Shock Over Ku Nan's FT Proposal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Thumbs 将槟纳为联邦直辖区? 槟城人:我们不要! down to 《珍珠快讯》封面及 FT idea pg 2-3 封底版 FREE buletin Competency Accountability Transparency http:www.facebook.com/buletinmutiara March 1-15, 2017 http:www.facebook.com/cmlimguaneng Shock over Ku Nan’s FT proposal Story and pix by Victor Seow questions, Buletin Mutiara spoke materialised. to and sought the legal opinion of In other words, who will be WHEN Federal Territories RSN Rayer, who’s Seri Delima calling the shots in the daily Minister Datuk Seri Tengku assemblymember and a lawyer administrative matters in the Adnan Tengku Mansor made his state if the Federal Territories Rayer sharing his thoughts on the legal and political perspectives con- by profession. cerning Penang as a federal territory. controversial proposal of turning To begin with, those who Minister’s wish comes true? certain parts of the country, do not share the sentiments “Penangites will then “There will be no The only possible way for including Penang, into federal of Tengku Adnan can rest basically be ruled by somebody assemblymembers doing their Tengku Adnan’s wish to come territories, political leaders and assured that changing the status who doesn’t even live in Penang. walkabouts in their respective true, according to Rayer, is ordinary Penangites were aghast of Penang as a state in the In fact, he doesn’t even need to constituencies. No service for BN to wrest control of and responded with shock. Federation of Malaysia into a come to Penang. The Minister centres to lodge complaints. the Penang state assembly by To the vast majority of them, federal territory cannot be done can be in his air-conditioned No chief minister to lead and winning sufficient seats to form the proposal by the Tengku single-handedly by the federal office in Putrajaya and not manage the state. Everything the state government. Adnan, or Ku Nan as he is also government. be aware of the welfare of will need to be referred to the “The only possible way for known, was preposterous, to say “Without the consent of the Penangites and the problems Federal Territories Minister this to happen is for Barisan the least. state, even with a two-thirds affecting the people in their daily like what’s happening now in Nasional to come into power While many responded with majority in Parliament, BN lives. Labuan,” said Rayer. Turn to page 3 anger, at the end of the day, it won’t be able to simply turn remains of vital importance Penang into a federal territory. that the people are actually The state government must informed of what is at stake if first of all agree to Penang indeed Penang is made a federal being converted into a federal territory, thus joining the likes territory,” said Rayer. of Kuala Lumpur, Putrajaya and “Parliament cannot decide Labuan, in the overall make-up autonomously on this matter. It of the Federation of Malaysia. has to be by virtue of consent Can it be arbitrarily done by the state government to by a mere stroke of the pen by the changes. Only then can a the federal government despite particular portion of the state be objections from the state? turned into a federal territory. And this is done with the In other words, the first hurdle assumption that Barisan Nasional for the process to take place, (BN) has a two-thirds majority in would be acquiring the state’s Parliament, which they currently agreement. If the state says don’t. What are the repercussions ‘No’, that’s the end of the federal towards the day-to-day running territory proposal,” he added. of administrative affairs in Now, let’s assume the Penang? Can the 1.6 million scenario in which Penang indeed people in the state who proudly becomes a federal territory. The call themselves Penangites have writer was keen to know how the a say at all in this issue? power structure in the state will In order to answer the above be if Tengku Adnan’s proposal 2 March 1-15, 2017 BULETIN Mutiara took to the streets to find out what Penangites think of the proposal to turn the state into a federal territory A majority of our readers gave a resounding “no”, while some were downright dismissive or sarcastic of the idea. Penang.Big But judging from how ‘NO’Why change something when to FT move things are done especially in it’s doing just fine? Labuan, I doubt the proposal by the federal minister deserves my support. Imran Idris, 28. Penang will lose its status as a tourism and manufacturing state if it becomes a FT. Frankie Chong, 50, manager Honestly, I do not see the pur- pose of Penang become an FT. Evaine Khoo, 37, self-employed What good will it do for Penan- I do not agree with Penang Eng Hup Teng, 50, self-em- gites? This is just some political becoming an FT. We are comfort- ployed game, a waste of precious time able and happy with what we are I don’t agree at all because we and resources, isn’t it? having now in Penang. will then lose our state rights. Amy Siew, 44, retail supervisor How can the mere wish of one person be compared to the 1.6 million people of Penang? He Lee Chee Cheow, 72, pensioner should at least consult what the In my more tzhan 70 years of people actually want before mak- life, I have seen the changes in ing his own personal wish so Penang brought by Tan Sri Wong widely known. Pow Nee, Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu, Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon and now Lim Guan Eng. I can’t imagine Penang not having the fifth Chief Minister. Ryan Lim, 35, station man- Umashankari a/p Ravindrana- ager Khoo Wan Hoe, 57, businessman than, 30, 32,housewife Basically, I would want The yellow star on the Malay- I don’t agree at all. Penan- someone who can decide mat- sian flag has 14 pointed ends gites will lose their voice. I ters on my behalf and he must which means 13 states and Kuala support the Pakatan Harapan be based in Penang. Whether Lumpur as the capital. Any chang- Sammi Chan, 50, professional state government because it he’s a local or not is a different es to the status quo would render emcee helps the people through its matter. At the very least, he the flag meaningless. The Federal Territories Minis- various ‘Golden’ programmes. must have the interests of Pen- ter is already playing the role of Chief Minister or Mentri Besar of Lim Chin Leng, 41, businessman Kuala Lumpur, Putrajaya and Penang will lose its original Labuan as all these territories are Justify your FT idea, Tengku Adnan told status once it becomes a federal under his direct supervision. To IN view of the enthusiastic re- of Penang into a federal terri- territory. I believe many born and include Penang into his ‘domain’ sponse from the public to the “I tory is an unwelcome move. bred Penangites like me won’t be would be a burden too heavy for ❤PENANG” Run that will be “I hope Tengku Adnan can comfortable with the change. him. He should allow others to do on March 12, the state govern- answer growing calls that this the job as he already has enough ment as the organiser has de- idea of his cannot be justified or on his plate. cided to increase the number of defended. He should not hide participants by an additional and keep quiet. He must come 2,000 from the previous 6,000. and explain and respond to The March 12 “I ❤ PENANG” growing calls not only in Pen- Run will be held at Beach Street ang but elsewhere opposing his and starts at 7.30am. suggestion. We want him to It will provide an opportu- come out and explain. If he nity for the people, not only can’t explain, he should with- Penangites, to send a clear mes- draw his statement and apolo- sage to Federal Territories gise,” Chief Minister Lim Guan Liza Mohd Noor, 42. Minister Datuk Seri Tengku Eng said during a press confer- I’m satisfied with the develop- Jennifer Seow, 43, self-employed Adnan Tengku Mansor that his ence on Feb 24. ment carried out by the Penang As a voter, I would support a suggestion of turning the state It was widely reported in the government. So, no need for FT. proposal as long as it’s good for Lim Bak Ngoo, 68, housewife 3 March 1-15, 2017 Ramkarpal Singh, Bukit don’t even live here. Gelugor MP Turning Penang, or part of it, Dato’ Jerry Chan, Past Chair- into a FT requires, amongst oth- man of Real Estate and Hous- ers, consent from the state gov- ing Developers Association, ernment which will never hap- Penang pen as long as Pakatan is in We cannot agree to making any Big ‘NO’ to angitesFT closest to his heart. I move power. It is imperative for such or all of Penang state as Federal wouldn’t want someone who’s a thing never to happen because Territory. The people who stay, 24/7 hundreds of miles away to if Penang, or part of it, were to work and retire here deserve to be playing that role. be turned into an FT, it is very elect their state and federal rep- unlikely that it will ever be re- resentatives. When there are Micheal Raj, 45, businessman versed. local or even federal issues, we I don’t agree! Because Pen- expect direct and quick access ang will lose its status to Putra- Syerleena Abdul Rashid, to the elected reps.