Arxiv:2004.10298V2 [Physics.Atom-Ph] 11 Sep 2020 Far Lower Than in Alkali Atom MOT Setups
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Crossed-Beam slowing to enhance narrow-line Ytterbium Magneto-Optic Traps Benjamin Plotkin-Swing,1 Anna Wirth,1, a) Daniel Gochnauer,1 Tahiyat Rahman,1 Katherine E. McAlpine,1 and Subhadeep Gupta1 Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle WA 98195, USA (Dated: 15 September 2020) We demonstrate a method to enhance the atom loading rate of a ytterbium (Yb) magneto-optic trap (MOT) 1 3 operating on the 556 nm S0 ! P 1 intercombination transition (narrow linewidth Γg = 2π × 182 kHz). 1 1 Following traditional Zeeman slowing of an atomic beam near the 399 nm S0 ! P 1 transition (broad linewidth Γp = 2π × 29 MHz), two laser beams in a crossed-beam geometry, frequency tuned near the same transition, provide additional slowing immediately prior to the MOT. Using this technique, we observe an improvement by a factor of 6 in the atom loading rate of a narrow-line Yb MOT. The relative simplicity and generality of this approach make it readily adoptable to other experiments involving narrow-line MOTs. We also present a numerical simulation of this two-stage slowing process which shows good agreement with the observed dependence on experimental parameters, and use it to assess potential improvements to the method. I. INTRODUCTION neously operated in a core-shell configuration14. While the core-shell scheme combines the higher loading rate of Techniques for laser cooling of alkali atoms developed the broad transition with the lower temperature of the more than three decades ago1 have also been fruitfully narrow transition, it requires two sets of six MOT laser applied to laser cooling of atomic species beyond alkalis beams with the additional complexity of shaping these over the last two decades2{8. New scientific pursuits are beams to produce a \shell" arrangement with 399 nm afforded through the different electronic structure of such light overlapped with a \core" of 556 nm light. non-alkali atoms including optical atomic clocks9 for pre- In this work we demonstrate a method to enhance the cision metrology and strong dipolar interactions for ex- atom loading rate of a narrow-line Yb MOT fed by a plorations of novel many-body phenomena10{12. The dif- Zeeman-slowed atomic beam by introducing only two ad- ferent electronic structure can also lead to optical cycling ditional laser beams on the broad transition. These ad- transitions with linewidths far narrower than their al- ditional beams are oriented in a crossed-beam geometry kali counterparts, leading to opportunities for narrow-line to provide additional slowing immediately prior to the 15 laser cooling and magneto-optical traps (MOTs) with MOT . Using this technique, which is readily adopt- correspondingly lower temperatures due to the reduced able to other atomic species, we observe an improvement limiting value of the Doppler temperature. by a factor of 6 in the MOT loading rate. We also This narrow linewidth however poses a problem for the perform a numerical simulation of this two-stage slow- atom loading rate of a MOT, since the laser cooling force ing process and find good agreement with the observed is proportional to this linewidth. One method to circum- dependence on experimental parameters. We then use vent this problem is to use a second transition with a the simulation to assess potential improvements to the broader linewidth as an intermediate \pre-cooling" MOT crossed-beam slowing technique. stage with protection from the correspondingly higher The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec- Doppler temperature being furnished by separating the tion II we discuss the basic idea of the cooling scheme broad- and narrow-line MOT beams in time3,5. and in Section III present its experimental demonstra- In the case of alkaline-earth-like ytterbium (Yb) atoms, tion. We discuss our numerical model in Section IV and 1 the standard approach has been to use the broad S0 ! present a summary and outlook in Section V. 1 P 1 transition at 399 nm for Zeeman slowing followed by 1 3 a single color MOT using the S0 ! P 1 transition at 556 nm4. This approach is sufficient for MOT produc- II. CROSSED-BEAM SLOWING tion but typically with loading rate and atom number arXiv:2004.10298v2 [physics.atom-ph] 11 Sep 2020 far lower than in alkali atom MOT setups. Good perfor- In order to be captured by a MOT, an atom (i) must mance of narrow-line Yb MOTs has been demonstrated be located within the volume of the MOT beams (diam- by loading it from a 2D MOT operating on the broad eter D) and (ii) must be moving slower than the capture 13 transition using a pushing beam . In another approach, velocity vc of the MOT. A standard method in cold atom a broad-line MOT and a narrow-line MOT were simulta- physics is to use the Zeeman slower technique16 to reduce the forward velocity of atoms in a beam emerging from an oven and bring a large fraction below vc. This method allows for fine tuning of the exit velocity vf of the slowed a)Author to whom correspondence should be addressed: atoms using the current flowing through the electromag- [email protected]. net generating the Zeeman slower field. In traversing the 2 distance d between the end of the Zeeman slower and TABLE I. Wavelength λ, linewidth Γ=2π, Doppler tempera- the MOT beams, the finite transverse velocity vt of the ture TDop, MOT capture velocity vc, recoil velocity vrec, recoil atoms leads to a transverse displacement vt ×d=vf which 2 shift !rec = ¯hk =2m, and saturation intensity Isat for the two needs to be less than D=2 for capture. Yb transitions and, for comparison, the main transition in Rb. There are several mechanical and optical access con- A MOT diameter of 2 cm is used for the calculation of vc. straints common to such setups (see Fig. 1) that lead to Yb Yb Rb 1 3 1 1 2 2 a finite value of d. The slowing laser beam is set to coun- S0 ! P 1 S0 ! P 1 S 1 ! P 3 2 2 terpropagate with the atomic beam, which means that λ (nm) 556 399 780 the beam must pass nearby or through the MOT region. Γ=2π (MHz) 0.182 29 6 To accommodate this close passage, an increasing field TDop (µK) 4.4 696 144 Zeeman slower is usually used so that the slowing beam vc(m/s) 9.7 144 67 detuning is sufficiently large to not affect the atoms in vrec (mm/s) 4.1 5.7 5.9 the MOT. This scheme requires some distance d for the !rec=2π (kHz) 3.7 7.2 3.8 2 magnetic field to decay between the end of the Zeeman Isat (W/m ) 1.38 597 16.5 slower and the MOT region. In addition, the electromag- netic coils at the end of the Zeeman slower are often of p sufficient size that they would block optical access to the we expect vt to scale as Nvr, where N is the number MOT unless they are at least several inches away. In our of scattering events in the Zeeman slower and vr is the recoil velocity. experiment d ' 10 cm, which is a typical value for such q setups. hk¯ g Γg D We can estimate vc ' m , where Γg = 2π × 182 1 3 kHz is the linewidth of the S0 ! P 1 556 nm atomic transition, kg is the corresponding laser wavenumber, and m is the mass of ytterbium. It is clear from this expres- sion that a narrow-line MOT will feature a correspond- ingly small capture velocity vc. For Yb this is 9:7 m/s for D = 2 cm. The transverse velocity is vt ' 1:5 m/s for our system; for an atom traveling at vc, this then converts to a transverse displacement which is larger than D=2. These estimates already suggest that loading a narrow- line Yb MOT with a Zeeman slowed atomic beam is less efficient than with a broad-line MOT as in alkali systems. For comparison, in alkali rubidium (Rb) with a large nat- ural linewidth, vc is almost an order of magnitude larger. See Table I for a summary of characteristics for relevant transitions in Yb as well as Rb. The dual constraint on vc and transverse position on a conventional Zeeman slower is lifted by the addition of FIG. 1. Schematic top-down view of the vacuum chamber with MOT and various slowing beams superimposed. The a second stage of cooling. The crossed beam slower is crossed slowing beams intersect just upstream of the MOT designed to provide a final stage of slowing immediately and provide the final stage of slowing down to below the MOT before the MOT, so that the Zeeman slower exit velocity capture velocity. The distances from the end of the Zeeman vf can be set higher than vc. This allows the condition slower coils to the MOT center and from the center of the vt × d=vf < D to be satisfied for larger values of vt. The crossed beams to the MOT center are denoted by d and dM , crossed beam slower consists of beams near the strong 1 1 respectively. dipole transition ( S0 ! P 1 at 399 nm) that are set to propagate parallel to two of the MOT beams, intersecting Even for an atomic beam that is initially perfectly col- each other in the atomic beam path just upstream of the limated, transverse velocity at the end of the Zeeman MOT, as shown in Fig 1.