OEB51 Lecture 9 Mollusk Embryology Ctenophora Animals Porifera Placozoa Cnidaria Xenacoelomorpha Parahoxozoa Ambulacraria Echinodermata Hemichordata Planulozoa Deuterostomia Cephalochordata Chordata Urochordata Bilateria Craniata Chaetognatha Bryozoa Entoprocta Cycliophora Nephrozoa Annelida Trochozoa Mollusca Nemertea Brachiopoda Phoronida Spiralia Gastrotricha Protostomia Platyhelminthes Gnathostomulida Micrognathozoa Gnathifera Rotifera Nucleariida Orthonectida Fungi Dicyemida Opisthokonta Filasterea Priapulida Ichthosporea Scalidophora Holozoa Animals Loricifera Choanoflagellata Kinorhyncha Nematoida Nematoda Ecdysozoa Nematomorpha Tardigrada Panarthropoda Onychophora Arthropoda Spiral cleavage general proper es II • Four cell stage: – May be equal sized blastomeres or unequal • (at 2 and 4 cell stages) Some Spiralia show Polar Lobe forma on Polar Lobe Forma on. Example 1.
Acila castrensis
Remember the polar lobe is not the same as the polar body! You can see both of these “polar things” in this movie. Make sure you know which is which! Polar Lobe Forma on. Example 2.
Pulsellum sp. Phylum Mollusca Snails, bivalves, squid
• direct and indirect development • vast majority of classes show spiral cleavage • e.g. Ilyanassa obsoleta (snail) • emerging system for molecular embryology • cephalopod classes have very modified cleavage (and modified body plans) • e.g. Loligo pealei (squid): no spiral cleavage Spiral cleavage can be sinistral (to the le ) or dextral (to the right)
Lymnaea stagnalis Shibazaki et al. (2010) Curr Biol Microtubules (red) and microfilaments (green) during third cleavage:
Sinistral Dextral Turns a er Turns before cleavage cleavage
The spiral arrangement can be achieved by different mechanisms Lymnaea stagnalis Shibazaki et al. (2010) Curr Biol The roles of microtubules (red) and microfilaments (green) during third cleavage: Turns a er Turns before cleavage cleavage Nocodazole inhibits Latrunculin A inhibits microtubule polymeriza on ac n polymeriza on
Microtubules needed for Polymerized ac n needed for Dextral cleavage Sinistral cleavage Cytoskeletal elements play different roles in dextral and sinistral embryos Lymnaea stagnalis Shibazaki et al. (2010) Curr Biol NATURE | Vol 462 | 10 December 2009 LETTERS
Sinistral or dextral arrangement of cleavage can be changed manually Lucifer Yellow
Sinistralization of Dextralization of dextral embryo sinistral embryo a d g k
+ Trace b e h l o 1Q
c f i m p 2q 2Q 1q
j n q Lymnaea stagnalis 1 Kuroda et al. (2009) Nature 1q 1q2
Figure 1 | Reversal of the third cleavage directions by micromanipulation chirality by manipulating as in d–f and culturing them. The resultant and the resultant 8-, 12- and 16-cell stage embryos. Dextral embryos at the dextral-typeeight-cellstage sinistralembryo (g, k) was compacted(h, l, o) and metaphase-anaphase (a) and sinistral embryos at the telophase (d) of the then cleaved into 12- (i, m, p) and 16-cell (j, n, q) embryos, which arose from third cleavage were manipulated. The first quartet of micromeres getting the typical non-synchronous division of macromeres (1Q) and micromeres generated was continuously pushed towards the direction opposite to (1q). Each blastomere of 1Q (o) and 1q (p) divided in the dextral-type normal by glass rods (sinistrally for the dextral embryo (b) and dextrally for anticlockwise direction and produced their descendants 2q-2Q (p) and 1q1- the sinistral embryo (e)), which resulted in chirality-inverted sinistral-type 1q2(q), respectively. a–j, Bright field image; k–q, fluorescence image with (c) and dextral-type (f) eight-cell embryos, respectively. Fluorescence- outline of blastomeres (o–q). Arrows (o, p) indicate the spindle orientation. imaged cell-lineage tracing was carried out by injecting Lucifer Yellow dye Scale bar, 100 mm. into one quadrant of the four-cell stage sinistral embryo, then reversing the Fig. 2p, v) and their internal organ asymmetry was examined in detail. do not show them20 (see below). SD is a helical deformation of the Fully grown ‘sinistralized’ and ‘dextralized’ snails had pulmonary sac, blastomeres at the metaphase–anaphase, and SI is a spiral orientation anus, male and female genital pores open at the left or right side of the of the four spindles, as a consequence of SD, before the cleavage 20 body (Fig. 2e, k), just like the normal sinistral (Fig. 2q) and the dextral furrow ingression . We have succeeded in making F7 congenic ani- (Fig. 2w) snails, respectively, and internal organs, such as heart, mals, which inherit 99.2% of sinistral strain-derived and 0.8% of the stomach, liver coiling and gut looping, with the shape and positions dextral strain-derived genome. Remarkably, SD and SI were observed (Fig. 2f, l) just like the normal sinistral (Fig. 2r) and dextral (Fig. 2x) in all the dextral embryos oviposited by F7 animals that inherit the snails, respectively. Thus, the chirality-reversed embryos at the eight- dextrality gene(s), but not in any of the sinistral embryos oviposited cell stage developed to situs inversus. We did not observe situs solitus by F7 snails devoid of the dextrality gene(s). Thus, the organismal or situs ambiguus. The reversed-coiled snails were fertile, and pro- handedness-determining gene(s) is strongly linked to, or is, the gene duced sinistral or dextral progenies dictated by their genotype and that induces or activates SD and/or SI. We made dextral snails by not the reversed body handedness (Supplementary Table 1). pushing the micromeres of sinistral embryos from the telophase Although chirality is the most prominent at the third cleavage, it without SD. can be traced back to the first and second cleavages21. We altered, by These results suggest that chiral blastomere configuration is the key manipulation, the directions of blastomere rotations of both the factor in handedness determination, which is achieved by SD and SI sinistral and dextral embryos at the first or the second cleavage to genetically in the wild, and by micromanipulation in our experiments. produce reversed blastomere configuration at the four-cell stage. The epigenetic manipulation reprograms the left–right asymmetry However, the manipulated embryos all reverted to the original-type determination most probably by altering blastomere arrangement third cleavage (Supplementary Fig. 2). We also observed that sinistral around the 3D organizer which is specified at the 24-cell stage23. In embryos occasionally showed dextral-type blastomere arrangement the case of C. elegans, it has been reported13 that mechanical treatment at the four-cell stage even in the egg capsules, but they all showed at the six-cell stage produced chirality-reversed animals, similar to the normal anticlockwise cleavage at the third division. Thus, macro- case of L. stagnalis. Although spindle orientation is important in both mere–micromere cell contacts at the eight-cell stage embryo appear species, L. stagnalis appears to adopt a different chirality determining to be the first determining step for asymmetric development of snails. pathway (see below). We have studied the orthologues of Ga and We have previously reported that dextral and sinistral snail several cell polarity-related proteins (for example, Par6, atypical embryos are not mirror images of each other at the third cleavage PKC) for the sinistral and the dextral L. stagnalis, but no chirality- (refs 20, 22). The dominant dextral snails exhibit spiral deformation dependent difference was observed in their expression (T. Homma, (SD) and spindle inclination (SI), while the recessive sinistral snails M.S. and R.K., unpublished results). 791 ©2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved Ilyanassa obsoleta – development to veliger larva Ilyanassa obsoleta – micromere fate maps
8 cell stage
First quartet micromeres: 1a, 1b, 1c, 1d 1a and 1c make eyes normally
When 1a and 1c are removed, eyes are missing Ilyanassa obsoleta – micromere poten als
Cytoplasmic determinants are not the whole story
Put 1a into the posi on of 1b: 1a no longer makes eyes!
What prevents 1b and 1d from making eyes? Ilyanassa obsoleta – micromere poten als
Experiment: FIRST Remove the polar lobe contents at first cleavage THEN Put 1d into the posi on of 1a
1d can make eyes!
The polar lobe contents give 1D the power to repress 1d’s eye making poten al Ilyanassa obsoleta – recall that micromeres have different poten als
What is special about the polar lobe (and the D lineage) that makes it able to repress poten als of neighbouring cells? Ilyanassa obsoleta – one molecular mechanism for segrega ng cytoplasmic determinants The D lineage inherits specific mRNAs encoding for signaling molecules This enables 1D to signal to neighboring cells like 1d
mRNA tubulin centrosome DNA mRNAs segregate to specific cell lineages Loligo pealeii – these mollusc embryos look nothing like spiralian embryos Cephalopod hatching
h ps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6geyV0i3QI RESEARCH | REPORTS
ORIGIN OF NOTOCHORD by double WMISH (Fig. 2, F to L). Although none of the genes were exclusively expressed in the annelid mesodermal midline, their combined Development of the annelid coexpression was unique to these cells (implying that mesodermal midline in annelids and chor- damesoderm in vertebrates are more similar to axochord: Insights into each other than to any other tissue). It is unlikely that the molecular similarity between annelid notochord evolution and vertebrate mesodermal midline is due to in- dependent co-option of a conserved gene cas- Antonella Lauri,1*† Thibaut Brunet,1* Mette Handberg-Thorsager,1,2‡ sette, because this would require either that this Antje H.L. Fischer,1§ Oleg Simakov,1 Patrick R. H. Steinmetz,1‖ Raju Tomer,1,2¶ cassette was active elsewhere in the body (which is not the case) or that multiple identical inde- Philipp J. Keller,2 Detlev Arendt1,3# pendent events of co-option occurred (which is The origin of chordates has been debated for more than a century, with one key issue being unparsimonious). As in vertebrates, the meso- the emergence of the notochord. In vertebrates, the notochord develops by convergence dermal midline resembles the neuroectodermal and extension of the chordamesoderm, a population of midline cells of unique molecular midline, which expresses foxD, foxA, netrin, slit, identity. We identify a population of mesodermal cells in a developing invertebrate, the marine and noggin (figs. S6 and S7) but not brachyury or annelid Platynereis dumerilii,thatconvergesandextendstowardthemidlineandexpressesa twist.However,unlikeinchicken(10), the an- notochord-specific combinationofgenes.Thesecellsdifferentiateintoalongitudinalmuscle, nelid mesodermal and ectodermal midline pop- the axochord, that is positioned between central nervous system and axial blood vessel and ulations are not directly related by lineage (fig. S2). secretes a strong collagenous extracellular matrix. Ancestral state reconstruction suggests that Last, the Platynereis mesodermal midline is contractile mesodermal midline cells existed in bilaterian ancestors. We propose that these devoid of paraxis,whichisexclusivelyexpressed cells, via vacuolization and stiffening, gave rise to the chordate notochord. in laterally adjacent mesoderm (fig. S8), in line with its vertebrate ortholog demarcating par- axial mesoderm (11). In vertebrates, this segre- efining the propertiesFischer et al. andFrontiers characteristics in Zoology 2010, 7:31bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) body side (5) gation depends on canonical Wnt signaling, with of the last commonhttp://www.frontiersinzoology.com/content/7/1/31 ancestor of bilaterian that stood out by early and continuous expression b-catenin–positive cells preferentially adopting animals, Urbilateria, is a key question of of colA1,encodingcollagentypeA(Fig.2,AtoD). aparaxialfateandposition(12). Consistently, we the evolution and development field (1). SiMView light sheet microscopy (6)revealedthat observed nuclear localization of b-catenin in the In an attempt to infer a possible urbila- these cells moved underneath the neuroectoderm more-lateral mesoderm only, and b-catenin over-
Dterian precursor for the chordate notochord (2, 3), toward the midline until they contacted their bi- activation converted the mesodermal midline on February 4, 2016 RESEARCH Open Access we reasoned that this structure should occupy lateral counterpart (movie S1 and Fig. 2E). Sub- toward a more lateral fate and position (fig. S8). asimilarpositionwithregardtooverallmor- sequently, these cells narrowed and elongated We next compared the developmental fate of phology and molecular topography during de- without a net increase in cell surface (fig. S1), annelid and vertebrate mesodermal midline cells. velopment and in theThe adult body normal plan of living developmentand additional adaxial mesodermal of Platynereis cells were Phalloidin dumerilii staining and expression analysis of descendants (Fig. 1, A and B); that it should observed to intercalate between the elongating muscle markers (fig. S9) revealed that, after express, during its development,(Nereididae, a suite of genes Annelida)pairs (Fig. 2E), reminiscent of the processes by elongation, the Platynereis mesodermal midline that have proven specificAntje HL and Fischer indispensable1*, Thorsten for Henrichwhich1,2, Detlev the chordamesoderm Arendt1* converges and ex- cells differentiate into the previously described
notochord formation in the chordates; and that tends (table S1) (7). Lineage tracking by targeted “medial ventral longitudinal muscle” (13)(Fig.3A). Downloaded from it should be of widespread occurrence in bilate- photoconversion of the fluorescent protein kikGR Given the ropelike appearance and axial position rian body plans (Fig. 1C). We focused our search confirmed the origin of these cells from the meso- of this muscle, we propose to call it “axochord.” A Abstract on the model annelid Platynereis dumerilii,which dermal bands (fig. S2). muscular nature of a putative invertebrate count- is amenable to molecularBackground: studies andThe has polychaete retained annelidThePlatynereis unique location, dumerilii is large an emerging size, and model specific organismerpart for of the the study chordate of notochord is consistent with more ancestral featuresmolecular than Drosophila developmental melano- processes,arrangement evolution, of neurobiology the Platynereis andmesodermal marine biology. mid- Annelidsthe observationbelong to the that in the most basal chordate, gaster or CaenorhabditisLophotrochozoa, elegans (4). By looking the so far for understudiedline cells third allowed major their branch unambiguous of bilaterian animals identifi- besidesamphioxus, deuterostomes the notochord and is composed of spe- cell populations thatecdysozoans. would resembleP. dumerilii the verte-has provencation highly after relevant whole-mount to explore in ancient situ hybridization bilaterian conditionscialized via muscle comparison cells to(14 the)andexpressesthesame brate chordamesodermdeuterostomes, (a population because of mesoder- it has accumulated(WMISH) and less thus evolutionary expression change profiling than byconventional con- muscle ecdysozoan markers models. (15). We further observed segmen- mal midline cells thatPrevious converge staging medially was tomainly give referringfocal to imaging. hours post To fertilization test a possible but did homology not allow of matchingtal sets stages of transverse between studies muscles connecting to the rise to the notochord;performed red in Fig. at1A), (even we identified slightly) differentthese temperatures. cells with the To chordamesoderm, overcome this, and we to chose provide aaxochord first comprehensive (“ventral oblique muscles”)(13)(Fig.3,A segmental pairs of mesodermaldescription cells of P. on dumerilii the nonnormal– a development, chordamesoderm-specific a temperature-independent gene set accord- staging systemand B, is needed.and fig. S3). Scanning electron microscopy Results: Platynereis dumerilii normaling development to the following is subdivided criteria: (i) into specificity 16 stages,—their startingrevealed with the zygotethat, in and adult ending worms, the axochord is with the death of the mature wormscombined after delivering expression their uniquely gametes. defines The stages the chor- describeddeeply can be embedded easily identified in the fibrous sheath of the 1Developmental Biology Unit, European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL), D-69117by Heidelberg. conventional2Janelia light Farm microscopydamesoderm; or even by dissecting (ii) conservation scope. Developmental—their chorda- landmarksventral such nerve as the cord beginning (16)andremainsconnectedto of Research Campus, 19700 Helixphototaxis, Drive, Ashburn, the visibility VA 20147, of the stomodealmesoderm opening expression and is of conserved the chaetae, in at the least first three occurrencethe transverse of the ciliary muscles bands, (Fig. the 3, C and D). Immu- USA. 3Centre for Organismalformation Studies, University of the parapodia, of the extensionof four vertebrate of antennae species; and cirri, and the (iii) onset function of feeding— andnostainings other characteristics confirmed its are axial position between Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany.used to define different developmentalthey have stages. proven The essential morphology for chordamesodermof all larval stages as wellneuropil as of andjuveniles blood and vessel (fig. S12; similar to the *These authors contributed equallyadults to is this documented work. †Present address: by light microscopy. We also provide an overview of important steps in the development of Institute for Biological and Medical Imaging and Institute of development or signaling. We thus investigated notochord; Fig. 1, A and B). Axochord contractility Developmental Genetics, Helmholtzthe nervous Zentrum systemMünchen, and of the musculature,expression of using seven fluorescent transcription labeling factors techniques(brachyury, andwas confocal evident laser-scanning from live imaging (fig. S9, E to G, and Ingolstädter Landstrasse 1, D-85764microscopy. Neuherberg, Timing Germany. of each developmentalfoxA, foxD, stagetwist, not refers, soxD to,and hourssoxE post), fertilization the signal- at 18movie ± 0.1°C. S2) For and comparison, occurred in alternation with the ‡Present address: Max Planckwe Institute determined of Molecular the Cell pace Biology of developmenting molecules of larvaenoggin raisedand at 14°C,hedgehog 16°C, 20°C,[chordin 25°C, 28°Ctransverse and 30°C. muscles A staging (movie S3). Electron micro- and Genetics, Pfotenhauerstrasseontology 108, 01307 representing Dresden, Germany the comprehensive list of developmental stages of P. dumerilii is available online. §Present address: Department for Molecular and Cell Biology, appears absent from annelid genomes (8)], and graphs confirmed the muscular nature of axochor- Harvard University, 16 DivinityConclusions: Ave, Cambridge,Our MA 02138, atlas USA. of Platynereisthe guidancedumerilii normal factors developmentnetrin and representsslit (table an S2 importantdal cells resource and revealed for the a tight physical connection to ||Present address: Departmentgrowing for MolecularPlatynereis Evolutioncommunity and andfor references).can also be applied Transcripts to other for nereidid all but one annelids. [the transverse muscles (Fig. 3, E to I). Laser ablation of Development, University of Vienna, Althanstrasse 14, A-1090 Wien, not gene (2)] were detected (figs. S3 to S5) in the axochord impaired crawling (fig. S10 and Austria. ¶Present address: Howard Hughes Medical Institute, accordance with previously reported brachyury movie S4) and confirmed anchoring of the trans- Stanford University, Stanford,Background CA 94305, USA. #Corresponding in P. dumerilii and vertebrates [8,9]. Gene expression author. E-mail: [email protected] expression (9), and their coexpression confirmed verse musculature. Additionally, we found that the In the past decades, the annelid Platynereis dumerilii during development of the two-celled larval eye may has been established as a marine animal model for reflect the bilaterian ground pattern [10]. SCIENCE sciencemag.orgdevelopmental, evolutionary and neurobiological Bilaterian animals comprise12 three SEPTEMBER main taxa: 2014 deuteros-• VOL 345 ISSUE 6202 1365 research as well as for ecology and toxicology [1-6]. It is tomes (e.g. chordates, hemichordates, echinoderms), especially suitable for comparative studies because sev- ecdysozoans (e.g. arthropods, nematodes), and lophotro- eral lines of evidence indicate that its evolutionary line- chozoans (mollusks, annelids and other marine inverte- age has been slow-evolving. For example, P. dumerilii brates). “Classical”,well-establishedanimalmodels has a highly conserved gene structure [7] and genes belong to the ecdysozoans (fruit fly, C. elegans)ordeu- involved in the development of the central nervous sys- terostomes (mouse, chicken, fish). Lophotrochozoans tem are expressed in a conserved molecular topography are still largely under-represented despite their obvious relevance to comparative approaches that seek to unra-
* Correspondence: [email protected]; [email protected] vel the ground pattern of all bilaterians. 1Developmental Biology Unit, European Molecular Biology Laboratory, D- P. dumerilii, which has been kept in laboratory culture 69117 Heidelberg, Germany since 1953, easily breeds in captivity where it produces Full list of author information is available at the end of the article
© 2010 Fischer et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Fischer et al. Frontiers in Zoology 2010, 7:31 Page 3 of 39 http://www.frontiersinzoology.com/content/7/1/31