NATURE|Vol 440|9 March 2006

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

NATURE|Vol 440|9 March 2006 9.3 News & Views MH NEW 6/3/06 9:42 AM Page 162 NEWS & VIEWS NATURE|Vol 440|9 March 2006 OBITUARY Richard Dalitz (1925–2006) Particle physicist and creator of the Dalitz plot. Richard Henry Dalitz was a giant in the field it decayed into two pions, whereas the tau of particle physics. A theorist who always decayed into three. Using his plot, he was endeavoured to work close to experiment, able to establish that the tau, like the theta, his contributions over 60 years shed vital has zero spin, so that the two particles light on the nature of the fundamental could not be identical if parity holds. forces and the constituents of matter. (Parity is the idea that reactions proceed Born in the small wheat-belt town the same way when all spatial coordinates of Dimboola, northwest of Melbourne, are reversed.) Indeed, this ‘tau–theta’ puzzle Australia, Dalitz gained degrees in both was the first indication that parity did not mathematics and physics at the University of hold for interactions involving the weak Melbourne. Awarded a travelling scholarship, nuclear force. The subsequent realization he moved in 1946 with his wife Valda to by T. D. Lee and C. N. Yang that this could England, to study for a PhD under Nicholas indeed be the case won them the 1957 Kemmer at Trinity College, Cambridge. Nobel Prize in Physics. There he benefited from the teaching of After brief periods at Cornell University in Paul Dirac, whose lecture course on quantum Ithaca, New York, and back at Birmingham, mechanics he attended twice. After two years, in 1956 Dalitz accepted a professorship at the he ran short of funds and, with a small child Enrico Fermi Institute in Chicago. Working to support, moved to a one-year post as with Riccardo Levi-Setti, he developed what assistant to Nevill Mott at the University became a lifetime interest, often pursued strange particles, whose unusual properties of Bristol. In retrospect, Dalitz considered in collaboration with Avraham Gal, in are now attributed to the presence of at this year at Bristol vital to his subsequent the recently discovered hypernuclei, in which least one ‘strange’ quark in their make-up research: there he first learned from the a strange particle takes the place of a proton that hampers their decay, as well as states G.-C. WICK/AIP group of Cecil Powell about elementary or neutron. that contain the heavier quarks ‘charm’ particle physics and the ‘strange’ particles In 1963, Dalitz was persuaded by Peierls and ‘bottom’. (so named because they left unusual tracks in to return to Britain and join him at the The quark model was the foundation the emulsions used to detect them) produced University of Oxford as a Royal Society of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), in cosmic-ray collisions. He started to think research professor and, from 1964, a fellow the comprehensive theory of the strong particularly about the nature of one of these, of All Souls College. At Oxford, Dalitz nuclear force that depicts quarks as being the ‘tau meson’, or ǻ+, as it is now known. continued his work on the resonant states held together by the exchange of gluons Dalitz was invited by Rudolf Peierls to the that were being discovered in ever-larger — analogues of the photons of the University of Birmingham in 1949, where numbers — often through the use of electromagnetic force — which are coupled his encounters with Freeman Dyson Dalitz plots. These states could be grouped to a new ‘colour’ charge. Dalitz first heard of proved most useful for his mastery of according to their mass, spin and parity into colour in a talk by Gell-Mann and recognized the quantum-electrodynamical methods families of eight and ten. Murray Gell-Mann that it resolved some profound problems that Richard Feynman was then developing dubbed this the ‘eightfold way’, and proposed associated with the quark model. The success to describe electromagnetic interactions. that the pattern could be explained if of this model once colour was included set After completing his thesis, which was on the resonances were combinations of the scene for the subsequent development transitions between spin states in the oxygen fundamental building-blocks of fractional of QCD. Dalitz’s interest in the quark model nucleus, Dalitz was finally able to concentrate electric charge — quarks, as he named them. continued all his working life. In 1992, with on particle physics and study of the tau. At the time, most physicists considered Gary Goldstein, he developed a method The result was two seminal contributions quarks as merely a mathematical tool. still in use today, to determine the detailed that bear his name: the study of the decay of Boldly, Dalitz pursued the possibility that properties of the ‘top’ quark, the last of the the neutral pion (one of the lightest mesons, they might be real dynamical objects, and, six types of quark to be found. a class of particles now identified as in a remarkable paper presented in Tokyo A fellow of the Royal Society and recipient quark–antiquark pairings) to a photon in 1965, showed how different combinations of many honours, among them the Hughes and an electron–positron, or ‘Dalitz’, pair; of three tightly bound ‘up’ and ‘down’ quarks Medal and Royal Medal of the Royal Society, and the development of the ‘Dalitz plot’. explained many properties of the proton and ‘Dick’ Dalitz never lost his appetite for This plot presents the kinematic variables neutron. He further proposed that the quark physics. He remained an active member of of the three-body final state of a reaction model could describe not only these ground the theoretical-physics department at Oxford in two dimensions. This allowed so-called states, but also the multitude of higher- after his retirement in 1990, always keen to resonances — transient states that flag energy resonant states. encourage students to share in his passion for their existence through their decay to At Oxford, Dalitz established a flourishing physics. He died on 13 January 2006, and is final-state particles of definite total energy research programme to study the quark survived by his wife, son and three daughters. — to be readily visible. model, and attracted many senior physicists Graham Ross Dalitz was interested in the difference and students to it. Their work, and work Graham Ross is in the Rudolf Peierls Centre for between the tau and another strange worldwide, has shown that all particles found Theoretical Physics, University of Oxford, particle, the theta, which seemed to be the then and since fit well with quark-model 1 Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3NP, UK. tau’s identical twin except for the fact that predictions. This encompasses the original e-mail: [email protected] 162 © 2006 Nature Publishing Group © 2006 Nature Publishing Group .
Recommended publications
  • Nucleon Resonances and Quark Structure
    Nucleon Resonances and Quark Structure J.T. Londergan Physics Dept and Nuclear Theory Center, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA. [email protected] (Dated: October 25, 2018) A pedagogical review of the past 50 years of study of resonances, leading to our understanding of the quark content of baryons and mesons. The level of this review is intended for undergraduates or first-year graduate students. Topics covered include: the quark structure of the proton as revealed through deep inelastic scattering; structure functions and what they reveal about proton structure; and prospects for further studies with new and upgraded facilities, particularly a proposed electron- ion collider. Keywords: I. INTRODUCTION These lectures were given at Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh India, at a nuclear physics workshop attended by Indian graduate students and postdocs. These lectures provide a pedagogical review of the past 50 years of experimental and theoretical studies of the quark and gluon structure of the nucleon. Since many speakers at this workshop will discuss structure functions extracted from deep inelastic scattering reactions, we define these quantities and review what can be extracted from them. We hope that specialists in this field will tolerate our brief and superficial summary of many years' study of strongly-interacting systems. FIG. 1: Richard H. Dalitz, 1925-2006. arXiv:0907.3431v1 [hep-ph] 20 Jul 2009 These lectures are dedicated to my mentor, Richard Dalitz, who was from 1963-2000 Royal Society Professor of Physics at Oxford University and who made seminal contributions in particle phenomenology. Dalitz pairs (electron- positron pairs from decay of a high-energy photon) and the Dalitz plot were named after him.
    [Show full text]
  • Standard Model Festival
    Standard Model festival The Hamburg Lepîon-Photon Symposium also marked the tenth anniversary of the discovery at Fermilab of the upsilon particle (beauty quark and antiquark bound together). At a Fermilab celebration of the discovery earlier this year were (left to right) Alvin Tollestrup, Sandy Anderson (with balloon), Hwa Yoh, Leon Lederman, Janine Tollestrup, Drummond Rennie, Martyl Langsdorf and Vivian Bull. The 'Standard Model' of modern particle physics, with the quantum chromodynamics (QCD) theory of inter-quark forces superimposed on the unified electroweak picture, is still unchallenged, but it is not the end of physics. This was the message at the big International Symposium on Lepton and Photon Interactions at High Energies, held in Hamburg from 27-31 July. The conference is a celebration of the Standard Model', admitted Graham Ross of Oxford, given the task of looking beyond. He pointed out a few interesting clouds on the horizon, and echoed the in­ creasing belief that experiments at higher collision energies (1000 GeV for constituent quarks inside nucléons or for electrons) would probe deep inside the Standard Model and reveal some­ thing new. Carlo Rubbia of CERN flew in at the end of the meeting with some suggestions for future machines to explore these far horizons. 'However our preoccupation with high energy should not exclude other interesting topics,' he warned, mentioning solar neutrino dronic events per day, and are plained single muons accompany­ studies, particle mixing, CP viola­ providing interesting new informa­ ing produced hadrons, reported tion, the search for proton decay tion to take over where the elec­ by some studies at the PETRA ring and supernova detection ('We tron-positron machines at Stanford at DESY (see September issue, should be better prepared next (US) and DESY (Hamburg) left off.
    [Show full text]
  • Fellowships for US Lab Directors
    CCEMarFACES33-38 14/2/06 12:21 Page 33 FACES AND PLACES AWARDS Fellowships for US lab directors Two associate directors of US particle-physics laboratories were among the members of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) to receive awards as new fellows at the 2006 AAAS Annual Meeting in St Louis, Missouri, on 18 February. They join other leading figures in US particle physics and related fields that were elected as new fellows by the AAAS Council during 2005. Swapan Chattopadhyay, associate director for accelerators at the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility (Jefferson Lab), was awarded the distinction of fellow for his “fundamental contributions to accelerator science, including phase-space cooling, innovative collider designs and pioneering Swapan Chattopadhyay, left, and Samuel Aronson, received AAAS fellowships in February. femto-sources, and for mentoring accelerator scientists at facilities worldwide, especially in Accelerator Department, the Physics professor at the University of Chicago, was developing countries”. He is responsible for Department, the Superconducting Magnet honoured “for his exceptional research in the all aspects of Jefferson Lab’s accelerator and Division, the Instrumentation Division and the evolution of the earliest universe, explaining Free-Electron Laser (FEL) programmes, Center for Accelerator Physics. its significance to the public, and for including R&D and operations, maintenance Neil V Baggett, advisor for planning and co-founding the interdisciplinary field of and upgrades of the Continuous Electron communication in the high-energy physics particle physics and cosmology”. Beam Accelerator Facility and the FEL. programme of the Office of Science of the US Lastly, C W Francis Everitt, research professor Samuel Aronson, associate laboratory Department of Energy, was also elected as a at the Hansen Experimental Physics Laboratory director for high-energy and nuclear physics fellow.
    [Show full text]
  • Discovery of Gluon
    Discovery of the Gluon Physics 290E Seminar, Spring 2020 Outline – Knowledge known at the time – Theory behind the discovery of the gluon – Key predicted interactions – Jet properties – Relevant experiments – Analysis techniques – Experimental results – Current research pertaining to gluons – Conclusion Knowledge known at the time The year is 1978, During this time, particle physics was arguable a mature subject. 5 of the 6 quarks were discovered by this point (the bottom quark being the most recent), and the only gauge boson that was known was the photon. There was also a theory of the strong interaction, quantum chromodynamics, that had been developed up to this point by Yang, Mills, Gell-Mann, Fritzsch, Leutwyler, and others. Trying to understand the structure of hadrons. Gluons can self-interact! Theory behind the discovery Analogous to QED, the strong interaction between quarks and gluons with a gauge group of SU(3) symmetry is known as quantum chromodynamics (QCD). Where the force mediating particle is the gluon. In QCD, we have some quite particular features such as asymptotic freedom and confinement. 4 α Short range:V (r) = − s QCD 3 r 4 α Long range: V (r) = − s + kr QCD 3 r (Between a quark and antiquark) Quantum fluctuations cause the bare color charge to be screened causes coupling strength to vary. Features are important for an understanding of jet formation. Theory behind the discovery John Ellis postulated the search for the gluon through bremsstrahlung radiation in electron- proton annihilation processes in 1976. Such a process will produce jets of hadrons: e−e+ qq¯g Furthermore, Mary Gaillard, Graham Ross, and John Ellis wrote a paper (“Search for Gluons in e+e- Annihilation.”) that described that the PETRA collider at DESY and the PEP collider at SLAC should be able to observe this process.
    [Show full text]
  • UK News from CERN Issue 17: 26 March 2013
    UK news from CERN Issue 17: 26 March 2013 In this issue: LHCb’s extra dimension – seeing data in a different way An holistic approach to improving accelerator performance Educating the united nations – maintaining continuity and broadening horizons Northern Ireland Assembly visits CERN Dates for the diary LHCb’s extra dimension Precision is key. LHCb provides the opportunity Predictability can be both reassuring, and a bit for unprecedented precision – it is a detector dull. For physicists at CERN, the Standard especially built for exploiting the vast number of Model of particle physics is like a jigsaw into b and c quarks (heavy cousins of the ‘everyday’ which they are gradually fitting pieces. Some quarks you find inside protons and neutrons) pieces seem to be fitting – measurements of the produced at the LHC, which are ideal for these Higgs boson seem to be pointing towards a precision measurements. Higgs that fits beautifully. But most physicists prefer living life on the edge, and they are The b and c quarks produced in LHCb collisions hoping to find pieces that just won’t fit. This associate with other quarks to form various would mean that the Standard Model isn’t right. types of short-lived particles that decay in a And it would force a radical (and exciting) number of ways; two-body, three-body or four- rethink; one that could lead to a theory that body, with the name relating to the number of answers questions that the Standard Model pieces of particle debris produced in the leaves open. For example, why there is only explosion.
    [Show full text]
  • People and Things
    People and things Jean-Pierre Gourber will be Leader of the Miguel Virasoro becomes Director of the CERN's new LHC Division for three years from International Centre for Theoretical Physics 1 January 1996. (ICTP), Trieste. CERN elections and appointments A t its meeting on 23 June, XI CERN's governing body, the Council, decided to create an LHC Division as from 1 January 1996. The LHC Division will focus on the core activities related to the construction of the machine, namely supercon­ ducting magnets, cryogenics and vacuum together with supporting activities. Jean-Pierre Gourber was appointed Leader of the new LHC Division for three years from 1 January 1996. Council also appointed Bo Angerth as Leader of Personnel Division for three years from 1 January 1996, succeeding Willem Middelkoop. Jiri Niederle (Czech Republic) was elected Vice-President of Council for one year from 1 July 1995. tion, demonstrated that the gluons of EPS Prizes the strong interactions were a physi­ cal reality. The prestigious High Energy and The existence of such three-jet Particle Physics Prize of the Euro­ events in electron-positron collisions pean Physical Society for 1995 goes had been predicted in a pioneer to Paul Soding, Bjorn Wiik and ICTP Trieste Director CERN Theory Division paper by John Gunter Wolf of DESY and Sau Lan Ellis, Mary K. Gaillard and Graham Distinguished theorist Miguel Wu of Wisconsin for their milestone Ross. work in providing 'first evidence for Virasoro becomes Director of the There has always been keen rivalry three-jet events in electron-positron International Centre for Theoretical between the four 1979 PETRA colla­ collisions at PETRA' (DESY's elec­ Physics (ICTP), Trieste, succeeding borations - JADE, MARK-J, PLUTO tron-positron collider).
    [Show full text]
  • Mass Determination of New Particle States
    Mass Determination of New Particle States Mario A Serna Jr Wadham College University of Oxford arXiv:0905.1425v1 [hep-ph] 9 May 2009 A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Trinity 2008 This thesis is dedicated to my wife for joyfully supporting me and our daughter while I studied. Mass Determination of New Particle States Mario Andres Serna Jr Wadham College Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Trinity Term 2008 Abstract We study theoretical and experimental facets of mass determination of new particle states. Assuming supersymmetry, we update the quark and lepton mass matri- ces at the grand unification scale accounting for threshold corrections enhanced by large ratios of the vacuum expectation value of the two supersymmetric Higgs fields vu=vd ≡ tan β. From the hypothesis that quark and lepton masses satisfy a classic set of relationships suggested in some Grand Unified Theories (GUTs), we predict tan β needs to be large, and the gluino's soft mass needs to have the opposite sign to the wino's soft mass. Existing tools to measure the phase of the gluino's mass at upcoming hadron colliders require model-independent, kinematic techniques to determine the masses of the new supersymmetric particle states. The mass deter- mination is made difficult because supersymmetry is likely to have a dark-matter particle which will be invisible to the detector, and because the reference frame and energy of the parton collisions are unknown at hadron colliders. We discuss the current techniques to determine the mass of invisible particles. We review the transverse mass kinematic variable MT 2 and the use of invariant-mass edges to find relationships between masses.
    [Show full text]
  • Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory UNIVERSITY of CALIFORNIA
    t.,t(> ~Yd LBL- 2 0 7 4 7 ~ I Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA 1 . '' r, ·) t· Physics Division ·• ... ' ;..; ;] 1986 :BRARY AND -"'TS S'=r..,...f('" • Lectures given at the Summer School on 'Architecture of Fundamental Interactions', Les Houches, France, July-August 1985 THE QUEST FOR SUPERSYMMETRY I. Hinchliffe December 1985 - Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract DE-AC03-76SF00098 DISCLAIMER This document was prepared as an account of work sponsored by the United States Government. While this document is believed to contain correct information, neither the United States Government nor any agency thereof, nor the Regents of the University of California, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by its trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof, or the Regents of the University of California. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government or any agency thereof or the Regents of the University of California. "") •.~ t ~ -- December 1985 LBL-20747 Table of Contents 1. Introduction THE QUEST FOR SUPERSYMMETRY* 2. Cosmological Bounds 3. Supersymmetry in e+ e- Annihilation Lectures given at the Summer School on 'Architecture of Fundamental 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Memories of a Theoretical Physicist
    Memories of a Theoretical Physicist Joseph Polchinski Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics University of California Santa Barbara, CA 93106-4030 USA Foreword: While I was dealing with a brain injury and finding it difficult to work, two friends (Derek Westen, a friend of the KITP, and Steve Shenker, with whom I was recently collaborating), suggested that a new direction might be good. Steve in particular regarded me as a good writer and suggested that I try that. I quickly took to Steve's suggestion. Having only two bodies of knowledge, myself and physics, I decided to write an autobiography about my development as a theoretical physicist. This is not written for any particular audience, but just to give myself a goal. It will probably have too much physics for a nontechnical reader, and too little for a physicist, but perhaps there with be different things for each. Parts may be tedious. But it is somewhat unique, I think, a blow-by-blow history of where I started and where I got to. Probably the target audience is theoretical physicists, especially young ones, who may enjoy comparing my struggles with their own.1 Some dis- claimers: This is based on my own memories, jogged by the arXiv and IN- SPIRE. There will surely be errors and omissions. And note the title: this is about my memories, which will be different for other people. Also, it would not be possible for me to mention all the authors whose work might intersect mine, so this should not be treated as a reference work.
    [Show full text]
  • Dalitz Analyses: a Tool for Physics Within and Beyond the Standard
    DCPT/06/112 IPPP/06/56 DALITZ ANALYSES: A TOOL FOR PHYSICS WITHIN AND BEYOND THE STANDARD MODEL M.R. PENNINGTON Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology, Durham University, Durham DH1 3LE, United Kingdom Abstract Dalitz analyses are introduced as the method for studying hadronic decays. An accurate description of hadron final states is critical not only to an understanding of the strong coupling regime of QCD, but also to the precision extraction of CKM matrix elements. The relation of such final state interactions to scattering processes is discussed. 1 Motivation This serves as the introduction to following talks on Dalitz plot analyses. I will first remind arXiv:hep-ph/0608016v1 2 Aug 2006 you of the motivation for such analyses and discuss some aspects of how to perform them and I leave it to others to describe detailed results. We know that there is physics beyond the Standard Model but we do not yet know what this is. Insight is provided by precision measurements of the CKM matrix elements, and in particular the length of the sides and the angles of the CKM Unitarity triangle. Such measurements in heavy flavour decays probe the structure of the weak interaction at distance scales of 0.01fm. However, the detector centimetres away records mainly pions and kaons as the outcome of a typical process like B → D(→ Kππ)K decay. Consequently, the very short distance interaction we wish to study is only seen through a fog of strong interactions, in which the quarks that are created exchange gluons, bind to form hadrons and then these hadrons interact for times a 100 times longer than the basic weak interaction.
    [Show full text]
  • The Shape of Inner Space Provides a Vibrant Tour Through the Strange and Wondrous Possibility SPACE INNER
    SCIENCE/MATHEMATICS SHING-TUNG $30.00 US / $36.00 CAN Praise for YAU & and the STEVE NADIS STRING THEORY THE SHAPE OF tring theory—meant to reconcile the INNER SPACE incompatibility of our two most successful GEOMETRY of the UNIVERSE’S theories of physics, general relativity and “The Shape of Inner Space provides a vibrant tour through the strange and wondrous possibility INNER SPACE THE quantum mechanics—holds that the particles that the three spatial dimensions we see may not be the only ones that exist. Told by one of the Sand forces of nature are the result of the vibrations of tiny masters of the subject, the book gives an in-depth account of one of the most exciting HIDDEN DIMENSIONS “strings,” and that we live in a universe of ten dimensions, and controversial developments in modern theoretical physics.” —BRIAN GREENE, Professor of © Susan Towne Gilbert © Susan Towne four of which we can experience, and six that are curled up Mathematics & Physics, Columbia University, SHAPE in elaborate, twisted shapes called Calabi-Yau manifolds. Shing-Tung Yau author of The Fabric of the Cosmos and The Elegant Universe has been a professor of mathematics at Harvard since These spaces are so minuscule we’ll probably never see 1987 and is the current department chair. Yau is the winner “Einstein’s vision of physical laws emerging from the shape of space has been expanded by the higher them directly; nevertheless, the geometry of this secret dimensions of string theory. This vision has transformed not only modern physics, but also modern of the Fields Medal, the National Medal of Science, the realm may hold the key to the most important physical mathematics.
    [Show full text]
  • Dalitz Plot Analysis of the Decay B ! K
    PHYSICAL REVIEW D 74, 032003 (2006) Dalitz plot analysis of the decay B ! KKK B. Aubert,1 R. Barate,1 M. Bona,1 D. Boutigny,1 F. Couderc,1 Y. Karyotakis,1 J. P. Lees,1 V. Poireau,1 V. Tisserand,1 A. Zghiche,1 E. Grauges,2 A. Palano,3 M. Pappagallo,3 J. C. Chen,4 N. D. Qi,4 G. Rong,4 P. Wang,4 Y.S. Zhu,4 G. Eigen,5 I. Ofte,5 B. Stugu,5 G. S. Abrams,6 M. Battaglia,6 D. N. Brown,6 J. Button-Shafer,6 R. N. Cahn,6 E. Charles,6 C. T. Day,6 M. S. Gill,6 Y. Groysman,6 R. G. Jacobsen,6 J. A. Kadyk,6 L. T. Kerth,6 Yu. G. Kolomensky,6 G. Kukartsev,6 G. Lynch,6 L. M. Mir,6 P.J. Oddone,6 T. J. Orimoto,6 M. Pripstein,6 N. A. Roe,6 M. T. Ronan,6 W. A. Wenzel,6 M. Barrett,7 K. E. Ford,7 T. J. Harrison,7 A. J. Hart,7 C. M. Hawkes,7 S. E. Morgan,7 A. T. Watson,7 K. Goetzen,8 T. Held,8 H. Koch,8 B. Lewandowski,8 M. Pelizaeus,8 K. Peters,8 T. Schroeder,8 M. Steinke,8 J. T. Boyd,9 J. P. Burke,9 W. N. Cottingham,9 D. Walker,9 T. Cuhadar-Donszelmann,10 B. G. Fulsom,10 C. Hearty,10 N. S. Knecht,10 T. S. Mattison,10 J. A. McKenna,10 A. Khan,11 P. Kyberd,11 M. Saleem,11 L.
    [Show full text]