What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title This is (Not) What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/80z6106p Author Schradie, Jennifer Anne Publication Date 2014 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California This is (Not) What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism By Jennifer Anne Schradie A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology and the Designated Emphasis in New Media in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Kim Voss, Chair Professor Claude Fischer Professor Abigail DeKosnik Fall 2014 Abstract This is (Not) What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism by Jennifer Anne Schradie Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology University of California, Berkeley Professor Kim Voss, Chair This dissertation addresses longstanding sociological questions about organizational democracy in the context of contemporary advances in digital technology. To date, most of the scholarship on digital activism suggests that the Internet enables social movements to be less hierarchical, more participatory, and more egalitarian. However, such claims are weakened by researchers’ tendency to study only high levels of digital activism, rather than investigating digital practices across a range of organizations with differing levels of digital engagement. In contrast, I explore political, labor and social movement organizations across an entire political field. My units of analysis are the 34 groups in North Carolina active on both sides of a political issue: public employee collective bargaining rights. The organizations range from Tea Parties to rank-and-file labor unions and from conservative think tanks to progressive coalitions. I collected data on over 60,000 Tweets, Facebook posts and Web site metrics of the organizations. I then created an index to measure the extent of digital engagement of each group, and I developed a typology of online social movement activities and platforms. An analysis using this index indicates that rather than digital technologies simply shaping social movements, I find that social movement organizational differences affect Internet use. Groups that are more hierarchical, conservative, reformist and composed of middle and upper class members are much more likely to have higher digital activism levels than less hierarchical, progressive, radical and working class organizations. Using in-depth interviews, ethnographic observations, and content analysis, I also uncover the mechanisms of these digital differences. First, contrary to the literature that suggests that digital activism is tied to non-hierarchical groups, I find that groups that are more hierarchical and bureaucratic have the infrastructure to develop and maintain online organizational engagement. Next, rather than the typical image of the digital activist as a left-wing radical, the highest digital activism levels are among right-wing groups because of what I call their organizing ideology: their ideas and practices of liberty and spreading the truth align with their Internet use. In turn, reformist groups embrace the Internet to reach those in power in their lobbying efforts while radical groups simply treat digital technology as one of many tools for mass organizing, resulting in lower digital activism levels. Finally, digital activism is not an egalitarian participatory space due to low costs of entry because of a social class gap, which derives from the high costs of online participation, as well as power and entitlement differences between working-class and middle-to-upper class groups. This study demonstrates that the Internet does not render obsolete sociological theories of collective action, oligarchy, and stratification. Instead, this research points to how ideology, hierarchy and inequality shape Internet use, challenging the theories of digital democracy. 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ii CHAPTER ONE: 1 Introduction—What is the Relationship Between Organizational Democracy and Internet Use? CHAPTER TWO: 16 North Carolina as a Context for Action Around Collective Bargaining CHAPTER THREE: 23 Organizational Factors Shape Digital Activist Scores CHAPTER FOUR: 36 Iron Law 2.0—Bringing the Organization Back into Digital Activism CHAPTER FIVE 48 Organizing Ideology—Patriots, Radicals, Unions and Reformers CHAPTER SIX 66 The Digital Activism Gap—Social Class, Social Media, Social Movements CHAPTER SEVEN 77 Conclusion—Digital Activism in a Societal Context REFERENCES 83 APPENDIX 92 i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am grateful for all of the support I received along this dissertation path. Thank you to the following funders, especially the committee members and staff who made the grants possible: The National Science Foundation Doctoral Dissertation Improvement Grant (NSF DDIG SES-1203716), the Jacob K. Javits Fellowship, the Mike Synar Fellowship from the Berkeley Institute of Governmental Studies, the Peter Lyman Graduate Fellowship in New Media, Student Research and Travel Grants from the Department of Sociology, University of California, Berkeley, and the Berkeley New Media Summer Research Fellowship. I am truly indebted and grateful to Kim Voss, my dissertation adviser, who early on in my graduate career encouraged my intellectual curiosity and passion. She mentors with a unique balance of intellectual rigor, conceptual guidance and personal encouragement. Kim made time for lively dissertation dinners, last minute help on letters of recommendation, and multiple draft feedback. From my first day of class with her, I knew I had found a lifetime mentor. Thank you, Kim, for helping me keep my eyes on the prize. I also want to thank Claude Fischer, another dissertation committee member, for his no-nonsense, practical and astute guidance on my writing, in particular, and scholarship, in general. He does not overpraise, underpraise, or ignore. He is very unassuming and straightforward, and that is what makes him a fantastic mentor. His writing guidance is unparalleled while also managing to help me see the big picture and frame my work sociologically. Abigail DeKosnik was a critical dissertation adviser in my understanding of how new media theories mesh, and sometimes clash, with sociological theories. Her brilliance as a theorist guided me throughout my graduate career, and her professional advice has been enormously helpful. Other Berkeley sociology faculty members have been important advisers along the way. I want to express my appreciation to Michael Burawoy helping me early on map out the big picture of my research, Cihan Tugal for his theoretical guidance, especially in untangling Gramsci for me, Sam Lucas for arming me with a broad grasp of the stratification field, Mike Hout for his enthusiasm for my digital studies and for his statistical and Stata support, and Cristina Mora for her insightful writing critiques. Invaluable to my dissertation, and sociology graduate school experience, were an incredible group of graduate students at UC Berkeley. My dissertation group—Nick Adams, Pablo Gaston and Laura Nelson asked the hard, probing questions, as well as provided detailed copyediting, all with great humor and grace. In the final writing stage, I found new insight to my project from Berkeley Connect graduate students: Graham Hill, Ana Villareal, Kara Young, and, again, Pablo Gaston. My gratitude also goes out to Siri Colom, who walked, jogged and ran with me to the finish line. It is difficult to limit the list of graduate students who have helped me the past seven years, whether with funding applications, data analysis, and copyediting or with a patient ear, a union protest, and a cold beer. Many thanks to Lindsay Bayham, Jenny Carlson, Jessica Cobb, Sarah Garrett, Adam Goldstein, Pat Hastings, Katy Fox-Hodess, Shannon Ikebe, Daniel Laurinson, Zachary Levenson, Roi Livne, Sarah McDonald, Manuel Rosaldo, and Tamera Lee Stover. My special thanks are extended to the staff of the UC Berkeley Department of Sociology who guided me through the bureaucratic intricacies of registration, funding and filing. Thank you Carolyn Clark, Anne Meyer, and Belinda White. ii I am also indebted to faculty at UC Berkeley outside of the Sociology Department who opened up an indispensable window into the Information, Communication and Technology world. In addition to committee member Abigail DeKosnik, Coye Cheshire taught me how to take my ideas and shape them into robust analysis, and Jenna Burrell gave me ethnography tools for the fuzzy areas between online and offline spaces. The Berkeley Center for New Media (BCNM) was a second intellectual home to me on campus. More than just providing office space, BCNM created collegiality and collaboration. I want to thank faculty Ken Goldberg, Greg Niemeyer, and David Bates. I am particularly grateful to the BCNM students who made my writing and theorizing so much better with their comraderie: Alenda Chang, Kris Fallon, Ashley Ferro-Murray, Andrew Godbehere, Chris Goetz, Caitlin Marshall, Tiffany Ng, and Margaret Ree. Thanks also to BCNM staff: Nora Liddell Bok, Lara Markstein, and Susan Miller. The enormous data collection and content analysis of this dissertation could also not have been completed without the assistance of an inspiring crew
Recommended publications
  • Deborah Schiffrin Editor
    Meaning, Form, and Use in Context: Linguistic Applications Deborah Schiffrin editor Meaning, Form, and Use in Context: Linguistic Applications Deborah Schiffrin editor Georgetown University Press, Washington, D.C. 20057 BIBLIOGRAPHIC NOTICE Since this series has been variously and confusingly cited as: George- town University Monographic Series on Languages and Linguistics, Monograph Series on Languages and Linguistics, Reports of the Annual Round Table Meetings on Linguistics and Language Study, etc., beginning with the 1973 volume, the title of the series was changed. The new title of the series includes the year of a Round Table and omits both the monograph number and the meeting number, thus: Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics 1984, with the regular abbreviation GURT '84. Full bibliographic references should show the form: Kempson, Ruth M. 1984. Pragmatics, anaphora, and logical form. In: Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics 1984. Edited by Deborah Schiffrin. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press. 1-10. Copyright (§) 1984 by Georgetown University Press All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America Library of Congress Catalog Number: 58-31607 ISBN 0-87840-119-9 ISSN 0196-7207 CONTENTS Welcoming Remarks James E. Alatis Dean, School of Languages and Linguistics vii Introduction Deborah Schiffrin Chair, Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics 1984 ix Meaning and Use Ruth M. Kempson Pragmatics, anaphora, and logical form 1 Laurence R. Horn Toward a new taxonomy for pragmatic inference: Q-based and R-based implicature 11 William Labov Intensity 43 Michael L. Geis On semantic and pragmatic competence 71 Form and Function Sandra A.
    [Show full text]
  • Examination of the Use of Online and Offline Networks by Housing Social Movement Organizations
    University of Kentucky UKnowledge Theses and Dissertations--Sociology Sociology 2013 Examination of the Use of Online and Offline Networksy b Housing Social Movement Organizations Jessica N. Kropczynski University of Kentucky, [email protected] Right click to open a feedback form in a new tab to let us know how this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Kropczynski, Jessica N., "Examination of the Use of Online and Offline Networksy b Housing Social Movement Organizations" (2013). Theses and Dissertations--Sociology. 11. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/sociology_etds/11 This Doctoral Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Sociology at UKnowledge. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations--Sociology by an authorized administrator of UKnowledge. For more information, please contact [email protected]. STUDENT AGREEMENT: I represent that my thesis or dissertation and abstract are my original work. Proper attribution has been given to all outside sources. I understand that I am solely responsible for obtaining any needed copyright permissions. I have obtained and attached hereto needed written permission statements(s) from the owner(s) of each third-party copyrighted matter to be included in my work, allowing electronic distribution (if such use is not permitted by the fair use doctrine). I hereby grant to The University of Kentucky and its agents the non-exclusive license to archive and make accessible my work in whole or in part in all forms of media, now or hereafter known. I agree that the document mentioned above may be made available immediately for worldwide access unless a preapproved embargo applies.
    [Show full text]
  • Media, Protest and Resistance in Authoritarian Contexts Media, Protest and Resistance in Authoritarian Contexts
    APSA 2020 WORKING CONFERENCE PAPER Hashemi – Media, Protest and Resistance in Authoritarian Contexts Media, Protest and Resistance in Authoritarian Contexts Layla M. Hashemi, Ph.D. Public Policy George Mason University, 2020 [email protected] laymay.com Abstract Information communication technologies (ICTs) facilitate transnational connection, coordination and collaboration, which are essential for new social movements. At the same time, issues of access and censorship hinder social movement use of social media for mobilization. This paper examines how internet technology is used by social movements to discuss issues of identity, dignity and justice and to contest gender-based discriminatory laws. Through subtle everyday acts of protests, women contest state narratives by documenting their presence in both physical and virtual public spaces. Iranian women practice the art of presence, demonstrating social media activism’s ability to circumvent censorship and facilitate public discourse regarding controversial issues under repressive contexts. This study collects and analyzes data from Twitter and other social networking platforms to investigate the evolution of digital campaigns and relates these cases to the long-standing tradition of Iranian women’s voices with a focus on the critical role of the camera and user generated content in art and daily life. Keywords: social movements; social media; internet studies; information communication technology; computational social science; Iran; gender; human rights DRAFT WORKING PAPER Prepared for the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, September 2020 1 “Where there is power there is resistance” - Michel Foucault Information communication technologies (ICTs) facilitate transnational connection, coordination and collaboration, which are essential for new social movements. At the same time, issues of access and censorship hinder social movement use of social media for mobilization.
    [Show full text]
  • Slacktivists Or Activists?: Identity Work in the Virtual Disability March
    Slacktivists or Activists?: Identity Work in the Virtual Disability March Hanlin Li 1, 2 , Disha Bora 1 , Sagar Salvi 1 , Erin Brady 1 1 IUPUI, Indianapolis, USA, 2 Northwestern University, Evanston, USA [email protected], {dishbora, salvis, brady}@iupui.edu ABSTRACT Protests are important social forms of activism, but can be inaccessible to people with disabilities. Online activism, like the 2017 Disability March, has provided alternative venues for involvement in accessible protesting and social movements. In this study, we use identity theory as a lens to understand why and how disabled activists engaged in an online movement, and its impact on their self-concepts. We interviewed 18 disabled activists about their experiences with online protesting during the Disability March. Respondents’ identities (as both disabled individuals and as activists) led them to organize or join the March, evolved alongside the group’s actions, and were reprioritized or Figure 1: A poster held at an in-person march recognizing strained as a result of their involvement. Our findings people with disabilities who could not attend. Posted on describe the values and limitations of this activism to our Facebook; used with permission. respondents, highlight the tensions they perceived about discrimination against people with disabilities when they their activist identities, and present opportunities to support apply for or use federal services. further accessibility and identity changes by integrating technology into their activist experiences. However, in-person activism remains inaccessible for many people with disabilities. Activities such as marches, rallies, Author Keywords and town hall meetings often introduce environmental, Social media; activism; accessibility; identity theory.
    [Show full text]
  • A Language for Concurrent Disributed Programming for Cluster and GRID
    Russian Academy of Sciences Program Systems Institute MC#: a Language for Concurrent Disributed Programming for Cluster and GRID Architectures Introduction Novel Constructs of MC#: Movable Methods, Channels, and Handlers MC# is a high-level object-oriented programming language based on the .NET platform created for developing complex industrial software systems Movable methods are the methods that can be scheduled for execution on intended for running on multiprocessor architectures. remote machines. Such methods in the code are labeled with the special In contrast with the wide-spread MPI (Message Passing Interface) appro- keyword movable; for example: ach in MC# programs there is no need to movable Compute( int x, double y ){ (a) explicitly manage the distribution of computational processes over // method body cluster nodes or GRID machines, and } There are two forms of calling movable methods: (b) manually program the serialization of complex objects (data) for send- ing them to another processors. ! object.method( arguments ) — in this case the node where movable method will be executed is scheduled by the runtime system, The MC# language is the adaptation of the base idea of the Polyphonic C# language (nowadays also known as Cw — Benton N., Cardelli L., Fournet ! [email protected]( arguments ) — explicit indication of node C., Microsoft Research Laboratory, Cambridge, UK) for the case of con- where this method must be executed. current distributed computations. Channels and handlers are tools for interaction among distributed obj- Asynchronous methods of Polyphonic C# in the MC# language can be ects. Typically, they are defined with the chord construct as in the follow- scheduled for execution on other machines in two ways: ing example where channel sendInt for sending single integers and cor- responding handler are declared: ! automatically (typically a machine with the least workload is taken); ! manually through explicit indication by a programmer.
    [Show full text]
  • New Doc 2018-11-09 13.48.56
    Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Scanned by CamScanner Seminar Nasional Informatika 2013 (semnasIF 2013) ISSN: 1979-2328 UPN ”Veteran” Yogyakarta, 18 Mei 2013 SISTEM PENCARIAN FORUM BERBASIS ONTOLOGI DAN LABEL Adi Wibowo1), Gregorius Satiabudhi2) , Yulius Pranata3) 1,2,3)Program Studi Teknik Informatika Universitas Kristen Petra Surabaya Jl. Siwalankerto 121-131 Surabaya Telp (031)-2983455 e-mail : 1) [email protected], 2) [email protected] Abstrak Salah satu kegiatan yang sering dilakukan pengguna internet adalah berdiskusi melalui sebuah forum. Setiap forum terbagi ke dalam beberapa kategori, dan setiap kategori memiliki beberapa percakapan (thread). Setiap percakapan dapat diberi label (tag) baik oleh pengguna yang membuka percakapan tersebut, atau peserta forum. Masalah yang muncul adalah bila sebuah forum telah menjadi besar mencari percakapan yang tepat yang sesuai kebutuhan pengguna menjadi lebih sulit. Penelitian ini bertujuan mengusulkan metode rekomendasi percakapan di sebuah forum internet yang menggunakan label dan didukung oleh ontologi yang sesuai dengan kategori percakapan.Penelitian ini mengkhususkan pada forum dengan kategori teknologi komputer. Forum tersebut adalah StackOverflow. Pada setiap percakapan pada forum tersebut terdapat label-label yang menjelaskan isi percakapan, misalnya C#, recursive, programming, dll. Label-label tersebut dikembangkan (diperbanyak) menggunakan ontologi komputer. Hasilnya adalah setiap percakapan akan diwakili oleh label- label asli dari StackOverflow, dan ditambah dengan label-label baru yang berasal dari ontologi. Label-label tersebut digunakan dalam proses pencarian berbasis Vector Space Model (VSM).Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa penggunaan ontologi sebagai metode keyword extension meningkatkan nilai recall dari metode VSM tersebut.
    [Show full text]
  • Concurrency Expression in High-Level Languages, Best Practice and Amenability to H/W Compilation
    Concurrency expression in high-level languages, Best practice and amenability to h/w compilation. (povocative statements for BoF Panel Discussion !) David Greaves University of Cambridge Computer Laboratory [email protected] [email protected] Field Programmable Logic and Applications (FPL) 2nd September 2014, Munich. Parallel Programming Disciplines ➲ Hardware is parallel (massively). ➲ Software must go parallel owing to end of clock frequency growth. ➲ Hardware is software is hardware – we need (an) effective expression language(s) amenable to codesign. So: three classes of parallelism: ● 1. Embarrassingly parallel – no control or data interaction between strands. ● 2. Stream processing – pipelined parallelism – great if there are no control hazards. ● 3. General, fine-grained parallel programming! [email protected] Field Programmable Logic and Applications (FPL) 2nd September 2014, Munich. Eager versus Lazy Dichotomy ➲ Separating control and data flows often mooted: ● It is the key enabler for 'Spatial Computing' ● `A New Dataflow Compiler IR for Accelerating Control- Intensive Code in Spatial Hardware' A M Zaidi and DJ Greaves @ IPDPS'14. ● But why are people happier with OCAML than Haskell ? General purpose language must keep them quite close together – e.g. call-by-value in ML/Java/C etc.. [email protected] Field Programmable Logic and Applications (FPL) 2nd September 2014, Munich. Von Neumann Imperative Parallelism ➲ Shared-memory imperative programming is stupid – how have we got there? ➲ Using strongly typed C/C++/C# we can compile pointers and abstract data struc- tures quite safely. ➲ But aliasing problem restricts available par- allelism (w.r.t. critical ALU path) by: ● Factor of 100 by conservative static analysis ● Factor of < 10 in reality (Jonathan Mak's PhD).
    [Show full text]
  • Event-Driven Analysis of Crowd Dynamics in the Black Lives Matter Online Social Movement Hao Peng Ceren Budak Daniel M
    Event-Driven Analysis of Crowd Dynamics in the Black Lives Matter Online Social Movement Hao Peng Ceren Budak Daniel M. Romero University of Michigan University of Michigan University of Michigan [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT Previous research studied various OSMs such as the 2010 Arab Online social movements (OSMs) play a key role in promoting Spring [28], the 2011 Egyptian Revolution [41, 50], the 2011 Occupy democracy in modern society. Most online activism is largely driven Wall Street [9, 20], through the lens of social media, mainly Twit- by critical offline events. Among many studies investigating collec- ter [2, 3, 22, 32, 40]. Topics they investigated range from participant tive behavior in OSMs, few has explored the interaction between motivation [44], movement framing [24, 43], informal learning [20], crowd dynamics and their offline context. Here, focusing on the to information diffusion [22, 28, 41]. There are also studies focus- Black Lives Matter OSM and utilizing an event-driven approach ing on crowd behavior in OSMs. Subjects they examined include on a dataset of 36 million tweets and thousands of offline events, recruitment process [23], user engagement [6, 9, 40], and online we study how different types of offline events—police violence and interactions [34], as well as the temporal evolution of crowd be- heightened protests—influence crowd behavior over time. We find havior [2, 4, 9, 11, 48]. Although these studies focus on different that police violence events and protests play important roles in the OSMs that were driven by very different political agendas, most of recruitment process.
    [Show full text]
  • Not) What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism By
    This is (Not) What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism By Jennifer Anne Schradie A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology and the Designated Emphasis in New Media in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Kim Voss, Chair Professor Claude Fischer Professor Abigail DeKosnik Fall 2014 Abstract This is (Not) What Democracy Looks Like: How Ideology, Hierarchy and Inequality Shape Digital Activism by Jennifer Anne Schradie Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology University of California, Berkeley Professor Kim Voss, Chair This dissertation addresses longstanding sociological questions about organizational democracy in the context of contemporary advances in digital technology. To date, most of the scholarship on digital activism suggests that the Internet enables social movements to be less hierarchical, more participatory, and more egalitarian. However, such claims are weakened by researchers’ tendency to study only high levels of digital activism, rather than investigating digital practices across a range of organizations with differing levels of digital engagement. In contrast, I explore political, labor and social movement organizations across an entire political field. My units of analysis are the 34 groups in North Carolina active on both sides of a political issue: public employee collective bargaining rights. The organizations range from Tea Parties to rank-and-file labor unions and from conservative think tanks to progressive coalitions. I collected data on over 60,000 Tweets, Facebook posts and Web site metrics of the organizations. I then created an index to measure the extent of digital engagement of each group, and I developed a typology of online social movement activities and platforms.
    [Show full text]
  • Algorithmic Music Analysis: a Case Study of a Prelude from David Cope's
    ALGORITHMIC MUSIC ANALYSIS: A C ASE STUDY OF A PRELUDE FROM DAVID COPE’S “FROM DARKNESS, LIGHT” Reiner Krämer, B.M., M.M. Dissertation Prepar ed for the Degree of DOCTOR OF P HILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS May 2015 APPROVED: David Bard-Schwarz, Major Professor Andrew May, Minor Professor Thomas Sovík, Committee Member Frank Heidlberger, Chair of the Department of Music History, Theory, and Ethnomusicology Benjamin Brand, Director of Graduate Studies James C. Scott, Dean of the College of Music Costas Tsatsoulis, Interim Dean of the Toulouse Graduate School Krämer, Reiner. Algorithmic Music Analysis: A Case Study of a Prelude from David Cope’s “From Darkness, Light.” Doctor of Philosophy (Music Theory), May 2015, 433 pp., 16 tables, 57 figures, 125 examples, bibliography, 278 titles. The use of algorithms in compositional practice has been in use for centuries. With the advent of computers, formalized procedures have become an important part of computer music. David Cope is an American composer that has pioneered systems that make use of artificial intelligence programming techniques. In this dissertation one of David Cope’s compositions that was generated with one of his processes is examined in detail. A general timeline of algorithmic compositional practice is outlined from a historical perspective, and realized in the Common Lisp programming language as a musicological tool. David Cope’s compositional output is summarized with an explanation of what types of systems he has utilized in the analyses of other composers’ music, and the composition of his own music. Twentieth century analyses techniques are formalized within Common Lisp as algorithmic analyses tools.
    [Show full text]
  • Progressive Social Movements and the Internet - Oxford Reference
    2/12/2020 Progressive Social Movements and the Internet - Oxford Reference The Oxford Encyclopedia of Communication and Critical Cultural Studies Edited by Dana L. Cloud Publisher: Oxford University Press Print Publication Date: 2019 Print ISBN-13: 9780190459611 Published online: 2019 Current Online Version: 2019 eISBN: 9780190459635 Progressive Social Movements and the Internet Social Movements in Communication Studies Communication scholars have offered significant insight and provocation to the study of social movements. The praxis that results from the application of critical theory to the study of communication and social change allows scholars to document the role of rhetoric, symbols, media, and other communicative tools in social control, stagnation, protest, and revolution (Bowers, Ochs, Jensen, & Schulz, 2009). Early scholars of critical theory including Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno of the Frankfurt School highlighted the way economic and political elites control and limit the terms of debate in the public sphere through control of language and media (Boikos, Moutsoulas, & Tsekeris, 2014; Durham & Kellner, 2009). These scholars observed that communication plays a central role in the cultural and political hegemony that prevents the masses from collectively overthrowing those in power. Through dominant communication and the resulting naturalization of dominant ideologies, the masses consent to social hierarchies and inequalities. While this work draws heavily from Karl Marx’s 19th-century observations of class exploitation and Antonio Gramsci’s subsequent theorizations of cultural hegemony, they continue to be applied by communication scholars to understand a range of questions related to power and inequality in late-capitalist societies. Critical communication scholars also highlight the potentials of political resistance made possible through communication and developed analytical frameworks for theorizing power and counterpower.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Social Media During Social Movements – Observations from the #Metoo Debate on Twitter
    Proceedings of the 53rd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences | 2020 The Role of Social Media during Social Movements – Observations from the #metoo Debate on Twitter Felix Brünker Magdalena Wischnewski Milad Mirbabaie Judith Meinert University of Duisburg-Essen University of Duisburg-Essen University of Duisburg-Essen University of Duisburg-Essen [email protected] magdalena.wischnewski@ [email protected] [email protected] uni-due.de Abstract and the role of specific actors within these movements [38]. However, these pieces have so far not been put In recent years, the development of information together. Less is known about the specific content that communication technologies (ICT) such as social is shared by specific user groups. Yet, to broaden the media changed the way people communicate and understanding of social movements on social media, it engage in social movements. While conventional is crucial to understand the dynamics of movements were fought in the streets, social media communication among distinct groups participating in enabled movements to take place online. In this paper, a social movement on social media. we aim to investigate the role of social media during We, therefore, examined one recent example of social movements which evolve online. Specifically, we such a social movement, that is the #metoo movement. examined Twitter communication during the #metoo We investigated which kinds of user roles were debate. To this end, we applied methods from social involved in sharing and publishing tweets related to the network analysis to identify influential users hashtag #metoo during the time from September 30, to participating during the debate.
    [Show full text]