DOCSLIB.ORG

Media Coverage of the Benefits and Harms of Testing the Healthy: a Protocol for a Descriptive Study

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Media Coverage of the Benefits and Harms of Testing the Healthy: a Protocol for a Descriptive Study Open access Protocol BMJ Open: first published as 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029532 on 24 August 2019. Downloaded from Media Coverage of the Benefits and Harms of Testing the Healthy: a protocol for a descriptive study Mary O'Keeffe,1 Alexandra Barratt,2 Christopher Maher,1 Joshua Zadro, 1 Alice Fabbri,3 Mark Jones,4 Ray Moynihan2,4 To cite: O'Keeffe M, Barratt A, ABSTRACT Strengths and limitations of this study Maher C, et al. Media Introduction Much testing in medicine is aimed at Coverage of the Benefits healthy people to facilitate the early detection of health ► This will be the first study to analyse the media cov- and Harms of Testing the conditions. However, there is growing evidence that early Healthy: a protocol for a erage of the benefits and harms of tests that have detection is a double-edged sword that may cause harm descriptive study. BMJ Open the potential for overdiagnosis in healthy people. in the form of overdiagnosis. The media can be seen as a 2019;9:e029532. doi:10.1136/ ► Media stories will not be restricted by country. The major generator of consumer demand for health services. bmjopen-2019-029532 results could inform interventions to improve the Previous research shows that media coverage tends to quality of medical reporting in the media. ► Prepublication history for overstate the benefits and downplay the harms of medical ► The study will only consider media coverage of five this paper is available online. interventions for the sick, and often fails to cover relevant To view these files, please visit tests. conflicts of interest of those promoting those interventions. the journal online (http:// dx. doi. org/ 10. 1136/ bmjopen- 2019- However, little is known about how the benefits and harms 029532). of testing the healthy are covered by media. This study will examine the media coverage of the benefits and harms of treatment is more effective when it is tailored 3 Received 30 January 2019 testing the healthy, and coverage of potential conflicts of to the individual. Apparently healthy or well Revised 11 July 2019 interest of those promoting the testing. people are increasingly encouraged to proac- Accepted 11 July 2019 Methods and analysis We will examine five tests: 3D tively monitor, and be vigilant about under- mammography for the early detection of breast cancer; standing their health, with testing seen as a blood liquid biopsy for the early detection of cancer; positive step in consumer health empower- blood biomarker tests for the early detection of dementia; ment. However, there is mounting evidence artificial intelligence technology for the early detection of http://bmjopen.bmj.com/ that testing can harm healthy people, and © Author(s) (or their dementia; and the Apple Watch Series 4 electrocardiogram sensor for the early detection of atrial fibrillation. We the quest for ever-earlier detection of disease employer(s)) 2019. Re-use can lead to unnecessary classification of the permitted under CC BY-NC. No will identify media coverage using Google News and the 3–8 commercial re-use. See rights LexisNexis and ProQuest electronic databases. Sets of two healthy as sick: overdiagnosis. and permissions. Published by independent reviewers will conduct story screening and Although an exact definition of overdiag- BMJ. coding. We will include English language media stories nosis remains the subject of debate, particu- 1Institute for Musculoskeletal referring to any of the five tests from January 2016 to May larly in the context of non-cancer conditions, Health, Sydney School of Public 2019. We will include media stories if they refer to any overdiagnosis can be considered to occur Health, Faculty of Medicine and on September 29, 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. benefits or harms of the test for our conditions of interest. when persons are labelled with a technically Health, University of Sydney, Data will be analysed using categorical data analysis and Sydney, New South Wales, correct diagnosis that does not improve health multinomial logistic regression. 9 10 Australia outcomes. Key drivers of overdiagnosis 2 Ethics and dissemination No ethical approval is required Sydney School of Public Health, have been identified.11 One is the use of more for this study. Results will be presented at relevant Faculty of Medicine and Health, sensitive tests which can detect smaller abnor- The University of Sydney, scientific conferences and in peer-reviewed literature. 11 Sydney, New South Wales, malities, many of which are benign. There Australia is growing evidence demonstrating the pres- 3Charles Perkins Centre and INTRODUCTION ence of overdiagnosis, often arising through School of Pharmacy, Faculty of Much testing in medicine is aimed at appar- testing healthy people, across different areas Medicine and Health, University ently healthy people to identify those at an of medicine. Examples include screening for of Sydney, Sydney, New South increased risk of a disease or disorder.1 These cancer (eg, breast, prostate, thyroid), cardio- Wales, Australia 7 8 12–16 4Institute for Evidence-Based ‘healthy’ people can subsequently be offered vascular disease and dementia. Inap- Healthcare, Bond University, more tests, treatment(s) or preventive strat- propriate screening in this context is likely to Gold Coast, Queensland, egies (eg, a preventive medicine).1 The lead to higher healthcare spending and worse Australia increasing popularity of testing is indicative of outcomes (eg, psychological effects and 2 17–21 Correspondence to recent enthusiasm for early detection, which unnecessary and harmful treatments). Dr Mary O'Keeffe; is part of the promise of ‘precision medicine’. Sustained promotion to the public, mary. okeeffe@ sydney. edu. au That is, early detection is always better, and patients and clinicians of the importance O'Keeffe M, et al. BMJ Open 2019;9:e029532. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029532 1 Open access BMJ Open: first published as 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029532 on 24 August 2019. Downloaded from of early detection and testing, including via the media, promoting the testing, by examining the coverage of five is considered another driver of overdiagnosis.11 Uncrit- tests. ical coverage of new tests, without consideration of their potential downsides, contributes to the general lack of knowledge about the potential harms of getting tested METHODS AND ANALYSIS when healthy. In fact, research has shown that only a small Overview proportion of people are knowledgeable about overdiag- We will conduct a large descriptive cross-sectional study of 22 23 nosis. This includes individuals offered tests where the global English-language media coverage of five tests from 22 23 potential for overdiagnosis is high. As such, patients January 2016 to May 2019. (and clinicians) overestimate the benefits of testing, while underestimating the harms.24 25 Tests and conditions of interest There is also concern about how changing media envi- This study will focus on five tests: ronments, such as the rising influence of social media, 1. 3D mammography for the early detection of breast can lead to ‘junk-food news’.26 Indeed, previous studies cancer on the media have identified evidence of exaggera- 2. Blood liquid biopsy tests for the early detection of can- tion,27 28 inaccurate media coverage of published scien- cer(s) tific papers,29 30 overstating of benefits of treatments, 3. Blood biomarker tests for the early detection of de- downplaying of harms27 29 and failure to report important mentia conflicts of interest of the experts cited in the story.27 4. Artificial intelligence (AI) technology for the early de- Concern has also been expressed about the financial tection of dementia closeness between journalists and industry. For example, 5. Apple Watch Series 4 ECG sensor for the early detec- pharmaceutical industry funding of journalism practice, tion of atrial fibrillation (AF) awards and education, has been documented.31 32 Further, We identified these tests based on the following criteria there appears to be a lack of independent medical 1. Evidence-based concerns about overdiagnosis research commentators in the media. Only one in six 2. Evidence of Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ap- media reports of research published in high-impact proval for certain classes of each test medical journals included comments from people who 3. Concern that the results of these tests may not lead to were independent of the study investigators.33 Moreover, improved health outcomes for some individuals; either one in three of the independent commenters had finan- due to the unavailability of effective treatment options cial conflicts of interest, most of which were not disclosed (eg, dementia) or treatments that may cause more in the media stories.33 harm than benefit (eg, early mammography) Poor media coverage of medicine is a significant issue; it 4. Identifiable groups or companies with a financial in- can influence how the public perceives the risk of health terest in promoting these tests, or maximising the mar- http://bmjopen.bmj.com/ services and how patients make treatment decisions.29 31 kets for downstream treatments For example, media coverage about the celebrity Kylie 5. Notable media coverage Minogue’s self-referral mammogram bookings led to a One reviewer (MO) used Google News to track media 20-fold increase in media coverage about breast cancer coverage of tests for the healthy between April 2018 and and a 40% increase in mammogram bookings during the October 2018. Results were recorded in a Microsoft Excel 2-week peak after the interview.34 Six weeks later, media file. Based on these results, the same reviewer designed a coverage was still up by 30%.34 series of Google Alerts (running between April 2018 and Media coverage of overtreatment has been examined December 2018) with specific keywords related to testing. on September 29, 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. in one study35 which examined the framing of medical The Google Alert results were screened to identify media overtreatment in United States (US) newspapers from coverage on tests for healthy people which met the first January 2007 to December 2010.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Project Censored 2012: the Sourcebook for the Media Revolution
    Project Censored 2012: The Sourcebook for the Media Revolution By Media Freedom Foundation Theme: Media Disinformation Global Research, October 20, 2011 Media Freedom Foundation 20 October 2011 For Immediate Release: October 12, 2011 Contact: Project Censored/Media Freedom Foundation, 707.874.2695 Dr. Peter Phillips, President; Prof. Mickey Huff, Director [email protected]; [email protected] Interviews: Contact Mickey Huff at email above. Order the new book online at http://projectcensored.org or send check for $22.95 to Project Censored/Media Freedom Foundation, P.O. Box 571 Cotati, CA 94931 “Most journalists in the United States believe the press here is free. That grand illusion only helps obscure the fact that, by and large, the US corporate press does not report what’s really going on, while tuning out, or laughing off, all those who try to do just that. Americans—now more than ever—need those outlets that do labor to report some truth. Project Censored is not just among the bravest, smartest, and most rigorous of those outlets, but the only one that’s wholly focused on those stories that the corporate press ignores, downplays and/or distorts. This latest book is therefore a must-read for anyone who cares about this country, its tottering economy, and—most important—what’s now left of its democracy.” —Mark Crispin Miller, professor of media ecology, NYU Our new book has arrived! Censored 2012: The Sourcebook for the Media Revolution, The Top Censored Stories and Media Analysis of 2010-2011 by Mickey Huff and Project Censored. In this volume, there are 500 pages of real news you can use, plus ample analysis that eradicates civil paralysis, and antidotes to our current Truth Emergency that will strengthen societal media literacy.
    [Show full text]
  • “Project Censored's List of the Top Stories That Get Very Little
    “Project Censored’s list of the top stories that get very little mainstream me- dia traction should in fact drive the reporting agendas of every major news outlet. These 25 stories are clearly the most consequential of the year, and what is scary in looking at the list is how obvious it is that silencing reports of these themes protects corrupt governments and corporate gatekeepers. Project Censored is a lifeline to the world’s most urgent and significant stories.” —Naomi Wolf, author of the bestselling books The Beauty Myth; The End of America; and Give Me Liberty “The systematic exposure of censored stories by Project Censored has been an important contribution.” —Howard Zinn, author of A People’s History of the United States “Project Censored . has evolved into a deep, wide, and utterly engross- ing exercise to unmask censorship, self-censorship, and propaganda in the mass media.” —Ralph Nader, consumer advocate, lawyer, author “[Project Censored] is a clarion call for truth telling.”—Daniel Ellsberg, The Pentagon Papers “[Project Censored] shows how the American public has been bamboozled, snookered, and dumbed down by the corporate media. It is chock-full of ‘ah- ha’ moments where we understand just how we’ve been fleeced by bank- sters, stripped of our civil liberties, and blindly led down a path of never- ending war.” —Medea Benjamin, author of Drone Warfare, and cofounder of Global Exchange and CODEPINK “Project Censored . not only shines a penetrating light on the American Empire and all its deadly, destructive, and deceitful actions, it does so at a time when the Obama administration is mounting a fierce effort to silence truth-tellers and whistleblowers.
    [Show full text]
  • Guardian Media Group PLC's
    CONFIDENTIAL GMG RESPONSE TO CMA STATEMENT OF SCOPE - DIGITAL ADVERTISING MARKET STUDY CONFIDENTIAL VERSION About Guardian Media Group PLC (GMG) GMG is one of the UK’s leading commercial media organisations and a British-owned, independent, news media business. GMG owns Guardian News & Media (GNM), the publisher of theguardian.com website and the Guardian and Observer newspapers. It is known for its globally acclaimed investigations, including investigating the Paradise Papers and Panama Papers and Cambridge Analytica. As well as being the UK’s largest quality news brand, the Guardian and Observer have pioneered a highly distinctive, open approach to publishing on the web and their website has achieved significant global audience growth over the past 20 years. Our endowment fund and portfolio of other holdings exist to support the Guardian’s journalism by providing financial returns. As the CMA may be aware, The Guardian’s unique structure and trust model means that our owner - the Scott Trust - takes no dividend from the business. This means that any revenue generated by GNM is reinvested back into funding more high-quality public interest Guardian journalism. Introduction GMG welcomes the opportunity to respond to the CMA statement of scope and wider work to examine competition in digital markets. The digital economy underpins and impacts almost every sector of the UK and global economy in some way. Ensuring that there is fair and effective competition in the supply of key products such as digital advertising, and digital payment services
    [Show full text]
  • Gateway Journalism Review
    St. Louis Journalism Review Presents: OURNALISMOURNALISM REVIEWREVIEW Inside this issue: Daily Egyptian challenges Courage and coverage in real time by Jodi MacNeal chancellor’s ethics by Athena Chrysanthou Checking on the facts Remembering Roy Malone by Ben Lyons by Terry Ganey Activists draw attention to atomic city Review: McPhee and Bill Bradley by Don Corrigan by Michael Murray - PAGE 1 - 2018 • Volume 47 Number 348 • $8 St. Louis Journalism Review Presents: CONTRIBUTORS OURNALISM REVIEW Publisher William H. Freivogel Published by: Publisher of Gateway Journalism Review. Freivo- Artist Steve Edwards gel is a former editorial page deputy editor for Professional artist, Steve Edwards Studio. School of Journalism College the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and contributes to of Mass Communication St. Louis Public Radio. He is a member of the and Media Arts Missouri Bar. GJR Founder Charles Klotzer Deborah Tudor: interim dean The founder of the St. Louis Journalism Review. Kavita Karan: interim director Sherida Evans: School of Editor William A. Babcock Journalism, office manager Editor of Gateway Journalism Review. Former DON CORRIGAN senior international news editor and writing Don Corrigan is the editor-in-chief and co-pub- coach for the Christian Science Monitor. Media lisher of the Webster-Kirkwood Times, South Board of Advisers: ethics is his primary teaching and research area. County Times and West End Word newspapers in Jim Kirchherr, Don Corrigan, St. Louis. He also is a professor of journalism in Lisa Bedian, Tammy Merrett, the School of Communications at Webster Univer- Rita Csapo-Sweet, Steve Managing Editor Jin Lee sity in St. Louis, serving as a print adviser to the Perron, Eileen Duggan, Associate editor of the Gateway Journalism university newspaper.
    [Show full text]
  • Fake News: a New Trending Phenomenon and Challenges
    Vol-3 Issue-6 2017 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396 Fake News: A New Trending Phenomenon and Challenges *Ashish Sharma Assistant Professor-II Amity School of communication Amity University Abstract As we know news is a piece of information which we get through various forms of communication. In the beginning we have Traditional media like newspaper and Television through which we were getting news. After that through internet and nowadays through social media we were getting news .Earlier we believed that whatever information is communicated or conveyed through various medium of communication is real and we believed that , but with the advent of fake news on social media now it’s become difficult to believe which is real and which is not. Fake news has many synonyms like disinformation campaigns, cyber propaganda, cognitive hacking, and information warfare. It also makes it easier to manipulate the people’s perception of reality and thought processes, resulting in the proliferation of fake news that affects our real, non-digital environment. Nowadays social media is a dominant source of information for significant parts of our societies. There are numerous positive aspects of these media, such as their ability to mobilize for a political cause or to make any public opinion. Today no one can deny that social media strengthen free speech in general, allow greater and quicker flows of ideas across societies, and add to the quality of life. Yet at the same time, social media may sometimes negatively impact the public debate. This paper analyses how social media activist spread fake news and manipulate public opinion to serve various motives like political or personal.
    [Show full text]
  • Anthropology/Sociology 344—Selling the News (Fall 2014)
    Anthropology/Sociology 344—Selling the news (Fall 2014) Instructor: Bill Grigsby Date(s): Friday, Oct 10 (7:00 – 10:00 pm), Saturday, Oct 11 (9:00 am – 5:00 pm) Location: EOU Portland Metro Center, 7732 SE Harmony Rd, Portland – Room 143 Contact: 204B Ackerman; (541) 962-3591; [email protected] COURSE DESCRIPTION: Examines the commercial and alternative news media, how political bias is expressed and news is filtered, the pervasiveness of propaganda and deceptive techniques employed within and outside the news media, and what alternative, non-commercial sources are available and accessible. The object of this course is to provide students with a framework for understanding commercial news media and its effect on political processes and public opinion. This course fulfills Social Science and Culture (SSC) for gen-ed. The gen-ed curriculum assumes that ‘every educated person should have some acquaintance with certain traditional areas of human knowledge and experience and be able to synthesize and contextualize this knowledge within their own lives.’ This course is an introduction to mass news media. Because so much of what people understand about problems and important issues in our society comes from the news they watch/read/listen to, news ‘media literacy’ is a critical skill for engaged, public citizens. COURSE OBJECTIVES 1. To raise awareness of bias in commercial news media, and how to identify it. 2. To develop/sharpen students’ 'media literacy.' 3. To expose students to some of basic concepts of propaganda and its use in news media. 4. To better understand how news media bias affects politics and democracy.
    [Show full text]
  • State of the Free Press | 2021 • Teaching Guide
    TEACHING GUIDE Project Censored’s State of the Free Press | 2021 Edited by Mickey Huff and Andy Lee Roth ISBN: 9781644210260 $17.95 | 224 pages Paperback Seven Stories Press INTRODUCTION Countering news fatigue with critical media literacy We depend on news to help make sense of the world. But recent debates over “fake news” and corresponding concerns that news is often corrupted by propaganda have led many Americans—including students—to distrust all news sources or, in extreme cases, to avoid following any news at all. Yet, a well-informed public is essential to democracy, and each depends on transparent, trustworthy journalism. State of the Free Press | 2021 ignites students’ interest in news by giving them tools to distinguish whether reporting is trustworthy or not, and by showing how a truly free press is essential for social justice. The book provides a succinct and comprehensive survey of the current state of news media in the United States. The reading strategies, discussion questions, and explorations presented here provide examples of how teachers can use State of the Free Press | 2021 to engage students and develop their critical thinking skills in a wide variety of courses. sevenstories.com 1 State of the Free Press | 2021 • Teaching Guide Important but underreported news stories Continuing Project Censored’s 44-year history as an internationally-respected news media watchdog, State of the Free Press | 2021 includes capsule summaries for 25 of the most important but underreported news stories from 2019-2020. These stories cover a range of contemporary social issues that students may care about deeply, or only understand vaguely—including, for example, economic inequality, institutional racism, public health, environmental threats, and the power of people organizing together to create positive social change.
    [Show full text]
  • Democracy on Junk Food Processed News and the Body Politic
    DEMOCRACY ON JUNK FOOD PROCESSED NEWS AND THE BODY POLITIC Bill Grigsby NEWS ‘DIET’ AN INTERESTING, BUT UNDERDEVELOPED IDEA “One of the most salient features of our culture is that there is so much bullshit. Everyone knows this. Each of us contributes his share. But we tend to take the situation for granted. Most people are rather confident of their ability to recognize bullshit and to avoid being taken in by it. So the phenomenon has not aroused much deliberate concern, or attracted much sustained inquiry. In consequence, we have no clear understanding of what bullshit is, why there is so much of it, or what functions it serves. “ (philosopher) Harry Frankfurt, ‘On bullshit’ (1988) MAIN POINTS . Processing is a useful metaphor for examining parallels with food system and dysfunctions between the news media and political systems. Increased processing in the news represents higher propaganda content, which reflects corporate capture of commercial news media and elections. The effects of these dysfunctions represent serious problems for the health of representative democracy. LIMITS OF ANALYSIS . Commercial news merit special attention—theirs is the prevailing business model for American media. Television is still the primary news source for most Americans who consume news. Concerns national-level politics . Propaganda sources: . Pratkanis and Aronson, 2001 (Age of Propaganda) . Patrick, 2011 (Ten Commandments of Propaganda) . Cialdini, 2010 (Influence) . Hermann and Chomsky, 1988 (Manufacturing Consent) . Johnson, 2012 (The Information
    [Show full text]
  • Annotated Film Bibliography
    Annotated Film Bibliography Political Science 121 – Introduction to US Government Lough, A. B. (Writer and Director). (2018). Alt right: Age of rage. {Documentary]. United States: Gravitas Ventures. In the first year of Donald Trump's presidency, Daryle Lamont Jenkins, an Antifa activist, combats the rise of the alt-right movement, while Richard Spencer, an alt-right leader, fights to gain ground, culminating in a tragic showdown in Charlottesville. Moore, M. (Writer, Producer, Director). (2018). Fahrenheit 11/9. [Documentary]. United States: State Run Films. Filmmaker Michael Moore predicted that Donald Trump would become the 45th president of the United States. Traveling across the country, Moore interviews American citizens to get a sense of the social, economic and political impact of Trump's victory. Moore also takes an in-depth look at voting, the Electoral College, the government agenda, the school shooting in Parkland, Fla., and the water crisis in his hometown of Flint, Mich. Kaplowitz, D. (Director). (2002). In whose interest? [Documentary]. United States: Bullfrog Films. Filmmaker David Kaplowitz leads us on an eye opening journey, questioning the effects of U.S. foreign policy over the past 50 years. Revealing a pattern of intervention, the film focuses on Guatemala, Vietnam, East Timor, El Salvador, and Palestine/Israel. Archival footage, photographs and media tidbits are dynamically interwoven with personal eye-witness accounts and commentary from academics – such as Noam Chomsky – religious leaders and politicians. In Whose Interest? is informative and disturbingly honest, yet upbeat, with twists of irony and humor. Oscar, C. & Hecker, D. (Producer, Writer, Director). (2013). Project Censored: The movie.
    [Show full text]
  • FIVE WAYS to FLEX YOUR MEDIA LITERACY MUSCLES Andy Lee Roth and Project Censored
    FIVE WAYS TO FLEX YOUR MEDIA LITERACY MUSCLES Andy Lee Roth and Project Censored 1. Cut “Junk Food” news from your media diet. If you rely on corporate news, replace one or more of your usual news sources with independent journalism. Try this for two weeks and decide whether you are better informed by independent news than your usual sources. Project Censored maintains a list of independent news sources. 2. Follow the money. Corporate news is driven by advertising revenues and shaped by patterns of media ownership. For the news you consume, ask: What economic interests shape this content? The Columbia Journalism Review maintains a useful database on media ownership. 3. Ask: “Who is treated as newsworthy?” With rare exceptions, establishment journalists rely exclusively on government and corporate officials as news sources. This means elites tend to be the sources and the subjects of most corporate news. For news stories you follow, track who gets quoted as newsworthy sources. Do these sources represent the full diversity of people with relevant information and perspectives on those stories? For one example of this kind of research, conducted by Project Censored students and faculty, see “Oiling the Dangerous Engine of Arbitrary Government: Newspaper Coverage of the Military Commissions Act”, published in Censored 2009. 4. Resist “News Inflation.” We have access to more news than ever before, but it seems to be worth less and less. Project Censored fights news inflation by highlighting important and credible news stories that corporate media either ignore or cover partially. For direct access to “the news that didn’t make the news,” visit our Validated Independent News page.
    [Show full text]
  • Participatory Practices by Citizens in Media
    Pramana Research Journal ISSN NO: 2249-2976 Participatory Practices by Citizens in Media Dr. Kamaljeet Kaur UIMS, Chandigarh University Gharuan Abstract Citizen journalism is rapidly emerging as an invaluable part of delivering the news. With the expansion of the Web and the ever-decreasing size and cost of camera phones and video cameras, the ability to commit acts of journalism is spreading to everyone. Arianna Huffington Journalism is the fourth pillar of Democracy. While Participatory Journalism is the support to the pillar. More citizens are participating in Journalism after the emergence of Multimedia mobile phones, Internet, Broadband, Social Media and Youtube. With use of modern technology and the global distribution of the Internet, citizens without any background in journalism can write on issues for different platforms Citizen or participatory journalism strengths Democracy. In few cases the citizen journalist works as a whistle blower. The research article will emphasise on the need and importance of Participatory practices by the Citizens. Key Words: Citizen Journalism, Democracy, Participatory Journalism, Multimedia,Media, MOJO Introduction Journalism is an integral part of any healthy democracy. It plays an important role in shaping our identities as citizens. It facilitates conversations and deliberations between and among citizens and their representatives. It thus helps in the strengthening of the public sphere and hence democracy. Citizen Journalism is an important initiative towards the democratization of the media which is emerging rapidly in the era of Mobile Journalism. Media is the medium or channel through which news, entertainment or promotional messages are disseminated. It consists of Television, Newspapers, Magazines, Radio and New Media.
    [Show full text]
  • ENDRI AJBALS Mars 2018 .Indd
    ISSN 2410-3918 Academic Journal of Business, Administration, Law and Social Sciences Vol. 4 No. 1 Acces online at www.iipccl.org IIPCCL Publishing, Graz-Austria March, 2018 The disappearance of competence of headlines PhD (C.) Muhamet Mavraj University of Pristina Abstract The title is the text locomotive. It draws all the other compositions behind. Newspaper texts are termed as productions or reproductions of reality but are oft en denied their literary feature. It seems to be hasty denial. Endless examples show that news headlines have extraordinary power of expression. The transition from printed journalism to online journalism is degrading the stylistic power of news headlines. This article explains some of the types of degradation and the reasons related to the new concepts imposed by online journalism. The main factor that is degrading the title is clickbait, and it is not the only one. The titles either consist of two or three words, followed by reticence... to robbing clicks or being transformed into novels. Consequently, the title competence is vanishing. The measurements of the words in newspaper headlines at diff erent times and in two ideological blocks signal that the titles are being totalitarianized. Meanwhile, the competence of the locomotive is being transferred to wagons. Keywords: style, headline, newspaper, click, clickbait, empty calories of information. Introduction If the headline is a coherent, natural title, it looks like a head in its body, however, the fi rst identifying sign of a nature. It has many functions. Three of them are: the headline summarizes the news, it shows the importance of writing and pulls the reader to turn it into active.
    [Show full text]