The Case of Bale Mountains National Park, Ethiopia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
International Scholars Journals African Journal of Environmental Economics and Management ISSN: 2375-0707 Vol. 4 (3), pp. 266-277, June, 2016. Available online at www.internationalscholarsjournals.org © International Scholars Journals Author(s) retain the copyright of this article. Full Length Research Paper Valuation of environmental goods and services: The case of Bale Mountains National Park, Ethiopia 1Yilma Haroyu*, 2Muktar Bayeh and 2Habte Wolle 1College of Natural Sciences, Department of Biology, Arba Minch University, Arba Minch, Ethiopia. 2College of Natural Sciences, Department of Wildlife Management, Arba Minch University, Arba Minch, Ethiopia. Accepted 20 May, 2016 e Valuation of non marketed environmental goods and services is a newly emerging research area particularly in Ethiopia and other developing countries. The study was aimed to investigate willingness to pay for conservation of environmental services and local tourists' entrance fee of Bale mountains National Park as well as determinant factors affecting visiting interest of local community. The widely used and flexible technique of environmental valuation called contingent valuation method/CVM/ was used. Respondents were given hypothetical project of conserving the park. Hypothetical questions were prepared to elicit the maximum willingness to pay and Willingness to accept to conserve the park. Dinsho, Goba and Robe towns were purposefully selected from which 380 respondents were selected from stratified population using lottery method. Logistic regression model was used to quantitatively analyze socio-economic factors of local people to visit the park. The research finding indicated that visitors mean entrance fee WTP is over 3 times the current entrance fee. Maximum amount of willingness to pay for the proposed conservation project scenario varied from 0 to 1000birr (50$), whereas mean and mode were 35 $ and 10$. Regression analysis showed sex, age, family size, and education level were significant determinants of visiting the park. In addition, district/nearness, education level, job, awareness of biodiversity importance and status, and income level of respondents positively affected an individual’s willingness to pay. Generally, the survey was successful in eliciting willingness-to-pay for protecting the park and can potentially help policy makers as well as park managers to increase number of local tourists so as to increase revenue for conservation work. Keywords: Contingent valuation, conservation, environmental service, non-market values, tourism, willingness to pay. INTRODUCTION Nowadays, valuing environmental goods and service (g/s) the environmental g/s, both in developed and developing are increasingly becoming a global concern. It is largely countries (Bishop, 1999). However, to do so, several agreed that successful development activities depend on types of market failures can be defined (OECD, 1994). the efficient use of „natural capital‟ (World Bank, 1998). The most common type of market failure related to the However, the market for environmental services is environment is the failure to internalize, or take account substantial and growing throughout the world, driven in of market values of g/s. part by increasing environmental regulation and changing Before few years ago in production of goods and consumer preferences (UNEP, 2012; Kunte et al., 1998), services, physical and human capital was recognized as and in applying valuation techniques to the analysis of the main factors of production. But nowadays, economists have recognized that natural capital is an important input in any type of production (Tietenberg, 2006). An increasing number of economists nowadays, Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected] accept that natural capital is used for material and energy Yilma et al. 267 inputs into production, acts as a "sink" for waste understood in Ethiopia. Therefore, environmental emissions from the economic process, and provides a management decision making process and policy variety of "ecological services" to sustain production, makers, and conservation project implementers have no such as nutrient recycling, watershed protection and scientific background. According to Bekabil and Anemut catchment functions, and climate regulation (Tietenberg, (2000) very few studies analyzed local peoples 2006; Mishra, 2013). willingness to pay (WTP) for conservation of national Environmental assets like other assets provide benefits parks in Ethiopia. that enhance economic performance (DEFRA, 2007; There are no comprehensive studies done regarding the Pearce and Turner, 1990; Cesare, 2000; UNEP, 2012). environmental services provided by BMNP. Recreational Public benefits derived from biodiversity and natural value and even the entrance fee to enjoy the park is not resource such as a national park in the form of based on the scientific study that really reflect the local environmental amenities and ecosystem services implies tourists WTP. Therefore, this study was aimed to that the environmental goods and services contributes to examine the maximum amount of local tourists‟ public welfare, and loss of the resources or decline in willingness to pay to visit the park and the monetary their quality could result in a loss in welfare (Tietenberg value that people attach to the conservation of 2006). environmental services provided by Bale Mountain Generally, literatures divide the value of environmental National Park (BMNP) as well as the major determinant g/s into different categories. When considering why factors affecting the willingness of local community to visit individuals place values on a natural resource, a typical the park and conservation scenario of the park. approach in literature is to distinguish between those who use the resource (services) and those who do not (Brauman etal, 2007). The values held by the former MATERIALS AND METHODS group are generally termed as use values, and may occur in many different ways. Direct use values may derive Description of the Study Area from consumptive uses (e.g. fuel wood collection) and/or non-consumptive uses (e.g. hiking in the same forest), BMNP is situated in the Oromia Region encompassing and may involve commercial (selling fuel wood or 2,471km². The park is characterized for its Afro alpine collecting visiting tolls) and/or non-commercial activities habitat, including alpine meadows; it contains the second (home consumption of fuel wood or enjoyment of an largest moist tropical forest and the only cloud forest in open-access wilderness area) (Cesare, 2000). Ethiopia. With an altitudinal range from 4400 to 1500 Only some of environmental goods and services that are meters, it harbors an enormous diversity of habitats. All of very crucial for our existences have markets (Cesare this has resulted in a unique ecosystem that contains 2000) price (price tag) and these prices are most of the such a high degree of endemism that it is the envy of time very minimal. So, valuation of such goods and National Parks. It is estimated that if we were to lose the services is much more relevant (McClelland, 1993) for Bale Mountains more endemic mammals would go sustainable development. Some benefits of valuing extinct than any similar sized area on our planet. Two of environmental g/s are strengthening green growth our most recognized species, the Ethiopian wolf and the (McClelland, 1993; Mishra, 2013), helps to better mountain Nyala, are safeguarded by the Bale Mountains understanding of the value of the natural capital, rethink National Park, with more than 50% of the total the territory in a more integrated and intelligent manner, populations of both these endangered species occurring and to conduct more realistic cost/benefit analysis which within its boundaries (GMP, 2007). The park is home to effectively promote the sustainability of the biodiversity in several endemic mammal species, such as the Mountain the territory, balancing the economic vision with the Nyala, Ethiopian Wolf, Giant Mole Rat and Bale Monkey. preservation/conservation of natural resources (Santos, The forest area also provides a habitat for Lion, African 2013). Wild Dog and Giant Forest Hog. Driven by the continuing desire of Ethiopian government This park is safeguarding our Ethiopian Natural Heritage. for green economic growth, the result of this research can Climatically, the area is characterized by a rainy season potentially awake and ignite decision makers and policy from March to October and a dry season from November makers at national level about monetary value of non to February. Precipitation increases with altitude from marketable environmental g/s. In addition, an ability to 600mm to 1,000mm in the lower altitude areas to place a monetary value on the services provided by the 1,000mm to 1,400mm in the high alpine areas of BMNP. environmental g/s should increasingly be recognized by Mean monthly temperatures range from 19°C to 25.4°C. the broader research, policy and business communities. The Harenna forest within BMNP and the adjacent Mena The welfare contribution or economic value of protected Angetu National Forest Priority Area (NFPA) on the areas in developing countries, however, is scarce. southern slope forms the second largest stand of moist Similarly, both use values and non use values of these tropical forest remaining in Ethiopia covering about environmental services are not yet comprehensively 1,800km². Approximately, half of the park (877km²) lies 268 Afr. J. Environ. Econ. Manage. within this forest,