A Person-Centered Approach to Understanding Women’S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A PERSON-CENTERED APPROACH TO UNDERSTANDING WOMEN’S DECISION TO FAKE ORGASM ________________________________________________________________________ A Dissertation Submitted to the Temple University Graduate Board ________________________________________________________________________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY ________________________________________________________________________ by Erin B. Cooper, M.A. August 2014 Examining Committee Members: Robert Fauber, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Temple University Deborah Drabick, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Temple University Richard Heimberg, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Temple University Tania Giovannetti, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Temple University Lauren Alloy, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Temple University Marsha Weinraub, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Temple University ii © Copyright 2013 by Erin B. Cooper All Rights Reserved iii ABSTRACT Studies suggest that nearly two-thirds of women fake or have faked orgasm, yet few researchers have explicitly examined this phenomenon. Previous studies have identified some group differences between women who fake orgasm and those do not on dimensions of sexual experience, emotion regulation, intimacy, relationship status, and sexual functioning. To date, research into this phenomenon has relied solely on variable-centered analyses (e.g., exploratory factor analysis, correlation, and regression). This study used a person-centered approach (i.e., latent class analysis; LCA) to explore differences in women’s motives across individuals, using scores from the Faking Orgasm Scale for Women. A 5-class model was determined to be most interpretable and the best fitting to the data. Classes included low, moderate, and high frequency faking orgasm, partner-focused faking orgasm, and pleasure-focused faking orgasm. These classes were then compared on dimensions of sexual functioning, intimacy, and emotion regulation, as well as demographic variables (e.g., age, length of relationship, number of sexual partners). Significant differences were found in sexual desire, sexual activity, and orgasmic consistency, but not in sexual satisfaction. Significant differences were also evidenced in intimacy, general level of emotion dysregulation, and across various dimensions of emotion regulation. No differences across classes were revealed on age, length of relationship, or number of sexual partners. These findings can serve as the foundation for further exploration into understanding women’s various styles of interacting sexually with a partner and may have implications for couples therapy, sex therapy, and individual interventions for women struggling with physical and/or emotional intimacy with a partner. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AND DEDICATION I would like to thank all of my family, friends, colleagues, and mentors who supported me throughout this project and my career. Specifically, I wish to acknowledge my fiancé Dan Carter, and my parents Victoria Cooper, Billy Joe Cooper, and Belinda Cooper, without whom this work would not have been possible. I want to recognize Allan Fenigstein and Michael Levine for their support and encouragement in the earliest stages of this research. I would also like to thank Robert Fauber, Richard Heimberg, Deborah Drabick, Lauren Alloy, Tania Giovannetti, and Marsha Weinraub for their feedback and guidance on the project. This study is dedicated to my mother. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AND DEDICATION ............................................................ iv LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................ vii LIST OF FIGURES ......................................................................................................... viii CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 9 Conceptualizing Female Orgasm ............................................................................ 9 Female Orgasmic Experience ............................................................................... 12 Importance of Orgasm in Sexual Satisfaction ...................................................... 13 Fake Orgasm ......................................................................................................... 14 Motives for Faking Orgasm .................................................................................. 17 Emotions Potentially Associated with Faking Orgasm ........................................ 19 Potential Influence of Relationship on Faking Orgasm ........................................ 23 Present Study ........................................................................................................ 25 Aim 1: Define Classes .............................................................................. 26 Aim 2: Demographic Differences between Classes .................................. 27 Aim 3: Group Differences between Classes on Sexual Functioning, Intimacy, and Emotion Regulation ........................................................... 27 2. METHOD ..................................................................................................................... 28 Participants ............................................................................................................ 28 Sampling Procedures ................................................................................ 28 Measures ............................................................................................................... 28 Demographic Information ......................................................................... 28 Sexual History, Behavior, & Faking Orgasm ........................................... 29 Intimacy .................................................................................................... 31 Emotion Regulation .................................................................................. 32 Sexual Functioning ................................................................................... 33 Data Analytic Plan ................................................................................................ 34 Sample size/power analysis ...................................................................... 36 vi 3. RESULTS ..................................................................................................................... 37 Latent Class Analysis ............................................................................................ 37 Model Fit ................................................................................................... 37 Interpreting Latent Classes ....................................................................... 39 Model Selection ........................................................................................ 43 Group Differences ................................................................................................. 43 Demographic Variables ............................................................................ 43 Sexual Functioning ................................................................................... 44 Intimacy .................................................................................................... 48 Emotion Regulation .................................................................................. 50 4. DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................... 53 Strengths and Limitations ..................................................................................... 57 Conclusions and Clinical Implications ................................................................. 58 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................. 60 APPENDICES – Self-Report Measures ........................................................................... 66 Appendix A: Demographics Information ............................................................. 67 Appendix B: Faking Orgasm Scale for Women ................................................... 71 Appendix C: Miller Social Intimacy Scale ........................................................... 81 Appendix D: Fear of Intimacy Scale .................................................................... 83 Appendix E: Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale ........................................ 88 Appendix F: Brief Index of Sexual Functioning for Women ............................... 90 vii LIST OF TABLES Table Page 1. Fit indices for LCA models with 1 - 6 classes .............................................................37 2. Means and standard errors for class differences across demographic variables ..........43 3. Chi-square values, means, and standard errors for class differences in sexual functioning ......................................................................................................................................44 4. Chi-square values, means, and standard errors for class differences in orgasmic consistency ......................................................................................................................................46 5. Chi-square values,