Geologic Evidence of Earthquakes at the Snohomish Delta, Washington, in the Past 1200 Yr
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Geologic evidence of earthquakes at the Snohomish delta, Washington, in the past 1200 yr Joanne Bourgeois* Department of Geological Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195, USA Samuel Y. Johnson² U.S. Geological Survey, M.S. 966, Box 25046, Denver Federal Center, Denver, Colorado 80225, USA ABSTRACT suggest that one set of these dikes formed 1996, 1999a; Pratt et al., 1997). Only the ca. A.D. 910±990; radiocarbon ages on a downgoing plate has produced large historic Exposed channel banks along distribu- younger set indicate a limiting maximum earthquakes (e.g., 1949 and 1965; Langston taries of the lower Snohomish delta in the age of A.D. 1400±1640. We also interpret a and Blum, 1977; Baker and Langston, 1987; Puget Lowland of Washington reveal evi- sharp lithologic change, from olive-gray, Chleborad and Schuster, 1998). dence of at least three episodes of liquefac- rhizome-rich mud to grayer, rhizome-poor Paleoseismologic studies in southwest tion, at least one event of abrupt subsi- mud, ;1 m above the couplet, to indicate a Washington suggest that seven great earth- dence, and at least one tsunami since ca. second abrupt lowering of the marsh sur- quakes (M . 8) have occurred at the Cascadia A.D. 800. The 45 measured stratigraphic face during an earthquake ca. A.D. 1040± plate boundary since ca. 3500 yr B.P. (Atwater sections consist mostly of 2±4 m of olive- 1400, but no conclusive liquefaction struc- and Hemphill-Haley, 1997), including the gray, intertidal mud containing abundant tures have been identi®ed at this horizon. most recent (M ; 9) event in A.D. 1700 (e.g., marsh plant rhizomes. The most distinctive Two distinctive coarse-sand laminae, 30±80 Nelson et al., 1995; Satake et al., 1996). In stratigraphic unit is a couplet comprising a cm below the couplet, may record tsunamis the Puget Lowland, Bucknam et al. (1992) 0.523-cm-thick, laminated, ®ning-upward, older than A.D. 800. showed that a large (M . 7) earthquake oc- tsunami-laid sand bed overlain by 2210 cm Thus, study shows that in the past ;1200 curred on the Seattle fault ca. A.D. 900±930 of gray clay. We correlated the couplet, yr, this part of Washington's Puget Low- (Atwater, 1999). Recognition of these events which is generally ;2 m below the modern land has been subjected to stronger ground has boosted estimates of regional seismic haz- marsh surface, across an ;20 km2 area. shaking than in historic times, since ca. ard (Frankel et al., 1996) and demonstrates the Sand dikes and sand-®lled cracks to 1 m 1870. need for a more complete catalog of the num- wide, which terminate upward at the cou- ber, frequency, sources, magnitudes, and ef- plet, and sand volcanoes preserved at the Keywords: earthquakes, paleoseismicity, Pu- fects of large earthquakes affecting the Puget level of the sand bed record liquefaction at get Lowland, sedimentology, stratigraphy. Lowland. the same time as couplet deposition. Differ- Here we report geologic evidence for paleo- earthquakes from the Snohomish River delta ences in the type and abundance of marsh INTRODUCTION plant rhizomes across the couplet horizon, near Everett in the northern Puget Lowland as well as the gray clay layer, suggest that (Figs. 1 and 3), where there is minimal his- The densely populated Puget Lowland of compaction during this liquefaction led to torical information on earthquake effects. Del- Washington State (Figs. 1 and 2) occupies a abrupt, local lowering of the marsh surface tas are particularly good sites for paleoseis- dynamic geologic setting in the forearc of the by as much as 50±75 cm. Radiocarbon ages mologic investigations because their young, North American plate above the Cascadia sub- show that the tsunami and liquefaction date loosely packed sediments are prone to coseis- duction zone. Complex plate interactions from ca. A.D. 800 to 980, similar to the age mic liquefaction, compaction, and subsidence, along this convergent continental margin are of a large earthquake on the Seattle fault, and because their low elevation and proximity the driving force for a signi®cant, yet poorly 50 km to the south. to a water body make them susceptible to tsu- understood earthquake hazard (Ludwin et al., We have found evidence for at least two, namis. Bank exposures along tidal distributar- 1991; Rogers et al., 1996). Sources for mod- and possibly as many as ®ve, other earth- ies of the lower Snohomish delta show evi- erate or larger earthquakes include slip on the quakes in the measured sections. At two or dence of at least three liquefaction events, Cascadia plate boundary (interplate), ruptures more stratigraphic levels above the couplet, inundation by at least one tsunami, and at least in the downgoing Juan de Fuca plate 60 km sand dikes locally feed sand volcanoes. Ra- ; one episode of abrupt subsidence, all since ca. below Puget Sound (intraplate), and move- diocarbon ages and stratigraphic position A.D. 800. We infer that the most distinctive ment on shallow crustal faults in the North stratigraphic horizon (ca. A.D. 800±1100) re- *E-mail: [email protected]. American plate such as the Seattle fault or cords strong ground motion and tsunami in- ²Corresponding author; e-mail: sjohnson@usgs. southern Whidbey Island fault (Figs. 1 and 2) undation associated with the A.D. 900±930 gov. (Gower et al., 1985; Johnson et al., 1994, Seattle fault earthquake. GSA Bulletin; April 2001; v. 113; no. 4; p. 482±494; 9 ®gures; 3 tables; Data Repository item 2001034. For permission to copy, contact Copyright Clearance Center at www.copyright.com 482 q 2001 Geological Society of America PALEOSEISMOLOGY ON THE SNOHOMISH DELTA SNOHOMISH RIVER DELTA The Snohomish River begins at the con¯u- ence of the Skykomish and Snoqualmie Rivers and empties into Possession Sound (Fig. 1). At its lower end, the Snohomish ¯ows through a wide (;4 km) postglacial valley bounded by morainal deposits of the last (Fraser) glacia- tion. About 12 km upstream from Possession Sound, at an elevation of ,1.5 m above sea level, the main channel divides into several distributaries, or sloughs (Fig. 3). Spring-tide range in the sloughs is as much as 4.5 m. Snohomish delta lowlands are now primar- ily undeveloped wetlands or are used for ag- riculture. Lumber mills and storage, marinas, sewage treatment plants, and a hazardous waste site are also located on the delta plain. The delta is crossed by an interstate highway (I-5), the Burlington-Northern railroad, and a busy local highway. Agriculture on the delta is dependent on a system of dikes and levees, construction of which began in 1876 (Dunnell and Fuller, 1975). The cities of Everett and Marysville, ¯anking the Snohomish delta, were settled in the late 1870s and early 1880s. The northwestern part of the delta is on the Tulalip Indian Reservation. Cutbanks along both the main river channel Figure 1. Generalized geologic map of the Puget Lowland region showing location of and the sloughs in the lower delta typically ex- Snohomish River delta (SRD, area shown in Fig. 3) and selected regional crustal faults or pose, at maximum low tide, 1±4 m of strata de- geophysical lineaments (heavy dashed lines). Abbreviations: CÐCultus Bay; DMFÐDevils posited in about the past 1500 yr (Figs. 4 and Mountain fault; EÐEverett; LWÐLake Washington; OÐOlympia; PÐPossession Sound; 5). These strata, in general, record the building PSÐPuget Sound; SÐSeattle; SFÐSeattle fault; SJÐSan Juan Islands; SRÐSnohomish up of the delta, from channel point-bar deposits River; SKRÐSkykomish River; SNRÐSnoqualmie River; SWFÐsouthern Whidbey Is- to intertidal mud ¯ats to supratidal marsh de- land fault; TÐTacoma; WÐWest Point; WIÐWhidbey Island. Faults based on Gower posits. Marsh deposits predominate in studied (1985) and Johnson et al. (1996, 1999a). outcrops, and in-growth-position plant material and detrital wood debris are abundant in these sediments. Although tidal laminae are visible on weathered surfaces, they have been largely dis- rupted by bioturbation associated with modern and relict marsh vegetation. Snohomish River delta channels and marsh- es appear not to have migrated much since ca. A.D. 800. Since a United States Coast Survey hydrographic map was made in 1884, there has been neither signi®cant lateral migration of channels nor progradation of the mouth. Sedimentary facies, including fossil plant ma- terial, in cutbanks are at approximately the same elevations as facies currently being de- posited at nearby locations. Thus sediment supply appears to be in approximate balance with the combined effects of subsidence and slow sea-level rise. Vertical aggradation rates Figure 2. Schematic view of the Paci®c Northwest continental margin (no scale) showing are ;2 m/1 k.y., based on our radiocarbon distribution of three types of earthquakes that affect the region. dating (Table 1; Fig. 4). Geological Society of America Bulletin, April 2001 483 BOURGEOIS and JOHNSON SNOHOMISH SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS AND FACIES The lower, modern Snohomish delta com- prises ®ve basic subenvironments, in succes- sion from deeper to shallower: (1) subtidal channels, (2) lower intertidal ¯ats and point bars, (3) upper intertidal ¯ats and point bars, (4) supratidal marsh, and (5) lower delta plain and levees. This same succession is present in late Holocene facies in outcrop, produced as distributary channels migrate laterally and as the delta aggrades. Facies are distinguished primarily by sediment texture and color, growth-position plant fossils (see Table 2), and sedimentary structures. Our observations of the modern delta environments and the out- crop facies, including modern and fossil veg- etation, are summarized in the GSA Data Re- pository (Figs. DR1±DR31). Subtidal The major subtidal channel environments of the modern delta (i.e., the axes of the main channel and its distributaries) are constantly submerged, so we did not directly observe and describe them.