DOCSLIB.ORG

Building the Climate Change Regime Survey and Analysis of Approaches

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Building the Climate Change Regime Survey and Analysis of Approaches ISBN: 978-92-807-3224-5 Job No: DTI/1465/NA BUILDING THE CLIMATE CHANGE REGIME SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF APPROACHES APPENDIX III KEY HIGHLIGHTS FROM PROPOSALS AND BACKGROUND READING WORKING PAPER BUILDING THE CLIMATE CHANGE REGIME: SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF APPROACHES 1 Authors: Remi Moncel, Paul Joffe, Kevin McCall and Kelly Levin, World Resources Institute Contributors: Lavanya Rajamani, Center for Policy Research, Jacob Werksman, World Resources Institute, Kaveh Zahedi and Arkadiy Levintanus, United Nations Environment Programme Contact: [email protected]; to access the full paper, visit: http://www.wri.org/publication/building-the-climate-change-regime Please note that the summaries herein are not intended to reflect the entirety of the content in each of the proposals examined, but to highlight the particular aspects that relate to the key issues reviewed in the paper. KEY ISSUE 1: Options Under the UNFCCC to Increase Ambition Beyond Existing Commitments and Actions Andersen, S. and Sarma, K. 2010. This paper discusses reforms to the Clean Development Mechanism and “Making Climate Change and Ozone Treaties complementary actions under the Montreal Protocol to contend with HFC-23 Work Together to Curb HFC-23 and Other “Super emissions to enable all countries to cooperate for the protection of the climate Greenhouse Gases.” and the ozone layer. Natural Resources Defense Council Australia. 2009 The government of Australia submitted a draft protocol to the UNFCCC for “Submission by Government of Australia to the COP-15. The protocol envisions commitments and actions by all countries, in UNFCCC”, 2009, line with common but differentiated responsibilities where a spectrum of effort available at http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2009/ is undertaken based on national circumstances. To achieve the overall objective cop15/eng/05.pdf. of the Convention, Parties would maintain national schedules to register Last accessed October 3, 2011. nationally appropriate commitments or actions. These schedules could be amended over time to register additional commitments or actions which would enhance the global mitigation outcome. Bell, R. and Ziegler, M. forthcoming. The authors highlight the lessons that can be learned from international Reimagining a climate agreement: lessons security and economic regimes that may apply to international climate policy. from managing other challenges that transcend While modesty and sensitivity are required in transplanting these lessons, national boundaries, they can nonetheless serve to incentivize progress in international climate World Resources Institute, Washington DC. governance. Lessons include the incremental approach that can allow a Forthcoming. regime to emerge as trust develops between Parties: this is important for transparency and verification. They cite the transformative power of reviews, expert exchanges, consultative processes, and non-adversarial discussion to encourage Parties to undertake deeper engagement. Bice, K. et al. 2009. The authors examine the contribution of black carbon to global warming as Black Carbon: A Review and Policy well as its negative impacts on human health. They discuss the sources of Recommendations. black carbon, noting that while it has a warming impact it is coemitted with Woodrow Wilson School of Public Affairs, Princeton organic carbon, which has a cooling effect. Thus, the ratio of organic carbon University to black carbon makes a critical difference in the net warming impact. They also note the significant warming effect of black carbon when it is present in Arctic or Himalayan regions and its contribution to glacial melt. They identify strategies to reduce black carbon emissions, citing, for example, the benefits of transnational cooperation to tackle black carbon emissions, implementing fuel standards and domestic heating standards, among others. Bodansky, D. 2007. Bodansky notes that international sectoral agreements could contribute to International Sectoral Agreements in a Post-2012 a post-2012 effort as one element of a broader framework. They appear Climate Framework. best suited to advancing agreement and action by helping to defuse Working Paper, Pew Center on Global Climate competitiveness concerns and treating critical technology and finance issues Change, 2007. within a sector where they are most urgent. He concludes by noting that in sectors where industry is well organized at the international level (cement, aluminum) companies facing competitive imbalances may have an incentive to initiate a sectoral approach. Failing this it may fall to governments to take the initiative if sectoral agreements are to emerge. Bond, T. et al. 2005. The authors analyze governance strategies for short term forcings and find “Can Reducing Black Carbon Emissions Counteract that joint consideration along with carbon dioxide regulation is consistent Global Warming?” with the language of the UNFCCC. They note the difficulty in terms of cost Environmental Science and Technology, July 2005. and complexity for addressing such forcings, particularly in Annex I countries where only marginal additional abatement is possible. In non-Annex I countries, however, reducing particulate matter (e.g., black carbon) is economically feasible and can be undertaken in parallel with UNFCCC efforts. 4 BUILDING THE CLIMATE CHANGE REGIME: SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF APPROACHES KEY ISSUE 1: Options Under the UNFCCC to Increase Ambition Beyond Existing Commitments and Actions Cosbey, A. et al. 2005. The paper sets out to assess the extent to which the CDM is fully exploiting Realizing the Development Dividend. its potential to deliver benefits to developing countries, beyond those strictly International Institute for Sustainable Development. related to climate change, in the areas of economic growth through investment, technological evolution, poverty alleviation, as well as environmental and human health improvements. The flows are not substantial compared to overseas development assistance, but nonetheless there are a number of reasons to consider the CDM an important engine of sustainable development. This paper recommends a number of policy options to enhance benefits, including reforming the CDM project cycle, changing the rules of the CDM, engaging development assistance, and defining sustainable development. Daviet, F, et al. 2009. The paper sets out the need to establish a range of accounting and Forests in the Balance Sheet: Lessons from methodological tools to ensure the effectiveness of REDD programs as Developed Country Land Use Change and Forestry agreed upon in the Bali road map. The authors look at lessons from the Greenhouse Gas Accounting and Reporting experience of Annex I countries in accounting for forest-related emissions and Practices.Working Paper, sequestration under their emission reduction commitments with regards to their World Resources Institute. Washington DC. implementation of LULUCF provisions of the Kyoto Protocol. den Elzen, M., Olivier, J., and Berk, M. 2007. This paper provides an overview of various approaches for including maritime An analysis of options for including international and aviation emissions in a future agreement. aviation and maritime emissions in a post-2012 climate mitigation regime. Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency. European Union. 2011. Building on its objective of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by A Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon 80-95 percent by 2050 compared to 1990, the EU has set out a roadmap economy in 2050. outlining milestones and challenges between now and 2050. The report Brussels, March. examines investment opportunities in different sectors, including power, residential, industry, and transport, to determine the pathway to a low-carbon economy by 2050. The Commission intends to use the Roadmap as a basis for developing sector specific policy initiatives to support the transition to a low carbon economy, as well as a means to stimulate the international negotiations in the run-up to COP17. Faber, J. et al. 2007. This proposal presents several means for including aviation and maritime Climate Change Scientific Assessment And Policy emissions in a future climate agreement. Analysis: Aviation and Maritime Transport in a Post 2012 Climate Policy Regime. Netherlands Research Programme on Scientific Assessment and Policy Analysis, April 2007. Grieshop, A. et al. 2009. This paper discusses the mitigation potential of addressing black carbon and “A black carbon mitigation wedge,” argues for inclusion of black carbon under a future climate policy under the Nature Geoscience. Volume 2, August. UNFCCC. Hare, W. et al. 2010. The authors put forward an argument that a centralized, top-down, legally “The architecture of the global climate regime: a binding climate governance architecture is the best option to pursue an top-down perspective,” ambitious 2˚ C or 1.5˚ C goal. This requires strong global coordination and Climate Policy. Vol. 10 (6). strict targets and timetables for countries that need to be agreed-upon and implemented as soon as possible to address climate change with the effort and urgency that it necessitates. BUILDING THE CLIMATE CHANGE REGIME: SURVEY AND ANALYSIS OF APPROACHES 5 KEY ISSUE 1: Options Under the UNFCCC to Increase Ambition Beyond Existing Commitments and Actions IPCC. 2007. The Fourth Assessment Report outlines observed changes in climate, their Fourth Assessment Report: climate change 2007. – effects, and anthropogenic causes. Additionally, the authors summarize Synthesis report. the
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Using Cap and Share to Control Emissions from the EU Transport Sector
    Using Cap and Share to control emissions from the EU transport sector Executive Summary. Cap and Share is a cap and trade system in which tradable rights to whatever is being capped are distributed on an equal-per-person basis to every adult in the general population rather than being auctioned or being grandfathered (given) to existing users. Because those receiving the rights under C&S sell them within a year of receipt, it automatically compensates the least-well- off in society for the price rises that the shortages brought about by the imposition of the cap inevitably generate. This fairness and built-in fiscal neutrality make it a more politically acceptable way to control emissions than other allocation methods. Carbon dioxide emissions from all forms of transport apart from rail are rising within the EU at a time when those from other sectors are falling. Within the transport sector, emissions from road vehicles are rising most rapidly in absolute terms. However, the EU emissions trading system is unsuited to controlling them because of the way it was designed. As only aviation and marine emissions can be taken into the ETS with reasonable ease, this is what the Commission is proposing to do. This paper argues that capping some transport emissions and not others would be a serious mistake because the various transport modes are in competition with each other. Not only would the Commission's proposals distort competition between the modes but, because of the short-term inelasticity of the demand for transport, they are unlikely to cause total transport emissions to fall.
    [Show full text]
  • Personal Carbon Allowances Revisited
    PERSPECTIVE https://doi.org/10.1038/s41893-021-00756-w Personal carbon allowances revisited Francesco Fuso Nerini 1 ✉ , Tina Fawcett2, Yael Parag 3 and Paul Ekins4 Here we discuss how personal carbon allowances (PCAs) could play a role in achieving ambitious climate mitigation targets. We argue that recent advances in AI for sustainable development, together with the need for a low-carbon recovery from the COVID-19 crisis, open a new window of opportunity for PCAs. Furthermore, we present design principles based on the Sustainable Development Goals for the future adoption of PCAs. We conclude that PCAs could be trialled in selected climate-conscious technologically advanced countries, mindful of potential issues around integration into the current policy mix, privacy concerns and distributional impacts. limate change could undermine the achievement of at were proposed to be sold by individuals via banks and post offices to least 72 Targets across the Sustainable Development Goals fossil fuel companies11. In California, household carbon trading was C(SDGs)1. The development of a just and equitable transition proposed for household energy, and managed by the utilities12. In to a net-zero society is vital to avoiding the worst impacts of climate France, centrally managed tradable transport carbon permits were change1. However, by May 2021, Climate Action Tracker2 estimated assessed related to private transport13. Scholars from the University that climate policies implemented across the world at present, of Groningen have proposed European Union (EU)-wide emis- including the effect of the pandemic, will lead to a temperature rise sions trading for households and transport, embedded in the EU of 2.9 °C by the end of the century.
    [Show full text]
  • FEASTA Submission to …
    Submission of Evidence to the ERFA Committee’s examination of international climate policy post-2012 Executive Summary ● There is an urgent need for climate action but the UNFCCC process is moving at a snail's pace. It has become a Gordian Knot of complexity. A simpler process could cut through the knot and lead to a climate treaty being achieved in a relatively short period. ● The overall goals of the process need to be established. If these can be kept simple, it is much easier for competing schemes to be compared and for existing schemes such as the EU ETS to be used to achieve them. ● Simple schemes are also the easiest to explain and communicate. So far, the public has been unable to follow the UNFCCC process because it is just too involved. ● Equitable schemes are the hardest to oppose and so have the greatest chance of success. ● The ideal climate proposal should therefore be simple and equitable. A simple and equitable scheme is proposed in this paper. This is Cap and Share, a development of the well-known Contraction and Convergence approach. 1.Introduction 1.1 FEASTA is the Foundation for the Economics of Sustainability. It is based in Dublin and has an international membership (see www.feasta.org). Our evidence here relates mainly to items 1, 3 and 7 in the EFRA Committee’s list of issues in its Call for Evidence. 2. Background 2.1 There is a clear consensus that there is an urgent need to take effective action to limit the extent of climate change.
    [Show full text]
  • Oriental Despotism. a Comparative Study of Total Power. New Haven: Yale University Press
    credo – economic beliefs in a world in crisis Wittfogel, K. A. (1957). Oriental Despotism. A Comparative Study of Total Power. New Haven: Yale University Press. Index Wkipedia. (2013, August). Kaldor-Hicks Efficiency. Retrieved December 29th, 2013, from Wkipedia: Abatement cost conceived of like an insurance premium, 381 Australian aboriginal people, 118, 129, 131 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaldor%E2%80%93Hicks_efficiency Aborigines and land care, 118-131 Austrian economists, 64, 176, 296, 312, 314 Adaptation level, 53 Austrian school, 311 WorkingGroup1. (2013). IPCC Process. Retrieved January 3rd, 2014, from Inter-governmental Panel on Advertisers, 71, 75-76 Authenticity, 80, 83, 354 Climate Change: http://www.climatechange2013.org/ipcc-process/ Advertising, 73-77, 79-80, 88, 97, 237, 301, 351 Autistic economics, 54, 435 Xenophon, & Dakyns(Tr), H. H. (2013, January). The Economist. Retrieved December 31st, 2013, from Affluenza, 80, 83-84, 95, 420, 444 Autonomy, 12, 124, 234, 321, 437 Project Gutenberg: http://www.gutenberg.org/files/1173/1173-h/1173-h.htm Age of Commerce, 29-30, 122, 127, 152 Autopoiesis, 124 Agricultural policy, 157 ‘Bads’ and goods, 414 Yan, K. (2012, February 2nd). The Global CDM Hydro Hall of Shame. Retrieved January 3rd, 2014, from China, 15, 23, 79, 157-158, 195, 198, 226, 291, 297, 379, 440 Banks, 99, 173, 230, 289, 291, 293, 315, 325, 328, 331, 335-337, 339-340, 343-344, 346, 352-354, 356-360, 362-363, 366 International Rivers: http://www.internationalrivers.org/blogs/246/the-global-cdm-hydro-hall-of-shame Ming sheng, 157 Bank credit creation, 173, 335, 339 Mughal India, 157 Bank reform, 354-365 Young, R., Cowe, A., Nunan, C., Harvey, J., & Mason, L.
    [Show full text]
  • Climate Curriculum Learning Outcomes NOV19.Indd
    CLIMATE What should young people know about 1 13 ACTION The Big Ideas: Climate Action by the time they leave school? Climate Curriculum Learning Outcomes KEY IDEAS SCIENTIFIC BACKGROUND By the end of Year 2: By the end of Year 4: By the end of Year 6: By the end of Year 9: By the end of Year 11: → Pupils understand that → Pupils understand that → Pupils can clearly → Students can clearly explain → Students can name a range of some human activity burning coal, oil and articulate the link the scientific consensus that greenhouse gases and describe in causes pollution in the gas has an impact on between burning human burning of fossil fuels is detail the processes that lead to air which is affecting the the climate and have a fossil fuels and the main and original cause of their increasing concentrations in world’s climate / making basic understanding of climate change using today’s climate change the atmosphere the world hotter the scientific processes appropriate scientific Students can describe Students know where uncertainties involved vocabulary → → → Pupils understand the processes that undermine or remain in climate science, e.g. how distinction between → Pupils are familiar with → Pupils can name key boost carbon sinks atmospheric water vapour will ‘weather’ and ‘climate’ the terms ‘atmosphere’, carbon sinks such as change; when tipping points may Students are aware that in ‘Climate Change’ forests, peatlands, → be reached; climate inertia; how Pupils know that the the public arena there are → and ‘greenhouse gas oceans, algal blooms,
    [Show full text]
  • Personal Carbon Trading: a Review of Research Evidence and Real-World Experience of a Radical Idea
    Energy and Emission Control Technologies Dovepress open access to scientific and medical research Open Access Full Text Article REVIEW Personal carbon trading: a review of research evidence and real-world experience of a radical idea Yael Parag1 Abstract: Personal carbon trading (PCT) is a radical and innovative mitigation approach for Tina Fawcett2 the residential and personal transport sectors. PCT is an umbrella term for various downstream cap-and-trade policies, all of which aim to limit carbon emissions within a society by engag- 1School of Sustainability, The Interdisciplinary Center, Herzliya, ing individuals in the process, and could cover more than 40% of national carbon emissions. Israel; 2Environmental Change This policy idea is unique because it provides an overarching approach to personal emissions Institute, Oxford University Centre for the Environment, Oxford, UK from energy use and because it combines a number of mechanisms to drive behavior change: economic, psychological, and social. This paper presents a review of research evidence and real-world experience of PCT. Most of the political interest, research, and experimentation with PCT has taken place in the UK. During 2006–2008, the UK government commissioned a number of studies on PCT, following high-level political interest. It concluded that public acceptability and the cost of the scheme were serious barriers to its introduction. However, a variety of other research work has subsequently demonstrated that public acceptability may not be such a barrier as feared. Nevertheless, there are a number of other barriers, including costs and technical challenges, some adverse distributional effects, and the low carbon capa- bilities of citizens.
    [Show full text]
  • Climate Crisis: Social Science Crisis
    Climate Crisis: Social Science Crisis [a chapter for Der Klimawandel: Sozialwissenschaftliche Perspektiven , VS-Verlag, forthcoming] Larry Lohmann The Corner House Introduction “Billions wasted on UN climate programme” (Vidal 2008). “European Union’s efforts to tackle climate change a failure” (Snow 2007). “Effort to curtail emissions in turmoil” (Ball 2008a). “. may slow the changes needed to cope with global warming” (Kanter 2007). “It isn’t working” (Vencat 2007). “Not effective” (Wheelan 2007). “A charade” (Wall Street Journal 2007). “Will such systems ever work?” (Kanter 2008). “Time to ditch Kyoto” (Prins and Rayner 2007). “Beware the carbon cowboys” (Harvey 2007). Such headlines may seem alarming. But they are becoming more and more commonplace, and reflect rising concern – even among many supporters of the Kyoto Protocol, the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS), and other flagship programmes to curb climate change – that, after 10 grueling years of seemingly earnest global efforts, things are not going according to plan. Whether or not current international climate agreements turn out in the end to be fixable, it is obvious that they have not worked so far in alleviating what US President George W. Bush refers to as the “addiction to fossil fuels” that is chiefly responsible for global warming. The headlines also point to serious gaps in the explanations most often offered for the failures of global climate policy. These explanations tend to stress a number of factors. Shorter-term political issues are said to be taking precedence over climate change. Fossil fuel-using lobbies are strong. The international legal regime is weak. Distrustful Southern governments are unlikely to buy into global solutions that appear to perpetuate colonialist inequalities (Roberts and Parks 2007).
    [Show full text]
  • Quarterly Economic Commentary
    RESEARCH SERIES NUMBER 4 OCTOBER 2008 BUDGET PERSPECTIVES 2009 Tim Callan (ed.) Ray Barrell, Alan Barrett, Noel Casserly, Frank Convery, Jean Goggin, Ide Kearney, Simon Kirby, Pete Lunn, Martin O’Brien, Lisa Ryan Copies of this paper may be obtained from The Economic and Social Research Institute (Limited Company No. 18269). Registered Office: Whitaker Square, Sir John Rogerson’s Quay, Dublin 2. www.esri.ie Price €15.00 (Special rate for students, €7.50) Tim Callan is Research Professor, Alan Barrett is Senior Research Officer, Ide Kearney is Research Associate, Pete Lunn is Post Doctoral Fellow, Martin O’Brien and Jean Goggin are Research Assistants at the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI). Ray Barrell is Senior Research Fellow, Simon Kirby is Research Fellow at the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR), London. Noel Casserly is Director, Comhar, Lisa Ryan is Director of Research, Comhar - the Sustainable Development Council. Frank Convery is Professor of Environmental Studies at University College Dublin. These papers have been accepted for publication by the Institute, which does not itself take institutional policy positions. Accordingly, the authors are solely responsible for the content and the views expressed. RESEARCH SERIES NUMBER 4 OCTOBER 2008 BUDGET PERSPECTIVES 2009 Tim Callan (ed.) Ray Barrell, Alan Barrett, Noel Casserly, Frank Convery, Jean Goggin, Ide Kearney, Simon Kirby, Pete Lunn, Martin O’Brien, Lisa Ryan © THE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL RESEARCH INSTITUTE DUBLIN, 2008 ISBN 0 7070 0273 7 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks are due to the referees and to research staff at the ESRI for comments which have helped to improve the papers included in this volume.
    [Show full text]
  • Feasta Annual Report 2016
    The Foundation for the Economics of Sustainability Annual Report 2016 " Feasta, the Foundation for the Economics ofSustainability, aims to identify the characteristics (economic, cultural and environmental) ofa truly sustainable so- ciety, articulate how the necessary transition can be effected, and promote the implementation ofthe measures required for this purpose. Cad a dhéanfaimid feasta gan adhmad? Tá deireadh na gcoillte ar lár What will we do in the future without wood? The end ofthe forests has come " Contents Introduction 1 Climate Group 2 Water/Water Commoning 4 Currency Group 5 Beyond GDP: New Approaches to Measuring Well-Being 6 Risk-Resilience 7 Fundraising 7 Networking 8 Training and Capacity Building 8 Events 9 Website 10 Submissions 12 Environmental Pillar 12 Staff and Management 13 " Introduction ur times require a fundamental change in the rela- An economy is a system nested within a human social system O tionship of humans to the earth and with each oth- and both in turn are nested within natural systems, on which er. We are all part of this planet and its health and our we depend completely for our well being. We need to have well being are inextricably linked. The pursuit of short- constantly evolving conversations in society about what the term, indiscriminate economic growth, pushed by the overall goals for our society are and how economy can serve needs of a capitalist, privatized money system, has them. The absolute reality is that we need to contain our eco- wrought huge damage on individuals, societies and the nomies and the kinds of work we do within them, within eco- ecosystems that provide the resources essential to life.
    [Show full text]
  • Frameworks & Proposals
    NO. 30⏐ JUNE 2007⏐ ENGLISH VERSION Frameworks & Proposals A Brief, Adequacy and Equity-Based Evaluation of Some Prominent Climate Policy Frameworks and Proposals By PAUL BAER & TOM ATHANASIOU (ECOEQUITY) Contents 1 Foreword 2 Introduction 3 A Normative Approach to Analyzing Adequacy & Equity 4 Contraction and Convergence 5 The Climate Action Network’s “Viable Framework for Preventing Dangerous Climate Change” 6 The South-North Dialogue’s “Equity in the Greenhouse” Proposal 7 Greenhouse Development Rights 8 The Vattenfall Proposal 9 The Global Climate Certificate System 10 By Way of Conclusion Paul Baer: [email protected] Tom Athanasiou: [email protected] EcoEquity – 1514 Beverly Place – Albany CA, 94705 USA – www.ecoequity.org Global Issue Papers, No. 30 Frameworks & Proposals A Brief, Adequacy and Equity-Based Evaluation of Some Prominent Climate Policy Frameworks and Proposals. By Paul Baer & Tom Athanasiou Commissioned by the Heinrich Boell Foundation © Heinrich Böll Foundation 2007 All Rights reserved Heinrich Böll Foundation – Rosenthalerstr. 40/41 – 10178 Berlin – www.boell.de 2 Table of contents 1 Foreword 5 2 Introduction 7 3 A Normative Approach to Analyzing Adequacy & Equity 10 4 Contraction and Convergence 14 4.1 Key Elements 14 4.2 Environmental Adequacy 14 4.3 Developmental Equity 15 4.3.1 Explicit equity principles 15 4.3.2 Protection of the “right to development” 15 4.3.3 Behavior under stringent targets 15 4.3.4 Other equity issues: The population question 16 4.4 Adaptation 16 4.5 Prospects for Modification 16 4.6 Evaluation
    [Show full text]
  • Feasta Cap and Share Report on South Africa
    Potential Impacts of a Global Cap and Share Scheme on South Africa JEREMY WAKEFORD RESEARCH DIRECTOR, SOUTH AFRICAN NEW ECONOMICS (SANE) NETWORK September 2008 Feasta, 14 St. Stephen’s Green, Dublin 2. Ireland Tel: +353 (0)1 6619572 • Email: [email protected] • Web: www.feasta.org SA FeastaReport.S_F.indd 1 3/12/08 18:11:44 Potential Impacts of a Global Cap and Share Scheme on South Africa CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 Overview of the Cap & Share scheme 1 1.2 Aims of the study 1 1.3 Scope 2 1.4 Assumptions 2 1.5 Methodology 2 1.6 Data 2 2 South African Background 3 2.1 Energy supply and consumption 3 2.2 CO2 emissions 3 2.3 Socio-economic context 4 3 Impact on Prices 5 3.1 Energy prices 5 3.2 Direct impact on the consumer price index 6 3.3 Indirect price effects 6 3.4 Sensitivity of price effects to initial prices and assumptions 8 4 Impact on the Macroeconomy 8 4.1 Balance of payments 8 4.2 Aggregate expenditure on CO2 and PAP income 10 5 Impact on Households 11 5.1 Household expenditure 12 5.2 Household income 16 5.3 Net impact on households 17 6 Impact on Industry 18 6.1 Energy use, emissions and CO2 costs by major sector 18 6.2 Second order effects 19 6.3 Export industries and international competitiveness 20 7 Opportunities for Renewable Energy 21 8 Summary and Conclusions 21 9 References 22 Appendix A: Fossil Fuel Scarcity Rents 24 APPENDICES Appendix B: Comparative Energy Intensities of SA Industries 26 Figure 1: Shares of total primary energy supply in South Africa, 2005 3 FIGURES Figure 2: Carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuel
    [Show full text]
  • ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITS and BOUNDARIES: a Research Paper
    ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITS AND BOUNDARIES: EVOLVING MEANINGS, HOW DIFFERENT SCHOOLS OF THOUGHT DRAW A ROADMAP AND WHAT WE LEARN FROM THAT A Research Paper presented by: ASMITA VAIDYA (India) in partial fulfilment of the requirements for obtaining the degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN DEVELOPMENT STUDIES Major: Agrarian Food and Environmental Studies AFES Specialization: ESD Environment and Sustainable Development Members of the Examining Committee: Murat Arsel (Supervisor) Arnim Scheidel (Reader) The Hague, The Netherlands December 2016 i ii Table of Contents List of Figures iv List of Appendices iv Acronyms v Abstract vii 1. ENVIRONMENTAL LIMITS AND BOUNDARIES: EVOLVING MEANINGS 1 1.1 Objective and Methodology 2 1.2 Origin of limits and boundaries 5 2. IDEAS, PEOPLE, PLACES AND TIME 7 2.1 Limits to growth 7 2.2 Planetary Boundaries 12 2.3 Degrowth 16 3. GROWTH, ENVIRONMENT AND PROSPERITY 21 3.1 Economic Growth 21 3.2 Accounting issues, environmental problems, and infeasibility of accumulation and profit 22 3.3 Beyond economy and ecology 27 3.4 The Bottom Line 28 4 VISION FOR CHANGE 29 4.1 Limits to Growth 29 4.2 Degrowth 30 4.3 Planetary Boundaries 32 5 IMPLICATIONS AND TAKEAWAYS 35 5.1 Co-production 35 5.2 Ideologies, worldviews and values 37 5.3 Environmental and social limits, yes, growth limits, not so much 40 6 IN CLOSING 42 References 44 iii List of Figures Figure 1: Scenario 6 from Limits to Growth 10 Figure 2: Real world data comparison from 1970-2000 11 Figure 3: The World Model 12 Figure 4: Planetary Boundaries 15 Figure 5: Francois Schneider’s
    [Show full text]