DOCSLIB.ORG

The Historical Genesis of the Kantian Concept of »Transcendental« Author(S): Marco Sgarbi Source: Archiv Für Begriffsgeschichte, Vol

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Historical Genesis of the Kantian Concept of »Transcendental« Author(S): Marco Sgarbi Source: Archiv Für Begriffsgeschichte, Vol The Historical Genesis of the Kantian Concept of »Transcendental« Author(s): Marco Sgarbi Source: Archiv für Begriffsgeschichte, Vol. 53 (2011), pp. 97-117 Published by: Felix Meiner Verlag GmbH Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/24361883 Accessed: 28-06-2016 13:41 UTC Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://about.jstor.org/terms JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Felix Meiner Verlag GmbH is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Archiv für Begriffsgeschichte This content downloaded from 194.94.133.193 on Tue, 28 Jun 2016 13:41:21 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms Marco Sgarbi The Historical Genesis of the Kantian Concept of »Transcendental«* I. Introduction The concept of »transcendental« is undoubtedly one of the most important terms in Kantian philosophy. For over one hundred and fifty years major Kan tian scholars have debated its origin and set out various interpretations.1 The Kant-Forschung has recently established four different possible sources: 1) Schulmetaphysik·,2 2) Ch. Wolff;3 3) A. G. Baumgarten;4 4) J. H. Lambert.5 The * AU quotes are from Immanuel Kant, Kant's gesammelte Schriften (=KGS) (Berlin 1900ff.) cited by volumes and pages. I read a preliminary version of the paper at the Annual Confer ence of the British Society for the History of Philosophy entitled Transcendental Philosophy: Its Nature and its History (Manchester Metropolitan University, 15-18 April 2009). My most heartfelt thanks to Gary Banham, Constance Blackwell, James Clarke, Dietmar H. Heidemann, Seung-Kee Lee, and Rudolf A. Makkreel, for their comments to my paper. I dedicate this article to Norbert Hinske, a master in the studies of the history of concepts in the Kantian philosophy, for his eightieth birthday. 1 See Ferdinand Schmidt: De origine termini kantiani transcendens (Marburg 1873); Abra ham Gideon: Der Begriff Transzendental in Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft (Marburg 1903); Hans Leisegang: Ober die Behandlung des scholastischen Satzes: »Quodlibet ens est unum, verum, bonum seu perfectum«, und seine Bedeutung in Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft. In: Kant-Studien 20 (1915) 403-421; Hinrich Knittermeyer: Der Terminus transzendental in seiner historischen Entwickelung bis zu Kant (Marburg 1920); id.: Transzendent und Transzenden tal. In: Paul Natorp zum 70. Geburtstage von Schiilern und Freunden gewidmet, hg. von Ernst Cassirer (Berlin, Leipzig 1924) 195-214; id.: Transzendentalphilosophie und Theologie. Eine kritische Erinnerung zum 22. April 1924. In: Die christliche Welt 38 (1924) 220-226; Gottfried Martin: Immanuel Kant. Ontologie und Wissenschaftstheorie (Kôln 1958); Hans Vaihinger: Kommentar zu Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft (Stuttgart 1992). For an exhaustive status quaes tionis see Norbert Hinske: Kants Weg zur Transzendentalphilosophie. Der dreiOigjahrige Kant (Stuttgart etc. 1970) 15-23. 2 See Francesco Valerio Tommasi: Kant di fronte alia tradizione del »trascendentale«: stato della ricerca e prospettive alia luce di un nuovo particolare. In: Studi Kantiani 16 (2003) 53-66; id.: Philosophia transcendentalis. La questione antepredicativa e l'analogia tra la Scolastica e Kant (Firenze 2008). 3 See N. Hinske: Die historischen Vorlagen der kantischen Transzendentalphilosophie. In: Archiv fur Begriffsgeschichte 12 (1968) 86-113; id.: Kants Weg, a.a.O. [Anm. 1] 49; ders.: Ver schiedenheit und Einheit der transzendentalen Philosophien. Zum Exempel fiir ein Verhàltnis von Problem- und Begriffsgeschichte. In: Archiv fiir Begriffsgeschichte 14 (1970) 41-68. 4 See Ignacio Angelelli: On the Origins of Kant's »Transcendental«. In: Kant-Studien 63 (1972) 117-122; id.: On »Transcendental« Again. In: Kant-Studien 66 (1975) 116-120. 5 Giorgio Tonelli: Das Wiederaufieben der deutsch-aristotelischen Terminologie bei Kant wahrend der Entstehung der Kritik der reinen Vernunft. In: Archiv fiir Begriffsgeschichte 9 (1964) 233-242, quoted 238. Archiv fïïr Begriffsgeschichte · Band 53 · © Felix Meiner Verlag 2011 · ISSN 0003-8946 This content downloaded from 194.94.133.193 on Tue, 28 Jun 2016 13:41:21 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 98 Marco Sgarbi aim of this essay is to suggest a différent origin and genesis of the Kantian con cept of »transcendental« through the méthodologies of Quellengeschichte and Begriffsgeschichte, investigating the philosophical and historical background of Königsberg from the beginning of the seventeenth Century to Kant and to show reasons for the shift of the concept of »transcendental« from metaphysics to logic. II. Transcendental Philosophy in Königsberg (1600-1724) The history of transcendental philosophy in Königsberg closely parallels the teaching of metaphysics in the German universities. There was a tendency in Germany between 1530 and 1590 to subordinate or to remove the discipline of metaphysics in the curricula of the most important Protestant universities.^ This tendency was characterized by: 1) a condition of diffuse uncertainty by the con tinuous doctrinal and theological mutations of the various reformist movements; 2) the identification of metaphysics with theology, with the conséquent teaching in the theological faculties;3) the dissémination of Philipp Melanchthon's works. Melanchthon, to whom Martin Luther gave the task of reforming the university curriculum in Protestant Germany, like many humanists did not pay attention to metaphysics. Melanchthon »completely neglected the systematic role played by metaphysics arguing that: (a) logic (dialectic) can replace metaphysics with regard to assessing principles; (b) metaphysics is useless with regard to the con cept of God and it is also pernicious and (c) the main advantage of metaphysics is to be seen in grammar.«7 »Melanchthon's exhortation ad res ipsas«, however, »implies a comprehensive metaphysical project aimed at retranslating the Aris totelian realist metaphysics in a System of ideal relations held together by men tal procédures.«8 In this process of mentalization and nominalization of metaphysics the doc trine of transcendentals became important for German philosophy after the publication of Francisco Suärez's Disputationes metaphysicae in 1600.9 »L'effet Suarez« extremely influenced the Königsberg cultural background with the dis sémination of Protestant metaphysical works of Suärezian origin such as those 6 See Joseph S. Freedman: Philosophy Instruction within the Institutional Framework of Central European Schools and Universities during the Reformation Era. In: History of Uni versities 5 (1985) 117-166; id.: Aristotle and the Content of Philosophy Instruction at Central European Schools and Universities during the Reformation Era (1500-1650). In: Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 137 (1993) 213-253. 7 Riccardo Pozzo: Logic and Metaphysics in German Philosophy from Melanchthon to He gel. In: Approaches to Metaphysics, ed. by William Sweet (Dordrecht 2005) 62. 8 R. Pozzo, ibid. 62. See Walter Spam: Wiederkehr der Metaphysik (Stuttgart, 1976) 109. 9 The first édition was published in Salamanca in 1597. See Ludger Honnefelder: Metaphys ics as a Discipline: From the »Transcendental Philosophy of the Ancients« to Kant's Notion of Transcendental Philosophy. In: The Médiéval Héritage in Early Modern Metaphysics and Mo dal Theory 1400-1700, ed. by R. Friedman and L. Nielsen (Dordrecht 2003) 53-74. This content downloaded from 194.94.133.193 on Tue, 28 Jun 2016 13:41:21 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms The Historical Genesis of the Kantian Concept of »Transcendental« 99 of Henning Arnisaeus, Jakob Martini, Christoph Scheibler, and Clemens Tim pler and with a général réévaluation of Jesuitic metaphysics. Georg Crusius was the first to deal with Suârez's metaphysics in his Disputationes metaphysicae in 1618.1° The most important and influential metaphysical work on the doctrine of transcendentals, however, was A. Calov's Metaphysica divina, which was pub lished in Rostock in 1636. It made Königsberg one of the strongholds of Lu theran metaphysics for its wide dissémination.!! Calov elaborated a new définition of the object of metaphysics, and in par ticular of ontology, which was the »ens qua ens«.i2 Calov's notion of »ens«, however, had special features, and differed from the other precedent and con temporary philosophical elaborations. It was »ens positivum, reale, actuale, incomplexum«,!3 and its investigation concerned also the transcendental affec tions.!4 The »ens«, Calov spécifiés, is that which does not imply any contradic tion.!5 What is contradictory is »non-ens« and it is in the realm of thought and intelligibility. On the contrary, the »ens« is the first object of knowledge, i.e. the »primum cognitum«.!6 The »ens« as »primum cognitum«, in fact, is not a mere abstract »ens« according to Calov, but it always needs a representational ground, i.e. a »realitas objectiva«, of an »objectum« in front of the »subjectum«. The »ens« is therefore a »cognoscibile« according to the classification of his gnosto logical doctrines!7 and not a mere intelligible, as for instance it was for Clemens Timpler.i8The transcendental affections therefore must be referred to the »ens« not
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Beauty As a Transcendental in the Thought of Joseph Ratzinger
    The University of Notre Dame Australia ResearchOnline@ND Theses 2015 Beauty as a transcendental in the thought of Joseph Ratzinger John Jang University of Notre Dame Australia Follow this and additional works at: https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses Part of the Philosophy Commons COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA Copyright Regulations 1969 WARNING The material in this communication may be subject to copyright under the Act. Any further copying or communication of this material by you may be the subject of copyright protection under the Act. Do not remove this notice. Publication Details Jang, J. (2015). Beauty as a transcendental in the thought of Joseph Ratzinger (Master of Philosophy (School of Philosophy and Theology)). University of Notre Dame Australia. https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses/112 This dissertation/thesis is brought to you by ResearchOnline@ND. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of ResearchOnline@ND. For more information, please contact [email protected]. School of Philosophy and Theology Sydney Beauty as a Transcendental in the Thought of Joseph Ratzinger Submitted by John Jang A thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Master of Philosophy Supervised by Dr. Renée Köhler-Ryan July 2015 © John Jang 2015 Table of Contents Abstract v Declaration of Authorship vi Acknowledgements vii Introduction 1 Structure 3 Method 5 PART I - Metaphysical Beauty 7 1.1.1 The Integration of Philosophy and Theology 8 1.1.2 Ratzinger’s Response 11 1.2.1 Transcendental Participation 14 1.2.2 Transcendental Convertibility 18 1.2.3 Analogy of Being 25 PART II - Reason and Experience 28 2.
    [Show full text]
  • CALCULUS: Early Transcendentals, 6E
    Sheet1 Math1161.01= Math 1161.02= Regular FEH Engineering Mathematics Semester I : 5 Credit hours (Autumn semester) Textbook sections are from J. Stewart: CALCULUS: Early Transcendentals, 6E Lecture Days Section# # of pages Subject Week 1 3 2.1 5 The Tangent and Velocity Problems 2.2 9 The Limit of a Function 2.3 7 Calculating Limits Using the Limit Laws Week 2 3 2.4 8 Precise Definition of a Limit 2.5 8 Continuity 2.6 11 Limits at Infinity; Horizontal Asymptodes 2.7 7 Tangents, Velocities, and Other Rates of Change Week 3 3 2.8 8 The Derivative as a Function 3.1 8 Derivatives of Polynomials and of Exponentials 3.2 4 The Product and Quotient Rules 3.3 5 Derivatives of Trigonometric Functions Week 4 3 3.4 5 The Chain Rule 3.5 6 Implicit Differentiation 3.6 5 Derivatives of logarithmic functions 3.7 9 Rates of change in the sciences Week 5 3 Review Midterm I 3.8 6 Exponential growth and decay 3.9 4 Related rates Week 6 3 3.10 5 Linear Approximations and Differentials 3.11 5 Hyperbolic Functions 4.1 6 Maximum and Minimum Values 4.2 5 The Mean Value Theorem Week 7 3 4.3 8 How Derivatives Affect the Shape of a Graph 4.4 6 Indeterminate Forms and L'Hospital's Rule 4.5 7 Summary of Curve Sketching 4.6 5 Graphing with Calculus and Calculators Week 8 3 4.7 6 Optimization Problems 4.9 5 Antiderivatives Midterm II 5.1 9 Areas and Distances Week 9 3 5.2 10 The Definite Integral 5.3 9 The Fundamental Theorem of Calculus 5.4 6 Indefinite Integral and the Net Change Theorem Week10 3 5.5 6 The Substitution Rule 6.1 5 Area between Curves 6.2 8 Volumes
    [Show full text]
  • Black Existential Philosophy: Truth in Virtue of Self-Discovery James B
    Duquesne University Duquesne Scholarship Collection Electronic Theses and Dissertations Spring 2014 Black Existential Philosophy: Truth in Virtue of Self-Discovery James B. Haile Follow this and additional works at: https://dsc.duq.edu/etd Recommended Citation Haile, J. (2014). Black Existential Philosophy: Truth in Virtue of Self-Discovery (Doctoral dissertation, Duquesne University). Retrieved from https://dsc.duq.edu/etd/614 This Immediate Access is brought to you for free and open access by Duquesne Scholarship Collection. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Duquesne Scholarship Collection. For more information, please contact [email protected]. BLACK EXISTENTIAL PHILOSOPHY: TRUTH IN VIRTUE OF SELF‐ DISCOVERY A Dissertation Submitted to McAnulty College and Graduate School of Liberal Arts Duquesne University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By James B. Haile, III May 2014 i Copyright by James B. Haile, III 2014 ii BLACK EXISTENTIAL PHILOSOPHY: TRUTH IN VIRTUE OF SELF‐DISCOVERY By James B. Haile, III Approved June 23, 2013 _______________________________________ ________________________________________ James Swindal Michael Harrington Professor of Philosophy Associate Professor of Philosophy (Committee Chair) (Committee Member) ______________________________________ Jerry R. Ward Professor of English Retired, Dillard University (Committee Member) _____________________________________ _____________________________________
    [Show full text]
  • Notes on God's Transcendental Properties 1.Pdf
    The “Infinity” of the Transcendental Properties of God The “properties” of God, the so-called transcendental properties, which traditionally include being, goodness and truth, as well as others like beauty, are paradigm examples of properties that are not “measurable.” They are not properties that are amenable to extensive measure as that idea is understood in modern science (see notes on extensive measure). That is, they are not properties for which it is possible to define an experimental unit and an experimental operation of “adding” one unit to another (called concatenation in measure theory). The best that is available for “quantities” of masses like being, goodness, truth, and beauty is that they may be put in to an ordering of more to less without exact numerical evaluation. It follows that it is not possible to apply the modern mathematical notion of “the infinite” to such “quantities” because the modern notion presupposes that it is possible to count – apply numbers to – the quantities that are being measured. It also follows that the only sense in which the properties of God would be infinite in a sense that is appropriate to a non-numerical ordering. In God’s being, truth, goodness, etc. are infinite only in the sense that the quantity of the properties that God possesses is the greatest possible. Below are internet texts explaining the transcendental properties. See also Thomas Aquinas, De Veritate, Q1, Articles 1‐3 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcendentals Transcendentals From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Jump to: navigation, search This article is about the transcendental properties of being, for other articles about transcendence; see Transcendence (disambiguation).
    [Show full text]
  • HTT Introduction
    1 The Transcendental Turn Sebastian Gardner Kant's influence on the history of philosophy is vast and protean. The transcendental turn denotes one of its most important forms, defined by the notion that Kant's deepest insight should not be identified with any specific epistemological or metaphysical doctrine, but rather concerns the fundamental standpoint and terms of reference of philosophical enquiry. To take the transcendental turn is not to endorse any of Kant's specific teachings, but to accept that the Copernican revolution announced in the Preface of the Critique of Pure Reason sets philosophy on a new footing and constitutes the proper starting point of philosophical reflection. The question of what precisely defines the transcendental standpoint has both historical and systematic aspects. It can be asked, on the one hand, what different construals have been put on Kant's Copernican revolution and what different historical forms the transcendental project has assumed, and on the other, how transcendental philosophy, in abstraction from its historical instances, should be defined and practised. Though separable, the two questions are best taken together. In so far as historical interest has a critical dimension, it will constantly broach systematic issues, just as any convincing account of the nature of transcendental philosophy will need to take account of the historical development. The present volume examines the history of the transcendental turn with the dual aim of elucidating the thought of individual philosophers, and of bringing into clearer view the existence of a transcendental tradition, intertwined with but distinguishable from other, more configurations in late modern philosophy.
    [Show full text]
  • Transcendentals in the Twenty-First Century
    Transcendentals in the Twenty-First Century Conference and Workshop 29.08.2019 – 03.09.2019 Recent years have seen increased interest in the Scholastic tradition, not only from a historical point of view, but as a source of inspiration for original philosophical work. One example of this is the rich and difficult idea of ‘transcendentals’, understood as the fundamental or ‘most common’ properties of being. Traditional examples include unity, goodness, and truth, and, more controversially, beauty. This idea has precursors in Plato, Aristotle, Dionysius, Augustine, Boethius, and Avicenna, and it plays an important role in the great scholastic thinkers including Thomas Aquinas and Duns Scotus. While its modern legacy is harder to trace, the idea of the transcendentals is closely related to the commonly cited triad of the truth, the good, and the beautiful, which appears in the medieval Summa Halensis and again in the nineteenth-century work of Victor Cousin. The 2019 conference and workshop asks what role the transcendentals have to play in twenty-first century thought. Special attention will be given to two traditional transcendentals in particular, truth and beauty, whose relationship has been a topic of especial interest in recent philosophy. This ranges from Theodor Adorno’s anxiety about the deceptive possibilities of beauty in the twentieth century to the cognitivist and expressivist theories of art defended by analytical philosophers like Nelson Goodman and Roger Scruton. Participants will have the opportunity to reflect on historical precursors to the doctrine of the transcendentals, the medieval doctrine itself, as well as work in other traditions that sees an important relationship between unity, goodness, truth, and/or beauty.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Naturalize Sensory Consciousness and Intentionality Within a Process Monism with Normativity Gradient a Reading of Sellars
    OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 04/23/2016, SPi 9 How to Naturalize Sensory Consciousness and Intentionality within a Process Monism with Normativity Gradient A Reading of Sellars Johanna Seibt Sellars’s philosophy has created a continuous stream of exegetical, critical, and con- structive commentary. Early commentators typically involved themselves close-up with one aspect of the complex tapestry of Sellars’s work. More recently, however, with increasing temporal distance, philosophical interaction with Sellars often aims to identify general strategies and “master thoughts.” For example, John McDowell finds in Sellars’s EPM the “master thought . that the conceptual apparatus we employ when we place things in the logical space of reasons is irreducible to any conceptual appara- tus that does not serve to place things in the logical space of reasons”; this “master thought as it were draws a line: above the line are placings in the logical space of rea- sons, below it are [“causal”] characterizations that do not do that” (McDowell 1998: 433). Similarly, Robert Brandom identifies in EPM the “master idea” that Sellars’s “two-ply account of observation” involves “two distinguishable sorts of abilities: the capacity reliably to discriminate behaviorally between different sorts of stimuli, and the capacity to take up a position in the game of giving and asking for reasons.”1 The following engagement with Sellars’s philosophy is a contribution to such endeavors of taking the larger contours into view. But my aim in presenting a wide- scope reconstruction is not to identify reasons for why and how we can leave Sellars’s philosophy safely behind.2 Rather, I will highlight elements in Sellars’s work that have 1 Brandom 2000: 599; here quoted from the English original.
    [Show full text]
  • Rockmore, "Remarks About Art and Truth After Plato and Its Critics
    Volume 9, No 1, Spring 2014 ISSN 1932-1066 Remarks about Art and Truth After Plato and Its Critics Tom Rockmore Peking University, China [email protected] Abstract: Though it is sometimes said that the aesthetic tradition began in the eighteenth century, for cognitive purposes it began much earlier in Plato's suggestion, on cognitive grounds, that artists of all kinds must be expelled from the city. The post-Platonic aesthetic tradition can be reconstructed as a series of attempts over the intervening centuries to answer Plato, who has perhaps never been satisfactorily answered. This work considers selected latter responses to Plato's pioneering invention of aesthetics on the basis of the theory of forms. It further considers a number of related themes, including the decline of representation and the Hegelian thesis of the end of art in pointing to the still unresolved Platonic thesis concerning art and truth. Keywords: Plato; Kant, Immanuel; philosophy of art; cognitive theory; transcendentals; historicism; aesthetics; empiricist; Marx, Karl; aesthetics; representation; mimesis. I have been asked to say a few words about how I came modern theory of knowledge. Though Immanuel to write this book and what I think it accomplishes. I am Kant is still often understood as representationalist, glad to have this opportunity since it helps me to reflect and though he routinely employs representationalist on this part of my philosophical trajectory in examining vocabulary, above all the term Vorstellung, he in fact the reasons known and perhaps unknown and even turns away from representationalism, which fails in unknowable leading me in this direction.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is a Dilemma?
    The Euthyphro Dilemma 1 What Is a Dilemma? 2 1 A dilemma is a choice between two options: 3 either when both options are desirable but only one can be chosen ... 4 2 or when both options are less than desirable and one must be chosen. 5 When there are only two possible choices, then it is a true dilemma. If a dilemma is passed off as a true dilemma when in fact there is a third (or more) option, then this is a false dilemma. 6 3 What Is the Euthyphro Dilemma? 7 The name 'Euthyphro' comes from the title of a dialogue written by Plato. Plato (428-348 BC) 8 4 Socrates meets Euthyphro along the way heading to court to prosecute his own father for Plato murder. (428-348 BC) 9 "So, in the name of heaven, tell me now about the matter you just felt sure you know quite thoroughly. State what you take piety (eujsebe;V, eusebes) and impiety (ajsebe;V, asebes) to be with reference to murder and all other cases. Is not the holy [o{sion, hosion] always one and the same in thing in every action, and, again, is not the unholy [ajvnovsion, anosion] always opposite to the holy, and like itself? And as unholiness does it not always have its one essential form [ijdevan, idean], which will be found in everything that is unholy? ... Then tell me. How do you define the holy [o{sion, hosion] and the unholy [ajvnovsion, anosion]?" [Euthyphro, 5d, trans. Lane Cooper (© 1941) in Plato: The Collected Dialogues, Socrates ed.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hierarchy of the Transcendentals According to Advaita Vedānta
    The Polish Journal of Aesthetics Vol. 32 (1/2014) Marta Kudelska* The Hierarchy of the Transcendentals According to Advaita Vedānta Abstract In advaita vedānta, the status of real existence is ascribed to the Brahman only. The Brahman is the transcendental ultimate reality and it is not possible to describe it by any attribute. The present paper will focus on the problem of values. What is the status of values according to the pure monistic system? When advaita vedāntists call the empirical world sad-asad-anirvacanīya to speak about the existence of values? And if they are real, what does ‘real’ mean in this context? (real-unreal-indefinable), are we entitled All the attributes by which we describe the world can be grasped in groups. This division depends on the way in which we experience the world. One group encom- passes objects experienced by the external organs, by the senses; its realm is responsi- ble for aesthetic values. The second group leads to discrimination; its domain is ethics. The third prejudges the status of the world and advances metaphysical arguments. These three groups are arranged hierarchically. This order includes the cosmological and the soteriological model as well; thus the vision of the world in classical Indian thought appears as total harmony. Key words advaita, nirguna, transcendental, satyam, dharma, bonum, ananda There are two ways of speaking of the Brahman in the advaita-vedānta sys- neti! neti! (not this! nottem this!).of philosophy. Therefore The silence first way epitomises is apophatic: the description it expresses of the the indefinable Brahman. nature of the ultimate reality, defining the Brahman as * Jagiellonian University in Kraków, Poland Centre for Comparative Studies of Civilisations Email: [email protected] 82 Marta Kudelska The second way attempts to ascribe to the Brahman the ultimate and the primordial attributes, or guṇa.
    [Show full text]
  • The Birth of the True, the Good, and the Beautiful: Toward an Investigation of the Structures of Social Thought
    THE BIRTH OF THE TRUE, THE GOOD, AND THE BEAUTIFUL: TOWARD AN INVESTIGATION OF THE STRUCTURES OF SOCIAL THOUGHT John Levi Martin ABSTRACT Purpose À To determine where, when, how, and wherefore European social theory hit upon the formula of “the True, the Good, and the Beautiful,” and how its structural position as a skeleton for the theory of action has changed. Methodology/approach À Genealogy, library research, and unusually good fortune were used to trace back the origin of what was to become a ubiquitous phrase, and to reconstruct the debates that made deploying the term seem important to writers. Findings À The triad, although sometimes used accidentally in the renaissance, assumed a key structural place with a rise of Neo-Platonism in the eighteenth century associated with a new interest in providing a Downloaded by Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, John Martin At 07:00 30 November 2016 (PT) Reconstructing Social Theory, History and Practice Current Perspectives in Social Theory, Volume 35, 3À56 Copyright r 2017 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0278-1204/doi:10.1108/S0278-120420160000035001 3 4 JOHN LEVI MARTIN serious analysis of taste. It was a focus on taste that allowed the Beautiful to assume a position that was structurally homologous to those of the True and the Good, long understood as potential parallels. Although the first efforts were ones that attempted to emphasize the unification of the human spirit, the triad, once formulated, was attractive to faculties theorists more interested in decomposing the soul. They seized upon the triad as corresponding to an emerging sense of a tripartition of the soul.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Philosophy As a Guide in Complex Scientific and Technological Processes, A
    The Role of Philosophy as a Guide in Complex Scientific and Technological Processes, A. Driessen, 17-9-2016 Page 1 of 16 The Role of Philosophy as a Guide in Complex Scientific and Technological Processes Alfred Driessen, prof. emer. University of Twente p/a Jan Luijkenstraat 52 1071 CS Amsterdam [email protected] Abstract Probably the most challenging issue in science and advanced technology is the ever increasing complexity. The term complexity refers to the experience that the complex whole is more than the sum of the parts. Emergence of new properties is observed at all levels, from relatively simple physical systems up to high-end evolution in biology or state-of-the-art microprocessors in technology. In this study an effort is made to arrive at an understanding of the underlying ontological basis in terms of the classical philosophy of Aristotle and Aquinas. In addition, the value of philosophy is emphasized as a means to develop the capacity for intuition. Only with this capacity it is possible to acquire an understanding of the great variety of concepts needed in the multidisciplinary approach to complex systems. Keywords: complexity; emergence, hylomorphism, analogy of being, intuition Outline 1. Introduction 2. Complexity in Science and Technology 3. Cognitive processes in human beings 4. Hierarchy in the material world and the analogy of being 5. A tentative philosophy of complexity 6. Conclusions The Role of Philosophy as a Guide in Complex Scientific and Technological Processes, A. Driessen, 17-9-2016 Page 2 of 16 1. Introduction Many of us have played with mechanical toys as children, mostly nicely arranged in a box.
    [Show full text]