PUBLISHED BY THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISTS OF AMERICA

JANUARY 1983 VOL XI, NO. 1 T $1

MARGULIE~ ROTH CO

What Price National Security? Ron Dellums on Defense Spending 3

Downhill Dealignment 6 Neighborhood ~olitics s that Soviet nuclear anns are "no threat" is of course that the West disarm unilaterally .... Against this I would say that the Soviets are LETTERS not noted historically for their kindness and consideration of weak and defenseless na­ tions. New Design Scrap Higgins Cartoon DSA has clearly stated its position of supporting a bilateral nuclear freeze. The We've come a long way in design, from To the Editcr: roughly equal and verified reduction of nucle­ the days when THE NEWSLETIER OF THE On the cover of th.e Unity Issue (Sept - ar arsenals on both sides seems a relatively DEMOCRATIC LEFT was a one-color, two-col­ Oct.] was a photograph of an unemployed safe and expeditious way to end the anns umn,\no photograph, eight-page communica­ auto worker. A good photo, moving. It com­ race. A nuclear freeze proposal, if and when tion to this latest design. Thanks to Sandy municated a message, a real and severe adopted by the US government would of Cate, who, we believe, has brought together message. course also require approval by the Soviets. the best of DEMOCRATIC LEFT and MOVING Yet on the back cover ever present as Helmut Wenkarl ON to create a new look for the publication of part of "Jimmy Higgins Reports," I see a New Ylri, N.Y. a new organization. Along with the new de­ caricature of working people: the little, mus­ sign will come an increased emphasis on tachioed guy with a broom and cap. It seems news from within the organization. We look to me a mocking figure of the real thing on the Get Your Hands Dirty! forward to hearing from you, about what you cover. I have never really appreciated that To the Editor: want to see in your publication, about what graphic. It is idyllic and misrepresents what a you're doing. worker really is.... I am a socialist from the old country and I do have a nutmeg to grind with you, my TM Editors I encourage the graphics editor to search for an alternative graphic and ap­ American comrades. All this debate about proach Jimmy Higgins, if that is the process, how, just HOW we are going to work in the Old Mistake and get his o.k. to switch. Democratic party reminds me of Huck and Mike Fogelberg Tom in that barn. All the while they were As a result of a proofreading error, a line MadisonDSA figuring out intricate plans on how to escape, was dropped from Joe Holland's article on the door was open. All they had to do was to Latin America in the November-December Ed. twle: See the explanation of the Higgins walk out. All we have to do is to go to the figure that appears at the end of the column. issue that completely changed the meaning next meeting of our local Democratic Com­ of the sentence. We are red-faced. The sec­ mittee, get to work and get our hands dirty. tion should have read (dropped portion in Threat to West There is no other way. italics): Dwight Eisenhower sent the CIA To the Editor: EvaOlkn into Guatemala. fl) overthrow the democrati­ Frank Scott, in a letter to DEMOCRATIC Rochester, N. Y. cally ekcted government of Jacobo Ar­ LEFT takes issue with Pat Lacefield's asser­ benz; Lyndon Johnson sent the marines into tion that Soviet nuclear weapons pose a the Dominican Republic to overthrow the threat to the West. Scott feels there is no Thank You in 1982 democratically elected president Juan such threat, but neglects to present argu­ Bosch. ments of any kind to back up his claim.. .. The Labor Day-Unity issue carried The logical thrust of those who argue names of friends and members who con­ tnbuted to our Socialist Unity Drive and EDITORIAL BoAID sent greetings tQ DEMOCRATIC LEIT. We were afraid that we might have left Leo Casey Gordon Haskell some names out because of our book­ F~ld Dirrctqr Polilical Director keeping problems and we were right Maxine Phillips Listed below are names of those we Organir.alional Dinctor know we missed. We appreciate their F""""'1y Newsldter of tM Democratic Left and support. If we missed you, we apologize Moving On. ADVISORY BoARD again. If you missed us, we hope you'll Joanne Barkan David Bensman send greetings next Labor Day. MICHAEL HARRINGTON Jim Chapin Jack: Clark Editor Gretchen Donart Kate Ellis Founding Sponsor Founding Pioneers Patrick Lacefield Ricardo Otheguy Quin Shea David and Eva Gil MAXINE PHILLIPS Jan Rosenberg Bernard Stephens Founder M (J1l(J{fing Editqr Peter Steinfels Guy Molyneux Susan Palmer DEMOCRATIC LEFT is published nine times a year (monthly except July, August and October) by Greetings Democratic Socialists of America, formerly DSOC/NAM. The editorial office is located at 853 Ruth Jordan Paul Garver Broadway, Suite 801, New York, N. Y. 10003, Telephone (212) 260-3270. Other national offices are located at 1300 West Behnont Ave., Chicago, ll. 60657, (312) 871-7700 and at 29 29th Street, San Helmut Wenkart Francisco, CA 94110, (415) 550-1849. Subsaiptions: $15 sustaining and institutional; $8 regular. For my sons Israel and Joshua, in the Signed articles express the opinions of the authors and not of the organization. ISSN 0164-3207. hope that their future is ~ ofpeace and Microfilm, Wisconsin State Historical Society, 816 State St., Madison, WI 53703. Indtxed in the Alternative Press Index, P. 0. Box 7229, Baltimore, MD 21218. Second Class Pennit paid at New justice. York, N.Y. Richard W. Smith

DEMOCRATIC LEFT 2 IANUARY 1983 DEFENSE UNCONSCIONABLE COSTS by RONALD V. DEUUMS

ince 1945, American foreign and ent growth/inflation rates, we may well be sile, the Trident II (D-5) Missile, and military policies have been predi­ spending $422 billion a year on the military by ground-, sea- and air-launched Cruise mis­ cated on a series of hypotheses, 1987. siles ushers us into a new era of the nuclear revolving around the basic theme The dimensions of disaster being plot­ arms race, one that drastically reduces the of preserving the "national secur­ ted by the Reagan administration almost defy prospects for a meaningful nuclear arms Sity" of the United States. Eight successive any rational analysis, as Robert Scheer dis­ freeze and subsequent mutual-balanced presidents have contended that the corner­ covered when researching and interviewing force reductions of both nuclear and conven­ stone of this policy must be an unrelenting for his excellent new book; With Enougls tional weapons. response at all levels to the alleged Com­ Sltovtls: Rt.ogan, Busls and Nuclmr War. It was in this context that, in January of munist crusade for "global hegemony" and The Reagan administration has consciously 1982, I mounted a comprehensive legislative the defense and maintenance of the "Free and debberately moved beyond the strategy challenge to the policy assumptions and World" Thus, with the passage of time, the of deterrence to one that proposes to fight, spending priorities of the Pentagon and the purported "vital" "national security" inter­ survive and "win" a nuclear war. White House. Two days after the Presi­ ests of the United Stated have assumed glob­ When he was Secretary of Defense in dent's State of the Union message, I formally al dimensions. Both Democratic and Repub­ the Kennedy administration, Robert Strange petitioned Representative Mel Price of Illi­ lican administrations have repeatedly McNamara defined deterrence as the capac­ nois, the Chair of the House Armed Services sought, through covert or overt interven­ ity to destroy 30 percent of the Soviet soci­ Committee, to expand the Committee's tion, military solutions to international prob­ ety's population and 70 percent of its eco­ hearings on the military budget in order to lems that are essentially political, economic, nomic infrastructure. He felt this objective examine a broader spectrum of policy issues social or cultural in origin. could be achieved through the use of approxi­ and economic f:actors relating to the military This "national security" psychosis has mately 400 strategic nuclear warheads. In budget The Committee informed me that it made possible the evolution of a permanent 1983, the U.S. possesses more than 10,000 had deadlines to meet, and could not afford war economy that has made the United strategic warheads in its nuclear arsenal, the time. States, because of its superior technology, plus 15, 000 more of intermediate range for the principal force in global anns escalation, theater nuclear use. At present, it IS estima­ n response, I decided to convene the both nuclear and conventional. It was a Dem­ ted that there are approximately 886 cities Special Congressional Ad Hoc Hear­ ocratic administration, headed by President and towns in the U.S.S.R. with a population ings on the Full Implications of the Harry S. Truman, that tri/Jkd the military of 25, 000 or more people. How much is Military Budget After raising the budget in 1950. It was a Democratic adminis­ enough? necessary funds from various peace tration, headed by John F. Kennedy, that The Reagan administration is commit­ I first proclaimed a missile gap with the Soviet ted to developing nuclear weapons that go Union when it knew the opposite was true, beyond our capacity to verify or control In and then brought the planet to the verge of a past years the necessity for verifiability and nuclear holocaust during the Cuban Missile control have been integral elements of all Crisis in 1962. previous arms control agreements and nego­ It was a Democratic administration, tiations. The development of first-strike nu­ headed by Jimmy Carter, that prepared and clear weapons such as the MX Missile (cyni­ began to implement the notorious Presiden­ cally christened the "Peacekeeper" by the tial Directive 59, which opened the way to Great Communicator), the Pershing II Mi~ discussion of a first-strike strategy. In 1977, when the Carter administration assumed office with a pledge. to reduce mili­ tary spending by $5-$7 billion in its first year, the total military budget was slightly less than $100 billion. Four years later it was A", $173 billion, but Carter left office asking for a 'V · further increase to $194 billion. The Reagan administration immediately raised that figure to $226.3 billion, as part of a five year-mili­ tary spending projection of $1.6 trillion. Be­ cause of cost-overruns and projected supple­ mental appropriations, that figure has al­ ready been raised to $2.3 trillion for the same period A recent study by the Congres­ sional Budget Office indicated that, at pres-

DEMOCRATIC LEn 3 JANUARY 1983 ar superiority in favor of nuclear sufficiency. I Next Steps THE CONTROLLABLES proposed the total elimination of all crisis­ destabilizing nuclear weapons systems, such THE ROI. ~S Al'Cl BUTIER C£8ATE Where do we go from here? We in the as the MX Missile, the Pershing Il Missile, progressive community need to develop a l£ll.TH.st:t..f EOOCAT I ON, all sea-and ground-launched Cruise missiles, ,-Al.I. Dna coherent, cohesive strategy and program for 10'?- \ 127. the Trident Il (D-5) Missile, and neutron challenging the military budget in 1983. l:NVIROIH:NT •7. ---.. ----=- weapons. I also proposed the elimination of One of the more disturbing realities of chemical warfare weapons, and such obso­ American political life is that most of its politi­ lete or useless conventional weapons sys­ cal l~aders, regardless of ideology or geo­ tems as the B-1 Bomber, the XM-1 tank, the graphical origin, function most comfortably in two nuclear carriers proposed in the Defense an atmosphere of ambiguity, one in which Department authorization bill. the Aegis pragmatism takes precedence over prin­ Missile Cruiser program, and the retrofitted ciple. The "hberal" and "moderate" will tem­ battleships. porize, saying that change must proceed Few people are aware that the re­ slowly, so we must consider transferring PAST fNl search, development, production and de­ L.. fUTURE: lf'IR$ funds from nuclear to conventional forces. 70Y. ployment of our current and proposed nucle­ When pushed, they will vote for a Nuclear ar arsenal constitute only 21 percent of the Freeze Resolution (H.R. 521), and even to overall military budget The remainder is for defer funding for an MX basing mode. But groups, which also ensured the hearings be­ conventional forces, maintenance overhead they will not vote for a comprehensive al­ ing broadcast on the Pacifica Radio Network, and personnel costs. Accordingly, I pro­ ternative military budget (H. R. 6696), or to my staff and I invited more than forty expert posed an initial 5 percent reduction in all U.S. terminate all funds for the MX Missile, be­ witnesses to testify. military personnel as a first step toward mu­ cause such proposals are considered "too For six days during March and April, a tual troop reductions. To reduce further the radical. " Thus the Freeze resolution could number of concerned congressional collea­ possibility of U.S. intervention in the Third garner 202 votes of congressional concern, gues and I conducted an indepth examination World, I also proposed the total elimination but the alternative military budget received of the military budget from the perspectives of the Rapid Deployment Force and the in­ only 55 votes. The latest proposal to defer of foreign policy and national security impli­ cremental reduction of the U.S. Navy fleet to funds because of the failure to develop a cations, escalation v. disarmament, econom­ approximately 400 vessels (the administra­ basing mode for the MX Missile secured 245 ic implications, moral implications, citizen re­ tion has proposed that the surface fleet be votes, but repeated attempts to delete all sponsibilities in challenging the military bud­ increased to 640 vessels). funds for the MX Missile program have nev­ get, and the impact of gtobal arms sales. nus alternative proposal would have er obtained more than 96 votes in the House. The witness list ranged from J. William reduced the Pentagon's budget authority by Why? Because these proposals are "too Fulbright, Chairman of the Senate Foreign more than $50 billion in the first year alone. radical"? On the contrary, I would argue that Relations Committee during the Indochina More important, it set the stage for con­ "radical" politics is the truly progressive pos­ War era to social policy analyst Frances Fox tinued cuts in nuclear and conventional weap­ ition. The progressive platform must be that Piven to Catholic Bishops Walter Sullivan of ons systems and in personne~ while estab­ which proposes new alternatives that mini­ Richmond and John Quinn of . lishing stringent oversight / controls for mize the risk of nuclear war by advocating Several witnesses were DSA members. waste, fraud and abuse. Within three years, policies of peace that mean not only the ab­ After studying more than l, 800 pages of such cuts and controls could reduce the an­ sence of war, but the absence of conditions in nual federal deficit by more than 60 percent transcript testimony, my staff a00 I met with the world which create international hostility defense analysts and budget experts to draft Even though it was defeated, its oppo­ and confrontation. That is why we must go nents treated it as a serious challenge to the a comprehensive alternative military budget. beyond the concept of a Nuclear Freeze to an After Congressional Budget Office verifica­ status quo. Many of those who opposed it did all-out sustained challenge to the administra­ tion of the accuracy of our doDar figures and so in statements of rebuttal drafted with the tion's military budget and the policy assump­ program projections, I introduced H.R. direct assistance of the Pentagon and the tions that are used to justify it. Armed Services Committee staff. They 6696. The peace community, in and out of We need an orchestrated national effort the Congress, was surprised when, in an know that they have not seen the last of it. As at every facet of the community level to mo­ unprecedented ruling, H. R. 6696 was desig­ I said on the House Floor after the formal bilize, energize and organize citizens around the nated by the House Rules Committee as the debate: "We will be back next year and the economic, political, and biological dan­ year after that and the year after that until we official substitute for the House Armed Ser­ gers they face because of this unre­ vices Committee bill (H. R. 6030). right the wrongs in this madness. strained military budget Thus, on Tuesday, July 20, 1982, for As progressives we have a special re­ the first time in the history of the Cold War, sponsibility to our fellow citizens at this criti­ the U.S. Congress debated a comprehensive The National Executive Com­ cal moment in history. to do so, we must legislative alternative to the Pentagon-in­ mittee of DSA has adopted a re­ reach out to every segment of our society to spired madness that has persistently pre­ solution supporting H.R. 6696, build this coalition of peaceful challenge and vailed. During the course of the extended which will be re-introduced in change. Nuclear weapons are equal oppor­ debate I formally proposed a military budget Congress. Proposals will be tunity destroyers-we must become equal based on the policies of nonintervention, nu­ made at the February board opportunity coalition builders. • clear and conventional arms reductions, a meeting for actions that locals mutual reduction of forces by both super­ can take to support the bill DSA member Ronald V. Dellums is a np­ powers and their NATO and Warsaw Pact resentative ofCongnss from ~8th District in allies, and a rejection of the doctrine of nude- Caiifomia.

DEMOCRATIC LEFT 4 JANUARY 1983 PROFILE

people who shared that gay anger and that Out of the Gay Ghetto very deep desire to relate to each other out­ side the traditional patterns." Then came by MAXINE PHILUPS and the experience of power. Britt delights in telling of Milk's chutzpah, the way he would appear before downtown real estate speculators and say, "fm the hen San Francisco Supervi· head queen in San Francisco. What are you sor Harry Britt steps into his going to do about it?" Milk's courage and City Hall office, he is waD