REPUBLIC OF

THE INDEPENDENT ELECTORAL AND BOUNDARIES COMMISSION

PRELIMINARY REPORT ON THE FIRST

REVIEW RELATING TO THE

DELIMITATION OF BOUNDARIES OF

CONSTITUENCIES AND WARDS

9TH JANUARY 2012

Contents BACKGROUND INFORMATION ...... iv 1.1. Introduction ...... 1 1.2. System and Criteria in Delimitation ...... 2 1.3. Objective ...... 2 1.4. Boundary Delimitation Preliminary Report ...... 2 1.5 Boundary Delimitation In Kenya: Historical Perspective ...... 3 1.6 An Over View of Boundary Delimitation in Kenya ...... 3 CHAPTER TWO ...... 6 LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR THE DELIMITATION OF BOUNDARIES ...... 6 2.0 Introduction ...... 6 2.2 The Constitution of Kenya, 2010...... 6 2.3 The Article 89 of the Constitution...... 7 2.4 The Fifth Schedule of the IEBC Act, 2011 ...... 7 3.6. Review of IEBC Boundaries Report ...... 8 2.5 Public Sensitization ...... 9 CHAPTER III ...... 10 REVIEW OF INTERIM INDEPENDENT BOUNDARIES REVIEW COMMISSION REPORT ...... 10 3.0 Introduction ...... 10 3.1 Consultations with Stakeholders and the Public ...... 10 3.2 Determination of Constituencies by the IIBRC ...... 10 3.3 Data for Population for Constituencies as stipulated by IIBRC ...... 17 3.4 Protected Constituencies under Article 262 Section, 27(4) of the Constitution ...... 19 CHAPTER IV ...... 21 PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS, IIBRC PROPOSALS AND EMERGING ISSUES ...... 21 5.0 Introduction ...... 21 5.1 General Views on the IIBRC Report ...... 21 4.2 Public Views, IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries and Emerging Issues ...... 22 4.2.1 County ...... 22 4.2.2 County ...... 29 4.2.3 County ...... 32

i

4.2.4 County ...... 34 4.2.5 ...... 38 4.2.6 County ...... 39 4.2.7 Taita Taveta County ...... 41 4.2.8 County ...... 44 4.2.9 County ...... 47 4.2.10 County ...... 51 4.2.11 County ...... 55 4.2.12 County ...... 57 4.2.13 ...... 58 4.2.14 Tharaka Nithi...... 63 4.2.15 ...... 66 4.2.16 County ...... 68 4.2.17 County ...... 71 4.2.18 ...... 73 4.2.19 ...... 76 4.2.20 County ...... 79 4.2.21 ...... 82 4.2.22 Murang’a County ...... 85 4.2.23 County ...... 89 4.2.24 ...... 93 5.3.25 ...... 97 5.3.26 ...... 99 5.3.27 Trans Nzoia County ...... 101 5.3.28 ...... 104 5.3.29 Elgeyo Marakwet County ...... 107 5.3.30 ...... 110 5.3.31 ...... 113 5.3.32 ...... 116 5.3.33 County ...... 119 5.3.34 County ...... 125 5.3.35 ...... 128

ii

5.3.36 ...... 132 5.3.37 ...... 134 5.3.38 County ...... 136 5.3.39 County ...... 142 5.3.40 County ...... 144 5.3.41 ...... 149 5.3.45 ...... 163 5.3.46 ...... 167 5.3.47 ...... 172 CHAPTER V ...... 176 PROPOSALS ON DELIMTATIONS OF COUNTY ASSEMBLYWARDS ...... 176 5.0 Introduction ...... 176 5.1 IEBC Determination of County Assembly Wards ...... 176 CHAPTER VI ...... 178 BOUNDARY DELIMITATION PROPOSALS & WAYFORWARD...... 178 6.0 Introduction ...... 178 6.1 Methodology applied by the IIBRC ...... 178 6.2 Applicable Framework ...... 178 6.3 Work Plan ...... 179

iii

Forward

The legal framework for elections requires objective drawing of electoral unit boundaries to achieve the principle of equal weight to each vote. To the greatest degree, this principle is aimed at ensuring effective representation and a translation of the will of the electorate into a representative government. It should be noted that the ideal international standards for delimitation is the equality of voting power for each vote so as to provide effective representation. Thus, boundary delimitation by its very nature is intended to produce the result of effective representation.

Ahmed Isaack Hassan, EBS, Chairman Indeed Article 89(1) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 states clearly the number of constituencies that are supposed to be in place - maximum of two hundred and ninety (290). Further, the Constitution stipulates the criteria and procedures that need to be applied in the delimitation of boundaries and which notably shall be undertaken at intervals of not less than eight years and not more than twelve years.

This has to be completed at least twelve months before a general election. It is therefore worth noting that pursuant to the provisions made in the Constitution of Kenya 2010, the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) has been mandated to carry out boundary delimitation of constituencies and wards. But this does not extend into the first review of the boundaries of constituency and wards. It should be acknowledged that the Interim Independent Boundaries Review Commission (IIBRC) did the first review of boundaries. IIBRC did its work and submitted its report to the Parliamentary Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs (JLA) which prepared its report and submitted to Parliament for adoption.

According to the Fifth Schedule of the IEBC Act 2011, IEBC is mandated to ‗resolve all issues arising from the first review relating to the delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards and publish its final report within a period of four months of the date of its appointment. It is predetermined that the Commission shall, in addressing the issues arising out of the first review:-

a) Use as its primary reference material, the report of the former boundaries commission on the first review as adopted by Parliament; and b) Use as its secondary reference material the report of the Parliamentary committee on the report of the former Boundaries Commission.

Notably, there were certain issues underscored in the JLA Report and in the discussions by Parliament and the public. Some of the issues cited included:

 The determination of boundaries on the basis of three types of population quotas instead of one;  The use of regions and provinces as units of analysis (yet not provided in the Constitution);  The treatment of Cities and urban areas in a similar way (definition of cities not agreed on);  The description of boundaries based on wards or sub-locations;

iv

 Inconsistency in the division of constituencies where some with large population were not split yet others with less population were split;  The creation or alteration of boundaries without taking into account geographical features and community interests; and  That there was no public participation.

While recognizing the provisions of the Constitution to redefine boundaries to accommodate other interests in the electoral sphere, it is important to note that any review of constituency boundaries is political in nature and is attached to highly competitive and emotive political issues. This means that it requires clarity and clear criteria and procedure commensurate to the electoral dynamics of the country. There is need for transparency, accuracy, objectivity and patriotism in presentations anticipated towards the process of resolving issues arising from the first review. Similarly, it requires that a middle ground be struck to achieve a win-win-situation.

Thus, in line with the IEBC Act, the Commission has prepared this Preliminary Report outlining the proposed delimitation of constituencies and wards and specific geographical and demographic details and hereby avail it to the general public for a period of twenty-one days and invite representations from the public on the proposals hereto. The public presentations and recommendations will be reviewed within fourteen days after receipt and the Commission will submit a revised Report to Parliament for deliberation. Consequently, the Commission will consider the resolutions of Parliament and prepare a Final Report for publication in the .

We must recognize that achieving the ideal and optimum population quota for our electoral units is not an instant achievement. The First Review and the exercise of addressing issues arising thereof is a process towards addressing gross disparities in the voting populations of different electoral units. It is indeed a step closer towards ensuring that the fundamental principle of the equality of the vote is attained. I therefore urge fellow Kenyans to read and understand the Preliminary Report in order to effectively engage in the process.

……………………………… Ahmed Issack Hassan, EBS CHAIRMAN .

v

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

1.1. Introduction The Constitution of Kenya, 2010, Article 89 gives the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) the mandate of creating and delimiting constituencies and wards. This has to be done at intervals of not less than eight and not more than twelve years. Additionally, the Constitution in Article 89 (5) spells out the criteria to be used in boundary delimitation as well as the maximum number of constituencies (Article 89 (1)). The IEBC Act 2011 limits the Commission to resolve issues arising from the first review and to use Interim Independent Boundaries Review Commission (IIBRC) Report as its primary reference material and Parliamentary Committee Report as its secondary reference material.

The delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards under the Constitution of Kenya Amendment Act 2008, Section 41c was a mandate of the IIBRC which was specifically responsible for:

i. making recommendations to parliament on delimitation of constituencies and local authority electoral units and optimal number of constituencies on the basis of equality of votes taking into account

a) Density of population and in particular the need to ensure adequate reprsenation of urban and sparsely-populated rural areas;

b) Population trends;

c) Means of communication;

d) Geographical features; and

e) Community interests

ii. making recommendations to parliament on administrative boundaries, including the fixing, reviewing and variation of boundaries of districts and other units; and

iii. the performance of such other function as may be prescribed by Parliament.

The IIBRC did the first review and submitted its report to the Parliamentary Departmental Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs (JLA). Following the presentation of the JLA report to Parliament, the IIBRC Report was adopted but there were several outstanding issues raised by the Members of Parliament and the Public. It is as a result of these issues that the IIBRC mandate was widely perceived as not complete, hence the requirement that IEBC addresses issues and concerns emerging from their report.

1

1.2. System and Criteria in Delimitation An appropriate system and criteria require that internationally accepted standards and procedures be used in the boundary delimitation process. The accepted standards have to take into consideration political, economic, social and other factors within a given country. Notwithstanding this, there is need for openness, accuracy, objectivity and patriotism in presentations anticipated towards the process of boundary delimitation. Based on the legal frame work predetermined in the Constitution (2010) and the IEBC Act 2011, the resolution of issues arising from the first review have to be completed in the shortest time possible (in 120 days). This should include proposals made to the public on the 290 Constituencies provided in the constitution.

It is important to note that any constituency boundary review process is political in nature and is attached to highly competitive and emotive political issues. This means that, in undertaking to resolve arising issues, it requires clarity, criteria and procedure commensurate to the electoral dynamics of the country. In the case of IEBC resolution of arising issues, the Constitution and the IEBC Act 2011 provide for the criteria and procedures to be followed. Similarly, it requires that a middle ground be reached through a win-win-situation.

1.3. Objective The main objective of the Boundary Delimitation: Preliminary Report is to provide information to the public on outstanding issues emerging from the IIBRC Report as well as reactions from the parliamentary Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs (JLA) Report. This is aimed at eliciting debate on presentations and proposals contained in the JLA Report. The information gathered will be analyzed and used to delimit the required constituencies as stipulated in the Constitution.

1.4. Boundary Delimitation Preliminary Report The Boundary Delimitation Preliminary Report is based on the analysis of the outstanding issues derived from the primary and secondary reference materials as provided for in the IEBC Act 2011. The Primary document reviewed is the IIBRC Report submitted to the Parliamentary Departmental Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs dated 27th November, 2010 while the Secondary reference materials is the Report of the Departmental Committee on Justice and Legal affairs as presented to the Parliament on 16th December, 2010. The report included the following annexes:

(i) Committee minutes ( JLA 1)

(ii) Arising Issues ( JLA 2);

(iii) Draft Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission‘s Bill 2010 ( JLA 3);

(iv) Presentation by the Hon. A. Ligale in Mombasa ( JLA 4);

(v) Presentation on Constitution Methodology ( JLA 5;

(vi) Views of dissenting Commissioners JLA 6;

2

(vii) Draft Gazette Notice and Court Ruling by Justice Musinga JLA 7;

(viii) Written Submissions JLA 9;

Other documents analyzed include:

(i) The Constitution of Kenya Amendment Act of 2008, that created and mandated IIBRC to carry out the delimitation of constituencies and ward boundaries herein referred as the review;

(ii) The Constitution of Kenya 2010;

(iii) Presentation to Members of Parliament (6th December , 2010) by Professor F.W.O Aduol;

(iv) Delimitation of Electoral Units: A critique of the process and product of IIBRC by Sakaja Johnson;

(v) Independent Electoral Boundaries Commission Act, 2011;

(vi) Delimitation of Electoral Units: Background, Outstanding Issues and Way forward. Presentation made to IEBC – 21st November, 2011 by Sakaja Johnson;

(vii) IIBRC Public hearings Verbatim Reports.

(viii) Memoranda presented by the Public to the IIBRC during public hearings and visits.

1.5 Boundary Delimitation In Kenya: Historical Perspective The delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards is not a new phenomenon in the Kenyan history. Delimitation of boundaries was started by colonial authorities in 1962 when the Royal Commission was created to go round the country and carry out an inquiry into electoral and administrative boundaries. The Commission held consultations with leaders at different levels including influential tribal leaders and chiefs.

1.6 An Over View of Boundary Delimitation in Kenya

1.6.1 The country‘s Constitution provided for the delimitation of constituencies so as to facilitate the conduct of elections in independent Kenya (Constitution of Kenya, 1963 Section 40). At that time, the determination of electoral units in Kenya started with creation of 117 Constituencies based on a clearly established principle that all constituencies contain as nearly as possible an equal number of inhabitants. The Constitution provided that no constituency was to form part or more than one administrative unit; or of both the Nairobi area and a region. Towards the delimitation of boundaries, the Commission also took into account the following:

3

a) The population density and in particular, the need to ensure adequate representation of urban and sparsely-populated rural areas; b) The means of communication; c) Geographical features; d) Community of interest; and e) The boundaries of existing administrative areas.

1.6.2 The Constitutional amendments of 1964 and 1966 resulted in the abolition of the seven regional assemblies and the Senate. The House of Representatives was renamed the National Assembly with 158 Parliamentary Constituencies consisting of the initial 117 plus 41 newly created constituencies following the abolition of the senate. In 1986, Parliament raised the number of constituencies from 158 to 188. 1.6.3 In 1996, The Electoral Commission of Kenya (established in 1992), reviewed the boundaries and names of constituencies and raised the number from 188 to a maximum of 210 as provided under the previous Constitution. 1.6.4 Following the disputed results of the Presidential elections in 2007, a National Dialogue and Recinciliation Accord was signed which provided a road map and made recommendations for the review of the electoral process in Kenya. This led to the establishment of the Independent Review Commission (IREC), popularly known as the Kriegler Commission. The IREC in turn recommended a review of the entire constitutional and legal framework in line with the political and legal aspirations of Kenyans. A major impact of the IREC recommendations was the amendment of Section 41 of the 1963 Constitution by Parliament in 2008, resulting in the disbandment of the ECK and the creation of the Interim Independent Electoral Commission-IIEC (Section 41A), and the Interim Independent Boundaries Review Commission-IIBRC (Section 41B). 1.6.5 The COK 2010 provides for the IEBC to assume the mandate of the defunct IIBRC as the successor body.

a) In this regard, the IEBC has responsibility for the delimitation of constituencies and wards [COK 2010 Article 88 (4) (c)].

b) The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission Act, 2011 provides for the IEBC to resolve all issues relating to the delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards. It further binds the Commission to employ the Report of the IIBRC as its primary reference material [IEBC Act, 2011, Fifth Schedule, Article 1 and 2(1) (a)].

c) The IEBC Act, 2011 also requires that the Report of the Parliamentary Committee on JLA on the former IIBRC be used by IEBC as secondary reference material in resolving issues relating to delimitation of boundaries.

4

1.6.6 In the light of the foregoing, the Report of the Parliamentary Committee on JLA Report sets the Agenda for the IEBC in completing the outstanding work of the IIBRC. This Interim Report is divided into several chapters:

a) Chapter one presents background information and an overview from a historical perspective on boundary delimitation in Kenya

b) The Legal framework governing the delimitation of boundaries of Constituencies and wards is handled in Chapter Two.

c) A review of the IIBRC boundary delimitation Report is presented in Chapter Three;

d) Chapter Four outlines criteria used by IIBRC in the first review.

e) Chapter Five presents analysis of public presentation, IIBRC Report, emerging issues and IEBC proposals on County basis.

f) Lastly, Chapter Six outlines the framework on public presentations and public consultation forums, within 21 days from the date of the publication of this Report.

5

CHAPTER TWO LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR THE DELIMITATION OF BOUNDARIES

2.0 Introduction Any boundary delimitation process has to be guided by a legal frame work. International standards dictate that such a legal framework should determine how constituencies or the electoral units are defined and drawn. The legal framework regulating drawing of boundaries for electoral units is expected to address:

a) The frequency of such determination; b) The criteria for such determination; c) The degree of public participation in the process; d) The respective roles of the legislature, judiciary and executive in the process; e) The ultimate authority for the final determination of the electoral units.

The Constitution of Kenya (1963) provided guidance for boundary delimitation. The Constitution of Kenya (Amendment) Act 2008 mandated IIBRC to make recommendations to Parliament on the delimitation of boundaries for constituencies and local authority electoral units. The Constitution of Kenya 2010 and the IEBC Act 2011, Fifth Schedule provides the criteria for delimitation of constituencies and wards.

2.1 The Constitution of Kenya (Amendment) Act, 2008

The Constitution of Kenya (Amendment Act), 2008 that established IIEC and IIBRC gave the two bodies different mandates. Whereas IIEC was mandated to reform the electoral process, the IIBRC was tasked to:- a) Make recommendations to Parliament on the delimitation of constituencies and Local authority electoral units and the optimal number of constituencies on the basis of equality of votes; b) Make recommendations to Parliament on administrative boundaries, including the fixing, reviewing and variation of boundaries of districts and other units; and c) Perform such functions as may be prescribed by Parliament.

2.2 The Constitution of Kenya, 2010. The promulgation of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 provided for the continuation of the functions of IIBRC in accordance with terms of section 41B and 41C of the former Constitution but was restricted from determining the boundaries of counties established under the new Constitution. The Commission was to:-

(i) Determine the boundaries of constituencies and wards using the Criteria mentioned in the Constitution (2010);

6

(ii) Observe the requirements of Article 89(2) of the Constitution (2010); and

(iii) Ensure that the first review of constituencies undertaken under the new Constitution (2010) shall not result in the loss of a constituency existing on the effective date.

2.3 The Article 89 of the Constitution.

Article 89(1) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 sets the maximum number of constituencies at two hundred and ninety (290). Further, the Constitution stipulates the procedures that need to be applied in the delimitation of boundaries and which notably shall be undertaken at intervals of not less than eight years and not more than twelve years. This has to be completed at least twelve months before a general election.

Article 89 (5) of the Constitution stipulates the criteria to be applied in the boundary delimitation process. It provides that the ―Boundaries of each constituency shall be such that the number of inhabitants in the constituency is as nearly as possible equal to the population quota‖. The Constitution further provides that this number may be greater or lesser than the population quota only by a margin of:

a) not more than forty per cent (40%)for cities and sparsely populated areas; and b) thirty percent (30%) for other areas

In determining the number of inhabitants, IEBC is expected to take into account:

a) geographical features and urban centres; b) community interest, economic and cultural ties; and c) means of communication.

The Commission shall progressively work towards ensuring that the number of inhabitants in each constituency and ward is as nearly as possible equal to the population quota (and in so doing consult all interested parties.) (Article 89 (7) b, IEBC Act Fifth schedule 2(c).

2.4 The Fifth Schedule of the IEBC Act, 2011

The Legal provision regulating the completion by the IEBC of the first review is set out in the Fifth Schedule of the Act. The IEBC is enjoined by the Act to ― resolve all the issues arising out of the first review relating to the delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards and publish its final report within the period of four months from the date of its appointment under this Act‖ . The Act lists the issues arising out of the first review as:

a) Re-distribute such wards or administrative units in the affected constituencies as may be appropriate;

7

b) Subject to the Constitution, addressing issues of new constituencies falling outside the population quota as provided for by Article 89(6) of the Constitution, but at the same time ensure that such a process shall – (i) Take into account the privisions of Article 89(7)(b) of the Constitution that requires progressive efforts and not instant demographic equality of all towards attaining the population quota in each constituency and ward for the purposes of the first review; (ii) Not be subject to new definitions of urban areas, cities or sparsely populated areas or to new population figures; (iii) Be subject to the use of enumerated national census figures and not projected figures. c) Addressing the issues of progressively advancing towards the population quota in protected constituencies in relation to neighbouring constituencies where appropriate.

In addressing the issues arising out of the first review, IEBC is restricted by the IEBC Act, 2011, Fifth Schedule Article 2(1) to:-

a) Use as its primary reference material, the report of the former boundaries commission (IIBRC) on the first review as adopted by Parliament; and b) Use as its secondary reference material the report of the Parliamentary Committee on the Report of the former Boundaries Commission (IIBRC).

Pursuant to the provisions of the IEBC Act the Commission shall:

i. prepare and publish a preliminary report outlining the proposed delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards, outlining specific geographical and demographical details ; ii. avail the report to the general public for a period of twenty-one days and invite representations from the public on the proposals; iii. review the public representations received within fourteen days after receipt of recommendations; iv. forward the revised report to Parliament; and v. consider views received from the national assembly and revise accordingly before final print for publication in the Kenya Gazette.

3.6. Review of IEBC Boundaries Report

Article 89(10) of the Constitution and paragraph 4 of the Fifth Schedule of the IEBC Act, 2011 provides for any person dissatisfied with the outcome of the Final Report of the Commission on Boundaries Delimitation to apply to the High Court for review of the Commission decision.

―An application for the review of a decision made under this Article (Article 89 of the Constitution) shall be filed within thirty days of the publication of the decision in

8

the Gazette and shall be heard and determined within three months of the date on which it is filed.‖

2.5 Public Sensitization

The principle of public participation and involvement is a running thread in the Constitution and the Commission is required by the IEBC Act to observe the principle of public participation and consultation with stakeholders in its processes. Paragraph 6 of the Fifth Schedule of the IEBC Act requires the Commission to conduct public sensitization on the proposed boundaries for a period of thirty days.

9

CHAPTER III

REVIEW OF INTERIM INDEPENDENT BOUNDARIES REVIEW COMMISSION REPORT

3.0 Introduction The Interim Independent Boundaries Review Commission (IIBRC) presented a report titled “Delimitation of Constituencies and Recommendations on Local Authority Electoral Units and Administrative Boundaries for Districts and other Units” addressed to the President, the Prime Minister and the Speaker of the National Assembly dated 27th November, 2010. After the Report was presented to the Parliamentary Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs and Parliament it elicited intense public debate. Some Kenyans were in support of the Report while others were opposed to the recommendations in the Report. However, not all Kenyans had a chance to read the IIBRC report and make their own views known.

3.1 Consultations with Stakeholders and the Public

From the Report it is evident that IIBRC held consultations and Public Hearings with stakeholders throughout the country as per its mandate. This was done between 1st February and 14th May, 2010. A total of one hundred and seventy (170) out of two hundred and ten (210) MPs and leaders attended the public hearingsThe hearings were characterized by oral and written Submissions. After 14th May 2010, the IIBRC continued to receive memoranda and held hearings with interested parties. Eight Provincial visits were held during which thousands of people were sensitized on the process. This was followed by one hundred and six (106) public hearings in which 20,726 attended and. 2,646 persons gave oral submissions to the Commission.

3.2 Determination of Constituencies by the IIBRC In embarking on the delimitation process IIBRC was guided by the provisions in the Constitution of Kenya 2010, Article 89 and the 2009 Census data. IIBRC calculated the population quota based on a definition provided in Article 89(12) of the Constitution (2010).

1. National population = 38,610,097

Popultion Quota = 38,610,097 = 133,138.26

290

40% greater than population quota for cities = 186,393.6

10

30% greater than population quota for other areas = 173,079.4

30% less than population quota for other areas = 93,196.6

40% less than population quota for sparsely populated areas = 79,882.8

I. Nairobi Province Population = 3,138,369

No. Of constituencies for Nairobi (40% limit) = 3,138,369 = 16.84 = 17 186,393 No. of existing constituencies = 8 No. of additional constituencies = 17 – 8= 9

II. Population = 3,325,307

No. Of constituencies for Coast = 3,325,307 = 24.98 = 25 133,138

No. of existing constituencies = 21 No. of additional constituencies = 25 – 21= 4

III. North Population = 2,310,757

No. Of constituencies for North Eastern = 2,310,757 = 17.36 = 17 133,138 No. of existing constituencies = 11 No. of additional constituencies = 17 – 11= 6

IV. Eastern Province Population = 5,668,123

No. Of constituencies for Eastern (Pop. quota) = 5,668,123 = 42.57 = 43 133,138 No. of existing constituencies = 36 No. of additional constituencies = 43 – 36= 7

V. Population = 4,383,743

No. Of constituencies for Central = 4,383,743 = 32.93 = 33 133,138 No. of existing constituencies = 29 No. of additional constituencies = 33 – 29= 4

11

VI. Population = 10,006,805

No. Of constituencies for Rift Valley = 10,006,805 = 75.16 = 75 133,138 No. of existing constituencies = 49 No. of additional constituencies = 75 – 49= 26

VII. Population = 4,334,282

No. Of constituencies for Western = 4,334,282 = 32.56 = 33 133,138 No. of existing constituencies = 24 No. of additional constituencies = 33 – 24= 9

VIII. Population = 5,442,711

No. Of constituencies for Nyanza = 5,442,711 = 40.88 = 41 133,138 No. of existing constituencies = 32 No. of additional constituencies = 41 – 32= 9

Option 1

PROVINCE CONSTITUENCIES Current No. Additional Total 1 Nairobi 8 9 17 2 Coast 21 4 25 3 North Eastern 11 6 17 4 Eastern 36 7 43 5 Central 29 4 33 6 Rift Valley 49 26 75 7 Western 24 9 33 8 Nyanza 32 9 41 TOTAL 210 74 284

12

Option 1 **

PROVINCE CONSTITUENCIES Current No. Additional Total 1 Nairobi 8 9 17 2 Coast 21 5 26 3 North Eastern 11 7 18 4 Eastern 36 8 44 5 Central 29 5 34 6 Rift Valley 49 27 76 7 Western 24 9 33 8 Nyanza 32 10 42 TOTAL 210 80 290

Option 1 above was then subjected to the scientific mathematical formula shown below:

1. Nairobi being the only legal city, the population of Nairobi subjected to its population quota as follows:

(40% x 133,138) + 133,138) = 186,393

2. Subjecting the population of Nairobi to the population quota for cities then:

= (3,138,369/186,393) = 17 Constituencies

3. Subtracting the population of Nairobi from the national population:

= (38,610.097 – 3,138,369) = 35,471,728

4. Subtracting the 17 constituencies given to Nairobi from the 290 Constituencies:

= (290-17) = 273

5. Dividing the remaining population by remaining Constituencies

= (35,471,728/273) = 129,933

6. Subjecting the remaining provinces to this quota:

= Province Population (X)/129,933

7. This gives a total of 291 constituencies. The allocation of constituencies in the Rift Valley was reduced by 1 because of its large number of constituencies.

13

Population Area (Sq. Km)

KENYA 38,610,097 581,315.9

Constituencies 290 581,315.9

Av per Constituency 133,138.27 2,004.54

Av -30% 93,196.79

Av+30% 173,079.75

Av -40% 79,882.96

Av +40% 186,393.57

14

Scientific Mathematical Formula on which Option 1** is based

irobi

urrent urrent

C

–

Serial Number Serial Province Population in sq km Area Population/sq. km Total Constituencies Constituencies calculated as Constituencies whole as number Constituencies adopted as Population/ Constituency Population as Constituency number whole Population as Constituency adopted Av Regional Av National wrt Deviation Na less Av from Deviation Av National from Deviation in Av National % 1 Nairo 3,138,3 695. 4,515. 8 16.8 17 17 186,39 184,610 184,61 -1784 -1.0% 51,47 38.7% bi 69 1 0 4 4 0 2

Population Area Pop. KENYA – 35,471,728 580,620.8 Pop. Nairobi

Constituencies 273 580,620.8

Av per Const 129,933.07 2,126.82

–

ulation

Serial Serial Number Province Population in sq Area km Population/s q.km Total Current Constituenci Constituenci as es es calculated Constituenci whole as es Constituenci number as es Population/ adopted Constituenc y Pop Constituenc whole as y Population number Constituenc adopted as y Av Regional Av National Deviation less Av wrt Nairobi Deviation from Av National Deviation from Av National in% 2 Central 4,383,74 13,165.4 333. 29 33.73 34 34 129,93 128,93 128,93 -999 - - -3.2% 3 0 8 3 4 4 0.8% 4205 3 Coast 3,325,30 82,892.8 40.1 21 25.59 26 26 129,93 127,89 127,89 -2037 - - -3.9% 7 2 3 6 6 1.6% 5242

15

4 Eastern 5,668,12 153,404. 36.9 36 43.62 44 44 129,93 128,82 128,82 -1112 - - -3.2% 3 2 3 3 1 1 0.9% 4317 5 North- 2,310,75 126,852. 18.2 11 17.78 18 18 129,93 128,37 128,37 -1558 - - -3.6% Eastern 7 4 4 3 5 5 1.2% 4763 7 Nyanza 5,442,71 12,613.0 431. 32 41.88 42 42 129,93 129,58 129,58 -345 - - -2.7% 1 5 9 3 8 8 0.3% 3550 8 Rift 10,006,8 183,383. 54.6 49 77.01 77 76 129,93 129,95 131,66 1735 1.3% - -1.1% Valley 05 5 5 3 9 8 1470 9 4,334,28 8,309.5 521. 24 33.35 33 33 129,93 131,34 131,34 1409 1.1% 1796 -1.4% Western 2 6 8 3 2 2

Total - 35,471,7 580,620. 61.1 202 273.0 27 273 129,93 129,45 129,93 0 0.0 - -2.4% 1 28 8 0 4 3 9 3 % 3205

16

Table of Delimitations

Provinces Populati Constituenci Constituenci IIBRC Current Additional on es Fraction es Rounded Delimitati Constituenci Constituenci on es es

Nairobi 3,138,369 16.84 17 17 8 9

Coast 3,325,307 25.59 26 26 21 5

Central 4,383,743 33.74 34 34 29 5

N. Eastern 2,310,757 17.78 18 18 11 7

Eastern 5,668,123 43.62 44 44 36 8

R. Valley 10,006,80 77.02 77* 76 49 27 5

Western 4,334,282 33.36 33 33 24 9

Nyanza 5,442,711 41.89 42 42 32 10

291 290 210 80

The result and summary of this analysis is captured in option 1** and the above Table of Delimitations.

*All the 290 constituencies being delimited according to this formula strictly meet the requirement of Article 89 (5,6,&7) and Section 6 of the Constitution of Kenya.

3.3 Data for Population for Constituencies as stipulated by IIBRC

The use of the criteria specified in the Constitution by IIBRC resulted into the following different categories of the existing 210 constituencies. These are:- (i) Constituencies that have a population above the highest limits (186,393.6 for cities); (ii) Constituencies that have a population below the lowest limit (79,882.8) for sparsely populated areas; (iii) Constituencies that have a population within the limits of the lowest and highest (79,882.8 to 133,138.26) for sparsely populated areas; (iv) Constituencies that have a population above the National population quota (133,138.26) for sparsely populated areas; (v) Constituencies that have a population above the highest limits (173,079.4) for other areas;

17

(vi) Constituencies that have a population within the limits of the lowest and highest (93,196.6 to 133,138.26) for sparsely populated areas; (vii) Lastly, constituencies that have a population below the lowest limits (93,196.6) for other areas. The constituencies under each of these categories are shown in Table 5 below: Table 5: Analysis of Population Quota Limits in Relation to Populations in the 210 Constituencies Population Areas Name of 210 Constituencies Quota limits Above Cities Makadara, Kamukunji, Strarehe, West lands, Langata, 186,393.6 Dagoretti, . Below Sparsely populated Mwatate, Galole, Lamu East, North Horr, Saku, 79,882.8 Laisamis, Isiolo south, Saburu East Between Sparsely Populated Bura, Garsen, , Fafi, Ijara, Wajir South, , Isiolo 79,882.8 to 133,138.26 North, Mutito, Above Sparsely Populated Kinango, Dujis, Lagdera, Wajir North, Wajir West, Wajir 133,138.26 East, Mandera, Mandera Central, Mandera, Kitui Central, Kitui South, Turkana North, Turkana Central, Turkana South, Kacheliba, , Sigor, Saburu West, Kajiado Central, Loitokitok. Above Other Areas , Kisauni, Likoni, Msambweni, Bahari, 173,079.4 Kaloleni, , Igembe South, Igembe North, North Imenti, South Imenti, Nithi, North, Mwingi South, Kathiani, Machakos Town, Mbooni, Makueni, , Kinangop, Ol-kalou, Mwea, Kiharu, , Kiambaa, Kabete, Kwanza, Saboti, Cherangany, North, Eldoret East, Eldoret South, Engwen, Tinderet, Laikipia West, Laikipia East, , Nakuru Town, Kuresoi, Molo, Subukia, Kilgoris, Narok North, Narok South, Kajiado North, Bomet, Sotik, Belgut, Ainamoi, Kipkelion, Malaba, Lugari, , Lurambi, Emuhaya, Kimilili, , Sirisia, Kanduyi, Bumula, Amagoro, Nambale, Ugenya, Town East, Kasipul Kabondo, Karachuonyo, Rongo, Migori, Kuria, Bomachoge, Bobasi, Kitutu Chache, Kitutu Masaba, North Mugirango Borabu, Between Other Areas Matuga Ganze, Magarini, Tigania West, Tigania East, 93,196.6 to 173,079.4 Central Imenti, Tharaka, Manyatta, Runyenjes, Gachoka, Kitui west, Masinga, Yatta, , Mwala, Kaiti, Kipipiri, Kieni, Mathira, Nyeri Town, Gichugu, Ndia, Kirinyaga Central, , Maragua, Kandara, Gatanga,

18

Gatundu South, Gatundu North, Githunguri, , Lari, Marakwet West, Keiyo South, Mosop, Aldai, Baringo East, Baringo North, Baringo Central, Eldama Ravine, Rongai, Chepalungu, Konoin, Buret, Funyula, Funyula, Matungu, Shinyalu, Ikolomani, Butere, Khwisero, Sabatia, Hamisi, Mt. Elgon, Butula, Gem, Bondo, Rarieda, Kisumu Town West, Kisumu Rural, Nyando, Muhoroni, Kasipul Kabondo, Karachuonyo, Ndhiwa, Uriri, Nyatike, Mbita, Gwasi, Bonchari, South Mugirango, Nyaribari Masaba, Nyaribari Chache, West Mugirango. Below Other Areas Mvita, , Lamu west, Taveta, , Siakago, Kilome, 93,196.6 Ndaragwa, Tetu, Othaya, Mukurwe-ini, Kangema, Mathioya, Marakwet East, Keiyo North, Mogotio, Vihiga, Bundalangi. (Source: IIBRC Report Table 1:210 Constituency Populations compared to the Population Quota)

3.4 Protected Constituencies under Article 262 Section, 27(4) of the Constitution Out of the the 290 constituencies, prescribed by the constitution, a total of 27 constituencies were protected. The protected constituencies were as follows:

Table 2: Protected Constituencies

27 PROTECTED CONTITUENCIES Area km. Sq. Population NAIROBI (NONE) COAST (9/27) 1. Mvita 7 74,735 2. Galole 9,657 60,866 3. Bura 12,796 82,545 4. Lamu East 1,663 18,841 5. Lamu West 4,504 82,698 6. Taveta 4,205 67,665 7. Wundanyi 702 56,021 8. Mwatate 1,873 71,513 9. Voi 10,348 89,458 NORTH EASTERN (NONE) EASTERN (6/27) 10. North Horr 38,953 75,196 11. Saku 2,078 46,502 12. Laisamis 20,266 65,669

19

13. Isiolo South 9,817 43,118 14. Siakago 777 89,035 15. Kilome 630 87,864 CENTRAL (6/27) 16. Ndaragwa 80 934 92,626 17. Tetu 81 418 78,320 18. Othaya 84 600 87,374 19. Mukurweini 85 180 83,932 20. Kangema 91 260 76,988 21. Mathioya 92 262 88,219 RIFT VALLEY (4/27) 22. Samburu East 113 10,142 59,094 23. Marakwet East 120 783 78,749 24. Keiyo North 122 541 73,715 25. Mogotio 131 1,364 60,959 WESTERN (2/27) 26. Vihiga 166 90 91,616 27. Budalangi 178 187 66,723 NYANZA (NONE)

20

CHAPTER IV PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS, IIBRC PROPOSALS AND EMERGING ISSUES

5.0 Introduction The methodology of particular emphasis IIBRC employed in the first review relating to the delimitation of boundaries of constituencies and wards - was public hearings. This was like a tool that both facilitated consultation on its mandate and for gathering and compiling relevant information from the general public on matters of concern. The public hearings promoted advocacy, awareness-raising and building consensus on the electoral reform process. In particular, the public hearings afforded the IIBRC unrivalled opportunity on a nation-wide scale to engage in public information, civic education and receiving public views on issues related to its mandate. The objectives, procedures and principles guiding the public hearings were determined and published beforehand.

To ensure maximum benefit of the public hearings to the delivery of its mandate, IIBRC formulated a checklist of documents and materials, provided for rapportuer‘s briefing notes and terms of reference, and used verbatim audio-visual recordings of all the proceedings. It is through the public hearings that several issues concerning boundary delimitation were presented to IIBRC. Based on such issues and the requirements of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, IIBRC developed a Report - “Delimitation of Constituencies and Recommendations on Local Authority Electoral Units and Administrative Boundaries for Districts and other Units”- that had proposals and maps indicating 80 new constituencies. However, the proposals presented in the Report elicited several reactions from county to county.

5.1 General Views on the IIBRC Report The delimitation process and criteria adopted by IIBRC has been subjected to debate with remarks pitted against the proposed constituencies. Some critics fault the ―formula‖ applied and the resulting inequities. Other critics of the Report have cited lack of adequate consultation between IIBRC and the Kenyan public as the cause of their contest.

A Report from the Parliamentary Departmental Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs that was presented to parliament notably underscored several issues. Some of the issues cited included:

(i) The determination of boundaries on the basis of three types of population quotas instead of one; (ii) The use of regions and provinces as units of analysis (yet not provided in the Constitution); (iii) The treatment of Cities and urban areas in a similar way (definition of cities not agreed on); (iv) The description of boundaries based on wards or sub-locations; (v) Inconsistency in the division of constituencies where some with large population were not split yet others with less population were split;

21

(vi) The creation or alteration of boundaries without taking into account geographical features and community interests; (vii) There was nullification census results in eight (8) constituencies yet no clarity on their delineation was stipulated; and (viii) Lastly, that there was no public participation.

Latently, the argument brought forth was that the proposals on which each scenario that was used or applied in the delimiting of boundaries by IIBRC were never considered.

Some experts on demographic issues have analyzed the IIBRC Report and noted that population limits are too tight to accommodate the wide variations in constituencies. A number of inconsistencies emerge with regard to constituencies /legal limits and interpretation of the legal population limits; variations of constituencies in population and area; special consideration for sparsely populated areas and qualitative factors such as geographical features and socio-economic factors.

In arriving at its review and variation of boundaries, it appeared that the IIBRC had not undertaken consultations as required by the constitution (evidenced by the elicited intense public reaction following the gazettment of the boundaries). However, whether there was public consultation or not, there are several documented evidences that indicate that there were public hearings that took place across the country. Similarly, there are memorandums through which the public presented their suggestions and opinions.

4.2 Public Views, IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries and Emerging Issues

4.2.1 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on constituency boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Westlands Constituency  It was proposed that, the constituency to be split into three Kangemi Ward, Mountain View constituencies namely: Ward, Kitisuru Ward, Parklands (i) Kilimani constituency which will comprise of the Ward, Kileleshwa Ward and following wards: Kilimani, Lavington, Kileleshwa, Highridge Ward of Nairobi Nairobi primary school, Kenyatta market/Madaraka, County. uppere hill, Kangemi, and Mountain view ward; (ii) Highridge/Westlands constituency will comprise of Kawangware Constituency the following wards: -Westlands, Parklands, Highridge, Katina Ward, Kilimani Ward and Muthaiga, city park, Karura forest, Pangani/Cemetery Kawangware Ward of Nairobi area and Safari Park; County. (iii) Kangemi constituency to comprise of the following

22

wards: Kangemi Central, Gichagi, Mountain view ward, Loresho, Kitisuru, Upper parklands, KIA/Spring Valley and Waruku.  It was also proposed that Westlands be divided along Waiyaki way and again along ring road Westlands and down to St Xaviers‘s Catholic Church to yield 3 constituencies. 2. Proposals related to Dagoretti Constituency Dagoretti Constituency  Proposed that, the constituency be split into two Uthiru-Ruthimitu Ward, Mutuini constituencies namely: Ward, Ngando Ward, Waithaka (i) Dagoreti South Constituency Ward and Riruta Ward of Nairobi (ii) Dagoreti North Constituency County

 The proposal was that, the constituency to be split into three constituencies namely: (i) Kenyatta Constituency will comprise of Woodley, Kenyatta and Golf course wards; (ii) Riruta Constituency will comprise of Ngando, Githembe, Kabiro, Kanungaga, Kinyanjui, Gatina, Kawangware and Kamitha Wards; (iii) Waithaka constituency will comprise of Ruthimitu, Uthiru, Mutuini, Kirigu, Waithaka and Kabira Wards. 3. Proposals related to Karen-Langata Constituency It was proposed that, the constituency to be split into three Mugumo-ini Ward, Nairobi West constituencies namely: Ward, Woodley Ward, Kenyatta 1. constituency on the east will comprise of Woodley, Golf Course Ward, Karen Ward Sarango‘mbe, Ayany, Lindi, Makina, Laini Saba and golf and Langata Ward of Nairobi course wards; and the boundary be defined as running from County. railways bridge off Naivasha road to Nairobi Jamhuri show ground to Ngong river dividing Kibera and Otiende to Nairobi Dam-AP‘s camp to Nyayo roundabout back to railway bridge off Naivasha road; 2. Langata constituency on the west to comprise of Nairobi west, Mugumoini, Langata, Karen, proposed Bomas and South C wards; and the boundary be defined from Posta Jamhuri-Ngong road-KBC transmission station near Ngong Makina Ward, Sarango’mbe road to institute of primate research linking Mbagathi river Ward, Laini Sabaa, Ward and to Karen and Hardy estates- national park - Wilson airport Lindi Ward of Nairobi County. Nairobi West - South C; and 3. Woodley/Kenyatta- golfcourse constituency and it will comprise of Woodley ward and Kenyatta/golfcourse wards It was also proposed that the constituency to be split into two

23 but with different naming:

 Kibra North constituency and the boundary will start from city mortuary roundabout on the north and goes on along Ngong road then pass Uchumi hyper, Adams arcade, impala club, Kenya science teachers college, metrological up to the railway bridge, on the south starts at the railway bridge at the Ngong road then passes along the railway line upto the bridge at the Mbagathi road. From the east starts from Mbagathi railway bridge upto city mortuary roundabout;

 Kibra South constituency and the boundary starts from railway bridge at Mbagathi road on the north and goes along railway line upto railway bridge at Ngong road near posta sports club. On the east is from railway bridge at Mbagathi road upto Mbagathi roundabout at Langata road and along Langata road upto to mukinduri road at Langata police station and from the west is from Langata police station along forest edge road, kungu karumba road upto kibera drive at Rowland camp to polo road and Jamuhuri road upto railway bridge at Ngong road;  Nubian community as a minority group in Kibera requested a constituency to be created 4. Proposals related to Kasarani Constituency  It was proposed that, the constituency to be sub-divided Njiru Ward, Ruai Ward, Mwiki into three constituencies namely: Ward and KasaraniWard of (i) Kasarani constituency; Nairobi County. (ii) Mathare constituency; and (iii) Kahawa constituency.

 Kasarani constituency to comprise of Kasarani, Mwiki, Lucky Summer, Ngomongo, Babadogo, and wards covering an area of 29.2 km2;  Mathare constituency to comprise of Mathare 4A/Utalii, Mathare North, Kariobangi, Kariobangi light industry and Roysambu Ward, Githurai Ward, 2 Korogocho wards covering an area of 29.6 km ; Kahawa Ward of Nairobi County.  Kahawa constituency to comprise of Kahawa West, Githurai, Zimmerman, Maziwa, Thome, Roysambu and Garden Estate wards covering an area of 33.8 km2;

Secondly, it was also proposed that, the constituency be split

24 into two constituencies using road as the boundary right from Muthaiga roundabout up to Githurai roundabout; (i) Githurai constituency; (ii) Kasarani constituency; (iii) Githurai constituency to comprise of Kahawa West, Githurai, Zimmerman, Maziwa, Thome, Roysambu and Garden Estate wards; and (iv) Kasarani constituency to comprise of Kasarani, Mwiki, Mathare 4A , Utalii, Mathare North, Babadogo, Kariobangi and Korogocho wards; 5. Proposals related to Starehe Constituency Proposals that starehe constituency be split into two Central Ward, Kariokor Ward, constituencies namely: Ward, Ngara West Ward and Ngara East Ward of a) Starehe Constituency will cover the following wards: Nairobi County. Central East, Central West(new), Ngara East, Ngara West, Kariokor and Pangani (new) wards; and the boundary will run from Muranga road, Pangani road roundabout, forest road, museum hill roundabout, Uhuru highway up to the Korogocho Ward, Mathare North railway bridge then using railway boundary up to railway Ward, Utalii Ward and Babadogo station, then HQs, then back to Haile Sellasie avenue, Ward of Nairobi County. Pumwani road, Digo road, Meru road, Muratina road, Mathare river up to Muranga road; b) Mathare Constituency will cover the following wards: Mathare Constituency Mathare, Hospital(new), Mabatini, Ngei(new), Huruma and Mathare Ward, Huruma Ward, Kiamaiko wards; and the boundary will run from Outering Kia Maiko Ward and Mabatini road, Gitathuru river up to Kiambu road then Muthaiga Ward of Nairobi County. roundabout, Muranga road up to Mathare river down to Muratina road up to Juja road and then back to Outering road.  It was also proposed that alternatively, starehe be split into three constituencies namely::- (i) Starehe constituency to comprise of ngara east, ngara west, central, pangani and ziwani wards; (ii) Mathare constituency to comprise of mathare, mabatini, huruma, kiamako and mathare north wards; (iii) Nairobi central constituency 6. Proposals related to Embakazi Constituency It was proposed that, the constituency to be split into three constituencies namely: 1. Njiru constituency will cover the vast from Dandora, I - Imara Daima and Kwa Njenga Ward of Nairobi County

25

IV wards, Kariobangi South, Njiru and Ruai wards; proposed Mowlem, Saika and Ngondo wards; 2. Kayole constituency will cover Umoja I, Umoja II, Kayole Kariobangi Constituency south, Savannah, Kayole North, and Kamarock wards; Kariobangi North Ward, Dandora proposed Soweto, Kayole central wards; Area I Ward, Dandora Area II 3. Embakasi constituency will cover Kwa Njenga, Imara Ward, Dandora Area III Ward Daima, Airport and Mihango wards, proposed Mukuru Kwa and Dandora Area IV Ward of Reuben, Pipeline, Utawala, Tassia and Kamulu wards; Nairobi County.

Further, it was propsed that, the constituency to be split into Kayole Constituency four constituencies namely: Komarock Ward, Kayole North Ward and Kayole South Ward of

1. Dandora constituency will constitute Dandora 1, Dandora Nairobi County. 2, Dandora 3, Dandora 4, Kariobangi south wards;

2. Umoja constituency will constitute Umoja 1, Umoja 2, Savannah, Kayole South and Komarock Wards; Mihango Constituency

3. Njiru constituency will constitute Njiru, Ruai, Kayole Embakasi Ward, Savanna Ward North, and Mihango Wards; and Mihango Ward of Nairobi

4. Embakasi constituency will constitute Embakasi, Kwa County Njenga and Imara Daima Wards. Umoja Constituency  That, the three constituencies have there natural boundaries Umoja I Ward, Umoja II Ward, of Kangundo road for Kayole; Njiru and Ngong river for Kariobangi South Ward and Kayole and Embakasi; however Njiru and Embakasi shall Harambee Ward of Nairobi border by Kangundo road after leaving Kayole at Ngong County. river after Njiru; 7. Proposals related to Makadara Constituency  The constituency be split into two constituencies namely:- Nairobi South Ward, Land Mawe a) Makadara/Viwandani constituency to comprise of Ward, Hamza- Lumumba Ward, South B, Mbotela, Maringo, Hamza, Lumumba, Ofafa Ward, Viwandani Ward, viwandani and Harambee wards; Mbotela Ward and Makongeni b) Nairobi South constituency to comprise of Hazina, Ward of Nairobi County. Nairobi South, Land Mawe, Makongeni and Kaloleni wards;  The existing boundaries in the administrative units should remain and be used as the boundaries for the proposed sub- divisions of the constituency and Likoni road should be the boundary of the two constituencies. 8. Proposals related to Kamukunji Constituency  Option 1 Eastleigh North Ward, Eastleigh The constituency be split into three constituencies namely: South Ward, Kimathi Ward,

26

(i) Eastleigh constituency, Muthurwa-Shauri Moyo, Uhuru (ii) Pumwani constituency and Ward and Air Base Ward of (iii) Kamukunji constituency Nairobi County.  Option 2 The constituency be split into two constituencies namely; a) Eastleigh/Pumwani constituency to comprise of the following wards: Pumwani, bondeni, Carlifonia, Eastliegh South, Eastleigh North and Eastleigh Airbase wards; b) Kamukunji constituency to comprise Kumukunji, Muthurwa, Shauri Moyo, Uhuru, Kimathi and Bahati wards;

27

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Nairobi County

(iii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

It emerged that the use of the population Quota and other parameters has given this county the appropriate number of constituencies that is, 17. The Community of interest, Historical, Economical and cultural ties were closely scrutinized. More so, the names of some wards and boundaries need to be changed or preserved to upload community wishes. As concerns Dagoretti Constituency, it emerged that:- (i) since Nairobi is highly populated, it is under represented and needs an one more addition of constituency; (ii) Not all interested parties were consulted. It was alleged that the residents are opposed to the name ‗Kawangware‘ for the new constituency as it doesn‘t represent the will of the people and the area‘s history; (iii) Community of interest, Historical, Economical and Cultural Ties were not observed in the drawing the boundaries; and (iv) That the people also desire to retain Woodley ward in Dagoretti instead of moving it to Kibra Constituency. In relation to Embakasi constituency, it emerged that:- The population quota was not well used in the sub-division of the constituency. It also emerged that not all interested parties were consulted. The constituency should have been split into five

28 constituencies using the formula of quota + maximum deviation per constituency; hence giving 186,393 people per constituency, and divide the wards as proposed by the leaders and constituents.

4.2.2 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Changamwe Constituency  It was propsed that Changamwe constituency be split into Ward, Ward, two: Airport Ward, and Ward o Changamwe Constituency (current) - Portreitz of Mombasa County. Ward, Magongo Ward, Kipevu/chaani Ward, Airport Ward and Changamwe Ward; Jomvu Constituency Jomvu Kuu Ward, Changamwe o Jomvu constituency comprising of : Jomvu kuu Ward, Ward, and Mikindani Ward of Iritini Ward, Mikindani Ward and Kwa Shee Ward Mombasa County. 2. Proposals related Kisauni Constituency Mjambere Ward, Junda Ward,  The following 2 proposals were presented, first: Mwakirunge Ward and Bamburi i. Kisauni Constituency (Follow Kisauni Division Boundary); Ward of Mombasa County ii. Kongowea Constituency (Follow Kongowea Boundary); iii. Bamburi constituency (Follow Bamburi Division Boundary);

 Secondly, it was proposed that: Nyali Constituency i. Mzizima Constituency – Boundary right from the Shanzu Ward, Frere Town Ward, island part of the Makupa causeway starting from Jomo Maweni Ward, Nyali-Mkomani Kenyatta Avenue upto Ronald Ngala Road Junction (77) Ward, Kongowea Ward of connecting to Sheikh Abdalla Farsy Avenue to coast and Mombasa County. turn right along Kisauni road connecting back with Jomo Kenyatta Avenue going down to Digo road moving straight down Nyerere avenue upto Likoni ferry bus terminus; ii. Kisauni Constituency will comprise of the remaining part of the current Kisauni Constituency. 3. Proposals related to Likoni Constituency  It was proposed that Likoni Constituency Remain as it is Mtongwe Ward, Likoni Ward, currently. Bofu Ward, Timbwani Ward and Shika Adabu Ward of Mombasa County.

29

4. Proposals related to Mvita Constituency The first proposal was to split the constituency (Island) into Tudor Estate Ward, Tudor Four two as indicated below: Ward, Shimanzi Ward, Tononoka 1. Mji Wa Kale constituency Ward, Majengo Ward, King‟orani 2. Mvita Constituency Ward, Mwembe Tayari Ward, The second proposal was to plit the constituency into 3 as Bondeni Ward, Mji wa Kale- indicated, though the proposed names were not given; Makadara Ward, Kizingo Ward  Constituency 1: Kizingo, Old Town, Makadara, Mji wa and Ganjoni Ward of Mombasa kale, County.  Constituency 2: Tudor Estate ward, Tudor four ward, Shimanzi ward, King‘orani  Constituency 3: Bondeni, Mwembe Tayari, Tononoka, Majengo  No specific names of these three constituencies were given.

30

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Mombasa

County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

It emerged out that Mombasa county has 939,370 people but only 2 constituencies were created. Thus, the distribution of new constituencies is skewed, with less given to areas with high populations. Mombasa as part of the coast region has been marginalized and needs to be protected.

31

4.2.3 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Prosposals given related to Msambweni Constituency Gombato-Bongwe Ward, Ward, The proposal was to split the Constituency into two as Kinondo Ward, Mivumoni Ward, indicated below: Kikoneni Ward, Msambweni Ward,  Msambweni Constituency ( from River Mwachema Kingwende-Shirazi, Ward and Pongwe- to River Ramisi)- (it should include Msambweni, Kidimu Ward of Kwale County. Mvumoni, Kinondo, Gombato, Ukunda, Kingwede shirazi wards); Lunga Lunga Constituency  Lunga Lunga Constituency (River Ramisi to Vanga Ward, Kasemeni-Sega Ward, Tanzania border) – to comprise of Pongwe Kidimu, Mwena Ward and Kilima-Ngondo Ward Kikoneni, Dzombo, Kasemeni, Vanga, and Dzombo Ward of Kwale Kilimangondo and Mwena wards County.

Mackinon Road Ward should remain as part of Kinango District/Constiuency in the county council of Kwale and should NOT be moved to Voi municipality.

2. Proposals related to Matunga Constituency Proposed to create two constituencies:- Mwalupamba Ward, Mkongani Ward,  Matuga Constituency starting near Likoni upto Mangawani Ward, Kubo South Ward, Lunga Lunga. Mazumalume Ward, Mwamgunga Ward,  Kubo constituency comprising Maluwamba, Mbuguni Ng’ombeni Ward, Ngolini- Mkongani, Mangawani, Lukore, Mwaluvanga and Vyongwani Ward, Ziwani Ward, Waa Mashimoni. Mkongani to be division Tiribe, Ward and Tiwi Ward, Vuga Ward, Kwale Mkomba and Msangani. Ward of Kwale County Another proposal was that Kubo be divided into Ng‘ombeni, Mbuguni, Waa, Tiwi, Simba and Golini to be Matuga Constituency. But if Simba and Golini is taken to Kubo Constituency it won‘t be fine for the residents. 3. Proposals Related to Kinango Constituency Two proposals given:- Mackinnon Ward, Chengoni Ward,  Maintain Status quo; or Samburu Ward, Vigurungani Ward,  Divide Kinango Constituency into two:- Kinango Mwavumbo Ward, Kasemeni West Ward, Constituency and Samburu Constituency. Mtaa Ward, Kinango Ward, Ndavaya Ward, Taru Ward, Makamini Ward, Puma

32

Ward, Gandini Ward, Mwatate Ward and Kasemeni East Ward of Kwale County.

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kwale County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major issue was raised against the IIBRC proposals.

33

4.2.4 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on constituency boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kilifi Constituency Six proposals came up from the presentations. Matsangoni Ward, Roka Ward, Proposal 1: Ngerenya Ward, Ngala Ward, Split Bahari constituency into Bahari and Kikambala/Chonyi Kibarani Ward, Hospital-Sokoni constituencies. Ward of Kilifi County.

Proposal 2: Kilifi South Constituency  Bahari - to stretch from Mbogolo River all the way to Mnarani Ward, Mavueni-Mkongani Matsangoni. Ward, Chasimba Ward, Shauri  Kikambala: To include the rest of the of Kikambala Moyo-Takaungu Ward, Ziani Ward, and Chonyi divisions Mwarakaya Ward, Junju North Proposal 3: Ward, Junju South Ward, Mtepeni 1. Bahari - will cover, Kilifi Township, Tezo Location, Ward, Kanamai Ward, Shimo la Ngerenya Location, Roka Location, Matsangoni Tewa Ward of Kilifi County. Location,Mavueni/Mkongani Locations 2. Bahari South - will cover Mtwapa, Junju Bandara Salama, Mwarakaya, Ziani, Chasimba Locations. Proposal 4: Split Bahari into; 1. Kilifi north - will cover Kilifi Town, Mtondia, Tezo, Ngerenya, Roka, Matsangoni Locations. 2. Kilifi south - will cover Mtwapa, Takaungu/Mavueni, Manrani; 3. Kilifi west - will cover Bandara Salama, Chasimba, Mwarakaya, Ziani/Ngombeni, Junju, Mtepeni Locations. Proposal 5. a) Kilifi South - Will Be Based on Kikambala Division comprising of the Following Locations; Shimo La Tewa, Mtepeni, Kijipwa, Junju South, Junju North Locations. b) Kilifi Central- will be comprised of Mbogolo Division- Takaungu, Pingilikani/Kadzinuni, Mavueni/Mkongani, Mnarani Locations; and Chonyi Division-Mwarakaya, Mwambe Kati, Chasimba, Ziani, Dzitsoni. c) Kilifi North - will be made of Kibarani Division;

34

Hospital/Sokoni, Ngala, Kibarani/Majaoni, And Konjora Loctions and Roka Divisions; Ngerenya, Chumani, Roka, Matsangoni locations. Proosal 6: Split Bahari constituency into 1) Kilifi North and 2) Kilifi South Constituencies 2. Proposals realted to Kaloleni Constituency Kaloleni - would comprise of the following locations namely; Kaloleni 13 Tsangatsini Ward, Mwanamwinga, Kaloleni, Jibana, Kambe, Ribe, And Kaloleni North Ward, Kaloleni Kayafungo Locations. South Ward, Kayafungo Ward, Mariakani Ward and Mwanawinga Mariakani - would comprise of the following locations Ward of Kilifi County. namely; Mwanamwinga, Kaloleni, Jibana, Kambe, Ribe, and Kayafungo Locations. Rabai Constituency Kawala Ward, Jibana Ward, Kambe Ward, Ruruma Ward, Ribe Ward, Kaliang‟ombe Ward, Mugumo-wa- Patsa Ward, Rabai Part Ward and Mwaweza Ward of Kilifi County. 3. Proposals related to Ganze Constituency  The following proposal was presented:- Mitanganyi Ward, Dungicha- Split the current Ganze constituency into; Ganze Ward, Vitengeni Ward, a) Vitengeni Constituency - will cover the following Sokoke Ward, Mrima wa Ndege locations, Mitangoni, Ndigiria, Bandari, Mrima Wa Ward, Kauma-Jaribuni Ward, Ndege, Vitengeni, Dungicha, Mwahera, Sokoke and Bamba Ward, Mwahera Ward, Dida Locations and; Ndigiria-Bandari Ward and b) Ganze constituency - be composed of Kauma, Palakumi Ward of Kilifi County. Vyambani, jaribuni, Ganze, Bamba, palakumi, Mtsara wa tsatsu, Mitangoni locations.  That the Jaribuni ward, be retained in Ganze Constituency.  Solution of disputes in Kauma Jaribuni wards, and in Mwahera location. 4. Proposal related to Malindi Constituency Proposal 1: Chakama Ward, Lango Baya Ward,  Proposed to split Malindi constituency into Malindi Madunguni Ward, Malimo Ward, Constituency and Galana Constituencies; Jilore Ward, Gede South Ward, Gede North Ward, Gede Ward, Proposal 2: Maweni Ward, Ganda-Mkaomoto Ward, and Watamu Town Ward,

35

 Merge the Malindi and Magarini constituencies then split Malindi North Ward, Malindi them into:- Central Ward, Shella Ward, i. Malindi constituency; Kijiwetanga Ward and Barani Ward ii. Galana Constituency; and of Kilifi County. iii.  The residents wanted the constituency split into two; Malindi and Galana constituency. There was however a variation in the naming of the wards.  Another option was to merge the existing two constituencies i.e. Malindi and Magarini then split them into three constituencies. 5. Proposal related to Magarini Constituency Magarini Constituency (i) No proposals were presented. Adu Ward, Bungale Ward, Marafa Ward, Garashi Ward, Dagamra Ward, Fundi-Issa Ward, Gongoni Ward, Magarini West Ward, Magarini East Ward and Marereni Ward of Kilifi County.

36

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kilifi County

37

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issue came as concerns the IIBRC boundary proposals and names for the new constituencies.

4.2.5 Tana River County

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Garsen Constituency It was proposed that Garsen constituency be split into: Kipini East ward, Kipini West ward, Shirikisho ward, Assa ward, Salama- (i) Chaffa constituency- Comprised of Galiai, Kipao and Mwina ward, Ndera ward, Bilisa ward, Kilelengwani; and Garsen Central ward, Garsen South (ii) Garsen constituency ward of Tana River County.

All locations to be granted their electoral autonomy

2. Proposals related to Galole Constituency Zubaki-Mikinduni ward, Milalulu ward, Proposal 1: Wayu ward, Waldena ward, Chifiri (i) Hive parts of Galole and Garsen Constituencies to create Ward, Chewani-Kiarukungu ward, a new one as indicated below: Gwano ward, Ndura ward, and (ii) Proposed Gale Dertu Constituency: To cover all areas Kinakomba ward of Tana River on the western part of Galole and Assa, Waldena, Wayu, County. Chifiri, kalikacha Locations of Garsen Constituency;

Proposal 2: (i) Split Galole Constituency to create Wenje Constituency

3. Proposals related to Bura Constituency Split the Constituency into two as indicated below: Chewele ward, Bura ward, Nanighi ward, Hirimani ward, Madogo South Proposals 1: ward, Sala ward, Saka ward, (i) Bura - Comprised of Hirimani Divisions Bangale ward, Kamaguru ward, and (ii) Madogo - Comprised of Mbalambala and Nanighi Mbalambala ward of Tana River Divisions District.

38

Proposal 2: Split into two as follows: (ii) Duresa - Comprised of Hirimani, Bangale Kamaguru Locations) (iii) Bura - Comprised of Bura, Nanighi, Madogo, Mbalambala Locations; Boundary between Bura and Madogo Constituencies to start from Mbalambala to Chwele following the existing divisional and Locational boundaries. Support quest for sisterconstituencies of Garsen and Galole to be split.

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Tana River County

(iii) Emerging Issues (According to the JLA Report)

No major issue was raised as concerns the proposed boundaries by IIBRC for the Tana River County.

4.2.6

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Lamu East Constituency Faza-Tchundwa Ward, Ndau Ward, It was proposed that two constituencies be created: Siyu-Pate Ward, Kizingitini West i. Lamu East constituency- Include Kisiwa cha Pate, Ward, Kiunga Ward and Basuba ndau and Kiwayuu; and Ward of Lamu County. ii. Barani constituency- Include Kililana, Magogoni, Kiangwi, Mangai, Baasuba , Barigoni, Milimani, Mkononi, Mvunduni, Rubu, Sendeni, Marereni, Kiunga, Ishakani upto Somali boarder.

2. Proposals related to Lamu West Constituency Hindi-Magogoni Ward, Proposal 1: Ward, Mokowe Ward, Mkomani- The status quo be maintained i.e boundaries remain as they are Matondoni Ward, Langoni Ward, currently. Mapenya Ward, Hongwe Ward, Shella Manda Ward, Central Ward,

39

Proposal 2: Mkunumbi Ward, Baharini Ward, Split Lamu West constituency into: Dide Waride Ward and Witu Ward  Lamu Central constituency- Cover Hindu and the of Lamu County. proposed Langoni and Mkomani Divisions  Lamu west constituency – Cover Witu, Mpeketoni and the proposed Mkunumbi divisions

Proposed the creation of a special ward in Lamu Couty council for the marginalized Boni Minority ethnic community.

It should include Bargoni, Ndununi. It is proposed Boni ward should be created for Boni Bajuni

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Lamu County

40

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

Issues that came up were general in nature referring to all islands in the Indian Ocean and Lake Victoria. It was argued that Geographical features are spread out in large areas separated by water bodies. Secondly that Community of interest, historical, Economic and cultural ties were not considered in the first review and lastly that these areas are difficulty to access.

4.2.7 Taita Taveta County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Taveta Constituency  No proposals on the electoral boundaries given Chala-Njukini Ward, Mboghoni Ward, Taveta North Ward, Taveta South Ward, Kitobo-Kimorigho Ward, Mahoo Ward and Mata Ward of Taita-Taveta County. 2. Proposals related to Wundanyi constituency  No Proposals submitted Wundanyi Ward, Werugha Ward, Wumingu-Kishushe Ward, Mbale Ward, and Mwanda-Mghange Ward of Taita- Taveta County. 3. Proposals related to Mwatate Constituency  The proposal was to split the Constituency into two Bura Ward, Mwatate Ward, Kighononyi as indicated below: Ward, Chawia-Kishamba Ward, Ron‟ge i. Ronge (To follow; Mwakishalua, Vigegu kwa Kati Ward, Rong‟e Juu Ward, Maktau Kena ya mwafuali, Ronge Nyika water intake, Ward and Mwachabo Ward of Taita- Zungula Juu, mnyichi Kishamba mbumbunyi, Taveta County. kanisa Morice, Kungu, ngerenyi, Mwafungu S.S, Chawia mruru, Mwatate Stage, Peleleza road, mwatate S. Estate, Mgeno, Nanak quarry, Makajini, Voi River, Kirutai, Ingoja ng‘ombe, Voi, kwa mwakishalua; and ii. Mwatate. 4. Proposals related to Voi Constituency Proposal 1. Voi Central Ward, Mbololo Ward, Sagala  Split Voi constituency to form Voi Town Ward, Ngolia Ward, Kasigau Ward, Voi constituency and South Ward, Voi North East Ward, Voi Voi constituency. West Ward, Kirutai Ward and Marungu Proposal 2 Ward of Taita-Taveta County.  Split Voi constituency to form Voi Town

41

constituency- to cover area of Voi municipal jurisdiction including Kirutai, Voi west, Voi central, and Voi North East ward Voi Rural Constituency- Cover Mbololo, Ngalia, Maungu, and Kasiagu. Proposal 3  Split Voi constituency to form Voi west constituency to comprise of Mwambirwa and Tausa Divisions and parts of Rong‘e Kati proceeding from based on the 1963 demarcations, going west to Ngulia Safari lodge, Southwards up to Mtwa- Mwagoti following Msau River, through Voi Municipality up to Tsavo National Park at Sala Gate; and

 Voi East Constituency to comprise of Parts of Voi Municipality and Sagalla. Proposal 4  Split Voi constituency to: a) Taita central b) Taita East Proposal 5  New Tausa constituency to be curved from Tausa and Mwambirwa (from Voi constituency and Mwatete division of Mwatate constituency and Paranga which is in Wundanyi Constituency; Proposal 6  Remain as it is

42

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Taita Taveta County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major issue emerged as a result of the proposals presented by IIBRC in the first review.

43

4.2.8 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Dujis Constituency Dujis Constituency Four proposals were made as follows: Biashara ward, Bulla ward, i). To split the constituency plit into two, Dujis and Garissa Jamuhuri ward, Market ward, Central Constituencies. Mashambani ward, Stadium ii). To split Dujis into Dujis and Garissa North Constituencies ward, Sankuri/Raya ward, iii). To split Dujis into Garissa and Garissa South Kora kora ward, Shimbirey Constituencies ward, Bouralgi and ward. iv). To split Dujis into Garissa Town (or south) and Balambala constituency and for Balambala constituency to be composed of balambala division, Danyere division Balambala Constituency and the proposed Saka Division; while the former Dujis constituency will be comprised of Central Division which Balambala ward, Danyere includes Garissa Municipality, Korakora Division and ward, Jarajilla ward and Saka Sankuri Division ward of Garissa County.

On the wards, the following proposals were made; i). Wards for proposed Garissa central constituencies:Biashara ward, Mashambani, Stadium, Sambul-Garissa Municipal;Garissa

County Council-Boralgi, Korkora, Fafi, Yumbis, Hagardera, Welmerer, Jarajilla ii). Wards for Garissa North: Garissa Municipal- Market ward, Bulla ward, Jamhuri ward, Garissa Ndogo, Garissa County Council- Sankuri, Saka ward, Balambala Ward,

Danyere, Shimbireye; (iii) Wards for Garisaa South : Garissa Municipal Council; Market ward, Bulla ward, Jamhuri ward, Garissa Ndogo,Garissa County Council; Sankuri ward, Saka ward, Balambala ward, Danyere ward, Shimbireye ward;

(iv) Garissa Municipal Council; Biashara ward, Mashambani ward, Stadium ward, Sambul ward,Garrisa Couty Council; Bor‘algi, Korkora wards, Galmagalla, Bullagolol, Bura, Mansabubu, Nanighi, Kamuthe, warabe; (v) Sambul ward to be calved from Stadium ward, Kamuthe; (vi) Maendeleo ward Added to Garissa Municipal Council.

2. Proposals Related to Lagdera Constituency

44

Two proposals were made : Benane ward, Modogashe i). Lagdera constituency to be split into:Lagdera constituency ward, Maalim ward, Gurufa and Dujis constituency; ward, Baraki ward and Shanta- Abak ward. ii). Lagdera constituency to be split into:Lagdera East constituency- Comprised of Garufa, Baraki, Goreale, Daadab Constituency Kumahumato, Labisigale, Dagahaley, Dadaab, Abakile, Dertu ward, Abakaile ward, Alango Arba, Dertu,Kulan Liboi, Damajale locations and Kumahumato ward, Dadaab Lagdera West constituency- Comprised of Madogashe, ward, Labisigale ward, Ilan, Maalimin, Eldere,Tokojo, Benane Locations Dagahley ward, Damajale ward and Liboi ard of Garissa County. 3. Proposals Related to Fafi Constituency Two proposals were made : i). To split the Constituency into two Fafi and Jarajilla Mansabubu ward, Bura ward, constituencies. Nanighi ward, Galmagala ii). To re-define the larger Garissa district to come up with ward, Bulagololl Ward, three constituencies as follows: Jarajilla ward, Wellmarere Fafi Constituency: Hive off half of central division of ward, Hagardere ward, Garissa stretching from the left flank of Garissa bridge, all Yumbis ward and Fafi ward. centres to the right of Kismayu road, including the centres of Boulargy, korakora and join with Jarajila) iii). Have the eastern bank of the Tanariver stretching from Garissa bridge to KoraKora to be part of Fafi. iv). Make the River Tana to the west of Fafi constituency the border for Tana River district.

v). Dagega Constituency: To cover Galmagalla Division and the vast Bura. vi). Have the eastern bank of the Tana River stretching from Korakora to Garasweinow be part of the planned Dagega district/constituency. vii). Create Nanighi, Bura, Mansabubu, Galmagalla and Bulla golol divisions for the new Dagega District. viii). Garissa Constituency: Eastern bank of the tana stretching from the right flank of Garissa bridge to Danyere be part of new Garissa Constituency/district ix). Create Garissa, Sankuri, Saka, Mbalambala and Danyere divisions for the new Garissa district.

N.B. Boundaries between Lagdera, Dujis and Fafi constituencies to

45 be clearly demarcated, in order to promote peace.

Proposals Related to Ijara Constituency Two proposals were made : Masalani ward, Korisa ward, i). The constituency to be split into two constituencies namely; Kotile ward, Ijara ward, Ruqa Hulugho Constituency comprising of Hulugho division, ward, Sangole ward, Ijara Galmagalla, Elkabore location, Hadhi up to Daresaalam South ward, Sangilu ward, location, entire Sangailu division and Songole location, entire handaro ward, Hulughop Bodhai division upto the Boni forest and parts of Jarajilla, Ruqa ward and Hadi ward. Adhal and parts of Amuma currently under Fafi constituency but originally were under Ijara. Ijara Constituency comprising of Ijara division, Masalani division, Ruqa division and Kotile division upto Wema location ii). The constituency to be split into two constituencies namely:  Ijara constituency has the existing constituency which will constitute Garasweinow, Gababa, Warsame, Sakar, Ananoto, Niqha, Ijara, Bothai, Masalani and Kotile divisions;  Sangailu constituency which will constitute of Hulugho, Galma Galla and Amuma Divisions,

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Garisa County

(iii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Ijara Constituency It was observed that there was discrimination of small clans. The big clans each have a constituency while small clans have only one between them. There was concern over means of communication with poor road network in the constituency. Further there is a minority group (the Boni and Abdulla) who have no representation. It was claimed that the historical ties of Abdulla community were ignored. It was also observed that the boundary between North Eastern province and Coast province need to be addressed. And lastly, the Geographical features such as a major river running through the constituency was not considered. The population of 92,000 in an area of 11,323 sq Km. should have warranted a extra constituency.

b) Fafi Constituency An issue was raised concerning the boundaries between Fafi and Ijara.

c) Dujis Constituency

An observation was made that IIBRC did not take into account the geographical features in the constituency. Further, the Formula used to come up with protected constituency was

46

termed as unclear. North Eastern Province did not have a protected constituency. Commission did not use all parameters provide in Article 89 of the Constitution. It only applied the population quota.

4.2.9 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Wajir North Constituency  Three proposals were made : Buna Ward, Korondille Ward, i). For the Constituency to remain the same Lensayu Ward, Batalu ward, Bute ii). To split Wajir North to Buna constituency and Ward, Danaba ward, Ajawa Ward, Bute constituency Godoma Ward and Gurara Ward. iii). To split Wajir North to Eldas constituency and

Wajir North constituency

 On the wards, the following proposals were made:

i). Batalu ward (Follow Butala location wards)Bute – to

cover Bute, Bute Goda, and Makutano,

ii). Ogorji- to cover Ogorji, Adadi Jole, and

Walensatutu,

iii). Ajawa- to cover Ajawa location,

iv). Gurar- to cover Gurar location,

v). Danaba- to cover Danaba and Qudama locations,

vi). Korondille- to over Korondille,

vii). Buna- to cover Buna and Malkaggufu,

viii). Ingirir-to cover Ingirir, Garsaakey and Chibder, Lensayu- Cover Lensayu and Lakoole 2. Proposals Related to Wajir West Constituency  Two proposals were made : i). Split Wajir West Constituency to Eldas Griftu Part (Griftu Township, constituency(maintain the current Eldas district boundaries) Matho,Fatuma Nur and Kurman and Wajir West constituency (maintain the current Locations)Ward, Tulatula Ward, Wajir West district District boundaries); Wagalla Ward, Logbogol North Ward, Boji Heri-Garse Ward, ii). Split Wajir West Constituency to Hadado Ganyure Ward, Hadado constituency – comprising of Hadado and Ward,Ademasajida Ward, Arbjahan Adamasajida divisions;Griftu Constituency Ward and Athibohol Ward. comprising of Griftu and Arbajahan and Eldas constituency comprising of Eldas, Anole and Elnur Eldas Constituency

47

division Griftu Part (Balatul Amin, Biad and El Yunis Locations) Ward,  Ward Proposals Eldas Ward, Lakoley South Ward, Reinstate the following wards Lolakuta North, Barmish, Aden Dela Ward, El Nur Ward and Basir Awale, Boji Heri, Garse, Shanta Abaq, Kukale wards. Ward of Wajir County. Subdivision of Wagalla to Wagalla Central and North. Creation of Jira, Griftu Township, Griftu central, Baji, Mathow wards, Bojiyare 3. Proposals Related to Wajir East Constituency It was proposed t split Wajir East Constituency into:  Tarbaj constituency- Comprising of Tarbaj, Mansa, Township Ward, Wagberi ward, Sarman and Kutulo division; and Jogbaru Ward, Barwako Ward, Wajir Bor Ward and Khorof-Harar  Wajir East Constituency- Comprising of Central, Wajir- Ward. Bor and Khorof Divisions.

The following wards were proposed under this proposal. ◦ Ali Maow Comprising Maow and Hodhan location; Tarbaji Constituency ◦ Halane – Comprising Halane and Godade location; Tarbaj Ward, Dambas Ward, ◦ Airport – Comprising of Maalim salat, Elmi sub location; Sarman Ward Elben Ward, ◦ Wajir air port, Wajir pri and sec sch, Ministry of water Wargadud Ward and Lafaley Ward camp and Wajir district Hospital; of Wajir County. ◦ Kotulo wards consisting of Kotulo and Boji Garas locations; ◦ Mansa ward consisting of Mansa and Ogoralle locations; and ◦ Gunana wards- Constiting of Gunana and Burmayo locations

It was also prposed to split wajir East Constituency into: (i) Wajir East Constituency comprising of the entire Mansa division, Kutulo division and Tarbaj divisions; and

(ii) Wajir Central Constituency comprising of Central Division, Wajir –Bor division and Khorof Harar divisions

And the following wards were proposed under this option: Elben ward- Consisting of Elben and Mansa locations and Ogoralle ward- Consisting of Ogoralle and Bur Mayo

48 locations.

4. Proposals Related to Wajir South Constituency  The constituency to be split into two constituencies Burder Ward, Diif Ward, Ibrahim namely: Habaswein constituency to be created out of the Ure Ward, Kulaaley Ward, Kibilai current constituency and it will constitute of Habaswein, Ward, Ndege Ward, Dilmanyale Sabule, Benane divisions and Wajir South constituency Ward, Abakore Ward, Lag-Boghol which will constitute Diif, Wajir-Bor South and Kulaaley South Ward, Sabule Ward, Benane divisions. Ward and Dadaja Bulla Ward.

 The following wards to be created: Burder West, Burder East, Burder CentralLelehey, Shalekey, Wajir-Bor South, Gerilley, Hambalash, Argani, Salel Maa, Sarif, Dagahley, Meri, Kursi, Macheza, Tesorie, Habaswein Township

49

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Wajir County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Wajir South Constituency. The emerging issues were: first that the means of communication in the constituency should have be considered. Second that Geographical expanse of the constituency should have been taken into account. Third, the use of projected population was disputed, and lastly, sparsely populated and urban areas were not defined by IIBRC.

50

b) Wajir East

It emerged that the expanse of the constituency was not considered. Second, the Census results were used, and lastly. Minority of interest was not taken into consideration.

4.2.10

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Mandera West Constituency Mandera West Constituency  The constituency to be split into two to produce: Takaba North Ward, Takaba South (i) Mandera North constituency to be curved out from the Ward, Gither ward and Dandu current Mandera central and ; Ward.

Banisa Constituency (ii) Mandera West –will comprise of the current Rhamu- Banisa Ward, Derkale Ward, dimtu, Malkamari and Ashabito divisions. Eymole Ward, Keliwe Hiri Ward,

Malkamari Ward and Guba Ward  Proposed Wards to be be created: of Mandera County. Derkale South, Derkale North, Lulis , Banisa West, Eymole,

Kiliwehuri, Goljo, Malka Mari, Guba, garsey, kalicha, shantoley, towfig, tulla doday, kubi, orgowein, sarman, gofa, hullow, makaruqu, choroqo. 2. Proposals Related to Mandera Central Constituency Mandera North Constituency Proposal made:- Rhamu Ward, Girissa Ward,  Split the Constituency into two:- Yabicho Ward Rhamu Dimtu (i) Mandera North Constituency (To cover Rhamu, Ward, Ashabito Ward, Marothile Rhamu Dimtu, Ashabito, Malkamari Divisions); and Ward, Guticha Ward, Shirshir Ward, Ola Ward and Wargadud (ii) Mandera Central Constituency (To cover Kutulo, Ward Part (Quramadow location) Qalaqalesa, Elwak and Shimbir Fatuma Divisions) of Mandera County.

Mandera South Constituency  Proposed Mandera North constituency to cater for the Elwak North Ward, Elwak South Degodia, Murule and Gareh communities; Ward, Wargadud Ward Part

(Wargadud Town, Wargadud East  Proposed constituency boundaries to follow the Locations), Shimbir Fatuma Ward, boundaries of the 2 districts in the current Mandera Fincharo Ward, Kutulo North Central constituency; Ward, Kutulo Ward and Kutulo  Infrastructural conditions, Poor health care, poor food South of Mandera County. security and literacy levels key issues necessitating a split.

51

(iii) All the memoranda analyzed propose the creation of Mandera North Constituency as a matter of urgency and utmost necessity. Proposals related to Mandera East Constituency Mandera East Constituency Several Proposals given:- Bulla Mpya Ward, Bulla Jamhuria Proposal 1. Ward, B.P.1 Ward, Township Split Mandera East constituency into:- Ward, Barwako Ward, Shafshefy ◦ Lafey constituency - will be based on Lafey Division, Ward, Neboi Ward, Garba Goley Warankara Division, Fino Location, Sala Location, Ward, Hareri Hosle Ward, Burabor Wargadud Ward, Dasheng Wante Ward); Ward, Bella Ward, Kalalio Ward, ◦ Mandera East constituencies Mandera east constituency Libehia Ward, Aressa Ward, Hareri will be based on Khalalio division, Central division, hareri Ward, and Arabia Ward of division, Lebehia division, Arabia location and Omar- Mandera County. Jilaow location.

Proposal 2. Split Mandera East Constituency into: Lafey Constituency  Mandera central will be comprised of the following Alango Ward, Lafey Ward, divisions. Kutulo, Elwak, Shimbir Fatuma, Qalaanqaleesa; Warankara Ward, Fino Ward and  Mandera North will be composed of the following Sala Ward of Mandera County. divisions; Wargadud, Rhmu, Rhamu Dimtu, Ashabito;  Mandera West will be comprised of the following divisions; takaba, Dandu, Gather;  Mandera east will be composed of the following divisions lafey, Finno, Waranqara, hareri, libahiya;  Daua constituency will have central mandera, and Khalalio divisions; and  Banisa constituency will consist of banissa malkamari,and kiliwe Hirri divisions. Proposal 3 Split mandera east into Lafey  Lafey constituency boundary will be Rhamu-Elwak road on the western side from Dumiga Der to Elwak Town; Elwak Boru Hache Road as its southern boundary from Elwak, on the eastern side will be the Somali border.  Khalalio constituency

Proposal 5  Create Dawa Constituency

52

The proposed Dawa constituency is to be curved from the Existing Mandera East Constituency and Khalalio and Central Divisions of Mandera East district.

53

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Mandera County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

54

There was need for more constituencies based on geographical features.

4.2.11 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Moyale Constituency (i) Split the constituency into 2 as follows:  Moyale Constituency Galole ward, Gurumesa ward,  Sololo Constituency Manyatta ward, Heillu ward, Butinye ward, Bori ward, Uran The boundaries of the above constituencies should follow ward, Walda-Rawana Ward, their current respective district boundaries. Godoma ward, Nana ward, Sololo ward, Sololo Makutano ward, Odda ward, Dabel ward, Dambala – Fachana ward and Moyale ward of Marsabit County.

2. Proposals related to North Horr Constituency

Proposal 1. Dukana ward, North Horr Ward, Split the Constituency into three as indicated below: ward, Bubisa ward, Balesa a) Chalbi East (to comprise of Turbi Division and ward, Ririba ward, Galas Ward, Maikona Location covering an area of 13,000 sq Turbi ward, Hurri Hills ward, km.) Maikona ward and Kalacha ward b) Chalbi North (Comprising Dukana diviwsion and of Marsabit County. Hurri Hills Location of Maikona division covering an area of 14, 000 sq km); and c) Chalbi West (comprising of North Horr Division and kalacha location of Maikona division covering an area of 13,000 sq km)

Proposal 2.

Split the Constituency into two as indicated below: a) North Horr (Comprising of North Horr and Dukana Divisions); b) Chalbi East (Comprising Maikona and Torbi Divisions)

55

3. Proposals related to Saku Constituency  Curve some Locations from neighbouring North Horr and Laisamis to add on the small sized Saku Mountain ward, Sagante ward, Constituency Karare ward, Dakabaricha ward,  Rename the constituency to MARSABIT constituency Dirib-Gombo ward, Jarime ward and Qilta ward of Marsabit County. 4. Proposals related to Laisamis Constituency Proposal 1. Logologo ward, Korr ward, Split of Laisamis constituency: Laisamis ward, South Horr ward, a) Laisamis Constituency- Comprised of Loglogo, Mt. Kulal ward, ward, Laisamis, Merille amd ngurunit; Ngurunit ward and Merille ward of b) Hafare/Loiyangalani constituency- Comprised of Marsabit County. Kargi, Korr, Mt. Kulal, South Horr and Loiyangalani locations.

Proposal 2. Split of Laisamis constituency to: a) Marsabit South constituency- Comprise of Merille, Laisamis, Logologo, Ngurunit ilaut and Lontolio wards b) Marsabit west constituency- Comprise of Korr, Kargi, South horr, Kulal and Loiyangalani, Balah wards

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Marsabit County

(iii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Moyale

It emerged that the population figures used to delineate were unreliable. The means of communication in the region is poor and was not taken into consideration in the first review. Lastly, the population deviation used is too low for a sparsely populated area. b) North Horr

The constituency is the largest in the country in terms of size but has a population of only 75,596. The means of communication should have been considered in the delimitation. It was alleged that IIBRC failed to define sparsely populated, urban areas and cities. And lastly, the use of projected population in determining boundaries was disputed since at the time of the census most people had migrated to Somalia (sic) to look for pasture.

56 c) Laisamis

The expansiveness of the constituency was not taken into consideration. The community of interest was not considered. There were unfair census results that were used to determine the population yet some people were not reached due to poor road network. Lastly, there are insufficient wards in Laisamis and the neighboring constituencies.

4.2.12

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Isiolo North Constituency Isiolo North Constituency Proposal 1. a) It was proposed that Isiolo North should remain Yamicha ward, Malka Galla ward, intact. Korbesa ward, Merti ward, Bulesa b) But should it be divided, it will separate communities ward, Bisano-Biliqo ward, Ngare who have lived in here for a long time and know no Mara ward, Burat ward, Isiolo other place. West ward, Odha ward Wabera ward, Kiwanjani ward, Bula Pesa Proposal 2 ward, Oldonyiro ward and Kipsing ward, of Isiolo County. Isiolo North Constituency be divided into 2; a) Isiolo North or Merti Constituency with its HQ at Merti and to encompass the Shaba Game reserve. The constituency shall comprise of Cherab Merti and Proposed Kom divisions;

b) Isiolo Central Constituency with its HQ in Isiolo town and to comprise of Buffallo-Springs game reserve. The constituency to comprise of Central, East, Oldonyiro divisions and the proposed Ngaremara Divison.

2. Proposals related to Isiolo South Constituency Isiolo South Constituency a) Requested the split of Isiolo South on the basis that Kula Mawe ward, Kinna ward, the Boranas have been marginalised for a long time, Rapsu ward, Malkadaka ward, though the population is not large enough. Garbatulla ward, Garfarsa ward, Madogashe ward, Sericho ward Proposal 2 and Eresaboru ward of Isiolo

57

Split Isiolo south into:- County.

a) Isiolo South (Rename Isiolo South to Garbatulla)and; b) Sericho constituencies.

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Isiolo County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

4.2.13 Meru County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Igembe South Constituency Igembe South Constituency Proposal 1: Kiegoi ward, Maua East ward, Split the constituency into:- Stadium ward, Maua South ward, a) Igembe South and; Giteretu ward, Giteretu-Achenge b) Igembe Central Constituencies. Ward, Igembe South West ward, Igembe South ward and Igembe Kangeta and Kiengu divisions will be the basis for Igembe South East ward of Meru County. Central constituency while the other four divisions-Maua, Kanuni, Akachiu, Athiru Gaiti; will form Igembe south constituency. Igembe Central Constituency Igembe East ward, Maua North Proposal 2: ward, Maili Tatu Ward, Njia ward, Split igembe South into:- Kangeta ward Akirang’ondu ward, a) Igembe South and; Athiru Rujine ward and Kawiru of b) Igembe West Constituencies Meru County.

That igembe west will cover Kangeta and Kiengu divisions; while the proposed Igembe South Constituency will cover; Maua, Kanuni, Akachu, Athiru Gaiti divisions.

2. Proposals related to Igembe North Constituency Igembe North Constituency It was proposed that it should be split to get 2 more Antuambui ward, Ntunenene ward, constituencies or at worst 1. Naathu ward, Antubetwe Kiongo ward, Amuathi II ward and

58

Proposal 1: Amuathi I ward of Meru County. Split igembe North Constituency into a) Laare Constituency and; b) Mutuati constituency

That the proposed Laare constituency will comprise of Laare Division (Akirang‘ondu, Antuambui, Ntunene locations); Ndoleli division (Athiru rujine, Kawiru locations).

Mutuati constituency will comprise of Mutuati Division (Kabachi and Naathu Locations); Ndoleli division (Luciutu, A/Kiongo Locations)

Proposal 2. Split igembe North into:- a) Igembe North and; b) Igembe Central constituencies

That the proposed Igembe North Constituency will be comprised of Kabachi, Naathi, and Luciuti Locations.

That the proposed Igembe Central Constituency will comprise of Akirang‘ondu, Antuambui, Ntunene Athiru Ruujine and Kawiru Locations. 3. Proposals related to Tigania West Constituency a) All the wards should revert to the old wards before Tigania West Constituency the 2002 general election; Kianjai ward, Mituntu ward, Thinyaine-Nchoro ward, Athwana- Rwanda ward, Nkomo ward, Kitheo ward and Mbeu ward of Meru County.

4. Proposals related to Tigania East Constituency a) Create a new consituency on the strength of Tigania East Constituency expansiveness of the constituency and high Muthara Ward, Buuri Ward, population. Karama Ward, Kigucwa Ward, Proposal 1. Ankamia Ward, Mikinduri East Merge Tigania West and Tigania East and curve out an extra Ward, Mikinduri West Ward and constituency Thangatha Ward of Meru County.

Proposal 2.

59

Tigania constituency to be split into: a) Tigania North constituency- Comprise Karama and Tigania North(Muthara) divisions; b) Tigania East constituency – Tigania central and Tigania East divisions

Proposal 3. Tigania East and West boundaries to be adjusted to create:

a) Tigania East constituency- Comprise Buuri, Muthara, Karama, Kigucwa, Ankamia, thangatha, Mikinduri East wards b) Tigania West constituency- Comprise Mikinduri west, Mbeu, Kitheo, Uringu; c) Tigania central constituency- Comprise Mituntu, Kianjai, Akithi, Rwanda/Athwana

5. Proposals related to North Imenti Constituency North Imenti Constituency Proposal 1. Thuura ward, Giaki ward, Nthimbiri Create Part ward, Chugu ward, Ntakira a) That Buuri constituency follows the boundary of Part ward, Nthimbiri Part ward, the newly created Buuri district. Kaaga ward, Ngakurumune ward, Stadium ward, Milimani ward, Proposal 2. Cathedral ward, Central ward, Split North Imenti into:-Imenti North, Buuri East and Commercial ward, Hospital ward Buuri West constituencies. and Mwendatu ward of Meru a) Imenti North constituency will cover Nyaki, Ntima, County. and meru municipality divisions. b) Buuri east will cover naari, Kiirua, ruiri, Rwareera Buuri Constituency divisions and Kibirichia ward, Ntugi ward, Naari c) Buuri west will comprise of Ontulili, Kirimaara, ward, Kiirua ward, Ruiri ward, ngusishi and kisima Divisions. Kirimara ward, Kisima ward and Ontulili wards of Meru County. Proposal 3. Timau, North imenti and Buuri constituency

Proposal 4.

Option 1: Split Imenti North constituency into; a) North Imenti and;

60

b) Ruguru constituencies.

Option 2: Split the constituency into:- a) Ruguru (composed of Buuri East and West Districts) and; b) Gaiti (Comprised of the current North Imenti Constituency.

Proposal 5 Option 1 a) Imenti North, b) Buuri, c) Meru Urban(Municipality) Option 2 a) Buuri b) Imenti North as per present boundary

6. Proposals related to Central Imenti Constituency Central Imenti Constituency It was proposed that since the population was high, it Kiagu ward, Uruku ward, Kithirune should be split. ward, Kibaranyaki ward, Gatimbi ward, Katheri ward, Kariene ward Proposal 1. and Mwangathia ward of Meru Proposed that Imenti central to be split to: County. a) Abothuguchi East Constituency- Comprised Abothuguchi central, Abothuguchi East, Kiagu, Kiija (to be delineated from from current Kiagu division); b) Central Imenti constituency

Proposal 2. a) Abothuguchi East constituency- Former Abothuguchi East division; b) Abothuguchi west constituency- former Abothuguchi west division. Proposal 3. Imenti central to be split to: a) Meru central west constituency and; b) Meru central east constituency

7. Proposals related to South Imenti Constituency South Imenti Constituency Split the Constituency into two as indicated below: Mitunguu ward, Mikumbune ward,

61

a) Nkuene Constituency ( Comprising Nkuene & Igoki ward, Kathera ward, Mweru Mitunguu Divisions); and ward, Karia ward, Kanyakine ward, b) South Imenti Constituency (Abogeta West, Kinoro-Kianjogu ward, Abogeta Abogeta East, Igoji East and Igoji West. ward, Kithangari ward and Igoji ward of Meru County.

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Meru County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

Imenti North. The consultation was not all inclusive. Interested parties were not consulted widely hence moving to wards from central Imenti to the newly created Buuri Constituency. This was against the community‘s wish. Some of the wards are not named correctly.

62

4.2.14 Tharaka Nithi (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Nithi Constiuency Nithi Constituency  Nithi Constituency is the largest Kiang’ondu Ward, Chuka East Ward, Muiru East constituency in Eastern Province as per the Ward, Muiru West Ward, Mugirirwa East Ward, 2007 registered voters with 123,972. Mugirirwa West Ward, Mwoge Ward, Githarene Ward, Thuita Ward, Mukuuni Ward, Kamwinbi Ward, Proposal 1. Kithangani-Mariani Ward and Kajuki Ward of Split the Constituency into two as indicated Tharaka–Nithi County. below: Maara Constiuency 1. Meru South Constituency: Comprising Chogoria Ward, Kiraru Ward, Maara Ward, Kiera of Magumoni, Chuka, Mwonge, Mariani Ward, Ganga Ward, Murugi East Ward, Murugi West and Igambang‘ombe Divisions; Ward, Muthambi Ward, Gitije ward and Mitheru Ward 2. Maara Constituency: Comprising of of Tharaka-Nithi County. Mwimbi, Muthambi, Ganga, Chogoria and Mitheru divisions

Proposal 2. Split the Constituency into five as indicated below:

1. Igambang’ombe constituency: Comprising of Igambangombe Division 2. Chuka Constituency: Comprising of Chuka and Mariani Divisions 3. Magumoni constituency: Comprising of magumoni and Mwonge divisions 4. Muthambi Constituency: Comprising of Muthambi and Mitheru divisions Mwimbi Constituency: Comprising of Mwimbi, Chogoria, Ganga Divisions.

Proposal 3. Split the Constituency into three as indicated below: 1. Igambangombe Constituency: Comprising of Igambangombe 2. Chuka Constituency: comprising of

63

Magumoni, chukka, Mwonge and Mariani Divisions; 3. Maara Constituency: comprising of Mwimbi, Muthambi, Ganga, Chogoria and Mitheru Divisions 2. Proposals related to Tharaka Tharaka Constiuency Constiuency Thiiti Ward, Gikingo Ward, Mwanyani Ward, Nkondi  Proposal tp create three constituencies Ward, Kajoro Ward, Kathangachini Ward, because the people of tharaka are highly Gatwe Ward, Turima Ward, Marimannti Ward, marginalised and oppressed by their Gakurungu Ward,Tungi Ward, Maragwa Ward, Tuyai neighbours. Ward, Chakariga Ward and Kamaragi-Kamanyaki Split to Ward of Tharaka-Nithi County.  North Tharaka constituency - Follow North Tharaka district boundaries; and  South Tharaka constituency – Follow south Tharaka district boundaries

64

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Tharaka Nithi County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

65

4.2.15 Embu County

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Manyatta Constituency  No major proposals Ngandori Ward, Nginda Ward, Ruguru Ward, Gaturi South Ward, Kithimu Ward, Njukiri Ward, Blue Valley Ward, Majengo Ward, Kamiu Ward, Matakari Ward, Kangaru Ward and Itabua Ward of Embu County.

2. Proposals related to Runyenjes Constituency  No major proposals Nthangaiya Ward, Gaturi North Ward, Kagaari North East Ward, Kagaari North West Ward, Runyenjes Central Ward, Kieni North Ward, Kieni Urban Ward, Karurumo-Kigumo Ward of Embu County. 3. Proposals related to Gachoka Constituency Gachoka Constituency  No major proposals Kiambere Ward, Kianjiru Ward, Mavuria Ward, Mbeti South Ward, Karaba Ward, Riakanau Ward and Makima Ward of Embu County. 4. Proposals related to Siakago Constituency Siakago Constituency  No major proposals Ishiara Ward, Kanyuambora Ward, Kiangombe Ward, Ndurumori Ward, Nthawa Ward, Muminji Ward and Gituguri Ward of Embu County.

66

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Embu County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

67

No major emerging issues.

4.2.16 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Mwingi North Constituency Mwingi North Constituency Option 1  Curve a third constituency from Mwingi South and Tseikuru-Musavani Ward, Mwingi North and name it Mwingi Central. Masyungwa Ward, Tharaka Ward, Mivukoni Ward, Kanthungu Ward, Kathe- Mtanda-Nguuku Ward, Ngomeni Ward, Kakuyu- Mkonga Ward, Kimangau Ward, Kyuso-Kamuwongo Ward and Mitamisyi Ward of Kitui County.

Mwingi Central Constituency Waita-Endui Ward, Mwingi-Ithumbi Ward, Enziu-Kivou Ward, Kanzanzu Ward, Nguni Ward, Ukasi Ward, Kyethani-Kyomo Ward, Kavuvwani Ward and Mbuvu Ward of Kitui County. 2. Proposals related to Mwingi South Constituency Mwingi South Constituency  Convert all the 6 districts into constituencies:- Kyuso, Wingemi Ward, Mutyangome Ward, Tseikuru, Mumoni, Mwingi East, Mwingi Central, Mui Ward, Katalwa-Nzeluni Ward, Mwigwani Nuu Ward, Kalitini Ward Kyome Ward, Migwani Ward, Nzauni Ward, Nguutani Ward, Thitani Ward, and of Kitui County.

3. Proposals related to Kitui West Constituency Spilt the constituency into two constituencies:- Kakeani- Ward, Katutu-  Kitui North; and Mutunda Ward, Kivani-Kauwi Ward,  Lower Yatta. Kwa-Mutonga-Kathivo Ward, Kalimani-Matinyani-Mutulu Ward, Kithumula-Kauma Ward and Ward Yatta of Kitui County.

68

Kitui Rural Constituency Itoleka-Katulani Ward, Yatta- Ntonguni Ward, Kanyangi Ward, Kiseuni Ward, Maliku-Itoleka Ward, Kisasi Ward, Ward and Mbusiyani Ward of Kitui County 4. Proposals related to Kitui Central Constituency Kitui Central Constituency Proposed to split into three:- Township Ward, Kyangwithya West  Kitui Central Ward, Mulango Ward, Musengo-  Mulango Usiani Ward, Miambani Ward,  Kisasi Kaveta Ward and Kyangwithya East Ward of Kitui County. 5. Proposals related to Mutito Constituency Mutito Constituency Proposals presented requested for a split to form two Kyanika Ward, Thua-Nzagathi- constituencies:- Ithumula Ward, Sombe Ward,  Nzambani Malalani-Endau Ward, Mwitika-  Mtito Kyamatu Ward, Mutito-Kaliku Ward and Voo Ward of Kitui County. 6. Proposals related to Kitui South Constituency Proposed to split into two:- Ikanga Ward, -Kibwea  Constituency Ward, Mutha-Ndakani Ward,  Mutomo Constituency Maluma-Kalivu Ward, Kyatune Ward, Athi Ward, Kanziku-Simisi Ward, Mathima Ward and Ikutha- Kasala Ward of Kitui County.

69

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kitui County

70

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Kitui South

The area is vast and covers 12.544sq.km with a population of 166,050. The Means of communication are poor and this is characterized by a poor road network due to historical neglect and vastness of the area. Based on the Population Quota, the constituency should be categorized as sparsely populated since the population density is 13 people/sq km. b) Mwingi South The Means of communication are poor in the constituency. Consultations with all interested parties were not adequately done. A new constituency, Mwingi Central was created in the middle of Mwingi South, leaving two portions of Mwingi without a means of communication from the rest. The boundaries need to be redrawn per the residents‘ views.

4.2.17 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Masinga Constituency Masinga Constituency  Requested a new constituency to be curved out of Masinga Ward, Kivaa Ward, Kithyoko Masinga to take care of Ndithini Division. Ward, Kangonde Ward, Ekalakala-  Create Masinga constituency and Ndithini Ikatini Ward, Mananja Ward, Ndithini constituency Ward and Muthesyia Ward of Machakos County. 2. Proposals related to Yatta Constituency  Split Yatta into two due to its expansive nature and thus Ndalani Ward, Kinyaata Ward, bring services closer to the people. Katangi Ward, Ikombe Ward,  Form Yatta Constituency and Katangi Constituency. Mavoloni Ward,Kakuumini-Central Ward, Katulani-Kaluluini Ward, Kithimani Ward, Kithendu Ward, Kyua Ward of Machakos County. 3. Proposals related to Kangundo Constituency  Split Kangundo into 2 due to high population and Kangundo North Ward, Kangundo expansiveness. East Ward and Kangundo West Ward  This should create Kangundo Constituency and of Machakos County. Matungulu Constituency Matungulu North Ward, Matungulu West Ward and Matungulu East Ward of Machakos County. 4. Proposals related to Kathiani Constituency Ward, Mathunya Ward,

71

 To be split into two citing high population growth and Kathiani Ward, Kaewa Ward,Iveti influx of land buyers from neighbouring Nairobi. The Ward and Kaani Ward of Machakos boundary can be the Komarocks road. County.

 Create Kathiani and Constituency. Mavoko Constituency Athi River North Ward, Katani Ward, Industrial-Station Ward, Makadara Ward, Sophia-Kenya Meat Ward, Kinanie-Mathatani Ward and Muthwani Ward of Machakos County. 5. Proposals related to Machakos Town Constituency Machakos Town Constituency Option 1 Kalama-Kiyangala Ward,Muumandu-  Split into two with the boundary being Mwania River up Kola Ward, Ngelani Ward, Kimutwa to Kyanzaasu to the East and Kapiti ranch along the Ward, Kiima-Kimwe Ward, Mutituni railwayline to the west to form Machakos and Kalama Ward, Mua Ward, Mumbuni North Constituency Ward,Muumbuni South Ward, Option 2 Katheka Kai Ward, Mjini Ward,  Split into two to form Machakos Town South and Eastleigh Ward and Muvuti Ward of Machakos Town north Constituencies. Machakos County.

6. Proposals related to Mwala Constituency Mwala Constituency  Mwala may not qualify to be split and can wait for the Mbiuni Ward, Mwala Ward, next review. The residents of Mwala however stated that Ward, Vyulya Ward, Muthetheni they do not want any part of Mwala to be taken to any Ward, Wamunyu Ward, Kibauni other constituency. Ward, Makutano-Mango Ward,  Alternatively, if it split, then form Mwala Constituency Kathama Ward, Miu Ward, Yathui and Yathui Constituency Ward and Ikalaasa Ward of Machakos County.

72

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Machakos County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major issues emerged from the IIBRC Report and recommendations.

4.2.18 Makueni County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Mbooni Constituency  Split Mbooni constituency to: Tulimani Ward, Kyuu-Nzeveni o Mbooni east- Comprise Kisau , Kalawa division and Ward, Kithungo-Kitundu Ward proposed Kako location; ,Kako Ward, Kiteta Ward, Waia o Mbooni west- Mbooni and Tulimani divisions. Ward,-Uthiuni Ward,Kalawani Ward of Makueni County. 2. Proposals related to Kilome Constituency  It was proposed that that it remains as it is now Kasikeu-Mumela Ward, Mukaa Ward, Kalanzoni-Kiima Kiu Ward,

73

Kiou Ward and Kitaingo Ward of Makueni County. 3. Proposals related to Kaiti Constituency That, the constituency to be split into two constituencies Kithembe Ward, Ukia-Iuani Ward, namely: Watema-Kee-Kivani Ward,  Kilungu constituency to cover Kithembe, Kilungu Kaumoni Ward, Kikoko Ward and And Ilima divisions; Kilungu-Ilima Ward of Makueni  Kaiti constituency to cover Kaiti, Kee, And County. Mumbuni divisions

4. Proposals related to Makueni Constituency The constituency to be split into three constituencies namely: Mavindini Ward, Wote Ward, Muvau 1. Makueni constituency will cover the lower region Ward, Kathonzweni Ward Kikumini comprising of kathonzweni district and wote division and Ward, Kanthuni-Kithuki Ward, will cover the following wards wote, kikumini, muvau, Mbuvo-Kitise Ward and Nziu Ward nziu and the proposed Mumbuni, mwaani, kambi mawe of Makueni County. wards; 2. Nzauni constituency which will cover the upper region comprising of the current nzaui district and will cover the following wards mbitini, mulala, kalamba, kilili, nguu and the proposed Wolwa, kyemundu, email, nzaui, ikangavya wards; 3. Manguu constituency which will constitute division of and nguu division of makueni constituency and its centre will be in makindu town. 5. Proposals related to Kibwezi Constituency Kibwezi West Constituency Option 1 Twaandu-Kiboko Ward, Kithumba- The constituency to be split into two constituencies namely: Kalamba ward, Makindu Ward,  Makindu constituency will constitute makindu Nguu Ward, Nguumo Ward, Mbitini district with makindu, nguumo, muuni and kavete Ward, Nzaui-Kilili Ward, Mulala- divisions Emali Ward, and Masumba Ward of  Kibwezi constituency will constitute kibwezi district Makueni County. with kibwezi, machinery and mtito andei divisions; Nb: the boundary should follow the current administrative Kibwezi East Constituency units‘ boundaries between the two districts Masongaleni Ward, Mtito Andei East

Ward, Mtito Andei Ward, Kinyambu Option 2 Ward Kikumbulyu South Ward, The constituency to be split into three constituencies namely: Kikumbulyu North Ward, Mtito  Kibwezi west constituency to cover the old Andei West Ward, Ivingoni- makindu, kikumbulyu, and kinyambu areas;

74

 Kibwezi east constituency to cover masongaleni, Mang‟elete Ward, Kambu Ward, utithi and mtito andei areas; Kathekani-Darajani Ward and  Manguu constituency which will constitute makindu Kinyambu Ward of Makueni County. division of kibwezi and nguu division of makueni

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Makueni County

75

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Makueni Constituency. It emerged that Community of interest, Historical, Economical and cultural ties were not considered in dealing with Makueni Constituency proposals. The proposed boundaries for kibwezi West Constituency and the shifting of Nzauni District to Kibwezi Constituency were created against community wishes and will likely cause disharmony. The National Population Quota was not as used since Makueni with a population of 224,613 and an area of 1,571.90 sq.km, it was not split while other areas with less people were split.

4.2.19 Nyandarua County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Kinagop Constituency  Proposals were made was to split the constituency into Muraki Gathara Ward, Tulaga-Kamun two to create: yaka Ward, Njabini Ward, Nyakio i). South Kinangop (with 6wards) ward, magumu Ward and Nyandarua ii). North Kinangop (with 5wards) County.  The boundary should be along the escarpment

2. Proposals Related to Kipiriri Constituency Wanjohi Ward, Kipiriri Ward, No proposals were made. Lereshwa Ward, Geta Ward,Malewa Ward, Kitiri-Kinja Ward, Mikaro- Nandarasi-Mkungi Ward and Murungaru Ward.

3. Proposals Related to Ol Kalau Constituency Ol Kalau Constituency Ol kalau Ward, Kaimbaga Ward,  Two proposals were put forward: Gichungo Ward,and ol Kalau Central Ward. i). That the three operational districts of

Nyandarua West (Chamuka), Nyandarua

Central and Milangine to be made

constituencies. Ol-Jorok Constituency ii). To split Olkalau into two, namely Kanjuiri Ridge Ward, Matindiri Ward, Ward, Ol Jorok Ward, Weru a. Ol-Kalau Constituency (Comprising Ward,Gatimu Ward and Gathanji Dundori, Matindiri, Kanjuiri ridge, Munyeki, Ward of Nyandarua County. Kiambogo and Gichugo wards); and

b. Ol-Jorok Constituency (Comprising of

76

Gatimu, Gathanji, Weru, Ol-Jorok, Rurii and Central wards)

 On the wards the proposal was to make all locations wards. 4. Proposals Related to Ndaragwa Constituency Rurii Ward, Shamata Ward, Ndaragwa  Split Ndaragwa into two as follows: Ward, Leshau Pondo Ward and Kiriita Ward. i). Shamata Constituency :comprising of Shamata, Kanyagia Locations and iriani, Mairokuni, Simbara, Pesi and Kihara Sub-locations); and

ii). Ndaragwa Constituency: comprising Kahutha, Kirigo, Leshau, kiriita and Mathingira Locations.

 The boundary between Kipipiri and Ndaragwa Constituencies remain Malewa River.

 On the wards, it was suggested that:

i). More wards to be created to include Karandi, Mathingira, Kiriogo and Kanyagia ward.

Ewaso-Narok East ward be transferred to Ndaragwa constituency.

77

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Nyandarua County

78

(ii) Emerging Issues (According to the JLA Report)

a) Kinagop Residents felt their presentations were ignored by IIBRC. Further, Historical ties were not considered since half of the constituency was moved to Kipipiri Constituency. , Geographical feature not put into consideration in the first review. Some areas are in Naivasha although it gets services from Kinangop.

b) Ndaragwa

The Formula used was not proper since Ndaragwa has a similar population with other constituencies such as Kipipiri but it was not given a constituency.

4.2.20 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Nyeri Town Constituency Three proposals were made for the delimitation of Nyeri Town Chania Ward, Gatito Ward, Karia Constituency. Ward, Kamakwa Ward, Muruguru Proposal 1. Ward, Nyaribo Ward, Kiganjo  To split Nyeri Town Constituency into Nyeri Central Ward, Kirichu Ward, Mukaro Ward, Constituency to have the following wards: Central, Mathari-Kihuyo Ward and Nyeri Chania, Gatitu, Karia/Giachamwenge, Kamakwa, and Central Ward. Mukaro wards; and

 Nyeri North Constituency comprising Mathari ward, Nyaribo ward, Kiganjo, Kirichu, Muruguru wards.

Proposal 2.  Split Nyeri Town Constituency into: (i) Lower Nyeri Municipality; and (ii) Upper Nyeri Municipality

Proposal 3.  Split Nyeri Town Constituency into: (i) Nyeri East Constituency, (ii) Nyeri West Constituency; and (iii) Nyeri Central Constituency. 2. Proposals Related to Othaya Constituency Nyamari Ward, Kanyange Ward,

79

 Split the constituency into two as follows: Kianganda Ward, Karima i). Othaya North :comprising Iria-ini, Mumwe and Ward,Chinga Ward, Mahiga Ward, mahiga Locations; and Nduie River Ward,Thuti Ward, Mumwe Ward, Rutune ward, karima ii). Othaya South : comprising Karima, Chinga North Ward and Irainin(Part) Ward. and Chinga South locations.  On the wards, the following suggestion were forwarded: subdivide the County Council wards into two each as follows:Mahiga (Mahiga East &West), Mumwe (Mumwe East &West), Karima (Karima South & North), Iria-ini (Iria-ini North & South) Chinga (Chinga North &South)

3. Proposals Related to Mukurweini Constituency Gakindu Ward, Muhito Ward, Githi  No proposals were made. Ward, Gikondi Ward, Giathugu Ward, Rutune Ward and Thanu Ward. 4. Proposals Related to Mathira Constituency  The Constituency to be split into two; Residential Ward, Commercial i. Mathira East Constituency comprising of Gatei, Ward, Market Ward, Stadium Ward, Gitunduti, Gikumo, Gathehu/Ragati Railway Ward, Hospital ward, Kaguyu/Thegenge/Kiaguthu/Gatundu, Konyu Ward, Iria-ini West( Mathira) Kiamwangi/Chehe/Kairia/Baricho/Mukore/Gachuku, ward, Ngorano Ward, Kirimukuyu Karindundu/Gakuyu, Karatina; Ward, Ruguru Ward, Ngandu Ward, ii. Mathira West Constituency comprising of the Ichuga Ward, Magutu Ward, and following wards: Ngorano, Iruri/Sagana, Iria-ini East (Mathira ). Kiamwangi/Ruturu, Ichuga/Itiati,Thaithi, Ngaini, Mutathiini, Kiria, Mbogoini/Thiu, Ngandu/Gachuiro 5. Proposals Related to Tetu Constituency  To split into 3 as follows: Tetu East Constituency, Tetu Aguthi Ward, Tetu Ward, Muhoya West Constituency and Tetu Central Constituency. Ward, Gaaki Ward, Karundu ward and Thigingi Ward.

6. Proposals Related to Kieni Constituency  The proposal put forward for Kieni East is to split it into Gakwa Ward, Naromoru Ward, two constituencies. Kieni East Constituency and Kieni Kiamathaga Ward, Kabaru Ward, West following the district boundaries.

80

(iv) IIBRC Proposed Map for Nyeri County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Kieni The Geographical features were not considered in the first review by IIBRC.

81

4.2.21 Kirinyaga County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals Related to Kutus South Ward, Thiba Ward,  Two proposals were made pertaining to Mwea. Tebere Ward, Nyangati Ward, Murinduko Ward, Nguka Ward, i). Mwea constituency to be split into two constituencies Gathigiriri Ward and Kangai Ward. namely Mwea East Constituency and Mwea West constituency ii). Mwea constituency to be split into three

constituencies.

i. Constituency 1: comprising of Mutithi Kangai and Thiba locations; ii. Constituency 2: comprising of Tebete location; iii. Constituency 3: comprising of Murinduko location 2. Proposals Related to Gichugu Constituency  Two proposals were made: Ngariama Ward, Kirima Ward, Kabere Ward, Baragwi Ward, Proposal 1. Karumandi Ward, Njuki-ini Ward and a) Gichugu Constituency to be split into two. Gichugu Kutus Central. West Constituency- Comprising of the whole of Kabare plus Kiaruri, Guama, Thimu and Gatu Location; and

b) Gichugu East Constituency - Comprising of the wholeof the old Ngariama plus Thumita, Kariru, Raimu and Rwambiti locations.

Proposal 2. Split and create the following:-

o Kirinyaga East Upper Constituency- Comprising of Kirima, Karumandi and Ngariama; and

82

o Kirinyaga East Lower Constituency- comprising of Kabare, Baragwi and Njuki-ini locations 3. Proposals Related to Ndia Constituency  It was proposed that the constituency be split into two Mutithi Ward, Gacharu Ward,Karima constituencies namely: Ward, Kathaka Ward, Kariti Ward, Mukure Ward, Kinyaga Ward, i). Ndia East Constituency to constitute Mwerua, Mwerua Ward and Kiine Ward. Kagio, Mukure and Giaconge locations; and

ii). Ndia West Constituency to constitute Kariti, Kiangai, Kiini, Sagana, and Thigirichi locations.

 It was also proposed that all operational locations to be converted into electoral wards

83

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Krirnyaga County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issue.

84

It is proposed that the recommendations of IIBRC Report be upheld.

4.2.22 Murang’a County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kangema Constituency Kanyenyaini Ward, Iyego Ward,  No proposals were submitted. Gakira Ward, Watuha Ward, Gacharaigu Ward, Muringaini Ward,

Kiairathe Ward, Rwathia Ward, Kihoyia Ward, Kiruri Ward, Ngathaithi Ward and Murarandia Ward.

2. Proposals related to Mathioya Constituency

 No proposals were submitted concerning constituencies. Njumbi Ward, Kiria-ini Ward, Kiru Ward, Karung‘e Ward, Gitugi Ward,  It was however proposed that Karunge ward In Karunge Gaturi Ward, Kamacharia Ward and location and split Njumbi Ward into -Njumbi and Locations of . Nyuro Wards

3. Proposals related to Kiharu Constituency Kimathi Ward, Gikindu Ward, a) Four proposals were submitted; Hospital Ward, Mumbi Ward, Central Ward, Mukuyu Ward,

i). It was propsed that Kiharu Constituency be split into Njouini Ward, Maragi Ward, Mbiri three constituencies namely: Rural Ward, Mirichu Ward,

a. Kahuro Constituency to comprise of Gatundu Ward, Kahuhia Ward and Muranda Division; Githamba, Theri, Weithaga Ward. Gathaithi, Kaganda, Gatuya Locations; Mugoiri Division; Mirichu, Kiria, Gatundu, Kahuro locations.

b. Kiharu Constituency to comprise of Weithaga Division; Kahuti, Wanjengi, Gatheru, Kahuhia; Kiharu Division: Township, Njoguini, Mbiri Locations.

c. Gaturi Constituency to comprise of Gaturi

85

division which comprises of Nyakihai, Gathukeini, and Mugeka Locations; Kimathi division covering Gikindu, Kigetuini and Kimathi locations. ii). The Constituency to be split into four constituencies namely Kahuro, Wangu, Gaturi, Kiharu. Boundaries were not proposed. iii). To split the Kiharu constituency into Kahuro Constituency to follow the current Kahuro Divisional boundary and Kiharu Constituency to follow the present Kiharu Divisional Boundary.

4. To create two constituencies (Kahuro Constituency - covering Gathaithi, Gatundu, Mirichu and Gatuya Locations- and Wangu Constituency covering Weithaga, Kahuhia, Upper Murarandia Locations) from Kahuro division and a further, 2 constituencies (Gaturi constituency comprising of Gaturi, Kimathi, Gikindu Locations and Kiharu constituency to cover Murang‘a municipality and Mbiri Location.) from Kiharu division.

5. Proposals related to Kigumo Constituency b) Kigumo constituency was proposed to be split into two Kinyona Ward, Kibage Ward, constituencies. Muthiti Ward, Kigumo East Ward, i). Kigumo Constituency to comprise of Kangari, Kangare Ward, Kahumbu Ward and Kinyona, Kigumo, Makuyu location ;and Kigumo West.

ii). Makuyu Constituency to comprise of Maragua Ridge Location, Kambiti Location, Makuyu Location, Kagunduini Location, Gaichanjiru Location

6. Proposals related to Maragwa Constituency Maragwa Constituency c) A proposal was made to split Maragwa into two Mbugua Ward, Makuyu Ward, constituencies; Ichagaki Ward, Kirimiri Ward, i). Makuyu Constituency to consist of Kambiti, Samar Ward, Kabiti Ward, Maragwa Kirimiri, Wempa, Karimawaro, Kagunduini, Ridge Ward, Nginda Ward, Mwuka, East and Makuyu, and Gaichanjiru wards Kamahuha-Maranjau Ward and Wempa Ward.

ii). Murang’a South Constituency to consist of Kamahuha, Maragwa, Ridge Mbugwa, Samar

86

Gakoigo, Icagak and Nginda wards. d) The other proposal with regard to existing wards was to have Nginda, Makuyu, Kamahuha, and Murang‘a town split into two more wards and Kamahuha/Maranjau ward split into Sabasaba and Kamahuha Wards

7. Proposals related to Kandara Constituency Two proposals were forwarded:- Kaguthi-Githuia Ward, gatundu- Proposal 1. Kiiri-Kandara Ward, Kagunduini i). To split Kandara constituency into two constituencies West Ward, Kagunduini East Ward, that is Kandara South Constituency (Covering Gaichanjiru Ward, Githumo Ward, ithiru East, Ithiru west, Ithiru South, Gacharage, Ngararia Ward, Muruka Ward, Ngararia, Naroo, Kiraga & Githumu) and Kandara Gakui-Karimamwaro Ward and North Constituency (Covering kagungu-ini East, Gathugu-Ruchu-Gakarara Ward. Kagunduini West, Gaichanjiru, Nguruwe-ini, Muruka, Kibaage, Kariua, Gichagi-ini & Gituru)

ii). To make all the current divisions of Gaichanjiru, Ithiru and Ruchu Constituencies. 8. Proposals Related to Gatanga Constituency Gatanga Constituency Kariara Ward, Kihumbuini e) There were no proposals submitted for Gatanga Ward,Gatanga Ward, Kigoro Ward, Constituency. Samuru Ward, Mitubiri Ward, Kakuzi Ward, Kiriaini Ward, Mukarara ward and Mugomuini Ward.

87

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Murang’a County

(iii) Emerging Issues a) Kiharu It was alleged that the IBBRC failed to take account of the population, communication and geographical features. Secondly, two wards were transferred to Kagema, which is a protected constituency. The division of the wards weakened Kiharu‘s economic stability and broke cultural ties. A tea factory has been moved to another constituency. The Population quota used for rural areas was not suitable and should have been used for urban areas only. The community was not consulted in moving Muraranda and Gaturi to Mathioya Constituency.

88

4.2.23 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Gatundu South Gatundu South Constituency Mundoro Ward, Ngenda South  It was proposed that Gatundu south be split into two Ward, Ngenda North Ward, constituencies:- Kiganjo ward, Kiamwangi ward and Ndarugu Ward . i). Gatundu South Constituency that will comprise of

Kiamwangi, Ngenda, Kiganjo division and parts of Division ii). Gatundu Central Constituency to comprise of Kiganjo, Ndarugu, Ngenda Divisions and parts of Juja division  It was also proposed that the following Wards be created: Rwabura and Munyuini from Ndarugo; Kimunyu from Ng‘enda South Mutati; Gathage from Kiamwangi; Kiamworia and Gatitu from Mundoro and Kiganjo ward

2. Proposals related to Gatundu North Gatundu North Constituency There were two proposals relating to Gatundu North. Mangu Ward, Ward, Makwa Proposal 1. Ward, Gathaite Ward, kamwangi Split Gatundu North Constituency into: ward, Gituamba ward and i. Chania Constituency, Githobokoni Ward. ii. Mang‘u Constituency, iii. Githobokoni Constituency and

Creation of: Gikoe ward and Githobokoni ward. Proposal 2.

Split Gatundu North Constituency into:-  Gatundu West Constituency to cover the Tea Zones; and  Gatundu East Constituency to cover the Coffee zones. 3. Proposals related to Juja Constituency There was a proposal to split Juja into: Murera Ward, Gitothua Ward, Kalimoni Ward and Juja Ward. i). Githurai Constituency: covering Kahawa Sukari and Githurai Wards. Thika Town Constituency Gatuanyaga Ward, Kiganda Ward, ii). Ruiru Constituency: covering Gitothua, Commercial Makongeni Ward, Kamenu Ward,

89

and Murera wards and proposed Gikumari Division. Ndururumo Ward, Mugumoini Ward, Majengo Ward, Market Ward, Hospital Ward and Biashara Ward of Kiambu County.

Ruiru Constituency Kahawa Sukari Ward, Githurai Kimbo Ward and Gatongora Ward of Kiambu County. 4. Proposals related to Githunguri Constituency  It was proposed that Githunguri constituency be split Githunguri Ward, Ikinu Ward, into two Constituencies: Komathai Ward, Githiga Ward, i). Githunguri West Constituency and Ngewa ward, Kiratina Ward,and Kanjai-Kiairia Ward. ii). Githunguri East Constituency comprising of Lower Lari, Karatina and Kamotoi Division.

 It was also proposed that the following be split: i). Githiga ward into Gathangari and Githiga wards; ii). Ikinu ward into Ikinu and Riuki wards; iii). Kiratina ward into Kiratina, Gathagu and Kibichai Wards; iv). Ngewa ward into Nyaga and Kiri wards.

5. Proposals related to Kiambaa Constituency Cianda Ward, Kanunga Ward,  It was proposed that Kiambaa Constituencies be split Muchata Ward, Ndenderu Ward, into three constituencies as namely Kiambu Kihara Ward and Kiambaa Ward. Constituency, Kihara Constituency and Kiambaa Constituency and that the boundaries of the above Kaimbu Constituency should follow the current divisional Boundaries; Riabai Ward, Township Ward, Ting,ang,a Ward, Technology Ward,  It was also proposed to merge Kiambu Municipal Ndumberi Ward, Kihongo Ward council, Karurri Town Council, and Ting‘ang‘a & and Kanunga Ward of Kiambu Cianda Wards to form Kiambu Municipality County.

6. Proposals related to Kabete Constituency It was proposed that Kikuyu Constituency be split into two to Kabete Ward, Muguga Ward and be referred to as: Nyathuna Ward of Kiambu County. i). Kabete Constituency :Covering Muguga, Kabete,

90

Nyathuna and parts of Kinoo Divisions [Kinoo &Uthiru]) Kikuyu Constituency ;and Kinoo Ward, Karai Ward, Nachu Ward and Kikuyu Ward of Kiambu ii). Kikuyu Constituency: Covering parts of Kinoo, County. Kikuyu and Karai division. The boundary between the two constituencies to be the great North road.

7. Proposals related to Limuru Constituency Bibirioni Ward, Kamirithu Ward,  It was proposed that Limuru Constituency be Limuru Central Ward, Limuru East split into two namely Limuru Ndeiya Ward, Ngecha Ward, Ndeiya Ward, Constituency and Limuru Constituency. Thigino Ward and Tigoni Ward.

 Retention of the existing wards were proposed, Thigio, Ndeiya, and Kiriri Wards.  Split Limuru into, Gecha, Limuru and Ndeiya wards. 8. Proposals related to Lari Constituency There were two proposals. Lari Ward, Kijabe Ward, Kirenga i). Lari constituency to be split into Lari Upper Ward, Gatamayu Ward, Namayu Consituency and Lari Lower. The boundary to be along Ward and Kinale Ward. Komothai River to the East of Gatamayu division, Ruiru River to the West, Kiambururu to the south and Gekohi in Kerita division. ii). To curve Gatamaiyu constituency from existing Githunguri Constituency and Lari Constituencies to consist of:

 From Lari Constituency; Nyanduma location, Gatamaiyu location, Kamburu location

 From Githunguri Constituency; Komothai location and Kirathina location

91

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kiambu County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major issues raised as concerns the recommendations in the IIBRC Report.

92

4.2.24 Turkana County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Turkana North Constituency Turkana North Constituency Several Proposals were given:- Lokitang Ward, Karebur Proposal 1: Ward,Ngissiger Ward, Riakomor 1. The constituency be divided into four parts:- Karach Ward, Kaeris Ward, Kataboi Ward, Constituency – that will comprise Polopoi Division Kibish Ward, Naita Ward, Meyan and Kakuma Divisions; Ward,Kaikor Ward, Kokuro Ward, Loruth Esokon Ward, Yapakuno 2. Lokichoggio Constituency – that will comprise of Ward and Pelekech /Nakalate Lokichoggio and Nanam divisions Ward (Part) of Turkana County.

Proposal 2: The Divisions to be merged to make five constituencies:- Turkana West Constituency 1. Constituency: - Lokichoggio/Nanan Nakalale-Pelekech (Part) Ward, divisions; Kakuma Ward, Loreng Ward, 2. Kakuma Constituency: - Orupoi/Kakuma divisions. Oroboi Ward, Kalobeyei Ward, 3. Lokitaung’ Constituency:- Kataboi/Lokitaung Songot Ward, Lokichoggio Ward, divisions; Loteteleit Ward, Nanaam-Mogila 4. Kaler Constituency: Kaleng/Lapur divisions; and Ward and Lorau Ward of Turkana 5. Kibich Constituency: Kibish/Kaikor divisions. County.

Proposal 3: The People with disability proposed:- 1. Kakuma Oropoi Constituency; 2. Lokichoggio/Ng’ang Constituency stretching from Lokichoggio up to a place called Kaleng; and 3. Constituency stretching from Kataboi up to Kibish

2. Proposals related to Turkana Central Constituency Turkana Central Constituency  The public proposed five constituencies namely Kalakol, Kang'irisae Ward, Kerio Ward, Town, Turkwell, Loima and Ekerio constituencies; Nakwanga Ward, Napetet Ward, Napuu Ward, Kenyatta Ward,  Proposed formartion of the following wards:- Kangirise; Kanamkemer Ward, Kang‟atotha Nakoret; Kerio; Nakurio; Langatosa; Lomapus; Namukse; Ward, Kalokol Ward, Kapua- Kalokol; Kapua; Nakwele; Ekurot; Lomeyian; Napeling; Namadak Ward, Kawalathe Ward Kapus; Nadapal; and Napeikar; Turkwel; Lorugum; and of Turkana County. Kotaruk; Lokitotota; Rangany; Kalemunyang; Lobei;

93

Loyima; Push; Lokiriama; Urum; Loruinkipi; and Loima Constituency Kahemanik. Lomeyan Ward, Loima Ward, Nadapal Ward, Turkwel Ward, Lokiriama Ward, Lobei Ward, Lorengippi Ward and Kotaruk Ward of Turkana County. 3. Proposals related with Turkana South Constituency  Proposed that Turkana south be divided into 3 Turkana South Constituency constituencies based on the existing divisions; Lokichar Ward, Kalapata Ward, 1) Turkana South Constituency should have the Katilu Ward, Kaputir Ward and following divisions:- Lobokat Ward of Turkana County. i) Lokichar Division which has two locations and four sub-locations and also Kapese Location; ii) Proposed Kalapata Division which will have three locations namely Kalapata, Akipur and Nakale locations; iii) Proposing Locha to be a division with Locha, Aspurur and Lochariamois locations.

2) Turkana East Constituency will have: i) Lochagulo Division with Acheder and Lothii locations Turkana East Constituency with eight sub-locations, two for each; Katilia Ward, Kochodin Ward, ii) Lokor Division should have Lokor, Lotuba and Gangtit Lokori Ward, Napeitom Ward and locations. There are six sub-locations; Kapedo Ward of Turkana County. iii) In Kapila Division, to have Kapila, Aparkat and Loriu locations. Each will have two sub-locations; iv) Lonelo Division with Lonelo, Apar and Domelo locations with six sub-locations. Each location will have two sub-locations; and v) Nataiton Division is the last one with Nataiton, Kamuge, Nyuluka locations, each with two sub- locations.  Turkana East Constituency should have 15 civic wards. Out of this, five Wards already exist and ten additional wards proposed.  It should also have five divisions out of which two exist. It should have 15 locations, out of which nine exist. It should also have 31 sub-locations, out of which 21 exist.

(3) Turkwel Constituency to have three divisions. That is i) Katilu Division with Katilu, Almung‘oroko,

94

Nakabasang and Lokafai locations. Each of them should have two sublocations; ii) Kainuk Division which should have Kainuk and Lorokor and Kakong Location. All those three locations will have two sub-locations each; iii) Nakwamoru Division: Nakwamoru, Kalamweya and Kaptir locations. Each of this will have two sub- locations

95

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Turkana County

96

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Turukana Central The Population Quota used was not proper. Based on the population in the area and the entire Turkana County, Turkana Central deserved 5 additional constituencies to ensure adequate representation.

5.3.25 West Pokot County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kapenguria Constituency Endugh Ward, Ptoyo Ward, Nakwijit Ward, Proposal 1. Miskwony Ward, Tamugh Ward, Sook Split it to create Kapenguria and Pokot South Ward, Chekomos Ward, Chepkopegh Ward, constituencies Riwo Ward, Kanyarkwat Ward, Senetwo Ward, Kapenguria Ward, Kapenguria North Proposal 2. Ward, Keringet-Psigirio Ward, Talau Ward, Split to create Kapenguria and LeLan constituencies Keringet Ward, Chemwochoi Ward, Kisiaunet Ward and,Kaibos Ward of West Proposal 3 Pokot County. Split it to create Kapenguria and Sengwer constituencies Pokot South Constituency Lelan Ward, Tapach Ward, Kaptabuk Ward, Ywalateke Ward, Siyoi Ward, Parua Ward, Kapyogen Ward, Kopro ward, Sodany ward, Kapchemongen Ward and Chepareria- Kosulol Ward of West Pokot County.

2. Proposals related to Sigor Constituency Proposed Pokot South Constituency to be crated. Porkoyu Ward, Masol Ward, Sekerr Ward, Wei-wei Ward, Lomut Ward, Sekerot Ward, Batei Ward, Cheptulel Ward, Mwino Ward and of West Pokot County. 3. Proposals related to Kacheliba Constituency Proposed to spilt it and create Pokot North Akoret Ward, Chemorongit Ward, Constituency Lokitanyala Ward, Kalapata Ward, Kases Ward, Kiwawa Ward, Kasei Ward, Lopet Ward, Kapchok Ward, Kodich Ward and Suam Ward of West Pokot County.

97

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for West Pokot County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Sigor The issue of Community of interest was not observed.

98

b) Kapeguria Two wards, Kanyarkwat and Chemochoi, were wrongly taken to the new Pokot South constituency.

5.3.26 Samburu County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Samburu West Constituency Samburu West Constituency El-Barta Ward, Nyiro East Ward, Nyiro c) Proposal create one more constituency to be named West Ward, Nyiro South Ward, Samburu North Ward, Nachola Ward and Ndoto Ward of Samburu County.

Samburu North Constituency Amaiya Ward, Baawa Ward, Ng’ari Ward, Lkorroto Ward, Milimani Ward, Biashara Ward, Shabaa Ward, Suguta Marmar Ward, Lpartuk Ward, Marti Ward, Kawap Ward, Arsim Ward, Lodokojek Ward, Latakweny Ward, Poro Ward, Loosuk Ward, Opiroi Ward, Angata Nanyokie Ward, Barsaloi Ward and Kisima Ward of Samburu County. 2. Proposals related to Samburu East Constituency Samburu East Constituency d) No proposal was presented. Ngilai West Ward, Ngare Narok Ward, Wamba Ward, Ngaroni Ward, Lodungokwe Ward, Nairimirimo Ward, Waso West Ward, Waso East Ward and Sere-Olipi Ward of Samburu County.

99

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Samburu County

100

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

5.3.27 Trans Nzoia County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Saboti Constituency  Two constituencies proposed to be created: 1. Central Constitueny which is to comprise Kisawai Ward, Kinyoro Ward, Central Division and Waitaluk division with a Matisi Ward, Kipsongo population of 201,322; Ward,Saboti Ward, Machewa 2. Kitale West Constituency to comprise Saboti, Ward, Nabiswa Ward, Sikhendu Kiminini/Kinyoro and Central Divisions with 183, 000 Ward, Mumia Ward and Tuwani people. Ward and Sokoni Ward of Trans-  Another proposal was to divide the constituency into 3 Nzoia County. constituencies:- 1. Kitale Town Constituency (the old central division); Kiminini Constituency 2. Kitale Central Constituency (Kiminini Division and the newly established Kinyoro which includes Kisawai); Kimini Ward, Sirende Ward, 3. Kitale West Constituency to include Sikhendu, Waitaluk Ward, Milimani Ward, Machewa, Saboti na Timboroa divisions. Kibomet Ward, Lessos Ward,  Proposal 3: the constituency to be divided into: Webuye Ward, Hospital Ward, 1. Kimini Constituency – To comprise Kiminini Sokoni Ward and Masaba Ward of Division, Waitaluk Division and part of the Central Trans-Nzoia County. Division which is Kibomet Location (With an area of 391.3 sq km) Endebese Constituency 2. Saboti Constituency - Saboti Division, Kinyoro Endebess Ward, Matumbei Ward, Division and part of Central Division which is the Chepchoina Ward, Kaptega Ward Municipality Location. (With an area of 350.2 sq); and Mumberes Ward of Trans- Nzoia County. 2. Proposals related to Cherangany Constituency  It was proposed that the Constituency remains as it is; Makutano Ward, Sitatunga Ward,  Following wards were proposed:- Cherangany Ward; Kaplamai Ward, Motosiet Ward, Suwerwa Ward; Geta Ward; Milimani Ward; Chepsiro Cherangani-Suwerwa Ward, Ward; Motosit Ward; Kaplamai Ward; Konyek Ward; Kiptoror Ward and Chepsiro Ward Mukuyu Ward; Sitatunga Ward; Sinyereri Ward; Michai of Trans-Nzoia County. Ward and Makutano 3. Proposals related to Kwanza Constituency

101

 Proposal 1: Kapkoi Ward, Keiyo Ward, Kwanza Constituency should remain as it is; Kapomboi Ward, Kwanza Ward, Kaisagat Ward, Kapsitwet Ward  Proposal 2: and Sinyerere Ward of Trans- The constituency to be divided into two: Nzoia County. 1. Entebess Constituency 2. Kwanza Constituency

102

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Trans Nzoia County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues in Trans Nzoia County.

103

5.3.28 Uasin Gishu County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Eldoret North Constituency Soy Constituency Soy Ward, Kipsomba Ward, Koisagat It was proposed that the following constituencies be Ward, Ziwa Ward, Moi’s Bridge North created out of the current Eldoret North: Ward , Moi’s Bridge South Ward, 1. Soy/Moi‘s bridge Stadium-Industrial Ward, Kidiwa- 2. Turbo/sosiani Kipsuswa Ward, Kiplombe (Kuinet 3. Sirikwa Sublocations) Ward (Part) and Eldoret North Ward of Uasin Gishu County.

Turbo Constituency Ngenyilel Ward, Tapsagoi Ward, Sugoi Ward,Kamagut Ward, Kamukunji Ward, Kapyemit Ward, Shauri Yako Ward and Kiplombe (Kiplombe and Kilimani sublocations) Ward (Part) of Uasin Gishu County. 2. Proposals related to Eldoret East Constituency Moiben Constituency Moibeki Ward, Moiben Ward, Karuna  Split the constituency into two and rename them as Ward, Sergoit Ward, Tembelio Ward, indicated below: Kimumu-Sergoit Ward, (i) Moiben Constituency; and Hospital (Sigot Sublocation) Ward (Part), (ii) Ainabokoi Constituency. Market Ward and Kapyeimet Ward (Part) of Uasin Gishu County.

Ainabkoi Constituency Chemng‟oror Ward, Kipkabus Ward, Kaptagat Ward, Kapsoya Ward, Olare Ward and Ainabkoi Ward of Uasin Gishu County. 3. Proposals related to Eldoret South Constituency Kapseret Constituency Kipkenyo Ward, Langas Ward, Ngeria  Proposed for the creation of Eldoret South and Ward, Race Course Ward, Simat-Kapsaret Wareng. Ward, Kipchamo Ward, and Megun- Kesses Ward of Uasin Gishu County.

Tarakwa Constituency

104

Simotwa Ward, Tarakwa Ward, Cheptiret Ward, Oleinguse Ward, Pioneer-Elgon View Ward, Timboroa Ward, Kipchamo Ward, Race Course (Langas Sublocation) Ward (Part) and Tulwet-Chuiyat Ward of Uasin Gishu County.

105

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Uasin GishuCounty

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Eldoret South It emerged that some wards were swapped and one ward had name changed incorrectly.

106

5.3.29 Elgeyo Marakwet County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Keiyo North Constituency 2. Proposed a creation of two constituencies:- Keiyo Kapchemutwa Ward, Kokwao Ward, North and Keiyo East; Irong Ward, Kapkonga Ward, Kamogich 3. The boundary of the two constituencies should run Ward, Kessup Ward, Central Ward, along Keiyo escarpment; Sergoit Ward, Kiptuilong Ward, Kapterik 4. Eastern boundary should be Kerio River and the Ward, Mutei Ward, Keu Ward, of Elgeyo current Keyio East Division to be elevated to a district and made a Constituency; 2. Proposals related to Keiyo South Constituency Kaptarakwa Ward, Mosop Ward, Metkei  No issues presented. Ward, Kapkwony Ward, Marichor West Ward, TumeiwoWard, Marichor East Ward, Maoi Ward, Kocholwo Ward, Nyaru Ward, Kamwosor Ward, Soy Ward, Kibargoi Ward, Chemoibon Ward, Chepsigot Ward, Kitany Ward and Kabiemit Ward of Elgeyo-Marakwet County. 3. Proposals related to Marakwet West Constituency Marakwet East Constituency  Divide into two constituencies: Marakwet West Chebororwa Ward, Cherangany Ward, Constituency and Marakwet Central Constituency; Lelan Ward, Kamoi Ward, Sengwer Ward,  Marakwet West should comprise of Chebororwo Kuserwo Ward, Moiben Ward, Kapsowar Division which has the following locations:- Konda Ward, Chesuman Ward, Kipsaiya Ward, bilet; Yamurgoi; Tamarur; and Kiabai; Arror Ward and Koibarak Ward of  Kapcherop Division has Kapterit; Kamoi; Sengwer; Elgeyo-Marakwet County. and Kipteber; and  Another proposed name for the constituency is Kapcherop Constituency . Marakwet Central to be hived from the existing Marakwet West Constituency. It should comprise of Kapsowar Division, Chebiemit and Tunyo divisions.  Every existing location should be made a ward; 4. Proposals related to Marakwet East Constituency Marakwet East Constituency a) The constituency should remain as it is currently Endo Ward, Koibirir Ward, Embobut constituted; Ward, Embolot Ward, Murkutwo Ward, Mokoro Ward, Kipkaner Ward, Sambirir

107

Ward, Mon Ward, Kaptich Ward and Kapyego Ward of Elgeyo-Marakwet County.

108

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Elgeyo Marakwet County

109

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Keiyo North It emerged that the Community of interest, Historical, Economical and cultural ties were not considered. The community also requested a review of the boundary between two neighboring constituencies in different counties.

The Means of communication for resident of a location& sub-location in Eldoret East would like to be moved to Keiyo North as they‘re too far away from the service in their constituency headquarters; and that the residents would like the issue of county boundaries looked at in future boundaries review.

5.3.30 Nandi County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Tinderet Constituency O’llessos Ward, Sochoi Ward, (iii) Proposal to split Tinderet and create Kapng‘etuny or Kapchorwa Ward, Siret Ward, Mogobich Nandi Hills constituency Ward, Kapkoros Ward, Kapng‟etuny Ward, Miteitei Ward, Tindiret Ward and Kosoiywo Ward of Nandi County.

Nandi Hills Constituency

Chemase Ward, Chemilil Ward, Soba Ward, Kapsimotwo Ward, Chebarus Ward and Songhor Ward of Nandi County.

2. Proposals related to Aldai Constituency Terik Ward, Maraba Ward, Kibwareng- (iv) No proposed constituency Chebilat Ward, Kabwareng Ward, Kapkemich Ward, Koyo Ward, Ndurio Ward, Kaptumo Ward, Kemeloi Ward and Kaboi Ward of Nandi County.

3. Proposals related to Emgwen North Constituency Proposal to split Emgwen constituency into two; Kosirai Ward, Chepterit Ward, (v) Emgwen North and Chemundu-Kaptildil Ward,

110

(vi) Emgwen South Ward, Mutwot-Ngechek Ward, Kaptel Ward, Sangalo Ward, Kiptuiya Ward, Itigo Ward, Lelmokwa (Bibiriet Location) Ward (Part), Songalo (Kipsomoite Sublocation) Ward (Part), Ward (Part) Kapsisiywa Ward and Kamoiywo Ward of Nandi County.

Emgwen South Constituency Kapkangani Ward, Chepkumia Ward, Kiminda Ward, Kamobo Ward, Kilibwoni North Ward, Kipture-Irimis Kimaam Ward, Kipsigak-Kipsotoi Ward, Kabirirsang Ward, and Arwos Ward of Nandi County. 4. Proposals related to A proposal presented Split Mosop into three; Mosop Constituency (a) Mosop Central Constituency Chepterwai Ward, Surungai Ward, (b) Mosop West Constituency; and Kurgung Ward, Kabisaga Ward, (c) Mosop East Constituency Kipkaren Ward, Lelmokwo (Sigot, bibiriet and lelmokwo locations) Ward (Part), Kebulonik Ward, Kabiyet Ward, and Ndalat Ward of Nandi County.

111

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Nandi County

112

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Mosop &Emgwen The Means of communication and consultation with all interested parties was not done. As aresult some wards were omitted while others appeared in both constituencies .this needs to be corrected. b) Tinderet Not all interested parties were consulted. There was a mix up of wards and sub- locations, with some going to Tinderet instead of new Nandi Hills Constituency.

5.3.31 Baringo County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposal related to Baringo East Constituency  Proposal to split the constituency into two and rename as Baringo East Constituency indicated below:- Akoret Ward, Churo Ward, (a) Tiatiy West ( Tiatiy) Constituency, Tangulubei Ward, Korossi Ward, (b) Tiatiy East Korosi Constituency Kolowa Ward, Ribkwo-Kositei Ward, Loiyamorok Ward, Silale  If not possible to split into two, then it should be renamed Ward and Tirioko Ward of Baringo to Tiatiy Constituency County. 2. Proposal related to Baringo North Constituency Baringo North Constituency  The Commission to consider splitting the constituency Ngo’rora-Kinyach Ward, Kabutiei into two but no proposal was given to this effect. Ward, Kaptebererwo Ward, Sibilo Ward, Kaboskei–Kerio Ward, Kaboskei-Kipkata Ward, Kalabata Ward, Lawan Ward, Kabutiei Ward, Kelyo Ward, Ossen Ward, Katiorin- Saimo South Ward, Saimo North Ward and Bartum Ward of Baringo County. 3. Proposal related to Baringo Central Constituency Proposal 1. Baringo Central Constituency  Split Baringo Central to create Bogoria Constituency and Tenges Ward, Emom-Kisonei Baringo central constituencies Ward, Sacho Mosop Ward, Sacho Soi Ward, Kimalel Ward, Kabasis Proposal 2. Ward, Nge’t Moi Ward, Kapsoo  Split Baringo Constituency into Marigat Constituency and Borowonin Ward, Ewalel-Soi Baringo Central Constituency Kimondis Ward, Orokwo Ward, Seguton Ward, Chebano Ward,

113

Proposal 3. Kinyo Ward, Kaprogonya Ward,  Split the Constituency into Ilchamus and baringo Central Kapsoo/Borowonin Ward, With the indicated Wards:- Ilchamus and Baringo Central. Soi Ward, Kituro Ward, Talai-Ewalel Ward and Kabasis Ward of BaringoCounty.

Mochongoi Constituency Mukutani Ward, Salabani Ward, Ngambo Ward, Marigat Ward, Loboi Ward, Chebinyinyi- Arabel Ward, Kimoriot Ward, Ilchamus Ward and Mochongoi Ward of Baringo County. 4. Proposal related to Mogotio Constituency  Proposed to maintain the consistency as it is. Koibos-Soi Ward, Cheberen Ward, Kamar Ward, Sinende Ward, Ol Kokwe Ward, Kisanana Ward, Moguriny Ward, Emining Ward, Kakimor-Rosoga Ward, Lembus- Kiptoim Ward, Lembus Mogotio Ward and Kimngorom-Sirwa Ward of Baringo County. 5. Proposal related to Eldama Ravine Constituency Eldama Ravine Constituency  Change the name Eldama-Ravine constituency to Kiplombe Ward, Solian Ward, Koibatek West or Koibatek Mosop. Benonin Ward, Ravine Ward,  Create Endorois constituency comprising of Mogorwo, Perkerra Ward, Kabimoi Ward, Tenges, Bekibon, Loboi , Mochongoi and Kibos wards. Saos- Kibias Ward, Poror Ward, Sigoro Ward, Lembus Torongo Ward, Lembus Mosop Ward, Mumberes Ward and Maji Mazuri Ward of Baringo County.

114

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Baringo County

115

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Eldama Ravine & Baringo Central It emerged that Community of interest were not considered by IIBRC and the Report varied the names of the wards.

5.3.32 Laikipia County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Laikipia West Constituency Proposal 1. Laikipia West Constituency Ngobit Ward, Sirma Ward, Lamuria Split the existing Laikipia west constituency into:- Ward, Tigithi Ward, Mashamba

(iii) Rumuruti; and Ward, Nturukuma Ward, Hospital

(iv) Ol-Moran constituencies Ward, Stadium Ward, Central Ward and Biashara Ward of Laikipia Proposal 2. County. Split the existing Laikipia west constituency into:-  Laikipia West and  Laikipia South constituencies

Proposal 3. Split the existing laikipia west constituency into:-  Ngarua,  and  Laikipia West constituencies

Proposal 4. Split the existing laikipia west constituency into:-  Ngarua  Nyahururu and  Laikipia West constituency

Proposal 5. Split the existing laikipia constituency into;  Laikipia North and  Laikipia West constituencies 2. Proposals related to Laikipia East Constituency Proposal 1. Laikipia East Constituency

116

Split Laikipia East to:- Nduyu Ward, Manguo Ward, 1. Laikipia North Constituency; Ndururumo- Hospital Ward, 2. Laikipia East Constituency Igwamiti Ward, Melwa Ward, Proposal 2. Salama Ward, Mutara Ward, Lorian Split Laikipia East to:- Ward, Marmanet Ward, Sosian 1. Laikipia North Ward, Muthengera Ward, Gituamba 2. Laikipia Central and Ward, Muhotetu Ward, Umande 3. municipality Ward, Manyatta Ward, Ayam Ward, Donyo Loip Ward, Dimkom Ward, Waso Narok Ward and Kinamba Ward of Laikipia County.

Laikipia North Constituency Segera Ward, Naibor Ward, Ol- Moran Ward, Hethi Ward, Mukurian Ward, Ilngwesi Ward, Mukogodo Ward, Mumonyot Ward, Oloibor Soit Ward, Idigri-Lepalei Ward, Sosian Ward and Lonyiek Ward of Laikipia County.

117

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Lakipia County

118

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Laikipia West It emerged that Laikipia West has a population of 100,361, with its neighbours also having higher populations, but boundaries were not adjusted or a new constituency added.

5.3.33 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Molo Constiuency Proposal 1. Whole of Eastern Mau Forest Complex Block be a Sachangwan Ward, Turi South Ward, constituency Molo Ward, Mariashoni Ward, Elburgon Ward, Mutamaiyu Ward, Proposal 2. Turi North Ward and Kiambiriria Create Bogoria constituency out of Molo. Ward of Nakuru County.

Proposal 3. Njoro Constituency Split Molo into three:- Njoro Ward, Mukungugu Ward, Lare o Mau Ogiek Ward, Nessuit Ward, Mauche Ward, o Molo Kihingo Ward, Naishi Ward, Sururu o Njoro Ward, Naishi (Piave Location) Ward Proposal 4 (Part) and Mau Narok Ward of Molo constituency be split to:- Nakuru County. 1. Molo 2. Njoro

Other Proposals Proposal by Ogiek community  Ogiek are an indigenous ethnic minority community found in most parts of the Mau Forest Complex. Proposal by Endorois community Endorois are indigenous people.  Bogoria constituency be created from the existing locations  Bogoria constituency be created from the existing locations Proposal by Mau Ogiek  Ogiek are an indigenous ethnic minority community. They propose Mau Ogiek constituency to be curved from the larger Molo constituency.

119

Proposal Boundaries 1. Molo constituency as per the current Molo district boundary 2. Njoro constituency as per the current Njoro district boundary. Therefore the boundary shall be at Kamwaura River which draws from Mau forest to Lake Baringo via . 3. It is proposed that Sirikwa ward in Kamara division of Kuresoi district be brought to Molo district. 4. It is proposed that Ngondu, Ngecha ―B‖, Ogilgei, Kerma and the whole of Piave be moved to Njoro district (as per the current Njoro district) 5. Miti Mingi location of elementaita division in is moved from Gilgil division to Njoro district. 2. Proposals related to Naivasha Constiuency Naivasha Constiuency Proposal 1. Malewa East Ward, Maiella Ward, Split Naivasha to: Olkaria Ward, Hells‟Gate Ward, 1. Gilgil constituency Longonot Ward, Mwiciringiri Ward, 2. Maai Mahiu constituency; and Maragishu Ward, Lake View Ward, 3. Naivasha Constituency Biashara Ward, Viwanda Ward, Naivasha East Ward and Mai Mahiu Proposal 2. Ward of Nakuru County. Split Naivasha to:- 1. Naivasha town constituency, 2. Naivasha rural constituency and 3. Gilgil constituency Gilgil Constituency Kiambogo Ward, Ndabibi Ward, Proposal 3 Malewa West Ward, Miti Mingi Ward, Split Naivasha to:- Murindati Ward, Gilgil Ward and 1. Naivasha west constituency, Mbaruk Ward of Nakuru County. 2. Naivasha East constituency

Proposal 4. Split Naivasha to:- 1. Gil gil constituency, 2. Naivasha constituency

120

3. Proposals related to Kuresoi Constiuency Proposal 1. Kuresoi SouthConstituency Proposal to create a constituency called Tinet out of Tinet Ward, Kapsimbeiywo Ward, Kuresoi. Keringet Ward, Amalo Ward, Kaplamai Ward, Kiptagich Ward, Proposal 2. Chemener Ward and Cheptuech Sub-division of Kuresoi to Ward of Nakuru County. 1. Kuresoi south constituency and 2. kuresoi North constituency

Proposal 3 The proposed boundary will run as follows i. From Masaita and follows Kipsonoi River to Kuresoi North Constituency Kipsonoi road to Kamara Ward, Koige Ward, Sirikwa ii. From Langwenda- Siwot road to Langwenda Ward, Temoyota Ward, Nyota Ward, shopping centre to Selilia School Mkulima Ward, Kuresoi Ward and iii. From Selilia School, it goes to Kamwaura Bridge Kiptororo Ward of Nakuru County. (Chemosit River) all the way downwards to Ndoinet. o The upper part shall be the proposed Kuresoi North Constituency, while the lower side shall be the proposed Kuresoi south constituency

4. Proposals related to Subukia Constiuency Subukia Constiuency It was proposed that Subukia be split the constituency into 3 Lanet Ward, Solai (Nyandudu as indicated below:- Sublocation) Ward Part, Waseges ◦ Nyamithi constituency; (Mwitethia Location and Gitundaga ◦ ; and sub-location) Ward Part, Kabazi ◦ Kabazi constituency. Ward, Munanda Ward and Subukia Ward of Nakuru County.

5. Proposals related to Rongai Constiuency Rongai Constituency Ngata Ward, Solai Ward Part, ,  No request for sub-division was submitted. Rongai Ward, Boror Ward Makongeni Ward, Kampi Ya Moto Ward, Waseges (Manyatta and Nyamatithia Sublocations) Ward Part, Lengenet Ward and Maji Tamu Ward of of Nakuru County. 6. Proposals related to Nakuru Town Constiuency Bahati Constituency

121

Proposal 1. Bahati Ward, Dondori Ward, Split Nakuru town constituency into Nakuru town West Kiamaina Ward, Ndungiri- Kirima and Nakuru town East. Ward, and of Nakuru County.

Proposal 2. Split Nakuru town constituency into Menengai, Lanet, Pipeline, Barut, Nakuru Central, Nakuru East, Nakuru West Proposal 3. Nakuru Town West Constituency Split Nakuru town constituency into :- Viwanda Ward, Kaptembwa Ward, ◦ Lanet; Barut West Ward, Barut East Ward, ◦ Menengai; Hospital Ward, Rhoda Ward and ◦ Nakuru west; and Shabab Ward of Nakuru County. ◦ Lake Nakuru Proposal 4 Split Nakuru town constituency to; Nakuru Town East Constituency 1. Nakuru town West and Langa Langa Ward, Nakuru East 2. Nakuru town East. Ward, Shauri Yako Ward, Biashara Ward, Bondeni Ward, Lake View Proposal 5: Ward, Kivumbini Ward, Menengai Ward and of Nakuru County.  Kiamunyu, Ngata and Technology areas be part of the proposed constituency because of the current status of development and which needs provision of urban dwelling related services e.g. water and sewage system e.t.c.

 Area around Wanyororo, Greenstead and Maili Moja should be made part of the town to benefit from the urban dwelling services. Proposal 6:

Boundary of Nakuru Town East and Nakuru Town west constituency to be Crater View, KBC Transmitter, Nakuru Forest Station, Nakuru Municipal Main Treatment water Tank, Nakuru municipal Mortuary, Railway Flyover, Kanu Office, Kenyatta avenue round about, Bondeni road, N.C.C.K to Game Park Main Gate of Nakuru National Park.

122

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Nakuru County

123

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

Subukia & Rongai  There was a mix-up in the transfer of divisions, locations and sub-location and  Minority group interests were not considered (Ogiek)

Naivasha  Community of interest, Historical, Economical and cultural ties not considered.  The area is home to diverse people groups, and would benefit from better representation.  Population quota; has high population of 226,056 and by the quota qualifies for 2 extra conctituencies instead of one as proposed. Molo  Re-drawing of boundaries: - one sub-location, Piape, was to be moved from Rongai to Njoro constituency but this was not done.

Kuresoi  Community of interest, Historical, Economical and cultural Ties/Minorities/Marginalization not taken into consideration.  The minority group & marginalized in the area, the Ogiek, will be further marginalized as the new constituency, Njoro is bigger than the mother constituency, Molo, thus offering less chance of representation of this people.

124

5.3.34

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kiligoris Constituency .Proposal 1. Masurura Ward, Nkararo Ward, Kilgoris constituency be split into:- Osinoni Ward, Olomismis Ward, Shartuka Ward, Kapune Ward, 1. Trans- Mara East – to cover Meguarra tributaries Poroko Ward, Ololchani Ward, between Shartuka and Ololtenet ward. It will follow Shankoe Ward, Kimintet Ward, along the river towards thicketed area Olomismis and Oloirien Ward, Enoosaen Ward, Join Mogor river covering engulfing the former pirrar Angata- Barrikoi Ward, Moyoi and kerindon Division and continue s along the valley of Ward and Sikawa Ward of Narok Operai downstream to Mara river. County. 2. Trans-Mara West- the remaining part of the entire district Emurua Dikirr Constituency Proposal 2. Kilgoris constituency be split into:- Osinoni Ward, Njipiship Ward, Ololmaasani Ward, Mogondo Ward, 1. Trans-Mara East- cover the previous Pirrar and Ilkerin Ward, Emarti Ward, Kerindon divisions; Kapsasian Ward, Emurua Dikirr 2. Kilgoris Constituency Ward of Narok County.

Proposal 3. Kilgoris constituency be split into:- 1. Emurua Dikirr, (include Ololmaasani, Dikirr Divisions) 2. Trans Mara South,(Include Kirindon, Lolgorian, Loirien); and 3. Trans Mara North (Include Keyian, Kilgoris,Pirrar)

2. Proposals related to Narok North Constituency Proposal 1. Olpusimoru Ward, Naisoya Ward, Spilt Narok into:-Narok North and Narok East Olokurto Ward, Olorropil Ward, Entiani Ward, Olchorro Ward, Proposal 2. Siyiapei Ward, Olopito Ward, Spilt Narok into:-Narok North, Narok east and Melili Masikonde Ward, Entontol Ward, Stadium Ward, Imasharian-Morijo Proposal 3.

125

Spilt Narok into:- Narok North, Narok East and Melili Ward, Oleleishwa Ward, Nkairamiram Ward, Nkareta North Ward, Olokurto  The Existing Narok North constituency be split into Ward, Upper Melili Ward, Enabelbel two, Narok North and East Constituencies. The Mau Ward of Narok County. and Olokurto divisions will form the basis of splitting the constituency, Central division will be redistributed.  The residents of Ntulele Ward wanted the ward be split Narok East Constituency into two; Ntulele and Olenkomei.  It was proposed that the proposed Melili constituency Mosiro Ward, Oletukat Ward, Ongata would border Narok North along Olchorro/Entontol Naado Ward, Suswa Ward, Nkareta boundary separated by the Nairobi - Narok highway. East Ward, Keekonyoike Ward, Reasons being:- Ntulele Ward, Ololpironito Ward, Enoosupukia Ward and Idarmat Representation and benefitting from the allocation of funds Wards of Narok County. from the council. Equal distribution of resources and manpower if their requests were granted 3. Proposals related to Narok South Constituency Split Narok south into two; Loita West Ward, Morijo Loita Ward, 1. Olululunga Elang‟ata-Enterit Ward, Naroosura 2. Osupuko Ward, Naikarra Ward, Siana Ward,  The boundary of the proposed constituencies will be Mara Ward, Olderkesi Ward, Olkinyei cutting across the current constituency from Mao forest Ward, Olkiriane Ward, Nkareta West to the north and to Loita division on the south. Ward, Maji Moto Ward, Lemek Ward,  The area is vast with estimated 10,444 km2 square and Melelo Ward and Ololulung‟a Ward the boundary with other constituencies should remain of Narok County. the same  The infrastructure within the constituency is poorly Narok West Constituency done only the Naroosura, Loita, Lemek/Aitong and Sagamian Ward, Olmekenyu Ward, significant sections of Narok-Sekenani roads are only Sogoo Ward, Mulot Ward, ololoipangi passable during the dry seasons and Olmekenyu Sublocation of Ololunga ward and Enelerai Ward and Ilmotiook Ward of Narok County.

126

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Narok County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

127

No major issues emerged.

5.3.35 Kajiado (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kajiado North Constituency Kajiado North Constituency Proposal 1. Ngong Ward, Oloolua Ward, Split Kajiado North into:- Kajiado North and Ngong Kandis Ward, Ward, Constituencies. Kiserian Ward, Olkeri Ward, Lemelepo Ward of . Proposal 2. Split kajiado North into three; Kajiado East, Kajiado West and Kajiado North constituencies. Kajiado West Constituency Shompole Ward, Magadi Ward, Proposal 3. Oldonyonyokie Ward, Iloodokilani Create Kajiado North Constituency that will comprise of Ward, Olkiramatian Ward, Mosiro Ngong, Kiserian and Rangai, Oloolua; and this should be an Ward, Central Keekonyokie Ward, urban constituency. North Keekonyokie Ward, South Keekonyokie Ward and Torosei Proposal 4. Ward of Kajiado County. Create Kajiado West Constituency by putting together Magadi and Ewaso Kedong Divisions; and this will be comprised of Hoodokilani, Keekonyokie and Ipurko Sub-groups.

 Kajiado North constituency is within Kajiado North district.  The residents proposed that the constituency be split into two or three but there was a variance in the naming of the proposed constituencies and wards. 2. Prposals related to Kajiado Central Constituency Kajiado East Constituency Oloosirkon-Sholinke Ward, Proposal 1. Ward, Kaputei North . Create Kajiado East Constituency that will comprise of Ward, Ilmunkush Ward, Ilmaroro Isinya Division and Mashuru Divisions - the two have a total Ward, Poka Ward and Kinyewa- of 11 locations; Merrueshi Ward of Kajiado County. . The boundary between the new constituency and Machakos and Makueni districts to be the Nairobi – Mombasa /Railway Kajiado Central Constituency line; Esukuta Ward, Olopurupurana . Chyulu Game Reserve and Nairobi National Park to be part Ward, Ildamat Ward, Market Ward, of the constituency;

128

. Kajiado East be made of Kaputiei sub-tribe of theMaasai; Majengo Ward, Eiti Ward, Hospital Ward, Purko Ward, South Proposal 2. Dalalakutuk, Lorng‟osua Ward, . Create Kajiado East Constituency by putting together Enkorika Ward, Meto Ward, Division and Central Division; Matapato West Ward, Namanga . This should be made up of Ildamat, TIpurko, Dalalale Kutuk Ward, Mailua Ward, Matapato East and Matapato sub-group of the Maasai; Ward of Kajiado County.

Proposal 3. Kajiado West, Kajiado East(Isinya division of Kajiado North constituency and Mashuru division of Kajiado Central division), and Kajiado south.

Proposal 4. Create Ngong Constituency:- Boundaries of the proposed Ngong to be:-  The Ngong Hill to the West  The Kiserian River to the East  The Mbagathi river to the South;  Ngong Forest and Kibiko Escarpment to The South west. Proposal 5. Option 1 Kajiado East:- They proposed to be curved from the two districts (Kajiado Central and Kajiado North) Option 2 1. Kajiado East 2. Kajiado West The two constituencies to be curved from the two districts (Kajiado Central and Kajiado North) Option 3 1. Namanga 2. Kajiado West The two constituencies to be curved from the two districts (Kajiado Central and Kajiado North 3. Proposals related to Kajiado South Constituency

Proposal 1. Kajiado South Constituency . change the name of Loitoktok constituency to Kajiado Lenkisim Ward, Entonet Ward, South Constituency and every location to be made a ward; Mbirikani Ward, Kimana Ward, Olorika-Kuku Ward, Oloolopon . Kajiado South constituency should to remain as presently

129

constituted (should not be divided); Ward, Entarara Ward and Rombo- . Rombo Group Ranch to be squarely in Loitoktok Njukini Ward of Kajiado County. constituency/District; Proposal 2. . Split the constituency into two: Loitokitok West and Loitokitok East.

130

ii. IIBRC Proposed Map for Kajiado

County

131

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues

5.3.36 Bomet (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Sotik Constituency Monire Ward, Chemagel Ward, Kamungei Ward,  Proposals to create sotik North Constituency Kapkelei Ward, Ndanai Ward, Abosi Ward, were presented. Kipsonoi Ward, Rongena Ward, Chebilat Ward, Kaplong Ward, Yaganek Ward, Siriat Ward andKapletundo Ward of . 2. Proposals related to Chepalungu Constituency Lelaitich Ward, Kaboson Ward, Sigor Ward, Itembe Ward, Tuluapmosonik Ward, Makimeny  It was proposed that it should be retained as it is. Ward, Kong‟asis Ward, Sugumeriga Ward, Siongiroi Ward and Chebunyo Ward of Bomet County. 3. Proposals related to Bomet Constituency Bomet East Constituency Kipreres Ward, Kapkimolwa Ward, Kembu The constituency to be split into two namely: Ward, Chemaner Ward, Township Ward Part,  Bomet Central constituency to comprise of Cheboin Ward, Tegat Ward and Mugaango Bomet central division and the boundary of Ward of Bomet County. the proposed constituency should follow the current divisional administrative boundaries Bomet Central Constituency without any alterations and all should extend Chesoen Ward, Kanusin Ward, Mutarakwa to Bomet town Ward, Sibayan Ward, Singorwet Ward,  Bomet East constituency to comprise Township Ward Part, Ndaraweta Ward, Longisa division Emkwen ard and Kanusin Ward of Bomet County. 4. Proposals related to Konoin Constituency Proposal to create another constituency to be shared Cheptalal Ward, Chepchabas Ward, Boito Ward, between Bureti and Konoin constituencies as:- Mogogosiek Ward, Koiwa Ward, Embomos  Konoin (Current Konoin Constituency) Ward, Kaptebengwet Ward, Kimulot Ward and  Bureti Central (Vurrent ) Saosa Ward of Bomet County.  Bureti North (To take Kimulot Division from

132

Konoin Const. And Roret Division from Bureti Const.) The public proposed split to affect the two neighbouring constituencies of Konoin and Bureti.

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Bomet County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

(iii) IEBC Proposals

133

5.3.37 Kericho (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposal related to Kipkelion Constituency Kipkelion East Constituency Londiani Ward, Kimugul Ward, Kipsirichet  Proposal presented on the creation of Ward,Masaita-Toiyobei Ward, Chesinende Ward, Kepkelion West Constituency and Kepkelion Kedowa Ward, Sorget Ward, Lemotit Ward, East Constituency. Kapseger Ward,Cheboswa Ward, and Tendeno Ward of .

Kipkelion West Constituency Kunyak Ward, Kapseger Ward (Tugunon and Chepcholiet Sublocations) (Part), Moniat (Kamarus Sublocation) Ward Part, Kokwet Ward, Chilchila Ward, Kipteres Ward, Kamasian Ward, Barsiele Ward and Lesirwa Ward of Kericho County. 2. Proposal related to Ainanmoi Constituency Ainamoi Ward, Kapsaos Ward, Kipchimchim  No proposal was presented. Ward, Kimugungu Ward, Kapkugerwet Ward, Majengo Ward, Soin (Kechiliat and Kapkomonom Sublocations) Ward (Part), Hospital-Biashara Ward, Motobo Ward, Chelimo Ward, Kenegut Ward and Kapsoit Ward of Kericho County. 3. Proposal related to Belgut Constituency  Three proposals given. Two indicating that it Chemamul Ward, Kabianga Ward, Waldai Ward, should remain as it is and the third one Kaptoboiti Ward, Seretut Ward, Cheptororiet indicating that it should be subdivided into Ward, Kipkoyan Ward, Kapsurer Ward, Chaik Belgut North Constituency and Belgut South Ward and Saosa Ward of Kericho County. Constituency Sigowet Constituency Kaplelartet Ward, Kiptere Ward, Kebeneti Ward, Soliat Ward and Soin Ward Part of Kericho County. 4. Proposal related to Bureti Constituency Bureti Constituency Cheplanget Ward, Kapkatet Ward, Kibugat Ward,  Two proposals given:- Split the Constituency Chemosot Ward, Cheborge Ward, Cheptendeniet into two to create Bureti North Constituency Ward, Litein Ward, Kusumek Ward, Tebesonik and Bureti South Constituency. Ward, Kisiara Ward and Techoget Ward of Kericho County.

134

 An additional constituency to be shared among, Buret, Konoin and Sotik Constituencies.

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kericho County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Ainamoi Historical ties were not considered during the delimitation and consultation was not done on where the boundaries should be. b) Kipkelion West The Means of communication was no considered since the headquarters of the new constituency is far from the residents. The Population quota of the wards needs to be redistributed to ensure balanced population in the Kipkelion West and East Constituencies.

135

5.3.38 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Mumias Constituency Mumias Constituency The following proposals were made during the public Mumias Central Ward, Nucleus-Mumias hearings as concerns Mumias Constituency: North Ward, Ekero Ward, Lureko . Split the current Mumias Constituency into two. Ward, Matawa Ward, Etenje Ward, The first part is Mumias which will comprise of Shikalame Ward and Musanda Ward of Mumias Central Division and South Wanga Division. Kakamega County. Its Population is estimated at 124,321 inhabitants with an area of 191.8 Km2 and Population Density of 2 648 people/Km . The Proposed wards for Mumias Constituency Etenje, Musanda, Eshikalawe, Buchifi, Mumias East Constituency Emasinjira, Emukhuwa, Bungasi, Eshikhalame, Eshihaka, Municipality, Mwigunda, Matawa, Lubinu, East Wanga Ward, Eluche Ward, Chibale, Ekero, Kamashia, Bomanyi, Nucleus and Lusheya Ward, Mukulu Ward, Isongo Lureko (Total of 18 wards). Ward and Shibinga Ward of Kakamega County. . The second one is Mumias East to comprise of East Wanga and Wanga Mukulu with an area of 134.6Km2. The Projected population is103,230 and Population Density of 766.72 people/Km2. East Wanga Division has Eluchea, Eluche, Shibinga, Makhwale, Shianda wards.Wanga Mukulu Division comprise of Malaha, Aunga, Mbomini, Makunga, Mukubu, Isongo and Khaimba ward. 2. Proposals realted to Matungu constituency Matungu Constituency Split Matungu constituency into; Matungu Ward, Lunga‟anyiro Ward, 1. Koyonzo constituency - will comprise of the Namamali Ward, Koyonzo Ward, following locations/wards: Indangalasia, Koyonzo, Mayoni Ward, Indangalasia Ward, Lung‘ganyiro, Namamali, Nanyeni, Munami, Mirere; Kholera Ward, Khalaba Ward of and Kakamega County. 2. Matungu Constituency- will comprise of the following locations/wards: Khalaba, Mayoni, Matungu, Kholera, Musamba, Makale, Mwira and Namulungu 3. Alternatively take; . Koyonzo, Nanyeni, Lung‘anyiro, Munami, Emanani, Mirere, Indangalasia, Mayoni, Makale, Ikama, Matungu, Namulungu, Kholera, Khalaba and

136

Musambe wards should form Matungu Constituency;

. This should comprise of three (3) municipality wards and 12 county council making a total of 15 wards. 3. Proposals for Khwisero Constituency Khwisero Constituency (iii) Khwisero Costituency (Sub – divided) Khwisero West Kisa Ward, Central Kisa Ward, East Constituency to cover proposed Khwisero East Kisa Ward; South Kisa Ward, North and Khwisero East division and Khwisero Mulwanda Ward and North KisaWard West Constituency to cover proposed Khwisero of Kakamega County. West division and Khwisero Central division.

. It was proposed that Esherombe to be reinstated as a ward; Mulwanda should be divided into two wards (Mulwanda and Mushiangubu); North to be divided into two wards (North and Mundorerwa); and Central be divided into two (Central and Township);

. It was further proposed that the Constituency be subdivided into two: East Bunyore and West Bunyore. 4 Proposals for Butere Constituency Butere Constituency (iv) Proposal to split Butere (Butere North Constituency) – to cover Lunza and Butere North Marama Ward, Buchenya Ward, divisions. Shiatsala (Butere South Constituency) – Lunza Ward, Central Marama Ward to cover Shiatsala and proposed Marenyo divisions. Butere Township Ward and South Alternatively: Marama Ward, Manyala Ward, . Divide Butere into two Constituencies namely South Marenyo-Shianda Ward of Kakamega Butere and North Butere and create new wards :- County. Eshitari, Imanga, Shiraha, and Marenyo; . South Butere Constituency should comprise of :- Marama South; Manyala; Shianda; Township; Marama Central; and Imanga; . North Butere Constituency should be formed by Marama North; Shiraha; Lunza; Buchenya; Marenyo and Eshitari. 5 Proposals for Lugari Constituency Lugari Constituency Proposal 1. Mwamba Ward, Munyuki Ward, (v) Split the current Lugari constituency into: Lugari Marakusi Ward, Mautuma Ward, West - will cover lugari, lumakanda, chekalini, Chekalini Ward, Lugari Ward, lwandenti and chevaywa locations and Lugari East - Chevaywa Ward, Mabuye Ward, will cover nzoia, kongoni, likuyani, mautuma and Luandeti Ward, Mahanga Maturu Ward

137

sinoko locations of Kakamega County.

Proposal 2. Likuyani Constituency

(vi) Split the current Lugari constituency into: Likuyani Likuyani Ward, Sango Ward, Kongoni constituency; Matete constituency and Lugari Ward, Moi‟s Bridge-Matunda Ward, constituency Musemwa-Vinyenya Ward and Sinoko Proposal 3. Ward of Kakamega County. (vii) Split the current Lugari constituency into: Lugari constituency - would comprise of the following locations; Sinoko, Nzoia, Kongoni, Likuyani, Mautuma and Matete constituency - would be composed of; Lumakanda, Lugari, Chekalini, Lwandeti, and Chevaywa locations.

Proposal 4. Create Likuyani Constituency from the current Lugari Constituency Proposal 5 (viii) It should be retained as it is.

Proposal 6. (ix) Split the current Lugari constituency into:- Lugari constituency and Likuyani Constituency.

6 Proposals for Malava Constituency Malava Constituency Proposal 1. West Kabras Ward, South Kabras (x) Merge Malava Constituency with Matete District Ward, East Kabras Ward, Mahira Ward, then Subdivide to: Malava North (or Matete Mugai Ward, Shirugu Ward, Chegulo Constituency ) Ward, Butali Ward, Chemuche Ward, Malava South ( or Malava Constituency). Shivanga Ward and Manda Ward of Kakamega County. Proposal 2.  Malava South- Constitute of South Kabras, West Kabras, Shirugu Location and Malava North constitute of East Kabras, Central Kabras.

Proposal 3. Option 1  Malava South- Constitute of East, South Kabras, Shirugu and Malava North- Shivanga Location, Central Kabras, Chevanywa and Lwandeti Locations Option 2

138

 Malava south- Comprise of East, South, West Kabras and Mwisanjiro (Township)- Proposed and Named; and Malava North- Shivanga Division, Shirugu

 The need of the people of Matete District to have their own Constituency is because they have never had a stable chance to participate in political election due to individual political interferences after it was curved out of .

 All proposals Propose that Matete division be returned to Malava Constituency before it is subdivided. 7 Proposals for Lurambi Constituency Lurambi Constituency Proposal 1. Sichirayi Ward, Central Ward, Milimani a) Split Lurambi constituency into: Kakamega town; Ward, Amalemba Ward, Matende Ward Navakholo – (will comprise of West Bunyala, Musaa Ward, Bukhulunya Ward, Nambacha, and east Bunyala Locations-Navakolo Shibiriri Ward, Maraba Ward, division); and Lurambi – (will comprise of the current Mahiakalo Ward and Shikoti Ward, North Butsotso, South butsotso, Centaral Butsotso, and Bukura Ward, Central Butsotso Ward East butsotso Locations). of Kakamega County.

Proposal 2. b) Split lurambi into:- Lurambi North; Lurambi South; Navakholo Constituency and Navakholo Constituencies. Shinoyi-Shikomari-Esumeiya Ward, Budonga Ward, Ingotse-Matiha Ward, Bunyala Central-Nambacha Ward, Bunyala East-Namirama Ward, Sidikho- Kochwa Ward of Kakamega County. 8 Proposals for Shinyalu Constituency Shinyalu Constituency c) Proposal to split Shinyalu constituency into: - Ileho Kambiri Ward, East Ward, Constituency (to cover Ivihiga and Kambiri Murhanda Ward, Ivihiga Ward, divisions) and Shinyalu Constituency (comprising Virhembe-Mukango Ward, Shing’oto- of West and Central isukha divisions) Shiasava Ward, Museno-Shirulu-Lukose Ward, Shidodo-Shitochi Ward and Ilesi Ward of Kakamega County. 9 Proposals for Ikolomani Constituency Ikolomani Constituency d) Split Ikolomani Constituency into two as follows: North Ward, Idakho Central Ikolomani North -( to comprise of proposed Ward, Idakho East Ward, Idakho North Ikolomani North and central divisions) and Ward and Idakho South Ward of

139

Ikolomani south -(To comprise of Ikolomani East Kakamega County. and South divisions).

140

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kakamega County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report) a) Malava The Population quota was not adhered to. The population of Malava is beyond the National quota, at a population of 205‘166 in area of 427.40 sq.km and yet was not subdivided.

141

5.3.39 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Vihiga Constituency Proposal 1. Vihiga Constituency b) Vihiga Municipal Constituency or ―Wambale‖ for Wamuluma Ward, Lugaga Ward, the Maragolis to include: Wamuluma, Central Mungoma Ward, Central Maragoli, Izava North, Izava South and part of Ward and South Maragoli Ward of Chavakali and West Maragoli locations; and Vihiga County. c) To be curved from Sabatia and Vihiga constituencies. Proposal 2.  Split Vihiga constituency to create:- Mbale constituency; The current Sabatia and Vihiga constituencies should be brought together so that a new constituency will be curved out to form Mbale constituency; and Mbale constituency will incorporate the current Chavakali division of Sabatia district in addition to Mbihi, chambiti, Kegoye and Chango sub - locations of Vihiga district; Sabatia constituency and Vihiga constituency.

2. Proposals related to Sabatia Constituency Proposal 1. Sabatia Constituency  Convert the following proposed divisions to Busali Ward, Wodanga Ward, North constituncy Maragoli Ward, Chavakali Ward, Ezava i. Division 1-Wadonga and North Maragoli Ward, Lyaduywa Ward and Sabatia location, West Ward of Vihiga County. ii. Division 2-Busali East and West iii. Division 3-West Maragoli and Chavakali locations, iv. Division 4-Izava north and South location v. Division 6- Lugaga, Mung‘oma location, vi. Division 5-Central and south maragoli location; and vii. Vihiga municipality.

Proposal 2. Merge Sabatia and Vihiga Constituency and create and create 3 constituencies namely: Mbale, Sabatia and

142

Vihiga

3. Proposals related to Hamisi Constituency Proposal 1.  Hamisi constituency split to; Hamisi Constituency 1. Itirichi Yiivwakwe (East ) Muhudu Ward, Shiru Ward, Shaviringa 2. Itirichi Yiitunen (West Tiriki) Ward, Shamakhokho Ward, Banja Proposal 2. Ward, Gisambai Ward, Tambua Ward  Create Hamisi Hamisi West constituency by and Jepkoyai Ward of Vihiga County. combining Tambua, Jepkoyai, Banja and Gisambai; and Hamisi East constituency by combining Senende, Shiru, Shamakhokho and Muhundu.

4. Proposals related to Emuhaya Constituency Emuhaya Constituency East Bunyore, Bunyore North Ward,  Split Emuhaya constituency to create:- North East Bunyore Ward, Central i. Emuhaya constituency; and Bunyore Ward and West Bunyore ii. Luanda constituency. Ward of Vihiga County.

Luanda Emuhaya Constituency Wemilabi Ward, Emabungo Ward, Luanda Ward, Mwibona Ward, Luanda South Ward and Mukhalakhala Ward of Vihiga County.

143

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Vihiga County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

5.3.40 (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals realted to Mt. Elgon Constituency Option1 Mt. Elgon 1. Mt. Elgon West constituency /district (Cheptais) will Cheptais Ward, Chepkube Ward, Sasur comprise of Chepatis and Kopsiro divisions with Cheptais, Ward, Chesikak Ward, Emmia Ward, Chepkube, Sasuri, Cheongenywo and Kapkateny locations; Chengeywo Ward, Kapkateny Ward, 2. Mt. Elgon East constituency (Kapsokwony) will comprise of Chepyuk Ward, Namorio Ward, Elgon Kapsokwony, Kaptama divisions with Kamuneru, Nomorio, Ward, Chemoge Ward, Kaboywo Ward Elgon, Kapsokwony, Chemoge, Kongit, Kaptama and and Kaptama Ward of Bungoma County. Kaboywo locations; Option 2 1. Mt. Elgon West constituency/district (Cheptais) will

144

comprise of Chepatis and Kopsiro divisions with Cheptais, Chepkube, Sasuri, Cheongenywo and Kapkateny locations; 2. Mt. Elgon East constituency/district (Kapsokwony) will comprise of Kapsokwony, Kaptama divisions with Kamuneru, Nomorio, Elgon, Kapsokwony, Chemoge, Kongit, Kaptama and Kaboywo locations; 3. Mt. Elgon Central constituency Option 3. 1. Create Endebese Constituency 2. Proposals realted to Sirisia Constituency Sirisia Constituency It was proposed that:- Namwela Ward, Kulisiru Ward, Chongoyi  Kabuchai constituency to comprise of Nalondo, Kabuchai, Ward, Ndakalu Ward, Namubila Ward, Chwele and Mukuyuni divisions; this will cover the entire Lwandanyi Ward, Bungoma central district Chebukutumi Ward, Sitabicha-Mwalie  Sirisia constituency to comprise of the old Sirisia with code East Ward and 171 and it will cover Sirisia, Namwela, Lwandanyi and Malakisi Tamlega-Mwalie West Ward of Bungoma division which will cover the entire Bungoma west district with County. Changara.  Sirisia constituency to comprise of the old Sirisia with code Kabuchai Constituency 171 and it will cover Sirisia, Namwela, Lwandanyi and Malakisi Mukuyuni Ward, Chwele Ward, Kabuchai division which will cover the entire Bungoma west district with Ward, North Ward, Luuya Ward Changara. and Sirare Ward of Bungoma County. 3. Proposals related to Bumula Constituency Proposal 1. Bumula Constituency . Proposed that the following locations form the Bumula Kabula Ward, South Bukusu Ward, constituency:-Musikoma, Mabusi, Bumula, Khasoko, Bukusu, Khasoko Ward, Bumula Ward, West Kabula; Bukusu Ward, Kimaeti Ward, Siboti . Proposed the creation of Siboti Constituency having the Ward, Napara Ward and Mukwa Ward of following wards:-Kibuke; Kimaieti; Napara; Siboti; waisawahi Bungoma County. and Mukwa; . The following Wards were proposed to be created:- Nakhawana, Nasianda, Mabusi, Watoya, Nabudalaya, Siboti, Mwomo, Mayanja, Lumboka, Isawahi, Musakasa. Proposal 2. (vii) Kibabii constituency be created out of Bumula and Kanduyi constituencies and it will comprise of Kibabii, Mukwa, Siboti, Napara, Kimaeti, West Bukusu Locations and Sinoko Ward and Siranyi Wards. 4. Proposals realted to Kanduyi Constituency Kanduyi Constituencies Kanduyi constitutes: Bungoma South District, and Kanduyi Bukembe West Ward, Bukembe East Division. Ward, East Sang’alo Ward, West

145

It was proposed for the creation of Sang‘alo constituency to be Sang’alo Ward Kibabii Ward, Stadium curved out of Bumula and Kanduyi constituency which will Ward, Siritanyi Ward,Sinoko Ward, Mjini comprise of the following areas: Ward, Sio Ward, Musikoma Ward, (i) Bukembe location Khalaba Ward, Namasanda Ward of (ii) East Bukusu location Bungoma County. (iii) Khalaba sub-location and Parts of Kabula location;

5. Proposals realted to Webuye Constituency Webuye Constituency . An area of 214.8 Km2 as per 1999 census. Webuye South Ward, Nabuyoole Ward, . Proposed to divide Webuye into two constituencies: Ndivisi Webuye North Ward, Webuye East Ward, and Webuye; Chetambe Ward, Lugusi . Requested Kibisi location to be part of Ndivisi constituency; Ward, Ndivisi Ward and Namarambi . Correct the mistake of wards done by transferring districts and Ward of Bungoma County. transfer Lwandeti to Webuye and rename it Malaha while Lwandeti ward should remain in Lugari; . Ndivisi Constituency should have the following locations:- Chetambe; Lukusi; Namarambi and Ndirisi; Bokoli Constituency . Requested for Mbakalu and Misikhu Sublocations to be added Bokoli Ward, Misikhu Ward, Milo up the population to 97,384; Ward Sitikho Ward, Miendo Ward and . Proposed Ndivisi Constituency to comprise of the following Kituni Ward of Bungoma County. locations:- Chetambe, Lukusi, Namarambi and Ndivisi; . Proposed to borrow Mbakalu sub-location and Misiku sub- location to form part of Ndivisi constituency. 6. Proposals realted to Kimilili Constituency Kimilili Constituency Proposal 1. Chebukwabi Ward, Kibingei Ward, . It is formed out of current Kimilili and Bungoma North Kimilili SouthWard, North Ward, Maeni District with a Population 135,000 inhabitants; Ward, Makhonge Ward and . The Bungoma North District should be divided create a new Nabikoto Ward of Bungoma County. District called Tongaren which should in turn be Split into two constituencies. Tongaren Constituency . The two constituencies should be:-Tongaren constituency Mbakalo Ward, Milima Ward, Kabuyefwe should run from River Nzoia to Kiminini River while Naitiri Ward, Tongaren Ward, Soysambu Ward, constituency should run from Kiminini river to Kamukuywa Kiminini Ward , river. Naitiri Ward and Ndalu Ward of Proposal 2. Bungoma County. 1. Tongaren constituency to comprise of the old Tongaren and Ndalu divisions. The feature that delineates the constituency is river Kamukuywa and it borders Saboti and Lugari constituency.

146

2. Naitiri constituency/Kimilili to comprise of two divisions namely Mbakalo and central division, the feature that delineates this constituency is river Kamukuywa as the district boundary for Kimilili constituency and Tongaren Constituency. This has been the old boundary for the two divisions and it borders Mt. Elgon, Webuye and Sirisia constituencies

147

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Bungoma County

148

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

5.3.41 Busia County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Nambale Constituency . Nambale is the most highly populated constituency with Nambale Constituency over 200,000 people; Tangakona-Khwirale Ward; Manyole . Geographical area of over 400 square Km. Ward; Lwanyange Ward; Bukhayo . Two rivers that interferes with communication, thus, Sio North-Walatsi Ward; Bukhayo East River and River Walati which joins River Sio at Nambale Ward; Kisoko Ward; Bukhayo  Nambale Constituency has two districts: Nambale and Central Busia; Ward of Busia County.  Nambale should be divided into two Constituencies which should be exactly identical to the two districts;  Nambale District be called Bukhati – (Nambale Matayos Constituency Constituency) while Busia District which comprises of Busibwabo Ward; Matayos South Matayos and Busia Municipality to be called Ward; Bukhayo West Busia/Matayos Constituency Ward; Burumba Ward; Mayenje . There should be no attestation to the administrative Ward; Bulanda Ward and Mjini Ward boundaries; of Busia County. . Changes should be within the existing administrative boundaries;

. Busia Municipality has four wards from Amagoro, Four wards from Busia District. This should remain as an entity; 2. Proposals related to Budalangi Constituency . Bunyala South Ward should have two more wards as it Budalangi Constituency was in 1997 - Ajula ward; Bunyala North Ward, Bulemia Ward, . Bunyala East should be split into two: -Bunyala East and Bukani Ward, Bukoma Ward, Bunyala North. This is due to the fact that it is densely Lunyofu Ward; and Bunyala South populated with a population of 20,000 and floods make Ward of Busia County. it impossible for one Councillor to serve these people; . Split Budalangi Constituency along River Nzoia into two for easy service delivery and development; . There is need recovery of Islands from Uganda: Sigulu,

149

Ama, Siamulda, Siro, Sagiti, Lolwe and Musambwa; . Based on Historical reasons areas from Usonga along the Yala Delta be placed in Bunyala; . On the Yimbo side, there were requests that Bunyala goes up to some level and leaves it for Budalangi i.e. Mau Mau road which is graded up to Goi River and beyond the slopes of Got Ramogi; . The neighbouring road which Members of Parliament grades some roads upto some level and leaves it for Bundalangi i.e. Mau Mau road which is graded up to Nyadorera and then its left about 12 Km thus, the section should now be officially given to Budalangi. . The Chairman was not convinced that, the Bunyala had agreed to divide the Constituency into two. . There were no figures, no maps or memorandum presented on administrative units.

3. Proposals related to Funyula Constituency  Split Funyula Constituency into two:-Funyula North Funyula Constituency and Funyula South. Funyula North Ward; Namboboto Ward; Odiado Ward, Wakhungu Ward; Nangina Ward; Funyula South Ward; and Bwiri Ward of Busia County. 4. Proposals related to Amagoro Constituency Teso South Constituency Proposal 1. Malaba West Ward, Amukura East Split Amagaro into two constituencies:Teso North- Colonial Ward, Amukura Central Ward, North Teso Location and Teso South – Colonial South Akoret Ward, Chakol North Ward, Teso Location Kaliwa Ward, Chakol Central Ward, Chakol South Ward, Alupe Ward,

Ang‟orom Ward, Amerikwai Ward Proposal 2. and Agolot Ward of Busia County. Split Amagoro into:-

1. Amukura Constituency – Comprise of : Busia town, Ochude, Omong‘ura, Asing‘e, Apegei, Angorom, Okame, Kaujakito, Kaliwa, Kotur, Amukura, Kwang‘amoru, Aremit, Akoret, okatekok 2. Amogoro Constituency – Walatsi, Lupinda (Bukhayo

Reverted original name which is Lupinda), Kimaeti, Akadetewai, Amoni, Amagoro, Kamolo, Kamuriai, Teso North Constituency

150

Katakwa, Kokare, Aboloi, Kocholya, Kotur, Okuleu, Malaba Central Ward, Malaba South Osajai; Ward, Malaba East Ward, Malaba 3. Angurai- Aboloi, Angurai, Changara, Chamasini, North Ward, Ang‟urai Ward, kakapel, Katakwe, Kolanya, Moding, Lwandanyi, Ang‟urai North Ward, Ang‟urai Namubira, Malakisi East Ward of Busia County. 5. Proposals related to Butula Constituency  No proposal to split constituency however, Split Butula Constituency Wards/Locations as follows:- West Ward, Bukhalalire Marachi East, (Tingolo, Bumala, Elukongo), Elukhari ( Ward, Esikoma Ward, Elugulu Ward, Elukhari), Elugulu (Bukhuma, Elugulu,) Mariachi Central Elukongo Ward, Elukhari Ward and (Bukhalalire, Sikoma, Kingandole,) Bumala Bujumba, Tingolo Ward of Busia County. (Ikonzo Bujumba )

. It is inhabited by Abamarachi Luhya sub-tribe. No expansion or interference with boundaries. They should remain intact; . Requested for more wards.

151

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Busia County

152

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

5.3.42 County

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Alego Constituency  Three proposals were made: Alego Usonga Constituency Mjini Ward, Siaya East Ward, Siaya i). The constituency to be split into two namely: West Ward, SiayaNorth Ward, Siaya Alego East – comprising of Umala and Kogelo Central Ward, Usonga Ward, West division and Alego West – Comprising of Boro Alego Ward, South West Alego Ward, and Uranga division of Siaya district. East AlegoWard, South Alego Ward, Boro West Ward, Boro EastWard and ii). The constituency to be split into three South East Alego Ward of Siaya namely;Alego East (Umala and Kogelo County. division)Alego Central (Boro division) and Alego West (Uranga division) iii). Alego constituency be sub-divided into two; Alego Constituency – Eastern part comprising of East Alego, South East Alego, South Alego, Township and North Alego location.

Alego Usonga – (Central Alego, South Central Alego, South West Alego, West Alego and Usonga location.

2. Proposals related to Ugenya Constituency  It was proposed to split Ugenya Constituency into Two Ukwala West Ward, Ukwala East namely Ugunja Constituency and Ugenya Ward, North West,Ugenya Ward, Constituency. North Ugenya Ward, West Ugenya Ward, East Ugenya Ward, Jera Ward, North East, Ugenya Ward and West Ugenya Ward of .

Ugunja Constituency Ugunja Ward, North Alego (Part) Ward, Uholo NorthWard, Uholo East Ward, Ugunja Ward, South Ugenya

153

Ward, Umala Ward, Ambira-Ngunya Ward andMagoya-Rambula Ward of Siaya County.

3. Proposals related to Rarieda Constituency  It was proposed that Rarieda constituency be Sub- East Uyoma Ward, West Uyoma divided into two namely Ward, South UyomaWard, Central (i) Madiany constituency- made of Madiany East Uyoma Ward, East Asembo Ward and West. and Central Asembo Ward of Siaya (ii) Rarieda constituency- made of Rarieda East and County. West

4. Proposals related Gem Constituency  It was proposed that Gem be split into two namely: Anyiko-Sauri Ward, Nyamninia Ward, Jina Ward,Marenyo Ward, North (i) Gem Yala – to include Malanga, Yala Division Gem Ward, Central Gem Ward, East (ii) Gem-Wagai- comprising Wagai, Rera, Bar Kalare Gem Ward, Wagai North Ward, Divisions Wagai SouthWard and South Gem Ward of Siaya County.

5. Proposals related Bondo Constituency  Three proposals were made: Oyamo Island, Deda Island, Nyawita (i) That Bondo Constituency be divided into two namely Ward, MarandaWest Ward, Bondo Nyan’goma Constituency – Comprise Nyan‘goma, Town Ward, Ajigo Ward, BarKowino Nango, Ouya divisions and Bondo Constituency East Ward, Bar Kowino West Ward, (ii) To split Bondo constituency into Usigu constituency UsiguEast Ward, Usigu West Ward, and Bondo constituency Central Yimbo Ward,North Sakwa Ward, South Sakwa Ward and Central (iii) To split Bondo constituency into Bondo Constituency Sakwa Ward of Siaya County. and Bondo South Constituency

154

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Siaya County

155

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No emergining issues.

5.3.43

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kisumu Rural Seme Constituency Constituency(Seme) North Central Seme Ward, South  Five proposals were made: Central Seme Ward, West Seme (i) To split Kisumu Rural into Maseno Constituency Ward, South West Seme Ward, and Kombewa Constituency. Otwenya Ward and East Seme Ward (ii) To split Kisumu Rural into Seme East and Seme of Kisumu County. West and create Luanda Constituency (iii) To split Kisumu Rural into Kisumu Town and Seme constituencies. (iv) To split Kisumu Rural into Kisumu Rural and Seme

2. Proposals related to Kisumu East Constituency  Three proposals were made East Kajulu Ward, West Kajulu (i) Kisumu East be split into Kibos constituency and Ward, Manyatta Ward,Nyalenda A Kisumu Town East constituency Ward, East Kolwa Ward and Central (ii) Split KisumuTown East into; Kolwa Ward of Kisumu County. a. Kisumu Town East constituency- Comprised East and west Kajulu, Kondele Locations b. Kolwa Constituency- comprise of the entire West Kolwa as it is in the current administration structure; central and East Kolwa location bordering to the South of at the Sidho-Obumba-Lie Lan‘go Border (iii) Split Kisumu Town East into Kisumu East constituency- (Kajulu East and West, Kolwa Central, Kolwa East and Miwani) Kisumu Central Constituency- Comprise of Town, Kondele, Nyalenda and Migosi 3. Proposals related to Kisumu West Constituency

156

 Three proposals were made: South West Kisumu Ward, Kisumu (i) To split Kisumu Town West into two namely East Ward, Kisumu Central Ward, Kisumu Town West and Kisumu Rural and Re- Kisumu North Ward, Kogony Ward, name current Kisumu Rural to Seme Constituency. North West Kisumu Ward and West Kisumu Ward of Kisumu County. (ii) To split Kisumu Town West into two and re-align boundaries of the Current Kisumu Town West Consituency (Proposed Seme Constituency) by transferring West and North West Kisumu Wards/ Locations to the proposed Kisumo Constituency

(a) Seme constituency ( To cover N.C Seme, S.C

Seme, West Seme, S.W Seme, Otwenya, East Seme

Locations) Kisumu Central Constituency

Kondele Ward, Nyalenda ―B‖ Ward, (b) Kisumo Constituency (To Cover N.W Kisumu, Railway Ward,Aerodrome Ward, West Kisumu, S.W Kisumu, East Kisumu, Central Milimani Ward, Kibuye Ward, Kisumu, North Kisumu Locations) Stadium Ward, North Kisumu Ward,

Market Ward,Kaloleni-Shauri Moyo (iii) To split Kisumu Town West into two to create Ward and Migosi Ward of Kisumu Kisumu Central and Kisumu Constituency. County

4. Proposals related to Nyando Constituency Nyando Constituency  Two proposals were made: Kochieng’ Ward, Kawino Ward, (i) To split Nyando constituency into Kadibo Kombura Ward,Bwanda-Kanyagwal Constituency and Nyando Constituency Ward, Awasi Ward, East Kano (ii) To split Nyando constituency intoWinam Ward, Kombura-Katho Ward, Constituency and Nyando Constituency Kakola Ward, KochogoWard and  It was also proposed that the following wards be Onjiko-Wawidhi Ward of Kisumu created: County. (i) A new Tura ward

(ii) Subdivision of Awasi to Osiri, EastAwasi, West Awasi wards  Create:- (i) Winam Constituency wards- Comprised of Katho, Kombura, Kochieng‘ East and West, Kanygwal, Bwanda, Kawino North and Kawino South Wards and for Remaining wards to constitute Nyando constituency; and (ii) Nyando constituency to consist of Tura (New),

157

Kakola, East Awasi(New), West Awasi Kochogo, Onjiko, Ayweyo (New), Magina(New) East Kano wards 5. Proposals related to Muhoroni Constituency Muhoroni Constituency Six proposals were made: Miwani Ward, Ombeyi North Ward,  Split Muhoroni settlement Constituency- Comprise Masogo Ward,Nyang’oma Ward, of Muhoroni and Miwani constituencies (Boundary of Tamu Ward, Chemilil Ward, God the Settlement will be adopted) and Muhoroni Nyithindo Ward, Muhoroni Town Constituency- formed by the remaining part Ward, Owaga Ward,Ward, Fort Ternan Ward, Ombeyi South Ward And for North East Kano constituency to adopt the and Kabar Ward of Kisumu County. Miwani Division Boundaries (i) Muhoroni to remain as it is. (ii) To review Nyando, Muhoroni and Kisumu East Constituency boundaries and names to include Awasi, Kakola, Kikolo, Kochogo, Wawidhi, Onjiko wards; (iii) Muhoroni Constituency to be renamed Kano North Constituency to nclude Muhoroni township, Chemelil, Fort Tenan, God Nyithindo, Koru, Nyang‘oma, N.E Kano, Ombeyi, Miwani Locations (iv) Nyando Constituency to be renamed Kano East Constituency (v) Kano west Constituency – Comprise of Bwanda/Kanyagwal, Kawino, Kochieng‘Kombura/Katho, Kolwa East and Central

6. Proposals related to Nyakach Constituency North Nyakach-Rangul Ward, North  It was proposed that the existing Nyakach constituency East NyakachWard, South West be split into Upper Nyakach Constituency and Lower Nyakach Ward, Sigoti Ward, Nyakach Constituency. SouthNyakach Ward, Thurdibuoro  The following was proposed for the wards: Ward, East NyakachWard, West (i) Split Asawo to form Awaso and pap Onditi wards. Nyakach Ward, Nyakach-Nyalunya (ii) Split Oboch to form Oboch and South West Ward and Pap Onditi Ward of Nyakach wards Kisumu County. (iii) Split Nyalunya ward to form Nyalunya and Central Nyakach wards (iv) Split North nyakach to form North Nyakach and Rang‘ul ward. (v) North Nyakach be split into South Nyakach and

158

South East Nyakach ward

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kisumu County

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No major emerging issues.

159

5.3.44 County

(i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kasipul-Kabondo Constituency Kasipul Constituency Option 1 West Kasipul Ward, Central Kasipul The constituency to be split into two namely; (Part) Ward,Mawira-Rabuor Ward, 1. Kabondo Constituency created to comprise of the Wire Hill-Migwa Ward, Sikri Ward, current Kabondo Division; Obisa Ward, Ayoro Nyadong‟e 2. Kasipul Constituency created to comprise of the current Ward, and Kachien Ward. Kasipul Division

Option 2 Kabondo Constituency The current Kasipul Kabondo Constituency be split into Kawuor Ward, Kojwach Ward, three; Kokwanyo Ward,Kabondo-Ramba 1. Kasipul East Constituency; Ward, Kasewe Ward, Wang‟chieng 2. Kasipul West Constituency; Ward and Kakelo Ward 3. Kabondo Constituency 2. Proposals related to Karachuonyo Constituecny Proposal 1. Kanam Ward, Kibiri Ward, Central  Split the Constituency into three as follows, though KarachuonyoWard, Simbi-Kogembo respective wards not indicated at all: Ward, Gumba-Jieri Ward,Gendia- (i) Karachuonyo South (To Cover Kanyaluo and Kibiri Awach Ward, Rambira Ward, Divisions); Kanyaluo Ward,Kakdhimu Ward, (ii) Karachuounyo West (To Cover West and North Kanjira-Kobier Ward, Kokoth Ward West Divisions); and and Wang’chieng-Karabondi (iii) Karachuonyo East (To Cover North East and Ward. Central Divisions)  Split into two as follows: (i) West Karachuonyo ( Covering current West Karachuonyo Divisions); (ii) East Karachuonyo (Covering current East Karachuounyo Divisions) 3. Proposals related to Rangwe Constituency Proposal 1. Gem West Ward, Gem Central  Split Ragwe constituency into; Ward, Gem East Ward, Kochia West 1. Homa Bay Town; Comprising of Homa Bay town, Ward, Kochia East Ward, Kagan East and West Kanyadas; WestWard and Kagan East Ward. 2. Rangwe; Comprising of Gem Asumbi, Kochia and Kagan Locations

160

Proposal 2. Homa Bay Town Constituency  Split Ragwe constituency into; Kanyabala Ward, Katuma Ward, (i) Homa Bay Constituency; Along the present Asego Posta-Bonde Ward,Hospital-Central- Division Boundary; Market Ward, Kalanya Ward, (ii) Rangwe; Along the present Rangwe Division Kanyadier-Kothidha Ward, West Boundary Kanyada (Part) Ward and East Kanyada (Part) Ward.

4. Proposals related to Ndhiwa Constituency Proposal 1. West Kwabwai Ward, East Kwabwai  Split Ndhiwa into two to create the following: Ward, WestKanyidoto Ward, Riana (i) Ndiwa East (To cover Pala, Riana, Ndhiwa and West Ward, Kanyikela Ward, South Kobodo Divisions); Kanyamwa Ward, North Kanyamwa (ii) Ndhiwa West (To cover Kobama and Nyarongi Ward,Central Kabuoch Ward, South Divisions). Kabuoch Ward, Central Kanyamwa Proposal 2. Ward and West Kanyamwa Ward.  Split Ndhiwa into two to create the following: (i) Ndhiwa (To Cover Kobado and Ndhiwa Divisions); (ii) Ndiwa East or Riana Constituency (To cover Pala, Riana, Divisions); (iii) Ndhiwa West or Nyarongi Constituency (To cover Kobama and Nyarongi Divisions) 5. Proposals related to Mbita Constituency Option 1 Takawiri Island, Remba Island, 1. Mbita East Constituency to comprise Mbita Mainland Rusinga East Ward,West Mfangano made up of Gembe East, Gembe Central, Gembe West, Ward, Mfangano South Ward, Lambwe East and Lambwe West locations GembeEast Ward, Gembe Central 2. Mbita West Constituency to comprise all the Mbita Ward, Lambwe East Ward,Lambwe islands namely; Mfangano, Rusinga, Takawiri, Remba, West Ward, Kamasengre Ward, Ringiti, Atego, and other small island. Kaswanga-Wanyama Ward, Waware- Wakinga Ward, Kasgunga Central Option 2 Ward and Kasgunga West Ward. 1. Lambwe Constituency that, a constituency be created along the boundaries of Lambwe Valley Settlement Scheme curved out of Mbita constituency with its original boundaries as prescribed by the beacons to include Ruma location now in Gwassi Constituency. The constituency is named Lambwe Valley Settlement Scheme. 2. Mfangano Constituency

161

3. Mbita constituency 6. Proposals related to Mbita Constituency Gwasi Constituency  Suba Central constituency; That, a new constituency Migingo Island, Kaksingri East be curved out from the old , i.e. Mbita and Ward, Ruma Ward, Kaksingri West Gwassi constituencies should cede some of their parts Ward, Gwasi North Ward, Gwasi and it shall be formed by Sumba, Central and Gwassi Central Ward, Owich Kibwer Ward north divisions; and Gwasi WestWard of Homa Bay  Suba Central constituency comprising parts hived off County. from Mbita constituency, namely the Mfangano division and Central Division hived off from Gwassi constituency. To this will also be added the islands of Ringiti, Remba, Takawiri and other small islands. (ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No emerging issues.

162

5.3.45 Migori County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Nyatike Constituency  Split into Nyatike into two Constituencies along river Kuja as Kachieng’ Ward, Kanyasa follows:- Ward, Ndiwa Ward, Nyakwere . North Nyatike Constituency Ward, Kanyarwanda Ward, . South Nyatike Constituency Macalder Ward, Got Kachola  North Nyatike Constituency should include:- Ward, East Kadem Ward, Kaler . West and Central Karungu (Thakanchieng ward) Ward, Muhuru East Ward and . East and South East Karungu (Kanyasa ward) Muhuru West Ward of Migori . North and North East Kadem (Ndhiwa ward) County. . Central Kadem (Nyakwere ward) . South East Kadem (Macaldar ward)

 South Nyatike Constituency to include:- . West Kadem ( Got Kachora ward) . Southern Kadem (Kanyarwanda ward) . Karer Location (Karer ward) . Muhuru West location (Muhuri West ward) . Muhuru East (Muhuru East ward)  Others suggested not to be split Nyatike due to uneven distribution of resources.  There were suggestion to split the existing 11 constituencies to 61. The new ones should be:- West Muiru, Mairu South East, Muiru East, Muiru Central, West Kadem, East Kadem, Kater, Central Kadem, South East Kadem, and North Kadem

2. Proposals related to Uriri Constituency  It was suggestions that Uriri be divided into two constituencies:- North Kanyamkago Zone Ward, Uriri Constituency and Rapogi Constituency; Central Kanyamkago Zone Ward,  The Boundaries for Uriri Constituency should cover Oyani West Kanyamkago Zone Ward, division and Uriri division; South Kanyamkago Zone Ward,  Rapogi Constituency should include Kambogo division and East Kanyamkago Zone Ward Rapogi division; and Kamgundho Ward of Migori County.  Currently there are six wards, thus suggestions that each ward be divided into two = 12 wards to create 15 wards up from 12. These will be named as Central Kanyamkago; Karatini; Mpper

163

Kamgundo; Lower Kamgundo; South Kanyamkago; Buware; Kawere; Karateng (New); Lwala; Bware (New); Kinyupe; Kinjope (New); Lower Central Kamyamkago; and Lower Kangundo.  Every location to have a councillor 3. Proposals related to Migori Constituency Migori East  Migori district has 2 divisions; Suba West which has seven ConstituencyKakrao Ward, God locations and seven wards; and Suba East that has six locations Jope Ward, Kwa Ward, Milimani and six wards; Ward, Kadika Ward, Ward  Constituency should be divided into two:- Suba West and Nyasare Ward of Migori Constituency and Suba East Constituency; County.  Alternatively, it can be divided into Suna West Constituency and Suna East Constituency;  Or it can be divided into Migori East and Migori West being split along river Migori;  The following existing wards Giribe ward, Mukuro ward, God Migori West Constituency Jope ward, Upper Suna ward, North Suna ward, Ngege ward , Giribe Ward, Suna South Ward, Ragana ward and Oruba ward should be divided to form the Mukuro Ward, Suna Nyabisawa following new ones - Giribe ward, Wasimeeti ward, Mukuro ward, Ward, Oruba Ward and Ragana Rahaa ward, Suna East ward, God Jope ward Rabuor ward, Kwa Ward of Migori County. ward, Otacho ward, North Suna ward, Mapera ward, Ngege ward, Ragana ward, College ward, Oruba ward and Nyanguma ward 4. Proposals for Rongo Constituency  The Constituency be divided into two:- Rongo Constituency and West Kamagambo Ward, South Awendo Constituency; Kamagambo Ward, East  Boundaries for Awendo constituency to cover two divisions - Kamagambo Ward, North Awendo and Dede; Kamagambo Ward and Central  Rongo Constituency to have two divisions of Rongo and Chamgi Kamagambo Ward of Migori Wadu; County.

 Proposed that all existing locations should become wards. Awendo Constituency

North Sakwa Ward, South Sakwa

Ward, Central Sakwa Ward, East Sakwa Ward and West Sakwa Ward of Migori County. 5. Proposals related to Kuria Constituency Kuria West Constituency  Split Kuria Constituency into two constituencies:- Nyamosense Ward, Taranga’nya o Kuria East Constituency that will comprise of the Ward, Tagare Ward, Komosoko following divisions; Kegonga, Chinato, Ntimaru, and Ward, Getonga’nya Ward, Kwiho Masaba Ward, Kombe Ward, o Kuria West Constituency that will comprise of the Ikerege Ward, Nyamaharaga

164

following divisions:- Kehancha, Ikerege, Mabera, Masaba, Ward, Bukira Central Ward, and Isebania; Gokeharaka Ward, Getambwega  Prposed 7 additional wards to the existing 25 to form a total of 32 Ward, Kehancha Ward, Nyankore wards. Ward, Nyabikaye Ward and Nyametaburo Ward of Migori County. Kuria East Constituency Nyabasi West Ward, Maeta Ward, Nyabasi North Ward, Kegonga Ward, Wangirabose Ward, Ntimaru Ward, Siabai Ward, Gwitembe Ward and Kebaroti Ward of Migori County.

165

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Migori County (Kuria Excluded)

166

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

No emerging issues.

5.3.46 Kisii County (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Bobasi Consitituency It was proposed that Bobasi be split into two using tea processing zones to make demarcations as follows:- Emenwa-Nyoera Ward, Kiobegi- . Sameta Constituency and Bobasi/Borabu Constituency Gionseri Ward, Nyachogochogo Ward, or Sameta Constituency and Nyancheki Constituency; Nyantira Ward, Nyacheki . Sameta to be a Constituency (Bobasi Chache); Ward, Maji Mazuri Ward, Mosora . Nyacheki & Nyamache Division to form another (Bobasi Ward, Bobasi Masige Ward, Nyangusu Borabu); Ward and Bobasi Borabu Ward of Kisii . Turwa sub-location and Nyabisia Sub-locations to be part of County. Mosora ward because of communication problem. Alteranatively: Bobasi to be split into 2 1. Bassi Chache- Comprise of Itibo, Kenyerere and Orogare Division; 2. Basi Borabu Constituency- Comprised of Nyacheki, Bogetaorio, Suguta, Kiobegi Division 2. Proposals related to . Bomachoge Constituency  The Constituency comprise of two (2) districts namely:- Kenyenya District; and Ogembo District. Mokubo Ward, Kenyenya Ward,  The Constituency be divided into two Constituencies as Boochi Borabu Ward, Majoge Borabu follows:- Ward, Majoge Masaba Ward and 1. Bomachoge Borabu Constituency (Current Kenyenya Magenche Ward of Kisii County District); and 2. Bomachoge Chache Constituency (Current ).  Alternatively, divide Bomachoge into: 1. Kenyanya Constituency; and 2. Ogembo Constituency (Gucha Constituency).

 It is suggested also that the formation of the following Wards: Kerongoroni; Kimonge; Bokione Borabu and Kenyenya.

167

 There was suggestions to form the following wards for Kenyenya Town Council: Central Ward, Keberei Ward; Nyakoiba Ward; Omobera Ward; Enamba Ward and Nyabirongo Ward; and

3. It was further suggested that Bokiomonge and Bosoti should have two wards each and Kenyenya society to be called Nyangweta Ward. NOTE: Above presentations led to the creation of Gucha Gucha Constituency Constituency that comprises of 7 wards from Bomachoge Bosoti Ward, Nyaisero Ward, Misesi and 4 from Bobasi Ward, Egetuki Ward, Getare Ward, Central Ward, Tendere Ward, Sameta Ward, Bobasi Chache Ward, Mokwerero Ward and Bobasi Boitangare Ward of Kisii County. 4. Proposals related to South Mugirango South Mugirango Constituency Constituencies Nyansore Ward, Bogetenga Ward,  The Constituency be divided into two using river Kuja as a Boikanga West Ward, Boikanga East boundary between:- Ward, Getenga Ward, Chitago i. South Mugirango Borabu; and Ward, Borabu Ward, Nyachenge Ward, ii. South Mugirango Chache. Central-Ikoba Ward, Nyango- Kiburunga Ward, Otendo-Nyansakia Ward, Kabiero Ward and Bomonyara Ward of Kisii County. 4. Proposals related to Bonchari Constituency  It was suggested that Bonchari remains as it is currently – no subdivisions. Riana Ward, Bomokora Ward,  It was suggested that the wards for Suneka Town Council Nyamokenye Ward,Nyang‟iti Ward, be as follows: Bonyanchaire, Bomwancha, Township ward Ensaria Ward, Bukeira Ward, Bomariba (Suneka) and Suneka Town ward. Ward, Bogiakumu North Ward and  Gusii Town Council should formed by Bomariba West Bogiakumu South Ward of Kisii ward, Bomokura North ward and Riara South ward. County.

5. Proposals related to Nyaribari Masaba Constituency Nyaribari Masaba Constituency  Two suggestions were given as follows:- Kiamokama Ward, Mobamba Ward, i. Borabu be given first priority for a constituency and Ikorongo Ward, Metembe Ward, Kitutu Chache to be given a constituency; and Gesusu Ward, Ichuni Ward, Amabuko Ward, Kerema Ward, Ekware Ward and ii. Nyaribari Masaba constituency should remain undivided Ibacho Ward of Kisii County. with intact boundaries as it is now.

168

 It was suggested that the Wards for Masimba County Council should include the existing wards (4) Geteri, Ikenye, Masimba township, Riamichoki and Riabitutu;

 Keroka Township should include Keroka township ward, Keroka, Kiamirega, Riamakanda and Bogeche; and

 County Council of Gusii should include Nyamasibi, Nyankononi, Masaba, Magonga and Nyasike. 6. Proposals related to Nyaribari Chache Constituency Nyaribari Chache Constituency

It was suggestions as follows:- Kegati Ward, Kiogoro Ward, Birongo  Nyaribari Chache remains intact with its boundaries; Ward, Ibeno Ward, Keumbu Ward,  Gusii County Council should comprise of the 6 existing Kanga Hill Ward, Nyansira Ward, wards:- Nyamimiso; Nyosia; Nyanko; Nyamawa; Bobaracho Ward, Nyaura Ward, Nyamesocho; Nyankororo; Taracha; Nyamarwe; Bomuagi; Mwembe Tayari Ward and Boronyi Matunwa; and Nyaguta; Ward of Kisii County.  Kisii Municipality should include 5 existing wards namely:- Kiamabundu; Masongo; Nyanchwa; Kionganyo; Nyamage; Nyongusu; Nyataro; Masongo; Nyasacha; Central East; and Hospital ward. 7. Proposals related to Kitutu Chache Constituency Marani Constituency  The following suggestions were presented:- Option 1. Kegogi Ward, Ikuruma Ward, Sensi  Split the constituency into three constituencies namely: Ward, Mwamonari Ward, Marani Ward 1. North Kitutu Chache Constituency - comprising the upper and Matongo-Gesangero Ward of Kisii part. County. 2. South Kitutu Chache Constituency - comprising the Lower part. 3. Kisii Town ( Getembe) Constituency Mososcho Constituency

Option 2. Mosocho Ward, Bogeka Ward, Nyakoe i. Kitutu Chache Constituency be divided into two i.e. Ward, Nyatieko Ward, Nyankongo Marani Constituency and Mosocho Constituency. Ward, Kiamwasi Ward, Nyabururu ii. Marani Constituency to cover Marani district while Ward, Central Ward, Daraja Mbili Ward Mosocho Constituency covering areas of Mosocho and and Kiongongi Ward of Kisii County. Kisii Township in Kisii Central District.  The Wards within Kisii Township should be Nyabururu, Kiamuasi, Nyakongo, Daraja Mbili and Kiongongi but

169

additional ones such as Getembe, Mwamogesa, Nyambira and Geticha wards.  Marani County Council should comprise of Mwamoriari, Mwagichana, Kegogi, Ikuma, Matongo/Gesangera and Sesi. They further requested for two more wards: Mwakibagendi and Gesangero wards  It was suggested that Mosocho should comprise of Bogisero ward, Bogeka ward, Nyakoe ward, Nyanguru ward and Nyatieko ward. Further create Bogisero South and Bogisero North wards.

170

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Kisii County

171

(iii) Emerging Issues

 Nyaribari Chache The Community of interests were not considered. For instance a ward was curved out of Nyaribari Chache and taken to Borabu.  Bobasi The re- drawing of boundaries was not consultatively done. The transfer of wards from the neighboring Bobasi and Bamachoge constituencies to the new Gucha constituency was not consultative.

5.3.47 Nyamira (i) Public Presentations and IIBRC Proposals on Constituency Boundaries

Public Views IIBRC Proposals

1. Proposals related to Kitutu Masaba Constituency Kitutu Masaba Constituency  Kitutu Masaba comprises of Manga and Masaba Districts;  Manga district has three divisions namely:- Magombo Magombo Ward, Gachuba Ward, Division, Kemera Division and Manga Division; Rigoma Ward, Getare Ward, Biticha  Masaba District has Gesima Division, Rioma Division and sub-location in East Kitutu Ward, Gachuba Division; Nyankoba Ward, Tombe Ward, Omogonchoro Ward, Bugwendo  It was suggested that Kitutu Masaba be split into two as Ward, Miriri Ward, Kemera Ward and follows:- North Manga Ward of Nyamira . Kitutu Masaba Constituency County. . Central Kitutu Constituency . It was also suggested that the constituency can be along river Kuja . Kitutu Masaba South Constituency. . Kitutu Masaba North Constituency. (i) There was a proposal that the existing 11 wards to the following:- Nyamakoroto, Riamoni, Esami, Rigena, Geni, Nyaganya, East Kitutu, Sirate, Nyaguku, Gekano, Nyakongo, Ritongo, Nyikuro, Kianguso, and Nyangina. 2. Proposals related to North Mugirango/Borabu Constituency North Mugirango Constituency (ii) Divide the Constituency into two as follows:- i. Borabu Constituency (Borabu district) Omonono Ward, Nyaramba-Nyangoge ii. North Mugirango Constituency Ward, Mageri Ward, Magwagwa Ward, (iii) Recommended that the Constituency has 17 wards and should Itibo Ward, Bokeira Ward, Obwari be increased to 30 due to population of the area. The Ward, Mokomoni Ward, Ikonge Ward, following should be divided:-Omonono ward 2, Mekenene Bomwagamo Ward and Nyankono-

172

ward 2, Esakia ward 1, Central ward 2, Central ward 2, Kerumbe sublocation in Kiangeni Nyanamba ward 2, Matutu ward 1, Mageri ward 2, Magwanga Ward of . 3, Kiang‘eni 2, Umwagamo 2, Itibo 3, Bokeira ward 3, Obwani 2, Mokunguni 2 and Ikonge 2 Borabu Constituency

Matutu Ward, Ensakia Ward, Gesima Ward, Embaro sub-location of East Kitutu Ward, Mochenwa Ward,Central Ward, Bocharia Ward, Nyasore Ward, Esise Ward, Manga Ward, Mekenene Ward and Kitaru sublocation in Kiangeni Ward of Nyamira County.

3. Proposals related to West Mugirango West Mugirango Constituency (iv) The constituency has currently 12 wards and it is suggested that each ward be divided into two to form 24 new wards. Rangenyo Ward, Kebirigo Ward, Sironga Ward, Nyamira Ward, Bigege Ward, Motagara Ward, Bogichora (Part) Ward, Keera Ward, Bonyamatuta (Part) Ward, Ikobe Ward, Miruka Ward and Motontera Ward of Nyamira County.

173

(ii) IIBRC Proposed Map for Nyamira County

174

(ii) Emerging Issues (Acording to the JLA Report)

a) Kitutu Masaba

It emerged that about 60,000 people were moved to Borabu constituency without consultation while some constituencies with less people were given more constituencies. b) North Mugirango Some wards were moved to the existing or new constituencies. The requested number of constituencies were not granted. The community of interest request for North Mugirango to be splitin two was not given.

Note: the wards used by IIBRC in delimitation of constituencies are the local government electoral units as per 2007.

175

CHAPTER V PROPOSALS ON DELIMTATIONS OF COUNTY ASSEMBLYWARDS

5.0 Introduction The criteria for delimitation of wards is provided for in Article 89 (5) and (6) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010). Article 89(6) provides that the number of inhabitants of a constituency or Ward may be greater or lesser than the population quota by a margin of not more than— (a) forty per cent for cities and sparsely populated areas; and (b) thirty per cent for the other areas.

Article 89(12) of the Constitution defines ―population quota‖ by dividing the number of inhabitants of Kenya with the number of constituencies or wards, as applicable.

Article 89(3) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 provides that the IEBC shall review the number, names and boundaries of wards periodically. The Act requires that the Commission shoulr resolve all issues arising from the IIBRC review. Specifically, the Commission is given the following mandate as regards completion of the first review - (a) re-distribution of such wards or administrative units in the affected constituencies as may be appropriate; (b) subject to the Constitution, addressing issues of new constituencies falling outside the population quota as provided for by Article 89(6) of the Constitution but at the same time ensuring that such a process shall – (i) take into account the provisions of Article 89(7)(b) of the Constitution that requires progressive efforts and not instant demographic equality of all towards attaining the population quota in each constituency and Ward for the purposes of the first review; (ii) not be subject to new definitions of cities, urban areas and sparsely populated areas or to new population figures; (iii) be subject to the use of enumerated national census figures and not projected figures.

5.1 IEBC Determination of County Assembly Wards

The IEBC has applied a three-step process to determine the number of County Assembly Wards. Under the first step, the Commission determined the total number of wards into which the country shall be divided. In this respect, an upper limit of 1,450 is proposed1. According to the Report of the Task Force on Devolved Government (TFDG), each of the 290 constituencies will have a minimum of 3 and a maximum of 5 wards. The number of wards was determined using the number of constituencies in each County with the primary consideration for equity in representation in the

1 Final Report of the Taskforce on Devolved Government, Volume I

176

County. The TFDG in effect proposed to reduce Ward representatives from the current 3,465 including nominated councillors to about 2,000. The IEBC considers this national limit plausible as it enables a County to effectively fulfil its representation and oversight functions.

In computing the number of wards nationally, the IEBC has been guided by the constitutional provision that the number of inhabitants of a constituency or Ward may be greater or lesser than the population quota by a margin of not more than 40 per cent for cities and sparsely populated areas and 30 per cent for the other areas. For the constituency population quota, a figure of 133,138 was determined by the Constitution of Kenya (Total national population divided by the total number of constituencies). In a similar vein, the population quota for the Ward which is 26,628 has been arrived at by dividing the total national population by the total proposed number of wards. The population quota for the Ward obtained using the formula below is consistent with the population quota for the constituency as provided for under the Section 27(1)(b) of the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution of Kenya.

National Population as at 2009 Census =38,610,097 = 26,628 Total Number of Wards 1,450

The IEBC obtained the number of wards applicable to each constituency by computing the proportion of the population of the constituency in relation to the total population of the County and multiplying by the number of wards which the County is entitled to. The computation is based on a formula which serves to maintain equality between wards and the number of electors.

Total Population of Constituency X Number of wards allocated each County Total Population of each County

Applying the above formula ensures that even the smallest County has the required members of the County Assembly to perform its function. This approach takes cognisance of the inherent inequities in the populations of various counties and the imbalances in each constituency. This is because counties were created by the Constitution without regard to their populations. The approach therefore achieves equity of representation within the County and is therefore preferred by the IEBC. The table below presents the proposed determination of wards by IEBC based on the above approach and deviation from the quota.

The proposed county wards are annexed.

177

CHAPTER VI BOUNDARY DELIMITATION PROPOSALS & WAYFORWARD

6.0 Introduction The creation of electoral units in Kenya started with the creation of 117 Constituencies in 1963, followed by Constituency reviews in 1966 which then culminated in the creation of 210 Constituencies. The Independence Constitution of Kenya provided key criteria to guide the delimitation process. These criteria guided all the boundary reviews by the ECK and generally remained in place until the Constitutional Amendment of 29th December 2011 under which the criteria that guided the work of the IIBRC were enacted. Notably, the authority and criteria for delimitation of local authority electoral areas has been the same at that of Constituencies.2 With the promulgation of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, the IIBRC was mandated to determine the names and boundaries of wards against the criteria provided under the Constitution 3also to generally apply in the delimitation of county wards.

6.1 Methodology applied by the IIBRC

In reviewing constituency and ward boundaries, the Constitution of Kenya 2010 requires the Commission to consult all interested parties.4It is documented that the IIBRC held eight provincial visits and a total 106 public hearings whereof 20,726 attended the public hearings.

The objective of the public consultations was to collect views regarding electoral and administrative boundaries. All stakeholders were requested to present to the Commission oral submissions or written submissions either as individuals or groups and the public invited to give presentations through scheduled public hearings in existing constituencies.

6.2 Applicable Framework

Many of the submissions received offered suggestions on delimitation with emphasis on constitutional criterion. Various boundary concerns were brought to the attention of the IIBRC as it emerged that Kenyans were aware of the historical injustices in the delimitation of electoral and administrative boundaries of Kenya.

In consideration of the criteria under Article 89 of the constitution, public submissions and petitions should be presented within three key limits;

2 As provided under the Local Government Act 3 Article 89(5) 4 Article 89(7) of the Constitution

178

a) Community Interests: This relating to the historical, political, economic and cultural conflicts existing in various parts of the country. As such areas of economic interest to the community and the existence of a favorable economic infrastructure (schools; hospitals; market centers); presence of harmonious co-existence between communities and political stability that also protects the rights of minorities and marginalized communities posit as boundary concerns.

b) Geographical Features: For purposes of delimitation focus is on patterns of human settlement; land use and road networks and land cover for communications (TV; mobile telephony).Also inclusive of equities in resource allocation, natural and water resources and national security.

c) Communication Protocol: Means of communication also considers roads networks, telecommunications (mobile and radio telephony) and postal and courier services. All submissions should focus thereof on access to these services and infrastructure and the Commission in retrospect shall take into account views of the communities affected.

6.3 Work Plan The workplan for the delimitation exercise is developed on the basis of the mandate provided under the fifth schedule to the IEBC Act 2011. i. Collection, Analysis and presentation of data Information and data collected having been interpreted and legally analyzed informs the delimitation exercise. This involves collection and analysis of population data based on the constitutional provisions. Literature review undertaken not only covers the relevant documents cited under the IEBC Act but also covers maps and archival data on boundaries and boundary delimitation in Kenya, including best practices. ii. Field Visits Public hearings provide a tool for gathering and compiling relevant information from the general public on matters of concern in delimitation. This will also offer immediate feedback on emerging issues on suggestions for boundary variations.

Field visits by the IIBRC were organized to sensitise the general public and stakeholders on the mandate and responsibility of the IEBC and providing Kenyans and opportunity to contribute their views. These were structured to clusters of a minimum of 6 to a maximum of 12 constituencies per public hearing based on vicinity of selected constituencies per region and were conducted for a consecutive period of 3months. iii. Memorandum Written submissions-memoranda were presented to the IIBRC by all interested parties, either individuals or groups seeking to have their views equally taken into consideration.

179

These too were strictly based on the mandate of the IIBRC and Constitutional criteria for delimitation.

iv. Analysis of data collected The IIBRC analysed data against the constitutional provisions using analytical tools-ICT and GIS

The most appropriate media for communication will be identified and employed by the Commission to reach the stakeholders and general public. And to achieve optimum results, it is expected, through civic education; that the general public will be equipped with the requisite knowledge on the process of delimitation to enable them submit their views against the constitutional provisions. Stakeholder, consultation will focus on key principles in the public and private sector, which strategy may be further supplemented by interactive media briefings.

Data from field visits and public hearings is to be analysed in relation to constituency and community groupings on community interest, geographical features and means of communication.

180