University of South Florida Scholar Commons
Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School
10-19-2015 Millennial-scale Variability of a Major East Antarctic Outlet Glacier during the Last Glaciation Michelle Guitard University of South Florida, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the Geology Commons
Scholar Commons Citation Guitard, Michelle, "Millennial-scale Variability of a Major East Antarctic Outlet Glacier during the Last Glaciation" (2015). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/5957
This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected].
Millennial-scale Variability of a Major East Antarctic Outlet Glacier during the Last
Glaciation
by
Michelle E. Guitard
A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Marine Science with a concentration in Geological Oceanography College of Marine Science University of South Florida
Major Professor: Amelia E. Shevenell, Ph.D. Eugene W. Domack, Ph.D. Brad E. Rosenheim, Ph.D.
Date of Approval: November 3, 2015
Keywords: Amery Ice Shelf, radiocarbon, cosmogenic beryllium-10, millennial-scale variability
Copyright © 2015, Michelle E. Guitard
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I want to say a huge thank you to those who helped and supported me through my
Masters degree. Thank you to my major advisor, Amelia Shevenell, who works so hard for her students. She inspires me to work hard and to always keep learning. Thank you to my committee members, Brad Rosenheim and Eugene Domack, for their insight and guidance on this project.
Thank you also to Amy Leventer at Colgate University, and Yusuke Yokoyama and his lab at the
Atmosphere and Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo for their mentorship in the laboratory and in the field. Thank you to the Australian researchers who have devoted their time to investigating the Prydz Bay region and for their scientific collaboration. Thank you to the crew and support staff aboard the Research Vessels Nathaniel B. Palmer and Aurora Australis for their assistance on cruises NBP01-01, AA-186, and KROCK. Thank you to the faculty, staff and students of the Paleo Lab at the College of Marine Science for making the lab experience a great one. Last, but certainly not least, thank you to my friends and family who have supported me through the triumphs and the tears. Your love and support mean the world to me.
!
TABLE OF CONTENTS
List of Tables ...... iii
List of Figures ...... iv
Abstract ...... v
Introduction ...... 1 Background ...... 1 Study Location ...... 2
Methods ...... 8 Physical Properties Analyses ...... 8 Development of Marine Composite Depth Scale ...... 8 Ramped Pyrolysis Preparation for Radiocarbon Analysis ...... 8 Radiocarbon Analysis, Correction and Calibration ...... 9 Beryllium-10 Preparation ...... 9
Results and Discussion ...... 11 Physical Properties ...... 11 Radiocarbon ...... 11 Beryllium-10 ...... 12 Regional Glacial and Oceanic Fluctuations: Timing and Variability ...... 14
Conclusions ...... 17
References ...... 18
Appendix A: Extended Data ...... 22 Extended Data Figure 1 ...... 22 Extended Data Figure 2 ...... 23 Extended Data Table 1 ...... 24 Extended Data Table 2 ...... 26 Extended Data Table 3 ...... 27 Extended Data Table 4 ...... 28
Appendix B: Supplementary Methods ...... 29 Radiocarbon Contamination Correction ...... 29 Calibration ...... 31 Beryllium-10 Concentration Corrections ...... 31
! i Beryllium-10 Budget Estimates ...... 32
Appendix C: Supplementary Discussion ...... 34 Diatom Assemblages ...... 34
Appendices References ...... 36
!
! ii
LIST OF TABLES
Extended Data Table 1: Percent diatom abundance (%abundance) from NBP01-01 JPC-34, -35, and -36 SMO units ...... 24
Extended Data Table 2: Prydz Channel 14C and cal BP ages, δ 13C, and %TOC ...... 26
Extended Data Table 3: NBP01-01 ramped pyrolysis 14C ages, RP temperature range, uncorrected and corrected Fm values ...... 27
Extended Data Table 4: Aliquot weight, uncorrected and corrected 10Be abundance with associated error, and flux for NBP01-01 cores ...... 28
! !
!
! iii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Prydz Channel, East Antarctica, depicting multibeam swath bathymetry, core locations ...... 5
Figure 2: NBP01-01 core stratigraphy, magnetic susceptibility (MS), % diatom abundance, 10Be concentration ([10Be]) alongside Prydz Channel composite MS and radiocarbon (14C) ages ...... 6
Figure 3: Improved acid insoluble organic matter (AIOM) radiocarbon (14C) ages derived from the ramped pyrolysis (RP) technique ...... 7
Figure 4: Oceanic and climatic millennial-scale variability ...... 16
Extended Data Figure 1: Down-section NBP01-01, AA-186, and KROCK core lithology and normalized magnetic susceptibility data ...... 22
Extended Data Figure 2: Uncorrected Beryllium-10 concentration (10Be), Total Organic Carbon (TOC), and δ13C for NBP01-01 cores ...... 23
!
iv
ABSTRACT
Ongoing retreat of Antarctica’s marine-based glaciers is associated with warm (~2° C) modified Circumpolar Deep Water intrusion onto the continental shelf, suggesting that Southern
Ocean temperatures may influence Antarctic ice sheet stability. Understanding past cryosphere response to environmental forcing is crucial to modeling future ice sheet behavior. Of particular interest is the response of the East Antarctic Ice Sheet (EAIS), which stands to contribute ~20 m to global sea level. However, marine sediment sequences recording timing and variability of
EAIS fluctuations through the last major climate shift, the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), are either missing from the margin or have poor chronological control. Here we present three marine sediment cores that contain a record of pre-LGM fluctuations of the marine-based Lambert
Glacier-Amery Ice Shelf (LG-AIS) system into Prydz Channel, East Antarctica. Analyses of core lithology, physical properties, cosmogenic nuclide concentration and diatom assemblage demonstrate that Prydz Channel was characterized by alternating open-marine and sub-shelf deposition, implying repeated LG-AIS fluctuations through the LGM. Our radiocarbon chronology demonstrates that LG-AIS fluctuations occurred on millennial timescales. Our record corroborates regional marine and terrestrial records, which demonstrate millennial scale variability in Antarctic Circumpolar Current strength, ice-rafted debris deposition, sea ice extent,
Antarctic atmospheric temperature, and Southern Ocean sea surface temperature. This evidence suggests that the EAIS was sensitive to sub-orbital climate forcing in the past, and has implications for modeling future EAIS behavior.
!
! v
INTRODUCTION
Background
The response of Antarctica’s ice sheets to ongoing atmosphere and ocean warming is the largest uncertainty in future sea level rise projections. Whereas much has been learned about the impact of warming on the marine-based West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS)1,2, recent observations of East Antarctic Ice Sheet (EAIS) outlet glacier retreat suggest that this ice sheet, with its 19.2 meters of marine-based sea level equivalent, may also respond sensitively to abrupt climate perturbations, including the warm ocean waters presently destabilizing the WAIS3. To reduce uncertainty surrounding future sea-level rise, predictive models require reliable ice-proximal observations of the orbital to millennial-scale EAIS response to past climate change.
Models and observations highlight the sensitivity of Antarctica’s ice sheets to abrupt oceanic perturbations (e.g. sea level rise and/or ocean warming) in regions of enhanced glacial flow2. Models that prescribe abrupt warmings and/or sea level rise during the last deglaciation reveal maximum ice flow and discharge rates via outlet glaciers that drain into the Weddell Sea,
Amundsen Sea, Ross Sea, and Prydz Bay and suggest that abrupt oceanic forcings propagate rapidly through associated glacial catchments4. Chronologically constrained observations of late
Quaternary (0-40 ka) EAIS variability are limited, but terrestrial records suggest episodes of thinning and retreat between 40 and 30 ka in catchments associated with Weddell Sea5 and Prydz
Bay6,7 marine-terminating outlet glaciers as well as during millennial-scale Antarctic Isotopic
Maxima (AIM) events, a proxy for atmospheric temperature8. Ice distal Southern Ocean marine sediment records reveal millennial-scale episodes of warming and IRD deposition, which suggest
! 1 either dynamic ice sheet responses to ocean perturbations and/or fluctuations in seasonal sea ice extent9.
Because the EAIS extended across the continental shelf in most locations during the last glaciation, preserved late Quaternary sediments are rare and dating these sequences is complex.
Thus, sub-orbital scale ice sheet variability is inferred from far-field marine records. Due to these limitations, existing studies of past outlet glacier behavior and forcings focus on understanding the timing and rates of retreat during the last deglaciation10,11 by radiocarbon (14C) dating the contact between the sub-glacial diamictites and overlying glacial marine sediments. This approach yields important paleoclimatic insights and is straightforward if sufficient marine calcium carbonate (CaCO3) is present, there is minimal sediment reworking, and a local reservoir age can be constrained through time. However, the ice-proximal Antarctic margin is a complex depositional environment; marine sediments are CaCO3-poor, reworking is common, and reservoir ages fluctuate. Bulk sedimentary acid insoluble organic matter (AIOM) 14C ages, used in the absence of CaCO3, often overestimate depositional age because they incorporate a matrix of autochthonous marine- and glacially-derived allochthonous organic carbon that encompasses a spectrum of ages12.
Study Location
Here we present the first accurately-dated detailed late Quaternary (~40-0 ka) record of
EAIS outlet glacier variability. This record, from Prydz Channel, in Prydz Bay, East Antarctica, fills an important ice-proximal gap between terrestrial Antarctic and Southern Ocean records and enables direct investigation of late Quaternary EAIS variability. Within Prydz Channel, a 150 km wide and 700 m deep cross-shelf trough, a set of elongate streamlined ridges trend parallel to the channel axis. These ridges extend the length (~60 km) and width (40-150 km) of the central
! 2 trough, with a 0.5 to 2.5 km spacing from crest-to-crest (Fig. 1). Ridge relief is most pronounced at shallower depths (<500 m) near the shelf edge and muted landward in the deeper portion of
Prydz Channel. These ridges are interpreted as mega-scale glacial lineations (MSGLs). Large grounding zone wedges (GZWs) delineate Prydz Channel to the southwest, south, and southeast and are characterized by oblique fluting (Fig 1). Glacial landforms within Prydz Channel record the Pleistocene history of streaming ice and the retreat of the LG-AIS system. The MSGLs indicate that a fast, northwest flowing paleo ice stream occupied Prydz Channel The length and continuous nature of these MSGLs suggest rapid retreat of the LG-AIS system via ice-bed decoupling and iceberg calving. One clue to the timing of retreat comes from the Prydz Channel trough-mouth fan, where the transition from debrites to hemipelagic sediments dates to ~780 ka13.
The angle of Prydz Channel MSGLs relative to the angle of flutes Prydz Channel GZWs implies that MSGL formation predates the most recent deglaciation14.
Today, the marine-based Lambert Glacier-Amery Ice Shelf (LG-AIS) outlet glacier system, which drains 16% of the EAIS15, is situated at the head of Prydz Channel. The Amery
Ice Shelf, the largest embayed ice shelf in East Antarctica, is presently grounded 2500 m below sea level and experiences basal melt (~2 m ice/yr) due to the seasonal influx of modified
Circumpolar Deep Water (mCDW), which enters the ice shelf cavity on the eastern side of Prydz
Channel and exists on the western side as Ice Shelf Water16. Clockwise gyral circulation recognized in Prydz Channel and eastern Prydz Bay17,18 draws mCDW onto the shelf to compensate for dense shelf water outflow; this influx is particularly strong during the austral autumn and early winter. Regional mCDW presence is seasonally and inter-annually variable as it is associated with eddy flux and regional polynya dynamics19.
! 3 We investigate late Quaternary LG-AIS dynamics using three marine sediment cores collected along a southeast-northwest transect in inner Prydz Channel during United States
Antarctic Program cruise NBP01-01: JPC-34 (68°15.04’S, 72°43.82’E; 754 m), JPC-35
(68°17.13’S, 72°28.45’E; 854 m), and JPC-36 (68°03.94’S, 72°16.38’E; 752 m) (Fig. 1).
NBP01-01 JPC-34 and JPC-35 were collected from a ~10m hemipelagic to glacial marine sediment drape ~50 km seaward of a series of prominent grounding zone wedges, which delineate Prydz Channel; JPC-36 was collected 30 km farther north, towards the shelf edge. All cores exhibit a consistent sequence of up to four distinct siliceous mud and ooze (SMO) units interbedded with sandy muds and granulated sediments (Fig. 2; Extended Data Fig. 1). Initial 14C ages derived from bulk AIOM and foraminiferal calcite suggested this sequence contained a late
Quaternary record of LG-AIS dynamics20 (Fig 3). However, old to infinite 14C ages20 suggested either a low resolution sequence of limited paleoenvironmental utility or substantial contamination of the bulk AIOM 14C ages by pre-aged allochthonous organic carbon12.
!
! 4 a 72°E 73°E
mCDW
-500m 67° ISW
Prydz Channel
-500m
GC-22
GC-09 68° JPC-36 GC-24 GC-20 ISW JPC-34 JPC-35
Amery 69°S Ice Shelf
N mCDW 100 km
480 600 840 m
b 72°30'E 73°00'E
JPC-36 GC-09 GC-24 Ice flow GZW Depth (mbsf) GC-20 Prydz Channel
68°15'S m 480 JPC-34 600 JPC-35
GZW
N GZW
10 km 840
Figure 1. Prydz Channel, East Antarctica, depicting multibeam swath bathymetry, core locations. a b, a b S N
NBP01-01 NBP01-01 NBP01-01 Prydz Channel Chaetoceros F. curta and other T. antarctica E. antarctica Extinct JPC-34 JPC 35 JPC 34 JPC 36 mag. sus. stack Fragilariopsis spp. 10Be abundance 0 0 SMO-1 4 JPC-34 4 JPC-35 1 4 1 JPC-36 c 0.5 3
2 Depth (mcd) 3 2 SMO-2 1.5
3 2
3 3 2 2.5 4 0 5 10 15 20 25
Depth (mcd) 10 8 1 Be x 10 (atoms/g)
Depth (mbsf) 4 2 5 1 SMO-3 0 10 20
5 6 0 10 20 SMO-4
1 Magnetic susceptibility (10-5 cgs) 7 6 0 4 5 25 45 65 5 25 45 65 5 25 45 65 5 25 45 65 5 25 45 65 0 10 20 0 10 Normalized 10Be x 108 magnetic susceptibility (atoms g-1) 8 % Diatom abundance
Legend Foraminifer 14C siliceous mud and ooze (SMO) Bulk AIOM 14C sandy mud granulated texture RP AIOM 14C sandy clay granule-rich pebbly muddy sand
1 Core section
Figure 2. NBP01-01 core stratigraphy, magnetic susceptibility (MS), % diatom abundance, 10Be concentration ([10Be]) alongside Prydz Channel composite MS and radiocarbon ( 14C) ages. a b c