Crime Solving Instructions

Adult supervision and assistance required for children under 12.

Contents

Materials required and preparation...... 2 Clue 1 – Magnetic swipe card ...... 3 Clue 2 – Powders (shoe scrapings)...... 8 Clue 3 – Ink samples ...... 9 Clue 4 – Fibres ...... 11

Approximate time required Clue 1 – 30 to 45 minutes Clue 2 – 10 to 15minutes Clue 3 – 30 to 40 minutes Clue 4 – 15 to 20 minutes

You need to enter correct results all the test results for all the suspects to be eligible for the prize draw.

That’s twenty correct results in total to win the prize so you’d better get crackin’!

When you’ve done the tests, go to: www.abc.net.au/forensic to enter your results

GOOD LUCK! MATERIALS REQUIRED AND PREPARATION

No special science equipment is required to solve the case. All you’ll need is your forensic evidence kit and the following materials. You should read all the instructions carefully before you begin. Remember, you only have a small amount of evidence. Making a mistake could be costly!

Clue Equipment Required Preparation / Notes . 1. Swipe y Evidence: the swipe card This is the most labour intensive clue. Card y Black magnetic powder You’ll be amazed at the result from the (provided in kit in plastic vial with swipe card … then you have to do some clear lid) maths (that’s right, maths!) y Scale map of Gold Coast City (provided in kit) You should work over a sheet of white A3 y Clear sticky tape or A4 paper when using the magnetic y White paper (A4 + A3 if available) powder! Excess powder should be y Scissors returned to the container - not discarded! y Dividers or compass (if available) The small amount provided should be y Rulers sufficient to repeat the test at least five y Calculator . times as long as you keep the excess powder after each test.

2. Powders y Evidence: Powder samples in This is a quick and simple test. Just plastic vials squeeze in some acetic acid (vinegar) y Acetic acid (white vinegar) and look for the bubbles of guilt. y Narrow test tube If you don’t have an eyedropper, learn alternatively, transfer evidence into a small zip-lock bag and use the plastic how to pipette the vinegar using a vial as your test tube drinking straw and your thumb y Eyedropper or pipette alternatively, you can use a drinking straw as a pipette by holding your thumb over the top . 3. Inks y Evidence: Ink samples There’s a bit of work to do here, but y Clear sticky tape you’ll be amazed by the results. You can y Beaker(s) or clear plastic cup(s) try it on other inks from your own y 10-20 ml Methylated Spirits pens/printer too. y 2 Paddlepop sticks You can test all the ink samples y eyedropper / pipette simultaneously if you have sufficient y Sticky tape . beakers/cups . 4. Fibres y Evidence: Fabric samples and The quickest test of all . . . but don’t be fibre (in zip lock bag) fooled by its simplicity. y White paper (A4 or A3) Be careful not to confuse suspect’s y 1 pair of tweezers samples when unpacking the fabric y 1 pair of scissors bundle. Attach each sample to a separate, y 1 magnifying glass (optional) labelled sheet of paper to avoid confusion y sticky tape . or loss.

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 2 Clue 1: The Stolen Swipe Card

track 1 – PIN info track 2 – time code track 3 – spare (blank)

Crime scene notes:

The stolen swipe card used by the culprit to steal the Minister’s Malibu was found inside the crime scene and can be used to determine the time that the crime was committed. Once you know this time, you’ll be able to determine which suspects had sufficient time to commit the crime and reach their alibis. The card belongs to the Prof. Max Standage who is the Pro-Vice-Chancellor of Griffith University’s Gold Coast campus. It has access to all rooms and storerooms and the fact it was missing was discovered when Prof. Standage and the Minister returned to the store room to collect the Malibu. Normally a central computer records all the details of every transaction made with these swipe cards. But as luck would have it, being a new building, the cabling to the store room had not yet been connected (one should expect these kinds of uncanny circumstances in such a high profile case). Fortunately however, the magnetic stripe on the card is encoded with the time whenever it is used, and this code remains unchanged until the card is used again. Since the card was found inside the secure storeroom by police, the code on the card will reveal the exact time the culprit entered the room to steal the Malibu. By measuring distances on the map of the Gold Coast and using some basic maths, you’ll determine the minimum travel times to each suspect’s alibi from the crime scene. Suspects who reached their alibi later than the earliest time of arrival after the time encoded on the card remain under strong suspicion.

Procedure:

Step 1 – Determine the time encoded on the card

NOTE! Only a small amount of magnetic powder is supplied. You may need to use all of the powder to do conduct the test but only a small amount of powder is actually consumed – the rest of the powder can be re-used so make sure you work over a sheet of white paper to catch the excess. CLEAN THE CARD FIRST! Ensure the magnetic stripe on the swipe card is clean and free of smudges and fingerprints. You can clean the card with a bit of methylated spirits and a tissue or soapy water but make sure the card is dry before you proceed.

1 Sprinkle the analytical magnetic powder evenly across the entire length of the magnetic stripe.

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 3 2 Holding the card by the edges, carefully spread the powder across the stripe by gently tapping the card while holding it at different angles.

You should notice that the powder sticks to the encoded tracks on the card (tracks 1 and 2). You need to have powder along the entire length of track 2

3 Next, tap the card on the table to get rid of excess powder. Do this on a sheet of paper to catch excess powder. Examine the stripe – you should see a bar code pattern on track two. If this code is not visible, keep gently tapping the card on the table until it is. Don’t be concerned if it doesn’t work the first time – you can try again by returning the powder to its container and simply starting again.

4 Once you can see the bars clearly, you can either read the code directly from the card and/or lift the powder pattern using sticky tape to make a permanent record of it. To do this, lay a piece of sticky tape on the magnetic strip (adhesive side down) and rub the powder onto the tape. Then adhere the tape to a sheet of white paper to provide a better contrast. Record the time 5 Use the information below to decode the encoded on card here: information stored on the card. The number of bars (thick, medium, and thin), and the order in which they appear reveals the time. The space between the bars is not important information. Record your result in the box provided.

TIME FORMAT AND SAMPLE CODES:

AM / PM HOUR TENS OF MINUTES MINUTES TENS OF SECONDS SECONDS thick bars thin bars medium bars thin medium thin (max: 2) (max:12) (max: 5) (max: 9) (max: 5) (max: 9) PM 2: 4 7: 2 4

PM 2:47:24 > > PM / THIN THIN THIN THICK AM hours MEDIUM MEDIUM BLANK minutes seconds < LAST MEDIUM MEDIUM LAST < < end of code > tens of minutes tens of seconds AM 8:34:13

AM 8: 3 4: 1 3

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 4 Step 2 – Determine the earliest time of arrival

1 For each suspect, use the map to measure and record the length of each individual street travelled (see table below for this information). Use a compass or dividers and/or a ruler to carefully step out small, equal distances for each street.

NOTE: Use the CENTRE of location markers (round dots), or intersections between streets as start and end points.

2 Use the scale on the map to convert each measurement from millimetres to kilometres and record your result in the table below.

3 For each street, road or motorway travelled, calculate the minimum time required to travel the distances Distance you measured on the map. To do this, use the Time = average speeds provided below for each street and Average speed the simple equation for speed (To make this easier, convert speeds given as km/hr to km/minute first. Your results will now be in minutes.)

4 Add the times you calculated for all the streets travelled to calculate the MINIMUM TRAVEL TIME to ++= the alibi location. street 1 street 2 street 3 total travel time 5 You can now check this time against the time the crime was committed to determine which suspect had enough time to commit the crime and reach the alibi location.

Summary Results:

If the departure time is the time encoded on the card, which suspect could have reached their alibi before the confirmed times given by witnesses?

Did they have Route to alibi Confirmed enough time to Suspect Alibi Location see worksheets for time at alibi reach the alibi? average speeds (YES/NO)

Warner Bros. Parklands Dve Ö Olsen Ave Ö 10.45 AM Studios Brisbane Rd ÖPacific M’Way Dick Johnson Parklands Dve Ö Smith St Ö Steven Bradbury Racing 10.35 AM Pacific M’Way Ö Elliot Rd Ö (Stapylton) Jacobs Well Rd Parklands Dve Ö Smith St Ö Mick Fanning Burleigh Heads 10.20 AM Gold Coast H’Way

Gold Coast City Parklands Dve Ö Olsen Ave Ö Adam & Wil 10.40 AM Council (Nerang) Nerang-Southport Rd

Coolangatta Parklands Dve Ö Smith St Ö Charlie & Nicole 11.25 AM Airport Gold Coast H’Way

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 5 Clue 1 Worksheets:

Use these tables to work through each suspects’ information.

Table 1: Suspect: Killing Heidi Alibi location: Warner Bros Studios Time confirmed at alibi: 10.45 AM

Streets used to Average speed Length of street Actual distance Time required to travel reach alibi typical morning measured on map Use map scale this distance at given traffic conditions (millimetres) (kilometres) average speed (km/hr) Parklands Drive 30 Olsen Ave 40 Brisbane Road 45 Pacific M’Way 90

Total travel time required to reach alibi (add the times for each street)

IF GUILTY: Earliest arrival time (add the total travel time to the time encoded on card)

Did Killing Heidi have sufficient time to reach their alibi? (YES / NO)

Table 2: Suspect: Stephen Bradbury Alibi location: Dick Johnson Racing (Stapylton) Time confirmed at alibi: 10.35 AM

Streets used to Average speed Length of street Actual distance Time required to travel reach alibi typical morning measured on map Use map scale this distance at given traffic conditions (millimetres) (kilometres) average speed (km/hr) Parklands Drive 30 Smith Street 45 Pacific M’Way 90 Elliot Rd 55 Jacobs Well Rd 55

Total travel time required to reach alibi (add the times for each street)

IF GUILTY: Earliest arrival time (add the total travel time to the time encoded on card)

Did Stephen Bradbury have sufficient time to reach his alibi? (YES / NO)

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 6 Table 3: Suspect: Mick Fanning Alibi location: Burleigh Heads Time confirmed at alibi: 10.20 AM

Streets used to Average speed Length of street Actual distance Time required to travel reach alibi typical morning measured on map Use map scale this distance at given traffic conditions (millimetres) (kilometres) average speed (km/hr) Parklands Drive 30 Smith St 45 Gold Coast H’Way 45

Total travel time required to reach alibi (add the times for each street)

IF GUILTY: Earliest arrival time (add the total travel time to the time encoded on card)

Did Mick Fanning have sufficient time to reach his alibi? (YES / NO)

Table 4: Suspect: Adam & Wil Alibi location: Gold Coast City Council Chambers (Nerang) Time confirmed at alibi: 10.40 AM

Streets used to Average speed Length of street Actual distance Time required to travel reach alibi typical morning measured on map Use map scale this distance at given traffic conditions (millimetres) (kilometres) average speed (km/hr) Parklands Drive 30 Olsen Ave 40 Nerang-Southport Rd 40

Total travel time required to reach alibi (add the times for each street)

IF GUILTY: Earliest arrival time (add the total travel time to the time encoded on card)

Did Adam & Wil have sufficient time to reach their alibi? (YES / NO)

Table 5: Suspect: Charlie & Nicole Alibi location: Coolangatta Airport Time confirmed at alibi: 11.25 AM

Streets used to Average speed Length of street Actual distance Time required to travel reach alibi typical morning measured on map Use map scale this distance at given traffic conditions (millimetres) (kilometres) average speed (km/hr) Parklands Drive 30 Smith St 45 Gold Coast H’Way 45

Total travel time required to reach alibi (add the times for each street)

IF GUILTY: Earliest arrival time (add the total travel time to the time encoded on card)

Did Charlie & Nicole have sufficient time to reach their alibi? (YES / NO)

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 7 Clue 2: Powder scrapings

Crime scene notes:

The crime scene investigator identified significant quantities of a commercial carpet deodorising powder present on the carpets of the storeroom and adjacent corridors. Cleaning contractors testified that the powder had been sprinkled earlier that morning and the carpets were to have been vacuumed at approximately 11.00 am. Inspection of the carpet powder packaging revealed that the product contains high concentrations of baking soda (sodium bicarbonate – a common deodorising ingredient). In this test, you will use acetic acid (vinegar) to test for the presence of sodium bicarbonate in scrapings taken from suspect’s shoes. Acetic acid and sodium bicarbonate react vigorously to produce visible bubbles of carbon dioxide gas. The formation of bubbles would suggest the presence of sodium bicarbonate in a suspect’s sample.

Detectives questioned academic staff who provided an alibi in an adjacent building for the cleaning contractors between 9.40am and 10.35am.

Procedure:

Perform this test on the crime scene carpet powder sample provided to observe the reaction and then repeat the test for each suspect sample.

You can use the plastic evidence vial as a test tube if one isn’t readily available.

1 Use an eyedropper (if available) to add acetic acid to each suspect’s sample you can use a drinking straw and your thumb to pipette the acid if you don’t have an eyedropper

2 Record the presence or absence of a visible reaction in the table below.

Results:

Suspect Reaction with acetic acid

Killing Heidi Steven Bradbury Mick Fanning Adam & Wil Charlie & Nicole

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 8 Clue 3: Ink samples

Crime scene notes:

A map of the Gold Coast campus of Griffith University with details for the Minister’s was found inside the secure storeroom. This map was emailed to the suspects prior to the function to help them find their way to the function room. Only the suspects received this map and the fact that it was sent by email allowed detectives to narrow the list of suspects to the five celebrity guests. The ink on the map found inside the crime scene can also be analysed and compared to samples of ink from each suspect’s printer using a technique called ink Figure 1: Section the of crime chromatography. This standard test is often used in cases of scene map to be analysed fraud or tax evasion where a forgery is suspected on questioned documents.

Ink chromatography: Many types of ‘black’ ink are really just combinations of dyes which combine to produce black. Chromatography is a method which separates these component colours using a solvent, drawn up through a substrate by capillary action. Capillary action is so strong that it can draw liquids (such as water or methylated spirits) up into porous materials (such as paper) against the force of gravity.

The different molecules present in inks move through the microscopic spaces in the substrate at different rates due to their different shapes, sizes and chemical properties. Every type of ink has a unique chromatography ‘fingerprint’ which can be used to identify the source of handmade or mechanical markings.

IMPORTANT: the ink spot itself should not become submerged in the solvent during this test. Only the paper should make contact Figure 2: Liquids (such as with the solvent. If any part of the ink spot is submerged in the water) are drawn up into solvent, it will simply dissolve into the solution and no visible porous materials (such as result will be observed on the paper. paper) by capillary action

Procedure:

Perform this test on the section of the map found at the crime scene and repeat for each suspect’s printer sample. NOTE: Grease and markings made on the samples could affect your results. Ensure your scissors are clean and do not make cutting guide marks on the ink samples.

1 Carefully cut a narrow strip of paper about 2 to 3 mm wide, containing a section of the black ink spot from the section of the map as illustrated. Trim the bottom of the strip so that there is about 3 - 4 mm of white paper below the ink spot.

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 9 2 BEFORE ADDING SOLVENT TO THE : Attach the strip of paper to a paddle pop stick with sticky tape so that the bottom of the strip sits about 5 mm from the bottom of the beaker or cup. Rest the paddle pop stick on top of the cup so that the strip hangs in the centre and does not touch the bottom or sides of the beaker.

3 Using an eyedropper, carefully add enough solvent (methylated spirits) until the bottom of the strip is just submerged. DO NOT ALLOW THE INK SPOT TO BE SUBMERGED IN THE SOLVENT – the solvent needs to travel up through the ink spot If the ink spot is submerged, you won’t get a result!

4 Observe carefully as the solvent front rises and passes through the ink spot. Remember that the absence of a visible result is an important result in itself.

5 After fifteen minutes, you should see should be able to draw conclusions about which printers might have produced the map found at the crime scene. (optional : leave the strip in the solvent for an hour or more if you want to see an even more vivid separation of colours)

Results:

Suspect Printer Matches Crime Scene (yes / no) Killing Heidi HP OfficeJet Pro 1150C Adam & Wil HP DeskJet 880C Charlie & Nicole Canon Laser Printer Mick Fanning Epson Stylus Color 480 Steven Bradbury HP DeskJet 710C

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 10 Clue 4: Fibre and fabric samples

Crime scene notes:

A conspicuous blue fibre was found on a burred edge of the filing cabinet which the Minister’s Malibu had been resting against inside the storeroom. This fibre was carefully removed and entered into evidence by the crime scene officer. You will now use the most important tool in all detective work: your careful observations. Samples of clothing which this fibre could have originated from were seized from suspects at the time of apprehension. You will compare fibres plucked from each suspect’s fabric sample to the fibre found at the crime scene.

A magnifying glass may be helpful but is not essential.

Procedure:

The edges of the fabric samples are slightly singed because they were cut into square pieces using a laser. You should prepare the fabric samples by trimming about 2 mm from the edges with scissors. This will enable you to pluck individual fibres from the sample. Some adhesive residue may persist on the fabric samples – this will not affect your observations.

Use tweezers to carefully pluck individual fibres from the fabric sample. Take notice of how easily the fibre is released from the weave, how the fibres dislodge, as well as the colour and shape of individual fibres. Record your observations in the table below.

Results:

Suspect Source of Fabric Description Matches crime scene fibre (yes/no) . Killing Heidi Ella Hooper’s blue jacket. No Blue cotton drill other members of Killing Heidi type fabric wore blue clothing Steven Bradbury Vest worn over shirt Medium weave No other blue items worn dark blue material Mick Fanning Fast-dry material Board shorts No other blue items worn Adam & Wil Adam’s shirt (bearing a Purple silk like triple j logo) - Wil wore a material matching white shirt. Both suspects were wearing black jeans. Charlie & Nicole Nicole’s triple j shirt (bearing a Dark blue silk like triple j logo) - Charlie wore a material matching red shirt. Nicole wore red jeans. Charlie wore black jeans.

“Who stole the Minister’s Malibu?” instructions 11