Dharma Planet Survey of Fgkm Dwarfs: Survey Preparation and Early Science Results
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DHARMA PLANET SURVEY OF FGKM DWARFS: SURVEY PREPARATION AND EARLY SCIENCE RESULTS By SIRINRAT SITHAJAN A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2018 ⃝c 2018 Sirinrat Sithajan I dedicate this to my family and friends who always love and support me unconditionally. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I greatly appreciate many people for helping me achieve this success. Firstly, I would like to thank my parents for encouraging me to follow the career path I love, being an astronomer. This has brought my life full of great experiences and happiness. I especially want to thank my husband, San, who loves me unconditionally and always stands by my side. He usually gives me good advice and cheers me up when I have a hard time. I also would like to thank my advisor, Dr. Jian Ge, who has given me many great work opportunities including working at Kitt Peak Observatory. Staying overnight at the observatory, monitoring target stars, and taking data were a marvelous experience and made me more appreciate my research work. I would like to thank my dissertation committee: Dr. Jian Ge, Dr. Jonathan Tan, Dr. Katia Matcheva, and Dr. James Fry for their constructive advice. I want to thank my close friends from high school for always keeping in touch with me wherever they are in the world. We have been sharing stories about our life living abroad and how to deal with various difficulties. We sometimes meet up and travel together, so I never feel lonely. I would like to thank Dr. Bo Ma who gave me valuable advice when I got stuck on some particular points of my research, and he also helped me find bugs in my programs. I want to thank Nolan Grieves for proofreading my papers and giving constructive comments. Finally, I would like to thank UF classmates who have worked and had fun together. They made me had a wonderful graduate student life in the US. 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................... 4 LIST OF TABLES ...................................... 7 LIST OF FIGURES ..................................... 8 ABSTRACT ......................................... 11 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION ................................... 13 1.1 Dharma Planet Survey .............................. 13 1.2 History of Radial Velocity Method to Detect Planets .............. 14 1.3 Motivations for Improving Planet Detection Sensitivity of Radial Velocity Surveys 15 1.4 Challenges in the Detection of Low Mass Planets ................ 17 1.4.1 Observing Cadence ............................ 17 1.4.2 Measurement Precision .......................... 18 1.5 Areas of Emphasize ............................... 20 2 TARGET SELECTION ................................. 21 2.1 Method ...................................... 21 2.2 Results ...................................... 23 2.3 Conclusions .................................... 25 3 SIMULATIONS OF OBSERVATIONS ......................... 37 3.1 Simulation Method ................................ 37 3.2 Results ...................................... 42 3.3 Conclusions .................................... 48 4 SIMULATIONS OF PLANET DETECTIONS ..................... 53 4.1 Simulation Method ................................ 53 4.1.1 Precision of Radial Velocity Measurements ............... 53 4.1.2 Simulated Radial Velocity Data ..................... 55 4.1.3 Planet Detectability ........................... 58 4.2 Results ...................................... 60 4.2.1 Planet Detectability of the Dharma Planet Survey ........... 60 4.2.2 Planet Yields ............................... 60 4.3 Conclusion .................................... 61 5 EFFECT OF TELLURIC LINES ON RADIAL VELOCITY MEASUREMENTS .... 65 5.1 Simulation Method ................................ 66 5 5.1.1 Simulated Observed Spectra ....................... 66 5.1.2 Precision of Radial Velocity Measurements ............... 70 5.1.3 Telluric Line Correction .......................... 72 5.1.3.1 The masking method ..................... 72 5.1.3.2 The modeling method ..................... 72 5.2 Results ...................................... 75 5.2.1 The Effect of Telluric Lines in Optical, Broad-Optical, and NIR Regions 75 5.2.2 Treatment of Telluric Contamination .................. 76 5.2.2.1 Optical wavelength region ................... 76 5.2.2.2 Broad-Optical and NIR wavelength regions .......... 77 5.3 Conclusions .................................... 79 6 CURRENT STATUS OF THE DHARMA PLANET SURVEY AND EARLY SCIENCE RESULTS ....................................... 88 6.1 Instrument and Pipeline Performance ...................... 88 6.2 Observation ................................... 90 6.3 Planet Detection ................................. 96 REFERENCES ........................................ 115 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH ................................. 120 6 LIST OF TABLES Table page 2-1 Reference sources of stellar properties used in the target selection. .......... 24 2-2 List of target stars for the Dharma Planet Survey and their stellar parameter values. 32 2-3 Minimum and maximum values for stellar parameters of the DPS targets in each spectral type. ..................................... 36 3-1 Percentage of available time that can be used for observation. ............ 41 3-2 Summary of observations for the target stars. ..................... 49 4-1 Planet yields of 150 target stars observed in the Dharma Planet Survey ....... 62 5-1 Signal to noise ratio of the simulated spectra with different effective temperatures (or spectral types) at 1.25 µm and 0.55 µm. ..................... 70 5-2 The fraction of stellar spectrum remaining for the RV precision calculation after contaminating telluric lines with different strengths are masked. ........... 74 6-1 The DPS target stars observed between October 2016 - April 2018. ......... 93 6-2 List of the planet and planet candidates from the Dharma Planet Survey. ...... 97 7 LIST OF FIGURES Figure page 1-1 Detection probability of planets with different masses and orbital periods around the stars observed in the Lick-Carnegie Exoplanet Survey ............... 18 1-2 Detection probability of planets with different masses and orbital periods around the stars observed in the Eta-Earth Survey ...................... 19 2-1 Distribution of the Right Ascensions and Declinations of the DPS target stars ... 25 2-2 Distance distribution of the DPS Targets ....................... 26 2-3 V magnitude distribution of the DPS Targets ..................... 27 2-4 H-R diagram of the DPS targets ........................... 28 2-5 Stellar mass distribution of the DPS Targets ..................... 29 2-6 Stellar rotational velocity distribution of the DPS Targets .............. 30 0 2-7 Log RHK index distribution of the DPS Targets .................... 31 3-1 Simulated observing schedule for December 29th, 2018 ................ 39 3-2 Kitt Peak weather statistics during 1999-2006 .................... 40 3-3 Comparison between simulated weather patterns of January 2017 and January 2018 42 3-4 Simulated weather in the night of December 29th, 2018 ............... 43 3-5 Simulated observing report for December 29th, 2018 ................. 44 3-6 The number of observations received by the target stars at the end of observing period ......................................... 45 3-7 Time span the target stars needed to obtained 100 observations ........... 45 3-8 Time span the target stars needed to obtained 100 observations as a function of RA 46 3-9 Simulated Observations of GJ 761.1 .......................... 46 3-10 Simulated Observations of GJ 708.4 .......................... 47 3-11 Simulated Observations of GJ 892 ........................... 48 4-1 The overall detection efficiency of the TOU spectrograph as a function of wavelength 55 4-2 Estimated RV measurement precisions of the DPS target stars ............ 56 4-3 Simulated RV data set 1 ................................ 58 8 4-4 Simulated RV data set 2 ................................ 59 4-5 Distribution of planet eccentricities used in simulating RV data ........... 60 4-6 Simulated RV data set 3 ................................ 61 4-7 Planet detectability of 0.5-MJ star .......................... 62 4-8 Planet detectability of the Dharma Planet Survey in the baseline case ........ 63 4-9 Planet detectability of the Dharma Planet Survey in the pessimistic case ...... 64 5-1 Synthetic atmospheric transmission used in simulating observed stellar spectra ... 68 5-2 Simulated stellar spectra with and without telluric lines ............... 69 5-3 Radial velocities measured from simulated observed spectra with different input barycentric velocities ........................................ 71 5-4 Spectral regions that are masked out from RV precision calculation due to strong telluric lines ...................................... 73 5-5 Simulated observed spectra after telluric lines are modeled and subtracted out ... 76 5-6 Radial velocity measurement error caused by telluric lines in the Optical, Broad-Optical, and NIR regions. .................................... 77 5-7 Radial velocity precision of the Optical, Broad-Optical, and NIR spectra contaminated with telluric lines, assuming SNR=200 ........................ 78 5-8 Radial velocity precision of the Optical, Broad-Optical, and NIR spectra contaminated with telluric lines, assuming SNR=1000 ........................ 79 5-9 Radial velocity precision of the Optical region when strong telluric lines are masked out,