A TIGER AWAKENS: E-COMMERCE IN

A GUIDE FOR AUSTRALIAN BUSINESS CONTENTS A tiger awakens: Vietnam’s internet economy landscape 05 Rapid Growth 05 Low revenue per capita 08 Key drivers 10 The rise of a connected, mobile-first population 10 A dramatic increase in licensed e-commerce platforms 11 Proactive participation of SMEs in e-commerce 12 Future potential 14 The golden population structure and an emerging middle class 14 Consistent inflow of foreign direct investment (FDI) 14 Government policy and regulation frameworks 15 Improving logistics 15 Challenges 17 Key players in Vietnam’s e-commerce industry 20 Vietnam’s biggest e-commerce platforms 21 Vietnam’s online consumers 24 Purchasing on mobile 24 High-value items 25 Instant gratification market 26 High social media usage and video consumption 26 Cash on delivery preferred 27 Popular e-commerce product categories 30 Entry points for Australian businesses 35 Existing relationships 35 No existing relationships 35 Cross-border online exporting 35 Conclusion 36 How Austrade can help 37 References 39 Disclaimer Copyright © Commonwealth of Australia 2019

This report has been prepared by the Commonwealth of Australia represented by the Australian Trade and Investment Commission (Austrade). The report is a general overview and is not intended to provide exhaustive coverage of the topic. The information is made available on The material in this document is licensed under a Creative Commons the understanding that the Commonwealth of Australia is not providing Attribution – 4.0 International licence, with the exception of: professional advice. • the Australian Trade and Investment Commission’s logo While care has been taken to ensure the information in this report is • any third party material accurate, the Commonwealth does not accept any liability for any loss • any material protected by a trade mark arising from reliance on the information, or from any error or omission, in • any images and photographs. the report. More information on this CC BY licence is set out at the creative commons Any person relying on this information does so at their own risk. The website: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode Commonwealth recommends the person exercise their own skill and care, including obtaining professional advice, in relation to their use of the information for their purposes. Enquiries about this licence and any use of this document can be sent to [email protected].

The Commonwealth does not endorse any company or activity referred Attribution to in the report, and does not accept responsibility for any losses suffered in connection with any company or its activities. Before reusing any part of this document, including reproduction, public display, public performance, distribution, dissemination, communication, or importation, you must comply with the Attribution requirements under the CC BY licence.

02 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 03 A TIGER AWAKENS: VIETNAM’S INTERNET ECONOMY LANDSCAPE

E-commerce has taken off in Vietnam thanks to soaring internet connectivity and smartphone adoption, a young tech-savvy population, and rising disposable incomes. The appetite for online shopping is growing and the number of licensed e-commerce platforms is expanding rapidly.

The development of Vietnam’s online industry can be broken down into three distinct periods:

› 1998 to 2005: the establishment of the first ever internet infrastructure › 2006 to 2015: mass proliferation of the internet. Almost 50 per cent of the population goes online for the first time, allowing Vietnamese to engage in e-commerce every day › 2017 to 2020: further expansion, with e-commerce crossing into new areas of the economy.1

RAPID GROWTH

Vietnam’s internet economy has experienced rapid growth since 2014. Starting from a total business-to-consumer (B2C) revenue of US$2.97 billion, the sector doubled its value in three years to reach US$6.25 billion by the end of 2017.2

Since 2017, the internet economy in Vietnam has been well established with four key active sectors: e-commerce (first-hand goods); online travel (online flights, hotels and vacation rentals); online media (advertising, gaming, subscription music and video on demand); ride hailing (transport, food delivery).

Figure 1 - B2C E-commerce revenue and average annual value per customer (US$)

10B 10B CAGR - 20% 350 350 8B 300

6B 25% 6.25B 250

23% 5.00B 4B 200 37% 4.07B Value per customer Value Revenue (US$ Billion) Revenue 2.97B 170 2B 150 160 145 0B 100 2014 2015 2016 2017 2020f Total B2C revenue Average annual value per customer

Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency, Vietnam E-Commerce Association

1. Vietnam E-commerce Association 2. Vietnam E-commerce Association

04 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 05 Having tripled in value from 2015 to the end of 2018, Vietnam’s online market is now the fourth largest in Southeast The most dynamic part of Vietnam’s online economy is sales of durable goods. This sector grew by 22 per cent in Asia. Amongst the region’s major economies, Vietnam’s online market is also the fastest growing, with a compound 20175, and almost doubled in 20186. Sales reached nearly US$3 billion in 2018 and are forecast to reach US$15 annual growth rate of 35 per cent over the same period.3 billion by 2025. This means durable goods will constitute almost half of all online sales in Vietnam.7

According to recent industry reports, Vietnam’s online economy will continue to grow strongly, and be worth US$10 billion by 2020.4 If trend rates continue, Vietnam’s online economy will be worth US$33 billion by 20253, making it the third-largest digital market in . Figure 4 - SEA e-commerce market size (GMV, US$ Billion)

Figure 2 - SEA internet economy market size (GMV, US$ Billion) 41%

28% 53B 100B 30% 43% 21% 34% 18% 49% 87% 94% 27% 42% 22%

15B 12.2B 13B 7.0B 10B 22% 16% 25% 5.0B 1.7B 1.0B 2.0B 1.5B 1.8B 3.0B 2.8B 25% 43B 0.5B 1.0B 0.9B 0.4B 13% 49% 27% 19% 35% 33B 30% Vietnam 27B 16% 21B 21B 22B

10B 12B 2015 2018 2025 CAGR 8B 8B 9B 5B 5B 6B 2B 7B 3B

Indonesia Malaysia Philippines Singapore Thailand Vietnam

2015 2018 2025 CAGR

The value of Vietnam’s internet economy is also the highest of the major regional economies, with a gross merchandise value equivalent to 4 per cent of gross domestic product.

Figure 3 - Internet economy GMV as a percentage of GDP (2018)

2.8% 2.9% 2.7% 4.0% 2.7% 3.2% 1.6%

SEA Indonesia Malaysia Philippines Singapore Thailand Vietnam

5. Statistica 3. e-Conomy SEA 2018, by Google and Temasek 6. e-Conomy SEA 2018, by Google and Temasek 4. Vietnam E-Commerce and Digital Economy Agency, Vietnam E-Commerce Association 7. Statistica

06 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 07 LOW REVENUE PER CAPITA

Vietnam’s online shopping cart value per capita is still low in comparison with other markets. This can be attributed in part to Vietnam’s low GDP per capita. In 2017, online shopping cart values averaged US$23 per shop in Vietnam, compared to US$42 in Thailand and US$36 in Indonesia.8

Even after a decade of rapid economic development and huge improvements in the country’s overall quality of life, Vietnam’s GDP remains significantly lower than most other Southeast Asian nations.

Figure 5 - Average e-commerce shopping cart value & GDP per capita of Southeast Asian countries (US$)

100 62K 60K 90 80 50K

40K 60 56 54

42 30K 40 36 20K GDP per capita 23 20 11K Average shopping cart value Average 7K 10K 3K 3K 4K - K Vietnam Philippines Indonesia Thailand Malaysia Singapore 90

Source: E-Commerce shopping cart value recorded by iPrice, July 2016 - Jun 2017, GDP per capita by International Monetary Fund 2017

11k 7k 3k 3k 4k

8. Statistica

08 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 09 KEY DRIVERS A DRAMATIC INCREASE IN LICENSED E-COMMERCE PLATFORMS

As the number of online shoppers continues to climb, so too has the number of licensed e-commerce platforms. Direct sales websites hosted by individual brands have been the fastest growing, and currently represent the highest number of e-commerce operators.

Figure 8 - Licensed e-commerce direct sales Figure 9 - Licensed online promotion & auction websites & trade platforms in Vietnam websites in Vietnam

14,000 13,510 100 93 90 12,000 80 75 10000 9,429 70 Vietnam’s e-commerce sector has developed as a result of three key factors: a rapidly growing online population; the establishment 60 60 of user-friendly e-commerce platforms; and the uptake of online business transactions by small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). 8,000 50 6,000 THE RISE OF A CONNECTED, MOBILE-FIRST POPULATION 40 4,653 4,000 30 The expansion of e-commerce in Vietnam has been fuelled by a growing online population, which reached 52 million 20 in 2017. An impressive 65 per cent of the online population has participated in an e-commerce activity, and this 20 19 9 2,000 13 13 14 number is predicted to increase steadily until 2020. 10 674 492 682 0 90 283 0 Figure 6 - Total Population vs. Total Internet users in Vietnam Figure 7 - Percentage of internet users who Direct e-commerce E-commerce trade Online promotion Online auction (million) participated in e-commerce in Vietnam sales websites platforms websites websites

2013 2014 2015 2016 2013 2014 2015 2016 120M 68% 67% 93M 94M 95M 96M Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency 100M 88M 89M 90M 91M 66% 65% 90 80M 64% As e-commerce platforms have become more established in Vietnam, many have started to offer alternative payment options, including 62% 60M 52M 62% cash on delivery. This has made buying online more convenient than ever and, coupled with appropriate consumer-protection policies, has 41M 44M resulted in a high ratio of return customers for e-commerce sites. The results of a 2016 survey by the Vietnam E-commerce and Digital 40M 33M 35M 38M 60% 27M 31M Economy Agency confirmed this, with 42 per cent of 2,593 e-commerce platform owners reporting that at least 10 per cent of their 58% customers would re-purchase. 20M 58%

0M 56% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Figure 10 - Customer return rates for e-commerce websites as a proportion of all websites 54% Total Population Total Internet users 52% 2014 2015 2016 2020f 40% 11k 7k Source: World Bank, Ministry of Information & Communication Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital 35% 3k 3k 4k 35% Economy Agency 30% Vietnamese consumers have become increasingly mobile, with smartphone usage exploding in the past few years. In 2017, the total number of smartphone users in Vietnam was estimated at 28.8 million and is forecast to reach 38.4 25% 10 million by 2020. This level of penetration means one in five Vietnamese can make online purchases via a smart 23% 23% device. 20%

11 Mobile phones are effective facilitators: according to a study by Criteo , 82 per cent of Vietnamese say it is more 15% convenient to buy goods via mobile apps than websites. The study highlighted that more than 90 per cent of people who install e-commerce apps on their smartphones end up buying goods at least once a month, while 60 per 13% cent do so three times or more a month. 10% 5% 6%

0% >50% re-purchase 30-50% re-purchase 10-30% re-purchase <10% re-purchase Don’t know 9. Vietnam E-Commerce Association 10. Vietnam E-Commerce Association 11. Criteo Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Eonomy Agency Nationwide Survery for Licensed e-Commerce platform Owners, 2016 n=2593

10 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 11 Credit card payments for online purchase are less popular in Vietnam than in other countries in Southeast Asia. However, Vietnam’s e-commerce platforms do offer a range of alternative payment options.

Figure 11 - Payment solutions offered by merchants in Southeast Asia contries (%)

100% 100% 100% 94% 95% 88% 90% 84% 81% 82% 80% 80%

65% 60% 60% 52% 50% 49% 47% 46% 43% 40% 38% 41% 25% 20% 20% 17% 18% 15% 13% 15% 10% 8% 4% 0% Bank Transfer Cash On Delivery Credit Card Installment Offline POS

Vietnam Indonesia Thailand Philippines Malaysia Singapore

Source: iPrice e-Commerce merchant database, 2017 n= 1000

90 PROACTIVE PARTICIPATION OF SMEs IN E-COMMERCE

Social networks, especially Facebook, have become increasingly popular among SMEs as online business tools. In 2017, the proportion of all enterprises transacting business via social networks reached 32 per cent, according to the Vietnam E-commerce Association’s Vietnam E-business Index 2018 Report.

Figure 12 - Proportion of enterprises doing Figure 13 - Proportion of enterprises doing business on social networks businesson e-commerce marketplaces

11k 40% 40% 7k 3k 3k 4k 34% 32%

30% 28% 30%

20% 20%

13% 13% 11% 10% 10%

0% 0% 2015 2016 2017 2015 2016 2017

Source: VECOM’s Vietnam E-business Index 2018 Report Source: VECOM’s Vietnam E-business Index 2018 Report

12 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 13 GOVERNMENT POLICY AND REGULATION IMPROVING LOGISTICS FUTURE POTENTIAL FRAMEWORKS

Recognising e-commerce’s potential to attract investment and In an attempt to address some of the biggest obstacles facing drive Vietnam’s economy, the government has made clear its e-commerce in Vietnam, the government has lifted some commitment to the sector. The approval of the ‘Masterplan To restrictions on foreign investment and announced a commitment Develop E-Commerce From 2016–2020’ signifies the government’s to developing Vietnam’s logistics capabilities. A new legal support of e-commerce as a crucial economic pillar. Further framework means local logistics companies can expect more investment in improving regulatory frameworks, tax rules and data financial and resources support. security policies is also scheduled. From 2018, investors can establish 100 per cent foreign-owned In November 2017, the Ministry of Finance drafted a proposal to logistics companies or joint ventures in Vietnam with unlimited develop the tax administration law. The proposal, which is foreign participation. In a meeting with the Deputy Prime expected to be approved in 2019, is designed to improve and Minister in June 2017, the World Bank committed to providing centralise the country’s online tax system.13 Once it comes into human resources and expertise to improve Vietnam’s logistics effect, e-commerce platforms can expect significantly faster, more industry.14 The outlook for e-commence in Vietnam is positive. The country is experiencing a ‘golden population’ period, meaning more than half of the convenient tax procedures. The proposal sets out a framework for population are of working age, with rising incomes. In addition, there is a consistent flow of foreign direct investment and a high level taxing merchants operating on social media platforms such as of government support to create legal frameworks and infrastructure to ensure a robust online economy. Facebook, Instagram and Zalo. Merchants will be required to register when their revenue exceeds a certain amount, and submit e-receipts and a record of all transactions every quarter. THE GOLDEN POPULATION STRUCTURE AND CONSISTENT INFLOW OF FOREIGN DIRECT A streamlined tax procedure for e-commerce platforms combined AN EMERGING MIDDLE CLASS INVESTMENT (FDI) with appropriate tax regulations for individual merchants may see more merchants transitioning to e-commerce once the plan is Since 2007, Vietnam has been in a period known as the ‘golden As growth continues in Vietnam’s e-commerce industry, global approved, resulting in a more centralised e-commerce environment. population structure’, a state in which more than half of its and regional conglomerates have been investing in the country. In The government is looking to increase cashless payments in population are of working age. The United Nations Population Fund January 2018, JD.com – Alibaba’s direct competitor in China – 12. says that with a total dependency ratio of below 50 – meaning announced a US$44 million investment in Vietnam’s leading B2C urban areas to 50 per cent by 2020. The government and the The Boston Consulting Group State Bank of Vietnam have issued instructional documents on 13. PwC Vietnam News Brief, 29 November 2017 only one dependent for every two or more working people aged platform Tiki.vn. In February 2018, an affiliate of private equity firm 14. 15–64 years – Vietnam has a unique opportunity to ‘increase its Creador approved an investment of US$43.8 million in digital payment methods as well as a list of 25 non-bank Customs News of The General Department of Vietnam Customs, savings and boost its socio-economic development from now Thegioididong.com – Vietnam’s largest mobile and electronic organisations licensed to provide payment services. 28 June 2017 until 2041.’ device retailer. In March 2018, Alibaba – the Chinese e-com- merce giant – raised its total investment in Lazada Group to 90 It is expected that Vietnam’s middle and affluent class will US$4 billion and brought in its own executives to lead Lazada’s increase from 12 million to 33 million between 2012 and 2020, a regional office in Ho Chi Minh City. rate much faster than any other ASEAN country over the same period.12 It is this tech-savvy, convenience-driven segment of the population that will be the most likely to drive e-commerce forward in Vietnam.

11k 7k 3k 3k 4k

14 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 15 CHALLENGES

While the government and local e-commerce players have taken measures to create and maintain a healthy environment for growth, challenges remain for the market’s long-term development. From the perspective of an e-commerce platform owner, the first challenge is ‘unhealthy competition,’ which stems from the lack of a consistent set of regulations, particularly regarding dispute resolution.

Figure 14 - Barriers and challenges according to e-commerce platform owners (mean score)

Unhealthy competition 1.22

High logistics cost 1.08

Incompetent human resources 1.05

Unguaranteed online security 1.02 About the business

Difficulty in intergrating digital payment 0.91

Customers’ concern about security when making online payment 1.01

Customers lack trust in the quality of products 0.87

About customers Customers’ concern that personal data is disclosed or traded 0.65

0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00 1.10 1.20 1.30

Question: How do you rank these barriers and difficulties in operating an e-Commerce platform, from 0 to 2 with 0 being “Not an obstacle”, 1 being “Somewhat an obstacle” and 2 being “A great obstacle” n=2593 Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency Nationwide Survey for Licensed e-Commerce platform Owners, 2016

Logistics infrastructure is another impediment facing almost every e-commerce operator in Vietnam on a daily basis. Despite huge investment, online shoppers still complain about faulty products or non-delivery of goods. Poor management of e-logistics data has exacerbated the problem. Most e-commerce sites in Vietnam work with third-party providers in the hope of achieving a smooth ordering and delivery process for consumers. It hasn’t, however, always worked. Logistic costs currently account for 30 per cent of e-commerce revenue in Vietnam – more than in other ASEAN countries.15 High logistics costs translate into higher shipping fees for consumers, which ultimately influences their willingness to buy online more frequently.

15. Vietnam Briefing, E-commerce Logistics: Emerging Opportunities in Veitnam, 6 June 2017

16 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 17 Compounding the problem in Vietnam is the lack of investment in high-tech logistics infrastructure. With the excep- tion of a few e-commerce players, such as Tiki and Lazada, most do not operate their own central distribution centres. This results in longer order processing times and a greater chance of incomplete or non-deliveries.

A 2016 survey of consumers by the Vietnam E-commerce and Digital Economy Agency identified the major barriers to online purchasing as a lack of trust in how products are advertised, a lack of trust in merchants themselves and the inability to check product quality.

Figure 15 - Barriers perceived by current Figure 16 - Barriers perceived by non e-commerce users (%) in 2016 e-commerce users (%) in 2016

False advertising 80% Difficult to check quality 50% Lack of trust for the 48% Incompetent customer merchants 44% service Easier to shop at stores 48% More expensive than 43% No prior experience in offline purchase 21% shopping online 40% Incompetent logistics Privacy concern 21%

Lack of information to 17% Privacy concerns 36% decide No digital payment 17% Incompetent web solution design 23% No need for shopping 12% online Complicated order process 19% Complicated order 11% process Complicated payment 15% process Few product choices 10%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 0% 25% 50%

Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency

18 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 19 KEY PLAYERS IN VIETNAM’S VIETNAM’S BIGGEST E-COMMERCE PLATFORMS E-COMMERCE INDUSTRY Lazada.vn Tiki.vn

Lazada is the leading e-commerce website in Vietnam Tiki.vn has morphed from a local online bookstore into and has the highest number of average visits per an e-commerce giant in eight years. month. Tiki is Vietnam’s version of Amazon, entering the market Lazada, founded in 2011 by Germany’s Rocket Internet, in 2010 selling books online. In 2013, Tiki expanded its entered Vietnam in 2012 as Lazada.vn. The original product range to include electronic devices, lifestyle business model was to sell goods to customers from its products and miscellaneous products such as airline own warehouse. In 2013, Lazada introduced the tickets. In 2017, Tiki introduced a marketplace feature, marketplace model, allowing third-party merchants to allowing merchants to sell goods on its platform. sell via its platform. This became popular quickly, accounting for 65 per cent of total regional sales by the Tiki has an advantage over its competitors with its 16 end of 2014. third-party logistics. By retaining total control of its There are four main types of e-commerce platforms in Vietnam: direct sales websites, trade platforms, online supply chain, Tiki has established a reputation for high promotional websites and online auction websites. Of these, direct sales websites and trade platforms are the leading Operating throughout Southeast Asia, Lazada raised customer satisfaction, which includes a two-hour players. around US$700 million in investment up to 2014. delivery policy. Alibaba now owns 83 per cent of Lazada Group and Direct sales websites are those set up by brand owners to sell their own goods and services. The original business recently invested a further US$2 billion. The move has JD.com – the direct competitor of Alibaba in China – model is B2C, but several direct sales websites, such as thegioididong.com, fptshop.com.vn and vietnamairlines.com, helped Alibaba expand its business in Southeast Asia has made a further US$44 million investment in Tiki, have recently incorporated a new customer-to-customer (C2C) model. and allows more Alibaba merchants to sell on this committing to help the brand improve its payment platform. integration, warehousing and delivery systems. The Trade platforms provide a marketplace for merchants, individuals and companies. The business model can be B2C or investment makes JD.com the largest partner in Tiki, C2C, with well-known platforms including tiki.vn, foody.vn, vatgia.com and shopee.vn. Thegioididong.com along with VNG, Vietnam’s top provider of internet content. Thegioididong.com is the leading mobile phone and Lazda Thegioididong Tiki Shopee Sendo Adayroi Lefair electronics retailer in Vietnam and part of Mobile World Shopee.vn Investment Corporation (MWG). Following Mekong Business B2C B2C B2C B2C B2C B2C B2C Capital’s first investment in 2007, Mobile World has model C2C Physical C2C C2C Physical shop Shopee.vn, a newcomer to Vietnam’s e-commerce shop (VinPro, quickly scaled up its retail network from seven to landscape, has adopted a promising and different VinMart, etc...) thousands of stores in just 11 years. business model. Type of Individuals - Registered Individuals Individuals Registered Registered seller Registered enterprises and and enterprises enterprises Mobile World owns the largest retail chain store in Shopee is managed by Sea, a Singapore-based enterprises only Registered Registered only only enterprises enterprises Vietnam. Originally an electronic device retailer, the company that made its debut in Vietnam in August company expanded its product mix to include household 2016. In just two years, Shopee has risen to fifth place in Product General Electronic General retail General General General High-end appliances through dienmayxanh.com, which has 719 terms of average monthly traffic, according to the Categories retail devices Tourism/ retail retail retail retail Transportation grocery storefronts; groceries via bachhoaxanh.com, which has company’s 2018 first quarter data. approximately 360 storefronts; and pharmaceutical Payment Processed - Processed Processed Processed - - products through seven storefronts. Thegioididong.com method for weekly monthly instantly into instantly into Unlike other e-commerce operators in Vietnam, Shopee sellers partner’s partner’s e- itself owns 1,745 storefronts. established a C2C marketplace model from day one, account wallet SenPay Partner can Partner can meaning its merchants are usually individuals or small withdraw withdraw All of Mobile World’s brands have established e-com- businesses. The company assists in delivery and money money merce websites. In the first two months of 2018, online anytime anytime payment, and takes a commission for each successful revenue reached a record high of approximately US$87 order made via the platform. To protect customers, Quarterly 42.4 million 39.1 million 22.6 million 24.6 million 20.8 million 5.3 million 694 thousand million, contributing nearly 12 per cent of total group Shopee only makes payments to merchants once Traffic revenue.17 buyers have verified the product’s quality. Ownership Majority Mobile World JD.com Sea FPT VinGroup Leflair owned by Group In the past financial year, Shopee reached annualised Alibaba gross merchandise volume of over US$3 billion. Australia - No No No No No No No based procurement Annual fee None - - None None - - for C2C partners Logistics In-house In-house In-house Partner with Partner with In-house Partner (LELExpress) 3rd party 3rd party with Partner with 3rd party 3rd party for delivery

Online promotional websites sell vouchers and display promotions from companies other than the website owner. Well-known sites include nhommua.com, hotdeal.vn and muachung.vn. 16. Lazada’s Marketplace platform accounts for 65% of its sales revenue, 7 November 2014 Online auction websites host auctions for goods and services owned by individuals and companies other than the website 17. Mobile World Investment Corporation, CEO Report For First Two Months owner. While the business model can be B2C or C2C, it is mostly C2C. Well-known sites include weshop.com.vn (part of 2018 eBay) and chilindo.com.

20 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 21 Foody.vn Adayroi.com

Foody.vn is one of Vietnam’s most successful startups, Adayroi is the e-commerce arm of Vingroup, one of growing from a simple food and dining review forum Vietnam’s largest real estate companies. Launched in into an online restaurant directory, reservations and 2015 as a subsidiary of Vingroup, Adayroi attracted an delivery service. initial investment of around US$50 million.

Foody launched in 2012 as an online review forum of Adayroi is a valuable addition to the Vingroup ecosys- food outlets throughout Vietnam. It then added a tem as it is capable of managing a large number of restaurant table-booking service, TableNow, and a stock-keeping units (SKUs) on its pages. Adayroi delivery platform called NOW to its ecosystem. effectively acts as a distribution channel for all of Vingroup’s products and services, with offerings ranging Singapore-based company Sea first invested in Foody from groceries and other fast-moving consumer goods in 2015, buying 6 per cent of the platform. When to cars and houses. Cyberagent Ventures divested its 17 per cent ownership stake in September 2017, Sea bought a further 82 per While there have been no official statements about cent (a deal presumed to be worth US$64 million18) and Vingroup’s plans for Adayroi, it is reasonable to assume became Foody’s largest stakeholder. the company will continue to use the platform to distribute its trademarked products and services, NOW is Foody’s most profitable platform. It includes including Vinfast cars and Vsmart phones. food delivery, table reservations, housekeeping, grocery shopping and even flower delivery. In 2017, NOW deliveries reached a capacity of 10,000 orders per day. Leflair.vn Leflair is a niche player in the market focusing on mid- Sendo.vn to high-end products. Founded in 2015, Leflair focuses on providing products to Vietnam’s growing middle Fast-growing Sendo.vn is backed by Vietnamese tech class using a flash-sales model. It presents itself as a giant FPT Corporation, and is one of the country’s stylish e-commerce platform, servicing high-end largest e-commerce companies. shoppers with premium on-trend fashion and beauty at a discount. Sendo is a subsidiary of FPT Corporation, which inherited the technology platform of 123Mua – previous- After only two years in operation, Leflair has built up a ly one of the most popular e-commerce platforms – in a membership of more than 700,000, with 1,000 new deal with Vietnamese internet content provider VNG in subscribers daily. This high-potential startup has raised 2014. US$4 million and intends to invest in more mid- to high-end brands while establishing itself in Singapore. Rather than investing in central distribution centres, Brands currently working with Leflair include Abercrom- Sendo focused on connecting consumers with micro, bie & Fitch, Balenciaga and local Vietnamese designers small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs). The such as Võ Công Khanh and Trương Thanh Hải. company also partnered with Google to create Shop Ads – a service allowing all Sendo merchants to advertise on Google at a reduced rate.

As of 2017, Sendo was Vietnam’s most prolific e-com- merce platform, with over 120,000 online shops. Sendo ranks in the top five in website traffic, according to the iPrice Map of E-Commerce.

18. Vietnam Investment Review: Sea seizes 82 per cent of Foody, 3 October 2017 19. Leflair.vn

22 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 23 VIETNAM’S ONLINE CONSUMERS HIGH-VALUE ITEMS Contrary to speculation that a lot of online purchases made in Vietnam are of low value, official statistics from the E-Commerce and Digital Economy Agency indicate that Vietnamese consumers have shown a willingness to buy a diverse set of products at a wide range of price points.

The agency’s 2016 survey revealed that over one-quarter of the most frequently purchased products in Vietnam had a value range from around VND1 million (US$45). The agency also reported in the same year that approximately 50 per cent of Vietnam’s online shoppers spent more than VND3 million (US$130) per year. As the economy continues to grow and GDP per capita improves, this amount is expected to rise.

Figure 18 - Most often purchased product’s value range recorded by e-commerce platforms (% platforms)

The profile of Vietnam’s online shoppers reflects the country’s total online population – mostly young, urban and predominantly single. They have grown up with the internet and largely consider themselves to be digital natives. They are undoubtedly e-commerce’s ‘early adopters’ – willing to try, spend and set trends. 13% 21% PURCHASING ON MOBILE Under VND 200K VND 200K - VND 500K A study of Vietnamese consumers’ online behaviour in 2017 by Decision Lab confirmed that almost half of all online 13% purchases had been made using mobile phones in the last six months. VND 500K - VND 1M VND 1M - VND 5M Figure 17 - The devices that consumers used to make online transactions in the past 6 months (%) Over VND 5M 23% 16%

5% 1%

Mobile phone Source: Vietnam E-commerce And Digital Economy Agency Nationwide Survey for Licensed e-Commerce platform Owners, 2016 n=2593 Laptop/Computer 49% Tablet Others 45%

Q: In your most recent online purchase, which device did you use to buy the product? Source: Decision Lab Device Study, 2017 n=2854

24 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 25 INSTANT GRATIFICATION MARKET CASH ON DELIVERY PERFERRED

While convenience is a key attraction of e-commerce over traditional brick-and-mortar outlets, instant gratification is Despite a clear willingness to transition from the traditional shopping experience to online, Vietnamese consumers still pivotal to boosting the appeal of online shopping worldwide. Vietnamese consumers are no different. They not only have some concerns, especially when it comes to payment. The overwhelming majority of online shoppers, 90 per expect immediate delivery, but have expressed a willingness to pay extra for it. This emphasises the need to optimise cent, still prefer cash on delivery as the payment method, while only 23 per cent said they used a credit or debit card. logistics and transport infrastructure. This behaviour is very much related to a lack of trust of both product quality and merchant reputation, amplified by the absence of a user-friendly return policy at many e-commerce platforms. As a result, consumers are happy to revert to Figure 19 - Expectation and willingness to pay extra for delivery cash on delivery as insurance, as they can check the product before paying.

45% Figure 21 - Preferred payment methods of online shoppers (%) 41% 40% 100% 35% 91% 90% 89% 30% 28% 25% 25% 80% 25% 24% 23% 23% 20% 70%

15% 60% 11% 10% 10% 8% 7% 50% 5% 48% 2% 3% 3% 2% 0% 0% 40% 41% Specific 1-2 Less than 3 Same day Next day 2 days 3-5 business 1 week More than 1 hour time of hours days week my choosing 30% Expect goods to arrive Willing to pay extra charge for 23% 20% 20% Q: For the majority of your online purchases how soon do you expect your goods to arrive? Which of the following delivery lead time frames are you willing to pay a charge for? Sourc: PwC, Global Consumer Insights Survery (including Vietnam) 2018 n= 22,480 10% 11% 6% 7% 5% HIGH SOCIAL MEDIA USAGE AND VIDEO CONSUMPTION 0% Cash on delivery ATM Credit/debit card Scratch phone card Digital wallet (COD) In a bid to reach Vietnam’s online consumers, brands across product categories must incorporate major social media platforms into their marketing campaigns. Vietnam’s top three platforms currently are Facebook, YouTube and locally developed Zalo. 2015 2016 Source: Vietnam E-Commerce And Digital Economy Agency Figure 20 - Most popular social media platforms

Almost all consumers who have access to the internet watch online videos – regardless of their age group.

96% Figure 22 - The percentage of audiences who have internet access and watch online videos 83% 83%

99% 99% 100% 98% 97%

38% 80% 34%

15% 7% 7% 4% 4% 60%

40% Facebook Youtube Zalo Instagram Zing Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Snapchat

20%

0% Source: Decision Lab’s Device Study 2017 Total Respondents: 528 Gen Z Millennials 35 - 44 y/o 45+

Source: Decision Lab online population study 2017 n= 1.945

26 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 27 There was a significant lift in the reach of digital campaigns in 2017. This is a consequence of the increasing number of people watching online videos, and the improved ability of online video platforms to target the right audiences.

While the majority of Generation Z reported watching online videos, more than half of them closed advertisements as soon as they appeared. Older users, however, were more likely to engage with an advertisement, especially when they deemed it to be relevant.21 As a result, advertisers need to work much harder to engage younger consumers in their digital campaigns.

Almost half of all Vietnamese consumers actively research products online before making an offline purchase. This provides opportunities for online marketers to influence purchasing decisions.22

Google is the most popular search engine in Vietnam, with a reported market share of over 95 per cent in November 2018. Google has led the market since October 2017, when it achieved more than 90 per cent market share. It is followed by Coc Coc, a search engine integrated into a locally made browser, which accounts for over 3 per cent of users. Bing and Yahoo are minor players in the market.23

21. Decision Lab: Online population study 2017 22. Think with Google, Be the first and last stop: Rethinking search strategies for SEA Consumers, December 2018 23. StatCounter

28 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 29 When it comes to online transactions in Vietnam, leisure and transportation lead the market, with ride-hailing apps such as Grab and POPULAR E-COMMERCE PRODUCT CATEGORIES Go-Viet, and hotel booking sites such as Booking.com and Agoda proving extremely popular. Cosmetics and personal care products are the most frequently purchased durable goods. The latter is forecast to reach US$335 million in online sales by 2020.

Figure 24 - Product categories purchased online in consumers’ most recent transaction (%)

Long trip (by plane, coach, train, etc) 70% A stay in hotel (for leisure purposes) 63% Short trip (by bike or taxi) 60% Cosmetics & Personal care 55% Clothing & shoes 52% Mobile phones 49% Data collected from Decision Lab’s Device Study 2017 indicate that the food and beverages sector is the most popular for online sales in Vietnam. The next most popular sectors are: clothing and shoes; cosmetics and personal care; and non-prescription medicines or vitamins. Movie tickets 48% Household appliances 48% Takeaway/Delivery food 24% Figure 23 - Product categories purchased in the past 6 months (%) Insurance/Loan 24% Dairy products 19% Snacks 18% Food & beverages* - 50.2% Cooking ingredients 15% Clothing & shoes - 10% Non-precription medicine or vitamins 14% 2%2% Alcoholic beverages 11% 3% Cosmetics & personal care - 5.9% 4% Non-alcoholic beverages 11% 4% Non-prescription medicines or vitamins - 5.2% Vegetables 9% 4% Short trip (by bike or taxi) - 5% Meat & Fish 8% 5% Baby products 0% Mobile phones - 4.9% 5% 50% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Movie tickets - 4.3%

5% Household appliances - 4% Source: Decision Lab Device Study, 2017 n=2854

6% Long trip (by plane, coach, train, etc) - 3.7% 24. Decision Lab, Device Study 2017 Baby products - 2.8% 10% A stay in hotel (for leisure purposes) - 2.4 % Insurance/Loan - 1.6%

Q: Which type of products have you purchased in the past 6 months? * Food & beverages include: snacks, cooking ingredients, dairy products, vegetables, meat & fish, non-alcoholic beverages, alcoholic beverages, takeaway/ delivery food n=2854 Source: Decision Lab Device Study, 2017

30 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 31 While many food and beverages products are still purchased offline, Vietnamese consumers have taken to researching them online. Online food and beverages sales are expected to grow at an annual rate of 15.2 per cent up to 2020, contributing US$159 million to Vietnam’s total e-commerce revenue.

Figure 25

Use penetration growth predic- Average revenue per user in 2018 Revenue growth prediction (in tion US$)

CAGR 2018-2020 = 15.2% 24% 180M 159M 20% 19.2% 150M

16% 15.9% 120M 90M 12% US$ 5.99 90M

8% 60M

4% 30M

0% 0M 2018 2020 2018 2020

Source: Statista, Figures include the online sale of fresh and packaged foods (excluding baby food), delicacies and beverages. This market segment covers for example the sale of fruit, vegetables, pasta, snacks, sweets, refrigerated products, frozen food, soft drinks and alcoholic drinks via a digital channel. Not included in this market segment are delivery services of ready-to-eat meals.

Australian companies hoping to break into personal care or food and beverages in Vietnam need to establish a strong presence on Facebook or one of the big local e-commerce platforms to attract Vietnamese consumers. Across all devices, these are the top two means by which consumers shop for these products.25

25. Decision Lab, Device Study 2017

32 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 33 ENTRY POINTS FOR AUSTRALIAN BUSINESSES

Access to the market varies according to the size of the company, the products and existing relationships within Vietnam. CROSS-BORDER ONLINE EXPORTING

Online exporting provides businesses with more options by allowing EXISTING RELATIONSHIPS varying levels of control and the ability to monitor offshore sales. Online exporters can also maintain brand reputation more easily Companies with distributors or operations in Vietnam should through consistent pricing, marketing and sales. Businesses can already have an e-commerce strategy in place. adopt a B2B model by using a distributor, although for products sold online to consumers this is known as a business-to-busi- Companies with existing supply chains in Vietnam can work either ness-to-consumer (B2B2C) model, which functions similarly to independently or with local partners to leverage current B2C traditional exporting. In this model, businesses sell products to a platforms such as Lazada and Tiki.vn. Both platforms are distributor that will then sell products to online consumers. continuously working to raise their own brand awareness, attract traffic to their sites, and make it easier for customers to shop Products that require government registration prior to entering the online. market, such as food, beverages, health and personal care products, cannot yet be directly exported into Vietnam from Bricks-and-mortar retail chains in Vietnam have also moved Australia. online, selling directly to consumers. Vinmart does it via adayroi.com, AEON has aeonshop.com and Auchan has At the moment, clothing, sports and outdoors, and electronic Auchan.vn. products must comply with local sale and circulation regulations. International e-commerce companies, such as Lazada, that sells to As the most frequently purchased online products in Vietnam are multiple Southeast Asian countries, are not currently providing cosmetics and personal care, Australian businesses operating in products directly from Australia to Vietnam, but there is potential for this space could link up with key beauty chain stores, such as future international fulfillment services and cross-border exportation. Medicare, Guardian and Pharmacity. All include their merchants’ In terms of logistics, there are many international freight forwarders products in their online catalogue, while Pharmacity has instigated like DHL that can help exporters move cargo into the country. direct online orders on its webpage. To appeal to increasingly mobile Vietnamese consumers, Australian businesses must get their products known. This can be done by linking with an e-commerce channel with a local fulfilment service, NO EXISTING RELATIONSHIPS or using a local social media platform, such as Facebook and Zalo Shop, to conduct a branding, communications and self-managed SMEs without relationships or a presence in Vietnam must get their direct selling strategy. products into the market via traditional export channels first before selling on e-commerce platforms. Shopping through social media apps such as Facebook is popular in Vietnam, so businesses should consider how they will use social Vietnamese law stipulates that all consumer goods, including food, media as a promotion and sales tool. See the social media section beverages, skincare and healthcare products, must go through a of Austrade’s export marketing guide. quality declaration procedure before entering the market. The importer is responsible for this procedure. New exporters to market Businesses can also set up their own website for direct consumer should: sales. Please refer to the ‘Exporting from your own website’ section in Austrade’s Guide to Online Exporting for more information. connect with potential partners in market register products with the relevant local government agencies It is important to have an overall strategy to protect your intellectual property rights (IPR) in Vietnam. Rights must be registered and arrange for local partners to import the products enforced in Vietnam, under Vietnam laws, where IPR protection may list with an e-commerce channel (normally carried out by the be different from Australia. Companies should consider how to local partner). obtain patent and trademark protection before introducing their products or services to the Vietnam market, because the granting Under the ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand Free Trade Agreement of patents and registering of trademarks are based on a first-to-file (AANZFTA), many products imported from Australia to Vietnam can basis. The National Office of Intellectual Property oversees the IP enjoy the 0 per cent tariff from 2018. registration procedure following Vietnam’s IP laws.

34 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 35 CONCLUSION HOW AUSTRADE CAN HELP

Vietnam is an emerging e-commerce market that will become If you have any questions, please contact the Austrade team either The Australian Trade and Investment Commission (Austrade) is AUSTRADE IN VIETNAM more dynamic as more global players enter the market. in Hanoi or Ho Chi Minh City. Our mission is to help Australian the Australian Government’s international trade promotion and E-commerce companies are spending to gain market share and companies connect with potential partners. We look forward to investment attraction agency. Every market is different. But wherever you want to do business, competition is intensifying. Developments in the industry are introducing you to the one of the most creative, dynamic and local knowledge goes a long way. At Austrade, we can offer you unlocking new opportunities for foreign businesses. fast-growing economies in Asia. We deliver quality trade and investment services to businesses the experience, insights and contacts you need to make your to grow Australia’s prosperity. We do this by generating and entry or expansion a success. Increasing internet access, widespread smartphone usage, Austrade Hanoi Austrade Ho Chi Minh City providing market information and insights, promoting Australian improved technological infrastructure and improvements in capability, and facilitating connections through our extensive We can help you: regulations are advancing Vietnam’s e-commerce industry. While Australian Embassy Australian Consulate-General global network. challenges remain around consumer confidence in product 8 Dao Tan Street 20th Floor Vincom Centre Better understand the market you’re quality, data privacy, unfulfilled orders, and logistics infrastructure, Understand the market: Ba Dinh District 47 Ly Tu Trong Street, District 1 We also provide financial assistance for exporters through thinking of entering, or discover one you’d never considered. We rising disposable incomes mean that consumers are paying for Hanoi Ho Chi Minh City programs such as the Export Market Development Grants provide information on export issues, statistics, trends and higher value products online. Additionally, foreign-branded scheme. regulations relevant to your product. products are considered to be safe and of high quality so Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Australia’s reputation for producing premium quality products is a Tel : +84 24 3774 0300 Tel : +84 28 3827 0600 To discover how we can help you and your business visit Make a connection: We can introduce you to experienced strong advantage in market. Fax : +84 24 3831 7757 Fax : +84 28 3829 1656 austrade.gov.au or contact us at [email protected] or on 13 locals who can help your business with importing, distribution or 28 78 (within Australia). support. Australian businesses with existing operations in Vietnam should be actively looking at how to make the most of current e-com- Be more efficient: We can help you make the most of your time merce opportunities. Alternatively, cross-border online exporting overseas by arranging appointments for you in advance. offers Australian companies with the potential to expand their reach and sell directly to consumers, without becoming involved Get feedback: After your visit, we’ll get honest feedback from in complicated local supply chains. local contacts, giving you an insight into their take on what you offer, and their poential as business partners.

Promote yourself: When you’re ready to launch overseas, we can help you with your marketing plan, with access to key trade shows and ways to reach your target audience.

36 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 37 REFERENCES

Decision Lab, Device Study 2017, December 2017, Internal data, accessed 26 June 2018. Statista, Digital Market Outlook: ARTICLES: eCommerce, Vietnam Ministry of Justice, “Laws related to e-Commerce: https://www.statista.com/outlook/243/100/ecommerce/worldwide, Shortcomings and Suggestions on Improvement”, 9 October 2017, accessed 2 July 2018. http://moj.gov.vn/qt/tintuc/Pages/nghien-cuu-trao-doi.aspx- World Bank Open Data, Vietnam, ?ItemID=2222, accessed 30 June 2018. https://data.worldbank.org/country/vietnam, accessed 2 July 2018. Nhan Dan, “World Bank helps Vietnam in trade facilitation, logistics development”, 27 June 2017, REPORTS: http://en.nhandan.com.vn/business/item/5301302-wb-helps-viet- nam-in-trade-facilitation-logistics-development.html, accessed 2 Vietnam eCommerce and Digital Economy Agency (VECITA), July 2018. Vietnam e-Commerce Report, April 2017, http://idea.gov.vn/?page=document, accessed 26 June 2018. Cong Thuong, “Vietnam needs to take down barriers so logistics for e-commerce can develop”, 27 April 2018, Vietnam eCommerce and Digital Economy Agency (VECITA), https://congthuong.vn/viet-nam-can-xoa-bo-nhieu-rao-can-de-lo- Vietnam e-Commerce Report, April 2015, gistics-cho-thuong-mai-dien-tu-phat-trien.html, accessed 2 July http://idea.gov.vn/?page=document, accessed 26 June 2018. 2018. Vietnam eCommerce and Digital Economy Agency (VECITA), Vietnam Investment Review, “Sea seizes 82 per cent of Foody”, 3 Vietnam e-Commerce Report, April 2014, October 2017, http://idea.gov.vn/?page=document, accessed 26 June 2018. https://www.vir.com.vn/sea-seizes-82-per-cent-of-foody-52678. html, accessed 2 July 2018. iPrice, State of eCommerce in Southeast Asia 2017, 2017, https://iprice.my/insights/stateofecommerce2017/, accessed 26 Techinasia, “Alibaba injects a further $2b in Lazada as Max Bittner June 2018. steps down as CEO”, 19 March 2018, https://www.techinasia.com/alibaba-injects-2b-lazada-max-bit- EU-Vietnam Business Network, Research Report: e-Commerce tner-steps-ceo, accessed 2 July 2018. Industry in Vietnam, 2018 https://evbn.org/e-commerce-industry-in-vietnam-report-edi- Techcrunch, “JD.com leads investment in Vietnam-based tion-2018/, accessed 30 June 2018. e-commerce service Tiki”, February 2018, https://techcrunch.com/2018/01/18/jd-com-tiki-indonesia/, We Are Social, Digital In Southeast Asia In 2017, February 2017, accessed 2 July 2018. https://wearesocial.com/sg/blog/2017/02/digital-south- east-asia-2017, accessed 2 July 2018. StatCounter, Search Engine Market Share in Vietnam, http://gs.statcounter.com/search-engine-market-share/all/viet-nam, We Are Social, Digital In Southeast Asia In 2016, January 2016, accessed 3 December 2018. https://wearesocial.com/sg/special-reports/digital-2016, accessed 2 July 2018. VIETNAM’S LAWS: Vietnam E-commerce Association, Vietnam e-Commerce Index Report, 2018, Decision 1563/QD-TTg of the Prime Minister approving the Master http://www.vecom.vn/tai-lieu/tai-lieu-trong-nuoc/- Plan for e-commerce development during the period of bao-cao-chi-so-thuong-mai-dien-tu-viet-nam-2018, accessed 2 2016-2020, 8 August 2018. July 2018. Decision 200/QĐ-TTg of the Prime Minister approving the Action PwC Global, PwC’s Global Consumer Insights Survey, 2018, Plan for the action plan for improvement of competitiveness and https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/consumer-markets/con- development of Vietnam’s logistics services by 2025, 24 February sumer-insights-survey/delivery-expectation.html, accessed 3 July 2017. 2018. Decree 163/2017/NĐ-CP on provision of Logistics Services, 30 December 2017.

38 E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM E-COMMERCE IN VIETNAM 39