From: Shelby Managh To: Mailroom Mailbox Subject: Plan Change 7 LWRP Further Submission Date: Friday, 29 November 2019 1:57:08 PM Attachments: Plan Change 7 Further Submission.pdf

Good afternoon,

Please find attached to this email Trustpowers further submissions on Plan Change 7 to the Canterbury Land and Water Plan.

Thanks

Shelby Managh Environmental Advisor - Policy

Trustpower

M 027 269 9488 E [email protected] Trustpower Limited, Private Bag 12023, Tauranga 3143, trustpower.co.nz

The contents of this email and any attachments are confidential and may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you may not use, copy or disclose this email or its attachments. Please notify the sender immediately by e-mail if you have received this e-mail in error and delete both emails from your system. It is your responsibility to check this email and any attachments for viruses or other harmful code before opening or sending on. Trustpower Limited and its subsidiaries (collectively, Trustpower) accepts no responsibility for any such virus or any effects of a virus on your systems or data. Trustpower does not endorse anything in this email that is not related to its official business. Please think of the environment before printing this email.

FURTHER SUBMISSIONS THAT ARE IN SUPPORT OF, OR IN OPPOSITION TO, SUBMISSIONS ON PROPOSED PLAN CHANGE 7 TO THE CANTERBURY LAND AND WATER REGIONAL PLAN

UNDER CLAUSE 8 OF THE FIRST SCHEDULE TO THE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ACT 1991

To: Canterbury Regional Council

Email: [email protected]

Submission on: Proposed Plan Change 7 to the Canterbury Land and Water Regional Plan

Submitter Name: Trustpower Limited (“Trustpower”)

Address for Service: Trustpower Limited Private Bag 12023 TAURANGA 3143

027 269 9488 [email protected]

Further submission from Trustpower on the Proposed Plan Change 7 is as follows and contains:

• The particular parts of the original submission (as derived from the summary of submissions) that Trustpower has submitted on; • Reasons for the submission; and • The decision sought.

As a generator and supplier of , Trustpower has an interest in the proposal that is greater than the interest the general public.

Trustpower wishes to be heard in support of its submission.

If others make a similar submission, Trustpower would not be prepared to consider a joint case.

______

Signature: Shelby Managh, Environmental Advisor – Policy For and on behalf of Trustpower Limited

Date: 29 November 2019

Page | 1 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose Policy 4.61A C7-193.4 Cashmere Stream Care Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Group Trustpower C7-292.5 Timaru District Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-351.4 Central South Island Fish Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point and Game Council Trustpower PC7-95.61 North and Central South Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Island Fish and Game Trustpower PC7-214.14 Beef + Lamb New Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Zealand Trustpower PC7-430.9 Combined Canterbury Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Provinces, Federated Trustpower Farmers of New Zealand PC7-343.8 Ashburton River Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Irrigators Association Trustpower PC7-160.105 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-422.7 Genesis Energy Limited Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes PC7-422.8 Genesis Energy Limited Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point

PC7-472.30 Royal Forest & Bird Support It provides clarity to the intent of the policy which aligns Accept submission point Protection Society Inc. with the relief sought by Trustpower PC7-138.12 Canterbury Aoraki Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Board Trustpower PC7-160.6 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-357.3 DairyNZ Limited Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower

Page | 2 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-88.36 Water and Wildlife Support In so far as it does not impact the relief sought by Accept submission point Habitat Trust Trustpower PC7-472.28 Royal Forest & Bird Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Protection Society Inc. PC7-423.18 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower Policy 4.101 PC7-193.5 Cashmere Stream Care Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Group Trustpower PC7-292.8 Timaru District Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-337.12 Christchurch City Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-356.20 Horticulture New Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Zealand Trustpower PC7-214.18 Beef + Lamb New Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Zealand Trustpower PC7-430.15 Combined Canterbury Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Provinces, Federated Trustpower Farmers of New Zealand PC7-207.16 Ellesmere Sustainable Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Agriculture Incorporated Trustpower PC7-312.18 Greenstreet Irrigation Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Society Trustpower PC7-343.16 Ashburton River Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Irrigators Association Trustpower PC7-160.106 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-160.107 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower

Page | 3 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-138.3 Canterbury Aoraki Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Board Trustpower PC7-160.8 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-88.37 Water and Wildlife Support In so far as it does not impact the relief sought by Accept submission point Habitat Trust Trustpower PC7-422.11 Genesis Energy Limited Oppose in Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point Part hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes PC7-422.12 Genesis Energy Limited Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point

PC7-472.40 Royal Forest & Bird Support In so far as it does not impact the relief sought by Accept submission point Protection Society Inc. Trustpower PC7-346.5 Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point

PC7-346.6 Meridian Energy Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes PC7-423.22 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-522.1 King, J Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-3.8 Waimakariri District Support In so far as it does not impact the relief sought by Accept submission point Council Trustpower PC7-472.41 Royal Forest & Bird Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Protection Society Inc. Trustpower PC7-472.42 Royal Forest & Bird Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Protection Society Inc. Trustpower PC7-88.114 Water and Wildlife Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Habitat Trust Trustpower

Page | 4 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose Policy 4.102 PC7-138.9 Canterbury Aoraki Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Board Trustpower PC7-138.10 Canterbury Aoraki Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Board Trustpower PC7-214.19 Beef + Lamb New Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Zealand Trustpower PC7-193.6 Cashmere Stream Care Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Group Trustpower PC7-138.10 Canterbury Aoraki Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Board Trustpower PC7-207.17 Ellesmere Sustainable Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Agriculture Incorporated Trustpower PC7-472.43 Royal Forest & Bird Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Protection Society Inc. Trustpower PC7-430.16 Combined Canterbury Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Provinces, Federated Trustpower Farmers of New Zealand PC7-312.19 Greenstreet Irrigation Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Society PC7-351.7 Central South Island Fish Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point and Game Council Trustpower PC7-346.7 Meridian Energy Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point PC7-423.23 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-422.13 Genesis Energy Limited Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes PC7-346.26 Meridian Energy Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point

Page | 5 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-160.9 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-423.95 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-346.25 Meridian Energy Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point PC7-423.96 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower Rule 5.139 PC7-160.18 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-292.27 Timaru District Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-351.13 Central South Island Fish Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point and Game Council Trustpower PC7-337.62 Christchurch City Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-423.52 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-95.74 North Canterbury Fish Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point and Game Council Trustpower PC7-430.40 Combined Canterbury Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Provinces, Federated Farmers of New Zealand PC7-207.25 Ellesmere Sustainable Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Agriculture Incorporated PC7-312.40 Greenstreet Irrigation Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Society PC7-346.10 Meridian Energy Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes

Page | 6 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-422.19 Genesis Energy Limited Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes PC7-343.46 Ashburton River Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Irrigators Association Rule 5.140A PC7-160.20 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-292.29 Timaru District Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-337.64 Christchurch City Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-423.54 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-430.42 Combined Canterbury Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Provinces, Federated Farmers of New Zealand PC7-207.27 Ellesmere Sustainable Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Agriculture Incorporated PC7-312.42 Greenstreet Irrigation Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Society PC7-346.13 Meridian Energy Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes PC7-422.21 Genesis Energy Limited Oppose Trustpower opposes the exemption of specifically named Reject submission point hydroelectric power schemes and as per Trustpower’s submission seeks the exemption of all existing hydroelectric power schemes

Page | 7 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-343.48 Ashburton River Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Irrigators Association Rule 5.163 PC7-430.58 Combined Canterbury Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Provinces, Federated Farmers of New Zealand PC7-351.19 Central South Island Fish Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point and Game Council PC7-95.80 North Canterbury Fish Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point and Game Council PC7-160.28 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower PC7-430.47 Combined Canterbury Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Provinces, Federated Trustpower Farmers of New Zealand PC7-207.33 Ellesmere Sustainable Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Agriculture Incorporated Trustpower PC7-312.47 Greenstreet Irrigation Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Society Trustpower PC7-346.17 Meridian Energy Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-422.28 Genesis Energy Limited Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-472.66 Royal Forest & Bird Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Protection Society Inc. Trustpower, and the appropriate protections are already in place through the current wording of the policy PC7-343.53 Ashburton River Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Irrigators Association Trustpower

Maps General

Page | 8 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-554.2 Adams, M Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point PC7-43.3 Wium, D H Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Map 49 PC7-337.134 Christchurch City Council Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Definition of Indigenous Freshwater Species Habitat PC7-351.1 Central South Island Fish Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point and Game Council PC7-95.58 North Canterbury Fish Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point and Game Council PC7-430.4 Combined Canterbury Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Provinces, Federated Trustpower Farmers of New Zealand PC7-312.6 Greenstreet Irrigation Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Society Trustpower PC7-343.5 Ashburton River Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Irrigators Association Trustpower PC7-160.38 Department of Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Conservation Trustpower, and Trustpower does not consider that the definitions framework is an appropriate place for this addition to sit PC7-214.4 Beef + Lamb New Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point Zealand PC7-422.4 Genesis Energy Limited Support In so far as it aligns with the relief sought by Trustpower Accept submission point PC7-472.4 – Royal Forest & Bird Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point 472.9 Protection Society Inc. Trustpower PC7-346.2 Meridian Energy Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-337.2 Christchurch City Council Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower

Page | 9 November 2019

Submission Submitter Name Support or Trustpower’s Reason for Support or Opposition Relief Sought Number Oppose PC7-339.2 Fenwick, G D Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-399.1 Te Ngāi Tūāhuriri Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Rūnanga Trustpower PC7-399.93 Te Ngāi Tūāhuriri Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Rūnanga Trustpower PC7-399.94 Te Ngāi Tūāhuriri Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Rūnanga Trustpower PC7-423.78 Ngā Rūnanga Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower PC7-387.16 As One Incorporated Oppose In so far as it does not align with the relief sought by Reject submission point Trustpower

Page | 10 November 2019