Mimbres Archaeology of the Upper Gila, New Mexico
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mimbres Archaeology of the Upper Gila, New Mexico Item Type Book; text Authors Lekson, Stephen H. Publisher University of Arizona Press (Tucson, AZ) Rights Copyright © Arizona Board of Regents Download date 05/10/2021 15:55:23 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10150/595471 Mimbres Archaeology of the Upper Gila, New Mexico ANTHROPOLOGICAL PAPERS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA NUMBER 53 Mimbres Archaeology of the Upper Gila, New Mexico Stephen H. Lekson THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA PRESS TUCSON 1990 About the Author Stephen H. Lekson began his archaeological career by help ing to layout grids at the Saige-McFarland Site. He con tinued to work in southwestern New Mexico, assisting in and eventually directing excavations at eight sites in the Cliff Valley and the Big Burro Mountains, and directing a survey of the Redrock Valley of the Gila River, which was the subject of his Master's thesis. His subsequent research in and around Chaco Canyon produced his doctoral dissertation (University of New Mexico, 1988), several monographs, and a number of journal articles on Chacoan architecture and settlement pattern. He returned to the Mimbres area with a University of New Mexico field school on the east slopes of the Black Range and later directed a survey of the Rio Grande in Sierra County, New Mexico. This work resulted in a monograph and several shorter papers. He has written an overview of the Mimbres for the National Park Service and an archaeological synthesis of southwestern New Mexico for the New Mexico Historic Preservation Division. Lekson is a Research Associate at the Arizona State Mu seum, University of Arizona. Cover: Mimbres Transitional (Style II) Black-on-white bowl from Burial 2, Room 4A, Saige-McFarland Site (Vessel 28; rim diameter, 27 cm). Draw ing by Fel Brunett. THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA PRESS Copyright © 1990 The Arizona Board of Regents All Rights Reserved This book was set in Linotype CRTronic 10/ 121imes Roman i§ This book is printed on acid-free, archival-quality paper. Manufactured in the United States of America. 94 93 92 91 90 5 4 3 2 I Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lekson, Stephen H. Mimbres archaeology of the Upper Gila, New Mexico / Stephen H. Lekson. p. cm. - (Anthropological papers of the University of Arizona: no. 53) Includes bibliographic references. ISBN 0-8165-1164-0 (a1k. paper) I. Saige-McFarland Site (N.M.) 2. Mogollon culture-New Mexico. I. TItle. II. Series. E99.M76L43 1990 89-20538 978.9'692-dc20 CIP British Library Cataloguing in Publication data are available. Contents PREFACE IX Pit House 3 33 Acknowledgments IX Trenches N775 and N790 34 I. THE SAIGE-McFARLAND SITE AND 3. ARTIFACTS 35 MIMBRES ARCHAEOLOGY Ceramics 35 The Cliff Valley Ceramic Densities 36 The Saige-McFarland Site Typology 37 Geology 2 Analysis of Decorated Sherds 37 Archaeology 3 Typological Stratigraphy 38 Excavations, 1971-1972 5 Rim Sherds and Vessel Forms 42 Documentation 5 Vessel Assemblages 43 2. ARCHITECTURE AND STRATIGRAPHY 7 Lithics 60 Room Block A 7 Chipped-stone Artifacts 60 Room I IO Ground-stone Artifacts 65 Room 2 (A and B) IO Stone Slabs 70 Room 3 II Hammerstones 71 Room 4 (A and B) II Minerals and Odd Rocks 71 Room 5 12 Ornaments 72 Room 6 13 4. ARCHAEOLOGICAL SYNTHESIS OFTHE Room Block B 15 SAIGE-McFARLAND SITE 75 Room 8 19 Architecture 75 Room 9 20 Pit Structures 75 Room 10 20 Room Blocks 76 Room II 20 Artifact Deposition 78 Room 12 21 Vertical Distribution 79 Room 13 24 Chronology 80 Room 14 24 Tree-ring Date 80 Room 15 25 Carbon-14 Dates 80 Pit Structures Beneath Room Block B 26 Non-Mimbres Pottery Types 81 Room BlockC 27 Mimbres Series Pottery Types 81 Pit House I 29 Chronological Synthesis 82 [v] vi Contents 5. MIMBRES ARCHAEOLOGY OffHE UPPER GILA 84 APPENDIX B: CERAMIC SORTING CATEGORIES AND SHERD COUNTS 97 Ceramic Assemblages 85 Site Size 85 APPENDIX C: LITHIC DEFINITIONS AND ARTIFACT COUNTS 103 Surface Archaeology 86 REFERENCES III Regional Chronology 88 EPILOGUE: MIMBRES TAXONOMY 91 INDEX 115 APPENDIX A: BURIALS 93 ABSTRACT 117 FIGURES 1.1. Cliff Valley 2 3.7. Vessels from Room Block A, Room 4A, Burial 2 50 1.2. Plan of the Saige-McFarland Site 4 3.8. Profiles of vessels from Room Block A, 2.1. Room Block A 9 Burial 2 51 2.2. Room Block B, upper floors 14 3.9. Vessels from Room Block B, Room 12, 2.3. Room Block B, lower floors of Rooms 12 burials 52 and 15 15 3.10. Profiles of vessels from Room Block B, Room 12, burials 53 2.4. Pit structures below Room Block B 16 3.11. Vessels from Room Block B, fill and floor 2.5. North-south profiles of Room Block B 17 proveniences 54 2.6. East-west profiles of Room Block B 18 3.12. Profiles of vessels from Room Block B, fill 2.7. Room Block C 28 and floor proveniences 55 2.8. Pit House 1 28 3.13. Vessels from Room Block B, Room 14, floor assemblage 56 2.9. Excavation units of Pit House I 30 3.14. Profiles of vessels from Room Block B, 2.10. Pit House 3 33 Room 14, floor assemblage 57 3.1. Tripolar graph of Mimbres I-II-III Black- 3.15. Vessels from pit houses and various on-white series, grouped proveniences 40 proveniences 58 3.2. Tripolar graph of Mimbres I-II-III Black- 3.16. Profiles of vessels from pit houses and on-white series, Room 12 40 various proveniences 59 3.3. Vessels from Room Block A, fill and floor 3.17. Selected projectile points 64 proveniences 46 3.18. Selected man os and metates 66 3.4. Profiles of vessels from Room Block A, 3.19. Stone axes 68 fill and floor proveniences 47 3.20. Stone palettes 69 3.5. Vessels from Room Block A, Room 4A, 3.21. Stone pipes Burial 2 48 69 3.22. Small stone mortars 69 3.6. Profiles of vessels from Room Block A, Burial 2 49 3.23. Stone turtle effigy vessel 70 Contents vii TABLES 1.1. Mimbres Valley chronological sequence 3 3.16. Frequency distribution of ornaments 73 2.1. List of features at the Saige-McFarland Site 8 3.17. Frequency distribution of shell bracelets 73 3.1. Contexts and dating of grouped 4.1. Density of artifacts per cubic foot of proveniences used in artifact analysis 35 excavated dirt 78 3.2. Volumes in cubic feet of excavated and 4.2. Density, in items per cubic foot, of various screened fill 36 artifact classes at Cliff Valley sites 79 3.3. Ceramic sorting categories 38 4.3. Artifact densities and vertical distribution of materials in rooms at the 3.4. Percentages of typable decorated pottery by Saige-McFarland Site 80 grouped proveniences 38 4.4. In.rusive pottery types grouped into 3.5. Style III vessel rim attributes by grouped temporal ranges 81 provenIences 41 4.5. Occurrence of dated intrusive ceramics 81 3.6. Vessel form-ware assemblage composition expressed as a percentage of all rims in 4.6. Synthesis of absolute and ceramic dates for the matrix 42 selected events at the Saige-McFariand Site 82 3.7. Vessel form-ware assemblages expressed as percentages of rims within each grouped 5.1. Ceramic assemblages and chronological provenience 43 periods 85 3.8. Provenience, classification, and rim 5.2. Survey room counts expressed as a diameters of whole and partial vessels 44 percentage of total rooms by chronological periods 86 3.9. Percentages of lithic materials by grouped proveniences 61 5.3. Absolute dates from the Upper Gila 89 3.10. Percentages of coarse and fine lithic A.1. Weight in grams of bone fragments materials by grouped proveniences 61 from three cremations 93 3.11. Percentages by archaeological period of A.2. Materials associated with burials 93 coarse materials in lithic assemblages B.1. Sherd counts 99 from the Mimbres Valley and the Gila Valley 61 B.2. Summary rim form-ware data 102 B.3. Non-Mimbres pottery types 3.12. Frequency distribution of core types 62 102 c.1. Data for chipped stone 105 3.13. Frequency distribution of projectile points 65 C.2. Numbered ground-stone artifacts 108 3.14. Frequency distribution of one-hand and two-hand manos 67 C.3. Data for manos 109 3.15. Frequency distribution of minerals 72 C.4. Data for metates 110 Preface The Saige-McFarland Site is a multicomponent Mimbres undertaken only when changes in typology over the last 15 site in the Cliff Valley of the Gila River, located less than a years made reanalysis necessary (as with ceramics) or to mile northeast of Cliff, in Grant County, New Mexico. complete unfinished projects (as with chipped stone). James E. Fitting excavated the site in 1971 and 1972. A Although a number of observations and conclusions are preliminary report was published for the first season's work offered in the course of the descriptions of architecture and (Fitting and others 1971), but a final report was never com artifacts, integration of one with the other remains incom pleted. I had an opportunity to study the records and artifacts plete. What may appear to be a lack of cohesiveness in this in the late 1980s, and this monograph represents a descrip regard results primarily from the nature of available docu tion of architecture and stratigraphy of the site and of the ar mentation. The limitations imposed by that fragmented rec tifact analyses completed in 1987.