MINUTES of MEETING of STIRLING COUNCIL Held in FALLIN PRIMARY SCHOOL, LAMONT CRESCENT, FALLIN on THURSDAY 9 OCTOBER 1997 at 7.30 Pm
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STIRLING COUNCIL MINUTES of MEETING of STIRLING COUNCIL held in FALLIN PRIMARY SCHOOL, LAMONT CRESCENT, FALLIN on THURSDAY 9 OCTOBER 1997 at 7.30 pm Present:- Provost John PATERSON (in the Chair) Councillor Rob BALL Councillor Helen HODGINS Depute Provost Margaret BRISLEY Councillor Brenda HOLLIDAY Councillor Tommy BROOKES Councillor Pat KELLY Councillor Ken CAMPBELL Councillor Ian LAMBIE Councillor Tom COLL Councillor Corrie McCHORD Councillor David DAVIDSON Councillor Helen SCOTT Councillor Keith HARDING Councillor Ann STRANG Councillor Tom HAZEL Councillor Gillie THOMSON Councillor John HENDRY Councillor John WYLES In Attendance:- Mr Tom Bateman, Fleet Care Specialist, Technical and Commercial Services Mr Bill Dickson, Director of Finance and Information Services Mr Paul Doherty, Strategic Support Manager, Chief Executive’s Services Ms Carol George, Research, Performance and Quality Manager, Chief Executive’s Services Mr Bob Jack, Director of Civic Services Mr Gordon Jeyes, Director of Education Services Mr Robin Iffla, Community Safety Officer, Central Scotland Police Ms Felicity McLelland, Head of Community Support, Community Services Mr David Martin, Director of Environmental Services Ms Fiona Matheson, Committee Services Manager Mr Don Monteith, Press and PR Manager, Chief Executive’s Services Mr Tom Pollock, Area Manager, Technical and Commercial Services Ms Jill Preston, Director of Housing and Social Services Mr Bill Pritchard, Head of Policy, Chief Executive’s Services Mr Iain Robertson, Head of Planning and Resources, Education Services Apologies:- Apologies for absence were received on behalf of Councillors Ann Dickson, Arthur Ironside and Catherine Organ. URGENT BUSINESS - DONATION OF REFUSE COLLECTION VEHICLE The Provost agreed that a report concerning a request from Direct Aid to Bosnia Herzegovina and Croatia for the donation of a refuse truck be considered as an urgent item of business following item 16 on the Agenda in view of Direct Aid’s immediate need to secure a vehicle. r:\decision\minutes\council\sc091097.doc SC152 MINUTES (a) Stirling Council - 26 June 1997 (b) Special Meeting - Stirling Council - 21 August 1997 (c) Adjourned Special Meeting - Stirling Council - 25 August 1997 (d) Special Meeting - Stirling Council - 4 September 1997 (e) Community Committee - 19 June 1997 (f) Social and Economic Committee - 29 May 1997 Decision The Council approved the above minutes of meetings as correct records of the proceedings. SC153 QUESTIONS The Provost confirmed that two written questions had been received in terms of Standing Order No. 23. Written answers from Chairs are contained in Appendix 1. Decision In response to a supplementary question asked in relation to the question concerning the sale of library property, the Council agreed that notwithstanding the terms of delegated powers to Officers, no items of intrinsic cultural value should be disposed of without a proper assessment of the value of such items. As appropriate to a particular item consultation would also take place with the Chair of the appropriate Committee and the Director of Civic Services on the requirement for the matter to be reported to the relevant Committee. SC154 QUESTION TIME In terms of Standing Order No. 30, Members put questions to Chairs of Committees on relevant and competent matters contained in the current volume of Minutes of Committees and Corporate Management Groups. The Chairs replied in appropriate terms. SC155 CHILDREN’S COMMITTEE - APPOINTMENT OF CO-OPTED MEMBERS The Children’s Committee had provision for the appointment of 4 Non Voting Co-opted Members on the Committee namely one staff, one parent, one student and one Children’s Panel Representative. On 19 September 1996, the Council had appointed Mrs Anne Walsh as Parent Member. Mrs Walsh had resigned from the Committee. Mr Derek Robertson, and not Mr David Robertson as stated in the report, had been nominated by Stirling’s Parents Forum to serve as a parent member until May 1999. The Director of Civic Services advised the Committee that following the resignation of the Student Representative from the Children’s Committee, Ms Kirsty Kennedy had been nominated to serve on the Children’s Committee for a period of one year. r:\decision\minutes\council\sc091097.doc Decision The Council agreed:- (1) to appoint Mr Derek Robertson as Parent Representative to serve as a non-voting co- opted member on the Children’s Committee until May 1999 and (2) to appoint Ms Kirsty Kennedy as Children’s Representative to serve as a non-voting co-opted member on the Children’s Committee for a period of one year. (Reference:- Report by Director of Civic Services dated 19 September 1997 submitted). SC156 APPOINTMENTS TO EXTERNAL AND OTHER ORGANISATIONS (a) Prison Visiting Committees A report by the Director of Civic Services confirmed that there was a vacancy on the Cornton Vale over 21’s Prison Visiting Committee. In terms of the Prison’s and Young Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Amendment Rules 1996, the Council was required to appoint replacements on Prison Visiting Committees. Decision The Council agreed to appoint Ms. Teresa Moraes to the Cornton Vale Over 21’s Prison Visiting Committee. (Reference:- Report by Director of Civic Services dated 18 September 1997 submitted). (b) Best Value Elected Member’s Network On 4 July 1997 a Task Force report on Best Value had been discussed with the Secretary of State for Scotland when it was emphasised that elected members and senior officials must be jointly committed to making best value work. In this context a whole variety of networks on best value had been established at Officer level and an Elected Member’s Network was to be similarly established by COSLA. COSLA had asked all Councils to appoint a member representative on the Network following which a meeting with Malcolm Chisholm, Minister for Local Government, would be arranged. Decision The Council agreed to appoint Councillor Tom Coll to the COSLA - Best Value Elected Member’s Network. (Reference:- Report by Director of Civic Services dated 25 September 1997 submitted). (c) Stirling Partnership for Urban Regeneration On 25 September 1997, the Community and Economic Development Committee had considered a report by the Director of Community Services which provided an up-date on the progress made by the Stirling Partnership for Urban Regeneration (SPUR) since the previous report to the Social and Economic Committee in January 1997. The Council had been requested to confirm the nomination of two Councillors to the SPUR Executive. Decision r:\decision\minutes\council\sc091097.doc The Council agreed that Councillors John Hendry and Corrie McChord be nominated to the SPUR Executive. (Reference:- CE8 - 4 September 1997 submitted). (d) Review of other Appointments At the meeting of the Council held on 11 April 1996 appointments were made to various external organisations. Following the mid-term review in August 1997 and due to the resignations of Members/Chairs/Vice Chairs on Committees, appointments to these external organisations required to be reviewed. A report by the Director of Civic Services detailed the current appointments to external organisations. Decision The Council agreed the appointments and other decisions detailed in Appendix 2. (Reference:- Report by Director of Civic Services dated 25 September 1997 submitted). SC157 PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO STANDING ORDER NO. 17 - APPOINTMENTS PANEL On 26 June 1997, the Council had given notice of its intention to amend Standing Order Number 17 - Appointment of Committees and Panels - Appointments Panel. At its meeting on 11 April 1996 the Council established an Appointments Panel comprising 7 Members of the Resources Committee to deal with appointments to the posts of Chief Executive, Directors and Heads of Service. On 9 May 1996, the Resources Committee in appointing Members to the Panel agreed that the Panel would have the discretion to invite the Chair of the Committee appropriate to a particular appointment to attend meetings of the Panel. The membership of the Panel was set at 7, consequently, the Chair of the Committee appropriate to a particular appointment did not have voting rights. A report by the Director of Civic Services confirmed a proposal that the membership of the Panel be increased to 8 to include either the Committee Chair, Spokesperson or Chair of the Policy Executive appropriate to a particular Appointment. Decision The Council resolved:- (1) to amend Standing Order No. 17 - Appointment of Committees and Panels to provide for a change in the membership of the Appointments Panel from 7 to 8 Members to include either the Committee Chair, or Spokesperson, or Chair of the Policy Executive appropriate to a particular Appointment; and (2) that it be remitted to the Director of Civic Services to prepare and issue an addendum pending the annual review of standing orders to be undertaken in time for consideration by Council in Spring 1998. (Reference:- Report by Director of Civic Services dated 9 October 1997 submitted). r:\decision\minutes\council\sc091097.doc SC158 PLANNING SCHEDULE - INCREASED USE Since the Council’s inception, the planning schedule had been used to determine the bulk of planning applications, to authorise enforcement action and approve other planning issues such as forestry, planning and treework. In terms of the Scheme of Delegation such delegations to the Director of Environmental Services was by exception in that any member or spokesperson could refer (subject to agreement of the Chair of the Environmental