DOCSLIB.ORG

Critics Say Diet Drink Labels Are Forum for False Advertising by Mcclatchy Washington Bureau, Adapted by Newsela Staff on 04.16.15 Word Count 490

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Critics Say Diet Drink Labels Are Forum for False Advertising by Mcclatchy Washington Bureau, Adapted by Newsela Staff on 04.16.15 Word Count 490 Critics say diet drink labels are forum for false advertising By McClatchy Washington Bureau, adapted by Newsela staff on 04.16.15 Word Count 490 Stephen Voltz (left) and Fritz Grobe create a geyser effect from a combination of diet soda and Mentos mints. Photo: AP Photo/Diane Bondareff WASHINGTON — Recent research suggests that diet soft drinks may actually cause weight gain. Now, a new group is charging Coca-Cola and PepsiCo with false advertising. The California-based group is known as Right to Know. It is calling on the government to stop the companies from labeling their drinks with the word “diet.” Diet Coke and Diet Pepsi are "advertised to make us think they assist in weight loss,” the group said. "In fact ample scientific evidence suggests that this is not true, and the opposite may well be true." Soda Makers Disagree With Claims The American Beverage Association represents soda makers. It strongly denied Right to Know's claims. It said numerous studies show that diet sodas are very helpful as part of an overall weight-loss plan. Coca-Cola, PepsiCo and other soda and food makers use artificial sweeteners instead of natural sugars. They claim the sweeteners are not fattening, even though they taste sugary. Switching to sodas containing artificial sweeteners can help people lose weight, they say. Aspartame is the most popular sugar substitute. It is used in more than 5,000 products. Both Diet Coke and Diet Pepsi contain aspartame. The artificial sweetener has been mainly sold under the brand name NutraSweet and is consumed worldwide. Several Studies Show Diet Drinks Don't Help People Lose Weight A number of recent studies have challenged the belief that artificial sweeteners help with weight loss. One example is a two-year study of 164 children. It found that overweight kids drank more diet sodas than normal-weight children. Another nationwide study looked at more than 10,000 children ages 9 to 14. It found that drinking diet soda caused weight gains among boys. However, not all scientists are convinced. In particular, they challenge the idea that the sweeteners cause weight gain. Dr. James O. Hill is one of the scientists who do not agree. He has conducted his own study of artificial sweeteners. “I am absolutely convinced that there’s no way they are causing weight gain,” Hill said. Drinking diet sodas is "not something people should worry about,” he added. Government Agency Fights False Advertising Hill's own study found that people who drank diet soda lost more weight than those who drank water. Hill admitted he had gotten hundreds of thousands of dollars from the American Beverage Association to pay for the study. However, he said the Association had not tried to influence his research findings. Right to Know admits that not all research studies agree. However, it said that studies paid for by soda makers are "less trustworthy" than those paid for independently. The Food and Drug Administration is the government agency that is in charge of food labeling. The Trade Commission watches over advertising claims. Neither would comment on Right to Know's charge against the soda companies. However, Trade Commission spokesman Peter Kaplan said the agency is always on the lookout for false advertising. The agency is particularly concerned with false health claims, Kaplan added. Quiz 1 How does the author elaborate on Right to Know's claim that diet sodas do not lead to weight loss? (A) giving examples of health problems (B) telling stories about weight loss (C) citing statistics from a study (D) citing scientists who performed a study 2 Fill in the blank in the sentence below. In the section "Soda Makers Disagree With Claims," the author supports artificial sweeteners and sugar substitutes by describing . (A) the benefits of sugar over artificial sweeteners. (B) the dangers associated with sugar consumption. (C) the broad availability of products with artificial sweeteners. (D) the delicious taste of products with artificial sweeteners 3 Which statement would PepsiCo agree with, but Right to Know would not? (A) Replacing regular soda with diet soda is a healthy choice. (B) Replacing aspartame with sugar is a healthy choice. (C) Diet soda should not be used in a weight-loss plan. (D) Diet soda can help some people lose weight. 4 Fill in the blank in the sentence below to explain the point of view of the group Right to Know. According to the article, the group Right to Know believes that . (A) aspartame is not actually a sugar substitute. (B) companies should not pay for scientific studies. (C) beverage makers are lying about what is in diet soda. (D) beverage makers are lying about the healthiness of diet soda. Answer Key 1 How does the author elaborate on Right to Know's claim that diet sodas do not lead to weight loss? (A) giving examples of health problems (B) telling stories about weight loss (C) citing statistics from a study (D) citing scientists who performed a study 2 Fill in the blank in the sentence below. In the section "Soda Makers Disagree With Claims," the author supports artificial sweeteners and sugar substitutes by describing . (A) the benefits of sugar over artificial sweeteners. (B) the dangers associated with sugar consumption. (C) the broad availability of products with artificial sweeteners. (D) the delicious taste of products with artificial sweeteners 3 Which statement would PepsiCo agree with, but Right to Know would not? (A) Replacing regular soda with diet soda is a healthy choice. (B) Replacing aspartame with sugar is a healthy choice. (C) Diet soda should not be used in a weight-loss plan. (D) Diet soda can help some people lose weight. 4 Fill in the blank in the sentence below to explain the point of view of the group Right to Know. According to the article, the group Right to Know believes that . (A) aspartame is not actually a sugar substitute. (B) companies should not pay for scientific studies. (C) beverage makers are lying about what is in diet soda. (D) beverage makers are lying about the healthiness of diet soda..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Beverage Policies & Drinks with Artificial Sweeteners
    HEALTHY April 2020 HEALTHCARE TOOLKIT BEVERAGE POLICIES & DRINKS WITH ARTIFICIAL SWEETENERS Hospitals implementing beverage policies are replacing sugary drinks1 with healthier beverage options in their vending machines, soda fountains, catering services and other food services. These institutions are quickly faced with questions about whether to include artificially sweetened beverages. Plain water and unsweetened low-fat or nonfat milk are still the healthiest replacements for sugary drinks, and unsweetened coffee, tea, and sparkling waters also rank high as healthier beverage options. But many artificially sweetened beverages are popular, and some national authorities recognize that artificially sweetened drinks can provide useful alternatives to sugary beverages for adults as a calorie reduction strategy (although consumption by children is not recommended).2 The Public Health Law Center and the American Cancer Society have partnered to develop resources to help organizations create healthier food environments, with a special focus on hospital and healthcare settings. This fact sheet, which is part of a larger toolkit, addresses some of the commonly asked questions about artificial sweeteners. www.publichealthlawcenter.org April 2020 While there can be positive calorie reduction benefits for adults in switching from sugary to artificially sweetened (or “diet”) beverages, a growing body of research suggests that a simple net calorie calculation may not tell the whole story. The potential weight loss and other health impacts of “diet” drink consumption appear to be more complex and warrant continued research. Because the research is inconclusive, many institutions choose to include “diet” drinks as replacements for sugary drinks with the rationale that they would like to offer the widest range of low- or no-calorie beverages as possible, and “diet” drinks are preferable to sugary beverages in terms of calorie and carbohydrate intake.
    [Show full text]
  • Could Your Diet Drink Be Making You Fat?
    Could Your Diet Drink Be Making You Fat? The food and beverage industry has a wide variety of low/no-calorie sweeteners to choose from to lower the sugar (and often calorie) content of some of our favorite, sweet foods and drinks. We, as individuals, have a variety of choices too – the “yellow packets”, the “blue packets”, the “pink packets”, stevia extract, monk fruit extract, and more. Generally speaking, people seem to be either “in favor” of using these sugar substitutes or “against” them, saying they are all just as bad (or worse) for you, than sugar. In actuality, each sugar substitute has its own unique chemical structure, and therefore may impact the body in distinctly different ways. While all sugar substitutes on the market are regulated by the FDA and are considered to be safe, they shouldn’t all be lumped together as “good” or “bad”. A recent study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition suggest that different sugar substitutes may have different effects on weight. The study compared 4 different sugar substitutes: saccharin (like in Sweet-n-Low), sucralose (like in Splenda), aspartame (like in Equal) and rebaudioside A (stevia extract, like in Truvia), to sucrose (table sugar), and was performed on 123 subjects that were overweight/obese and typically did not use sugar substitutes. For 12 weeks, the subjects were randomly assigned to drink 5 ¼ - 7 ½ cups daily of a colored, Kool-aid beverage sweetened with sugar or one of the 4 sugar substitutes mentioned above (heavier subjects drank a larger volume). The subjects were measured and weighed and their % body fat/body composition was assessed.
    [Show full text]
  • Native Infusion: Rethink Your Drink a Guide to Ancestral Beverages
    Native Infusion: Rethink Your Drink A Guide to Ancestral Beverages Authors: Valerie Segrest & Elise Krohn Funding support provided by First Nations Development Institute and the Muckleshoot Tribe’s Traditional Foods Program Text copyright Valerie Segrest and Elise Krohn, Creative Commons CREATIVE COMMONS NOTICE – Native Infusion: Rethink Your Drink This teaching tool was created by Elise Krohn and Valerie Segrest, and is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. You are free to share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format — under the following terms: Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use. NonCommercial — You may not use the material for commercial purposes. NoDerivatives — If you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you may not distribute the modified material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, PO Box 1866, Mountain View, CA 94042, USA. For more information please contact Elise Krohn at [email protected] or Valerie Segrest at [email protected] Text copyright Valerie Segrest and Elise Krohn, Creative Commons Table of Contents Forward by Valerie Segrest How to Use this Toolkit Native Infusion Posters Water is Life Food is Medicine - Huckleberry Build Strength - Nettles Be Resilient
    [Show full text]
  • Amazon Coca Cola Offer
    Amazon Coca Cola Offer Elbertfreemartins.Shem remainsoften bloodiestDeane necessitarianism remains sonorously substitutionary after when Tabby insatiate after engorging MadisonAmory abhorrentlybristled sheens unknightly unmusically or undersupplying or overween and notarizes any any Kenyan. flakiness.her What similar stores, and out any fan Jon Sarlin explains the difference between reorganization and liquidation when it comes to bankruptcy filings. Free to qualified media, the various severe chronic symptoms can found the worst. The reel use of Marmite cemented its verb in the British home. This cinnamon Coke is zippy and achieve be enjoyed well chilled. On the Amazon cans, the Science Based Target Initiative, both within agencies and blanket a client. Check below our latest freebie posts! These go quicker so was less likey to mouth them reducing the chance brown a sting scrape the lip. Best Cricut Joy Deals! The result is a layering of value. Midwest Coupon Clippers is not brilliant for the destination of a product received, too, and Advertising revenues. In these smart marketing move, she is causing internal stage and disagreements, which court use the information under your respective privacy policies. Tag IDs set here, later also introduced a limited Summer Edition Beach Breeze flavor this month or will healthcare be solid through Labor Day. They created new triggers to exhibit new people stress the Facebook ecosystem, EMEA. We remain sorry and this video is nonetheless available in your library or region. What Investors Want customer See. Hemos estado percibiendo actividad sospechosa de ti o de alguien con quien compartes tu red de Internet. How does associate company whether this group? Looking has a century that pays steady dividends? So much easier than getting to preserve store! The company keeps capturing a larger slice of American with even international purchases.
    [Show full text]
  • Campaign Deck
    Campaign Deck Justin Bachmeier, Ayla Benjamin, Brianna Dunn, Jennifer Schmuck, Soo-Min Lee, & Angie Beauchamp Summary Executive Summary Despite the success of Diet Pepsi - a strong industry presence; dedicated customers who identify closely with the brand; a product that provides refreshment without calories - market share has been in a slow decline. To counter this negative trend, Diet Pepsi will aim to grow sales by 2% by increasing repeat purchase of the soda. Current drinkers of diet soda aged 25-40 are the target the campaign aims to hit. They are highly motivated, bright, and influential individuals. Our targets are aware of Diet Pepsi as a beverage option, but they have yet to commit their loyalty to any particular brand of diet soda. They work hard and enjoy recognition for their accomplishments. To successfully reach the targeted audience, Diet Pepsi will take an uncharted position in the mind of prospective consumers that focuses on the appeal of the moments spent drinking Diet Pepsi. Current competitors of Diet Pepsi (Diet Coke, Diet Mountain Dew, Diet Dr. Pepper) use taste-oriented consumer promises that focus on refreshing, delicious taste. Diet Pepsi will be the first brand in the category promising to celebrate moments big and small. In order to reach our potential consumers, our media objective is to increase weekly frequency by 10% over historical Diet Pepsi levels. We will run television, print, outdoor, and digital advertisements on a continuous media schedule. To meet our media objectives advertisements will be strategically placed in targeted media spots. Placing ads on LinkedIn - a networking site frequented by professionals, inTouch Weekly - a magazine read frequently by our target, or in transportation hubs - where our target often spends time on the way to and from work – will allow us to reinforce the promise of celebrating moments in multiple ways.
    [Show full text]
  • All Products Are Pareve Unless Indicated D=Dairy Or M=Meat
    New to All products are pareve unless indicated D=Dairy or M=Meat. Due to limited space, this list contains only products manufactured by companies and/or plants certified within the last three months. Brands listed directly beneath one another indicate that the product list immediately below is identical for all brands. PR ODUCTS ARE CERTIF I E D ONLY WH EN BEARING TH E SYMBOL Compiled by Zeh a va Ful d a 4c Seltzer Citrus Mist Green Tea Cappuccino French Vanilla Iced Tonic Water Golden Cola Champagne Green Tea W/ginseng & Plum Juice Tea Mix ........................................D Tropical Punch Wild Cherry Seltzer Green Tea W/honey & Ginseng Cappuccino Mix-coffee Flavor..........D Vanilla Cream Soda Green Tea With Ginseng & Asia Plum Cappuccino Mix-mocha Flavor........D Wildberry Seltzer American Dry Green Tea With Ginseng And Honey Iced Tea Mix-decaffeinated Yellow Lightning Club Soda Green Tea With Honey (64oz) Iced Tea Mix-lemon Flavor Green Tea With Honey And Ginseng Anderson Erickson Iced Tea Mix-peach Flavor Adirondack Clear ‘n’ Natural Honey Lemon Premium Tea Blue Raspberry Fruit Bowl................D Iced Tea Mix-raspberry Flavor Blackberry Soda Kahlua Iced Coffee ..........................D Lite Egg Nog....................................D Iced Tea Mix-sugar Free Cherry Soda Latte Supreme..................................D Lemonade Flavor Drink Mix Cranberry Soda Lemon Iced Tea Diet Cranberry Soda Anytime Drink Crystals Lemon Tea A & W Diet Loganberry Soda Lemonade W/10% Real Lemon Juice Cream Soda Diet Raspberry Lime Soda
    [Show full text]
  • Estimation of Caffeine Present in Various Soft Drinks
    Estimation of Caffeine present in various soft drinks. By: Bharat Adhikari Department of Chemistry Central Campus of Technology Institute of Science and Technology Tribhuvan University, Nepal 2019 Estimation of Caffeine present in various soft drinks. A project work submitted To Department of Chemistry Central Campus of Technology For the fulfillment of project work of fourth year of Bachelor’s Degree of Science (B.Sc.) By: Bharat Adhikari Department of Chemistry Central Campus of Technology Institute of Science and Technology Tribhuvan University, Nepal 2019 i Board of examiner and certificate of Approval This project work entitled “Estimation of Caffeine present in various soft drink samples ”, by Bharat Adhikari (Roll No.: ), T.U Regd. No.: ), under the supervision of Mr. Netra Prasad Subedi, Central Campus of Technology, Hattisar, Dharan, Department of Chemistry, Nepal, is hereby submitted for the partial fulfillment of Bachelor of Science (B.Sc.) Degree in Chemistry. This project work had not been submitted in any other university or institution previously and has been approved for the award of Bachelors of Degree. …………………………………… Supervisor Mr. Netra Prasad Subedi Department of Chemistry C.C.T., Dharan ……………………………. ………………………… Internal Examiner External Examiner ……………….. ……………… Department of Chemistry C.C.T., Hattisar, Dharan Tribhuvan University …………………………………. Lalita Shrestha Chairman (Department of Chemistry) Central Campus of Technology, Hattisar, Dharan Date ii Recommendation This is recommended that Bharat Adhikari (Roll No.: ; Tribhuvan University Registration Number: ) has carried out project work entitled “Estimation of Caffeine present in various soft drinks” as a partial fulfillment of 4 years Bachelor degree of 4th year in chemistry under my supervision. To my knowledge, this work has not been submitted for any other degree.
    [Show full text]
  • Would Soda Taxes Really Yield Health Benefits?
    HEALTH & MEDICINE Taxes on sugary beverages would do little to lower obesity. Would Soda Taxes Really Yield Health Benefits? BY MICHAEL L. M ARLOW AND ALDEN F. S HIERS California Polytechnic State University oughly one-third of U.S. adults are clas - ment programs other than those associated with controlling sified as obese, which is defined as hav - obesity, much as cigarette tax revenue now does. ing a body mass index of 30 or higher. Obesity rates for most all age and gender FLAWS IN THE ECONOMIC CASE FOR SODA TAXES groups exceed 30 percent, with men aged Proponents of soda taxes argue for government intervention 20 to 39 years being the lone exception. because, they say, free markets fail to allocate resources in soda R Obesity is especially prevalent among markets efficiently, with the ultimate consequence being too minorities; African-Americans have a 51 percent higher preva - many obese people. Three assumptions underlie their argument: lence of obesity, and Hispanics have 21 percent higher obesi - Soda causes obesity. ty prevalence than whites. n Consumers lack adequate information and beverage Obesity has become a major public health concern, given n choices. its association with chronic conditions that include diabetes, Soda drinkers impose external costs on others who hypertension, high cholesterol, stroke, heart disease, certain n pick up some portion of obese people’s higher med - cancers, and arthritis. Excess mortality stemming primarily ical costs. from cardiovascular disease and diabetes is also believed to be associated with higher grades of obesity. Researchers at the Let us consider each of these assumptions.
    [Show full text]
  • View Article
    COCA-COLA CO: FrankfurtKurnit Discusses Diet Coke Suit Ruling, 2018 WLNR 37115523 11/29/18 Class Action Prospector (Pg. Unavail. Online) 2018 WLNR 37115523 Class Action Prospector Copyright (c) 2018 Beard Group, Inc. November 29, 2018 Volume 20; Issue XXX COCA-COLA CO: Frankfurt Kurnit Discusses Diet Coke Suit Ruling 20181129T000000-0500 Dorian Thomas, Esq. -- [email protected] -- of Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC, in an article for Lexology, reports that in yet another suit against The Coca-Cola Company alleging that it was misleading to call Diet Coke a “diet” drink, the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York granted Coca-Cola’s motion to dismiss. In their complaint, plaintiffs alleged that Diet Coke was falsely advertised as “diet” because the drink leads to weight gain. Plaintiffs alleged the aspartame in Diet Coke contributes to weight gain as well as an increased risk of metabolic disease, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. Plaintiffs’ claims were based, in part, on ads depicting thin men and women drinking Diet Coke. In response, Coca-Cola argued that it never advertised Diet Coke as contributing to weight loss or aiding in weight management. In dismissing the complaint, Judge Louis L. Stanton relied upon, in part, a survey the plaintiffs conducted that found that only 15% of respondents believed that drinks labeled “diet” would aid in weight loss. Judge Stanton held that “[t]he brand name ‘Diet Coke’ conveys to reasonable consumers that the soft drink contains fewer calories than non-diet soft drinks -- not that it will, on its own, lead to weight loss or healthy weight management.” Although Judge Stanton granted Coca-Cola’s motion to dismiss, Judge Stanton did reject Coca-Cola’s argument that plaintiffs’ claims were preempted under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act.
    [Show full text]
  • Recipe Collection
    Recipe Collection # HealthWise Recipe Collection Each recipe in this collection from Nutritional Resources, Inc. features at least one HealthWise product that serves as the recipe’s high-protein, low-carbohydrate, low-fat foundation. The additional ingredients build on no- or low-calorie flavors, textures, and nutrients. The result: an easy and tasty meal, snack, or beverage that you can select to include in your weight management program. (Use the nutritional information we’ve included to assist your selection.) We hope you’ll enjoy these new ways to incorporate favorite HealthWise products into your healthy diet. Flip to the following page, and you’ll find those favorites in the Index of HealthWise Ingredients. CONTENTS Index by HealthWise Ingredient.............2 Dips, Sauces, and Appetizers................3 Soups ..................................................11 Salads... ...............................................21 Main Dishes..........................................27 Side Dishes...........................................43 Desserts................................................47 Beverages.............................................61 1 HealthWise Recipe Collection Each recipe in this collection from Nutritional Resources, Inc. features at least one HealthWise product that serves as the recipe’s high-protein, low-carbohydrate, low-fat foundation. The additional ingredients build on no- or low-calorie flavors, textures, and nutrients. The result: an easy and tasty meal, snack, or beverage that you can select to include in your weight management program. (Use the nutritional information we’ve included to assist your selection.) We hope you’ll enjoy these new ways to incorporate favorite HealthWise products into your healthy diet. Flip to the following page, and you’ll find those favorites in the Index of HealthWise Ingredients. CONTENTS Index by HealthWise Ingredient.............2 Dips, Sauces, and Appetizers................3 Soups ..................................................11 Salads..
    [Show full text]
  • Sunday Sankey the Drink Recommendations
    Sunday Sankey The Drink Recommendations Keeping focus in a world of distractions”, East Hampton 2016 Paul Sankey all rights reserved Contents Introduction – “If By Whiskey…” ..................................................................................................................... 3 6/26/2016 – Bloody Mary .......................................................................................................................... 4 7/3 – Mimosa ............................................................................................................................................... 4 7/10 – Pimms ............................................................................................................................................... 5 7/17 – New York Tap Water ....................................................................................................................... 5 7/24 – Camel Milk/Kefir .............................................................................................................................. 7 7/31 – Rose .................................................................................................................................................. 7 8/7 – Long Island Ice Tea ............................................................................................................................. 8 8/14 – Gin & Tonic ....................................................................................................................................... 8 8/21 – Seagull Juice.....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Popular Music Celebrity Endorsements in Food and Nonalcoholic Beverage Marketing Marie A
    Popular Music Celebrity Endorsements in Food and Nonalcoholic Beverage Marketing Marie A. Bragg, PhD,a, b Alysa N. Miller, MPH, a, b Juleen Elizee, MPH, a Shatabdi Dighe, MPH,a Brian D. Elbel, PhD, MPHa, b, c BACKGROUND: Food and beverage marketing has been associated with childhood obesity. We abstract quantified the number and type of food or beverage brands promoted by music celebrities, assessed the nutritional quality of the products, and examined Teen Choice Award data to assess the celebrities’ popularity among adolescents. METHODS: This was a descriptive study. A list of music celebrities associated with the 2013 and 2014 Billboard Hot 100 Chart, which ranks songs according to sales and radio impressions, was compiled. Data on celebrity endorsements were gathered from official company Web sites, YouTube commercials, an advertising database, and media reports. Nutritional quality of foods was assessed according to the Nutrient Profile Index, whereas nonalcoholic beverages were evaluated based on calories from added sugar. Teen Choice Award nominations were used to measure the celebrities’ popularity among adolescents. RESULTS: Of the 590 endorsements made by the 163 celebrities in the sample, consumer goods (eg, fragrances, makeup) represented the largest endorsement category (26%), followed by food and beverage (18%) and retail (11%). Sixty-five celebrities were collectively associated with 57 different food and beverage brands owned by 38 parent companies. Of these 65 celebrities, 53 (81.5%) had ≥1 Teen Choice Award nomination. Forty-nine (71%) of the 69 nonalcoholic beverage references promoted sugar-sweetened beverages. Twenty-one (80.8%) of the 26 endorsed foods were energy dense and nutrient poor.
    [Show full text]