Changing Attitudes to Mental Illness in the Australian Defence Force: a Long Way to Go…

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Changing Attitudes to Mental Illness in the Australian Defence Force: a Long Way to Go… Parliamentary Library Changing attitudes to mental illness in the Australian Defence Force: a long way to go… Dr Edward Scarr 2015 Australian Parliamentary Fellow Changing attitudes to mental illness in the Australian Defence Force: a long way to go… Dr Edward Scarr 2015 Australian Parliamentary Fellow © Commonwealth of Australia Creative Commons With the exception of the Commonwealth Coat of Arms, and to the extent that copyright subsists in a third party, this publication, its logo and front page design are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia licence. In essence, you are free to copy and communicate this work in its current form for all non- commercial purposes, as long as you attribute the work to the author and abide by the other licence terms. The work cannot be adapted or modified in any way. Content from this publication should be attributed in the following way: Author(s), Title of publication, Series Name and No, Publisher, Date. To the extent that copyright subsists in third party quotes it remains with the original owner and permission may be required to reuse the material. Inquiries regarding the licence and any use of the publication are welcome to [email protected]. This work has been prepared to support the work of the Australian Parliament using information available at the time of production. The views expressed do not reflect an official position of the Parliamentary Library, nor do they constitute professional legal opinion. Any concerns or complaints should be directed to the Parliamentary Librarian. Parliamentary Library staff are available to discuss the contents of publications with Senators and Members and their staff. To access this service, clients may contact the author or the Library’s Central Enquiry Point for referral. Disclaimer This paper was prepared under the Parliamentary Library’s Australian Parliamentary Fellowship. The views expressed in this paper are those of the Fellowship author, and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of the Parliamentary Library. Cover image: Australian soldiers at the Australian War Memorial, Canberra. Copyright rorem, Shutterstock.com Contents Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................... v List of interviewees ........................................................................................................ vii Executive summary ........................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 5 Methodology...................................................................................................................... 9 Terminology .................................................................................................................... 11 PART I—THE SCOPE OF THE PROBLEM ............................................................ 13 Defining the problem .................................................................................................. 13 Prevalence rates of mental ill-health in service personnel and veterans ................ 14 Contemporary Australia ......................................................................................... 15 First-hand accounts of personal impacts ................................................................ 18 Transition ............................................................................................................... 20 PART II—CHANGING ATTITUDES........................................................................ 22 The Parliament of Australia ........................................................................................ 22 Floor of parliament................................................................................................. 24 Ministerial statements ............................................................................................ 24 Vietnam veteran influence ..................................................................................... 26 Anecdotal ............................................................................................................... 27 References to the previous Labor Government...................................................... 28 Minor party positions ............................................................................................. 28 The Long Way Home .............................................................................................. 29 Self-fulfilling prophecy .......................................................................................... 30 Independent voices ................................................................................................. 30 Aspirational ............................................................................................................ 31 Previous committee inquiry ................................................................................... 32 Recent Senate committee inquiry .......................................................................... 33 i Parliamentary Friendship Groups .......................................................................... 35 Defence—policy background on mental health ......................................................... 35 Department of Veterans’ Affairs—policy background on mental health .................. 44 Pathways to Care in Veterans Recently Compensated for a Mental Health Condition (ACPMH—now Phoenix Australia)..................................................... 46 Independent Study into Suicide in the Ex-Service Community 2009 (DVA, conducted by Professor David Dunt) .................................................................... 46 Australian National Audit Office Audit Report: Administration of Mental Health Initiatives to Support Younger Veterans (DVA) ....................................... 47 Strategy .................................................................................................................. 48 Australian Public Service Commission Review of DVA 2013 ............................. 48 Department of Veterans’ Affairs Annual Report 2013–14 ................................... 50 Department of Veterans’ Affairs Annual Report 2014–15 ................................... 51 DVA submission to the recent Senate inquiry ...................................................... 51 2014–15 Department of Veterans’ Affairs Budget Fact Sheet .............................. 53 Image problem ....................................................................................................... 53 PART III—MEASURING PROGRESS..................................................................... 55 Stigma ........................................................................................................................ 55 Ex-Service Organisations ........................................................................................... 59 Reported experiences of members of the 2nd Commando Regiment—a case study ........................................................................................................................... 61 Prevention .................................................................................................................. 64 International and Australian approaches to PTSD ..................................................... 68 Conclusion—harnessing the chaos ................................................................................. 70 Opportunity ................................................................................................................ 71 Appendices ...................................................................................................................... 73 Appendix A—veteran testimonials ................................................................................. 73 Appendix B ................................................................................................................... 105 Moral injury ............................................................................................................. 105 ii Problems with PTSD itself ....................................................................................... 105 The need for a realistic narrative on military ‘service’ ............................................. 106 Limitations of the entitlement narrative ................................................................... 106 Appendix C .................................................................................................................... 108 Rural Fire Service model—Paul Patti, veteran advocate .......................................... 108 Appendix D ................................................................................................................... 109 Abbreviations and acronyms ......................................................................................... 110 iii Acknowledgements I am indebted to the Parliamentary Library for providing the Fellowship program and the unique opportunity for research it offers. In particular I would like to thank the Director of the Foreign Affairs, Defence and Security Section, Nigel Brew, Assistant Secretary Research Branch Jonathan Curtis and Dr Dianne Heriot, Parliamentary Librarian who offered enthusiasm and support. I would like to express
Recommended publications
  • The National Capital Canberra
    EXPLORING CIVICS AND CITIZENSHIP Through a visit to the national capital canberra UPPER PRIMARY Student Resource Book A classroom resource to support the Parliament and Civics Education Rebate (PACER) program EXPLORING CIVICS AND CITIZENSHIP Through a Visit to the National Capital, Canberra Upper Primary Student Resource Book A classroom resource to support the PACER program ISBN: 978-0-642-77926-7 (PDF) ISBN: 978-0-642-77927-4 (RTF) First published 2008 Second edition 2010 © 2010 This work is copyright. Permission is given by the Commonwealth for this booklet and CD-ROM to be copied without payment by educational institutions within Australia solely for educational purposes. Any other use will require written permission of the Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations (DEEWR) and may require the written permission of other copyright owners. Copies should include this copyright statement or an appropriate acknowledgement. All other rights are reserved. Apart from any use permitted above or under the Copyright Act 1968, no part of this booklet or CD-ROM may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic, digital, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission of DEEWR. To the best of DEEWR’s knowledge, copyright permission has been obtained for any non-Commonwealth material used in this booklet and for the use of such material for educational purposes. If you believe there has been an error or omission in any of the material, please contact DEEWR. For inquiries about reproduction or other uses of this publication, please contact the Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations at www.deewr.gov.au/.
    [Show full text]
  • Anglican News
    A NEWSPAPER FOR THE CANBERRA & GOULBURN ANGLICAN COMMUNITY VOL. 30 FREE N0. 3 3,900 COPIES EVERY MONTH ANGLICAN NEWS MAY 2013 ‘Walk’ culminates in Canberra Journey with the service was over people were Cross impacts standing around having prayer.” communities from Over 100 join walk in Eden to Goulburn Canberra Participants in Canberra By Jeremy Halcrow were equally moved by the pre- dawn walk on Easter Sunday. Participants described The walk from the ACT the colourful and moving Legislative Assembly began culmination of the 150th with about 50 people - several anniversary Cross walk as a carrying colourful fl ags “huge joy” and “an amazing symbolizing spiritual virtues – experience”, as hundreds of building to over 100 by the time people attended both the Good the group reached Capitol Hill. Friday service in Goulburn and the Easter Sunday service in Canberra. Bishop Stuart Robinson, “At almost every described the Good Friday meeting, people event in Goulburn’s Belmore were invited to Park as “the most unexpectedly pleasing event” of his entire turn to Christ – Cross Walk. and in total, “People joined in the hundreds did.” procession from across the district and from all denominations – the crowd kept on swelling. In the park the “As we walked more people numbers grew to many hundreds joined us until there were including Goulburn Mayor, Geoff so many, it was amazing… Kettle and NSW Minister, Pru probably up to 150 people Goward. A very signifi cant group by the end,” One Canberran HELPING HAND: Roman Catholic Bishop Pat Power lends a hand as Bishop Stuart carries the of people came forward to give participant, Claire Lloyd- cross past the War Memorial en route to St John’s Church their lives to Christ.” Jones reported.
    [Show full text]
  • Australian War Memorial
    Commonwealth of Australia Gazette No. S 64, Tuesday, 25 April 2006 SPECIAL Published by the Commonwealth of Australia Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 INCLUSION OF A PLACE IN THE NATIONAL HERITAGE LIST I, Ian Gordon Campbell, Minister for the Environment and Heritage, having considered, in relation to the place listed in the Schedule of this instrument - (a) the Australian Heritage Council’s assessment whether the place meets any of the National Heritage criteria; and (b) the comments given to the Council under section 324G of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999; and being satisfied that the place specified in the Schedule has the National Heritage value or values specified in the Schedule include, pursuant to section 324J of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999, the place listed in the Schedule in the National Heritage List. Dated 20 April 2006 [SIGNED] Ian Gordon Campbell Minister for the Environment and Heritage Cat. No. S6406 ISSN 1032-2345 © Commonwealth of Australia 2006 Commonwealth of Australia Gazette Commonwealth of Australia Gazette 2 Special Gazette No. S 64, 25 April 2006 No. S 64, 25 April 2006 Special Gazette 3 SCHEDULE STATE/TERRITORY Name: Location / Boundary Criteria / Values AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY Australian War Memorial and the Memorial Parade: About 25ha, in Reid and Campbell, comprising the whole of Anzac Parade (including the median strip) from the northern alignment of Constitution Avenue to the southern boundary of Section 39 Reid; Anzac Park (comprising Block 1 Section 41 Reid, Block 4 Section 39 Reid, Block 1 Section 1 Campbell, Block 2 Section 60 Campbell); the whole of Section 39 Campbell; that part of Limestone Avenue to the east of the alignment of the south-eastern most boundary of Block 5 Section 39 Reid; and that part of Fairbairn Avenue to the west of the alignment of the north west boundary of Block 3 Section 60 Campbell.
    [Show full text]
  • Congratulations to Our Reverend Tom Frame AM
    http://www.tarago.org.au/tarago_community_times.php July 2019 The Tarago Times is a non-profit community service, published monthly by the Tarago Sporting Association Inc by a team of volunteers. It has a circulation of 525 copies distributed throughout Tarago, Lake Bathurst, Mayfield, Boro, Taylors Creek and the surrounding district. View online at http://www.tarago.org.au/tarago_community_times.php Congratulations to our Reverend Tom Frame AM When Tom Frame was 7 years old he told his adoptive mother he wanted to be one of two things when he grew up - a clergyman or a butcher as these were the men in his community he respected the most. After 14-years of Naval service, he chose the former and from tough beginnings, at the age of 39 he become Australia’s youngest Anglican Bishop. In 1991 he completed his doctorate in history at the Australian Defence Force Academy. Tom has also written 47 books on theology, philosophy and history which are his passion. The Order of Australia (AM) honour recognises his “significant service to higher education, to the Anglican Church of Australia, and to the community.” Tom is the director of the Howard Library in Canberra (named after former Prime Minister John Howard) a job he enjoys enormously. He is also a former director of the Public Leadership Group and of the Australian Centre for Study of Armed Conflict and Society. He was also Bishop to the Defence Force and directed Saint Mark’s Theological College in Canberra from 2006 to 2014. With his heart firmly placed in rural ministry he has chosen to live in Tarago with his lovely wife Helen raising beef cattle at one of their properties on Mayfield Road.
    [Show full text]
  • Bulletin of the Royal Australian Regiment Foundation ABN 31 055 902 433
    ‘SERVING THE REGIMENT’ Bulletin of The Royal Australian Regiment Foundation ABN 31 055 902 433 GPO Box 3112 CANBERRA ACT 2601 TEL: 02 6265 9842 Email: [email protected] Web: www.rarfoundation.org.au Issue No 34 – October 2016 5 RAR Soldier during live fire exercise 2016 1 PLEASE JOIN US…. ROYAL AUSTRALIAN INFANTRY CORPS (ACT) 2016 ANNUAL DINNER THURSDAY 24 NOVEMBER 2016 1. The RAR Foundation and the RAR Association (ACT) have joined together to host the Royal Australian Infantry Corps (ACT) Annual Dinner which will be held to celebrate the 69th Birthday of the Royal Australian Regiment. The Dinner will be held at the Canberra Institute of Technology Restaurant (1st Floor, Building K, Constitution Avenue, Reid). 2. The Hassett Trophy for the “Best Junior Leader in the Regiment” will also be presented at the Dinner. 3. The Dinner is open to all Infantry soldiers and officers in the ACT Region, serving or retired, ARA or ARES, including Allied Infantry personnel serving in Canberra. 4. Dress will be lounge suit, no medals. Timings are 1830 for 1900 hours. Cost is $90.00 per head. 5. To secure your place, please book and pay no later than Thursday 17 November 2016 by: * advising us by mail or e-mail of your acceptance [email protected] making your payment; and advising us if you have any special dietary requirements. 6. Payment should be made by cheque to the “RAR Foundation” or by direct deposit to: * Account Name: RAR Foundation * BSB: 112 908 * Account Number: 043 368 817 * Description: Surname/Dinner 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Heritage Management Plan Final Report
    Australian War Memorial Heritage Management Plan Final Report Prepared by Godden Mackay Logan Heritage Consultants for the Australian War Memorial January 2011 Report Register The following report register documents the development and issue of the report entitled Australian War Memorial—Heritage Management Plan, undertaken by Godden Mackay Logan Pty Ltd in accordance with its quality management system. Godden Mackay Logan operates under a quality management system which has been certified as complying with the Australian/New Zealand Standard for quality management systems AS/NZS ISO 9001:2008. Job No. Issue No. Notes/Description Issue Date 06-0420 1 Draft Report July 2008 06-0420 2 Second Draft Report August 2008 06-0420 3 Third Draft Report September 2008 06-0420 4 Fourth Draft Report April 2009 06-0420 5 Final Draft Report (for public comment) September 2009 06-0420 6 Final Report January 2011 Contents Page Glossary of Terms Abbreviations Conservation Terms Sources Executive Summary......................................................................................................................................i How To Use This Report .............................................................................................................................v 1.0 Introduction............................................................................................................................................1 1.1 Background..........................................................................................................................................1
    [Show full text]
  • Scientists' Houses in Canberra 1950–1970
    EXPERIMENTS IN MODERN LIVING SCIENTISTS’ HOUSES IN CANBERRA 1950–1970 EXPERIMENTS IN MODERN LIVING SCIENTISTS’ HOUSES IN CANBERRA 1950–1970 MILTON CAMERON Published by ANU E Press The Australian National University Canberra ACT 0200, Australia Email: [email protected] This title is also available online at http://epress.anu.edu.au National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Author: Cameron, Milton. Title: Experiments in modern living : scientists’ houses in Canberra, 1950 - 1970 / Milton Cameron. ISBN: 9781921862694 (pbk.) 9781921862700 (ebook) Notes: Includes bibliographical references and index. Subjects: Scientists--Homes and haunts--Australian Capital Territority--Canberra. Architecture, Modern Architecture--Australian Capital Territority--Canberra. Canberra (A.C.T.)--Buildings, structures, etc Dewey Number: 720.99471 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. Cover design by Sarah Evans. Front cover photograph of Fenner House by Ben Wrigley, 2012. Printed by Griffin Press This edition © 2012 ANU E Press; revised August 2012 Contents Acknowledgments . vii Illustrations . xi Abbreviations . xv Introduction: Domestic Voyeurism . 1 1. Age of the Masters: Establishing a scientific and intellectual community in Canberra, 1946–1968 . 7 2 . Paradigm Shift: Boyd and the Fenner House . 43 3 . Promoting the New Paradigm: Seidler and the Zwar House . 77 4 . Form Follows Formula: Grounds, Boyd and the Philip House . 101 5 . Where Science Meets Art: Bischoff and the Gascoigne House . 131 6 . The Origins of Form: Grounds, Bischoff and the Frankel House . 161 Afterword: Before and After Science .
    [Show full text]
  • Community No. 22 Summer 2012 Final
    Serving the Combined Ministry District of St Paul’s Manuka, St David’s Red Hill and St Luke’s Deakin Community Three churches: one community No. 22 Summer 2012 Commemorating the Book of Common Prayer The 350th anniversary of the publishing of the Book of Common Prayer in 1662 was celebrated at a special choral evensong at St Paul’s on 23 August. It coincided with a two-day seminar organised by St Mark’s National Theological Centre to mark the anniversary. “Brilliant” was how the Bishop of Canberra and Goulburn, Bishop Stuart Robinson, described the service. “I was greatly heartened and felt privileged to find myself in that context.” He thanked the Ministry team and Parishioners for their love and services. (Continued on page 3) Papers presented at the seminar Theological reassessed the BCP’s influence, significance and relevance both for connections the past and for today. The Bishop of Canberra and his issue of Community goes into Goulburn, Bishop Stuart Robinson, in T some theological depth, the his address to Synod said the Book of reward for which is in the reading. Common Prayer had worked A significant event at St Paul’s alongside the Authorised King James was the special evensong celebrating version of the Bible to shape the the 350th anniversary of the first English-speaking world. Where God between the two institutions. publication of the Book of Common spoke to his people through the The Rev’d Dr John Moses reflects Prayer, conveniently referred to as vernacular of the King James Bible, on how the Book of Common Prayer BCP.
    [Show full text]
  • Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009-2010
    Australian War Memorial War Australian Annual Report 2009-2010 Annual Report Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009-2010 Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009–2010 Then Prime Minister of Australia, the Honourable The Council Chair walks with Governor-General Her Excellency Kevin Rudd MP, delivers the Address on ANZAC Ms Quentin Bryce through the Commemorative Area following Day 2010. the 2009 Remembrance Day ceremony. Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009–2010 Annual report for the year ended 30 June 2010, together with the financial statements and the report of the Auditor-General Images produced courtesy of the Australian War Memorial, Canberra Cover image: New Eastern Precinct development at night (AWM PAIU2010/028.11) Back cover image: The sculpture of Sir Edward ‘Weary’ Dunlop overlooks the Terrace at the Memorial cafe (AWM PAIU2010/028.01) Copyright © Australian War Memorial ISSN 1441 4198 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced, copied, scanned, stored in a retrieval system, recorded, or transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior written permission of the publisher. Australian War Memorial GPO Box 345 Canberra, ACT 2601 Australia www.awm.gov.au Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009–2010 iii Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009–2010 iv Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2009–2010 Introduction to the Report The Annual Report of the Australian War Memorial for the year ended 30 June 2010 follows the format for an Annual Report for a Commonwealth Authority in accordance with the Commonwealth Authorities and Companies (CAC) (Report of Operations) Orders 2005 under the CAC Act 1997.
    [Show full text]
  • Ram Ramblings the Newsletter of the 107 Field Battery Association
    Ram Ramblings The Newsletter of the 107 Field Battery Association Volume 12 Edition 2 – August 2015 From the Presidents Pen, Hello All Rammers for the Winter of 2015. I thought I was forever young, like "Noddy" or "Peter Pan" until this year CommenCed. Firstly, My original Royal Military College Class had a reunion. 50 years sinCe walking through the gates in Canberra and getting a Regimental Number. That was a reality CheCk. Then, after writing many times to tell you about health CheCks and PSA and DRE, the dreaded diagnosis of CanCer of the Prostate was thrust upon me. I have been through the Test and Evaluation mill in the past 6 months and finally had the little bugger out about 10 weeks ago. Part of the ageing proCess I suppose, but a reminder to you all to have a baseline PSA and annual testing as I was totally without symptoms. Even my sudden rise in PSA/Free PSA was still within 'weight for age', but the relatively non invasive testing told the story. Well it's done now and anybody who is on the hamster wheel and is a little (or a lot) ConCerned about the proCess, feel free to give me a Call or email. I am very eduCated about the whole thing. But it will not slow me down. I have just returned from Dinner Plain, ViCtoria's Alpine region, where I have been CoaChing the Navy Skiing and Biathlon team for InterserviCe Competition. What a great bunCh of youngsters. I piCked up a biathlon rifle for the first time in years, threw it on my baCk and skied some 2.5km loops and shot at the metal dots, standing unsupported and prone, and found I had not forgotten muCh.
    [Show full text]
  • Attachment A
    ATTACHMENT A Original Referral, October 2019 LIST OF ATTACHMENTS ATTACHMENT DESCRIPTION STATUS Submission, October 2019 Included A Action Area Location Plan Included B Action Area Site Plan and Disturbance Areas Included C Indigenous Consultation Summary (Redacted) Superseded by ATTACHMENT S of the Final Preliminary Documentation September 2020 Resubmission D Stakeholder Engagement and Consultation Report Superseded by ATTACHMENT S of the Final Preliminary Documentation September 2020 Resubmission E AWM Redevelopment HIA Superseded by ATTACHMENT D of the Final Preliminary Documentation September 2020 Resubmission F Mitigation Measures Included G ACT Standard Construction Environmental Management Plan Included H Energy and Environmental Policy, May 2019 Included I National Collection Environmental Management Plan Included (NCEMP) EPBC Act referral Note: PDF may contain fields not relevant to your application. These fields will appear blank or unticked. Please disregard these fields. Title of proposal 2019/8574 - Australian War Memorial Redevelopment Section 1 Summary of your proposed action 1.1 Project industry type Commonwealth 1.2 Provide a detailed description of the proposed action, including all proposed activities Overview The proposed action is the redevelopment of the Australian War Memorial (the Memorial), specifically the Southern Entrance, Parade Ground Anzac Hall and new glazed courtyard. The Project is being undertaken to address current constraints in available display space (including future provision) and visitor amenity, enabling the Memorial to fulfil its role of telling the story of Australian’s experience in conflicts, peacekeeping and humanitarian operations. The action proposed is consistent with the Project’s Detailed Business Case (DBC) as announced by the Commonwealth Government in November 2018 and funded in the Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook 2018-19 (Ref.
    [Show full text]
  • Howard Government Retrospective II “To the Brink: 1997 - 2001” Old Parliament House 14-15 November 2017 Howard Government Retrospective II
    Howard Government Retrospective II “To the brink: 1997 - 2001” Old Parliament House 14-15 November 2017 Howard Government Retrospective II Conference Broadcast Partner: 2 University of New South Wales Canberra To the brink: 1997 - 2001 The Howard Government Retrospective Conference Series he Liberal-National Party Coalition was elected Tto office on 2 March 1996 and continued in power until 24 November 2007. UNSW Canberra is holding a series of retrospective conferences to assess the performance of the four Howard Governments. Each event provides the basis for collections of essays contributed by principal participants, key public servants, leading commentators and notable scholars drawing on documents in the John Howard Collection held at the Defence Force Academy Library. The intention is for this series to become the ‘standard’ treatment of the Howard years. Contributors have been asked to focus critically on the Coalition’s policies and performance to reveal the Government’s shortcomings and failures. This commitment to a candid critique will attract the attention of the press and current-serving politicians, guaranteeing the volumes a substantial public profile at the time of their release. UNSW Press is the series publisher. The first conference and volume covered the 1996 election, the Coalition’s readiness for office, the main policy decisions and practical challenges of the first year of the Howard Government, including gun control and ministerial responsibility. The second conference and volume deals with the second and third years of the Coalition’s first term in office (1997-98) and most of its second term (1998-2001). Volume II will include coverage of Wik and native title, the Patricks waterfront dispute, the constitutional convention, the Coalition’s near defeat at the 1998 poll, the Government’s response to post-independence violence in East Timor, and the introduction of the GST.
    [Show full text]