DOCSLIB.ORG

9. MEGARA HYBLAEA and the SICELS of the Many Deficiencies In

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
9. MEGARA HYBLAEA and the SICELS of the Many Deficiencies In 9. MEGARA HYBLAEA AND THE SICELS Of the many deficiencies in our evidence for Greek colonization in the Archaic period, one of the worst is the lack of good informa­ tion about the native peoples among whom the Greeks established their new settlements. We are fortunate if we know more than the general name of the people involved. The size and nature of their political units and institutions must usually be guessed on the basis of probabilities and analogies. So the initial relations between colonists and natives can only be grasped, at best, in a vague and general manner. Yet we do know that these relations ran the gamut from most hos­ tile, when colonization was achieved by the forcible expulsion of the native inhabitants, to most friendly, when the colony was established as the invitation of the local people. The best example of the latter phenomenon, had colonization resulted, would be provided by Herodotus' story ( 1.163) of Arganthonius, king of Tartessus, and the Phocaeans. In this instance the Phocaeans traded regularly with Tartessus and became so beloved by the local king, that he invited them to settle in his country. Although the invitation was refused, our evidence does provide a small number of other cases where Greek colonies were established at the invitation of the native peo­ ple. The earliest and perhaps the best attested is that of Megara Hyblaea. II Megara Hyblaea was founded on the East coast of Sicily by set­ tlers from Megara in Greece in c. 728 BC.1 This date can be reached by very close calculations on the basis of Thucydides' statements (6.4.1-2). 2 The higher date, c. 750, which was proposed by Vallet and Villard and widely accepted until recently, was chiefly based on inferences from archaeological material, which have since been found to be incorrect, and has been publicly retracted by its proposers. 3 1 See CAH IIF.3, 106-8; ]. Berard, La colonisation grecque de I'Italie et de Ia Sicile dans l'antiquite, second edition (Paris 1957) 109-16. 2 See T. J. Dunbabin, The Western Greeks (Oxford 1948) 435-8. 3 G. Vallet and F. Villard, "Les dates de fondation de Megara Hyblaea et de Syracuse," BCH 76 (1952) 289-346, and, for the retraction, Insediamenti coloniali Local Ethnopolitical Entities qf the Black Sea Littoral in the Seventh to Fourth Centuries BC (1988), 304-321 150 MEGARA HYBLAEA AND THE SICELS Our most authoritative source, Thucydides, states that the colonists were conducted to their final site by the Sicel king, Hyblon, who gave them the land (6.4.1). This statement is in general terms strongly confirmed by topography and archaeology. The low-lying site has no natural defences on the westward, landward, side, and the low escarpments on its eastern, northern and southern sides where the land rises from the sea and two small rivers, which have been con­ sidered natural defences by some authors, 4 are in truth barely worthy of such a description. It is more realistic to regard the whole side as undefended by nature and its choice undoubtedly reveals the colonists' confidence on the goodwill of the native inhabitants. Archaeological investigations have also shown that human settle­ ment of the site began with the establishment of the Greek colony, which was, therefore, planted on virgin, unoccupied, land.5 These facts would lead us to postulate circumstances of settlement similar to those described by Thucydides, even we did not possess his explicit statements. If the general circumstances of Megara Hyblaea's settlement are pleasingly clear, it is much more difficult to achieve the sharper definition and greater detail that we arc bound to seek. For this a close examination of the literary sources is the essential beginning. We have four main passages to consider: Thuc. 6.4.1; Polyaenus, Strat. 5.5; Strabo 6.267; and Ps.-Scymnus 270-79. The two last were derived, whether or not directly, from Ephorus, and are printed as his fragment 137 in Jacoby's collection (FGH 70 F 137).6 Ephorus' account of the early colonization of Sicily diverges significantly from that of Thucydides (as also from Polyaenus), so we must subject it to close scrutiny. greci in Sicilia nell' VIII e VII secolo A.C., Cronache di Archeologia e di Storia dell' Arte 17 (1978) 150-2. 4 E.g. Berard, op. cit. 114 and Villard, 'Megara Hyblaea', Me!.Arch.Hist.Ecole Franc Rome 63 (1951) 7-52. 5 Compare Villard's description of the stratigraphy, op. cit. 10-12. 6 The unmistakable similarities in the passage Ps.-Scymnus, 264ff. show that it too came from Ephorus, even though his name is not mentioned, whether directly or through an intermediary. (Both Jacoby, FGH Introduction to the commentary on 70, Ephorus von Kyme, pp. 34f., and G. L. Barber, The Historian Ephorus, Cambridge 1935, I 75-6, believe that the author of the geographical poem did not use Ephorus directly.) The main importance of the Ps.-Scymnus passage is that it establishes the dating given by Ephorus, since there is a corruption at this point in the MSS. of Strabo; see Jacoby's commentary on the fragment and Berard, op. cit. 76 n. I. We have two passages which attest Ephorus' date for the Return of the .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Equality in the Colonies: Concepts of Equality in Sicily During the Eighth to Six Centuries BC Author(S): Matthew Fitzjohn Source: World Archaeology, Vol
    Equality in the Colonies: Concepts of Equality in Sicily during the Eighth to Six Centuries BC Author(s): Matthew Fitzjohn Source: World Archaeology, Vol. 39, No. 2, The Archaeology of Equality (Jun., 2007), pp. 215- 228 Published by: Taylor & Francis, Ltd. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40026654 . Accessed: 18/09/2011 07:36 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Taylor & Francis, Ltd. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to World Archaeology. http://www.jstor.org Equality in the colonies: concepts of equality in Sicily duringthe eighth to six centuries bc MatthewFitzjohn Abstract In thelate eighthand earlyseventh centuries BC, a seriesof Greeksettlements of significantsize and organizationwere established on the east coast of Sicily.Their spatial organizationand systemsof land tenureappear to have been establishedon the principleof equality.This standsin contrastto the widelyheld beliefthat relationsbetween Greeks and the indigenouspopulation were based predominantlyon inequality.The aim of this articleis to re-examinethe materialexpression of equalityin the Greek settlementsand to reflectupon the ways in whichour categoriesof colonizer and colonizedhave influencedthe way thatwe look forand understandthe social relationsbetween people. I argue that the evidence of hybridforms of existenceas expressedthrough material culturerepresent different forms of equalitythat were experienced across the island in the Archaic period.
    [Show full text]
  • ANCIENT TERRACOTTAS from SOUTH ITALY and SICILY in the J
    ANCIENT TERRACOTTAS FROM SOUTH ITALY AND SICILY in the j. paul getty museum The free, online edition of this catalogue, available at http://www.getty.edu/publications/terracottas, includes zoomable high-resolution photography and a select number of 360° rotations; the ability to filter the catalogue by location, typology, and date; and an interactive map drawn from the Ancient World Mapping Center and linked to the Getty’s Thesaurus of Geographic Names and Pleiades. Also available are free PDF, EPUB, and MOBI downloads of the book; CSV and JSON downloads of the object data from the catalogue and the accompanying Guide to the Collection; and JPG and PPT downloads of the main catalogue images. © 2016 J. Paul Getty Trust This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, PO Box 1866, Mountain View, CA 94042. First edition, 2016 Last updated, December 19, 2017 https://www.github.com/gettypubs/terracottas Published by the J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles Getty Publications 1200 Getty Center Drive, Suite 500 Los Angeles, California 90049-1682 www.getty.edu/publications Ruth Evans Lane, Benedicte Gilman, and Marina Belozerskaya, Project Editors Robin H. Ray and Mary Christian, Copy Editors Antony Shugaar, Translator Elizabeth Chapin Kahn, Production Stephanie Grimes, Digital Researcher Eric Gardner, Designer & Developer Greg Albers, Project Manager Distributed in the United States and Canada by the University of Chicago Press Distributed outside the United States and Canada by Yale University Press, London Printed in the United States of America Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: J.
    [Show full text]
  • Iconography of the Gorgons on Temple Decoration in Sicily and Western Greece
    ICONOGRAPHY OF THE GORGONS ON TEMPLE DECORATION IN SICILY AND WESTERN GREECE By Katrina Marie Heller Submitted to the Faculty of The Archaeological Studies Program Department of Sociology and Archaeology In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Science University of Wisconsin-La Crosse 2010 Copyright 2010 by Katrina Marie Heller All Rights Reserved ii ICONOGRAPHY OF THE GORGONS ON TEMPLE DECORATION IN SICILY AND WESTERN GREECE Katrina Marie Heller, B.S. University of Wisconsin - La Crosse, 2010 This paper provides a concise analysis of the Gorgon image as it has been featured on temples throughout the Greek world. The Gorgons, also known as Medusa and her two sisters, were common decorative motifs on temples beginning in the eighth century B.C. and reaching their peak of popularity in the sixth century B.C. Their image has been found to decorate various parts of the temple across Sicily, Southern Italy, Crete, and the Greek mainland. By analyzing the city in which the image was found, where on the temple the Gorgon was depicted, as well as stylistic variations, significant differences in these images were identified. While many of the Gorgon icons were used simply as decoration, others, such as those used as antefixes or in pediments may have been utilized as apotropaic devices to ward off evil. iii Acknowledgements I would first like to thank my family and friends for all of their encouragement throughout this project. A special thanks to my parents, Kathy and Gary Heller, who constantly support me in all I do. I need to thank Dr Jim Theler and Dr Christine Hippert for all of the assistance they have provided over the past year, not only for this project but also for their help and interest in my academic future.
    [Show full text]
  • Archaic Greece Edited by H
    Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-52929-7 - The Cambridge Companion to Archaic Greece Edited by H. A. Shapiro Frontmatter More information The Cambridge Companion to ARCHAIC GREECE S The Cambridge Companion to Archaic Greece provides a wide-ranging syn- thesis of history, society, and culture during the formative period of Ancient Greece, from the Age of Homer in the late eighth century to the Persian Wars of 490–480 BCE. In ten clearly written and succinct chapters, leading scholars from around the English-speaking world treat all aspects of the civilization of Archaic Greece, from social, political, and military history to early achievements in poetry, philosophy, and the visual arts. Archaic Greece was an age of experimentation and intellec- tual ferment that laid the foundations for much of Western thought and culture. Under the rule of strongmen known as “tyrants,” individual city-states in Greece rose to great power and wealth, and after a long period of isolation, many cities sent out colonies that spread Hellenism to all corners of the Mediterranean world. The Greeks came together in great sanctuaries like Delphi and Olympia to compete in athletic contests and celebrate their gods with the earliest examples of mon- umental architecture and sculpture. The book offers a vivid and fully documented account of this critical stage in the history of the West. H. A. Shapiro is the W.H. Collins Vickers Professor of Archaeology and Professor of Classics at The Johns Hopkins University. A Fellow of the Guggenheim Foundation, the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, and the American School of Classical Studies at Athens, he is the author of Art and Cult under the Tyrants in Athens (1989), Personifications in Greek Art (1993), and Myth into Art: Poet and Painter in Classical Greece (1994) and coauthor of Women in the Classical World (1994).
    [Show full text]
  • Demeter Malophoros and Zeus Meilichios in Selinus
    Journal of Ancient History 2019; 7(1): 62–110 Allaire B. Stallsmith* A Divine Couple: Demeter Malophoros and Zeus Meilichios in Selinus https://doi.org/10.1515/jah-2018-0019 Abstract: This paper concerns a collection of rough-hewn flat stelae excavated from the precinct of Zeus Meilichios in Selinus, Sicily between 1915 and 1926, a majority with two heads or busts, one male and one female, carved at their tops. These crudely fashioned idols are unique in their iconography. They combine the flat inscribed Punic stela with the Greek figural tradition, with some indigenous features. Their meaning is totally obscure – especially since they lack any literary reference. No comparable monuments have been found in ancient Mediterranean cult. The twin stelae were often set up above a collection of burnt rodent and bird bones, ashes, lamps, broken and burnt pottery and terracotta figurines, as a mem- orial of a sacrifice. The stelae were the objects of a gentilicial cult, similar to that posited for the inscribed “Meilichios stones” with which they shared the Field of Stelae of Zeus Meilichios. The theory advanced here interprets these diminutive stelae (average height 30 cm) as the objects of domestic cult. It was customary in many parts of the ancient Mediterranean, from the Bronze Age down to the Ro- man period, to venerate household or family gods who protected the health and the wealth of the family. They were thought to embody the spirits of the ancestors and could at times be identified with the gods of the state religion. This divine couple whose effigies were dedicated in the Field of Stelae over a period of four centuries, into the third century, cannot be claimed as Greek or Punic deities.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Preprint of Marconi, C. 2019. "New Evidence for Early Greek Settlement on the Acropolis of Selinunte."
    Preprint of Marconi, C. 2019. "New Evidence for Early Greek Settlement on the Acropolis of Selinunte." In Listening to the Stones: Essays on Architecture and Function in Ancient Greek Sanctuaries in Honour of Richard Alan Tomlinson, eds. Elena C. Partida and Barbara Schmidt-Dounas, 252–261. Gloucester: Archaeopress. New Evidence for Early Greek Settlement on the Acropolis of Selinunte Clemente Marconi, Institute of Fine Arts–NYU1 In 2006, the Institute of Fine Arts at New York University started a new project of topographical, architectural, and archaeological investigation of the main urban sanctuary on the so-called Acropolis of Selinunte. In our first ten years of work, we have been focusing on the southern sector of the sanctuary, including Temple B and its altar, Temple R, the southern portion of Temple C, the peribolos wall, and the South Building [Figure 1].2 This new investigation has included the systematic documentation of the structures in the area, their block- by-block analysis, and the excavation of a series of trenches, mainly in correspondence of their foundations. The southern sector of the main urban sanctuary was repeatedly investigated and excavated between the nineteenth and twentieth centuries (especially by the Commissione di Antichità e Belle Arti in Sicily in the early nineteenth century, by Francesco Saverio Cavallari in 1876, and by Ettore Gàbrici in the early 1920s), and we did not expect to find much stratigraphy left, since the buildings had been excavated down to the level of their foundations. However, our excavations have shown that the foundations of Temple B, its altar, and the South Building were laid not on the bedrock but on layers of earth and sand, for various possible reasons, including antiseismic considerations.
    [Show full text]
  • Urban and Rural Land Division in Ancient Greece
    URBAN AND RURAL LAND DIVISION IN ANCIENTGREECE T75HE RESTLESSENERGY of Greek civilization led for some five hundred years to the constant founding of new communities and the reorganizationof old ones. Homer (Odyssey6.9-10), in describingthe Phaiakiansettlement in Scheria, speaks of a circuit wall for the city, the building of houses and of temples of the gods and of the division of the fields. Implicitin the foundation of new colonies was the notion of equal- ity among the members, exemplified in the division of their prime resource, the land.1 To achieve this, accurate measurement and equitable division were from the outset essential, even when gods or privileged men were to be honored with larger or better assignments. Land division involved both town and country, as the epigraphicalrecord shows for KerkyraMelaina in the 4th century B.C., where colonists received plots both inside and outside the walled area.2No doubt also the geonomoi,dispatched with Athe- nian colonists, assigned kleroiin both town and country.3The redistributionboth of land and of houses were revolutionarymeasures in settled communities, and the oaths for- mulated against this likewise reflect division of urban and agrarianland.4 So Meton in Aristophanes, Birds, 995-996, wishes "to survey the sky and divide it up in fields" but goes on to plan a city, such a city, to be sure, as no Greek city ever resembled. When it comes to the archaeologicalrecord the regular division of urban land for houses is conspicuous but in the Greek world only exceptionally does the countryside reveal its patterns. Nonetheless the link between the two is fundamental, and for both the same techniques of surveyingand geometry ("land measurement", cf.
    [Show full text]
  • Relations Between Greek Settlers and Indigenous Sicilians at Megara Hyblaea, Syracuse, and Leontinoi in the 8Th and 7Th Centuries BCE
    It’s Complicated: Relations Between Greek Settlers and Indigenous Sicilians at Megara Hyblaea, Syracuse, and Leontinoi in the 8th and 7th Centuries BCE Aaron Sterngass Professors Farmer, Edmonds, Kitroeff, and Hayton A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Degree of Bachelor of Arts in the Departments of Classical Studies and History at Haverford College May 2019 i Table of Contents Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................ i Acknowledgements........................................................................................................................... iii Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ iv I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 1 II. BACKGROUND INFORMATION PRE-750 BCE .................................................................................... 2 Greece ....................................................................................................................................................... 2 Euboea ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 Corinth .....................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Archaeological Data on the Foundation of Megara Hyblaea. Certainties and Hypotheses Henri Treziny
    Archaeological data on the foundation of Megara Hyblaea. Certainties and hypotheses Henri Treziny To cite this version: Henri Treziny. Archaeological data on the foundation of Megara Hyblaea. Certainties and hypotheses . DONNELAN L.; NIZZO V.; BURGERS G.-J. Conceptualising early Colonisation, Brepols, pp.167- 178, 2016, 978-90-74461-82-5. halshs-01434820 HAL Id: halshs-01434820 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01434820 Submitted on 13 Jan 2017 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. C onceptualising early Colonisation L ieve Donnellan, ed. Valentino Nizzo Gert-Jan Burgers B ruxelles - Brussel - Roma Belgisch Historisch Instituut te Rome Institut Historique Belge de Rome Istituto Storico Belga di Roma 2016 98110_Donnellan_voorwerk.indd 3 17/03/16 09:45 © 2016 IHBR - BHIR No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm or any other means without written permission of the copyright owner. D/2016/351/2 ISBN 978-90-74461-82-5 98110_Donnellan_voorwerk.indd 4 17/03/16 09:45 Table of content Acknowledgments ............................................................................................................................... 7 L. Donnellan & V. Nizzo, Conceptualising early Greek colonisation. Introduction to the volume ..
    [Show full text]
  • Revista RAP Extra 4 COLOR.Indb
    Chloé Chaigneau Abstract: Megara Hyblaea, one of the first Greek settlements in Sicily, has a large and diverse assemblage of millstones: saddle querns, Olynthus mills, Morgantina mills, Delian mills, rotary querns and possibly a Pompeian mill. This diversity of mill types is the result of the long occupation of the site and the confluence in Sicily of Greek, Punic and Roman cultures and a variety of food processing traditions. Keywords: Megara Hyblaea, Saddle quern, Morgantina, Olynthus, Delian, millstone Chloé Chaigneau, Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne (Paris) [email protected], ++33 0622405035 201 Introduction excavated by the French School of Rome resulting in the discovery of a large number (110) of millstones. The city of Megara Hyblaea, founded in 728 BC, Unfortunately, the spatial and chronological contexts was one of the first Greek colonies in Sicily. It is of the millstones were not recorded. Previous work located on the Bay of Augusta between Catania on millstones in Sicily, besides a few references and Syracuse, just east of the Hyblaean Mountains, in site reports or surveys, were undertaken at the between a volcanic district and the sedimentary inland cities of Morgantina (White 1963) and Entella plateau of Ragusa (Fig. 1). According to ancient (Canzanella 1997). texts, the colony was destroyed in 483 BC by Saddle querns are characteristic of the earliest, Gelon of Syracuse and remained uninhabited until longest and the most active occupation of Megara the foundation of a second settlement around 340 Hyblaea. It is interesting that the number of BC. This second city remained under the sphere lower stones of both saddle querns and Olynthus of influence of Syracuse until the Second Punic mills far outnumber their respective upper stones.
    [Show full text]
  • In Search of the Mother Goddess: Native Sculptures of Archaic Sicily (6Th -5Th Century BC)
    The Compass Volume 1 Issue 3 The Compass, Issue 3 Article 3 April 2016 In Search of the Mother Goddess: Native Sculptures of Archaic Sicily (6th -5th Century BC) Michael Lee, Bates College Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.arcadia.edu/thecompass Recommended Citation Michael Lee, Bates College (2016) "In Search of the Mother Goddess: Native Sculptures of Archaic Sicily (6th -5th Century BC)," The Compass: Vol. 1 : Iss. 3 , Article 3. Available at: https://scholarworks.arcadia.edu/thecompass/vol1/iss3/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by ScholarWorks@Arcadia. It has been accepted for inclusion in The Compass by an authorized editor of ScholarWorks@Arcadia. For more information, please contact [email protected]. In Search of the Mother Goddess: Native Sculptures of Archaic Sicily By Michael Lee, Bates College When researching sculptures during the Archaic period in the 6th-5th Century BC, the literature focuses specifically on Greek sculptures. This is because of the large variety of Greek sculptures across Sicily varying in artistic ability and symbolic meaning. There is also a greater knowledge of the Greek culture, which leads to more interest in the life of the Greek Sicilians. This is due to Greece’s colonization of Sicily, which brought an influx of art and culture that was deemed superior to the native Sicilians’. This concentration on the Greek culture has caused the culture and art of the Sicels, the native people inhabiting Sicily at the time of the arrival of Greeks, to be unintentionally neglected. This is mostly because there are very few known statues that are archaeologically significant.
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of Astronomical Alignments of Greek Sicilian Temples
    An analysis of astronomical alignments of Greek Sicilian Temples Alun Salt, The Centre for Interdisciplinary Science, University of Leicester, e: [email protected] t: @alun Abstract In the eighth century BC something peculiar seems to happen on Sicily. The archaeological record starts to show the arrival of Greek material culture. By the fifth century BC the island is effectively 'Hellenised' and ancient historians record the political and military action of poleis, Greek city- states. Each polis has traditionally been seen as the offshoot of a city elsewhere. Genealogies of cities ultimately end in cities found in the cities of the Peloponnese and the Aegean. The 'Greek' identity of the Sicilian cities is part of a wider debate on the concept of Identity in the ancient world. This paper considers if there is a contribution archaeoastronomers can make to such discussions by considering the alignments of Greek temples. Greek religion was intimately related to notions of civic identity and what it meant to be 'Greek'. I propose a method of studying small samples of temples, which combines both alignment analysis and historical context. Therefore it may be possible that a study of the temples may yield useful information about collective identities. However, as this method shows, the more ambiguous the cultural data the less certain any astronomical patterns may be. Binomial Distribution and the temples of Greek Sicily This paper develops a method initially published by Salt (2009) using data published in the same paper. The data set comprises 41 orientations of 44 temples dating from the archaic and classical periods found in ten poleis around Sicily.
    [Show full text]