CANADIAN JOURNAL OF — Volume 24 (1994) — INDEX i

1994 Adams, Frederick, Trying, Desire, and Desiring to Try . 613 INDEX Adams, Frederick, Of Epicycles and Elegance 637 Articles Allen, Barry, Critical Notice of Hilary Putnam, by Author Realism With a Human Face, and Renewing Philosophy 665 Bogen, James, Critical Notice of Raymond Bradley, The Nature of all Being, A Study of Wittgenstein's Modal Absolutism 643 Brennan, Samantha, Paternalism and Rights 419 Burgess-Jackson, Keith, Critical Notice of Susan Sherwin, No Longer Patient: Feminist Ethics and Health Care 135 Clark, Ron, Pragmatic Paradox and Rationality 229 Dees, Richard H., Living With Contextualism 243 DeRose, Keith, Lewis on 'Might' and "Would' Counterfactual Conditionals 413 Exdell, John, Feminism, Fundamentalism, and Liberal Legitimacy 441 Ferreira, M. Jamie, Religion's 'Foundation in Reason': the Common Sense of Hume's Natural History 565 Fisher, John Andrew, Why Potentiality Does Not Matter: A Reply to Stone 261 Gauthier, David, Breaking Up: An Essay on Secession . . 357 Haji, Ishtiyaque, Autonomy and Blameworthiness .... 593 Haji, Ishtiyaque, Critical Notice of Alfred Mele, Springs of Action: Understanding Intentional Behavior 511 Hales, Steven D., Certain iy and Phenomenal States ... 57 Ha worth, Lawrence, Critical Notice of Christine Swanton, Freedom: A Coherence Theory 337 Hill, Christopher S., Critical Notice of William Seager, The Metaphysics of Consciousness 155 Jacquette, Dale, On the Designated Student and Related Induction Paradoxes 583 Kvart, Igal, Overall Positive Causal Impact 205 Marras, Ausonio, Nonreductive Materialism and Mental Causation 465 Mele, Alfred, Desiring to Try: Reply to Adams 627 Mills, Charles W., Marxism, 'Ideology' and Moral • Objectivism 373 CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY — Volume 24 (1994) — INDEX

Nelson, Lynn Hankinson, Critical Notice of Lorraine Code, What Can She Know? Feminist Theory and the Construction of Knowledge 295 O'Connor, Timothy, An Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism? 527 ~Pietroski,PaulM., A Defense of Derangement 95 Pugmire, David, Perverse Preference: Self-Beguilement or Self-Division? 73 Resnick, David, Hacking's Experimental Realism .... 395 Rice, Lee C, Le Nominalisme de Spinoza 19 Rovane, Carol, Critical Notice of Peter linger, Identity, Consciousness and Value 119 Schauer, Frederick, Critical Notice of Roger Shiner, Norm and Nature: The Movements of Legal Thought 495 Shaver, Robert, Hume's Self-interest Requirement .... 1 Stone, Jim, Why Potentiality Still Matters 281 Ten, C.L., Critical Notice of Wendy Donner, The Liberal Self: John Stuart Mill's Moral and Political Philosophy 327 Vogel, Jeffrey S., Is Marx a Moral Consequentialist? . . . 541 Warren, Paul, Self-Ownership, Reciprocity, and Exploitation, or Why Marxists Shouldn't Be Afraid of Robert Nozick 33 Williams, Meredith, The Significance of Learning in Wittgenstein's Later Philosophy 173 CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY — Volume 24 (1994) — INDEX ui

1994 Autonomy and Blameworthiness, Ishtiyaque Haji . . . 593 INDEX Breaking Up: An Essay on Secession, David Gauthier . 357 Articles Certainty and Phenomenal States, Steven D. Hales ... 57 by Title Critical Notice of Raymond Bradley, The Nature of All Being, A Study of Wittgenstein's Modal Absolutism, James Bogen 643 Critical Notice of Lorraine Code, What Can She Know? Feminist Theory and the Construction of Knowledge, Lynn Hankinson Nelson 295 Critical Notice of Wendy Donner, The Liberal Self: John Stuart Mill's Moral and Political Philosophy, C.L. Ten 327 Critical Notice of Alfred R. Mele, Springs of Action: Understanding Intentional Behavior, Ishtiyaque Haji 511 Critical Notice of Hilary Putnam, Realism With a Human Face, and Renewing Philosophy, Barry Allen 665 Critical Notice of William Seager, The Metaphysics of Consciousness, Christopher S. Hill . 155 Critical Notice of Susan Sherwin, No Longer Patient: Feminist Ethics and Health Care? Keith Burgess-Jackson 135 Critical Notice of Roger Shiner, Norm and Nature: The Movements of Legal Thought, Frederick Schauer 495 Critical Notice of Christine Swanton, Freedom: A Coherence Theory, Lawrence Haworth 337 Critical Notice of Peter Unger, Identity, Consciousness and Value, Carol Rovane 119 A Defense of Derangement, Paul M. Pietroski 95 Desiring to Try: Reply to Adams, Alfred Mele 627 An Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism? Timothy O'Connor 527 Feminism, Fundamentalism, and Liberal Legitimacy, John Exdell 441 Hacking's Experimental Realism, David B. Resnik . . . 395 Hume's Self-interest Requirement, Robert Shaver .... 1 Is Marx a Moral Consequentialist? Jeffrey S. Vogel . . . 541 Lewis on 'Might' and 'Would' Counterfactual Conditionals, Keith DeRose 413 CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY — Volume 24 (1994) — INDEX

Living With Contextualism, Richard H. Dees 243 Marxism, 'Ideology/ and Moral Objectivism, Charles W. Mills 373 Le Nominalisme de Spinoza, Lee C. Rice 19 Nonreductive Materialism and Mental Causation, Ausonio Marras 465 Of Epicycles and Elegance, Frederick Adams 637 On the Designated Student and Related Induction Paradoxes, Dale Jacquette 583 Overall Positive Causal Impact, Igal Kvart 205 Paternalism and Rights, Samantha Brennan 419 Perverse Preference: Self-Beguilement or Self-Division? David Pugmire 73 Pragmatic Paradox and Rationality, Ron Clark 229 Religion's 'Foundation in Reason': The Common Sense of Hume's Natural History, M. Jamie Ferreira . . 565 Self-Ownership, Reciprocity, and Exploitation, or Why Marxists Shouldn't Be Afraid of Robert Nozick, Paul Warren 33 The Significance of Learning in Wittgenstein's Later Philosophy, Meredith Williams 173 Trying, Desire, and Desiring to Try, Frederick Adams . 613 Why Potentiality Does Not Matter: A Reply to Stone, John Andrew Fisher 261 Why Potentiality Still Matters, Jim Stone 281 Canadian Journal of Philosophy

Information The purpose of the Canadian Journal of Philosophy is the publication for Authors m Canada of philosophical work of high quality, in English or French, and in any field of philosophy. All submissions are given blind editorial review; those of departmental colleagues are exter­ nally refereed. Manuscripts should be sent in triplicate to: Executive Secretary, Canadian Journal of Philosophy, Department of Philosophy, Univer­ sity of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada T1K 3M4. It is preferred that manuscripts be typed double-spaced, including quotes and footnotes. In general, the Canadian Journal of Philosophy follows The University of Chicago Manual of Style. Footnotes should be numbered consecutively and assembled on separate pages at the end of the manuscript. Manuscripts will not be returned unless return postage is prepaid by cheque, money-order, reply coupons, or Canadian stamps. Authors will receive, without charge, 25 copies of their articles. Additional offprints may be ordered when the proofs are returned to the publisher. The articles in CJP are indexed in The ' Index, Bowling Green, Ohio, USA, in the Reportoire bibliographique de la philosophie, Louvain, Belgium, and in the Canadian Periodical Index. All enquiries of an editorial nature should be directed to the Executive Secretary at the above address.

Avis aux The Canadian Journal of Philosophy a pour objet la publication canadi- auteurs enne, en langues anglaise ou francaise, d'etudes philosophiques de haut niveau, quel que soit le domaine philosophique auxquelles elles appartiennent. Les communications sont evaluees dans l'anonymat de leurs auteurs; celles que soumettent les collegues departementaux sont referees a un comite de lecture exterieur. Les manuscrits, en triple exemplaire, doivent etre adresses a La Secretaire de Redaction. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada T1K 3M4. Soumettre de preference des manuscrits (citations et notes comprises) dacty­ lographies a double interligne, en prenant pour guide, dans la mesure du possible, The University of Chicago Manual of Style. Les notes doivent suivre la numerotation continue et figurer sur des feuilles independantes en annexe au manuscrit. Les textes non inseres ne sont rendus qu'en cas de prepaiement des frais de poste par cheque, mandat, coupons-reponse, ou timbres canadiens. Les auteurs recoivent gratuitement 25 tires-a part de leur article, lis sont pries, s'ils desirent en obtenir un plus grand nombre a titre onereux, en informer l'imprimeur lors de renvoi des epreuves. Les articles du CJP sont catalogues dans The Philosophers' Index, Bowling Green, Ohio, E-U, dans le Repertoire bibliographique de la philosophie, Louvain, Belgique, et dans YIndex de Periodiques Canadiens. •_ Canadian Journal of Philosophy

Subscription Canadian Journal of Philosophy is published by the University Information of Calgary Press. Canadian Journal of Philosophy is published quarterly, in March, June, September, and December. In addition to these regular issues, CJP publishes annually a supplementary vol­ ume of original papers on a selected theme of contemporary philosophical interest. This supplementary volume is free to individual and student subscribers to the journal in that year. Supplementary volumes may also be purchased separately from UBC Press, 6344 Memorial Road, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z2. Correspondence regarding subscriptions, renewals, and single issues should be addressed to Canadian Journal of Philosophy c/o University of Calgary Press, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2N 1N4. A subscription for the 1995 volume of four issues plus the supplementary volume is: Canada Outside Canada Institutions On. $40.00 LB $40.00 Individuals 25.00 25.00 Students 15.00 15.00 Single issues 9.00 9.00 A joint subscription to Canadian Journal of Philosophy and the Australasian Journal of Philosophy is available to individuals at $40 and to students at $25. Outside Canada the price is in US dollars. Canadian residents please add 7% GST.

Canadian AyJourna l of Philosophy

University of Calgary Press, 1995 Subscription • Individual • University of Calgary, 1995 Joint Subscription • Student • CALGARY, Alberta, Canada T2N 1N4 Back Issue • No.

Please send me information on CJP Supplementary Volumes LI Name

AIdress_ Qty Country Postal Code Visa LI Mastercard LI No. Expiry Date Cheques should be made payable to University of Calgary Press. Canadian Journal of Philosophy

Abonnements Canadian Journal of Philosophy est publie par University of Calgary Press. Canadian Journal of Philosophy est une publication trimestrielle paraissant en mars, juin, septembre, et octobre. Outre ses quatre fascicules reguliers, il publie, annuellement, un supplement thematique d'articles inedits consacres a des sujets d'actualite philosophique. Le supplement est offert gratuitement a tout abonne — particulier ou etudiant — de l'annee courante. Les supplements sont egalement dis- ponibles a titre onereux a UBC Press, 6344 Memorial Road, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z2. Toute correspondance concernant l'administration (abonnements, renouvellements, commandes de numeros) doit etre adressee a Canadian Journal of Philosophy, c/o Uni­ versity of Calgary Press, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2N 1N4. Tarifs d'abonnement au volume 1995 (4 fascicules et de supplements): Canada Hors-Canada Institutions Cdn. $40.00 US $40.00 Individus 25.00 25.00 Etudiants 15.00 15.00 Numero simple 9.00 9.00 Tout individu ou etudiant peut souscrire, a raison de $40 et $25 respectivement, un double abonnement au Canadian Journal of Philosophy et a YAustralasian Journal of Philosophy. Regle- ment en dollars US pour tous ceux qui resident en dehors du Canada. Les residents du Canada doivent paye la TPS. Canadian Journal of cfcPhilosoph> y

University of Calgary Press, Abonnement 1995 • Individu • University of Calgary, Double Abonnement 1995 • Etudiant • CALGARY, Alberta, Canada Numeros disponsibles • No. T2N 1N4

Veuillez me faire parvenir tous les renseignements concernant les supplements du CJP •

Nom Adresse Ville „ Pays Code Postal Visa D Mastercard • No. Date d'expiration Libeller tout cheque a l'ordre de University of Calgary Press. (Canadian. _ Journal of Philosophy

Other All business correspondence should be addressed to Canadian Jour­ Business nal of Philosophy, University of Calgary Press, Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4. This includes enquiries concerning advertising and promotion, Information exchanges, and reprinting. The copyright for all materials appearing in the regular issues and in the supplements of this journal is held by the Canadian Journal of Philosophy, and consent for any reproduc­ tion or reprinting must be obtained with the following exception. Automatic Permission to reproduce parts of individual numbers of Canadian Permission Journal of Philosophy by photocopy, xerox, offset, etc., for scholarly purposes (but not for republishing by printing nor for sale to the to Reproduce public) is automatically granted without prior permission being secured at the following rates: first 5 copies, no charge; 4 cents for each copy in excess of five of each page of CJP. Remuneration is to be paid to the Canadian Journal of Philosophy, stating title and author of the article and number of copies. Proceeds above $10.00 from any one article will be shared with the author. This announcement applies retroactively to volume I, number 1. Back Issues Canadian Journal of Philosophy is indexed in Canadian Magazine Index by Micromedia Limited. Back volumes are available in micro­ form from Micromedia Limited, 158 Pearl St., Toronto, ON M5H 1L3.416-593-5211. Services Toute correspondance administrative, a l'exception de celle qui administratifs concerne les abonnements, renouvellements et commandes de numeros et de supplements, doit etre adressee aux Canadian Journal — details of Philosophy, University of Calgary Press, Calgary, Alberta T2N supplemen- 1N4. Ecrire a l'adresse ci-dessus pour tous renseignements relatifs a la publicite et a la promotion, ainsi qu'aux echanges et aux reimpres- taires sions. Le copyright des articles afferents aux fascicules et sup­ plements est propriete du Canadian Journal of Philosophy. Leur reproduction ou reimpression en tout ou partie ne peut etre faite sans l'agrement prealable de le Directeur de la Publication, sauf dans le cas suivant. Reproduction Est affranchie d'agrement prealable la reproduction partielle des affranchie numeros du Canadian Journal of Philosophy par precede technique de photocopie, xerox, offset, etc., lorsqu'elle vise exclusivement a des d'agrement fins ou a des recherches academiques. Est interdite toute reimpres­ prealable sion ayant pour objet la vente au public. Conditions tarifaires de reproduction: 1-5 copies, accorde a titre gracieux; 6 copies ou en plus, 4 cents pour chaque copie de chaque page du CJP. Effectuer tout reglement a l'ordre du Canadian Journal of Philoso­ phy. Avoir soin d'indiquer le nom de l'auteur et le titre de l'article a reproduire d'une part, et le nombre de copies requises, de l'autre. Les apports provenant d'un article sont partages a egalite avec son auteur pour la part numeraire depassant $10.00 (reglement retroactif au volume I, No. 1). Volumes Canadian Journal of Philosophy est repertoirie par Micromedia ltee anterieurs dans le Canadian Magazine Index et les volumes anterieurs sont disponibles en microforme chez Micromedia ltee, 158 Pearl St., Toronto, ON M5H1L3.416-593-5211. This Publication is available in microform

Back volumes of this publication are available in microform (film orfiche).

For further information, contact:

Micromedia Limited Canada's Information People

20 Victoria Street, Toronto, Ontario M5C2N8 (416)362-5211 1-800-387-2689 CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY SUPPLEMENTARY VOLUMES Retail Retail in outside Canada Canada Cdn. $$ US$$ Vol.I —1975 Part 1: New Essays in the History of Philosophy 10.00 10.00 Part 2: New Essays in the Philosophy of Mind 10.00 10.00 Vol. HI —1977 New Essays in Contract Theory 13.00 13.00 Vol. rv* —1978 New Essays in Rationalism and Empiricism 13.00 13.00 Vol. V —1979 New Essays on Mill and Utilitarianism 13.00 13.00 Vol. VI —1980 New Essays in Philosophy of 13.00 13.00 Language 15.00 15.00 Vol.VH —1981 Marx and Morality Vol. VIII —1982 New Essays in Ethics and 14.00 13.00 Public Policy 13.00 13.00 Vol. IX —1983 New Essays on Plato 14.00 14.00 Vol. X —1984 New Essays on Aristotle Vol. XI —1985 New Essays in the Philosophy 14.00 14.00 of Mind, Series II Vol. XII —1986 Nuclear Weapons, Deterrence 12.00 10.00 and Disarmament VoLXin —1987 Science, Morality and 14.00 12.00 Feminist Theory 14.00 12.00 VoLXTV —1988 Philosophy and Biology 25.00 21.00 Vol. XV —1989 Analyzing Marxism Vol. XVI —1990 Canadian Philosophers- Celebrating Twenty Years of the Canadian Journal of Philosophy 24.00 20.00 Vol.XVII —1991 Aristotle and his Medieval 21.00 21.00 Interpreters 22.00 22.00 Vol. XVm —1992 Return of the A Priori 30.00 30.00 Vol. XIX —1993 Meta-Philosophie Postage and Handling (Canada) is $3.00 for the first book and $.75 for each additional book. Postage and Handling (outside Canada) is $4.00 for the first book and $.75 for each additional book. Canadian orders must include 7% GST on the total cost of the book(s) as well as the postage and handling. Prices outside Canada are in US dollars. Order From: University of Calgary Press c/o UBC Press 6344 Memorial Road Vancouver, BC V6T1Z2 Philosophy and Phenomenological Research AN INTERNATIONAL QUARTERLY FOUNDED BY MARVIN FARBER

ERNEST SOSA, Editor RODERICK M. CHISHOLM, Associate Editor

PPR is now fifty percent longer than in the past. This has made possible some new departures with no decrease in refereed material published. For example, regularly featured book symposia include the following:

1. Jerrold Katz's The Metaphysics of Meaning. Precis by the author. Discussants: Paul Boghossian, Roger Gibson, Paul Horwich, and Eddy Zemach. Response by the author. 2. Alvin Plantinga's Warrant (2 vols.). Precis by the author. Discussants: William Alston, Carl Ginet, Matthias Steup, Richard Swinburne, James Taylor, and Nicholas Wolterstdrff. Response by the author. 3. Nicholas Rescher's A System of Pragmatic Idealism (3 vols.). Precis by the author. Discussants: Cornelius Delaney, John Kekes, Joseph Margolis, Jack Meiland, Terrance McConnell, Johanna Seibt, and T. L. S. Sprigge. Response by the author. 4. Daniel Dennett's Consciousness Explained. Precis by the author. Discussants: Frank Jackson, David Rosenthal, Sydney Shoemaker, and Michael Tye. Response by the author. 5. Michael Slote's From Morality to Virtue. Precis by the author. Discussants: Stephen Darwall, Henry Richardson, and Michael Stocker. Response by the author.

The three Royce Lectures delivered at Brown in 1993 by Sydney Shoemaker appear in the June, 1994 issue.

PPR can now typeset directly from disks and from text received electronically. This enables us to publish substantially more material in each issue with no increase in the time from submission to publication, or in the time required for publication of reviews and book symposia.

Subscription Order Form

Please enter my one-year subscription to Philosophy and Phenomenological Research:

• Individual $19.00 (foreign, $23.00 postpaid) • Institutional $53.00 (foreign, $57.00 postpaid)

• Enclosed is my check for .

Name

Address

City, State, Zip

Send to: Philosophy and Phenomenological Research Box 1947, Brown University Providence, RI 02912 (USA) Auslegung a journal of philosophy

AUSLEGUNG is a journal published two times a year at the University of Kansas. The journal is a forum for the expression of any and all philosophical perspectives. The editors are primarily interested in publishing the work of new Ph.D.'s and students pursuing the Ph.D. degree, but all papers of philosophical interest will be considered.

AUSLEGUNG gratefully acknowledges the financial sup­ port which it receives from the Student Senate and the Graduate Student Council of the University of Kansas.

Yes! I want to subscribe to Auslegung.

Student $8.00 Individual $10.00 Institution $20.00

Enclosed is my check for:

Name

Address

City

State/Zip

AUSLEGUNG Department of Philosophy University of Kansas Lawrence, Kansas 66045 Revue de 1'enseignement de la philosophic au Quebec Numeio 16, 1994, 300 pages ISSN 0827-1887 ISBN 2-9802484-3-6

Le difi ithique dans un contexte social et culturel en mutation, par Guy Rocher De la croyance morale a la parole ithique, par Georges A. Legault Uenseignement de Vithique comme activiti de formation morale, par Luc Begin tthique et enseignement, par Andre Carrier Riflexions sur l enseignement de I'ithique, par Claude Paris Enseigner Tithique selon leparadigme du «moi moralement relii», par S. M. Mullett Peut-on parler de thiories en ithique!, par Lukas K. Sosoe Rationalisme et ithique naturalisie, par Andrew Quinn La construction du champ de V ithique en environnement, par Andre Beauchamp Ethique et ithiques appliquies, par Marie-Helene Parizeau La bioithique : dune revolution a Vautre, par Marcel J. Melanfon La bioithique, une interface entre thiorie et pratique!, par Bruno Leclerc Chemins et impasses de Vithique a I'hdpital, par Jean-Francois Malherbe Pour un enseignement relativiste de Vithique, par Jean-Francois Martineau Notes sur le relativisme et le monisme en ithique, par Daniel M. Weinstock Relativisme ithique et rationaliti, par Michel Paquette Le difi pidagogique du relativisme en ithique, par David Davies L'humanitaire entre V ithique et la politique, par Jean-Marie Therrien En deqa de la souveraineti, par Joseph Pestieau La philosophie politique et la formation du citoyen, par Wayne Norman L'enseignement de la philosophie et la citoyenneti, par Jean Baillargeon Protreptique et dialectique, par Georges Leroux L'enseignement de I'histoire de I'ithique, par Dominique Leydet Enseigner Vithique par I'histoire, par Louise Marcil U ithique aujourdhui : entre fondation et application, par Alain Renaut

REDACTION : PHILOSOPHER, Coltege Montmorency, 475, boul. de TAvenir, Laval, Qc, H7N 5H9, Canada. ABONNEMENT : PERIODICA, C.P. 444, Outremont, Qc, H2V 4R6, Canada. Tel: (514) 274-5468 ou 1-800-361-1431.

CANADA : 1 an (2 numeros) institutions 51.04$, individus 28.49$, gtudiants 17.01$ (TPS et TVQ incluses) ETRANGER : individus 30$, institutions 50$. Commande au numero : 13.67$ Established in 1960, to provide a medium for study of the philosophy of art and the principles of aesthetic judgment in the context of the arts, The British Journal of Aesthetics is one of the leading journals of its kind on the international scene. VOLUME 35 1995 The Journal covers theoretical discussion of the principles and criteria of criticism but does not include practical criticism of any of the arts. In addition to general aesthetics, experience of both fine and applied arts is examined from the point of view of the psychologist, the sociologist, the Edited by T.J. Diffoy, University of Sussex historian, the teacher, and the general Pi£ .-.h<:.if:; n8tr.i:n£'"/:r/"IA

SUMARIO Presentaci6n Articulos DAVID SOSA, iD6nde se encuentra el enigma sobre la creencia? PEDRO RAMOS, El enigma de Kripke: una soluci6n formal-intensional RAUL ORAYEN, Un esbozo de so!uci6n a un enigma de Kripke MARK PLATTS, Deseos distinguidos OLBETH HANSBERG, Miedo e incertidumbre GUILLERMO HURTADO, Subjetividad y privacidad SALMA SAAB, Una position intermedia entre el fisicalismo y el intencionalismo: Dennett Notas bibliogrqficas JERROLD J. KATZ, The Metaphysics of Meaning [Lourdes Valdivia] CRISTINA LAFONT, La razon como lenguaje. Una revisidn del "giro linguistico" en la filosofia del lenguaje alemana [Carlos Pereda] CARLOS ULISES MOULINES, Pluralidady recursion. Estudios epistemologkos [Jos^-Luis Falguera] CRITICA, Revista Hispanoamericana de Filosofia is published in April, August and December. All correspondence should be addressed to CRITICA, Apartado 70-447, CoyoacSn, 04510, D. F., Mexico. ARCHIVES DE PHILOSOPHIE Revue trimestrielle publiee avec le concours du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, de la Fondation de Montcheuil et du Centre National des Lettres

TOME 56 - CAHIER 4 - OCTOBRE-DECEMBRE 1993 PHILOSOPHES EN ITALIE (I) Charles ALUNNI, Tommaso Campanella entre grammaire « monumentale » et grammaire generate - Bruno PINCHARD, Diis Manibus ou Vico chez les morts - Andre TOSEL, Le Marx actualiste de Gentile et son destin - Livio SICHIROLLO, e Hegel en Italie au xx siecle - Michele CILIBERTO, Philosophic et autobiogra­ phic chez Benedetto Croce - Gianfranco DALMASSO, Le propre du discours. Le christianisme et la pensee comme symptome - Fabio MINAZZI et Jean PETITOT, La connaissance objective comme valeur historique : le neo-illuminisme ita- lien - Remo BODEI, Un autre comme soi-meme.

TOME 57 - CAHIER 1 -JANVIER-MARS 1994 PHILOSOPHES EN ITALIE (II)

Franco SBARBERI, La formation de la theorie democratique de Bobbio - Dome- nico JERVOLINO, Notes sur Capograssi et Piovani - Marco RAVERA, Luigi Parey- son et son ecole - Gianni VATTIMO, Metaphysique et violence. Question de methode - Catherine PAOLETTI, Aldo G. Gargani ou du (de)constructivisme en philosophic - Francis WYBRANDS, En tant que. Les manieres de Giorgio Agam- ben - Giorgio AGAMBEN, Le philosophe et la muse (aphorismes) - Italo VALENT, Severino et la poesie du neant - Riccardo PINERI, La pensee a l'epreuve du poe- tique - Massimo CACCIARI, Augusto del Noce et le probleme de l'atheisme - Xavier TILLIETTE, Sciacca (1908-1975) ou le pathos du philosophe - Guy PETIT- DEMANGE, Michelstaedter, le defi de la metaphysique - Ferrucio MASINI, Giorgio ColU. Le philosophe et l'enigme - Domenico LOSURDO, Economisme historique ou materialisme historique ? Pour une relecture de Marx et Engels - Silvano PETROSINO, La « Khora » francaise. Notes sur la presence et sur l'influence de la pensee francaise en Italie de l'apres-guerre a aujourd'hui.

REDACTION : Centre Sevres - 35 bis, rue de Sevres - 75006 PARIS' VENTE ET ABONNEMENTS : BEAUCHESNE - 72, rue des Saints-Peres - 75007 PARIS Le cahier (France et Etranger) : 140 FF (CCP trois volets a l'ordre de Beauchesne ou cheque bancaire) AUSTRALASIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY Editor: Robert Young SOME RECENT AND FORTHCOMING ARTICLES Edwin Curley Spinoza on Truth Robert Dunn Motivated Irrationality and Divided Attention Sally Haslanger Humean Supervenience and Enduring Things Richard Swinburne Thisness

In the March 1995 issue part of a symposium on East-West Philosophy will be published; the other part will appear in Philosophy East and West in their April 1995 issue. The June 1995 issue will be devoted entirely to issues in Aesthetics. Annual Subscription: Individuals A$40.00 (US$40.00 or Stg£20.00); Special Student Rate A$20.00 (US$20.00 or Stg£10.00); Institutions A$70.00 (US$70.00 or Stg£35.00). For individual subscribers a special offer is available of a joint subscription to Australasian Journal of Philosophy and Canadian Journal of Philosophy for an additional A$10.00 (US$10.00 or Stg£5.00). All correspondence should be addressed either to the Editor or to the Business Manager, Australasian Journal of Philosophy, Department of Philosophy, La Trobe University, Bundoora, Victoria, 3083, Australia; e-mail: [email protected]; fax: 61 3 479 1700. Published quarterly by the Australasian Association of Philosophy with support from La Trobe University Q> (PfiiCosopfdcaC topics Editor: Christopher S. Hill, University of Arkansas

Vol. 21, No. 1, Spring 1993 TOPIC: DECISION THEORY Issue Editor: James Joyce

Brad Armendt: Dutch Books, Additivity, and Utility Theory; Cristina Bicchieri: Counterfactuals, Belief Changes, and Equilibrium Refinements; Daniel M. Farrell: Utility-maximizing Intentions and the Theory of Rational Choice; William Harper: Causal and Evidential Expectations in Strategic Settings; James Hawthorne: Bayesian Induction Is Eliminative Induction; Richard Jeffrey: Causality in the Logic of Decision; Mark Kaplan: Not by the Book; Teddy Seidenfeld: Outline of a Theory of Partially Ordered Preferences; Peter Vandershraaf & Brian Skyrms: Deliberational Correlated Equilibria; J. David Velleman: The Story of Rational Action.

Vol. 21, No. 2, Fall 1993 TOPIC: PHILOSOPHY OF LOGIC (Forthcoming)

C. Anthony Anderson: Toward a Logic of A Priori Knowledge; Graeme Forbes: "But a was Arbitrary..."; Michael L. Geis & William G. Lycan: Nonconditional Conditionals; Anil Gupta: A Critique of Deflationism; Vann McGee: A Semantic Conception of Truth?; Christopher Menzel: Singular Propositbns and Modal Logic; Gideon Rosen: The Refutation of Nominalism (?); Nathan Salmon: This Side of Paradox; Chris Swoyer: Logic and the Empirical Conception of Properties; Jamie Tappenden: Analytic Truth—It's Worse (or Perhaps Better) than You Thought; Edward N. Zalta: A Philosophical Conception of Propositional Modal Logic.

Subscription Rates: Domestic Individual Rate (U. S. and Canada)—$25; Foreign Individual Rate—$30 in U. S. Currency; Domestic Institutional Rate (U. S. and Canada)—$45; Foreign Institutional Rate—$50 in U. S. Currency. All checks should be made payable to The University of Arkansas Press /Philosophical Topics 201 Ozark Avenue, Fayetteville, AR 72701. ISSN: 0276-2080 the review off metaphysics a philosophical quarterly

ISSN 0034-6632 SEPTEMBER 1994 | VOL. XLVIII, No. 1 | ISSUE No. 189 j $11.00 articles books received philosophical abstracts doctoral dissertations visiting philosophers retiring philosophers announcements

DONALD W. SHERBURNE Some Reflections on Sartre's Nothingness and Whitehead's Perishing

KENNETH T. GALLAGHER Remarks on the Argument from Design

JOHN J. CLEARY Emending Aristotle's Division of Theoretical Sciences LAURENCE BERNS Aristotle and Adam Smith on Justice: Cooperation between Ancients and Moderns?

C. B. CHRISTENSEN Peirce's Transformation of Kant

GIUSEPPE BUTERA AND STAFF Summaries and Comments philosophical abstracts announcements

Individual Subscriptions $25.00 Institutional Subscriptions $42.00 Student/Retired Subscriptions $15.00 Jude P. Dougherty, Editor The Catholic University of America, Washington, D.C. 20064 CLASSICAL ANTIQUITY

A SELECTION OF RECENT AND FORTHCOMING ARTICLES

JUDITH BARRINGER The Mythological Paintings in the Macellum at Pompeii MATTHEW CHRIST Herodotean Kings and Historical Inquiry

ROBERT DOBBIN Aeneid 1.286-96 and the sidus Iulium DAVID FREDERICK Beyond the Atrium to Ariadne: Erotic Painting and Visual Pleasure in the Roman House CARIN GREEN The Necessary Murder: Myth, Ritual, and Civil War in Lucan, Book 3 GARY MELTZER Where is the Glory of Troy? Kleos in Euripides' Helen CHARLES PAZDERNIK Our Most Pious Consort Given Us by God: Dissident Reaction to the Partnership of Justinian and Theodora, A.D. 525-548

ROSSSCAIFE The Kypria and Greek Iconography

DANIEL SELDEN Displacement in Callimachus

Classical Antiquity is published twice a year. Subscriptions are $32 for individuals, $18 for students, and $64 for institutions (outside U.S. add $4 postage). To order, write: Journals Division, 2120 Berkeley Way #5812, Berkeley, CA 94720-5812, or FAX: 510/642-9917. UNIVERSITY OF PRESS the review off metaphysics a philosophical quarterly

ISSN 0034-6632 DECEMBER 1994 | VOL. XLVIII, No. 2 | ISSUE No. 190 | $11.00 articles books received philosophical abstracts announcements

CARLOS STEEL Does Evil Have a Cause? Augustine's Perplexity and Thomas's Answer

GABRIELA ROXANA CARONE Teleology and Evil in Laws 10

IAN WILKS Aquinas on the Past Possibility of the World's Having Existed Forever AMY MORGAN SCHMITTER Representation, Self-Representation, and the Passions in Descartes

STEVEN B. SMITH Spinoza's Democratic Turn: Chapter 16 of the Theologico-Political Treatise

GIUSEPPE BUTERA AND STAFF Summaries and Comments philosophical abstracts announcements Individual Subscriptions $25.00 Institutional Subscriptions $42.00 Student/Retired Subscriptions $15.00 Jude P. Dougherty, Editor The Catholic University of America. Washington, D.C. 20064 THE PHILOSOPHIGAL QUARTERLY Edited in die Chairman of the Board of Editors: ROGER SQUIRES Executive Editor: CHRISTOPHER BRYANT Reviews Editor: BERYS GAUT Founded in 1950, the Quarterly is one of the best established journals in the field. It aims to publish significant papers in all branches of the subject, discussions of new philosophical work, reviews of books and book notes. Recent articles include: Recent Reviews by: Richard Bellamy and Martin Hollis on Elizabeth Anscombe, Frederick Copleston, justice; Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit Jonathan Dancy, Gerald Dworkin, David on moral functionalism; John McDowell Hamlyn, Ross Harrison, Richard Heck, and David Hamlyn on perception; C.B. John Heil, Christopher Hookway, Anthony Martin on dispositionals; G.B. Hunter Kenny, Onora O'Neill, Jerrold Levinson, and E.J. Lowe on conditionals. Greg McCulloch, Joseph Margolis, Roger Scruton, Mary Wamock, Michael Williams.

Subscription Rates, Volume 45,1995 The Philosophical Quarterly ISSN 0031 -8094 Individuals £19.50 UK/Europe, $40.00 N America, £25.50 Rest of World Institutions £57.00 UK/Europe, $117.00 N America, £76.00 Rest of World

-* Cheques made payable to Blackwell Publishers should be sent to: Journals Marketing, Blackwell Publishers, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford, OX4 1JF, England. Or to: Journals Marketing, PHIQ, Blackwell Publishers, 238 Main Street, Cambridge, MA 02142, USA -• Sample copies can be ordered via EMAIL: [email protected] Blackwell Publishers Oxford, UK and Cambridge, USA

REVUE INTERNATIONALE DE PHILOSOPHIE

Editor: Michel MEYER Universite de Bruxelles, C.P. 188 50, avenue F.D. Roosevelt - 1050 Brussels, Belgium Each number is devoted to a particular movement, a particular philosopher, or a particu­ lar problem. We publish 4 issues annually. Articles are written in English, French, German, or Italian. Our last issue was devoted to Passions. Articles by: Michel Meyer, Introduction: De Timportance et de la resurgence des passions - Angele Kremer-Marietti, De la passionnalite - Herman Parret, Le timbre de I'affect et les tonalites affectives - Marc Wetzel, Action et passion - Benoit Timmermans, Descartes et Spinoza: de /'admiration au desir - Jacques Fontanille, Modalisations et modulations passionnelles - Michel Meyer, Le probleme des passions chez Saint Thomas d'Aquin. — Reviews: John H. Zammito, The Genesis of Kant's Critique of Judgment (R. Pouivet) - J.L. Heiberg, H.L. Martensen, P.M. M0ller, F.C. Sibbern, F. Beck et S.A. Kierkegaard, Lectures philosophiques de S0ren Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard chez ses contemporains danois (Jean-Marc Gabaude) - Yvon Bies, L'etre et la faute: essais psychanalytico-philosophiques - La souffrance et le tragique. Essais sur le judeo-christianisme, les tragiques, Platon et Freud (Jean-Marc Gabaude). Coming numbers: Port-Royal, L'idealisme allemand. THE PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY Edited in the University of St Andrews Chairman of the Board of Editors: ROGER SQUIRES Executive Editor: CHRISTOPHER BRYANT Reviews Editor: BERYS GAUT

Founded in 1950, the Quarterly is one of the best established journals in the field. It aims to publish significant papers in all branches of the subject, discussions of new philosophical work, reviews of books and book notes. Recent articles include: Recent Reviews by: Richard Bellamy and Martin Hollis Elizabeth Anscombe, Frederick on justice; Frank Jackson and Philip Copleston, Jonathan Dancy, Gerald Pettit on moral functionalism; John Dworkin, David Hamlyn, Ross McDowell and David Hamlyn on Harrison, Richard Heck, John Heil, perception; C.B. Martin on Christopher Hookway, Anthony dispositionals; G.B. Hunter and Kenny, Onora O'Neill, Jerrold E.J. Lowe on conditionals. Levinson, Greg McCulloch, Joseph Margolis, Roger Scruton, Mary • INCREASED EXTENT IN 1995 Wamock, Michael Williams.

ORDER FORM THE PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY Subscription Rates, Volume 45,1995 ISSN 0031 -8094 Individuals £19.50 UK/Europe, $40.00 N America*, £25.50 Rest of World Institutions £57.00 UK/Europe, $117.00 N America*, £76.00 Rest of World Published quarterly 'Canadian customers please add 7% GST

Please enter my subscription/send me a sample copy • I enclose a cheque/money order payable to Basil Blackwell • Please charge my American Express/Diners Club/Mastercard/Visa account number Expiry Date_ Signature Date Name Address

Postcode

E-Mail Address: [email protected] (Please include the name of the journal)

Payment must accompany orders Please return this form to: Journals Marketing, Blackwell Publishers, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford, OX4 1JF, England. Or to: Journals Marketing, PHIQ, Blackwell Publishers, 238 Main Street, Cambridge, MA 02142, USA.

Blackwell Publishers Oxford, UK and Cambridge, USA Canadian Journal of Philosophy is published with the aid of a grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.

La publication du Canadian Journal of Philosophy est rendue possible grace a une subvention du Conseil de Recherches Humaines du Canada.

Canadian Journal of Philosophy wishes to thank the University ofLethbridge for its generous support for the editorial admini­ stration of the journal.

Canadian Journal of Philosophy tient a remercier YUniversite de Lethbridge de l'aide genereuse qu'elle apporte a la gestion de sa redaction.

Canadian Journal of Philosophy is grateful for past support from its originating sponsor, the Canadian Association for Publishing in Philosophy. The Association is a non-profit or­ ganization, incorporated under the laws of Canada, with the object of promoting and publishing learned publications in philosophy. A regular member of the Association is a mem­ ber of, and appointed by, any department of philosophy in a Canadian university, upon payment of a subscription by that department. The Association is a Registered Canadian Charitable Organization within the meaning of the Income Tax Act; donations to the Association are thus tax deductible.

Canadian Journal of Philosophy desire exprimer sa gratitude a {'Association Canadienne des Publications en Philosophic qui l'a aide par le passe. L'Association est un organisme a but non lucratif, incorpore aux termes de la loi canadienne, ayant pour objet la promotion et la publication d'etudes savantes en philosophic Tout membre appartenant a et designe par, un departement de philosophie d'une universite canadienne est de facto, au recu du reglement de 1'abonnement departe- mental, membre a part entiere de 1'Association. L'Associa­ tion est inscrite au Registre officiel des Organismes de Charite canadiens aux termes de la loi de l'impot sur le revenu; les donations dont elle fait l'objet peuvent beneficier ainsi du degrevement d'impot.