Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Report on Public Consultation on

Mandatory Safety Equipment

National Transport Authority, Dun Scèine, Harcourt Lane, Dublin 2 . January 2016

Contents Page

1 Introduction and Background 3 1.1 Introduction 3 1.2 Background 3

2 Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment for SPSVs 5 2.1 Purpose and Process 5 2.2 Approach 5

3 Consultation Response 6 3.1 Submissions received 6 3.2 Issues Raised in Submissions 6

4 Analysis of Issues Raised 9 4.1 Cost and financial impact 9 4.2 Ownership and self-employed status 9 4.3 Safety Partitions 9 4.4 Monitoring 9 4.5 Policing and court 9 4.6 CCTV 10

5 Summary and Conclusions 11

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

1 Introduction and Background

1.1 Introduction

The National Transport Authority (Authority) is a State body set up under statute in 2009. From 01 January 2011, it assumed responsibility for the regulation of the small public service vehicle (SPSV) sector, i.e. taxis, wheelchair accessible taxis, hackneys, wheelchair accessible hackneys, local area hackneys and limousines, together with their drivers, owners and associated services. At 31 December 2015, a total of 21,146 SPSVs were licenced to the Irish fleet; 17,488 were taxis and wheelchair accessible taxis with c.70% of those in the Greater Dublin Area. At 31 December 2015, there were 27,440 SPSV drivers licensed to provide small public transport services across the country.

This industry has an almost unique set of characteristics in that a driver’s daily activity involves lone working, door to door services on unscheduled routes, the handling of money and valuables and, as has been increasingly reported upon in recent years, threats to personal security and violence at work.

1.2 Background

In January 2012, the Report of the Taxi Regulation Review Group was published on foot of a wide ranging review carried out in line with a Government decision of June 2011. The Review Group, which was convened and chaired by the then Minister for Public and Commuter Transport, Alan Kelly T.D., included dispatch operators, drivers, vehicle owners and consumers as well as Government Departments and regulatory and enforcement agencies. The aim of the review was to allow consumers to have confidence in the SPSV sector while also ensuring that legitimate and competent operators and drivers could be rewarded fairly by operating under a regulatory framework that is adequately enforced. This “Mandatory Driver Safety Equipment Consultation” was undertaken in line with the actions recommended within the Report.

Action 37 of the Report of the Taxi Regulation Review Group committed that:

“In recognition of driver safety issues, a consultation process will be carried out with the industry in 2012, on the possibilities and merits of introducing a requirement for the mandatory provision of certain driver safety equipment in taxis. Potential options for consultation include:

 In-vehicle security cameras;  A partition separating the driver front seat area from the remainder of the vehicle;  A locational alert system; or  Other new technology based options.”

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Within the context of this action and this document, the term “taxi” above is taken to mean all categories of SPSV.

Separately but in parallel, Action 45 states:

“This action proposes the planned migration to the use of smart (electronic) technologies in individual SPSVs to address the current challenges in monitoring and regulating a fleet of over 20,000 vehicles; and also to better exploit the potential to integrate the SPSV fleet into the wider public transport system.

Developments in computing and communications technology, together with the increasing sophistication of in-car technology, creates opportunities to move the SPSV industry to a different level, both in terms of interfacing with customers and in regard to efficient monitoring of regulatory compliance.

Possible capabilities that could be considered include enhanced information availability for customers, improved operational data collection, remote taximeter fare update capability, remote disabling of roof sign operation, driver security monitoring features and similar functionality.

It is likely that the integration of these features into taxi technology will take place over a period of time, on an incremental basis, and it is important that regulatory proposals in this area are considered in the context of likely technological developments.”

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

2 Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment for SPSVs

2.1 Purpose and Process

The purpose of this consultation was to elicit the views of the SPSV industry, stakeholders and general public on the possibilities and merits or demerits of introducing a requirement for the mandatory provision of driver safety equipment in SPSVs and, if appropriate what that equipment could be. The current SPSV regulatory framework does not prohibit any proportionate, lawful safety measures and many drivers have implemented certain safety measures already.

A consultation on the introduction, in a mandatory fashion, of safety equipment for SPSVs and their drivers was commenced on 07 August 2015, when submissions were invited from the industry and public by way of public advertisement in the Irish Independent newspaper, the SPSV Industry Update and website publications in relation to Action 37 of the Report of the Taxi Regulation Review Group.

Submissions were accepted received by the Authority up to and including 18 September 2015.

2.2 Approach

Two particular questions were set to prompt discussion and to understand the appetite for any requirement for such safety equipment to be made mandatory:

1. Do you consider that safety equipment in SPSVs should be made mandatory?

2. If you do consider that safety equipment in SPSVs should be made mandatory, please state any suggestions or proposals that you wish to have considered.

As a guide for those submissions, it was suggested that the discussion on safety equipment design considerations should range from potential options of a simple full view interior mirror right through to real time, live locational and identification aides, together with any other potential safeguards identified. No specific equipment proposals were made in this consultation.

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

3 Consultation Response

3.1 Submissions received

A total of 2,649 submissions were received, including three late submissions. A total of 2,353 hand delivered submissions received were identical but signed individually. 296 other submissions were received by email and post. A list of all those who made submissions is referenced in Appendix A. A copy of the common submission is attached at Appendix B. Repeat identical submissions by the same individual were excluded.

97.3% of the submissions received did not consider that safety equipment in SPSVs should be made mandatory. 2.7% of the submissions received considered that some form of safety equipment in SPSVs should be made mandatory. In the majority of submissions, question one, “Do you consider that safety equipment in SPSVs should be made mandatory?” was answered in the negative; resultantly, question two was not considered by the respondent. A small number of submissions provided suggestions or proposals for appropriate safety equipment for SPSV drivers and these are attached in Appendix C for information.

3.2 Issues Raised in Submissions

All 2,649 submissions were reviewed by the Authority and the issues raised were categorised, summarised and analysed. In total, 72 (2.7%) of the submissions were generally in favour of implementing safety equipment in SPSVs on a mandatory basis, some providing information on the available options. However, 2,577 submissions (97.3%) were against the concept of making this protection mandatory, noting that SPSV operator discretion should continue to be exercised in this regard.

A total of 8 main issues were identified during this review process. The core categories and the number of times the issues were raised under each heading are summarised in Table 1 below.

Number of Category Headings Times Raised

Concern over potential negative financial impact on SPSV 2,408 Operators. Cost and financial Concern over potential devaluing of vehicle for onward impact 3 sale.

Concern over potential a move towards standardised 2,354

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

vehicles in the Irish SPSV industry.

Ownership and Private vehicle, privately financed, not limited to SPSV self-employed work. 2,385 status Concern over erosion of rights of self-employed status.

Concern over potential monitoring of hours of work and / 2,359 or areas of operation.

Monitoring Tracking including panic feature should be mandatory. 16 One central control centre required. 3

One central control centre with police monitoring 24/7. 1

Concern over current policing, court attitudes and Policing and court 2,366 sentencing leniency.

Concern over potential illegal uploading of images through 2,357 social media. CCTV Concern over potential data protection / privacy issues. 15

CCTV should be mandatory. 76

Concern over potential negative effect on the passenger’s 2,392 safety perception and enjoyment of service.

Concern over potential reduction of passenger capacity 2,373 and driver comfort.

Security screen Partition/security screen should be mandatory. 38 Concern over potential driver and passenger safety in 7 collision/emergency incident.

Concern over potential difficulty in retrofitting. 5

Concern over potential lack of hygiene. 2

External panic/distress light silently alerting passers-by to 16 dial the police should be mandatory. Other suggestions Recommended use of common sense in confrontation. 10

Mandate London black cab style vehicles for all SPSVs / 4

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

uniformity of vehicle and colour.

Driver must control door locking/unlocking. 3

Information leaflet on driver safety with intoxicated/out of 4 control passengers to be provided to all operators.

Driver Check App should be promoted and used more. 2

Always have correct change. 2

Lone workers should use “buddy system”. 2

Credit card facility provision should be mandatory. 2

Credit card use by passengers should be mandatory. 1

Mandatory first aid course for all operators. 1

Night drop boxes to be made available to operators. 1

Dedicated emergency services number for SPSV drivers 1 only.

Table 1 – Issues raised in submissions received

In terms of issues that were raised most frequently in those submissions which did not consider that safety equipment in SPSVs should be made mandatory, the highest common factor (2,408 instances) related to cost and the potential financial impact on SPSV service providers.

The second highest proportion of issues referenced (2,392 times) related to potential negative impacts that physical safety equipment might have on passenger perception of a friendly, safe SPSV service.

The third most recurrent factor (2,385 instances) was based on the fact that that a vehicle might not be used solely for SPSV purposes and is privately financed by self-employed operators, with concern expressed around the potential for monitoring/surveillance of that vehicle.

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

4 Analysis of Issues Raised

4.1 Cost and financial impact

Respondents in the main submitted that making safety equipment mandatory would be an untenable financial burden on drivers and operators, particularly given the current operating costs and market environment facing the SPSV industry. It was also submitted that this move could be the commencement of a policy towards full compulsory standardisation of vehicles in the Irish SPSV fleet.

A further concern related to both the capacity for future sale of and an associated devaluing of vehicles with safety equipment installed or uninstalled.

4.2 Ownership and self-employed status

Concern was expressed regarding the fact that, whilst a vehicle may be licensed as a small public service vehicle in its business capacity, it is frequently, also, a private family vehicle and is directly financed by the self-employed owner. It was submitted that the normal, safe, private use of the vehicle and the employment status and autonomy of the vehicle owner would each be eroded by making safety equipment installation mandatory.

4.3 Safety Partitions

It was repeatedly submitted that safety barriers around the driver would lead to a perception of poor customer service and risk which would ruin the reputation of the sociable Irish driver and safe, friendly tourism in Ireland. Also, the impractical nature of physical barriers, emergency escape issues and a reduction in passenger seating capacity and driver workspace ranked high in the submissions received. Only 1.4% of respondents believed that partitions should be mandatorily introduced.

4.4 Monitoring

Many submissions indicated unease with the potential for monitoring by agencies of the State (or private servants of those public agencies) of a driver or a vehicle in terms of location and activity, both public and private.

4.5 Policing and court

Numerous submissions advocated that, rather than the mandatory installation of safety equipment being used to deter violence against drivers, a perceived leniency and inconstancy of

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

current policing and judicial approaches should be tackled with an emphasis on appropriate sentencing for such criminal activity.

4.6 CCTV

The highest number of positive responses to question one, 76, recommended that CCTV be made mandatory in the Irish SPSV fleet. There was limited suggestion with regard to potential options in this regard but those received are appended to this report.

Those submissions which negatively referenced CCTV specifically indicated concern in relation to potential data protection and privacy issues, including concerns around potential illegal uploading of images on social media.

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

5 Summary and Conclusions

The purpose of this public consultation process was to elicit the views of the SPSV industry, stakeholders and the wider public in relation to any necessity to make mandatory the installation or use of SPSV Driver Safety Equipment and to encourage debate within the industry.

A very high level of response was received to this consultation, with a total of 2,649 submissions provided to the Authority.

The overwhelming majority of the submissions – 97.3% - did not support the introduction of mandatory safety equipment for a variety of stated reasons. 2.7% were in favour of making safety equipment mandatory for SPSVs.

In relation specifically to privacy issues and CCTV and recording devices, we would recommend that operators engage directly with the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner for advice in this regard. General advice published by the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner last year states:

“There are a number of data protection implications regarding the installation of CCTV in taxis as the footage recorded would be considered to be personal data under the Acts. In general, this Office would have a concern about the proportionality and justification of installing CCTV cameras in taxis taking account of the legitimate privacy expectations of vehicle users. Our general guidance is that while a balance must be struck between the privacy considerations of the service users and the legitimate interests of an organisation to protect its business, the continuous recording of passengers in taxis is not compliant with the data protection legislation.

However, this Office is aware that certain taxis have introduced CCTV and it is assumed therefore that they have done so having assessed the proportionality conditions above. Where this is the case we would expect that the footage, given its extremely invasive nature, would be generally restricted from access and deleted on a rolling basis after 24 hours, except where there is a need to retain it in response to a specific instance. Other conditions in relation to prominent notices of such recording would also need to be met. This Office does not accept that it is ever proportionate to use audio recording (recording conversations) in a taxi.”

- www.dataprotection.ie/docs/CCTV/1242.htm

Following this consultation, it is not intended to make the installation of designated safety equipment in SPSVs mandatory. However, we would encourage all SPSV operators to continue to identify and actively manage those risks particularly associated with the SPSV industry, together with the general risks associated with customer service and vehicular transport businesses.

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Appendix A: List of Submissions Received

Ref Respondent DSE0001 Michael Noonan DSE0002 Patrick Kelly DSE0003 Billy Corkery DSE0004 John bowden DSE0005 Paul Barry DSE0006 Colm M DSE0007 Denis Sul DSE0008 laurence higgins DSE0009 Eugene ORourke DSE0010 Jenny Finnegan DSE0011 John galvin DSE0012 John Keane DSE0013 Gerard maughan DSE0014 Paul Priestley DSE0015 Matt Lawlor DSE0016 Derek Doran DSE0017 John o Donnell DSE0018 Gary Doyle DSE0019 Stewart Barron DSE0020 Sachin kumar DSE0021 Brian DSE0022 Damien Hanney DSE0023 Alan Daly DSE0024 Dympna king DSE0025 Tony Flynn DSE0026 Ciaran Collins DSE0027 Karlletaxi DSE0028 Nick Murphy DSE0029 Colm DSE0030 Muyiwa Ogunleye DSE0031 Des Hodgins DSE0032 Violet Doran DSE0033 Frank Hayden DSE0034 fergus sheehan DSE0035 Jean McCormack DSE0036 Evelyn Brady

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0037 Una Byrne DSE0038 Dessie O' Keeney DSE0039 pat bennis DSE0040 David whitehead DSE0041 Tony Stephens DSE0042 robert williamson DSE0043 Jerry Gilna DSE0044 Leon O'Brien DSE0045 Arno Jurjans DSE0046 Ken Keoghan DSE0047 patrick currid DSE0048 declan o sullivan DSE0049 Richard O Neill DSE0050 gregory lennon DSE0051 Derek Higgins DSE0052 Padraig Buckler DSE0053 Vinny Kearns DSE0054 Anonymous DSE0055 John Quigley DSE0056 Victor Okosun DSE0057 Bruce Hetherington DSE0058 Sean Falvey DSE0059 Davy Moore DSE0060 Fergal Beirne DSE0061 Brian Doherty DSE0062 Shane Landers DSE0063 Martin Reilly DSE0064 Olufunso Fajaiyeyomi DSE0065 owen rispin DSE0066 Mick Moloney DSE0067 John Maguire DSE0068 Jason Mooney DSE0069 Joe Howell DSE0070 Daragh Mc Cormack DSE0071 Desmond Maguire DSE0072 Sean lynott DSE0073 Joseph Birrane DSE0074 John Carney DSE0075 Leonard Roe DSE0076 Mattie Matrix

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0077 Patrick Gallagher DSE0078 Mark bradley DSE0079 Paul Brady DSE0080 Tony Flynn DSE0081 Matthew bane DSE0082 David Scully DSE0083 Gerard wallace DSE0084 Jason O' Neill DSE0085 Muriel kellett DSE0086 Bernard Dunning DSE0087 fergus sheehan DSE0088 william regan DSE0089 sean murray DSE0090 Adwallson DSE0091 rasheed geylani DSE0092 Owen Gorman DSE0093 Kennith Griffin DSE0094 Allan O'Neill DSE0095 john hannon DSE0096 Gerard DSE0097 Roy McSweeney DSE0098 Pat Morgan DSE0099 KEVIN BANKS DSE0100 William Reilly DSE0101 Alan Lawlor DSE0102 Gerard Reynolds DSE0103 Christy Higgins DSE0104 Brian Herron DSE0105 Kellys Emy DSE0106 Paul waters DSE0107 Derek Alford DSE0108 Gerald McGovern DSE0109 Declan Brunett DSE0110 Ian O'Hara DSE0111 Deni Toro DSE0112 Yvonne Ruane DSE0113 gerard hyland DSE0114 Eamonn Murphy DSE0115 Kevin Hinchion DSE0116 Robert Mulvaney

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0117 geraldine cousins DSE0118 Ciarán Mc Auley DSE0119 Paul Byrne DSE0120 Michael Akinwale DSE0121 Mark Rooney DSE0122 Brendan Edney DSE0123 Brendan Dickson DSE0124 StephenMcManus DSE0125 Robert Reilly DSE0126 Steve Watson DSE0127 Shamil Shahzad DSE0128 Brendan Homan DSE0129 Tony Carroll DSE0130 Pat Murphy DSE0131 Sean Breen DSE0132 Maurice O' Donoghue DSE0133 John Liston DSE0134 George W. Plant DSE0135 David Mantle DSE0136 Gavin branigan DSE0137 Peter Malone DSE0138 Janusz Skoczen DSE0139 David Ankers DSE0140 Colm McKeown DSE0141 Keiron Padmore DSE0142 Fabian Balfe DSE0143 Raymond Ruane DSE0144 Gareth Ennis DSE0145 Gregory Lennon DSE0146 John Downey DSE0147 Osagie Igbinedion DSE0148 John DSE0149 Bobby Byrne DSE0150 catherine mcelvaney DSE0151 Roy Thomas DSE0152 Derek Conroy DSE0153 Peter Robinson DSE0154 Louis O Carroll DSE0155 Joseph Byrne DSE0156 Lucas Bittencourt

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0157 Sean and louise O'Brien DSE0158 Bernard Gaskin DSE0159 Mark masterson DSE0160 Cormac O'Brien DSE0161 John morley DSE0162 james Maguire DSE0163 Frank Duffy DSE0164 Edward mc govern DSE0165 patrick kerwick DSE0166 Conor Hogarty DSE0167 David Keighrey DSE0168 Alan Dempsey DSE0169 Basil Geoghegan DSE0170 Jim Waldron DSE0171 Richard Griffin DSE0172 fidelis akhigbe DSE0173 Shane Freeney DSE0174 joseph murphy DSE0175 john redmond DSE0176 Sean Walsh DSE0177 Peter Sheerin DSE0178 eric byrne DSE0179 Derek Brennan DSE0180 Andrew Moss DSE0181 Paul Power DSE0182 juhn derwin DSE0183 FRANK OKONKWO DSE0184 Alan DSE0185 Kevin Noonan DSE0186 Peter Kinsella DSE0187 Gerard Kelly DSE0188 Paul Dunne DSE0189 kravchuk007 DSE0190 Ade Ola DSE0191 hugh mc fadden DSE0192 Noel Casey DSE0193 Gerard Mulcahy DSE0194 Thomas Cooke DSE0195 Kevin Faulkner DSE0196 Paul Downey

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0197 Annemarie Duffy DSE0198 Abdul karim DSE0199 Luke Maher DSE0200 george whelan DSE0201 Darren Hennessy DSE0202 Mike Flynner DSE0203 Jason shaw DSE0204 Sean Furlong DSE0205 Brendan Clabby DSE0206 Mark Gore DSE0207 Rory Mc Closkey DSE0208 Saji M Joseph DSE0209 Sanitha Thomas DSE0210 peter Gray DSE0211 Frank Layton DSE0212 Paul mc Donagh DSE0213 anthony mcgowan DSE0214 Peter Finnegan DSE0215 Tommy Cunniffe DSE0216 Declan Colgan DSE0217 Stephen Collins DSE0218 Daniel Mc Donnell DSE0219 Brendan Lynch DSE0220 Conor DSE0221 J Egan DSE0222 John O Sullivan DSE0223 John Motherway (Safe Cab Security LTD) DSE0224 Frances Thompson DSE0225 Adrian Crowe DSE0226 Mick O’ Brien DSE0227 Val McLoughlin DSE0228 Emmet Kearney DSE0229 Mike Collins DSE0230 Sean McCarthy DSE0231 Marion Roche Martin DSE0232 Franking34 DSE0233 liam oreilly DSE0234 Ayodeji DSE0235 ricky tan DSE0236 Anthony Jones

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0237 Edward Mc Bride DSE0238 Seamus Fitzgerald DSE0239 Gerard Cody DSE0240 Denis Kavanagh DSE0241 Eugene O'Brien DSE0242 Michael Feary DSE0243 Michael Flanagan (Kabzy) DSE0244 Fred noble DSE0245 Anthony Hoare DSE0246 Anthony Woods DSE0247 Denis McCarthy DSE0248 david knox DSE0249 Padraic Brehon DSE0250 John Deegan DSE0251 Jason Byrne DSE0252 Leslie Matthews DSE0253 James Lawless DSE0254 Val McLoughlin DSE0255 Stephanie Stapleton DSE0256 Paul McBride DSE0257 M . DALY DSE0258 MARK JONES DSE0259 EMMA GOREY DSE0260 JOE RYAN DSE0261 JOE REID DSE0262 SAM COLE DSE0263 GERRY KELLY DSE0264 LISA RYAN DSE0265 DAVE CASEY DSE0266 BILLY WRIGHT DSE0267 MR ROSE DSE0268 AMY CLARKE DSE0269 JIM WHITE DSE0270 LUCY PIERCE DSE0271 PAT MORAN DSE0272 DAVE BURKE DSE0273 TOM HILL DSE0274 GERRY FLANNERY DSE0275 NIAMH BARRY DSE0276 HELEN COLE

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSE0277 MIKE FOLEY DSE0278 GERRY CERBY DSE0279 TRISH KELLY DSE0280 mags kelly DSE0281 teressa coleman DSE0282 Paul Smith DSE0283 MARY SMITH DSE0284 Stuart PSV.ie DSE0285 Joe Herron DSE0286 S Farrell DSE0287 M Farrell DSE0288 C Farrell DSE0289 D Farrell DSE0290 Waldemar DSE0291 Auras Zota DSE0292 Roy Thomas DSE0293 Robert Luknar DSE0294 David Hendrick DSE0295 Jim Byrne DSE0296 Gerard Reynolds DSP0297 Sean Murphy DSP0298 Mukaila A. Bello DSP0299 Kula Makumbi DSP0300 M Harris DSP0301 Donal Mc Carthy DSP0302 Patrick Board DSP0303 Timothy Dennehy DSP0304 M Fitzpatrick DSP0305 C3542 DSP0306 John O' Gorman DSP0307 CO457 DSP0308 C9765 DSP0309 C2971 DSP0310 Robert Lynch DSP0311 C9811 DSP0312 J Roche DSP0313 Haji salim DSP0314 C9428 DSP0315 Adeniyi King DSP0316 D7055

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0317 Tony Oki DSP0318 William Drought DSP0319 K1980 DSP0320 K0428 DSP0321 K0500 DSP0322 K6801 DSP0323 K6902 DSP0324 K0493 DSP0325 K6821 DSP0326 Paul Alapini DSP0327 K6841 DSP0328 Herron Kirara DSP0329 Bertie Byrne DSP0330 David Healy DSP0331 Abul Salim DSP0332 Finbarr O'leary DSP0333 K0681 DSP0334 Matt O' Connor DSP0335 K0491 DSP0336 K0692 DSP0337 Barnabas Agorh DSP0338 Ricardo Pembele DSP0339 Edward Barry DSP0340 Sean Collins DSP0341 ThomasO' Keeffe DSP0342 Noel Barry DSP0343 Desmond Coughlan DSP0344 Michael Twomey DSP0345 Jerome Murphy DSP0346 John Barrett DSP0347 M0237 DSP0348 Daniel IBE DSP0349 William M M0229 DSP0350 Joe Lee DSP0351 M0761 DSP0352 Samuel DSP0353 M0236 DSP0354 Will O'Reilly DSP0355 Kenneth Lee DSP0356 L5296

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0357 L4444 DSP0358 Paul Videl DSP0359 L0094 DSP0360 Rory Ahern DSP0361 L0040 DSP0362 Michael Ahern DSP0363 Tariq Rafiq DSP0364 John Morrissey DSP0365 L2142 DSP0366 Bikram Singh DSP0367 L5299 DSP0368 Ali Safdar DSP0369 Rupinder Singh DSP0370 Lu561 DSP0371 L0055 DSP0372 Syed Fahadalam DSP0373 L4560 DSP0374 Wilson Okafor DSP0375 Ike udel DSP0376 L0095 DSP0377 L4592 DSP0378 L2108 DSP0379 Victor Okoye DSP0380 L4441 DSP0381 L2181 DSP0382 L4430 DSP0383 Benjamin Aihie DSP0384 Victor Okoye DSP0385 H7533 DSP0386 M.Howard DSP0387 H9466 DSP0388 K0510 DSP0389 H45855 DSP0390 H4940 DSP0391 H5748 DSP0392 Denis Murphy DSP0393 G5492 DSP0394 G9187 DSP0395 Pat Moynihan DSP0396 Michael O Dwyer

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0397 G5364 DSP0398 Tim Cotter DSP0399 G9162 DSP0400 G5404 DSP0401 Kevin crowley DSP0402 John O'Connell DSP0403 Darren O Neill DSP0404 Gordon Waterman DSP0405 J 2216 DSP0406 Will Murphy DSP0407 J7912 DSP0408 Michael O'Donoghue DSP0409 Thomas Frawley DSP0410 Richard Kenneally DSP0411 Thomas O' Connell DSP0412 John Ahern DSP0413 J4535 DSP0414 John Kelly DSP0415 Paul Marekia DSP0416 Edward Mc carthy DSP0417 Angela Cantwell DSP0418 J3900 DSP0419 J0614 DSP0420 J0533 DSP0421 J4525 DSP0422 J4543 DSP0423 Maurice Carrol DSP0424 Michael Montgomery DSP0425 J0614 DSP0426 J0787 DSP0427 Denis Cassidy DSP0428 Gary O'Sullivan DSP0429 J O' Donoghue DSP0430 K0528 DSP0431 K6877 DSP0432 Akimboni Koffi DSP0433 John Bolger DSP0434 John Kelleher DSP0435 Niall Long DSP0436 H0849

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0437 Roy Coughlan DSP0438 C0441 DSP0439 John Borrett DSP0440 C5450 DSP0441 Peadar Twomey DSP0442 Paul Byrne DSP0443 F3395 DSP0444 F3339 DSP0445 Gary o' Connell DSP0446 Bill Cronin DSP0447 F3692 DSP0448 F3125 DSP0449 Dermot Canning DSP0450 David Hedderman DSP0451 F3630 DSP0452 F3430 DSP0453 F3528 DSP0454 F3687 DSP0455 B1952 DSP0456 Michael Barry DSP0457 B2307 DSP0458 John Murray DSP0459 Daniel O' sullivan DSP0460 B2365 DSP0461 Kevin Barry DSP0462 E0428 DSP0463 S.Hickey DSP0464 John O' Brien DSP0465 Tom Harrington DSP0466 James Murray DSP0467 James O' Driscoll DSP0468 B4023 DSP0469 Pat Winning DSP0470 john Wyer DSP0471 Martin Murray DSP0472 Mick O'Mahony DSP0473 A13787 DSP0474 Brendan Murphy DSP0475 Brendan Gun DSP0476 H4930

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0477 William Griffin DSP0478 H2392 DSP0479 sean O Halloran DSP0480 John Corkery DSP0481 Majid Sharif DSP0482 Patrick Corkery DSP0483 H2493 DSP0484 H2313 DSP0485 John Ford DSP0486 H4953 DSP0487 Paul Murray DSP0488 H4922 DSP0489 D7055 DSP0490 E 2267 DSP0491 denis O' mahoney DSP0492 Finbarr Heffernan DSP0493 Niall Murphy DSP0494 E2227 DSP0495 Sean Long DSP0496 E1924 DSP0497 E5108 DSP0498 E5365 DSP0499 Ian Cummins DSP0500 E5158 DSP0501 L2161 DSP0502 Ishola Roberts DSP0503 L4423 DSP0504 L2192 DSP0505 L5386 DSP0506 Tafa Traore DSP0507 Patrick Power DSP0508 A6218 DSP0509 Patrick Murphy DSP0510 A5899 DSP0511 Eugene Burke DSP0512 denis hedy DSP0513 R lynch DSP0514 Martin Kearney DSP0515 Michael Lynch DSP0516 Thomas Foran

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0517 A4290 DSP0518 Paddy Mc Cormack DSP0519 Timothy Healy DSP0520 Peter Kearney DSP0521 Patrick O gorman DSP0522 kenneth Reilly DSP0523 B8695 DSP0524 Michael Ryan DSP0525 Patrick Fleming DSP0526 H4924 DSP0527 J0656 DSP0528 Michael O' Neill DSP0529 D7172 DSP0530 Pat Mc Kee DSP0531 James Horgan DSP0532 Sean Hourihan DSP0533 Anthony Murphy DSP0534 F2982 DSP0535 F3089 DSP0536 Brian Casey DSP0537 Carl Coleman DSP0538 G3789 DSP0539 Joe O' Donghue DSP0540 Maurice Shanahan DSP0541 H0877 DSP0542 H4923 DSP0543 H7560 DSP0544 Martin reade DSP0545 James O' Malley DSP0546 Pat Manogue DSP0547 L0397 DSP0548 Thomas Wade DSP0549 J2058 DSP0550 A1638 DSP0551 John Cahill DSP0552 Michael Kelly DSP0553 Frances Butler DSP0554 Mary Madden DSP0555 L0108 DSP0556 Nicky Byrne

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0557 willie Heffernan DSP0558 E7984 DSP0559 Martin Butler DSP0560 H0105 DSP0561 E5268 DSP0562 Anthony Madden DSP0563 Brian Taylor DSP0564 L0124 DSP0565 G5024 DSP0566 Eugene grace DSP0567 H8927 DSP0568 Seamus Walsh DSP0569 Graham Browne DSP0570 L0209 DSP0571 Paul Kelly DSP0572 Keith Burke DSP0573 Donal Madden DSP0574 J Holohan DSP0575 Pat Mahony DSP0576 James Walsh DSP0577 Paul Murphy DSP0578 William Lambe DSP0579 H0118 DSP0580 E1480 DSP0581 Joe Bourke DSP0582 Mark Dempsey DSP0583 Thomas Duffy DSP0584 Gerry Harken DSP0585 P Hurley DSP0586 Michael Barry DSP0587 Patrick murphy DSP0588 Shahid Azeem DSP0589 E6725 DSP0590 A Smith DSP0591 Joe Butler DSP0592 Bernadette Glynn DSP0593 Gareth Barker DSP0594 A13317 DSP0595 John Fitzpatrick DSP0596 John browne

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0597 J8830 DSP0598 Gerard Daly DSP0599 Leo Morgan DSP0600 K4946 DSP0601 Thomas O'Brien DSP0602 E 8054 DSP0603 J4694 DSP0604 Stephen Haughton DSP0605 Michael O' Reilly DSP0606 Colm Harte DSP0607 Albert Tucker DSP0608 Robert Wa;sh DSP0609 Darren Brown DSP0610 Joson Mathew DSP0611 Leszek Gabrys DSP0612 William Kinch DSP0613 Richard Daly DSP0614 Paul Coyle DSP0615 15816 DSP0616 G9655 DSP0617 Pat Tackaberry DSP0618 Paul Keogh DSP0619 Phil Mc Cluskey DSP0620 Pat Markey DSP0621 J2577 DSP0622 Jimmy Byrne DSP0623 Thomas Mc Grath DSP0624 B4553 DSP0625 John Byrne DSP0626 Pat Mc Ginley DSP0627 K8615 DSP0628 B0586 DSP0629 Noel Hyland DSP0630 Nelu Popa DSP0631 Brendan Murphy DSP0632 Mick Dollard DSP0633 D5561 DSP0634 J Teeling DSP0635 G4896 DSP0636 P Kavanagh

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0637 Alan Croker DSP0638 Joseph Branigan DSP0639 john Byrne DSP0640 K8658 DSP0641 B9085 DSP0642 C3037 DSP0643 D1970 DSP0644 Viorel Popor DSP0645 Paul Gannon DSP0646 H8318 DSP0647 Brenda Murray DSP0648 Patrick O'Connell DSP0649 John little DSP0650 Paul Mc Ellone DSP0651 John Preston DSP0652 John Brady DSP0653 John Cleary DSP0654 Gavnil Baratu DSP0655 K7831 DSP0656 Michael Glynn DSP0657 E Jocob DSP0658 Seamus Mc Carthy DSP0659 Conor Russell DSP0660 J Hilligton DSP0661 Mick Whelan DSP0662 Harry Allen DSP0663 M. Keeley DSP0664 F2745 DSP0665 E8246 DSP0666 H6570 DSP0667 K2480 DSP0668 Anthony MC Garry DSP0669 K3764 DSP0670 John Duggan DSP0671 J4461 DSP0672 K1687 DSP0673 J4129 DSP0674 H9930 DSP0675 Tony Howard DSP0676 Donal Moore

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0677 Ray Maguire DSP0678 C O' Leary DSP0679 Colm Dorrity DSP0680 Michael O'Driscoll DSP0681 Martin Byrne DSP0682 Philip Mc Govern DSP0683 H7915 DSP0684 Ray Murphy DSP0685 Frank Rowan DSP0686 Jim ryan DSP0687 Matt C DSP0688 E8211 DSP0689 Sean Murphy DSP0690 Peter Hynes DSP0691 Niall Byrne DSP0692 K1528 DSP0693 B5377 DSP0694 Kevin Nolan DSP0695 K3656 DSP0696 E1650 DSP0697 J1518 DSP0698 Ian Nicholson DSP0699 James Cranny DSP0700 Michael Keely DSP0701 A+J Cabs DSP0702 G8930 DSP0703 Patrick Forristal DSP0704 20635 DSP0705 D5786 DSP0706 F2749 DSP0707 H3487 DSP0708 H3092 DSP0709 A7216 DSP0710 E0266 DSP0711 Anthony Finlay DSP0712 Francis Nolan DSP0713 N Sutton DSP0714 C2380 DSP0715 A13213 DSP0716 G0556

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0717 F6181 DSP0718 Anthony Farrell DSP0719 K3982 DSP0720 C1269 DSP0721 John Curtis DSP0722 Niall Ward DSP0723 A5321 DSP0724 David Whitehead DSP0725 E1127 DSP0726 Maurice Gleeson DSP0727 V O' Driscol DSP0728 G8815 DSP0729 H4300 DSP0730 John H DSP0731 K7485 DSP0732 Alan power DSP0733 John Grace DSP0734 A6649 DSP0735 Paul Hennessy DSP0736 Nicholas Hannon DSP0737 Martin Lawalor DSP0738 Jonathan Leonard DSP0739 Niall Eager DSP0740 Bernard Murray DSP0741 Paul Murphy DSP0742 Sean Colgan DSP0743 Geroge Carthy DSP0744 F9163 DSP0745 Brendan Greene DSP0746 John Anderson DSP0747 K8035 DSP0748 Mark White DSP0749 J Mc Cormoc DSP0750 John Keegan DSP0751 Thomas Walsh DSP0752 Tony Treacy DSP0753 Paul Gartland DSP0754 Austin Blake DSP0755 Pat Curtis DSP0756 Ron Leonard

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0757 K7642 DSP0758 David Greene DSP0759 K9697 (coomon) DSP0760 Larry Ryan DSP0761 J5241 DSP0762 Richard MC Nally DSP0763 D8421 DSP0764 Patrick Kelly DSP0765 Gene Kelly DSP0766 G4442 DSP0767 Kevin Murphy DSP0768 A3467 DSP0769 J0408 DSP0770 F7778 DSP0771 Yamlal Yeung DSP0772 Conal Reilly DSP0773 John Costello DSP0774 J7236 DSP0775 Andrea Boccarossa DSP0776 Thomas Fay (Cpmmon) DSP0777 Noel Lowry DSP0778 Chris Fagan DSP0779 Niell St Ledger DSP0780 Paul Delahunty DSP0781 Edward Byrne DSP0782 Jason Mooney DSP0783 Martin O' Callaghan DSP0784 Christopher Temple DSP0785 Tom MC Cann DSP0786 Philip Rednond DSP0787 Peter Malone DSP0788 Albert Kelly DSP0789 J7851 DSP0790 James Mc Farland DSP0791 37298 DSP0792 Patrick Byrne DSP0793 Terry Mc Sweeney DSP0794 P. Maguire DSP0795 Patrick Fylan DSP0796 Ray Hurley

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0797 20247 DSP0798 K4783 DSP0799 30290 DSP0800 Noel Long DSP0801 E King DSP0802 P Corcoran DSP0803 David Burke DSP0804 Sean O' Shaughnessy DSP0805 Fiachra Burke DSP0806 David Michael DSP0807 Henry Bates DSP0808 Raymond Byrne DSP0809 Michael Mc Evoy DSP0810 Anthony Smith DSP0811 B8144 DSP0812 E6280 DSP0813 C8313 DSP0814 David Corcoran DSP0815 Jackie Morgan DSP0816 F9262 DSP0817 Stewart Barron DSP0818 Patrick Galligan DSP0819 Mary Tully DSP0820 M. Ward DSP0821 K9326 DSP0822 Joseph Duff DSP0823 Stephen Corcoran DSP0824 M Keogh DSP0825 70281 DSP0826 Ray Mc Mahon DSP0827 33562 DSP0828 Daniel John Mc Donagh DSP0829 Barry Mc Kay DSP0830 38827 DSP0831 E4138 DSP0832 E6579 DSP0833 26415 DSP0834 Paul Tucker DSP0835 Patrick Ferrie DSP0836 Maurice Power

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0837 William Jones DSP0838 Eamonn Mooney DSP0839 Jimmy Mc Dermott DSP0840 P Mc Guinness DSP0841 Danny Coughlan DSP0842 A14068 DSP0843 Arthur Hade DSP0844 J4293 DSP0845 Sean Bruton DSP0846 42218 DSP0847 David Dunne DSP0848 Syl Kavanagh DSP0849 Aidan Murphy DSP0850 K9205 DSP0851 H6059 DSP0852 L6463 DSP0853 E. Joe Gavine DSP0854 H5530 DSP0855 Andy Monks DSP0856 Oliver Kelly DSP0857 H9768 DSP0858 K9189 DSP0859 M Iliae DSP0860 L 6846 DSP0861 J 7722 DSP0862 Frances Brown DSP0863 Gerry White DSP0864 William Reilly DSP0865 Chris Dowd DSP0866 Wayne Bewley DSP0867 19987 DSP0868 John Dolan DSP0869 22802 DSP0870 Patrick Corcoran DSP0871 John Colhoun DSP0872 Imtiaz Nazir DSP0873 Suzanne Crosbie DSP0874 Roy Moynihan DSP0875 Jonathan Fagan DSP0876 K2609

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0877 Brendan Doyle DSP0878 James Cummins DSP0879 Thomas Keogh DSP0880 L7970 DSP0881 K8072 DSP0882 Mark Monnelly DSP0883 Mark Bradley DSP0884 John Timmon DSP0885 F9238 DSP0886 Colm Roche DSP0887 C6613 DSP0888 Marie Reilly DSP0889 Paul Darcy DSP0890 Neil Morgan DSP0891 Helen Malone DSP0892 F1468 DSP0893 C3235 DSP0894 Patrick Somers DSP0895 Stephen Dolen DSP0896 Ed Hickey DSP0897 F2615 DSP0898 Pat Mc Carthy DSP0899 Pat Emmett DSP0900 Anthony Moloney DSP0901 Ernie W Litton DSP0902 A. Bannon DSP0903 Keith Fagan DSP0904 Noel Synott DSP0905 Vincent Kinsella DSP0906 40094 DSP0907 D Murphy DSP0908 B1767 DSP0909 J0341 DSP0910 Joseph Brannigan DSP0911 Brian Keenan DSP0912 J6877 DSP0913 Michael Carroll DSP0914 Brendan Killee DSP0915 John Hogan DSP0916 Thomas Burke

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0917 H3779 DSP0918 P Kavanagh DSP0919 T Power DSP0920 J Power DSP0921 Johnny Johnston DSP0922 Patrick O' Neill DSP0923 Peter O' Connor DSP0924 Stephen Smith DSP0925 Edward Murphy DSP0926 D Johnston DSP0927 William Harcourt DSP0928 John Healy DSP0929 John Mc Cartney DSP0930 Gerard Tuite DSP0931 Patrick Scully DSP0932 Jim Roberts DSP0933 Martin Ring DSP0934 Edward Cullen DSP0935 Joe Mason DSP0936 Johnny Scurry DSP0937 L0700 DSP0938 Robby Richard DSP0939 Piotr Bys DSP0940 F0229 DSP0941 J1597 DSP0942 Edward Gill DSP0943 19384 DSP0944 N. William DSP0945 Phil Molloy DSP0946 Mark Woodward DSP0947 Patrick May DSP0948 26519 DSP0949 Eamonn Farrell DSP0950 36534 DSP0951 J4178 DSP0952 Derek O' Dowd DSP0953 A0589 DSP0954 Martin Daly DSP0955 Brendan Ryan DSP0956 Denis Hayes

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0957 John Hodson DSP0958 F7512 DSP0959 Heide Martin DSP0960 Brendan Cosgrave DSP0961 F5679 DSP0962 Darren O' Duffy DSP0963 Ken Delaney DSP0964 Jonathan Jewell DSP0965 18959 DSP0966 20328 DSP0967 20201 DSP0968 D4708 DSP0969 H6210 DSP0970 37488 DSP0971 1F6999 DSP0972 Arthur Murphy DSP0973 H8166 DSP0974 Patrick Fallon DSP0975 36838 DSP0976 E0232 DSP0977 Joseph Corri DSP0978 L6728 DSP0979 Matt Nugent DSP0980 Dave Morris DSP0981 K8758 DSP0982 K6665 DSP0983 J2546 DSP0984 K6272 DSP0985 W McCarthy DSP0986 S Conway DSP0987 John Byrne DSP0988 42093 DSP0989 Patrick Flynn DSP0990 22410 DSP0991 15890 DSP0992 Pat Lenihan DSP0993 L4937 DSP0994 L7820 DSP0995 Huseyin Salmon DSP0996 Ken O' Brien

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP0997 M McGuinness DSP0998 K5P40 DSP0999 F6106 DSP1000 C2911 DSP1001 K9135 DSP1002 J5261 DSP1003 Colm Hanlon DSP1004 G6801 DSP1005 Paul Spencer DSP1006 32186 DSP1007 Thomas Byrne DSP1008 Michael Purtill DSP1009 K3658 DSP1010 David Fitz DSP1011 David Lee DSP1012 Richard Fox DSP1013 H3524 DSP1014 Anthony Gray DSP1015 F8357 DSP1016 D8882 DSP1017 50071 DSP1018 R Reeder DSP1019 K5118 DSP1020 E0854 DSP1021 E Dodson DSP1022 L7578 DSP1023 21881 DSP1024 K7772 DSP1025 Noel Doyle DSP1026 Alan Kelly DSP1027 David Corrigan DSP1028 Maurice Keogh DSP1029 Gerard O' Halloran DSP1030 David O' Connor DSP1031 L6475 DSP1032 K9967 DSP1033 Edward Rooney DSP1034 L7846 DSP1035 William Hislop DSP1036 John O' Grady

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1037 J3246 DSP1038 F6838 DSP1039 D6127 DSP1040 James Bridgeman DSP1041 J1644 DSP1042 Liam Lawlor DSP1043 John Corcoran DSP1044 Damien Kenny DSP1045 Eddie Nolan DSP1046 F9316 DSP1047 H8369 DSP1048 J5103 DSP1049 Edward McGovern DSP1050 H6872 DSP1051 Jim Mooney DSP1052 G9454 DSP1053 Declan McCann DSP1054 Gerrard O' Toole DSP1055 G9798 DSP1056 B6881 DSP1057 Graham Byrne DSP1058 B Cahill DSP1059 Tony Capocci DSP1060 J8737 DSP1061 K3332 DSP1062 H6074 DSP1063 G9540 DSP1064 C211 DSP1065 F9287 DSP1066 B0422 DSP1067 J8864 DSP1068 F5673 DSP1069 D4515 DSP1070 M4321 DSP1071 Ciaran McCormack DSP1072 H5055 DSP1073 E Kavanagh DSP1074 G0945 DSP1075 K8933 DSP1076 A939

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1077 Tony Buggy DSP1078 Sokol Libofske DSP1079 Joe McGuinness DSP1080 Paul Quinn DSP1081 Thomas Burke DSP1082 Joseph Hayden DSP1083 A. Jenkins DSP1084 A5076 DSP1085 20512 DSP1086 Stephen Kelly DSP1087 Brian Carroll DSP1088 F7972 DSP1089 John Kelly DSP1090 Keith Flynn DSP1091 J4317 DSP1092 G9377 DSP1093 Colm Ross DSP1094 Warren Carroll DSP1095 F1656 DSP1096 D8917 DSP1097 F8508 DSP1098 34552 DSP1099 Thomas Fahy DSP1100 J3075 DSP1101 K1492 DSP1102 F7590 DSP1103 20188 DSP1104 F9512 DSP1105 G6775 DSP1106 D1406 DSP1107 H3701 DSP1108 Philip McDermott DSP1109 36109 DSP1110 F7639 DSP1111 J4284 DSP1112 Paschal Heary DSP1113 H7654 DSP1114 Trevor Harris DSP1115 A6116 DSP1116 Gerard Burke

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1117 Gerry Downey DSP1118 Larry Dignam DSP1119 Stephen Sully DSP1120 C6490 DSP1121 J Scanlon DSP1122 Thomas Moore DSP1123 A0031 DSP1124 C Dunne DSP1125 K4918 DSP1126 J8536 DSP1127 E6414 DSP1128 F6120 DSP1129 Brain Lawless DSP1130 L7621 DSP1131 Vincent Kiely DSP1132 John Pigott DSP1133 David Morris DSP1134 H0365 DSP1135 E9572 DSP1136 Colm Farrell DSP1137 J5995 DSP1138 Anthony O' Reilly DSP1139 K1775 DSP1140 B90576 DSP1141 F5755 DSP1142 A6616 DSP1143 Matt Woods DSP1144 Richard Troy DSP1145 J8816 DSP1146 G3496 DSP1147 F2711 DSP1148 Noel Reddy DSP1149 Les Walsh DSP1150 A4869 DSP1151 I8594 DSP1152 John Wilson DSP1153 Pat Lyons DSP1154 Pattrick Pugh DSP1155 John Hyland DSP1156 19566

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1157 J5347 DSP1158 Anthony Smith DSP1159 F Kennedy DSP1160 Edward Walsh DSP1161 Davids Gorman DSP1162 Arno Jurjans DSP1163 Jacinta Ryan DSP1164 Wayne Whelan DSP1165 Emmet Coakley DSP1166 Liam O' Shea DSP1167 F0186 DSP1168 Bernard Aherne DSP1169 Jie Chen DSP1170 John Gilroy DSP1171 Desmond Fallon DSP1172 A3180 DSP1173 David o' Keefe DSP1174 John Lowry DSP1175 A10463 DSP1176 A126 DSP1177 K7686 DSP1178 F9140 DSP1179 H4425 DSP1180 H5038 DSP1181 G6868 DSP1182 Micael Forristal DSP1183 K3762 DSP1184 J McCormack DSP1185 DD4463 DSP1186 D Sunistrum DSP1187 Niall O' Brien DSP1188 Albert Johnson DSP1189 F1468 DSP1190 H5548 DSP1191 F4741 DSP1192 M Treacy DSP1193 Ian Brophy DSP1194 F5782 DSP1195 Michael Walsh DSP1196 F8356

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1197 Colin Maguire DSP1198 Daniel Staskiewicz DSP1199 Thomas Mahon DSP1200 Larry Kelly DSP1201 Anthony Smullen DSP1202 Garry O' Hara DSP1203 Alan Kilbride DSP1204 Gerard Thunder DSP1205 Andrew Thunder DSP1206 Jerry Victory DSP1207 Alan Ingoldsby DSP1208 H4366 DSP1209 Keith Reddy DSP1210 J4950 DSP1211 E9034 DSP1212 Martin Gleeson DSP1213 Frank McMahon DSP1214 D373 DSP1215 Paul McMahon DSP1216 Joe Henway DSP1217 5047 DSP1218 Noel Murray DSP1219 Paddy Ivory DSP1220 L6719 DSP1221 Liam Brady DSP1222 J6985 DSP1223 L7735 DSP1224 David Slattery DSP1225 Cornelius O' Leary DSP1226 Niall Walsh DSP1227 M. O'Brien DSP1228 5316 DSP1229 C6635 DSP1230 Sean Saunders DSP1231 Edward McIntyre DSP1232 Salman Azeem DSP1233 Paul Kelly DSP1234 Eric Hickey DSP1235 James Merrigan DSP1236 James McNally

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1237 Patrick O' Neill DSP1238 John Doherty DSP1239 J1405 DSP1240 Joseph Fitzpatrick DSP1241 Gerald Fitzgerald DSP1242 Freddie Deignan DSP1243 Breda Doyle DSP1244 Noel Doyle DSP1245 Ross Dunne DSP1246 Michael McGuinness DSP1247 Paul Carey DSP1248 Mark Meehan DSP1249 Noel Gaskin DSP1250 20886 DSP1251 D9529 DSP1252 J0145 DSP1253 Denis Nolan DSP1254 Paul Grant DSP1255 Paul Cranley DSP1256 E8150 DSP1257 E3077 DSP1258 Noel McDonnell DSP1259 Thomas O'Keefe DSP1260 K4821 DSP1261 Denis Gordon DSP1262 Francis Duggan DSP1263 C1277 DSP1264 Gavin Mooney DSP1265 D Kavanagh DSP1266 Keith Hanway DSP1267 Fred Tucker DSP1268 J2466 DSP1269 Paul Kenny DSP1270 Ian McKenna DSP1271 K4765 DSP1272 Richard Ryan DSP1273 J3206 DSP1274 Daniel Lloyd DSP1275 Philip Grogan DSP1276 22112

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1277 H6872 DSP1278 John Byrne DSP1279 H6127 DSP1280 Charles Cosgrave DSP1281 Stephen Carberry DSP1282 J8267 DSP1283 Darren O'Reilly DSP1284 Robert Ryan DSP1285 Patrick Kelly DSP1286 K3959 DSP1287 F1064 DSP1288 A0090 DSP1289 Declan Robert DSP1290 James Brady DSP1291 J2532 DSP1292 A0043 DSP1293 W. Tyrrell DSP1294 Steven Moran DSP1295 Charlie O' Neill DSP1296 Darren May DSP1297 D3769 DSP1298 D1935 DSP1299 B4601 DSP1300 E0263 DSP1301 C3120 DSP1302 Anthony Flood DSP1303 L7724 DSP1304 K9466 DSP1305 Anthony Dignam DSP1306 Michael Laurence DSP1307 G9674 DSP1308 Andrew Lambe DSP1309 Matthew O' Sullivan DSP1310 Tom McGuinness DSP1311 F6557 DSP1312 J3101 DSP1313 Paul Akamelu DSP1314 David Kenny DSP1315 Seamus Power DSP1316 Gerard O' Neill

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1317 J0318 DSP1318 29681 DSP1319 J2585 DSP1320 Philip Keogh DSP1321 Thomas Burke DSP1322 H3357 DSP1323 65736 DSP1324 K3776 DSP1325 Godwin Aniuzu DSP1326 K8666 DSP1327 L6271 DSP1328 Gideon Formin DSP1329 Willie Omozuzi DSP1330 J7386 DSP1331 P Edge DSP1332 John Canavan DSP1333 Wai Kuew Hui DSP1334 James Butler DSP1335 Aurel Popa DSP1336 Tommy Cranny DSP1337 K1528 DSP1338 A4068 DSP1339 F0215 DSP1340 J9248 DSP1341 J Stone DSP1342 J4397 DSP1343 Aidan Hanney DSP1344 P Maples DSP1345 Noel Kinsella DSP1346 D6422 DSP1347 G6258 DSP1348 Hugh McGinn DSP1349 John Kennedy DSP1350 E6604 DSP1351 Greg Boyle DSP1352 M0405 DSP1353 Colin Tracy DSP1354 E9087 DSP1355 H9189 DSP1356 Tony Baker

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1357 W Aspill DSP1358 O Oluseyi DSP1359 E8454 DSP1360 P Hanney DSP1361 B5143 DSP1362 Eamon Hickey DSP1363 James Clarke DSP1364 Eugene O' Neill DSP1365 Chris Dalton DSP1366 K5194 DSP1367 K9166 DSP1368 H0330 DSP1369 James Keegan DSP1370 C1171 DSP1371 David Reilly DSP1372 Tommy Seagrave DSP1373 G0509 DSP1374 David Daly DSP1375 F1691 DSP1376 Darren Bergin DSP1377 M9768 DSP1378 K5181 DSP1379 D Purcell DSP1380 G6334 DSP1381 H0437 DSP1382 James Dalton DSP1383 Alan Mason DSP1384 21010 DSP1385 James Shiels DSP1386 B8048 DSP1387 Paul O' Dowd DSP1388 Joe Flanagan DSP1389 Noel Williams DSP1390 Denis Rigney DSP1391 A5909 DSP1392 Darren Dondall DSP1393 Joseph Flood DSP1394 Karl O' Neill DSP1395 Michael Scully DSP1396 F2870

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1397 Noel O' Reilly DSP1398 Stephen Yeomans DSP1399 John Clinton DSP1400 Terence O' Connor DSP1401 S. Brady DSP1402 M Dalton DSP1403 L6265 DSP1404 Susan McCarthy DSP1405 Mark Doran DSP1406 F9164 DSP1407 K3681 DSP1408 Collins Akintola DSP1409 Samson Ojo DSP1410 Patrick Creed DSP1411 M Sheridan DSP1412 L4983 DSP1413 Robert Keys DSP1414 G6318 DSP1415 Vernan Boyd DSP1416 Louis Jones DSP1417 Noel Boyne DSP1418 Niall Sheridan DSP1419 Jean Byrne DSP1420 Kevin Smith DSP1421 Thomas Tyrrell DSP1422 Gerry Eccles DSP1423 H0571 DSP1424 Thomas Walsh DSP1425 Brendan Cunningham DSP1426 Alan Wall DSP1427 B9090 DSP1428 P Graham DSP1429 26213 DSP1430 S O' kelly DSP1431 2G348 DSP1432 John Byrne DSP1433 36701 DSP1434 P Boyle DSP1435 G6080 DSP1436 G6366

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1437 Noel Flynn DSP1438 Anthony O' Reilly DSP1439 D Brady DSP1440 17448 DSP1441 Paddy Grant DSP1442 Brendan Losty DSP1443 B0543 DSP1444 Brian Buckley DSP1445 K1519 DSP1446 K1708 DSP1447 Pat lally DSP1448 Joe Reilly DSP1449 H9923 DSP1450 Patrick Lally DSP1451 Robert D. Farrelly DSP1452 Paul Lally DSP1453 Kenneth Griffin DSP1454 David McKeon DSP1455 J0211 DSP1456 K7603 DSP1457 Brendan kenny DSP1458 F8440 DSP1459 Christy O' Connor DSP1460 Alan Coyle DSP1461 G0579 DSP1462 J4229 DSP1463 DG457 DSP1464 J01014 DSP1465 Peter Smith DSP1466 Mary Farrell DSP1467 Oliver Byrne DSP1468 F5466 DSP1469 K9892 DSP1470 Con Brehony DSP1471 Brian Byrne DSP1472 John Rabbitt DSP1473 H4176 DSP1474 J8249 DSP1475 Liam Doyle DSP1476 L6249

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1477 Andrew Page DSP1478 Ian O' Carolan DSP1479 Kevin Daly DSP1480 22336 DSP1481 L6716 DSP1482 J8845 DSP1483 Myles Dillon DSP1484 Terry O' Donnell DSP1485 21107 DSP1486 Patrick Reid DSP1487 John Telling DSP1488 Paul Carroll DSP1489 25186 DSP1490 Ian Clarke DSP1491 Patrick O' Connor DSP1492 J6893 DSP1493 Jonathon Benson DSP1494 John Byrne DSP1495 19005 DSP1496 Laurence Doyle DSP1497 16801 DSP1498 K2615 DSP1499 David Emerson DSP1500 34367 DSP1501 Darren McKeown DSP1502 G9459 DSP1503 Frank Buckley DSP1504 Arthur Farrell DSP1505 G5546 DSP1506 Barry O' Sullivan DSP1507 Tonyu Dunphy DSP1508 Andrew Brady DSP1509 F8015 DSP1510 Bernard McCarthy DSP1511 Liam Murray DSP1512 John O' Brien DSP1513 Tim Barrett DSP1514 Christy O' Sullivan DSP1515 Patrick Leahy DSP1516 Niall McCarthy

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1517 B3701 DSP1518 Peter Duffy DSP1519 P O'Sullivan DSP1520 Maurice O' Keefe DSP1521 Diarmuid Bridgeman DSP1522 Donel O' Donoghue DSP1523 John O' Donovon DSP1524 F8021 DSP1525 B9512 DSP1526 Bridget Locke DSP1527 James Locke DSP1528 William Spring DSP1529 Corneluis Spring DSP1530 F7387 DSP1531 K976 DSP1532 K0578 DSP1533 James Cronin DSP1534 A1066 DSP1535 Brian McCarthy DSP1536 Daniel Murphy DSP1537 Liam O' Neill DSP1538 Dermot Couch DSP1539 John Ryan DSP1540 Paul Mulcahy DSP1541 Gerry Doyle DSP1542 J0529 DSP1543 11409 DSP1544 John Collins DSP1545 L5227 DSP1546 B2086 DSP1547 Alan O' Donovan DSP1548 Muhammad Junaid Ayub DSP1549 Jeramiah Purcell DSP1550 3341 DSP1551 E5578 DSP1552 Donal O' Callaghan DSP1553 G5579 DSP1554 Timmy Smith DSP1555 William Drought DSP1556 B2365

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1557 James O' Callaghan DSP1558 Richard Kearney DSP1559 Willie Prendergast DSP1560 Michael Paul Martin DSP1561 Mark Geaney DSP1562 Denis O' Keefe DSP1563 Eddie O' Sullivan DSP1564 Kieran McNamara DSP1565 Kingsley Eze DSP1566 M0845 DSP1567 Derek O' Sullivan DSP1568 Paul Pio Coffey DSP1569 E2052 DSP1570 Pat Kelleher DSP1571 David Joy DSP1572 42703 DSP1573 Anthony Brady DSP1574 John Lynch DSP1575 Alan O' Shea DSP1576 Paul Martin DSP1577 Liam Murphy DSP1578 Tom Buckley DSP1579 10781 DSP1580 Ganiyy Ishola Bamidele DSP1581 11995 DSP1582 Niall Curtin DSP1583 10783 DSP1584 Jim McAulliffe DSP1585 Robert Tyrrell DSP1586 John Bourke DSP1587 H5792 DSP1588 E3152 DSP1589 Patrick Horgan DSP1590 E5175 DSP1591 John Murphy DSP1592 Timothy Houlihan DSP1593 Anthony Foley DSP1594 John O' Connell DSP1595 Con Mooney DSP1596 H0768

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1597 E5445 DSP1598 L2119 DSP1599 G5537 DSP1600 Jim McAulliffe DSP1601 Pat Connolly DSP1602 Ger Leahy DSP1603 Raynor De Foubert DSP1604 Billy Bermingham DSP1605 Frank Healy DSP1606 Pat Hayden DSP1607 H7527 DSP1608 Brain Cronin DSP1609 John Delaney DSP1610 James Bonus DSP1611 Donal Spillane DSP1612 Tomas DSP1613 K0887 DSP1614 Henry Paul DSP1615 Patrick Roche DSP1616 H7570 DSP1617 Pat O' Sullivan DSP1618 Michael O' Connor DSP1619 D5058 DSP1620 Stephen McCarthy DSP1621 Pioir Fraciwwiak DSP1622 Robert Lukvar DSP1623 Roy McSweeney DSP1624 Paul Kelly DSP1625 Kieran Hayes DSP1626 Val Flannery DSP1627 J2362 DSP1628 A0037 DSP1629 Frank Ryan DSP1630 C5597 DSP1631 K5100 DSP1632 8755 DSP1633 Liam Brady DSP1634 Ko0604 DSP1635 Dennis Kelly DSP1636 40752

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1637 H4944 DSP1638 D5218 DSP1639 J0841 DSP1640 J0841 DSP1641 Colm Barry DSP1642 11729 DSP1643 Robert Mulliagn DSP1644 D5248 DSP1645 Ted Lynch DSP1646 Morgan Collins DSP1647 C5472 DSP1648 Paul Kelleher DSP1649 Declan O Brien DSP1650 J7960 DSP1651 K6990 DSP1652 Feargal Ryan DSP1653 10252 DSP1654 Daniel Desmond DSP1655 Pat Harington DSP1656 1741 DSP1656 Angile Gallagher DSP1656 Basil Dike DSP1656 Carlito Filipe DSP1656 Celestin D Luvawka DSP1656 Colm Ryan DSP1656 E4764 DSP1656 Gerry Hugh DSP1656 H5395 DSP1656 Henry Iegekwu DSP1656 Ifenyi Ibe DSP1656 Jim Maude DSP1656 John Moloney DSP1656 Michael Clancy DSP1656 Mick Power DSP1656 Mishanur Rahman DSP1656 P Lynch DSP1656 Patrick Omolshoa DSP1656 Peter O' Connell DSP1656 Steve Sommaizia DSP1656 Thomas Neville

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1656 Tom Tully DSP1657 Abdulrasaq Alugo DSP1657 Benedict Emeka Ezeony DSP1657 Bernardo Gaspar DSP1657 C7130 DSP1657 Cyril Henderson DSP1657 Derek Kelleher DSP1657 E5001 DSP1657 Fatmir Pregna DSP1657 Gerard McKeague DSP1657 Joe Deveney DSP1657 John Gallagher DSP1657 John Isobor DSP1657 L5535 DSP1657 M Leonariz DSP1657 Mike Burke DSP1657 Mike O' Brien DSP1657 Paddy Connolly DSP1657 Paul Langan DSP1657 Paul O' Donnell DSP1657 Peter Gibbons DSP1657 Prince Newman DSP1657 R Cotter DSP1657 Setukalayaku Befula DSP1657 T Dillon DSP1657 Toni Denis DSP1658 28049 DSP1658 32677 DSP1658 59869 DSP1658 A2111 DSP1658 A4619 DSP1658 Alan Connelly DSP1658 Aregbesolaq Abesim DSP1658 Chris O' Keefe DSP1658 Conleth Maloney DSP1658 Des Gallagher DSP1658 G1491 DSP1658 H4605 DSP1658 H9328 DSP1658 J9428

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1658 J9593 DSP1658 Joe Brazil DSP1658 Joe Guckian DSP1658 Joshep Maina DSP1658 Laundry Milansil DSP1658 Mary Dolan DSP1658 Mike Mullins DSP1658 Munger Alhaddad DSP1658 Shakbel Ahmed DSP1658 Willie Trill DSP1659 33585 DSP1659 Abid Quershi DSP1659 Aderrmi Bakare DSP1659 Autine Osbeide DSP1659 C1030 DSP1659 Christy Manning DSP1659 D Murphy DSP1659 Gerry Concannon DSP1659 Gerry Moylan DSP1659 J5628 DSP1659 John O' Donnell DSP1659 Kanda Mateta DSP1659 L4753 DSP1659 L5402 DSP1659 Laurence Lawless DSP1659 Liam Hannon DSP1659 Maissam Athir DSP1659 Mike lawal DSP1659 Ray Watek DSP1659 Taofeeq Kadeso DSP1659 V Lukyanov DSP1660 28799 DSP1660 Joe Nally DSP1660 John Ogsa DSP1660 Mike Kelly DSP1660 Patrick Connolly DSP1661 D45549 DSP1662 J8914 DSP1663 K2462 DSP1664 C5611

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1665 D Moran DSP1666 C2422 DSP1667 Liam Perkins DSP1668 James Connolly DSP1669 A0061 DSP1670 Armstrong Birlinary DSP1671 Mark Callaghan DSP1672 Michael McEvoy DSP1673 E3377 DSP1674 G6258 DSP1675 Ray McEvoy DSP1676 David Cunningham DSP1677 Anthony Rothwell DSP1678 Stanley N DSP1679 William Kennedy DSP1680 Brian Kelly DSP1681 Paul Sheridan DSP1682 Kenny Shaw DSP1683 Arthur Ebbs DSP1684 Bob Coffey DSP1685 A7051 DSP1686 F7448 DSP1687 K4830 DSP1688 K2544 DSP1689 A6777 DSP1690 Des Walker DSP1691 John Dignam DSP1692 V Lavelle DSP1693 B9290 DSP1694 G0525 DSP1695 J0396 DSP1696 Chris Ellis DSP1697 H5493 DSP1698 G0586 DSP1699 A6839 DSP1700 E3248 DSP1701 H8210 DSP1702 Gareth Donnelly DSP1703 F2627 DSP1704 Thomas Redmond

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1705 B5868 DSP1706 Tony Wall DSP1707 Thomas Butler DSP1708 James Griffin DSP1709 Jennifer Ryan DSP1710 F4760 DSP1711 J Egan DSP1712 Peter Kenny DSP1713 Jarlath Mooney DSP1714 A3097 DSP1714 Adeniyi Falai Alabi DSP1714 Afolabi Oseni DSP1714 Anthony Sheridan DSP1714 B8410 DSP1714 B9886 DSP1714 Billy McCaffrey DSP1714 Dolores McLawrence DSP1714 E5967 DSP1714 E6740 DSP1714 E7898 DSP1714 E7946 DSP1714 E7971 DSP1714 F4615 DSP1714 F5034 DSP1714 F9801 DSP1714 G5039 DSP1714 G5087 DSP1714 H1718 DSP1714 John Acheson DSP1714 John Dudy DSP1714 John Kerr DSP1714 K0259 DSP1714 K0333 DSP1714 K0358 DSP1714 K0360 DSP1714 K0366 DSP1714 K4009 DSP1714 L0176 DSP1714 L0193 DSP1714 L0212

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1714 L0360 DSP1714 L0387 DSP1714 L160 DSP1714 M Fitzgerald DSP1714 Mary Ryan DSP1714 Mick Kearney DSP1714 Noel McLawrence DSP1714 Paddy Doyle DSP1714 Pat Dermody DSP1714 Shane Mulcahy DSP1714 W7020 DSP1714 William Hearrie DSP1715 Michael Glancy DSP1716 17326 DSP1717 B4460 DSP1718 Patrick McNulty DSP1719 John Mooney DSP1720 John Mahon DSP1721 Gerard Kelly DSP1722 C Dempsey DSP1723 P Flood DSP1724 Jospeh Conlon DSP1725 Alan Kearns DSP1726 G4813 DSP1727 Kevin Gaffney DSP1728 G0737 DSP1729 James Keogh DSP1730 F9597 DSP1731 John Paul Byrne DSP1732 C3994 DSP1733 Chris Farrell DSP1734 J7579 DSP1735 K9151 DSP1736 C5230 DSP1737 Noel Bell DSP1738 Pat Whelan DSP1739 Anthony Austin DSP1740 E8079 DSP1741 K7511 DSP1742 J1381

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1743 F4794 DSP1744 F9102 DSP1745 Youssouf B Gba DSP1746 K3581 DSP1747 F6054 DSP1748 D5561 DSP1749 K4673 DSP1750 J1606 DSP1751 K1751 DSP1752 G0606 DSP1753 Paul Whelan DSP1754 D2268 DSP1755 Raymond Evans DSP1756 C6623 DSP1757 K3863 DSP1758 D0471 DSP1759 Patrick Lynch DSP1760 G7931 DSP1761 Susan Osavzou DSP1762 J6750 DSP1763 D4320 DSP1764 Fergus King DSP1765 J7334 DSP1766 Maurice Murphy DSP1767 K2567 DSP1768 B7952 DSP1769 Eamon Ryan DSP1770 A5146 DSP1771 Damien Gleeson DSP1772 Benson Egbon DSP1773 J8829 DSP1774 Joe Sorbes DSP1775 David Griffin DSP1776 F9536 DSP1777 Peter Keane DSP1778 James Connolly DSP1779 A11097 DSP1780 G Doyle DSP1781 C3212 DSP1782 David Dempsey

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1783 Mick Kelly DSP1784 Charles Moran DSP1785 B6644 DSP1786 John White DSP1787 A5905 DSP1788 Andrew Keane DSP1789 Seamus Roe DSP1790 David Bartley DSP1791 A5720 DSP1792 Donal Brophy DSP1793 D6163 DSP1794 William Hughes DSP1795 Mark Hennessy DSP1796 Keith Larkin DSP1797 E5730 DSP1798 B6115 DSP1799 C8372 DSP1800 K8273 DSP1801 H3917 DSP1802 J Brennan DSP1803 C5702 DSP1804 H0518 DSP1805 E8370 DSP1806 K8823 DSP1807 Gary Boyle DSP1808 Stephen Byrne DSP1809 58850 DSP1810 K7541 DSP1811 James Greene DSP1812 K1525 DSP1813 K3819 DSP1814 James Matthews DSP1815 Brian Sullivan DSP1816 K4900 DSP1817 B6711 DSP1818 Anthony Courtney DSP1819 E9369 DSP1820 Martin Shaughnessy DSP1821 John Garland DSP1822 B9128

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1823 E6244 DSP1824 J8336 DSP1825 Mark Keaty DSP1826 F1404 DSP1827 C6252 DSP1828 J5014 DSP1829 Yew Heong Yeow DSP1830 Thomas Fay DSP1831 E0296 DSP1832 K3951 DSP1833 H6187 DSP1834 Sean Nolan DSP1835 L6882 DSP1836 James Clerkin DSP1837 A10289 DSP1838 E8129 DSP1839 K4748 DSP1840 D6273 DSP1841 E1198 DSP1842 K1500 DSP1843 B5154 DSP1844 Ann Kavanagh DSP1845 H8370 DSP1846 C6396 DSP1847 Karl Moore DSP1848 Joe Fagan DSP1849 Kevin Smith DSP1850 Mick Smyth DSP1851 Francis Leech DSP1852 A0319 DSP1853 J8376 DSP1854 Ian Quigley DSP1855 F4722 DSP1856 Liam Kirwan DSP1857 G4375 DSP1858 C4197 DSP1859 Owen Power DSP1860 J8310 DSP1861 Anthony Madden DSP1862 Barry O' Toole

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1863 G6731 DSP1864 B Lloyd DSP1865 E4496 DSP1866 Agnes Crossan DSP1867 CB41 DSP1868 E3577 DSP1869 Sean Mahon DSP1870 James Kelly DSP1871 E5883 DSP1872 Eamon Hughes DSP1873 Mark Boyle DSP1874 Adrian O' Hara DSP1875 F.B. Healy DSP1876 Thomas O' Neill DSP1877 J6367 DSP1878 Michael Fleming DSP1879 G9998 DSP1880 J6277 DSP1881 J6323 DSP1882 E Hughes DSP1883 J6323 DSP1884 G9876 DSP1885 J B Healy DSP1886 J6367 DSP1887 G9876 DSP1888 Thomas O' Neill DSP1889 Mark Boyle DSP1890 G9998 DSP1891 J6377 DSP1892 J6277 DSP1893 H0089 DSP1894 A6659 DSP1895 A14070 DSP1896 Padraig Buckley DSP1897 Eamon Fitzgibbon DSP1898 K3553 DSP1899 E3198 DSP1900 J1643 DSP1901 Paul Donohoe DSP1902 H5553

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1903 E4344 DSP1904 C2251 DSP1905 L8585 DSP1906 K6446 DSP1907 John McDonnell DSP1908 A Omolodion DSP1909 Evelyn Brady DSP1910 C5566 DSP1911 Martin Akinjotimi DSP1912 A10208 DSP1913 E8276 DSP1914 E0238 DSP1915 Paul Boyle DSP1916 Leslie Matthews DSP1917 Peter O' Reilly DSP1918 21756 DSP1919 D6108 DSP1920 Olivia Malone DSP1921 K7202 DSP1922 Maurice Dunne DSP1923 K6236 DSP1924 Fran Lindsay DSP1925 K1616 DSP1926 Martin Griffin DSP1927 Alan Kelly DSP1928 Frank Byrne DSP1929 Martin Reilly DSP1930 K2463 DSP1931 Michael O' Driscoll DSP1932 G9539 DSP1933 Michael Reilly DSP1934 B6042 DSP1935 Thomas Reeves DSP1936 A0048 DSP1937 C8123 DSP1938 19189 DSP1939 Marcus Richardson DSP1940 F1407 DSP1941 H5008 DSP1942 Christopher O' Leary

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1943 John Gilroy DSP1944 B1096 DSP1945 E1535 DSP1946 Richard Fullam DSP1947 Derek Jackson DSP1948 G Burke DSP1949 Thomas Walker DSP1950 Michael Connell DSP1951 Mark Lawlor DSP1952 F01017 DSP1953 G8659 DSP1954 Christopher Ryan DSP1955 Gerard White DSP1956 C2505 DSP1957 D0593 DSP1958 J5071 DSP1959 K1422 DSP1960 L1241 DSP1961 B6959 DSP1962 F6479 DSP1963 Tom Ryan DSP1964 E6258 DSP1965 Ray McEvoy DSP1966 Peter McDonald DSP1967 H6369 DSP1968 Bernard O' Brien DSP1969 Lisa Cullen DSP1970 C5164 DSP1971 G8721 DSP1972 A981 DSP1973 K2882 DSP1974 E9050 DSP1975 Clar Smyth DSP1976 Liam Donohoe DSP1977 F7658 DSP1978 James Keogh DSP1979 C5183 DSP1980 Wayne Cole DSP1981 K2492 DSP1982 Patrick Smithirs

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP1983 A10804 DSP1984 H6557 DSP1985 P Fitzpatrick DSP1986 J8374 DSP1987 Kevin Hanlon DSP1988 Frank Moone DSP1989 Alex Larkin DSP1990 Anthony Groves DSP1991 Des Carroll DSP1992 J Long DSP1993 3937D DSP1994 David Evans DSP1995 Alan Reid DSP1996 Anthony O' Gorman DSP1997 E6441 DSP1998 Declan Fagan DSP1999 Brian Healy DSP2000 Paul Carroll DSP2001 Paul Davis DSP2002 F0181 DSP2003 18144 DSP2004 E5163 DSP2005 Patrick McKeon DSP2006 D8884 DSP2007 H8159 DSP2008 G6161 DSP2009 Alan Delaney DSP2010 A4500 DSP2011 J7750 DSP2012 D6104 DSP2013 Mark Masterson DSP2014 H4215 DSP2015 K1214 DSP2016 G4981 DSP2017 K9902 DSP2018 J8611 DSP2019 H5521 DSP2020 L7966 DSP2021 K2516 DSP2022 H3679

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2023 G0605 DSP2024 J7042 DSP2025 E4449 DSP2026 J3295 DSP2027 B4458 DSP2028 B1270 DSP2029 Conor Henelley DSP2030 Tommy Doyle DSP2031 Chris Johnson DSP2032 John Keane DSP2033 K9112 DSP2034 J4009 DSP2035 Kevin Lynch DSP2036 C6287 DSP2037 D1788 DSP2038 H0371 DSP2039 Declan Murphy DSP2040 F6040 DSP2041 K9904 DSP2042 G9728 DSP2043 Christopher Flynn DSP2044 John Doyle DSP2045 F6972 DSP2046 Martin Murtagh DSP2047 Denis Hayes DSP2048 C6303 DSP2049 Thomas Dunn DSP2050 Tom Kearns DSP2051 C2251 DSP2052 D4519 DSP2053 K8505 DSP2054 A0489 DSP2055 Joseph Quinn DSP2056 Vincent Merriman DSP2057 Brian Kane DSP2058 F2654 DSP2059 K6693 DSP2060 A0075 DSP2061 B3636 DSP2062 Hubert Cleary

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2063 P Hannabus DSP2064 James Baker DSP2065 Tom Cassidy DSP2066 C1516 DSP2067 G6469 DSP2068 Robert Ross DSP2069 John Feeney DSP2070 Carl Walsh DSP2071 James Mullaney DSP2072 Wayne Treacy DSP2073 K2569 DSP2074 D4121 DSP2075 A0038 DSP2076 D9097 DSP2077 H5111 DSP2078 D4593 DSP2079 H6564 DSP2080 Bernard O' Sullivan DSP2081 Tony Walsh DSP2082 Gerry Murphy DSP2083 K7042 DSP2084 G8885 DSP2085 Paul Kelly DSP2086 Derek Hanlon DSP2087 B5098 DSP2088 D1935 DSP2089 F0384 DSP2090 H6132 DSP2091 B6970 DSP2092 D6232 DSP2093 F6080 DSP2094 Peter Weidridge DSP2095 K6704 DSP2096 K7899 DSP2097 Osy Nweke DSP2098 J8748 DSP2099 Louis Doran DSP2100 G0766 DSP2101 Paul lawlor DSP2102 E6511

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2103 1774 DSP2104 Gerard Foy DSP2105 F5533 DSP2106 Kolawole Olubakin DSP2107 F1417 DSP2108 Henry Edogiawerie DSP2109 E6217 DSP2110 James Sheen DSP2111 Stephen Lavis DSP2112 K8361 DSP2113 Mick Barrett DSP2114 Samrt J Ewamsiha DSP2115 B4601 DSP2116 John Hackett DSP2117 J9019 DSP2118 William Byrne DSP2119 G9268 DSP2120 Thomas Harvey DSP2121 Thomas Connolly DSP2122 G5191 DSP2123 David Burke DSP2124 E0944 DSP2125 John Forde DSP2126 J3664 DSP2127 David Foley DSP2128 C0990 DSP2129 F4314 DSP2130 D Hanley DSP2131 J9039 DSP2132 G9273 DSP2133 Michael O' Donovan DSP2134 L2086 DSP2135 B9768 DSP2136 Edmond Sullivan DSP2137 C0953 DSP2138 Michael Pollard DSP2139 Michael O' Brien DSP2140 Tony Le Blanc DSP2141 A13561 DSP2142 Kevin Barrett

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2143 Pat Landers DSP2144 Marie Crotty DSP2145 William Ryan DSP2146 D. Connolly DSP2147 A11171 DSP2148 D1500 DSP2149 L Farrell DSP2150 D9546 DSP2151 G3499 DSP2152 9541 DSP2153 Ciaran Griffin DSP2154 Mark Quinn DSP2155 Declan Costello DSP2156 L0714 DSP2157 I6533 DSP2158 L5713 DSP2159 Gamiyu A Asubiaro DSP2160 Robert Kerr DSP2161 Michael Byrne DSP2162 L0722 DSP2163 L5790 DSP2164 Adam Hurley DSP2165 L4201 DSP2166 Bernard Daly DSP2167 Thomas Harding DSP2168 Gary Ellis DSP2169 K6231 DSP2170 Satimder Sihgy DSP2171 Desmond Delaney DSP2172 F6952 DSP2173 Eamon O' Donoghue DSP2174 David Palmer DSP2175 H6858 DSP2176 Garrett Hanney DSP2177 James kelly DSP2178 Anthony Murphy DSP2179 Anthony Coleman DSP2180 Aoran Lovett DSP2181 4861 DSP2182 David Daly

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2183 J5181 DSP2184 P Curtis DSP2185 Patrick Fennessy DSP2186 Alan Fitzpatrick DSP2187 J0353 DSP2188 E Dillon DSP2189 P O' Donoghue DSP2190 Joe Thomas DSP2191 F2761 DSP2192 K2417 DSP2193 Patrick Redmond DSP2194 J Delaney DSP2195 E8836 DSP2196 Stephen Doyle DSP2197 Oliver Carroll DSP2198 A3180 DSP2199 Patricia Hanney DSP2200 G9755 DSP2201 K2678 DSP2202 John Lowry DSP2203 Paul Foley DSP2204 Derek Doran DSP2205 L3512 DSP2206 J1590 DSP2207 Matthew Keogh DSP2208 J3268 DSP2209 James Ogiamiere DSP2210 Jospeh O' Farrell DSP2211 Patrick Govenu DSP2212 J7057 DSP2213 E5087 DSP2214 Paddy Keogh DSP2215 Michael Purcell DSP2216 F2662 DSP2217 Colm O' Brien DSP2218 Tony Shiels DSP2219 Robert Reilly DSP2220 B8165 DSP2221 E2813 DSP2222 H8331

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2223 K3808 DSP2224 H0659 DSP2225 Tony Evans DSP2226 Pauline O' Neill DSP2227 Fred Christie DSP2228 J8000 DSP2229 G4693 DSP2230 B9379 DSP2231 Morgan Kenny DSP2232 Michael Moore DSP2233 Paul Doran DSP2234 Paddy Duggan DSP2235 Clive Smyth DSP2236 P Gilligan DSP2237 Peter Delaney DSP2238 Gerard Murphy DSP2239 Stephen Smith DSP2240 Patrick Duffy DSP2241 K2768 DSP2242 Lee Hennessy DSP2243 H8219 DSP2244 K1579 DSP2245 H4377 DSP2246 K7588 DSP2247 B4552 DSP2248 F9690 DSP2249 Lee Jones DSP2250 Angus McDonnell DSP2251 Larry Kelly DSP2252 H8294 DSP2253 M0933 DSP2254 F2797 DSP2255 E9148 DSP2256 H0507 DSP2257 Paul Powell DSP2258 G4396 DSP2259 Liam Doyle DSP2260 G6497 DSP2261 F5520 DSP2262 Damien McGuinness

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2263 K8102 DSP2264 F5677 DSP2265 K1855 DSP2266 C0898 DSP2267 Oliver Kennedy DSP2268 Patrick Martin DSP2269 Eugene Reilly DSP2270 L4293 DSP2271 L6102 DSP2272 L5754 DSP2273 Simon Lipscomb DSP2274 K4007 DSP2275 Damian McGarry DSP2276 L5656 DSP2277 A10701 DSP2278 J9208 DSP2279 J2618 DSP2280 Tony O' Brien DSP2281 Darren Lee DSP2282 L0710 DSP2283 Kamran Butt DSP2284 James Carroll DSP2285 Raymond Lynch DSP2286 D8498 DSP2287 Con Fitzsimons DSP2288 Gerry Reynolds DSP2289 G7974 DSP2290 Anthony Smith DSP2291 Derek Brady DSP2292 F4888 DSP2293 Trevor Reyes DSP2294 J2736 DSP2295 H7044 DSP2296 Joe Lyons DSP2297 Thomas Sheerin DSP2298 F6931 DSP2299 F0238 DSP2300 Dermot Larkin DSP2301 D4555 DSP2302 G6711

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2303 25703 DSP2304 H6802 DSP2305 Eddie Byrne DSP2306 Brendan Rock DSP2307 Gerry Fallon DSP2308 H5050 DSP2309 F2797 DSP2310 Gary Kelly DSP2311 William Travers DSP2312 G6106 DSP2313 D4608 DSP2314 James Cantwell DSP2315 Robert Fitzsimons DSP2316 H9884 DSP2317 Thomas O' Donnell DSP2318 Kenneth Swift DSP2319 Alan O' Brien DSP2320 G8975 DSP2321 G6697 DSP2322 A0034 DSP2323 James Kelly DSP2324 H3179 DSP2325 D Anderanti DSP2326 Martin Duffy DSP2327 F7918 DSP2328 J Powell DSP2329 M Fitzsimons DSP2330 D9025 DSP2331 Philip O' Brien DSP2332 Matt Byrne DSP2333 J3087 DSP2334 Darren Abbott DSP2335 F7801 DSP2336 John Fitzsimons DSP2337 K9715 DSP2338 Liam Murtagh DSP2339 J7293 DSP2340 James McCormack DSP2341 Thomas Moore DSP2342 G7936

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2343 Damien Fitzgerald DSP2344 James Cullen DSP2345 John Mahon DSP2346 D6302 DSP2347 K O' Dowd DSP2348 E1591 DSP2349 Simion Tita DSP2350 P McGarry DSP2351 E Kelly DSP2352 C4090 DSP2353 G8763 DSP2354 H8331 DSP2355 Patrick Trayner DSP2356 D8215 DSP2357 J6349 DSP2358 Dermot Lawlor DSP2359 T Doyle DSP2360 Des Dempsey DSP2361 G3566 DSP2362 B6446 DSP2363 E3068 DSP2364 M A Farrell DSP2365 F6542 DSP2366 G0965 DSP2367 K7074 DSP2368 27751 DSP2369 Martin Faulkner DSP2370 Niall Connerty DSP2371 D9094 DSP2372 Noel Murray DSP2373 Rory McCloskey DSP2374 Gary Reddy DSP2375 Gerard Macken DSP2376 Elaine Connolly DSP2377 G5154 DSP2378 D3633 DSP2379 Brian Fitzgerald DSP2380 Anthony Lynch DSP2381 E5695 DSP2382 JJ Forde

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2383 F4422 DSP2384 J3633 DSP2385 Kenneth O' Keefe DSP2386 Joseph Shanley DSP2387 F9683 DSP2388 A13276 DSP2389 Edward Sammon DSP2390 James Doyle DSP2391 James Dalton DSP2392 F8440 DSP2393 Patrick McCormack DSP2394 K4821 DSP2395 Donal Kenny DSP2396 K0273 DSP2397 H9813 DSP2398 D Geraghthy DSP2399 Brian O' Grady DSP2400 A3516 DSP2401 G6956 DSP2402 G4787 DSP2403 G0584 DSP2404 J8452 DSP2405 E1113 DSP2406 G9514 DSP2407 Tony Corcoran DSP2408 L6677 DSP2409 F1424 DSP2410 Sean Gaffney DSP2411 Patrick Hughes DSP2412 John O' Reilly DSP2413 Paul Sharpe DSP2414 E7483 DSP2415 Paddy Purcell DSP2416 Mary Nelson DSP2417 C2912 DSP2418 58658 DSP2419 48858 DSP2420 Mark Doran DSP2421 K7308 DSP2422 H9479

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2423 H4330 DSP2424 David Brady DSP2425 Thomas Fahy DSP2426 Joseph Reilly DSP2427 F1208 DSP2428 Kevin Grogan DSP2429 H3427 DSP2430 Eric Clarke DSP2431 K3883 DSP2432 Francis Nolan DSP2433 43667 DSP2434 A7796 DSP2435 John Moran DSP2436 Anthony Murray DSP2437 Martin Barry DSP2438 A Maher DSP2439 Christopher McKenna DSP2440 Mark Quinn DSP2441 Seamus Glennon DSP2442 Michael Wastson DSP2443 Monica Dolan DSP2444 Sandra O' Shea DSP2445 Mary Murtagh DSP2446 Joe Corcoran DSP2447 Eugene Delaney DSP2448 Martin Haugh DSP2449 Noel McCormack DSP2450 Tom McCauley DSP2451 Michael McCauley DSP2452 Seamus Ward DSP2453 Charlie Harte DSP2454 Michael Adeleye DSP2455 Christopher Nelly DSP2456 J7710 DSP2457 Gary Carroll DSP2458 Paul Kirwan DSP2459 J3048 DSP2460 Patrick Purcell DSP2461 A6605 DSP2462 H3547

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2463 Philip Pearson DSP2464 E0859 DSP2465 F5514 DSP2466 Andrea Baccarsca DSP2467 H6254 DSP2468 J3225 DSP2469 217591 DSP2470 Jim Browne DSP2471 H3251 DSP2472 K2678 DSP2473 D9998 DSP2474 G9755 DSP2475 F9368 DSP2476 Cecil Killian DSP2477 A6670 DSP2478 H4148 DSP2479 J4901 DSP2480 P. Maguire DSP2481 F7778 DSP2482 Marie Reilly DSP2483 H9611 DSP2484 J5058 DSP2485 Yamlai Young DSP2486 A3180 DSP2487 Paul Kelly DSP2488 E4271 DSP2489 A12909 DSP2490 H5080 DSP2491 A4405 DSP2492 C2222 DSP2493 26001 DSP2494 Paul Duff DSP2495 A40168 DSP2496 Michael Howley DSP2497 J1849 DSP2498 M Thompson DSP2499 Brendan Mullins DSP2500 F6510 DSP2501 F6416 DSP2502 E Dodson

NTA Mandatory Safety Equipment Consultation Report

Report on Public Consultation on Mandatory Safety Equipment

Ref Respondent DSP2503 Eddie King DSP2504 L3698 DSP2505 K8651 DSP2506 Brian Martin DSP2507 Ken Abbott DSP2508 Fiona Sands DSP2509 G9798 DSP2510 E8498 DSP2511 J2579 DSP2512 J7236 DSP2513 H6618 DSP2514 Thomas Kennedy DSP2515 E9102