Desmogca Clearing the Pr Pollution

DESMOGCA CLEARING THE PR POLLUTION

Home About Us Who Funds Us? Editorial Independence Donor Transparency Ethics Contact Us Newsletter Sign Up

A Climate Science Denier Was Just Reappointed to a Parliamentary Science Committee

A trustee of the UK climate science denial think tank the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) has just been reappointed to a parliamentary...

Terminating Site C Dam, Building Alternatives Could Save B.C. Over $1B: Economist

Judith Lavoie (/user/judith-lavoie) | September 14, 2017 DESMOGCA CLEARING THE PR POLLUTION

Home About Us Who Funds Us? Editorial Independence Donor Transparency Ethics Contact Us Newsletter Sign Up

 270   0  0  (mailto:? subject=Check out this story from DeSmog Canada&body=htt ps://www.desmog .ca/2017/09/14/te rminating-site-c- dam-building- alternatives-save- Share 270 Tweet Reddit 0 Share 0 Share     bc-over-1-billion- (mailto:? economist%0D%0 subject=Check A%0D%0ATermin out this story ating Site C Dam, from DeSmog Building Canada&body=ht Alternatives Could tps://www.desmo Save B.C. Over g.ca/2017/09/14/t $1B: Economist) erminating-site-c- dam-building- alternatives-save- bc-over-1-billion- economist%0D% 0A%0D%0ATermi nating Site C Dam, Building Alternatives Could Save B.C. Over $1B: Economist)

Karen Goodings avoids the Site C dam area on the Peace River because she nds it Karen Goodings avoids the Site C dam area on the Peace River because she nds it DESMOGCA too heart-wrenching to look at the haCvLEAoRIcNG TcHaE PuR PsOLeLUdTIO Nby construction work, but, for the

rst time in years, she is now holdinHgom oe ut hope that the $8.8-billion project will About Us be scrapped. Who Funds Us? Editorial Independence Donor Transparency Ethics “I want to see it permanently stoppeCodnt aactn Uds now I think there is enough information out there to talk about alternate souNerwcseletste ro Sifg np Uop wer that are more economical and less devastating,” said Goodings, a Peace River Regional District director.

Her optimism has been boosted by reports underlining nancial uncertainties with Site C and emphasizing that B.C.’s power needs can be met by wind, geothermal and solar projects.

ICYMI: If Saskatchewan Can Build a Geothermal Power Plant, Why Can’t B.C.? (//www.desmog.ca/2017/06/21/if-saskatchewan-can-build-geothermal-power- plant-why-can-t-b-c)

“I’ve not had a feeling that it was looking good for us until the Deloitte report (https://www2.deloitte.com/ca/en.html) came out, but now I think there is still an opportunity. Someone is going to listen,” she said.

A report (//www.desmog.ca/2017/09/09/site-c-dam-costs-could-escalate-40-says-auditor-s- report) by the auditing rm Deloitte LLP, requested by the B.C. Utilities Commission, looked at the economics of the controversial project and BC Hydro’s forecasts of electricity demand — and that information could be a game-changer, Goodings predicted.

Deloitte, which provides consulting services to government, found there were risks that the project could be delayed (//www.desmog.ca/2017/08/31/bc-hydro-violated-rules- protecting-indigenous-sites-forced-re-evaluate-site-c-bridge-construction) because of geotechnical and contractor problems and that, if a 2019 deadline for diverting the river was missed, it could add up to $1.8-billion to the cost. DESMOGCA DeSmog Canada CLEARING THE PR POLLUTION @DeSmogCanada Home About Us Terminating #SiteC Dam, Building AlternativWehso FCunodsu Ulds? Save BC Over $1B: Economist desmog.ca/2017/09/1E4dit/oteriarl… Ind e#pbencdpenoclei Donor Transparency @SavePeaceValley Ethics Contact Us 8:05 AM - Sep 14, 2017 Newsletter Sign Up

Terminating Site C Dam, Building Alternatives Could Save B.C… Karen Goodings avoids the Site C dam area on the Peace River because she finds it too heart-wrenching to look at the havoc caused dbey scmonosgt.rcuaction work, but, for the first time in years, she is now...

The study concluded it would be cheaper to cancel the project, at a cost of $1.2 billion, that to delay it at a cost of $1.4 billion.

The estimates join a separate April analysis (https://beta.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/bc-could-save-16-billion-by- cancelling-site-c-ubc-report/article34757233/?ref=http://www.theglobeandmail.com&) conducted by researchers with UBC’s Program on Water Governance that found stopping Site C by this past June would have saved B.C. between $500 million and $1.65 billion.

Similar to UBC’s analysis, the Deloitte research also found that BC Hydro regularly overestimated demand for power by up to 31 per cent. Between 1964 and 2016, BC Hydro overestimated future electricity demand in B.C. 77 per cent of the time, according to the Deloitte report.

ICYMI: B.C. Scales Down Energy-Saving Measures to Manufacture ICYMI B.C. : Scales Down Ener DgyE-SSMavOinGgC MAeasures to Manufacture Demand for Site C: UBC RepoCrLEAtRI N(G/ T/HwE PwR POwLLU.dTIOeNsmog.ca/2017/04/20/b-c-scales-down- Home energy-saving-measures-Ambouat nUsufacture-demand-site-c-ubc-report) Who Funds Us? Editorial Independence Donor Transparency The Utilities Commission is preparing toEt hpicsroduce a preliminary Site C report by Contact Us September 20 and, following a serieNsew osleft trero Suignn Udp -the-province hearings, will provide nal recommendations to government in November.

In addition to the Deloitte report, a submission (//www.desmog.ca/2017/09/12/falling- costs-renewable-power-make-site-c-dam-obsolete-says-energy-economist) to the commission by renowned hydroelectric consultant Robert McCullough, who was contracted by the Peace Valley Landowner Association and Peace Valley Environment Association, concluded that renewables could meet B.C.’s power needs at a much lower cost than Site C.

Calls for construction to be halted were buoyed Wednesday when McCullough, in a review (//www.desmog.ca/2017/09/12/falling-costs-renewable-power-make-site-c-dam- obsolete-says-energy-economist) of Deloitte’s facts and gures, concluded that terminating Site C and building a renewable portfolio of wind and geothermal would save between $700 million and $1.6 billion.

There is no need for Site C to act as a back-up battery for times when wind and solar are unavailable as the Williston Reservoir already has that capacity, the review found.

“It is not nancially prudent to nish the Site C project,” McCullough said at a Vancouver news conference.

“The cost of building a renewable-based portfolio excluding Site C will be much less costly and still meets the province of B.C.’s clean energy goals.”

McCullough was supported by Harry Swain, former chairman of the Site C Joint Review Panel, who said the ndings provide solid proof of what experts have been saying for years.

“B.C. does not need this power and, even if we did, we have lots of less expensive alternatives,” Swain said.

The PVLA and PVEA are calling for an immediate end to “reckless spending” on the dam and Goodings is keeping her ngers crossed that the BCUC has enough information to recommend scrapping the project. information to recommend scrapping the project. DESMOGCA CLEARING THE PR POLLUTION

Her only disappointment is that BCUHCom me embers have not been able to accept an About Us invitation to tour the entire area and, inWshtoe Fuands Uws?ere shown the construction site by BC Editorial Independence Hydro representatives. Donor Transparency Ethics Contact Us Newsletter Sign Up Goodings, who, with Hudson’s Hope Mayor Gwen Johansson, sent an invitation to Utilities Commission panellists to tour the area, said she wanted to show them the surrounding farmland, wildlife habitat and Indigenous sites and how, with the construction, the surrounding land sloughs o (//www.desmog.ca/2016/01/07/impact- site-c-dam-b-c-farmland-far-more-dire-reported-local-farmers-show).

“We’re not only going to lose what’s under the water, but also the land around it,” she said.

An abandoned cabin sits perched on the edge of a cli created by unexpected sloughing (//www.desmog.ca/2016/01/07/impact-site-c-dam-b-c-farmland-far-more-dire-reported-local- farmers-show) along the banks of the Williston Reservoir, created by the W.A.C. Bennett Dam, in 2008. Photo provided to DeSmog

Canada by West Moberly First Nations Chief Roland Willson.

Goodings said, despite her disappointment, she understands the commission’s Goodings said, despite her disappointment, she understands the commission’s DESMOGCA timelines are extremely tight. CLEARING THE PR POLLUTION

Home About Us Utilities Commission chairman David MWohro tFounnds sUsa? id in an e-mailed statement that Editorial Independence panel members and Deloitte representDaotniovr eTrsan svpiasreintcey d the construction site and the Ethics Highway 29 realignment area on AuCgonutasctt U 1s 0 and 11 and received a brieng from BC Hydro’s on-site team, but did not reNceewisvletete rt Shigen U ipnvitation from Goodings and Johansson until later that month.

“This inquiry is working under an extremely tight timeline, so the panel was unable to schedule a second trip to the area,” Morton said.

The B.C. Utilities Commission is looking for feedback from as many British Columbians as possible during upcoming community and First Nations input sessions — including two in Fort St. John and one in Hudson’s Hope, he said.

Meanwhile, Goodings and her colleagues have invited Premier John Horgan and several ministers to come to the Peace River region, but have not yet had a reply.

“We were looking forward to sharing with BCUC a balanced view of the losses which have been minimized by BC Hydro throughout the joint review,” Goodings wrote in a letter to Horgan.

However, even if the ministers are not able to come to the Peace, area representatives are hoping to meet with them during the Union of B.C. Municipalities convention later this month, she said.

Image: Site C construction June 2016. Photo: Garth Lenz | DeSmog Canada

GET WEEKLY NEWS UPDATES SUBSCRIBE

 Share 270  Tweet  Reddit 0  Share 0  Share (mailto:? subject=Check out this story DESMOGCA CLEARING THE PR POLLUTION from DeSmog

Home Canada&body=ht About Us Who Funds Us? tps://www.desmo Editorial Independence Donor Transparency g.ca/2017/09/14/t Ethics erminating-site-c- Contact Us Newsletter Sign Up dam-building- alternatives-save- bc-over-1-billion- economist%0D% 0A%0D%0ATermi nating Site C Dam, Building Alternatives Could Save B.C. Over $1B: Economist)

PRINT (/print/12128) SUBSCRIBE (/newsletter)

‹ PREVIOUS (/2017/09/13/can- NEXT › (/2017/09/14/site-c-test-b-c- emissions-actually-shrink-while- ndp-s-commitment-indigenous- economy-grows) rights)

Can Emissions Actually Shrink While the Economy Site C to Test B.C. NDP’s Commitment to Grows? (/2017/09/13/can-emissions- Indigenous Rights (/2017/09/14/site-c-test- actually-shrink-while-economy-grows) b-c-ndp-s-commitment-indigenous- rights) DESMOGCA DeSmogBlog Comment PolicyCLEARING THE PR POLLUTION Home Civility and substance, folks. Civility andAb osuut bUs tance. Who Funds Us? Editorial Independence  Please read our Comment Policy before coDmonmore Tnratninspgar.ency Ethics Contact Us Newsletter Sign Up