneous symmetry [44]. Detailed analysis on the inelastic neutron scatter- breaking so they are beyond Landau's paradigm of phases ing (INS)data also shows a gap at (1; 0; 0) by subtracting and phase transitions. Moreover, their topological nature the intensities at (1; 0; 0) from those at (2; 0; 0) times a does not need to be protected by any global symmetry, parameter to make sure the low-energy intensities are as they are robust against any local perturbation. There- close to zero [21], but the choice of the parameter is still fore, they are seriously expected to be the building block not objective enough. for topological quantum computation [7{10]. Although In this work, we try to clarify the confusion in the field not protected by any symmetry, a topological order can by providing a tentative solution to this problem, i.e., we be further enriched by symmetries. In particular, the find experimental evidences of a Z2 topological order or fractionalized excitations can carry fractionalized quan- QSL in a 2D kagome material Cu3Zn(OH)6FBr. Both its tum numbers of global symmetries [11, 12]. crystal structure and magnetic properties are very simi- Up to now, only quantum Hall states can be unambigu- lar to those of herbertsmithite [23], such as very large ex- ously identified as topological orders with chiral quantum change coupling (∼200 K) and no magnetic order down topology [13, 14] . In principle, the topological orders can to 50 mK. It consists of 2D Cu2+ kagome layers with also be found in quantum spin liquids (QSL), which are Zn2+ ions between the layers as shown in Fig. 1(a). Like conceptually connected to the theoretical understanding in herbertsmithite, there is always a few percent of Cu2+ 2+ of high-Tc superconductivity and, as mentioned above, ions sitting on the Zn sites, acting as magnetic impuri- the material realization of topological quantum comput- ties. When all Zn2+ ions are replaced by Cu2+ ions, the ing [5{7, 9, 10, 15{17]. Among various QSLs, a Z2 QSL material is a natural mineral dubbed barlowite and shows is probably the simplest one, as all its excitations are slight lattice distortion below room temperature and an gapped and the low-lying anyonic quasiparticles therein antiferromagnetic order at TN ∼ 15 K [45{47]. Previ- have relatively simple mathematical descriptions. How- ous NMR measurements on Cu3Zn(OH)6FBr suggest a ever, despite the transparent theoretical understanding, spinon gap about 0.65 meV, whose magnetic field depen- there are few candidate materials that may host a Z2 dence is consistent with fractionalized S = 1/2 spinon QSL [4, 18{28]. One of the reasons behind the difficulty excitations [23, 48]. The measurements were done on of finding more candidates is because their properties, 19F, which shows only one peak and is not sensitive to or in modern language, the choreographed entanglement magnetic impurities due to its position. dances of anyons carrying fractionalized quantum num- Here we further studied the spin excitations and spe- ber that are dedicated by the emergent gauge structures cific heats of Cu3Zn(OH)6FBr to reveal its ground states. [6], are not subjected to direct experimental probes which One thing we have to overcome is the influences from usually couple to the local order parameters related with the residual interlayer Cu2+ spins as magnetic impuri- symmetry breaking such as spontaneous magnetization. ties, which contribute to the low-energy spin excitations A two-dimensional (2D) kagome lattice antiferromag- and low-temeprature speific heats as for the case in her- net is expected to host a Z2 QSL and thus the Z2 topolog- bertsmithite [18]. To do so, we have compared first prin- ical order due to strong geometrical and quantum frus- ciple calculations and INS data in magnetically ordered trations [17, 26, 29{36]. In this case, the ultimate ex- Cu4(OH)6FBr to show that the couplings between the perimental discovery of a Z2 QSL relies on the signa- interlayer and kagome spins are one order of magnitude ture of fractionalized excitations { spinons (carrying S smaller than those within the kagome planes. Moreover,

Load more