Race, Gender and Colonialism: Public Life Among the Six Nations of Grand River, 1899-1939
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Race, Gender and Colonialism: Public Life among the Six Nations of Grand River, 1899-1939 by Alison Elizabeth Norman A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Theory and Policy Studies in Education Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto © Copyright by Alison Norman 2010 Race, Gender and Colonialism: Public Life among the Six Nations of Grand River, 1899-1939 Alison Norman Doctor of Philosophy Department of Theory and Policy Studies Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto 2010 Abstract Six Nations women transformed and maintained power in the Grand River community in the early twentieth century. While no longer matrilineal or matrilocal, and while women no longer had effective political power neither as clan mothers, nor as voters or councillors in the post-1924 elective Council system, women did have authority in the community. During this period, women effected change through various methods that were both new and traditional for Six Nations women. Their work was also similar to non-Native women in Ontario. Education was key to women‘s authority at Grand River. Six Nations women became teachers in great numbers during this period, and had some control over the education of children in their community. Children were taught Anglo-Canadian gender roles; girls were educated to be mothers and homemakers, and boys to be farmers and breadwinners. Children were also taught to be loyal British subjects and to maintain the tradition of alliance with Britain that had been established between the Iroquois and the English in the seventeenth century. With the onset of the Great War in 1914, Six Nations men and women responded with gendered patriotism, again, in ways that were both similar to Anglo-Canadians, and in ways that ii were similar to traditional Iroquois responses to war; men fought and women provided support on the home-front. Women‘s patriotic work at home led to increased activity in the post-war period on the reserve. Six Nations women made use of social reform organizations and voluntary associations to make improvements in their community, particularly after the War. The Women‘s Institutes were especially popular because they were malleable, practical, and useful for rural women‘s needs. Women exerted power through these organizations, and effected positive change on the reserve. iii Acknowledgments Many people have supported the research and writing of this dissertation through various means. First and foremost, Cecilia Morgan pushed me in the direction of the Six Nations of the Grand River, without which, I would not have done this project. Her helpful suggestions, careful editing and thoughtful questions made my work stronger and made me a better historian. Ruth Sandwell‘s enthusiasm and Ian Radforth‘s questions at several committee meetings made this a much improved thesis. Heidi Bohaker‘s early help with advice on organizing my work and about forming a writing group were crucial to this project‘s success. Jarvis Brownlie‘s comments and suggestions clarified some important points and reinforced my belief in the importance of my project. Jane Errington‘s early support of my interests during my Master‘s was one of the chief reasons I chose to pursue doctoral studies after completing my Bachelor of Education. I also wish to thank the numerous kind historians in Canada and beyond who replied to email enquiries and were beyond generous with their time and their research. Their help is evidence of the generosity of spirit within the Canadian history community. I wish to thank the people of Six Nations who welcomed me and were interested in my work. Many individuals were generous with their time and their resources, particularly at the Ohsweken Genealogy Society and the Woodland Cultural Centre. Researching Six Nations family histories would not have been possible without the help of the community itself, particularly Tammy Martin of the Ohsweken Genealogy Society. Marion Press of the Education Commons at OISE was also especially helpful with my investigation of Scottish and English families. I also wish to thank Virve Wiland, the librarian of the Woodland Cultural Centre for her kind assistance and support over several years of research trips. Spencer Alexander of Buxton, Ontario, Sarah Innes of Elie, Scotland and William Milne-Home of Sydney, Australia generously shared their families with iv me. Many friends provided me with a place to stay while I visited archives, especially Karie Rippin in Guelph, Kerry Pfahl, Delphine Merven and Laura Schneider in Ottawa, Mayu Nishimura in Hamilton, and Abbey Peters in Peterborough. Finally, I wish to acknowledge that this research was funded by Ontario Graduate Scholarship, and the Department of Theory and Policy Studies in Education of the University of Toronto. This project benefited from the support of many colleagues and friends. I began as the only PhD student in the program in my year, and was beyond thrilled when Jennifer Bonnell arrived the following year so that we could get through this degree together. Jennifer, along with Kristine Alexander and Robin Grazley provided much needed stress relief in our ―off campus meetings.‖ The Toronto Area Women‘s Canadian History Group has been a place of support and encouragement for all of us who have attended our monthly potluck dinners since the Fall of 2005, myself included. The members of the Larkin Group: Cara Spittal, Susana Miranda, Ariel Beaujot, Nathan Smith and Denis McKim offered helpful criticisms, questions and suggestions for my work, as well as a place to enjoy the occasional Portuguese tart or pint! I also realize how lucky I am to have friends outside of school who supported my efforts, including Sara Kemp, Tara Scott, and the Bonnies girls. Finally, I could not have completed this project without the support of my family. My parents provided encouragement and support (financial and otherwise) and only occasionally asked when I might be finished. My siblings, in-laws, nieces and nephews made sure that I maintained a good work-life balance throughout my graduate schools years and I was a happier person as a result! My younger sister Amy joined me in the pursuit of a PhD a few years ago, and it is has been very special to be able to slog it out together. Lastly, my partner Derek Flack edited much of my work, offered support, and challenged me while also providing necessary distractions over the years. v Table of Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgments...........................................................................................................................iv Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................vi List of Tables ................................................................................................................................ vii List of Figures .............................................................................................................................. viii Introduction ......................................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1 ―Time shows that given a chance, Indian children can go far in education:‖ Schooling at Grand River Schools .................................................................................................................42 Chapter 2 ―The woman is the civilizer:‖ Gender and Education at Grand River Schools .............................98 Chapter 3 ―To cultivate a patriotic interest in their county:‖ Teaching Empire in Grand River Schools ....155 Chapter 4 ―In Defence of the Empire‖: Gendered Patriotism and the Great War .......................................188 Chapter 5 ―We decided that something must be done:‖ Social Reform, Voluntary Associations, and Community Work on the Reserve ...........................................................................................251 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................310 Appendices...................................................................................................................................323 vi List of Tables Table 1: Teachers at Six Nations Day Schools by Gender ........................................................325 Table 2: Teachers at Six Nations Day Schools by Race..............................................................326 vii List of Figures Figure 1. Emily General, Chauncey Garlow and Dora Jamieson, Hampstead England, 1930. ......1 Figure 2: Map of Six Nations of Grand River (1985)....................................................................48 Figure 3: The Alexander family.....................................................................................................84 Figure 4: Ethel and Nina Mae Alexander at the No. 2 School ......................................................86 Figure 5: Ethel and Nina Mae with their students at Six Nations..................................................87 Figure 6: Ethel Alexander in Belize...............................................................................................91 Figure 7: No. 2 School, Ohsweken. ...........................................................................................115