Social Safeguard Due Diligence Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Social Safeguard Due Diligence Review November 2019 Lao People’s Democratic Republic: Greater Mekong Subregion East-West Economic Corridor Agriculture Infrastructure Sector Project Prepared by the Department of Irrigation, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry and the Asian Development Bank. This social safeguard due diligence review is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “terms of use” section of this website. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. Lao People’s Democratic Republic Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry Department of Irrigation LAO: GMS East-West Economic Corridor Agriculture Infrastructure Sector Project ADB - Loan No. 3024-Lao (SF) Social Safeguard Due Diligence Review: Phase 1 Subprojects Prepared by the international social safeguard consultant for the National Project Management Office, Department of Irrigation, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry for the Government of Lao PDR and the Asian Development Bank. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of the NPMO. Vientiane, November 2019 ABBREVIATIONS ADB - Asian Development Bank AP/AH - affected person/affected household DAFO - Department of Agriculture and Forestry Office DCO - District Coordination Office DED - detailed engineering design DMS - detailed measurement survey DOI - Department of Irrigation EA - executing agency EWEC-AISP - GMS East-west Economic Corridor Agriculture Infrastructure Sector Project PAFO - Provincial Agriculture and Forestry Office GMS - Greater Mekong Subregion GoL - Government of Lao PDR IA - implementing agency LACP - land acquisition and compensation plan LACR - land acquisition and compensation report LAK - Lao Kip LAR - land acquisition and resettlement LIC - loan implementation consultants MAF - Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry NPMO - National Project Management Office PAFO - Provincial Agriculture and Forestry Office PIB - project information brochure PPMO - Provincial Project Management Office ROW - right of way RP - resettlement plan WUG - water users’ group WEIGHTS AND MEASURES ha - hectare km - kilometer lm - linear meter m - meter m2 - square meter i CONTENTS I. Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 3 II. Description of the Subprojects ....................................................................................... 4 III. Land Acquisition per the LACRs ..................................................................................... 5 A. Bungxe Subproject ................................................................................................ 5 B. Phanomxay Subproject .......................................................................................... 6 C. Vapy Neau Subproject ........................................................................................... 6 IV. Site Visits ............................................................................................................. 7 A. Bungxe Subproject ................................................................................................ 7 B. Phanomxay Subproject .......................................................................................... 8 C. Vapy Neau Subproject ........................................................................................... 9 V. Analysis and Discussion ................................................................................................10 VI. Lesson Learned and Follow-up Actions Required ...........................................12 VII. Conclusion ..........................................................................................................12 Appendix 1 Voluntary Donation Forms ..........................................................................13 Appendix 2 Master List of Bungxe Subproject AHs ......................................................42 Appendix 3 Land Losses of Bungxe Subproject AHs ...................................................43 Appendix 4 Master List of Phanomxay Subproject AHs ...............................................44 Appendix 5 Land Losses of Phanomxay Subproject AHs ............................................46 Appendix 6 Master List of Vapy Neau Subproject AHs .................................................51 Appendix 7 Land Losses of Vapy Neau AHs ..................................................................53 Appendix 8 DDR Mission Meeting in Bungxe Village, 23 September 2019 ..................57 Appendix 9 DDR Mission Meeting in Phanomxay Village, 23 September 2019 ...........60 Appendix 10 DDR Mission Meeting in Vapy Neau Village, 25 September 2019 .............64 LIST OF TABLES Table I-1 Subprojects of EWEC-AISP ........................................................................................ 3 Table III-1 Basic Information on Bungxe AH Heads ................................................................... 5 Table III-2 Basic Information on Phanomxay AH Heads ............................................................. 6 Table III-3 Basic Information on Vapy Neau AH Heads .............................................................. 7 LIST OF FIGURES Figure I-1: Project Location Map ................................................................................................ 4 ii I. Introduction 1. The Government of Lao People’s Democratic Republic (GoL) is implementing the GMS East-west Economic Corridor Agriculture Infrastructure Sector Project (EWEC-AISP) in the provinces of Savannakhet and Salavan. The Asian Development Bank (ADB) is supporting the project through Loan 3024-Lao (SF).1 The EWEC-AISP aims to regenerate and upgrade existing but underdeveloped and outdated agriculture infrastructure facilities that include pumping stations, weirs, canals, control structures, farm access roads and bridges. The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (MAF) is the executing agency (EA), assisted by the Department of Irrigation (DOI) that put up a National Project Management Office (NPMO) in Vientiane. The provincial governments of Savannakhet and Salavan are the implementing agencies (IAs), each assisted by a Provincial Project Management Office (PPMO). The District Coordination Office (DCO) at the District Agriculture and Forestry Office (DAFO) of each participating district provides support to the PPMO. The EWEC-AISP is being implemented in 3 phases, with 3 subprojects in Phase 1 (commenced in 2016) and 12 subprojects in Phase 2 (with 6 subprojects commencing in 2017-2018). Phase 3 has not yet started and 10 subprojects are being considered for inclusion. 2. This due diligence review (DDR) report covers the 3 subprojects in Phase 1 that were completed in 2017. The report will (1) look into the scope of project impacts, (2) check on how land acquisition was planned and executed, and (3) suggest actions that need to be undertaken to correct any outstanding social issues. It is hoped that lessons could be drawn from the findings of this report that would help project authorities improve resettlement planning and implementation in subsequent subprojects of the AISP. Table I-1 Subprojects of EWEC-AISP Phase Subproject Province District Phase Sub-project Province 1 Bungxe Savannakhet Xaybouli 3* Phouheau-sao-va Savannakhet Phanomxay Savannakhet Phalanxay Dan Savanh Savannakhet Vapy Neua Salavan Vapi Had-kham Dee Savannakhet 2 Group 1 Bungtalae Savannakhet Nathuen Salavan Khongxedon Nakang-xe Savannakhet Keng Houat Salavan Khongxedon Heuane-hine Savannakhet Gnotbak Savannakhet Champhon Sout-ta-vali Salavan Dong Boun Savannakhet Xonbouri Houay lath Salavan Dong Savang Thong Savannakhet Songkhon Vapy tai Salavan Houay Thouat Savannakhet Champhon Chalan Xe Salavan Group 2* Kan Tha Chane* Savannakhet Xaiphouthong Phak kha * Savannakhet Kaysone Prom Na tur * Savannakhet Virabouri Houay Sa Khouang* Savannakhet Phin Na Khoi Sao* Salavan Salvan Dong Mon* Salavan Vapi NOTE: * Has not yet commenced. 1 Loan 3024 was signed on 11 October 2013 and became effective on 7 November 2013. Project closing date is on 31 December 2019 while loan closing date is on 30 June 2022. 3 II. Description of the Subprojects 3. The Bungxe Subproject, located in Xayabouli District of Savannakhet Province, involved the rehabilitation and improvement of the Bungxe pump irrigation system and farm access roads. Rehabilitated or constructed under the subproject were 1 pump station; 2 main irrigation canals (3,703 m long); 7 secondary irrigation canals (8,033 m); 11 tertiary irrigation canals (5,857 m); 4 main drains (5,776 m); 227 ancillary structures (including farm turnouts, divisions, road crossings, culverts, flumes, side spillways, and end structures); and 3 farm roads (5,060 m). The subproject was envisaged to increase the area of dry weather irrigated farms to about 230 ha. 4. The Phanomxay Subproject, located in Phalanxay District of Savannakhet Province, involved the rehabilitation and improvement of the Phanomxay pump irrigation system and farm access roads. Rehabilitated or constructed under the subproject were 1 pump station; 2 main irrigation canals (2,720 m long); 6 secondary