OFFICIAL NEWSLETTER OF THE PARK SLOPE FOOD COOP
Established 1973
Volume II, Number 21 October 16, 2014 GM Report: Coop Shows Operating The Eden Foods Boycott: Loss, New Squad Created, When Food, Health, Religion, and Politics Mix Demographic Study Put Off By Alison Rose Levy But a company’s political n August 26, 2014, the leanings aren’t always easy OCoop General Meeting to discern. Eden Foods, for discussed the proposal to example, markets itself as participate in a nationwide a progressive company, so boycott of Eden Foods, a long many health food fans were time food producer that pro- surprised to learn that it had vides the Coop seventy prod- joined Hobby Lobby.” ucts. In alliance with the June In response, San Fran- 2014 Hobby Lobby ruling by cisco’s 40-year-old Other the U.S. Supreme Court, the Avenues Coop has removed natural food company sought all Eden Foods. Seattle’s to exclude its employees Central Coop removed 80% from health care coverage for of Eden Foods from their abortion and contraception, shelves. Fifty-seven per- provisions in the Affordable cent of shoppers at Madi- Care Act that don’t accord son, Wisconsin’s Willy Street with the Eden CEO Michael stores voted to remove Eden Potter’s religious beliefs. products. North Carolina’s
ILLUSTRATION BY DEBORAH TINT Eden Foods, a pioneering Weaver Market has dropped healthy foods company, in many Eden Foods. Philadel- By Thomas Matthews increased more than sales cent of members with 5 years business since 1969, has long phia’s Weaver’s Way Market he Sept. 30 General Meet- (meaning we made less or less, and 13 percent with 15 championed organic foods is still on the fence. Ting of the Park Slope Food “profit”) with the result that years or more. as well as GMO labeling. Pot- Even though Eden began Coop was largely devoted to the Coop showed an oper- “Most members don’t use ter is a devout Catholic who as a coop, its attempts to con- two proposals, both of which ating loss of $221,551 for the the Web site regularly,” Gal- holds strong views. trol employees health care asked the membership for 32 weeks prior to Sept. 14, lops reported. Eleven percent Notes Bill Moyers, “At a “has fallen short of our coop- permission to study topics of as opposed to an operating never do, and 41 percent visit time of unprecedented polit- erative values,” writes Kirs- interest to the community. profit of $148,630 for the pre- the site a few times per year. ical polarization… ordinary tin Moore, director of Willy One passed overwhelming- vious year. “We may lose a Most visits are to research citizens have to be aware of Street in an open letter to ly, the other was tabled for bit of money this year,” Mike general information (hours, the politics of the compa- Potter. “Please stop allowing future consideration. acknowledged. for example, or produce nies they patronize—some personal values to get in the The meeting, chaired by IT Coordinator Matt Klei- prices) and for issues con- of the dollars they spend way of the common ground Carl Arnold, was called to man and website redesign cerning members’ shifts. will end up influencing pol- you share with your diverse order right on time. No one team member Mark Gallops Almost 1,100 members iticians whose values may array of customers and help offered remarks during the presented results from the offered suggestions on how to not reflect their own. CONTINUED ON PAGE 3 Open Forum, so we moved Coop’s Web site survey, which improve the site. The leading swiftly into the Coordinator solicited member feedback request was for improvements Next General Meeting on October 28 and Committee Reports. on how they used the site in the shift swap process The General Meeting of the Park Slope Food Coop is held on (www.foodcoop.com) and (39 percent), which Gallops the last Tuesday of each month. The October General Meeting Coordinator and what suggestions they had noted was the greatest “pain will be on Tuesday, October 28, at 7:00 p.m. at MS 51, 350 Fifth Committee Reports for improvements. Of our point” for members. Enabling Ave., between Fourth and Fifth Sts. Enter on Fourth St. cul-de- General Coordinator Mike 16,000 members, just over members to check their work sac. The Fourth St. entrance is handicap-accessible. Eakin presented the financial 1,500 took the survey. Of the shift status came next at 27 The agenda is in this Gazette, on the Coop website at www. report. respondents, 64 percent were percent. Apparently, the site foodcoop.com and available as a flier in the entryway of the Total sales were up slightly, women, and the average ten- seems most useful as a func- Coop. For more information about the GM and about Coop gov- but operating expenses had ure was 7.4 years, with 53 per- CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 ernance, please see the center of this issue.
Tue, Oct 28 • PSFC October General Meeting IN THIS ISSUE 7:00 p.m. at MS 51 Puzzle ...... 2 Tue, Nov 4 •Agenda Committee Meeting 8:00 p.m. A New Co-op Organizing Effort ...... 4 Coop Safe Food Committee Report ...... 5 Thu, Nov 6 •Food Class: The Secrets of Community Calendar ...... 6 Event Healthy Indian Cooking 7:30 p.m. Coop Hours, Return Policy ...... 8 Coop Calendar, Governance Information, Mission Statement . . . . 9 Highlights Fri, Nov 7 •Film Night: Hit & Stay 7:00 p.m. Calendar of Events ...... 10 Letters to the Editor...... 12 Look for additional information about these and other events in this issue. Classifieds ...... 15 Exciting Workslot Opportunities, Thank You ...... 16 2 October 16, 2014 Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY
GM Report committees whose members eral Meeting scheduled for CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 must be approved by a vote of Dec. 30, 2014, be cancelled. the General Meeting, because He explained this was due tional tool to help members of its involvement in disci- to calendar quirks and is not navigate shifts and shopping; plinary issues. Its role is to unprecedented. The Chair using it to build a digital com- follow up on investigations by noted that December meet- munity or engage with wider the Disciplinary Committee to ings have generally drawn low issues outside the store drew determine if a Coop rule has attendance. The vote in favor little support. been violated and, if so, what was overwhelming. The next step, Gallops said, penalty to impose. is to convene focus groups of Monique Bowen, who has Research on International members and staff to discuss, been a Coop member for 12 Trade Agreements: Yes elaborate and refine the sur- years, is a member of the Susan Metz, a longtime vey results and consider pos- Board of Directors, and is cur- member, proposed that a new sible next steps. For updates rently serving her third term committee be formed called and further information, check on the Hearing Committee. the International Trade Edu- the blog posts published on She stood unopposed for cation Squad, and that seven new.foodcoop.com. reelection. The results were members be granted work-slot 179 in favor, 3 opposed and 4 credit to work with it. Agenda Items abstentions. “We’ve been doing this The Hearing Officers Com- General Coordinator Joe work voluntarily for more than mittee is one of the few Coop Holtz proposed that the Gen- a year,” Susan explained, “It is fair for us to get credit for the work we do because we as a Crossword Puzzle community benefit from the effort.” 123 456 7 8 9 10 11 12 This proposal was discussed
13 14 15 at the July GM, and many of the same issues were rehashed 16 17 18 before the vote. Though allot- 19 20 21 ted 30 minutes, this agenda item consumed just over an 22 23 24 25 26
hour of the meeting. ILLUSTRATION BY DEBORAH TINT 27 28 29 30 31 32 Supporters largely agreed
33 34 35 36 37 with Susan on two main He asked the General Meet- that “if you can shop, you assertions. The trade agree- ing to authorize a survey that can work” seems widespread, 38 39 40 41 ments, between the U.S. and would gather information on expressed as a matter of fair-
42 43 44 other nations, are opaque and members’ current ages, and ness and justice. Finally, there highly likely to have a negative their years of service, in order is suspicion of a survey that 45 46 47 48 49 impact on food policies sup- to understand the potential might be considered an intru- 50 51 52 ported by the Coop, thus jus- impact on the labor pool of sion on members’ privacy. tifying the need for research the current retirement policy, Laibman attempted to 53 54 55 56 57 58 to decide whether “individ- and whether change might be respond to these criticisms 59 60 61 62 63 64 ual or collective action” may beneficial. by recusing himself from
65 66 67 be called for. In addition, the The current retirement pol- the actual survey, offering to Coop’s Mission Statement icy, as detailed in the Mem- amend the language of his 68 69 70 is broad enough to encom- bership Handbook, offers two proposal and insisting that pass research like this and options, approved by different he was asking for informa- Across Down 1. Good name for an investment advisor? 1. 2012 Facebook event, in brief compensate it with work slot General Meetings. Members tion, not any particular policy 4. Flavor-enhancing additive 2. DVR button credit. who have completed 20 years change. 7. Kind of priest 3. Took off the table? Opponents countered of service may retire at 65 years At 9:31 (by this reporter’s 13. Snoopy, to Charlie 4. One of the Islas Baleares 14. Capt.’s guess 5. Plaster finish that the issue is tangential of age; members who have watch), the Chair cut off dis- 15. Capital of Sicily 6. Knee-slapper to the Coop’s primary focus, completed 30 years of service cussion, even though only 20 16. One of the Titans 7. Crosses dangerously 18. Deceiving 8. “24” actress Cuthbert and potentially divisive. “I’m may retire at 60. (Retirement is minutes of the allotted 30 had 19. Creations in Word, for short 9. Pres. Obama, once uncomfortable with asser- never mandatory.) been used. There was then 20. Pained cries 10. Prod tions about ‘our values’,” Coop “Nobody knows what the some confusion as to whether 21. Seemingly forever 11. “If ____ believe ...” 22. One way for people to be out 12. Bugs, e.g. member Anita said. “My val- effects of the existing policy a vote was in order. The Chair 25. Yellowfin tuna, on menus 15. West Bank grp. ues may be different. I joined will be over the next two to ten asked for a motion to extend 27. Napoleonic law 17. Hubbub 28. Shakespeare character played by 22. Run-D.M.C.’s “You Be ____” for good food at low prices. I years,” Laibman said. “This is the meeting by 15 minutes; it Ralph Fiennes in a 2011 film 23. “Haven’t a clue” feel this proposal goes beyond a proposal for a study. Noth- was defeated. A motion was 33. Wife of Augustus 24. Early morning hr. the Mission Statement.” ing is on the table regarding made to table the vote; it 35. Sitcom planet 26. Not up 36. Paisley or Pitt 29. Ancient land SE of Lesbos General Coordinator Joe the policy or changing the passed. “This proposal will go 38. Midmonth date 30. Sch. named for an evangelist Holtz voiced support for both policy.” back to the agenda committee 39. God for whom a month is named 31. Giggle-producing celestial name ... 41. Rain gutter site even though it ends just as many other education and activism, on The issue is clearly sensi- for further review,” noted the 42. Radio host Boortz words do, including 16-, 28-, 39-, 45- and this issue and in general, but tive. Discussion of Laibman’s Chair. 43. Ocean State sch. 61-Across asked, “Why can’t activists idea during the April GM 44. ____ Edibles (food shop on “The 32. Idiot ____ Facts of Life”) 34. Key chain? be activists without work slot was contentious. It gener- Unwrapped-Up 45. Ursus ____ (black bear) 37. Since: Sp. credit?” ated numerous letters to the The Board of Direc- 49. Sturm ____ Drang 39. Part of a kid’s lunch from home 50. Jiffy 40. Path of a pop-up A show of hands appeared Gazette, a follow-up article by a tors approved all the GM’s 51. With class 44. Ritzy residences to show the proposal had Gazette reporter, and a Member decisions, and the meet- 53. Zookeeper’s main squeeze? 46. Lecture, in a way passed, but, to be sure, a count Submission by Laibman. ing was adjourned at 9:38. 56. Two-time loser to DDE 47. Last innings 58. Fargo’s home: Abbr. 48. Like Dracula of raised hands was taken. The Opposition seems to be Even though, technically, 59. Passed effortlessly 52. Rap sheet abbr. vote was announced as 110 in founded on three points. First, seven minutes remained on 61. What some vaccinations prevent 53. Don Juan’s kiss 65. Country singer Blake 54. Obama’s birthplace favor, 54 opposed. there’s a sense that Laibman’s the meeting schedule, no 66. Own, to Burns 55. “I’d hate to break up ____” ultimate goal is to ease retire- Wrap-Up session was held. 67. Carpenter ____ 57. Roget entry: Abbr. Research on Coop ment rules (he joined the This generally encompasses 68. Get the better of 60. Dobby, e.g., in the Harry Potter books 69. Radical org. of the ’60s 62. Catch Demographics: Not Yet Coop in 2009, when he was 66 the mundane business of ride- 70. “Holy cow!” 63. Colorful card game David Laibman presented years old), possibly exacerbat- shares, but also the rarely 64. Hog’s home a proposal to study member ing an already troublesome used, but potentially produc- Puzzle author: author: David David Levinson Levinson Wilk. For Wilk. answers, For answers,see page xx. see page 15. characteristics pertinent to shortage of workers to run tive, opportunity to reflect on the Coop’s retirement policy. the store. Second, the belief the conduct of the meeting. ■
Read the Gazette while you’re standing on line OR online at www.foodcoop.com Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY October 16, 2014 3
Eden Foods gious beliefs and are free to tal consent, that action would is very specific. We do not hold the reach of the Hobby Lobby do so. not grant his Baha’i employer that….commercial enterprises decision,” Toobin reports. CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 the right to withhold vaca- can ‘opt out of any law…they Ginsburg, he says, “was us return our focus to the high Implications tion leave for the honeymoon. judge incompatible with their right: the decision is opening quality of your food.” This country was founded Why? Because U.S. law super- sincerely held religious beliefs.’” the door for the religiously Based on the discussion at by those seeking religious sedes religious law. In order Few people foresaw the observant to claim privileges, the August 26 GM, many Coop freedom. Most Americans still to guarantee each individual’s far-reaching impact of the that are not available to any- members agree. But how to agree that everyone retains the freedom of religion, we must Supreme Court’s Citizens one else.” bring this message through to right to practice their religion. also assure that people are not United decision that granted Sadly, for those of us who a vote? To decide whether or The two principles concern- forced to follow the tenets of personhood to corporations. would prefer to keep politics not to boycott Eden, members ing religion foundational to another’s religion. “The Becket Fund for Reli- away from our health care, must request the Agenda Com- the legal structure of the U.S. Since the Baha’i are a reli- gious Liberty, a conservative food, and democracy, funda- mittee to schedule a vote at republic remain core rights to gious minority, they have slight public-interest legal group, is mental changes in U.S. law are an upcoming General Meeting. this day: power to impose their beliefs. dedicating itself to expanding political. ■ So far no such vote has been 1. The First Amendment of But the laws of the land apply scheduled. the Constitution (part of the to everyone. The separation of The Food Coop’s Fun Committee Bill of Rights) grants all people church and state was designed is considering a future children’s What is the Hobby Lobby the freedom to practice their for all religions, major and book fair event and wants to find Decision? religion. minor. In June 2014, in a narrow 2. The First Amendment Here’s another example: In a pool of children’s book writers majority, the U.S. Supreme also encodes the separation Christian Science, disease is and illustrators who might be Court gave the retail chain, of church and state, which, as believed to be a mental error interested in participation. Hobby Lobby “the right to Founding Father Thomas Jef- rather than physical disorder. If you are and are interested, exempt themselves from cer- ferson stated, means, “building The sick should be treated, not please contact Tasha Paley at tain provisions of the Afford- a wall of separation of church by medicine, but by a form of [email protected] able Care Act…. Hobby Lobby, and state.” prayer that seeks to correct the a closely held corporation, a The freedom to practice a beliefs responsible for the illu- secular, for-profit business… religion means that believers sion of ill health. Due to this belief, if some- one sought to impose medical treatment on a practitioner of Christian Science, that would violate that person’s rights to practice their religion. But what if your employer were a VALET BIKE PARKING Christian Scientist, who sought to deny your health insurance IS HERE ON coverage based on his beliefs? If your employer were a Sci- SATURDAYS & entologist (a religion which deplores psychiatry and psy- SUNDAYS! chotherapy) would she have the right to deny you insur- ance-covered psychotherapy or reimbursement for anti-de- pressant medications pre- scribed by your doctor? Every Saturday, Today, some employers tell April 5–November 22, their employees how to vote in public elections, as Gor- 1:00–5:15 p.m. don Lafer, Associate Profes- sor at the University of Oregon and details in a recent article. The Every Sunday, Founders of the Constitution April 6–November 23, ILLUSTRATION BY LYNN BERNSTEIN “were particularly concerned that employees might be sub- 3:30–7:45 p.m. could deny employer-paid are free to go to their church, ject to the undue influence insurance coverage” for contra- synagogue, mosque, temple, of those who controlled their Coop members can leave their bikes with ception and abortion services, or Wicca ceremony, and wor- economic fate.” As Alexander our valet parking service, which is like explains Jeffrey Toobin in the ship accordingly. Non-believ- Hamilton warned, “In the main, a coat check for bikes. Working members will October 2014 New Yorker. ers are similarly free not to power over a man’s support is The American Congress believe or worship. power over his will.” check in and watch your bike for you. of Obstetricians and Gyne- The separation of church Prior to the Hobby cologists has gone on record and state imparts a clear dis- Lobby decision, the law Just drop off your bike, stroller, scooter or stating that birth control is tinction between the rights of did not permit employers to personal cart, do your shopping or your shift, essential health care because individuals on matters of reli- intercede in their employees’ and hop back on. it allows “women to time gion that affect themselves medical care. Nor could No locks, no worries, no theft. and space their pregnan- alone, and the laws governing employers determine employ- cies, it reduces fetal, infant, everyone. ees’ investments in a 401K. Nor Service operates rain or shine. and maternal morbidity and That is why, prior to Hobby prescribe what people eat or Look for us in front of the yellow wall. mortality. Contraception pre- Lobby, employers were not drink, based upon the boss’s vents unintended pregnancies, permitted by law to impose religious beliefs. (Some reli- Note: no bike check-in on thereby reducing the need for their religious beliefs. For gions proscribe certain foods.) Saturdays after 5 p.m. or abortion as well as preventing example, in the Baha’i religion, But the new ruling may a potential worsening of preex- people wishing to marry must change things. Following the Sundays after 7:30 p.m. isting health conditions, such first obtain parental consent. Hobby Lobby decision, in a dis- as diabetes or heart disease.” Despite his own beliefs, senting opinion, Justice Ruth By medical definition, these a Baha’i employer may not Bader Ginsburg called it “a Valet bicycle parking at the Coop is brought to you by the PSFC services are health care. Some impose that requirement on decision of startling breadth.” Shop & Cycle Committee. may prefer to opt out of such his employees. If a newly wed Judge Alito, writing for the treatments, due to their reli- employee fails to obtain paren- majority, countered, “Our holding
Read the Gazette while you’re standing on line OR online at www.foodcoop.com 4 October 16, 2014 Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY A New Co-op Organizing Effort Is Taking Root in Central Brooklyn By Frank Haberle aking a hands-on approach to address health equity issues, longtime residents of the Central TBrooklyn neighborhoods are coming together to develop a new food cooperative with an aim to make fresh, healthy food more accessible and affordable for longtime community residents of Central Brooklyn. Local residents of these communities now have the opportunity to express their ideas and interest in the new co-op through an on-line community survey, available now through mid-November 2014.
Currently in the planning The bigger grocery stores rarely Heights together to identify
and development phase, the offer fresh vegetables or organic issues of importance to them, COX MURRAY BY PHOTO Central Brooklyn Food Co-op, products, focusing on cheaper, to build power and to improve Harvir Kaur discussing the proposed Central Brooklyn Food projected to open its doors in unhealthy foods. The few “green conditions in their community. Co-op with an interested member of the community. 2016, is taking shape through and healthy markets” that have Food Sovereignty is one priority the vision and input of a food popped up in Bed-Stuy and issue area of BMC. In addition members joined their neigh- outreach campaign in how to co-op coordinating committee Crown Heights offer specialty to incubating the development bors at the first meeting orga- conduct the community survey composed of local, commu- “gourmet” organic products of the new Central Brook- nized through a “Grub Party,” and how to communicate about nity-based activists. The food and health foods, but at very lyn Food Co-op, the Brooklyn which are potluck gatherings our organizing effort to our co-op was originally organized high prices. Movement Center provides where the Brooklyn Move- community members. We have and incubated by the Brooklyn an online food justice tool kit ment Center engages residents conducted outreach in more Movement Center (a commu- By the People, For the where residents can identify of Central Brooklyn in con- than 20 locations—in front of nity organizing group based in People—Food Sovereignty green spaces, community gar- versations around inequities food pantries, supermarkets Bedford-Stuyvesant and Crown The issue of food sover- dens, community-supported that exist within the food sys- and at transportation hubs and Heights), and is also supported eignty—meaning that com- agriculture programs and other tem and possible solution in have collected over 200 surveys by North East Brooklyn Hous- resources in Central Brooklyn, addressing those inequities. on the street.” ing Development Corporation while also providing opportuni- With a commitment to find- With the survey now on-line, and other community based ties for residents to take action ing a business model that the Central Brooklyn Food organizations. Over the past 15 on food sovereignty issues. meets the community’s needs Co-op has already collected months, the food co-op coor- The co-op organizing proj- and its vision of economic another 100 surveys. “Our goal dinating committee has been ect is being coordinated by the and racial justice, the Central is 500 surveys,” says Harvir. operating through three com- BMC’s Food Sovereignty Orga- Brooklyn Food Co-op held a “We’re going to wrap-up our sur- mittees and has conducted nizer Harvir Kaur, who joined food co-op business models vey street outreach effort by the an outreach campaign and the organization in March 2013. teach-in session in March 2014. end of October, and hope to hit accessed technical assistance “Food sovereignty issues are “We held a teach-in around our goal of 500 surveys with our from existing Brooklyn co-ops, ingrained in DNA,” says Harvir. the different food co-op busi- on-line survey by mid-Novem- including the Park Slope Food “Food is who I am, and it is how ness models for our food co-op ber. But our outreach campaign Coop, to explore and under- I grew up.” Harvir was excited to coordinating committee mem- will continue as we continue to stand different co-op busi- take on an internship opportu- bers to engage in a conversa- develop the Central Brooklyn ness and financial models. The nity with BMC to help lead the tion with folks from Bushwick, Food Co-op and beyond.” ■
Central Brooklyn Food Co-op PHOTO BY BMC food co-op organizing effort. Greene Hill, and Park Slope launched its community sur- Harvir Kaur is part of the Food Coops around their dif- If you are a resident of Central vey this past summer with a movement to start a food coop A Step-by-Step Process ferent food co-op business Brooklyn, would like to have a say two-fold purpose: 1) to iden- serving Bedford-Stuyvesant The development of the models and the advantages in shaping the new Central Brooklyn tify shopping patterns and food and Crown Heights. Central Brooklyn Food Co-op and challenges of their different Food Co-op, please participate in the buying preferences among began over a year ago, when co-op models,” Harvir says. survey by November 15: It can be Central Brooklyn community munity members take charge the Brooklyn Movement Cen- The pieces for the Central accessed on-line here: www.nyu.qual- members, and 2) to conduct of their food supply and build ter reached out to local co-ops, Brooklyn Food Co-op are now trics.com/SE/?SID=SV_cBYa7sIN- outreach in the community that a more just food system by including the Park Slope Food coming together. The business 3juzt0pd. raises awareness for the Cen- bringing healthier, affordable Coop, for information. “When model is now in development. To learn more about the Brooklyn tral Brooklyn Food Co-op proj- food options into the neighbor- we hosted our first community While a mission statement and Movement Center and get directly ect. The Central Brooklyn Food hoods—has gained traction in meeting, the Park Slope Food core value statement are now involved in its Food Co-op Coordinat- Co-op is inviting Bed-Stuy and Central Brooklyn. The Brooklyn Coop gave us a great start, being finalized, a location for ing Committee please contact Harvir Crown Heights residents to take Movement Center’s community doing a mailing to inform its the new coop has yet to be Kaur at hkaur@brooklynmovement- part in the survey online before organizing efforts are led by 1,000 members who live in our determined but will be some- center.org or (718) 771-7000. mid-November 2014. Mark Winston-Griffith, a long- community districts of our where in Bed-Stuy or northern Bedford-Stuyvesant and time resident of Crown Heights, plans to start a food co-op Crown Heights. The Central Crown Heights have seen sig- along with a range of commu- organizing effort for Central Brooklyn Food Co-op’s out- nificant gentrification in the nity members. The Brooklyn Brooklyn and invite them to the reach and membership com- past decade, but they are still Movement Center brings resi- meeting,” reports Harvir. Forty mittee developed a strong plan home to a majority of lower- dents of Bed-Stuy and Crown Central Brooklyn community for community engagement in to moderate- income com- June 2014 and have been hit- munities and communities of ting the pavement since then, color who have lived in these engaging with their neighbors neighborhoods for genera- about the food co-op initiative tions. According to the most through the community survey. recent census data, the median The current survey, con- income of Bedford-Stuyvesant ducted on the street over the households is $34,735, versus past three months, has recently a citywide average of $51,865. been launched on-line. “This Neighboring Crown Heights has summer, we began with street a median household income of surveys to collect information $37,687. The Central Brooklyn and build our base,” Harvir Food Co-op’s business and continues. “We’ve held com- planning committee has found munity survey training ses- through research that fresh sions throughout the summer and affordable food options in order to train interested folks
are few and far between in Cen- WILLIAMS VERALYN BY PHOTO from our community who were
tral Brooklyn neighborhoods. Mark Winston Griffith, community activist. interested in being part of the ILLUSTRATION BY ETHAN PETTIT
Read the Gazette while you’re standing on line OR online at www.foodcoop.com Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY October 16, 2014 5
SAFE FOOD COMMITTEE REPORT Fracking, Food and Climate Change By Tom Angotti The water is often mixed with determines that there will be he incredible turnout of a chemical cocktail that expe- no significant negative envi- Tfood justice activists at dites the process. ronmental impacts (as claimed the historic People’s Climate Natural gas is touted as by the fossil fuel industry). March on September 21, 2014 the “clean fossil fuel” and a The state Health Department was uplifting and unprece- real alternative to the nation’s is currently reviewing this and dented. Among the nearly dependence on petroleum. has not yet made a recom- 400,000 marchers, the food However, natural gas is still a mendation. After this Novem- justice contingent was large major and growing source of ber’s gubernatorial election, and loud. Banners and chants greenhouse gas emissions. Its the Governor may very well act. communicated awareness that expanded use will help fore- Yet another danger is the vir- the potential for catastroph- stall efforts to make structural tually uncontrolled increase in ic climate change threatens changes in an economy that gas pipelines throughout the access to safe food, especial- is hooked on the burning of region, such as the Rockaway ly for those who have fewer fossil fuels. Fracking is produc- pipeline and the high-pressure
resources and alternatives. ing a new set of environmental Spectra pipeline from New PHOTO BY TOM ANGOTTI Also prominent throughout and public health risks. It has Jersey to New York City. These The PSFC is a long-time supporter of the Pride of New York the march were many groups contaminated and drawn down bring other risks to public program to promote fresh, local food. Fracking places the and activists calling for a ban underground aquifers used health and safety. safety of this supply at risk. on fracking. But what is fracking for drinking water and irriga- and what does it have to do with tion. Fracking can release vol- Fracking and Food Safety ing through local ordinances. Pride of New York program climate change and food jus- atile organic compounds that The New York moratorium In a recent communication, to promote fresh, local food. tice? The Park Slope Food Coop increase ground-level ozone on fracking would not have Holtz said that during the last Fracking places the safety of has joined a growing move- levels, which endanger human been possible without the fiscal year the Coop spent $9.6 this supply at risk. ment in the state and around health and reduce the produc- extensive organizing by envi- million on produce, of which The Food Coop has joined the nation to ban fracking. What tion of farm crops. ronmental and consumer about 30% is locally grown, Food Not Fracking (www.food- does it have to do with us? Fortunately for us, there is groups. Our Food Coop has and “far more than half of the notfracking.org) and many now no fracking in New York, supported the moratorium and local total was from New York organizations are part of the Fracking and Climate New Jersey and Connecticut opposed fracking. State.” Why is this? In his brief, New Yorkers Against Fracking Change (though Pennsylvania has In the May 6, 2010, issue of Holtz said that members pre- Coalition (www.nyagainstfrack- Fracking stands for hydrau- plenty of it). While our sister the Linewaiters’ Gazette an arti- fer local produce, and buying ing.org). You can help to per- lic fracturing, a technique for states in the metropolitan cle by Ed Levy, “Gas Drilling local also promotes long-term manently ban fracking, keep extracting natural gas from region have few natural gas Update,” identified the issues food security. The PSFC is a our food safe and reduce our deep underground pockets, deposits, New York State could with fracking. At the May 25, long-time supporter of the dependence on fossil fuels. ■ generally in areas with loose potentially become a haven for 2010, General Meeting, the shale formations. Companies gas drilling. Corporations have PSFC Environmental Commit- that use fracking dig straight already signed leases with tee proposed that the Coop down and horizontally, using many upstate property own- support the statewide ban large amounts of water under ers. The only thing that holds on fracking. It was approved high pressure—that’s why it’s them back now is a statewide by an overwhelming majority. called hydraulic fracturing— moratorium on fracking, which On June 21, 2012 General Coor- to loosen the layers of rock. could be lifted if the governor dinator Joe Holtz submitted an Amicus Brief in two court cases, Anschutz v. Town of Dryden and Cooperstown Hol- stein Corp. v. Town of Middle- field. These cases challenged fracking bans by local govern- ments in upstate New York. The court upheld the right of
the municipalities to ban frack- ILLUSTRATION BY ETHAN PETTIT
Read the Gazette while you’re standing on line OR online at www.foodcoop.com 6 October 16, 2014 Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY
COMMUNITY CALENDAR
Community calendar listings are free. Please submit your event listing in 50 words or less to [email protected]. Submission deadlines are the same as for classified ads. Please refer to the Coop Calendar in the center of this issue.
THU, OCT 16 Grosscup; Emma Graves. At 7:30 p.m. Beginner Swing Dance the Community Church of NY class with Arturo, most Wednes- 7 p.m. Book Launch: Brooklyn Spirits Unitarian Universalist, 40 E. 35 days. Introduction to dancing fun- by Peter Fornatale & Chris Wertz St.For info call 212-787-3903 damentals. No partners necessary. with Bridget Firtle & Steve DeAn- or see www.peoplesvoicecafe. At the Brooklyn Society for Ethical gelo. Brooklyn Spirits: Craft Cocktails org. Suggested donation $18, Culture. For more info: www.danc- and Stories from the World’s Hippest Bor- member $10. ingturo.com or 917-292-1404. ough, is the first distillery-to-glass cocktail book. At The powerHouse WED, OCT 22 SUN, NOV 9 Arena, 37 Main st. Bklyn. For info call 718-666-3049.Rsvp” Rsvp@ 7 p.m. Book Launch: At Home 4 p.m. BPL Chamber Players powerhousearena.com. in the Whole Food Kitchen by Amy present: Randall Scarlatta, bari- Chaplin who joins us for her tone Benjamin Hochman, piano. SAT, OCT 18 sophisticated vegetarian cook- F. Schubert: Die Schoene Muel- book release. At the powerHouse lerin at the Dr. S. Stevan Dweck 8 p.m. Peoples’ Voice Cafe: Arena, 37 Main St. Bklyn. For info Center for Contemporary Culture Young Political Songwriters call 718-666-3049.Rsvp: Rsvp@ Central Library. 10 Grand Army Night: Alexandra Bradbury; Ben powerhousearena.com. Plaza, Bklyn. Admission free.
Looking to help new coops form in Brooklyn while getting a tax deduction? Support the Fund for New Coops—a project of the Park Slope Food Coop. The Fund for New Coops will make low-interest loans to start-up coops that use the full-member labor model like ours. Loans will be extended to qualified start-ups to address problems and maximize the chances that start-ups will flourish. How can you donate? • Use the scannable Fund for New Coops donation cards available on the shopping floor • Donate directly from the Coop’s website, foodcoop.com. Follow the link for the Fund for New Coops and select the DONATE button • Mail a check—made out to the Fund for New Food Coops—to: FJC, 520 Eighth Ave., 20th Flr., New York, NY 10018 ILLUSTRATIONS BY ETHAN PETTIT Help nascent coops that want to use our model: Contribute today!
n S rv r dmini ra r Fo t e e A st to Help the Archives Committee create a subject index of the notes that have been taken at every General Meeting from who will administer Universal Type Server 4 for Macintosh. This is a workslot, not a paid 1976 to the present. From administrative decisions to position. We have seven workstations using UTS, and we are also using Adobe CC and Quark committee reports to product sale debates, these GM notes 8. Currently workstations are using OS 10.7.5, but we have plans to update shortly to OS need an index to make one of the Coop’s most important 10.8. Updating, maintenance and testing of UTS to work with current versions of OS plus primary sources more accessible. Adobe CC and Quark 8 are required. The Coop This is a temporary project and can be done for FTOP or currently uses the UTS extensis font server make-up credit. If you’re interested, to produce a bi-weekly newsletter and please e-mail internal documents. Hours are as [email protected] by November 1 and tell us about needed, for FTOP credit. your interest and skills in indexing, as well as how long you've been Contact: [email protected]. a Coop member.
Read the Gazette while you’re standing on line OR online at www.foodcoop.com Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY October 16, 2014 7
MEMBER SUBMISSION
The Gubernatorial Election: Fake and Real Choices ney and Tea Party activ- ist, Cohn’s further details By David Barouh trade deals. Both candidates legislation—mostly aban- national website generally are oddly absent. The par- he approaching guber- would lower corporate taxes. doned by today’s Democrats. opposes government regu- ty’s principles are: integ- Tnatorial election will Cuomo displayed malfea- It calls for extensive public lations, advising a “no” vote rity, flat tax, immigration play a crucial role in the sance when he disbanded employment to build 100% on California’s GMO-labeling reform, energy indepen- state’s direction, for better his Moreland Commission green-energy infrastructure referendum. dence, term limits, “Amer- or worse. Yet the American on Corruption after it began by 2030, single-payer public The Libertarian plat- ica’s right to defend its two-party “tradition” and its investigating his own admin- healthcare, fully funded pub- form favors free-market values,” “foreign aid with media coverage severely cur- istration. lic education, including free trade solutions. In general, American supervision,” tail political options. Major The Green Party: Howie tuition for CUNY and SUNY, it advocates individual lib- job creation and eco- media usually ignore or ridi- Hawkins a $15/hr minimum wage erty except for interference nomic growth. The web- cule the existence of alterna- Anti-war, community-jus- indexed to productivity, and with others’ rights by force site doesn’t elaborate on tive political philosophies, tice, environmental, and progressive taxes and bud- or fraud. Government’s role these points and lacks fur- fostering among voters labor activist since 1967, gets, including restoration of is to protect life, liberty, and ther internet presence. It capitulation and disinter- when he was 15, Hawkins the now-rebated stock trans- property, not interfere with seems, unfortunately, not est. “Voting the bums out” founded anti-apartheid fer tax. the voluntary and contrac- ready for prime time. www. becomes impossible, and divestment and anti-nu- The platform’s detailed tual relations of individuals, sapientparty.com. ■ citizens lose their leverage. clear alliances, and a work- Sustainable Agriculture or with individuals’ choices, Coop committees work on ers’ cooperative specializing and Food Justice segment including speech, religion, issues crucial to the Coop— in energy efficiency, solar includes a statewide frack- marriage, recreational activ- and the state’s burgeoning and wind installation. He ing ban, GMO labeling and ities, and abortion choices. agriculture—such as GMO unloads trucks at UPS, is statewide GMO moratorium, This party, like the Greens, labeling, fracking, and food an active Teamsters Union transition to organic agricul- has consistently stood its justice. A Coop letter to the member, board secretary of ture, re-legalization of hemp own candidates rather than governor stated it would Eat to Live Food Coopera- growing and research, and a cross-endorsing Democrats reconsider its strong patron- tive, and published author. farmworker bill of rights. or Republicans to win ballot age of that agriculture were Active in electoral politics, The party’s platform can status. Having yet to achieve fracking endorsed. But exclu- always supporting alterna- be perused at www.Howie- the required 50,000 votes, sively Democratic/Republi- tives to corporate-funded Hawkins.org. Oh, and the Libertarians have admirably can administrations don’t candidates, he co-founded Greens accept no corporate petitioned their way onto the readily tolerate directions the US Green Party in 1984. funding! ballot every four years since that undermine corporate He’s campaigned for numer- The Libertarian Party: Michael 1974. Read their platform at interests—and corporate ous federal, state, and local McDermott www.ny.lp.org. funding. offices. His strong showing A Long Island real estate The Sapient Party: Steve Cohn Alternative candidates in the 2010 gubernatorial broker and developer, Described as an attor- exist, however, having fought election secured the Green McDermott served on the their way onto ballots, often Party’s ballot status for the Hauppauge School Board overcoming intentionally first time in 14 years. and stood for Congress in labyrinthine legal obstacles. The centerpiece of the 2012. There’s no comment Here’s a brief survey of the party’s platform is the Green about fracking, GMO label- ballot-qualified gubernato- New Deal, based on FDR’s ing, or food-justice issues on rial candidates, two “tradi- Great Depression namesake his website, but the party’s tional” (read: “corporate”) and three alternatives: The Corporate Parties: Andrew ARE YOU A Cuomo, Rob Astorino Democrat Cuomo has BROOKLYN-BASED The Park Slope Food Coop recently collected an continued a moratorium on unprecedented 63 boxes of food drive donations fracking introduced by pre- FILMMAKER? for the CHIPS Soup Kitchen, 200 Fourth Ave. decessor David Paterson This is impressive, fantastic, and much higher than pending more “study”—now Would you like to our typical collections. Thank you to all members five years and running. Fully screen your work who donated. The Food Coop’s contributions do aware of the protest tsunami make a difference. he’d unleash by endorsing at the Coop? fracking, he has delayed a decision, apparently waiting See chipsonline.org for information on how to Then submit your film until this election concludes make financial donations to CHIPS. and his presidential possibil- for possible inclusion ities become clearer. Repub- in the Coop’s Since 1971, CHIPS has relied on the generosity of lican Astorino endorses Friday Film Night individuals like you to provide 103,000 nutritious fracking. Screening Series. breakfasts and lunches every year, to shelter and counsel Cuomo has avoided dis- young mothers and their infant and toddler children. cussing GMO labeling. If you’re a Coop member you’ll receive one FTOP CHIPS is a non-profit, tax exempt 501(c)(3) organization. Astorino endorses it. Cuo- credit for screening and offering a Q+A with your Contributions are tax-deductible and directly support mo’s agricultural initiatives film. If you’re not a member, it’s still a chance to the Soup Kitchen and the shelter for young mothers appear more fully formed and their children. than Astorino’s. Both involve spread the word about your work and build your fan grants, tax incentives, and base by screening for a local audience. the like. Both have avoided commenting on the rights of We accept documentary and fiction, both features farm-workers. and shorts (we program shorts as a group). Both have avoided free trade issues. But their par- PleasePlease e-mail e-mail Faye LedermanGabrielfor Rhodes details at ties’ leaders have con- [email protected] detailsor at mail your DVD to: sistently undermined Faye Lederman, 2000 Linwood Ave, #9E labeling and food justice, [email protected] Lee, NJ 07024 and endorsed authoritarian
Read the Gazette while you’re standing on line OR online at www.foodcoop.com 8 October 16, 2014 Park Slope Food Coop, Brooklyn, NY
COOP HOURS Friday, November 21, 8:00 p.m. Office Hours: Monday through Thursday 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Friday & Saturday 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Shopping Hours: Monday through Friday 8:00 a.m. to 10:00* p.m. Saturday 6:00 a.m. to 10:00* p.m. Sunday 6:00 a.m. to 7:30* p.m. * Shoppers must be on a checkout line 15 minutes after closing time. Childcare Hours: Monday through Sunday 8:00 a.m. to 8:45 p.m. Telephone: Come join Barry Bryson, bandleader and 718-622-0560 trumpeter of the Swing Street Orchestra, Web address: and fabulous Coop jazz musicians for a www.foodcoop.com night of big-band swing-dance music.
Marje Wagner Barry Bryson—Trumpet/Leader Emily Asher—Trombone Lisa Parrott—Alto Sax Jenny Hill—Tenor Sax Cynthia Hilts—Piano Alexis Cuadrado—Bass Rob Garcia—Drums There will also be The Linewaiters’ Gazette is published biweekly by the Park Slope Tom Beckham—Vibraphone Food Coop, Inc., 782 Union Street, Brooklyn, New York 11215. free dance lessons Dave Phelps—Guitar with professional Opinions expressed here may be solely the views of the writer. The Marje Wagner—Vocal Gazette will not knowingly publish articles that are racist, sexist or dance instructor otherwise discriminatory. Arturo Perez, who The Gazette welcomes Coop-related articles and letters from mem- will be partnered by bers. Carolynn Murphy. SUBMISSION GUIDELINES All submissions must include author’s name and phone number and www.facebook.com/ProspectConcerts conform to the following guidelines. Editors will reject letters and articles that are illegible or too long. Submission deadlines appear 53 Prospect Park West [at 2nd Street] • $10 • 8pm [doors open at 7:45] in the Coop Calendar opposite. Performers are Park Slope Food Coop members and receive Coop workslot credit. Booking: Bev Grant, 718-788-3741 Letters: Maximum 500 words. All letters will be printed if they conform to the guidelines above. The Anonymity and Fairness policies appear on the letters page in most issues. Voluntary Articles: Maximum 750 words. Editors will reject articles This Issue Prepared By: that are essentially just advertisements for member businesses and services. 2%452. 0/,)#9 Coordinating Editors: Stephanie Golden Erik Lewis Committee Reports: Maximum 1,000 words. I]Z 8dde hig^kZh id 2%15)2%$ &/2 !.9 2%452. `ZZeeg^XZhadl[dgdjg Editors (development): Erik Lewis I]ZEV^Y">c";jaagZXZ^eiBJHI Editor-Writer Guidelines: Except for letters to the editor, which bZbWZgh]^e# B^c^" WZegZhZciZY# Joan Minieri are published without editing but are subject to the Gazette letters b^o^c\ i]Z Vbdjci d[ '#GZijgchbjhiWZ]VcYaZY policy regarding length, anonymity, respect and fairness, all gZijgcZY bZgX]VcY^hZ l^i]^c(%YVnhd[ejgX]VhZ# Reporters: Frank Haberle submissions to the Linewaiters’ Gazette will be reviewed and, if ^h dcZ lVn lZ Yd i]^h# necessary, edited by the editor. In their review, editors are guid- >[ ndj cZZY id bV`Z V Tom Matthews ed by the Gazette’s Fairness and Anonymity policies as well as gZijgc! eaZVhZ \d id i]Z #!. ) %8#(!.'% -9 )4%- Alison Rose Levy standard editorial practices of grammatical review, separation 'cY;addgHZgk^XZ9Zh`# Cd!lZYdcdiÆZmX]Vc\ZÇ^iZbh# of fact from opinion, attribution of factual statements, and rudi- NdjbjhigZijgci]ZbZgX]VcY^hZ Art Director (development): Eva Schicker mentary fact checking. Writers are responsible for the factual VcYgZ"ejgX]VhZl]VindjcZZY# Illustrators: Lynn Bernstein content of their stories. Editors must make a reasonable effort to Ethan Pettit contact and communicate with writers regarding any proposed editorial changes. Writers must make a reasonable effort to #!. ) 2%452. -9 )4%- Deborah Tint respond to and be available to editors to confer about their arti- EgdYjXZ 7ja` ^cXa#8dde"WV\\ZYWja` Photographer: Rod Morrison cles. If there is no response after a reasonable effort to contact 8]ZZhZ HZVhdcVa=da^YVn>iZbh the writer, an editor, at her or his discretion, may make editorial 7dd`h HeZX^VaDgYZgh .%6%2 Thumbnails: Kristin Lilley changes to a submission without conferring with the writer. 8VaZcYVgh GZ[g^\ZgViZYHjeeaZbZcih 2%452.!",% ?j^XZgh D^ah Photoshop: Terrance Carney Submissions on Paper: Typed or very legibly handwritten and Hjh]^ 6WjnZg^hVkV^aVWaZYjg^c\i]ZlZZ`" placed in the wallpocket labeled “Editor” on the second floor at the YVnhidY^hXjhhndjgXdcXZgch# Quark: Helena Boskovic base of the ramp. Art Director (production): Dilhan Kushan 2%452.!",% Digital Submissions: We welcome digital submissions. The GZ[g^\ZgViZY