Sex Chromosome and Sex Determination Evolution in African Clawed Frogs (Xenopus and Silurana)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sex chromosome and sex determination evolution in African clawed frogs (Xenopus and Silurana) Sex chromosome and sex determination evolution in African clawed frogs (Xenopus and Silurana) Adam J Bewick, B.Sc. Hons., B.Ed. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy McMaster University c Copyright by Adam J Bewick, December 2012 DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (2012) McMaster University (Biology) Hamilton, Ontario TITLE: Sex chromosome and sex determination evolution in African clawed frogs (Xeno- pus and Silurana) AUTHOR: Adam J Bewick, B.Sc. Hons., (Laurentian University), B.Ed. (Laurentian Uni- versity) SUPERVISOR: Dr. Ben J Evans NUMBER OF PAGES: [xi], 142 ii ABSTRACT Sex chromosomes have evolved independently multiple times in plants and animals. Ac- cording to sex chromosome evolution theory, the first step is taken when an autosomal mutation seizes a leading role in the sex determining pathway, such that heterozygotes develop into one sex, and homozygotes into the other. In the second step, sexually antag- onistic mutations are expected to accumulate in the vicinity of this gene, benefiting from linkage disequilibrium. Recombination in the heterogametic sex is suppressed because of mutations that eliminate homology between the sex chromosomes, providing epistatic inter- actions between the sex determining and sexually antagonistic genes. However, suppressed recombination also lowers the efficacy of selection causing accumulation of deleterious mutations. Additionally large segments of non-functional DNA can be deleted in the sex chromosome and can reduce their physical size. Collectively, this leads to divergence be- tween non-recombining portions of each sex chromosome, causing drastic differences at the sequence level and cytologically. However, sex chromosome degeneration is not always the case, and evolutionarily old, and young, but nondegenerate sex chromosomes have been ob- served. African clawed frogs (Xenopus and Silurana) have homomorphic sex chromosomes due to a recent turnover event. However, occasional recombination between the sex chro- mosomes may contribute to the maintenance of homomorphic sex chromosomes in African clawed frogs. Mechanisms that prevent divergence and heteromorphy of sex chromosomes may be related to polyploidization, which is frequently observed in African clawed frogs. The studies herein construct a phylogenetic framework to test alternative hypotheses for selection on sex-linked and autosomal genes involved in sex determination, map sex chro- mosomes and compare sex chromosomes across African clawed frogs. I have also explored the relationship between phenomena like recent turnover events, recombination and poly- ploidization to sex chromosome degeneration (or lack thereof). In this dissertation, I have discussed the potential for multiple mechanisms of sex determination and the unique pseu- doautosomal nature of sex chromosomes within this group of frogs. This body of work provides a comprehensive study of sex chromosomes in a group lacking phylogenetic res- olution, anura, and sheds light on the origin and evolution of sex chromosomes in other organisms. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My academic career would not exist without Ben Evans. I thank my supervisor for his commitment, relentless encouragement and guidance on successful and many unsuccessful research projects, unprecedented enthusiasm and humour, for inadvertently introducing me to my wife, and for allowing me to have a life outside of the lab. My committee members Drs. Brian Golding, JP Xu and Jonathon Stone for pushing me to know and do more. Past undergraduate supervisors Drs. Albrecht Schulte-Hostedde and Thomas Merritt for their continual support and encouragement. I am also grateful to Dr. Wilfried Haerty and Wilson Sung for contributing their time to ease my suffering with bioinformatics. Many other students (past and present) have provided support, among them Drs. Melanie Lou, Carlo Artieri and Abha Ahuja, and many more who deserved to be mentioned Members of the Evans lab that I had the privilege to interact with over many years. Dr. Freddy Chain and Mr. Iqbal Setiadi were among the first to entertain me and I am greatly honoured to have worked along side them. Mrs. Shireen Bliss, Ms. Tia Harrison, Ms. Simone Mendel and Ms. Laura Pin for their help with my frog duties and various research projects. I especially acknowledge Simone for her unwavering work ethic and dedication to research. Master Jane Shen for being brave and trying new things, Hermina Ghenu for teaching me something new every day, and Ben Furman for putting up with my antics and for being an outstanding field companion in South Africa. My family and friends for their unwavering support and curiosity of my progression in my studies. My family for always reminding me that I still have a thesis to complete. My wife Emily for emotional and academic support, and for leaning on me as much as I have leaned on her. iv DECLARATION OF ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT Each chapter of this thesis has been written as a separate manuscript accepted for publica- tion with the exception of Chapter 4, which is a manuscript in preparation. Data collection, programming, analysis and manuscript preparation for each chapter was primarily an in- dividual effort, with contributions in data preparation, analysis and editing from Dave W Anderson, Fred´ eric´ JJ Chain, Ben J Evans, Joseph Heled, and from collaborators at the MRC National Institute for Medical Research in London, Charles University in Prague and the Veterinary Research Institute in the Czech Republic. v TABLE OF CONTENTS I INTRODUCTION 1 1 The pipid root 6 1.1 Preface . .6 1.2 Abstract . .6 1.3 Introduction . .7 1.4 Materials and methods . 10 1.4.1 Taxon sampling and multilocus data . 10 1.4.2 Gene tree estimation . 13 1.4.3 Concatenated analysis . 13 1.4.4 Species tree estimation – BEST and *BEAST . 14 1.5 Results . 15 1.5.1 Analysis of individual and concatenated loci . 16 1.5.2 Multilocus coalescent analysis . 19 1.6 Discussion . 22 1.6.1 Biogeographical implications . 24 1.7 Conclusions . 27 1.8 Acknowledgements . 28 1.9 Supplementary information . 28 2 Evolution of the closely related, sex-related genes DM-W and DMRT1 in African clawed frogs (Xenopus) 34 2.1 Preface . 34 2.2 Abstract . 34 2.3 Introduction . 35 2.4 Methods . 38 2.4.1 Genetic samples, phylogenetic estimation, codon analysis . 38 2.4.2 Multilocus polymorphism data . 39 2.4.3 Phylogenetically biased pseudogenization . 39 2.4.4 Expression divergence . 40 2.5 Results . 41 2.5.1 DM-W arose after divergence of Xenopus and Silurana but before divergence of X. laevis and X. clivii ................. 41 vi 2.5.2 DM-W evolved under natural selection . 45 2.5.3 Biased pseudogenization of DMRT1 paralogs after allopolyploid- ization . 49 2.5.4 DMRT1α expression is regulated by distinct mechanisms over de- velopment . 52 2.6 Discussion . 54 2.6.1 Marginalized expression of DMRT1β ................ 56 2.7 Conclusions . 57 2.8 Acknowledgements . 58 2.9 Supplementary information . 58 3 A large pseudoautosomal region on the sex chromosomes of the frog Silurana tropicalis 68 3.1 Preface . 68 3.2 Abstract . 68 3.3 Introduction . 69 3.3.1 Frog sex chromosomes . 70 3.4 Methods . 72 3.4.1 Genome-wide distribution of genotypes in female and male S. trop- icalis ................................. 76 3.4.2 Expression and molecular evolution . 77 3.5 Results . 78 3.5.1 Mitochondrial DNA variation within S. tropicalis, including the “golden” strain . 78 3.5.2 Reduced representation genome-wide genotyping from RAD tags . 80 3.5.3 Genome-wide genotype patterns and nucleotide diversity similar in males and females . 80 3.5.4 Genotype patterns based on Sanger sequencing . 83 3.5.5 Gene expression and molecular evolution . 85 3.6 Discussion . 85 3.6.1 Polyploidization, dosage compensation and sex chromosome turnover . 87 3.7 Conclusions . 88 3.8 Acknowledgements . 89 3.9 Supplementary information . 89 4 The sex chromosomes of frogs 97 4.1 Preface . 97 4.2 Abstract . 97 4.3 Introduction . 98 4.4 Evidence for recent evolution of sex chromosomes in frogs . 103 vii 4.5 Low rates of recombination may be sufficient to maintain homomorphic sex chromosomes in frogs . 106 4.6 Absence of a global mechanism of dosage compensation may effect sex chromosome evolution . 108 4.7 Homomorphic sex chromosomes and the rate of polyploidization . 109 4.8 Conclusions . 112 II CONCLUSION 114 III REFERENCES 117 viii List of Figures 1.1 Relationships among pipoid frogs . .9 1.2 Gene family extinction or missing data could generate misleading phyloge- netic affinities . 12 1.3 Evolution of the Atlantic ocean and of pipoid frogs . 16 1.4 Descriptive information about data analyzed in this study . 17 1.5 Posterior probability distribution of each of the 15 possible rooted topolo- gies recovered from analysis of 114 individual alignments . 18 1.6 Consensus species trees from *BEAST analyses . 22 1.S1 Posterior densities of mutation rates from *BEAST analysis 3 with the HKY codon model . 32 1.S2 Posterior densities of relative mutation rate from *BEAST analysis 3 with the HKY codon model . 32 2.1 Regions of homology between DM-W and DMRT1 and proposed competi- tive binding during sexual differentiation of females . 36 2.2 Autosomal genes are duplicated by allopolyploidization but sex-linked genes are not . 37 2.3 Phylogenetic distribution of DM-W in Xenopus ............... 42 2.4 DM-W originated after divergence of Silurana and Xenopus ......... 44 2.S1 Phylogenetic relationships estimated using additional partial data from other DMRT1 paralogs . 62 2.S2 Alternative scenarios for evolution of DM-W ................ 67 3.1 Genotypic scenarios for sex linked regions . 77 3.2 Phylogenetic analysis of the commercially obtained samples used for RAD tags suggests an origin from a population in Nigeria . 79 3.3 Nucleotide diversity (π) in 500,000 bp windows is similar in males and females throughout much of the S.