The Pedi Polity Under Sekwati and Sekhukhune, 1828-1880 P
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE PEDI POLITY UNDER SEKWATI AND SEKHUKHUNE, 1828-1880 Peter Nicholas St, TJartin Delius Thjesis submitted fo r the Degree of JDoctor of Philosophy, School of Oriental and African / Studies, University of London August 3980 ProQuest Number: 11010558 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a com plete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest ProQuest 11010558 Published by ProQuest LLC(2018). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States C ode Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. ProQuest LLC. 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106- 1346 ABSTRACT ’ THE PEDI POLITY UNDER SEKWATI AND SEKHUKHUNE, 1828-1660* Peter Nicholas St, Martin Delius. University of London, 1980 This thesis explores aspects of the history of the Pedi polity from 1828-1880 co verin g the p erio d from the emerjgence o f the p o lit y in the aftermath of the difaqane until its defeat in November of 1879. It sets out to f ill the lacunae in the existing literature caused by the failure to adopt a critical approach to historical sources or to provide a dynamic account of Pedi society. An analysis is provided of the changing nature and distribution of power within the polity. The economic changes and p o litical processes at work within the society and the impact of Christianity on it are explored. The development of the polity is also examined in the context of the processes of conflict and change taking place beyond its borders. The concluding chapters of the thesis draw on the insights afforded by the examination of these themes to attempt a substantive revision of the existing explanations and accounts of the conflicts in the 1870s which culminated in the defeat of the polity and the subjection of the Pedi to colonial rule. - i i - TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements iii L is t o f Flaps i v List of Abbreviations v Genealogy » after 26 SECTION ONE Introduction 1 Chapter One: The estab lish m en t o f fja ro te n g hegemony; the Ndwandwe and Sekwati’s rise to power; the Trekkers 20 SECTION TWO The Pedi Domain Chapter Two: The forms and nature of flaroteng dominance 67 Chapter Three: Fligrant labour 65 Chapter Four: Internal political process and external political relations 113 Chapter Five: Converts and missionaries in the Pedi domain i4 7 SECTION THREE The Z .A .R , Domain Chapter Six: Land, labour and legislation 171 Chapter Seven: From refuge to resistance; Botsabelo and Flafolofolo 216 SECTION f OUR War Chapter Eight; The 1876 War 249 Chapter Nine: The imperial factor and the destruction- of Pedi indepentleBce 301 Epilogue 346 Appendix I 346 Bibliography 360 - i i i - V\CKNOWLEDGEnENTS Acknowledgements and thanks are due to Anthony Delius who nurtured my Interest in Africa, and who has put up with me for all these years* to Richard Gray who shepherded me through -my undergraduate years and to Shula Darks who captured and shaped my interest in southern African history, and who bravely shouldered the burden of supervising this thesis - a task which she has performed with insight, -meticulous care and almost infinite patience. Stan Trapido rescued this thesis Cand its author] from a Brixton betting-§hbp and has contributed m aterially and intellectually to its completion, William Beinart far exceeded the dictates of reciprocity in his role as sounding board for and c ritic of the arguments presented in the thesis. I incurred a large number of debts of gratitude during my travels and researches. Ds. Ute Poershke, Bettina Gols and Gabriele flay gave me invaluable assistance in the Berlin Uissionary Society archives in T975. Phil and Chris Bonner's hospitality enabled me to escape from the 'Eureka Hotel' in Pretoria and they showed me great.kindness in trying times in 1976 and 1977. The Reverend and Urs, R. Schiele, Tebogo Tlaslkela and Godfrey and Isaac Sekhukfrune gave me sustained assistance during my field work in Sekhukhuneland. Flaureen Tayal edited, mapped and morale- boosted, helping to make the last stages of writing this thesis, incredibly, an almost pleasant experience. The bulk of the research for this study was done in the years 1974- 1977 during which I held a School of Oriental and African Studies Governing Body Postgraduate Exhibition, S.O.A.S,, in conjunction with the University of London CBhtral Research fund also funded -my research trips to Berlin and South Africa, fly present employers - Queen Elizabeth House, Oxford - have generously allowed-me time to complete the thesis, i -iv- LIST DF NAPS 1. The Transvaal fa c in g 19 2 . The eastern Tran svaal fa c in g 19 / -V- ABBREVIATIONS B.M.A. Berlin Missionary Society Archive B.M.B. Berlin Missions-berichte B.n.s. Berlin Missionary Society C.A. Cape A rchives N.A. Natal Archives T.A. Transvaal Archives U.A. University of South Africa Archives Z.A .R . Zuid-Afrikaansche Republiek / SECTION ONE -1- INTRDDUCTIDN This thesis explores aspects of the history of the Pedi polity from 182B to 1080, covering the period from the emergence of the polity in the aftermath of the difaqane until its defeat in the closing months of 1879 by a contained B r itis h and Swazi fo rc e . The term Pedi presents a number of problems. It has been variously used to indicate virtually a ll the Sotho-speaking peoples of the northern and eastern Transvaal, restricted to the Maroteng chiefdom and groups which seceded from it, and used to refer to the population living within 1 the area o f hegemony o f the H aroteng paramountcy. I t is in th is l a t t e r sense that it is employed in this thesis. Even this usage is, of necessity, a loose one. The Pedi polity was a geographically fluid entity and the period under consideration witnessed marked changes in the area and peoples which fe ll under its sway. The subject population was not ethnically homogeneous. By the late eighteenth century a m ultiplicity of groups of diverse origins lived within the Pedi domain. This diversity was compounded in the nineteenth century by the movement of groups of refugees into the area of the polity -/rom throughout the Transvaal and beyond, Hence while a common culture was in the process of emerging, differences of language, self-identification and culture remained, The history of the polity is a clear illustration of the fact that political and cultural boundaries were far from coterminus in nineteenth century African society in southern Africa, 1 M H.O. rionnig, The Pedi [Pretoria, 1967), v-^vir I follow the example of Andrew Roberts1 study of the Bemba in using the term polity in preference to state or kingdom. The proper definition of state remains a ‘thorny subject’ and the problem posed by the distinction between kingship and chieftainship is also unsolved. See A. Roberts-, A History of the Bemba, (London, 1973), :xxiii'-.xxxiv, There is, in comparison to other African communities in the Transvaal, a considerable body of secondary literature on Pedi history and society. The historical literature falls into two main categories. The first is principally based on extensive archival research in the records of the Z.A.R. and the British administration in the Transvaal (1877-18B1) i to a lesser extent it draws on published Berlin TUssionary Society sources. These accounts focus on the relationship between the Pedi polity and successive Transvaal administrations. They explore the conflicts which culminated in, and the course of, the m ilitary campaigns conducted against the Pedi in 1876-1877 and 1878-1879, The history of missionary activity in the eastern Transvaal, however, also forms an important if 1 subsidiary - theme. There are a number of weaknesses common to this literature. It is marred by an uncritical use of sources in relation to Pedi society. This has particularly serious consequences in a context in which almost a ll documentary material was generated externally to that society. The assumptions and interests of commentators on the polity are rarely examined, and these account^ draw m ainly on the explanations fo r events proffered by missionaries, officials and settlers without scrutinizing their basis in the evidence. This, despite the fact the evidence offered in support of these explanations is often ambiguous or contradictory. 1 The most important of these accounts are J.C, Otto, ‘Die SeRoekoeni Oorlog Tydens die Regering van President Burgers*, unpuh, 11,A,. thesis, University of South Africa, 1941 1 J.C, Otto, ‘Oorsake en Gebeurtenisse wat Indirek in Regstreeks Aanleiding Gegee het tot die Veldtog Teen Sekoekoene*, Historiese Studies, 7, 4 (19461 j T.S, Van Rooyen, ‘Die Verhoudinge Tussen die Boere, ~ Engelse en Naturelle in die Geskiedenis van die Oos^Transvaal tot 1882*, Archives Year Book. KIV 1(195!)j T.S, Van Rooyen, ‘Die Sendeling Alexander Tlerensky in die Geskiedenis van die Suid Afrikanse Republiek, 1B59-1B82', Archives Year Book, TSVII, 2(1954) * K,W, Smith, ’The Canpaigns against the Bapedi of Sekhukhune, 1877-1879', Archives Year Book, "XXX, 2 (1967lj ,K,W, Smith, ’The Fall of the Bapedi of the North-Eastern Transvaal’ , Journal of African History, 10, 2(1969)i D,W, Van Der Tlerwe ‘Johannes Dinkwanyane, 1842-1876’ , South African Historical Journal, 8(19761, -3- A major and related flaw that characterises these writings is the absence of any systematic attempt to explore the nature of economic and political processes, struggles and transformations within the polity, and to examine the extent to which these moulded the initiatives and responses of its rulers and subjects and shaped its ^historical role and experience.