Slavery and Manumission in Baltimore and Early National Maryland
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Kentucky UKnowledge African American Studies Race, Ethnicity, and Post-Colonial Studies 1997 The Price of Freedom: Slavery and Manumission in Baltimore and Early National Maryland T. Stephen Whitman Click here to let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Thanks to the University of Kentucky Libraries and the University Press of Kentucky, this book is freely available to current faculty, students, and staff at the University of Kentucky. Find other University of Kentucky Books at uknowledge.uky.edu/upk. For more information, please contact UKnowledge at [email protected]. Recommended Citation Whitman, T. Stephen, "The Price of Freedom: Slavery and Manumission in Baltimore and Early National Maryland" (1997). African American Studies. 19. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/upk_african_american_studies/19 THE PRICE OF FREEDOM This page intentionally left blank THE PRICE OF FREEDOM SLAVERY AND MANUMISSION IN BALTIMORE AND EARLY NATIONAL MARYLAND T. Stephen Whitman THE UNIVERSITY PRESS OF KENTUCKY Publication of this volume was made possible in part by a grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities. Copyright 1997 by The University Press of Kentucky Scholarly publisher for the Commonwealth, serving Bellarmine College, Berea College, Centre College of Kentucky, Eastern Kentucky University, The Filson Club Historical Society, Georgetown College, Kentucky Historical Society, Kentucky State University, Morehead State University, Murray State University, Northern Kentucky University, Transylvania University, University of Kentucky, University of Louisville, and Western Kentucky University. All rights reserved Editorial and Sales Offices: The University Press of Kentucky 663 South Limestone Street, Lexington, Kentucky 40508-4008 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Whitman, T. Stephen, 1950- The price of freedom : slavery and manumission in Baltimore and early national Maryland I T. Stephen Whitman. p. em. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-8131-5554-8 1. Slavery-Maryland. 2. Slavery-Maryland-Baltimore. 3. Slaves-Emancipation-Maryland. 4. Slaves-Emancipation Maryland-Baltimore. 5. Maryland-History. 6. Maryland-Race relations. 7. Baltimore (Md.)-History. 8. Baltimore (Md.)-Race relations. I. Title. E445.M3W45 1997 975.2'00496-dc20 96-27386 This book is printed on acid To Dorothy]. and Aaron T. Whitman This page intentionally left blank CONTENTS List of Illustrations and Maps ix List of Tables xi Acknowledgments xiii Introduction 1 1 SLAVERY IN EARLY NATIONAL BALTIMORE AND RURAL MARYLAND 8 2 INDUSTRIAL SLAVERY IN BALTIMORE 33 3 THE BLACK DRIVE FOR AUTONOMY AND MASTERS' RESPONSES 6r 4 MANUMISSION AND THE TRANSFORMATION OF SLAVERY 93 5 FREE BLACK FAMILY STRATEGIES FOR GAINING FREEDOM rr9 6 POLITICAL-ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND FREE BLACKS 140 Conclusions 158 Appendix A: Baltimore Slaveholders, 1790-1820 167 Appendix B: Occupational Categories 170 Appendix C: Sale Prices of Term Slaves and Slaves for Life 175 Notes 178 Bibliography 216 Index 233 This page intentionally left blank ILLUSTRATIONS 1. BUSINESS CARD OF MARYLAND CHEMICAL WORKS, 1828 44 2. FARDY AND AULD'S SHIPYARD, 1854 59 3. BROADSIDE, 1810 ro6 4. BROADSIDE, 1825 ro7 5. BALTIMORE STREET, 1811 146 MAPS 1. STATE OF MARYLAND, 1794 34 2. CITY AND ENVIRONS OF BALTIMORE, 1801 38 This page intentionally left blank TABLES 1. Slave Population in Baltimore, Dorchester, and Prince George's Counties, 1790-1860 10 2. Slaveholding and Wealth: Proportions of Slaveholders by Deciles of Taxable Wealth, Baltimore, 1813 17 3. Slaveholding and Wealth: Craftsmen and Manufacturers versus Other Wealth Holders, Baltimore, 1813 18 4. Numbers of Slaves Held by Craftsmen and Manufacturers, in Comparison to Slaveholders of Other Known Occupations, 1790-1820 19 5. Free and Slave Workers: Employment Duration at the Maryland Chemical Works 41 6. Number of Slaves and Free Workers at the Maryland Chemical Works 42 7. Annual Cost per Slave at the Maryland Chemical Works, 1828 55 8. Annual Cost per Slave at the Maryland Chemical Works, 1829 56 9. Destinations of Male Runaways from Baltimore Masters and Runaway Rates, 1773-1820 70 10. Conditions of Slave Sales Imposed by Baltimore Sellers, 1791-1820 76 11. Slave Dealing and Runaway Rates, 1811-1820 79 12. Advertisements for Sales of Baltimore Slave Women of Childbearing Age, 1791-1820 82 13. Manumission of Children, 1770-1830 133 14. Immediate Manumission of Children by Sex and Age at Freedom 134 15. Delayed Manumissions of Children: Sex and Length of Service 135 This page intentionally left blank ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to thank those who have helped me with this work. My colleagues at Mount St. Mary's have given me time to work and a summer study grant that enabled me to use that time to write. The archivists and staff of the Maryland State Archives and the Maryland Historical Society have unfailingly done a superb job, not only in ob taining materials I wanted, but also in helping me to figure out what might aid my inquiries. Many fellow researchers at the archives have shared ideas, but I owe a special debt of gratitude to Lois Green Carr and Phoebe Jacobsen for their sustained interest, encouragement, and observations. Chapters 2 and 4 have appeared in different form as ar ticles in the Journal of Southern History and Social Science History respectively; the editors' and anonymous referees' comments have been useful and enlightening. Stephanie Cole, Christine Daniels, Curt Johnson, Robert Olwell, Chris Phillips, James Rice, Stephen Sarson, James Sidbury, and Frank Towers have all read portions of this work and provided valuable comments. William Freehling's seminar on antebel lum history first sparked my interest in slavery and manumission, an interest nurtured by his subsequent support and insights and by his invaluable suggestions on how to revise the work for publication. Jack Greene kindly invited me to present my work at an informal workshop on slavery in 1993; the comments of the participants, especially Wilma King's, gave me several new ideas to pursue. To Ronald Walters, who supervised this work at the dissertation stage, my thanks not only for his indefatigable efforts to sharpen my thinking and writing, but also for his even-tempered dealing with an advisee who might easily have exhausted his patience. This page intentionally left blank INTRODUCTION During the first half century of American independence, Baltimore's population multiplied to make it the nation's third largest city. Within a single life span the mid eighteenth-century village at the mouth of Jones' Falls Creek swelled to a city of eighty thousand souls, spreading northeastward from the Patapsco River to Fells' Point in a crescent-shaped swarm of houses, shops, mills, and shipyards. In this vibrant and tumultuous environ ment, with spurts of virtually volcanic growth punctuated by short but prostrating slumps, workers of all statuses, whether free, apprenticed, indentured, or enslaved, were sought out by merchants, manufacturers, and craftsmen. Until the prolonged hard times of the 1820s, entrepre neurs regarded bound workers as key assets in seeking steady produc tion and profits from Baltimore's first flowering. Maryland's blacks played a vital part in making both Baltimore's fortunes and their own. Arriving as slaves either purchased from or migrating with masters leaving the Eastern and lower Western Shores of Maryland, they soon seized opportunities to earn money for them selves as well as their masters. For many, hard labor and its earnings became tools with which to carve out autonomy within slavery and, ultimately, to propel themselves out of slavery through self-purchase or manumission granted after a further term of service. So widespread were such manumissions that by 1830 four-fifths of Baltimore's blacks were legally free, the largest group of free people of color in any U.S. city. Meanwhile, blacks elsewhere in Maryland achieved freedom much more slowly, though still in impressive numbers. Nearly three-quarters of the state's rural blacks were still slaves in 1830. Before 1850 free persons of color outnumbered slaves only in Cecil and Caroline Coun ties, the former abutting on free Pennsylvania and the latter on north ern Delaware, where slavery had become moribund. Thus, Baltimore's hinterlands remained strongly committed to slave labor even as blacks transformed the city into an island of freedom. 1 2 The Price of Freedom Understanding Maryland's and Baltimore's experience with slavery and emancipation requires locating Maryland and Baltimore in con text, both spatially and temporally. On the eve of the American Revo lution every colony of British North America had slaves, and as Jack Greene has noted, their numbers were everywhere on the increase, even in such unlikely milieus as New Hampshire.1 But something happened over the next fifty years. By the 1820s slavery had become almost en tirely southern, as states from Pennsylvania northward gradually abol ished it. Accounting for this dramatic change in American society has generated a torrent of historical analysis and controversy. One broad band of thinking, perhaps best exemplified by the work of David Brion Davis, stresses the development of antislavery sensibili ties in seeking to explain the geographic contraction of slavery: in the late eighteenth century, large numbers of people first began to think and write that slavery was wrong, even indefensibly wrong, in a moral or religious sense. 2 These sensibilities, reinforced by republicanism