IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION \9 NOTICE OF MOTION(NO.S2J"OF 2018
IN
WRIT PETITION NO. 1286 OF 2018
Mumbai Cricket Association. ... Applicant
(Original Respondent No.1)
In the matter between
NadimMemon ... Petitioner
VERSUS
Mumbai Cricket Association &Ors ... Respondents.
INDEX
Date Exh.No. Particulars Page No.
Proforma
Notice of Motion 1-8
Affidavit in support of Notice of . 9-15
Motion ". ,
6/4/2018. A. Copy of order. 16-2~
2/5/2018 B. News paper report in Times ofIndia 23
2/5/2018 C. Copy of Minutes of Committee of 24
Administrators of Respondent No.1 ~
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
NOTICE OF MOTION NO. OF 2018
IN
WRIT PETITION NO. 1286 OF 2018
Mumbai Cricket Association, a public )
Trust registered under the provisions of )
Bombay public trust Act, 1950 as also a )
Society registered under the provision of the )
Societies Registration Act, 1860 having its )
Office at Cricket Center, Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate Mumbai- 400020. ) .. '" Applicant
(Original Respondent No.1)
In the matter between:-
Nadim Memon, an adult Indian Inhabitant )
Occupation ;- Business having his address at )
22, Rustom Sidwa Marg, Fort, Mumbai - 400 001 ) ... Petitioner
Vis
1) Mumbai Cricket Association, a public )
Trust registered under the provisions of )
Bombay public trust Act, 1950 as also a )
Society registered under the provision of the )
Societies Registration Act, 1860 having its )
Office at Cricket Center, Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate Mumbai- 400020. ) v
2) Wizcraft International Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. )
A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 )
Having its registered office at Satyadev Plaza, )
5th Floor, Fun Republic Lane, Off. New Link Road, )
Behind Bhagwati House, Andheri(West), )
Mumbai - 400 053 )
3) India Infoline Ltd (IIFL) a company registered )
Under the companies Act, 1956 having its )
Registered office at IIFL House Sun Infotech Park, )
Road No. 16V, Plot No. B-23, Thane Industrial Area, )
Wagle Estate, Thane - 400604 )
And Corporate office at IIFL Center kamala City, )
Senapati Bapat Marg, Lower Parel (West), )
Mumbai 400013 )
4) Probability Sports India Pvt. Ltd. )
A company registered under the Companies Act, 2013 )
Having its registered office at IIFL Center Kamala City,)
Senapati Bapat Marg, Lower Parel (West), )
Mumbai 400 013 )
5) Charity Commissioner, Maharashtra Mumbai, )
3rd Floor, 83, Dr. Annie Besant Road, Worli, )
Mumbai - 400018 )
6) Board of Control for Cricket in India )
A society registered under the Tamil Nadu Societies ) ~
Registration Act having its office at 4th Floor, )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, Churchgate, )
Mumbai - 400 020 )
7) Adv. Ashish Shelar, An adult Indian Inhabitant )
Occ. Advocate, the President of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, Churchgate, )
Mumbai - 400 020 )
8) Vinod Deshpande, An adult Indian Inhabitant )
Occ. unknown, the Vice President of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, Churchgate, )
Mumbai - 400 020 )
9) Pankaj Thakur, An adult Indian Inhabitant )
Occ. unknown, the Vice President of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede StadiUm, Churchgate, )
Mumbai - 400 020 )
10) Nitin Dalal, An adult Indian Inhabitant )
Occ. unknown, the Treasurer of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, Churchgate, )
Mumbai - 400 020 )
11) P. V. Shetty, An adult Indian Inhabitant ) Occ. unknown, the Jt. Secretary of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, Churchgate, )
Mumbai - 400 020 )
12) Prof. Dr. Unmesh Khanvilkar, )
An adult Indian Inhabitant, Occ. unknown, ) the Jt. Secretary ofMumbai Cricket Association, ) having address at Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium,)
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
13) Arman Malik, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
14) Mr. Navin Shetty, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
15) Arvind Kadam, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 ) ~)
16) Deepak PatH, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
17) Pravin Amre, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
18) Shrikant Tigdi; An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
19) Shahalam Shaikh, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
20) Ramesh Vajge, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, ) '--"
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
21) Ganesh Iyer, An adult Indian Inhabitant, )
Occ. unknown, the Managing Committee member of )
Mumbai Cricket Association, having address at )
Cricket Stadium Wankhede Stadium, )
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020 )
22) State ofMaharashtra )
Through the Government Pleader ) ... Respondents
Let all parties concerned attend before Their Lordship the Hon'ble Justice
Shri. S. S. Khemkar and Hon'ble Justice Shri. M. S. Karnik on the day of __ 2018 at 11:00 A. M. or soon thereafter for hearing an application on behalf of the Applicant in the above Petition. The above named Applicant prays:-
(a) That the directions of this Hon'ble Court to hold a general Body
meeting of the members of the Respondent No.1 Association on or
before 15th May 2018 and to complete the entire process including
the election to the New Managing Committee by 30tl1 June, 2018 in
terms of amended para No.6 of the order dated 6tl1 April, 2018
passed in the above Petition be kept in abeyance till such time as this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper.
(b) That this Hon'ble Court may direct that the above Petition to be
placed on board for appropriate directions on a date after the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India finalises the constitution of
Respondent No.6.
(c) That pending the hearing and the final disposal of the above Notice
of Motion this Hon'ble Court be pleased to keep in abeyance the
directions of this Hon'ble Court to hold a general Body meeting of
the Respondent No.1 association on or before ISth May 2018 and to
complete the entire process including the election to the New
Managing Committee by 30th June, 2018 in terms of amended para
No.6 of the order dated 6th April, 2018 passed in the above Petition.
(d) Interim and ad interim orders in terms of prayer clause (a) to (c)
above.
Advocate for the Applicant
This Notice of Motion is taken out by Warerkar & Warerkar Advocate for the Applicant/Respondent No. I Off at:- 6th floor, Vulcan Insurance Building, Veer Nariman Road, Churchgate, Mumbai - 400 020
To,
1. Nadim Memon 2. Wizcraft International Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. 3. India Infoline Ltd. (IIFL) 4. Probability Sports India Pvt. Ltd. S. Charity Commissioner 6. Board of Control of Cricket in India 7. Adv. Ashish Shelar 8. Vinod Despande 9. Pankaj Thakur '-.:/
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORlGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
NOTICE OF MOTION NO. OF 2018
IN
WRIT PETITION NO. 1286 OF 2018
Mumbai Cricket Association. . .. Applicant
(Original Respondent No.1)
In the matter between
NadimMemon ... Petitioner
VERSUS
Mumbai Cricket Association &Ors ... Respondents.
Affidavit in support ofthe Notice of Mofion
I, Chandrakant S. Naik, Adult of Mumbai, Indian Inhabitant, the
Chief executive Officer of the Respondent No.1 abovenamed having my office at Wankhede Stadium, "D" Road, Churchgate, Mumbai 400 020, do hereby solemnly'affirm and state as under:- .'" ,"
1. I say that I am the Chief Executive officer of Mumbai Cricket
Association being the Respondent No.1 abovenamed. I am conversant with the facts of the case and duly authorised by the Committee of administrators comprising of (1) Mr. Justice H. L. Gokhale, former Judge of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India (Chairman) and Mr. Justice V.M.
Kanade, former judge of the Bombay High court (member) appointed by this Hon'ble Court vide its order dated 6th April, 2018 passed in the above
1
--'--_.\\, \...... /
petition to file this affidavit. I say that the brief facts relating to filing of this r " notice of Motion are as under:
I.
2. I say that vide order dated 6th April, 2018 this Hon'ble Court was
pleased to appoint a Committee of Administrators (Hereinafter referred to
as "the Committee of Administrators") comprising of (1) Mr. Justice H. L.
Gokhale, former Judge of the Hon'ble Supreme Court ofIndia (Chairman)
and Mr. Justice V.M. Kanade, former judge of the Bombay High court
(member) for the purpose of ensuring that the Mumbai Cricket Association
implements all the directions contained in the Principal Judgment as well as
the steps set out in the timelines issued by the Hon'ble Justice Lodha
Committee pursuant thereto.
3. I say that relevant clauses of the said order dated 6th April, 2018
concerning this notice of motion are reproduced herein below and read as
under:
"5. The draft of the proposed new constitution and/or proposed
j;':::~" "j''::'::':;", • ..,.,' . amendments to the existing constitution as approved by the • <.,,;~./ ..A } ~~~;- J~" • ~t ""- ... ./ ·'.,cr, .;;.... --.. -..... G .~... ","" '-('" th ./" ....'.'" ",1'1 , c\.' .. ' "'i'\(\,\,' \" Managing Committee of the Mumbai Cricket Association on 29 ;t;' f C)r'i) (' '," 'c, ',.~ , ~ n )'" ' "I';" . I "')")0,~. '0 i II' i ,".? '0 I( 0'~o,. '..-"'-4.\ .' I.t March, 2018 shall be provided to the Committee of 0)\ ,"1..)' C) ("" ~, .,..() ~'<:) '> ,,,0 ! "" ',' f '\\ '0 ').l " "':'!l .~:'; (.J..,. ... /r-, ' J Administrators immediately upon them assuming charge. ··r-~<'~ \.";..~ ... , -'0• t.''--. C -'~-' ..( ...... ~ ,/,1 '~'~ V 1[1'-1 \ \ ") .J .. //
u~~~:~.~;~-:.:~,; ... '::;~---::': ,> 6. The Committee of Administrators shall ensure that the draft of
the proposed new constitution and/or proposed amendments to
the existing constitution of the Mumbai Cricket Association
which is to be placed before the General body of the Mumbai
Cricket Association is in conformity with the recommendations
2 '-----""
of the Hon'ble Justice Lodha Committee as modified and
accepted by the Hon'ble Supreme court vide the Principal
Judgement in its letter and spirit. The Committee of
Administrators may, if it considers necessary, postpone the
meeting of the General Body of the Mumbai Cricket Association
currently scheduled on 16th April, 2018. However, the Committee
of Administrators shall endeavor to hold such meeting by 15th
May, 2018 and complete the entire process including the election
to the New Managing Committee by 30th June, 2018.
7. The" General Body meeting for the purpose of voting on the
proposed new constitution and/or proposed amendments to the
- ~ existing constitution of the Mumbai Cricket Association shall be .~V.l~-1I' conducted under the supervision of the Committee of ~!.If- J?;99 O~"U6a
to time to in the course of discharging its functions."
" ~" -tdl Hereto annexed and marked as Exhibit "A" is a copy of said order dated 6th April, 2018.
4. I say that in terms of amended para No.6 of the said order dated 6th
April, 2018, the Committee of Administrators was required to
endeavor to hold General body meeting of the members of the
Respondent no.l to amend the constitution by 15th May, 2018 and
complete the entire process including the election to the New
Managing Committee by 30th June, 2018.
3 ~
5. I say that the Committee of Administrators took charge of the
administration of respondent No.1 association on 1/14/2018 and had
thereafter planned to draft the constitution of Respondent No.1 and
to hold the Special General body meeting of the Association to
consider the amended constitution as per the Lodha committee report
on or before 15/5/2018 so that the electoral process could be
completed by 30/6/2018 in accordance with the said order dated 6th
April, 2018 a copy whereof is annexed as exhibit "A" hereto.
6. I say that a period of about 45 days would be normally required
after amending the constitution of the Respondent No. lAssociation
to comply with the electoral process.
7. I say that on 2/5/2018 the Committee of Administrators has come
across a newspaper report published in the daily issue of the
newspaper "Times of India" circulated in Mumbai which has
inter-alia reported as under:
"A bench led by the cn Dipak Misra bench said it would
finalise the BCCI constitution by May 7 and state association
could amend their constitutions to bring it in sync with the
BCCrs. Thereafter, state association could hold elections to take
control of their affairs through elected bodies, the bench said."
I say that it is learnt that the said case before the Hon 'ble Supreme
Court ofIndia is adjourned to 11th May 2018 and hence information
4 ~
about finalization of the constitution of BCCI i.e. the Respondent
No.6 herein can be known only on 11th May, 2018 or thereafter.
t)<~B~ Hereto annexed and marked as Exhibit "B" is a copy of said
newspaper report. I crave leave to refer to and rely upon said order
when produced.
8. I say that in view of the said news paper report dated 2/5/2018 the
Respondent No.1 Association would be able to effectively amend its
constitution and bring the same in sync with the BCCI's constitution
only after the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India finalises the BCCI
constitution on i h May, 2018. I say that the Committee of
Administrators will also require additional time to ascertain changes
if any required to be made to the draft constitution of the Respondent
No.1 Association in order to bring it in sync with the finalized
constitution of BCCI and to thereafter convene a Special General
body meeting to get the constitution amended accordingly and also
to complete the entire process including the election to the New
«~~ Managing Committee. A notice of at least seven days would be o ;:0 0 O~~)- :::t ~ J!5 11 G) ?:- . required to be given under the existing constitution of Respondent , .>"" 0\?2 0 0 ,.:;0" 0"\:2 0 <: c.0 J 0 );::-i 0li No.1 to hold a Special General body meeting of the association. );/- C::'! ~.. .%e~o~;f:;jI 9. I say that in view of the aforesaid, it would not be possible to hold a
special general Body meeting of the Respondent No.1 association on
or before 15 th May 2018 and or to complete the entire process
including the election to the New Managing Committee by 30th June,
2018 in terms of amended para NO.6 of the said order dated 6th
April, 2018 passed in the above Petition.
5 '-'"
1O. I say that the Committee of Administrators has in its meeting held on
2/5/2018 considered the said newspaper report dated 1815/2018 and
inter-alia decided that appropriate application be made to this
Hon'ble court pointing out the said development so that this Hon'ble
Court would be in the know thereof and may pass appropriate --t;y lAc" directions. Hereto annexed and marked as Exhibit "C" is a copy of minutes of the Committee of Administrators of Respondent No.1
dated 2/5/2018.
11. I say that in the circumstances it would be necessary and in the
interest of justice that the directions of this Hon'ble <;:ourt to hold a
general Body meeting of the members of the Respondent No.1
association on or before IStl' May 2018 and to complete the entire
process including the election to the New Managing Committee by
30th June, 2018 in terms of amended para No.6 of the said order
dated 6th April, 2018 be kept in abeyance till such time as this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper.
12. I say that in the circumstances it would also be necessary and in the
interest of justice that this Hon'ble Court may direct that the above
Petition to be placed on board for appropriate directions on a date
after the Hon'ble Supreme Court ofIndia finalises the constitution of
Respondent No.6.
13. I say that in these circumstances and pending the hearing and the
final disposal of the above notice of motion this Hon'ble Court be
pleased to keep in abeyance the directions of this Hon 'ble Court to
6 \:/
hold a general Body meeting of the Respondent No.1 association on
or before 15th May 2018 and to complete the entire process including
the election to the New Managing Committee by 30th June, 2018 in
tenns of amended para No.6 of the said order dated 6th April, 2018.
14. In the above circumstances, I respectfully pray that the above notice
of motion be made absolute with costs.
Solemnly affinned at Mumbai' )
dated this 3rd day of May, 2018. ) ~~ rPof~'6. ~~- GRE \ .-, )\ --z;-- , GO Y' Advocate for the Respondent No.1 . ADVo.CAT~ .'iV. D'SOUZA . ¥.:jilPillk Esrat: : r.,OTARY ~p No.'; ag. NO'~B'1 ~VM!s""I~';~~top Hill /l (1,.-./' , .."" 037 0 f,.l./ 0 ".... 7Jf"'-'" If Pr=.!;;cp>(L In Reg. No !~h"\ '6. ! 0 3 MAY 2018' ~ fv
"-::'o"~'~ 1< C-I? '." ."$ //.;({)J~--!: '\.... . ", G'~;>,...... '\." · .---..: A' \. /' t,_~ ~ ' __, ,,<, \ <::-.,. , " '"":>.'\. ./(, .....,.,. ~:.' - . 'Y ). ~>o':'- '.;::J)"f (}."\ r-;;C \ (0 , _ IJ• :'-. "" . ~~ 1 '-", .' '- ._, \0 '~-17\1.,~ ..,../ 9)p>dj> ,-) ;:Q... ~-<-'1)~ i i.{ 1."'<-1 0;0).,..- J) ... >-,-'/ \?J( __ ~, 1 ' ,0) .. , . ~ , '. ~ ,',. , .... :..' , 'v;. "')' , .... ~ l'li.'- J, -,-<\ 1C "'.f?~ ~;;;'OC)I,<}' '\-' Lc'C. ' ' \\ S_~\0. :-;iJ'.~!.~~'l~'i;;.~~;';;.~ /~,! ...0. o-....,r 6' '~jtp_., . . \\, ":;-'."- -~ ______j~r, r _y .. Rf'!:. TARIAI, N~~';~A.!NOTARIA0\:;:Nb!A~ -1,) \f '_" ' "'-_:, .;:::::1"8. ,'.. _ . --=-~- ~,.
7 OJYNo... ~'2.!::'2.... I2~ ..~?:f •••.••• \ / Ill' {,t> Charges@Rs. 2:50f5:6!3:: ..I.:t2.CO 901_wpl.752_2018,doc Certified Copy/XBr:gl( Gepy .;. Issued by Certified Copy Dent IN TIlE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CML JURISDICTION
/'- j<' I" ':' WRIT PETITION (Ll NO:752 OF 2018
NadimMenon ... Petitioner vs. " Mumbai Cricket Association and Qthers . .. Respondents Mr. Mihir Desai, Senior Advocate rr/w. Mr. Chaitanya Bhandarkar. for the Petitioner. . . Mr. R.A. Dada•. Senior Advocate a/w. Mr. A.S. Khandeparkar. Mr. '. Vikas Warekar. Ms. Rad):lika War~kar. Ms. ApurvaKhandeparkar !/b. Warekar & Ware.lpt~.fin\lff;llS11l0..l~t No. 1. Mr. Mllind. Satll'(l; Sdn!eP:;{cI\>-~l!'I:~.lj~Hr" Devesh Juvekar. Mr. Mayur Shetty.~Dikshat Mehra!i/b. M1!i.fi'ajanji Associates, for ResponcJMl'1SNos. 2 and 4. -_; '...- ,,<1 .- Mr. bll.~"lfatki.AGP fi " '~ent No. 5-St:a~1>; Mr.. ~~ Thlzaput "I .~te a/w. Mr. P,..:J.arsh Saxena, MS('~chyeta Sh . . Sharma i/b{)W/s, Cyril AnMchand Mangald nt No.6. "",) t;;: . ~. (;J . TANU KEMKAR.~ ~ KARNlK.~ IJ:: ~ 06,2018 P.c.: . ;if~~' Parties through theii' counsel.
2. The learned counsel for the parties submits that the
Petition may be disposed of in terr¥s oithe Minutes of Order which
are taken on record and marked ~xhibit "X" for the identification,
howeVer, with the modification as agreed by ·the learned senior
counsel appearing for the parties, ~o the effect that in place of Para
4 which has beer;l, mentioned in thb, Minutes of Order. it be read as.
Vishal Parekar 1/2
::: Uploaded on ~ 06/0412018 ::: Downloaded on .. 17/041201816:18:54 :;:CM/S-CC ::: CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORREC.T COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGHED JUDGMENT/ORDER.
".
"'i'l"':ri'l II I Ii r... ·-..,...".....,--··-~-·-~-:-I .I •• II .___ -"J... 1...--1----..--.:--) 1 r- .... , --n~--rr·:'. l r.'Trn-r~llllfll-r. .. "·,..... ';'.. ~~--..;,..--.-7-"·~ .. -~>O ..-- ..,- .. ··-~··_.. ! _'. ..,.,'=" ." ~",~.. _.... ".,,_ ...... ,:.~.~.:. ;"j . ". I .j l..URA. "~,,- S;HANTAN.!J!l;; K.::M\(p,C·:.··· ':t .' t M.'S' k'ARII)tj<:. . JJ .. . . . " y DATE :.\ 06[l.t!U5r~; ...... , ..<1 .~.~.. . . ."C.l·' .y'" " ... ".J.~.t·,,-,-Il.' . .' . "-""'t.....- '" rCl"f' ~,(J1[p~, IN THE HILtH.COy~\,?F JUDICATURE.~TBOM1¥\' . . • .. ~ -. ',:.. ' .1; . -:;Yf/td~ . ':,1 ORDINARy ORIGINAL CML JURlSDiC'I:ION . >f , " 'r;' . ,. 'J .. WRIT PETITION (L) NO. 752 'OF 2018". :! . . \ .. c . J:' , ,"Nadlp,. ,Memon , ",; joetiti-';ner: ,'. i?
, : .. Vs: . t:: :'" • Mi~bai. Cricket-Association·& Drs.' • ' ...... Respondents
. • ~ t ~ ,. t· .' . ·It CORAM: • SHANTANU ·S. KEMKAR '. _.t- .. . ~': I I " . . .'.: ",:'!'.' .. I;·· . \ M. S, KARNIK; JJ.. ~. I ~' . : ;.: t \ .. ' .. DATE: 6 th April, 2018 k :1::: , .... '. ~. ". ". l', .a· • MINUTES OF ORDER ..:.'', " .!.~; ~., .. t- . :.' " .. 1· .. '.' ': i.:." . ~he ,recommendations '. of the Hen'ble Justice ··Lo.dh~ :'~:o~mittee .as . ··f·:· ·modified'. and accepted ..by the Hon'ble Supreme..... Court· vide judglnent'. dated 18th July 2016. passed ill Civil Appeal No .. 4.235"0(2014 ;"'d I,. . . . , connected matters ('oPrincipai Judgment") are i:iindh::g.and shall be .V·:,.! ;., - .' " ',,' • I '. implemented By the MumlJal Cricket Associati;n ~ong with "any ,. j'. : further orders' that may be Rassed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. ... j' " . , ., , . .:,.. .' , .~ 2,,' . 'A ·.Co;:"mittee of Adnlinlstr:,-to~s .. compri.rlng (1)' Mr,.· :J.ustlce H-:" L.' .
Gokh8le, former Judge' pf the Hon'bl~ Supreme Co.urt (Ch;;JPnE!I1); ";"d" ~.. . ;,. '. . . ~ , . . , . (2) Mr. Justice V: M. Kanade, former judge 'of the ·BombaY -High Court: • . (Me";berj, is hereby appointed for the purpo"~. o~ ~nsir;';ng that· the .' '. . ~ . . . /~;'1, T'"7;~ .. · . /~. ~N''''''~ ", ~< ... ,.'~ ~umbai Cricket Association imp.lement.s all tbe:dir~c:tions contaiped. ~,\ \"..)1' '- C ". /::,,)~ ,):: .... - -~ ..... , "/?"",:;> in the Pnncipal Judgment as well as i?J"fue " ..... , . \ .. the·step~·s~t oUt timelin~s 1\ . -.(.... ~ _:... "(7) .. h. (~-) (;.~~J V. -'...... , , ! "';' 0:" ·S·' .·,0 . \ L.jJ i i~.s1.led by the 'Hon'ble Justice. Lodha' Committeepursuant:fuereto. '. l .:. .;\ );. ; ~·t " •. '. '. . , _ - ""'~'" 'v I'" J ;" ," :: . ..,,' , \ ~'~A'\' ~ :. \~.~. ,-" \'--.C J • i:.0:::}" . . . . \ .'. .",.'. '.,\. ') / () /1.'3. The Committee of Ad~:tinistrators· shiill take charge withlti a' period of \ . \ _( .~--~ ", / ...·C ... ·, I,i . . '. . '". -...... ----. (". '" ./,,f' '. ". :.;.:/ '/ .vl \I -'~,-;;;: . . . one. week from today. Until the Committee 'qf Admipistrators .assumes ':;,::::::--:-_.:._-;;;:f:0. . .,,' . - '... chru.-g'e, ·the following persons viz. (A) Adv. Ashish Shelar (President),. ", . .. .
". .1 ...... i,:
~rt'--.j I .. ,.;.... JIT'.I;:~~"~~~'=."~- ~'~"~·~'-~~~~:=~'~·.~~~~;:~r~;·'-.'~r~~~·:~·::'~~·· i-' ·"~~.~~:=.~,_::;;:::r ~:D?.!:Z:~- ... "; ITl"~::::T:! ~,-- ·-'-·~1~r; .,"1"·" 11'1 ·11" -,11111 r -, '0]'d\ .'" -~ ;...... ,.. ~ '" ···s·~- ~ .. ----=-, ~-__' ...... -. ,,;;,,\ ,,' ( n "..ii, ~~....:..,~. .. ,.: ~-): :~- ..~~: :'\!
-.~ :J ",~~'."" .' ...... Ai...... :~., .(B) Prof, Dr. Uhmesb. Khanvilkar (Jt. Hon... S~c~~tsui. '(C). M~: Navin. · ...j i Shetty (Committee mem\>er). (D) Mr. Shahai.i.m.· Shaikh (C6minittee ~t~ ,/ . . . '.' ·i .' ·member). (E) Mr. Ganesh Iyer (Committee member) 'and (F) Mr.. AI'Jllan '. ; . " . '. '. ., ;, . " . '. .' ....' -. " . 1 . .'·Mellick (Committee :meIIlber) (hereinafter ,eferie<:l :.i:o :as·. the" "said· .. :::. :', i . . ' .. '. . ., .. '. .,:'.' . . .'. .... <. ·t P'lrsons")' ·shall .. continue to look after. the' IIlariagement and·. . :'.1
" ,. . administration of the Mumbai'Cricket ~:sociation ~cl~dit:Ig all work. '.' . ;T · " ..' . ". ", .. ' ...... ' . '. .'.. .I~' conc~rning the' smooth running of the 11 (h InClian' Premier ':LeagUe' . jj: , ot •• ·'. to~rnB.lllent.. . During this.," interim period. Ad'v.~A~~shSh~lar.::,' :': .. :..... : ..,.:-. .. ~d'~;Pf.... " ", . . . . '.. .p f' Dr. Unmesh Khanvilkar may also sign Che'l.~~~' ~a.l,oroper~te: ~e " . ,: '.:::fl.. 'bank acc~unts on behslf of the Mumbal . Crl6ket:'. Association . for. . j,1
.~. .. !' . . ~ ). '. .. ~ \',; '.' routine payments or any member frqm'(C) .to :(1") listed 'above' w!lo:are.. 'i . ;) ' .. . .. ~4 · autjlOrised by the President.. .. ;1. . : .. • .;! :.' ' " - . ·.. ;··::.t~ . ,'. . ,4'. .·Upon the Committee of Administrators assumil1g.:charg~:'the ·.~aici . f
P~rs~p.s as 'well as ruiy Comnii~es/ Srib~co.riunitte~~ qf.the '~~mbaj l~
.", 'C;';cket 'Association shall fu)1ction ocly '1.0' .' ,:\< subj;'~t i:h~. ~up~rvision' and · :'.' · c9ntrol or' \he ~~mmitteeof Ad~is~at~t~'Cbmmitte~ 0.£ 'I~<: ... .:. :i; ·~dministrators shalf hav; the pow:er to issue: sucn .direction~ as it ·1 . ,-. · considers necessWy. for ~xercising due supervisio~ and· conb:ol. The ... .,f" " <.c~mmittee of Administ~ators Sh~le ~~pervi~e ~e.~ana~:IIleIlf . :' j:: · and administration of 'the M~baio Crick~t Assdeiati~;". induding' iIi ! .., 1Y"A·~'}~,. '!.. ,~.f:s' '.ClC)91 -.....z~ G> \\ \ · relation to distribution of tick~ts f~r IPL miatch~s. ~ ,':! -. DCl'tl -;.tJ.1 \ CJJ( . Oi'-\ U [11/. ~- . . " G) 1 , 50\ '-"v· CihI~? _.,.... -,;: 0 ' . 5'0 The draft of the proposed new constituti,on' and!or proposed J' ~\:_tJ\U;'J \Y '. '1 to-~".~ .' ameI}.dments to the. exist:iiJg constituti~ri.:· .as, 'app;oved :by' the:, ., . : ': ~' . ··1 , . Managing Committee of the· Mumbai Cricket -Association on ,29th · I · ~ ~~ · ,• . " March. 2018 shall be Pf~vided to the Committee.·';rAdm\nistrators
im~ediately upon.thel'Il: assumin~ charge. , . "'. ~~. ' .. • 6. '. The Committee of Administrators shalj'ensur~ that :i.he .draIt:·of·¢.e . .'·
· propo.sed new constitution and! or proposed' ame~d~ents. to : the .'. . . existing constitution of the Mumbai Cricket Associati,on which is to be' ..
'. 2 . r· ,,~ . .... "'0 •• ",.•• ~.-.,. ":---'~':tl";--- n Tr'~"T'" -IIT"I":.... -r-~- .. .,.--- . """1-" ·l;::-'::;T;r~--w.·~:-l·~-'··'~!' 'I::~':---""::;-::-I~\':'::-- lT '~ .• -~-.... ""~_' , ... -... ,.•.. ?::;; .. _::, :-j.'F~:::'······':l:-r.'JT~T:'::;:'~':~ii;:-ri'il;i~·;~·: ~ «.. • :J. 1:.0;' " : ',"
'. '- ~,),?
placed before the Ge;'eral Body of the Mumbai Cricket Asso~iation is
in conformity with the recommendations of the Hon'ble Justice Lodha :'":. Committee as modified and accepted by the Hop 'hIe Supreme' Court
vide the Principal. Judgment in its letter and spirit. The Committee of
,., Administrators-may, if it considers necess'Wy, postpone the meeting of
the General Body of the . Mumbai Cricket. Association currently
scheduled on 16th April 2018""" "I:
7. The General Body meeting for the purpose of voting on the proposed
new, constitution and/ or proposed amencil)1ents to the existing
constitution of fue Mumbai Cricket Association shall be conducted
under the supervision of the Committee of Administrators.
8. BCCI, the said Persons and the members, of the Mumbai Cricket
Association shall render all such assistance to the Committee -of
Administrators as it may require. ,The Committee of Administrators
shall be at liberty .to seek the assistance of and/ or appoint such other , : . , . persons (including e>q>erts in fmance, audit, cricket administration,
etc.) as it deems fit for the purpose .of discharging its functions. The
i Mumbai Cricket Association shall bear such fees/expenses of such ~~l //'. ,\ '-'--.'.' . / \.uV! '-.:' persons as the Committee of Administrators may fIx. '1', / !>-~ ~,('-,I· '):1. " ()./ .) .... oJ' ,".' .. I ,1,,"(/ " ~/9Q j ",~' \','. ' .. f. ,. ~ ,( C, \.J.'t.". ''''. . ,., ,'. II~ c, i.. tIl U6- \'-' ~:. 9. The expenditure incurred towards. any travelling and/or conveyance ( >\ ,I!{" ,d)-!' -' :t \\'0.\ "',if;;; 'CJ j"',:»1 ,.\_",\ ., .. ,:::10 J.:c!Jlj. for the Committee of Administrators shall be borne by Mumbai ~\ ;\, .t. .' , ...... < • f,·., , . ~''',,'._.' ~ ",J",-,I ~--c,·)· 'J . ~<'I)"_ . .' 0 , Cricket Association. In addition, the Committee of J}dministrators' \ ,~."1)- --'-... /- \"J ,,>_,),n..... (' .'\'!\ 'r- ..' ,,; shall be entitled to remuneration of Rs. ~ lakh each per working day' • '<' •• ~-::.:;;.;.:;9(' spent on work in pursuance of this order. , ,; 10. The Committee of Administrators is, at liberty to seek any
clarifications and/or further directions from this Court from time to
time in the course of discharging Its functions.
3
.. ~;i; .. ! . .s. : i. rW-"'T . lr" .. '·1-.···11 '" ,_.". ''I'' . r''''''j' 'I-'''''rr:''''--"''r--''' - 1". I' "'1'1 II" " 'T 1 -- --:-l·-mT·r" 'm -~. I II :~ ...... , , :
.. ~ ',I? -'
Upon holding 01 the ~lections in terms of the amended constitution of the Mumbai Cricket Association, the Committee of Administrators
shail apply to this Court for discharge. . I:
The parties shall act on the duly authenticated copy of this order.
13. The Registry is directed to forward a copy of this order to the
Committee of Administrators. '.'
Dated this Gih day of Apn1, 2018
~1~;d.JM1'" LJAJ~ .. ~"~\'\<.iS v .. W"'.... <.".\(O\v .Advocate for the Petitioner . Advocate for Respondent No.1 '.'
'. ~~~~ . Advocate for Respondent No.6
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE copy this '-:rli?day of A-f'cr 20 I '8 7 'V~ . , For Ri:lgj~trar (0,$ )/Prothonotary . :. and Senior. M~'ster, High Court;,aom~ . ': Jt- . . . .
,
':
'f{ZUF UP,! :.1 L!"-vJ~:"- ·:"}i::r' .. ~ . I) .. (/.1-,) f\f!. £"12: \ 'li'.,.9.l."' ___~ T,-.. 'I .. .,. .. ·lfrh·· .. 'I' ...... '1 , • ~T ·'''T·...... lT'.. ''''rr-.- .. -r"····_·, l' ]- ...... '" 'IT" '"'.-.. ----:-----~..;.-~.- ~ -, 11-""--1-:-'----,,-"'1"'-":" flrr 'r,-' 11111'(1 • ~ ,. .. "It': ".:. ~. '. oJ.~.' , ~~.~'"~"" ~:. :'~ '-. ) I.? ~~ IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT~ i' ...'"'= . .' .....-, BOMBAY ~, I ,t! . \ ' "... 't\ '.U· ORDINARY ORlGINAL CIVIL JURlSDICTIO~ ''l'':i!~ , \'. ~ .~ ...! . ";. WRIT PETITION (L) NO. 752 OF 2018 '. . \J \"'.~~ :~~:;~~ . Nadim Memon Petitioner Versus Mumbai Cricket Association . Respondents < &Ors .: ,CERTIFIED COpy 6F1 DRAFT MINUTES OF TIlE ORDER ON BEHAj OF i:'HE RESPONDENT NO.6 Dated this 6th day of April 2018 ( I • 'flI!.pphea On .....f.Lf:! !..UL ...... · i \ Section Writer I ~~ Comparer 'P ...... -;-- , Examined BY' ~.. :~ ...... ~ ...... :D ., MIs. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. -r. c....-...... 3i'd Floor, Lentin Chambers, No. OfPa~c9 ...... '" nufi·' 10, '.••. j •• ,...... Dalal Street, Fort, Mumbai 400001 Furlll1er Charges :...... 1!"aid film;.... Advocates for the Respondent No. 6 / No. or Copies ...... \...... ; . 1J':"."""".,,,...... =t".•• ,.< ... , \l:!1\6fR !ij%' "C .' , ..ReadyOn o ...... •••••• ....··········I .•.•.• ~.D . Ul1. 8 APR... Z01S Oe livered On •••••••••• n ...... aeaoo • tI ...... •• .....• 1111 ."', ,."- -.~~ ...... ---.----.-.- .. _...... -:"'- .... ---.. -... -.~:~-.---'( 'i~'V;: ·.l:;: 1 ,l '.".':, .• " -. :. ;1l.~1f(';.,. ~",:'-",~, ,:1 i l .: • VI '" l~ fXHIB I, e ~ '1\ .--~-- L(f fvlE.,' 6.( J ;~j) I f\ - o.z./o .. /)..o 18 ...... ", . " Will CoA and judges manage cricket forever, asks Mehta TIMES NEWS NETWORK New Delhi: The arrangement of former judges presiding over the affairs of state cricket associations is likely to come to an end shortly, with the Supreme Court on Tues day indicating that cricket bodies will be al lowed to hold elections soon. A bench led by CJr Dipak Misra bench said it would finalise the BCCr constitution by May 7 and state associations could amend 'j their constitutions to bring it in sync with the BCCI's. Thereafter, state associ- : ations could hold elections to take control of I their affairs through elected bodies, the \ bench said. I Maharashtra Cricket Association's 1 counsel and additional solicitor general I Tushar Mehta had earlier asked the SC I whether it wanted the BCCr and state cricket I associations to be managed forever by the Committee of Administrators (CoA) andjudges, The query came when amicus curiae Go pal Subramanium told the three-judge bench that while a four-member CoA headed by ex CAG Vinod Rai was managing BCCI's affairs since January last year, several high courts had appointed retired judges as heads of .,:,:;;:\ ='::::::::::::".. state associations . . . O"~ ,. ',,, ,/{\". ;!....:-..:~, Gl);~'" & ~~ ...... " ••••••••••••• ~. ~.".'~"" ~-.-" ~'-' !~.. "-~ .•~-~...:.~!.!.:..!.;"- •. :..~.!.,!,.!,. ~~·,.J""·~ <.I ,~: " .... \. } 0• -h .'/, r.~Jj...... ~;6' \'l~ \ II. .,. ."( •.. ,,., ".':".' .'<) ,---. 0 \ ". '. .. ") ~'-}./ -y '(I2U t [C'P,! S "., .'. \, C :. c}:0 C.~') r: \..\ ...:.:. \,\. -J,...... "'Y /"-/. '-" -", ~ .. ".-::-~" ,,/ r ';J 1.J/..W~ ", '.', :'-.. __ ~ \ ~ '-V'J~ V .. V. \;J R RG ej( t.>rR, pe~JC,(.,A e' -'~f.lr! 'V7~i\\.1/ ~-- ;;....,;;;. ---::-;:- --" ." ~~I-FI is II '"c'" cJ111 \! ® Minutes ofthe Committee of Administrators of Mumbai Cricket Association 1. It is reported that in the hearing of the matter concerning BCeI in Hon'ble Supreme Court, which took place yesterday, i.e., 115/2018, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has sought suggestions from the member associations on BeCI Constitution. These suggestions are supposed to be made to amicus curie Shri Gopal Subramanium appointed by the Apex COUli. These suggestions are to be received by 7/512018 and he is supposed to make a report on proposed constitution of BCCI. The further hearing is presently fixed on 1115/2018. The court has in the meanwhile directed the members associations not to rush to hold elections on the basis of self-amended constitution till the cOUli finalises BCCI Constitution. The Court has also asked the member associations to synchronise their constitution with Bee!. 2. The Administrators appointed by Bombay High Court had in the meanwhile planned to draft the constitution and to hold the meeting to consider the amended constitution as per the Lodha COlmnittee report on or before 15/512018 so that the electoral process could be completed by 30/6/2018. This was in reference to amended para 6 of the order of Division Bench dated 614/2018 in O.S.W.P.(L) no. 752 of2018. The Administrators are however now of the view that in view of tillS development it may not be proper to call a ~~~~~eting on or before 15/5/2018 to consider any such constitution and to hold $~~~r'\'on on or before 30/6/2018. The Adlninistrators have therefore in tillS t g:;:g;; 8 ~.~. g today decided that appropriate application be made to the High Court i\ 0'\ if ~ ;:j /).0 ng out tillS development so that the court would be in the know thereof ),,, <::' . d' . . ..,.- &"'--- Mumb~i JU~le 2/512018 Chairman - COA ~-V--- Justice V.M.Kanade Member-COA ~l't ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION NOTICE OF MOTIO-:t~O.~ OF 2018 IN WRIT PETITION NO. 1286 OF 2018 Mumbai Cricket Association. ... Applicant (Original Respondent No.1) In the matter between NadimMemon ... Petitioner VERSUS Mumbai Cricket Association &Ors ... Respondents. AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF THE NOTI~ OF MOTION Dated this) day of May, 2018. WARERKAR & WARERKAR Advocate for Respondent No.1 6th Floor, Vulcan Insurance Bldg., V. N. Road, Churchgate. Mumbai - 400 020