In Self-Defence Seen at This Time of Year
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
the times | Thursday February 15 2018 1G M 27 Leading articles Daily Universal Register Spain: Philip Hammond, the chancellor, meets Luis de Guindos, the economy minister of Spain, in Madrid. Nature notes Flocks of redwings are some of the largest flocks to be In Self-Defence seen at this time of year. Where the fields are snowy, Privacy campaigners have no business undermining press freedom these wintering thrushes with scarlet underwings have come and the rule of law, however deep their pockets into woods to look for food among the leaf litter on the woodland floor. There may be The Data Protection Act 1998 was passed by proceedings or present debate on press regulation the state via royal charter and the press as many as 100 of them going up and down parliament to protect personal data from misuse is another matter. It is an attack on press freedom recognition panel, but not of a single major news- between the treetops and the ground. They in an age when more and more of it is accessible generally and on the freedom of the press to paper or broadcaster. Ipso is independent and often get noticed first by their soft, clucking, online to any company, government or hacker express opinions in particular. Both are hard won, successfully regulates hundreds of local and nasally calls, a call often unmentioned in who knows how and where to look. It was not easily eroded and central to the functioning of a national titles. One of the peers seeking to use the bird books. They can also be seen in sheep passed to muzzle the press. free society. Data Protection Bill to strengthen Impress, Lord fields where the first lambs are about to be The act is nonetheless being used by lawyers for The details of Mr Mosley’s complaints are Skidelsky, is a close friend and Oxford University born. Some of the hawfinches that invaded the privacy campaigner and former Formula One complex, verging on arcane, but they boil down to contemporary of Mr Mosley’s. He is also the us last November are also forming large boss Max Mosley to do just that. They have written an assertion that the public does not have a right author of a flattering biography of Mr Mosley’s flocks. There have been an astonishing 170 to newspapers including this one demanding that to know that he has donated some £3 million to father, Sir Oswald Mosley, the wartime leader of of them in Bramblehall Wood near Box Hill they stop publishing new stories, and purge their support Impress, the country’s only state-backed the British Union of Fascists. in Surrey. Small parties and single birds are online archives of old ones, on two subjects. Those regulator, via a charity set up in his late son’s name; If it appears self-serving for The Times to give still numerous, many in churchyard yew subjects are a tabloid sting in 2008 that led to a and that to this extent the regulator is reliant on prominence to a dispute such as this, that is trees. derwent may court case that Mr Mosley won, and his his largesse. The public has a right to know this because it is. But it is also emphatically in the subsequent decision to financially back the regardless of the wider context, but the wider public interest for the free press to defend itself. Birthdays today government’s preferred press regulator, Impress. context is significant. If the law can be used by people of means to After what was deemed a violation of his An updated version of the Data Protection Act, persuade the press that a quiet life is preferable to privacy, Mr Mosley sought and won legal redress the Data Protection Bill 2017, is currently before legitimate scrutiny, then the rule of law is at risk. It Claire Bloom, pictured, nine years ago. His decision since then to devote the House of Lords. Peers more concerned about is no coincidence that democracy and the free press actress, Limelight (1952), time and money to the causes of privacy and press privacy than press freedom have tabled have grown in tandem over the past two and a half 87; John Adams, regulation is of course entirely within his rights. amendments that would distort the legislation’s centuries. They need each other. Nor is it by chance minimalist composer and Others have joined him, notably the actor Hugh true purpose not just on an ad-hoc basis, as Mr that Vladimir Putin’s first target as he consolidated Pulitzer prizewinner, 71; Grant, and their efforts are part of a broader Mosley seeks to do, but permanently. If passed, the power in Russia was the country’s most popular Dame Frances Ashcroft, balancing act that any free society must foster amendments would bolster the power of Impress independent TV station. The traditions and professor of physiology, between privacy and openness. and its code of conduct for editors, and undermine liberties of a vibrant free press occasionally leave University of Oxford, 66; Enlisting a law never intended for the purpose those of the Independent Press Standards bruises but they serve the common good, and they Clive Aslet, author, The Birdcage (2014), 63; to try to prevent reporting on past public court Organisation (Ipso). Impress has the backing of cannot be taken for granted. Mick Avory, drummer, the Kinks, 74; Sir Tim Barrow, permanent representative to the EU, ambassador to Russia (2011-16), 54; Marisa Berenson, actress, Cabaret (1972), 71; Adam Boulton, Sky News presenter, 59; Bye Bye Bibi Susan Brownmiller, writer, Against Our Will (1975), 83; Prof Edward Byrne, president and principal, King’s College London, 66; The Israeli premier should step down to answer accusations of corruption Ali Campbell, singer, UB40, Red Red Wine (1983), 59; Sir Mick Davis, chief executive Israel stands out in the Middle East as a country sifted the evidence and decided whether to press inquiries. At the time Mr Olmert noted that “the and treasurer, Conservative Party, 60; that respects the rule of law. As Israeli police were the charges. His supporters suggest that this prime minister is not above the law”. He ended up Nathan Davis, jazz musician, 81; Frank recommending that the prime minister, Binyamin would be a precarious moment to paralyse the serving 16 months of a 27-month jail sentence. Dunlop, founder (1960), the Pop Theatre, Netanyahu, be indicted on bribery charges, their Israeli government. An Israeli fighter was shot Throughout this upheaval, Mr Netanyahu, then Edinburgh, 91; Ben Foakes, cricketer, Surrey Egyptian counterparts were cracking down on down last weekend over Syria in a mission that was the opposition leader, fiercely argued that a prime and England, 25; Dr Philip Goodwin, chief critics of President Sisi. Israel’s readiness to hold to supposed to block attempts by the Iranian-backed minister buried “up to his neck in investigations” executive, Voluntary Service Overseas account its leaders should be an object lesson to its Hezbollah to launch surveillance and attack could not give full attention to government. International, 53; Rt Rev Jonathan Gledhill, authoritarian neighbours. drones over the border. The Syrian war, which That comment will come back to haunt the Bishop of Lichfield (2003-15), 69; Lord There can, however, be no room for complacency. already pits Turks against US-backed opposition Israeli leader unless he recognises that staying in (Leslie) Griffiths of Burry Port, president, The two cases against Mr Netanyahu follow a forces, Russia against the US and Saudi versus power turns him into a lame duck. He may hope Methodist Conference (1994-95), 76; Matt thorough 14-month investigation and are destined Qatari-backed rebels, is now increasingly a stand- that he can bluster his way to the formal end of his Groening, creator, TV series The Simpsons, to shake up Israeli politics. One case alleges that he off between Israel and Iranian surrogate forces. tenure in November 2019. He may even count on 64; Desmond Haynes, cricketer, West Indies tried to promote the interests of an Israeli busi- Mr Netanyahu has made the struggle against the winning an early election and silencing his critics (1978-94), 62; Richard Hone, QC, Old Bailey nessman in return for generous gifts. The second Iranian regime a defining part of his premiership with the help of hefty popular support. judge (2005-17), 71; Miranda July, artist and claims that Mr Netanyahu discussed changes in and it forms a crucial binding ligament between Mr Netanyahu has brushed off scandal before film-maker, Me and You and Everyone We the regulation of Israeli media law that would have Israel and the administration of President Trump. and survived. There is, though, no disguising the Know (2005), 44; Sir Timothy Kerr, High benefited a newspaper in return for “indefinite” The resignation of Mr Netanyahu could send fact that he is a wounded leader and that will Court judge, 60; Sir Jonathan Marsden, positive political coverage. The prime minister has out a signal of weakness in the midst of a swirling weaken him in the eyes of his Middle Eastern director of the Royal Collection, 58; Keith denied the police interpretation of the various international crisis. Yet step down, he must. rivals and enemies, as well as diminishing the Ridge, chief pharmaceutical officer, NHS meetings and has branded it a witch-hunt. A key Like any citizen the prime minister is innocent pivotal US-Israeli relationship. Mr Netanyahu is England, 56; Martin Rowson, cartoonist, 59; witness, it now emerges, is the centrist politician until proven guilty, but his is a difficult enough role not short of courage.