Word Processing Revisited, September 1984, BYTE Magazine
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
WORD PROCESSING REVISITED A review of five new versions of familiar WP packages for the IBM PC--WordStar, Word, pfs:Write, MultiMate, and FinalWord BY JANET CAMERON ust a few years ago, we wordsmiths We pay for this with increased difficul were satisfied with a word pro ty in learning and operation. New pack cessor that would print out our ages with varying degrees of user text neatly. 1bday. though, our friendliness are flooding the market; standards are considerably higher, currently there are some 150 to 200 andJ software manufacturers are re word processors available for the IBM sponding with increasingly complex PC alone. programs. Updates, too, are flying out of soft Part of the complexity of "installing" ware manufacturers' doors faster than word-processing programs could be our you can push Escape. Some programs own fault. Almost everyone who uses offer significant improvements; some a word processor is spoiled. With our are simply gimmicky add-ons or "hold increasingly sophisticated palates, we ing patterns:' i.e., devices to keep users have come to expect our word pro from switching their loyalties. cessor to be at least as good as a new (continued) and improved R2D2. Some of them are. Some of them even Janet Cameron (POB 1069, Cambridge, MA do windows. 02238) is a professional business writer in the We demand an extremely high level areas of printed circuit boards and micro of performance from word processors. electronics. Fall 1984 • BYTE Guide to the IBM pc, 165 WORD PROCESSING AT A GLANCE WordStar. Microsoft Word. pfsWrite. WORDSTAR'S CAPABILITIES MultiMate. and FinalWord all are out with recent updates of their updates. There's not much you can't do with Each of them has put in a few or many WordStar. Commands are initiated Name new bells and whistles. Each of them mostly with the Control key plus one to WordStar 3.32 has deleted a few or many old bugs and several keystrokes coupled with com gremlins. It seems that instead of trying mands from one of the seven WordStar Type Word-processing program to approach some sort of "standardiza menus. tion" in the way we operate word-pro Beginning with the opening menu. a Manufacturer cessing software. the new wave of word WordStar user can go to any of the pro MicroPro International Corp. processing developers proceeds on the gram's seven help screens. open a file 33 San Pablo Ave. theory that whoever can achieve the for editing. execute one of four file com San Rafael. CA 94903 ultimate in esoteric will achieve the mands (print. rename. copy. or delete (41 5) 499-1200 ultimate in financial rewards. a file). see the file directory. set his level Price I am a writer. I definitely am not a of help (from 0 to 3). or run either Mail 5495 : options package. $345: both. 5695 mathematical whiz-bang kid . Along with Merge or CorrectStar. millions of others. then. I expect two Besides the opening and help menus. Format things of a word processor: I want it to WordStar users can access the editing On e 5 v.\-inch floppy disk: three additional do a lot and I want it to be fairly easy and formatting screens and the print disks for extended lesson tutorials: two ad ditional disks required for optional to learn and operate. So far. although menu (which. strangely enough. IS for speller/indexing programs I've thoroughly tested more than two special effects on the text and print de dozen packages. I haven't found any faults rather than for printing). Each Language such critter. screen is fairly self-explanatory. Word 'j)-anslation from 8080 machine language to In researching this article. I used Star supports most of the best-selling 8086/8088 machine language (listing provid ed for some sections that may be cu stom knowledge of and experience with printers on the market today. ized by the user) these five packages. information from All that is required to run WordStar is my anonymous calls to the manufac 64K bytes and one disk drive. but Cor Computer turers. opinions from friends who use rectStar takes a major upgrade to 192 K IBM Personal Computer (as reviewed) these programs. and a recently pub bytes of system memory and two disk lished paperback. The Ratings Book drives. On my benchmark tests of all five Documentation 475-page loose-leaf manual including an in (Wynnewood. PA : Software Digest. packages (see table 1 on page 180). stallation. training. and reference guide: 1984). that features overviews of some WordStar came out with medium-range three disks with extended lessons: reference 30 word-processing programs. I put the times on all four criteria: loading and folder: key labels programs. in their updated forms. saving the document. searching for the through some pretty strenuous paces final word End. and scrolling from the Audience on my machine. an IBM PC with DOS beginning of the file to the last line. Basic to sophisticated word-processing users. especially those who need to merge I.I. 320K bytes of memory. and two disk When I write with WordStar. its speed programs. create form letters. and use spell drives. seems acceptable. Some basic features WordStar ing and indexing capabilities WORDSTAR-VERSION 3.32 handles with ease include moving. In spite of its reputation as hard to copying. inserting. and deleting small learn. MicroPro's WordStar is one of the amounts or blocks of text; automatic easiest packages to get started. How search and replace. word wrap. and ever. between the new version of Word hyphenation; dynamic page-break dis Star and its options package. MicroPro play and default resetting; cursor moves must be attempting to earn a perma to any part of the text; and a variety of nent place in the Guinness Book of World format settings and within-text changes. Records. WordStar supports special features such With WordStar and its options pack as double strike. boldface. superscript. age. you receive six disks and two very subscript. underlining. and strike out. thick and erudite manuals. Just making The program automatically justifies the backups of this monumental mass of in text unless you change the default. formation costs a fortune. The increased With WordStar. you can perform si benefits provided by this library of flop multaneous editing and printing. as well py disks is worth a lot. but users must as microjustification. Directions for true be willing to wade through the newest proportional spacing on WordStar are WordStar changes. the new spelling available in books that explain how to checker (CorrectStar). · the new index modify the format portion of the pro system (Starlndex). and the handy but gram to achieve this result. involved WordStar tutorial. (continu ed) 166 • BYTE GUide to the IBM PC • Fall 19 84 WORD PROCESSING MicroPro representatives say they are The six-lesson tutorial. though quite AT A GLANCE "working on" a toll-free telephone num time-consuming, is helpful in learning ber for end-user support. Updates of this heavy-duty program. But the docu WordStar and the add-on packages are mentation is difficult and puzzling to get available for fees varying from $25 to through. I especially have difficulty try Name Microsoft Word 1.1/2.0 $85, depending on the program. Word ing to find the index. Star is not copy-protected, enabling With most of the other word-process Type users to make backup copies for their ing programs I use, there is an S com Word-processing program own use. mand for the Search function. Not so Users of the MicroPro family will find with WordStar. It uses a command Manufacturer they can merge not only information called Find. Even though WordStar prac Microsoft Corp. 10700 Northup Way from other "Star" packages into Word tically invented word processing and set Bellevue, WA 98004 Star, but also that this pioneering word the defaults for many programs, I still (206) 828-8080 processing package can often handle find this difference irritating. the integration of other vendors' pro When I am totally immersed in the Price grams into its system. WordStar handily writing process, I find it almost impossi 5375 without mouse: 5475 with mouse deals with the creation and manipula ble to return to WordStar's opening Format tion of columnar text and figures. menu. The way WordStar is set up, most Without mouse, two 5 !4-inch floppy disks: Sophisticated .DOT commands enable of its commands work off the opening mouse-driven system requires a third the user to utilize microjustification, menu; when I have a problem access 5 !4-inch floppy "mouse" disk and a mouse conditional page breaks, headers and ing it. I have a problem producing my card footers, top and bottom margins, page document. In fact. getting back and numbers, margin offsets, line height and Language forth between WordStar's menus is a C (user-configurable for typesetter interface paper length, bidirectional printing real pain, There are several ways to get but cannot be customized) commands, and a variety of other ad back and forth, including the CTRLrK vanced formatting options. commands, but they are awkward and Computer File merging, support of a host of frustrating. IBM Personal Computer (as reviewed) printers, an on-disk tutorial. column Still. WordStar is a clean, satisfying, in Documentation manipulation, and decimal tabbing are depth program. Writers, office workers 400-page loose-leaf manual. 120-page additional features appreciated by con with serious word-processing needs, mouse installation gUide, graphics mouse firmed WordStar users. Although Word and people who spend a lot of time pre guide, mouse operations guide, reference Star has been added to, subtracted paring nonstandard reports, papers, ar folder, and key labels from, and revamped as much as its own ticles, etc., will probably consider Word cut-and-paste feature, the latest version Star the respectable giant of word pro Audience Basic to sophisticated users: mouse-driven is a clean package that performs cessing.