Chapter - 7 Additional Studies
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
M/s. Zizer polymers LLP Environmental Impact Assessment Report Survey No.: 93, P-3, Behind Millennium Vitrified, Village: Bhadiyad, Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642 Gujarat. CHAPTER - 7 ADDITIONAL STUDIES A. Public Consultation All the aspects of the TORs are incorporated in the final EIA report, the same has been submitted to the Gujarat Pollution Control Board (GPCB) for conducting public hearing/public consultation as per EIA Notification, 2006 and its subsequent amendments. Minutes of Public Consultation / Public Hearing included in final EIA report with suggestions/recommendations in public consultation. B. Risk Assessment Study The said study report is presented in subsequent section. C. Social Impact Assessment, R & R Action Plan The socio-economic study of the study area is carried out and details are presented in the Chapter-3/Section- 3.9. It may be noted that the proposed project will be established on NA land only. The project site is intended for the industrial purpose and thus no displacement of villagers/people will take place. Therefore, the R&R (Rehabilitation & Resettlement) policy/plan is not required and not undertaken. 7.1 Overview of Project M/s. Zizer Polymers LLP is proposing to manufacture Resins Survey No.: 93, P-3, Behind Millennium Vitrified Village: Bhadiyad, Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642. Proposed production of resins will be of 1000 MT/Month (Fortified Rosin (100 MT/Month), Neutral Size Rosin (500 MT/Month), A.K.D wax emulsion (50 MT/Month), MF Resin & Fixer (90 MT/Month), Water Based emulsion polymer (100 MT/Month), Polyvinyl Alcohol (10 MT/Month), & Surface sizing agent (150 MT/Month)).Total land area is 4047.00 m2. The total estimated cost of the proposed project is Rs. 700 Lacs. Total budget allocation towards Environmental Management Facilities will be approx. 28.53 Lakhs. Major plant machinery to be installed is Cooling Tower, TFH, SS Reactors and RO. Utilities which includes Boiler & D. G. Set. 7.2 Surrounding Area Nearest village of M/s. Zizer Polymers LLP is Bhadiyad which is about 0.6 km far from the project site in North-West direction. National Highway 8A – 1.82 km far from the project site in North - East direction. Details of surrounding area is prescribed in topic number 2.2.2, table 2.1 in chapter no.2. 7.3 Risk Assessment The risk assessment essentially includes hazards identification, consequence analysis, risk assessment/evaluation and risk mitigation. For chemical industries, risk assessment is used for T. R. Associates (Ahmedabad) Chapter-7: Additional Studies NABET Accredited 7.1 M/s. Zizer polymers LLP Environmental Impact Assessment Report Survey No.: 93, P-3, Behind Millennium Vitrified, Village: Bhadiyad, Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642 Gujarat. determining the risk associated with use, handling, transportation and storage of chemicals and other hazardous substances. Quantitative Risk Assessments (QRAs) are done if dangerous substances are thought to be present at a location (e.g. industrial sites and transportation routes) in amounts that can endanger the environment. Risk assessment studies essentially encompass; x Hazard identification using techniques like checklist, preliminary hazard analysis, what-if, and HAZOP. x Hazard analysis using techniques like fault tree analysis, event tree analysis and dispersion modeling. x Consequence analysis using relevant models like ALOHA & PHAST. x Mitigation measures including: ¾ Risk reduction ¾ Emergency preparedness – on-site as well as off-site 7.3.1 Risk Assessment Methodology A typical risk assessment process consists of following tasks: x Obtaining detailed description of process and plant x Identification of hazards x Identification of vulnerable targets x Select Most Credible Scenario which can be converted into an accident out of several major and minor. x Select Worst Case Scenario which has the highest potential to cause an accident of maximum damage x Identification of mitigating measures x Estimation of consequences - in the plant in form of fire, explosion and toxic effects x Estimation of frequency of occurrence x Estimate Effect of Damage x Decision making 7.4 Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment (HIRA) The hazard identification and risk assessment is used to identify possible accidents and estimate their frequency and consequences. While identifying hazards only those areas of plants having potential risk are used further for risk analysis. Hazard is considered as characteristic of system/plant/process that presents potential of causing harm to people, property and the environment. Hence, all the components of a system/plant/process are thoroughly examined to assess their potential for initiating or propagating an unplanned event/sequence of events, which can be termed as an accident. 7.4.1 Hazard Identification Methods Hazard identification method used for the proposed project is given below. x Identification of major hazardous units based on Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemicals Rules, 1989 of Government of India (as amended in 2000); x Hazard Indices: Identification of hazardous units and segments of plants and storage units based on relative ranking technique. T. R. Associates (Ahmedabad) Chapter-7: Additional Studies NABET Accredited 7.2 M/s. Zizer polymers LLP Environmental Impact Assessment Report Survey No.: 93, P-3, Behind Millennium Vitrified, Village: Bhadiyad, Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642 Gujarat. 7.4.2 Identification of Hazardous Chemicals used within Premises Following chemicals to be stored and utilized within the premises falls under Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemicals Rules, 1989 (as amended in 2000). List of Hazardous Chemicals is given below. Amongst the below described raw materials and products, some are the hazardous chemicals as per the MSIHC Rules, 2000. Chemical and physical properties of raw materials are given in Table 7-1. T. R. Associates (Ahmedabad) Chapter-7: Additional Studies NABET Accredited 7.3 M/s. Zizer polymers LLP Survey No.: 93, P-3, Environmental Impact Assessment Report Behind Millennium Vitrified, Village: Bhadiyad Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642 Gujarat. Table 7-1 Chemical and Physical Properties of Hazardous Chemicals Toxicity Level Flammable Limit Chemical LD50 Class Class Sr. LD50 Vapor Chemicals TLV/TWA Oral LC50 LEL UEL (As per (As per NFPA rating No. Dermal FP 0C BP 0C pressure mg/ mg/l % % petroleum MSIHC mg/Kg Kg classification) Rules) 400 2,620 Health: 3, Maleic 1. 0.1 ppm mg/kg mg/kg N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 200 °C N.A. Hazardous Flammability: 0, N.A. anhydride* (Rat) (Rabbit) Reactivity: 0 1350 Health: 3, Sodium Ceiling: 2 1390 0.13 kPa 2. N.A. mg/kg N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. Hazardous Flammability: 0, hydroxide* mg/m3 °C @ 739 °C (Rabbit) Reactivity: 1 3310 Health: 3, ACGIH TWA: Highly 1.6 kPa 3. Acetic acid* mg/kg N.A. N.A. N.A. 40 °C 118 °C B Flammability: 2, 10 PPM Flammable (20 °C) (Rat) Reactivity: 0 11.7 > 2000 Health: 3, TWA: 20 mg/L 1.1 7.0 145 - Highly 0.7 kPa 4. Styrene* mg/kg 31 °C B Flammability: 3, ppm (Rat) % % 146 °C Flammable @ 20 °C (Rat) Reactivity: 2 4 h 7093 7872 Health: 2, Methyl TWA: 50 > 5 g/kg ppm 2.1 12.5 Very Highly 4 kPa 5. mg/kg 8 °C 100 °C A Flammability: 3, methacrylate* ppm (Rabbit) (Rat) 4 % % Flammable @ 20 °C (Rat) Reactivity: 2 h 8300 14800 > 9.1 Health: 2, Ethyl ppm 1.8 118 - Very Highly 2.13 kPa 6. N.A. mg/kg g/kg N.A. 15 °C A Flammability: 3, methacrylate* (Rat) % 119 °C Flammable @ 20 °C (Rat) (Rabbit) Reactivity: 0 4 h T. R. Associates (Ahmedabad) Chapter-7: Additional Studies NABET Accredited 7.4 M/s. Zizer polymers LLP Survey No.: 93, P-3, Environmental Impact Assessment Report Behind Millennium Vitrified, Village: Bhadiyad Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642 Gujarat. Toxicity Level Flammable Limit Chemical LD50 Class Class Sr. LD50 Vapor Chemicals TLV/TWA Oral LC50 LEL UEL (As per (As per NFPA rating No. Dermal FP 0C BP 0C pressure mg/ mg/l % % petroleum MSIHC mg/Kg Kg classification) Rules) ≥ Health: 3, Hydrogen ACGIH TWA: 150.2 7. 90000 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. Hazardous Flammability: 1, N.A. peroxide* 1 ppm °C mg/kg Reactivity: 3 0>118 128.2 7– 17100 Health – 2 TWA: 200 mg/L ( 6.0 31.0 64.7 Highly 12.8 kPa 8. Methanol* 2769 mg/kg ( 12 °C A Flammability –3 ppm Rat ) 4 % % °C Flammable @ 20 °C mg/kg Rabbit ) Instability - 0 h (Rat) ACGIH TLV: 2920 2335 1550 Very highly Health: 2, Vinyl Acetate 10 ppm 2.6 13.4 - 11.87 kPa 9. mg/kg mg/kg ppm (4 73 °C A flammable Flammability: 3, monomer* (35mg/m3) % % 7.7°C @ 20 °C (Rat) (Rat) Hour) liquid Reactivity: 0 8hr Note: * Hazardous chemicals as per MSIHC rule, 2000 The Toxicity level of hazardous chemicals as per Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical (Amendment) Rules, 2000 (MSIHC) is shown as below: Table 7-2 Toxicity of Chemicals capable of producing MAHs[1] Oral Toxicity Dermal Toxicity Inhalation Toxicity Sr. No. Toxicity LD50 (mg/kg) LD50 (mg/kg) LC50 (mg/l) 1. Extremely Toxic >5 <40 <0.5 2. Highly Toxic >5- 50 >40-200 <0.5-2.0 3. Toxic >50-200 >200-1000 >2-10 T. R. Associates (Ahmedabad) Chapter-7: Additional Studies NABET Accredited 7.5 M/s. Zizer polymers LLP Survey No.: 93, P-3, Environmental Impact Assessment Report Behind Millennium Vitrified, Village: Bhadiyad Ta. & Dis.: Morbi-363642 Gujarat. 7.4.3 Storage Details of Raw Material and Products Details of the raw materials and products with storage are given in Table 7-3 (A) and (B) respectively. Table 7-3(A) Storage Details of Products Type of Packing / Physical Capacity No.