DOCSLIB.ORG

Decisional Dignity: Teenage Abortion, Bypass Hearings, and the Misuse of Law

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Decisional Dignity: Teenage Abortion, Bypass Hearings, and the Misuse of Law Columbia Law School Scholarship Archive Faculty Scholarship Faculty Publications 2009 Decisional Dignity: Teenage Abortion, Bypass Hearings, and the Misuse of Law Carol Sanger Columbia Law School, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/faculty_scholarship Part of the Health Law and Policy Commons, Juvenile Law Commons, and the Law and Gender Commons Recommended Citation Carol Sanger, Decisional Dignity: Teenage Abortion, Bypass Hearings, and the Misuse of Law, 18 COLUM. J. GENDER & L. 409 (2009). Available at: https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/faculty_scholarship/1116 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Publications at Scholarship Archive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Scholarship by an authorized administrator of Scholarship Archive. For more information, please contact [email protected]. DECISIONAL DIGNITY: TEENAGE ABORTION, BYPASS HEARINGS, AND THE MISUSE OF LAW CAROL SANGER* I. IN TR O D U C TIO N .................................................................................. 4 10 II. JUDICIAL BYPASS HEARINGS ........................................................ 421 A . O rig in s .............................................................................................. 42 1 B . O peration .......................................................................................... 424 1. The P etition ................................................................................... 424 2. Procedural Features ....................................................................... 426 3. Maturity and Best Interest Standards ............................................ 429 4. Burden of Proof and Standard of Review ..................................... 432 C. Outcomes and the Nature of Harm ................................................... 433 III. H A RM TO M IN O R S ........................................................................... 437 A . The R isks of D elay ........................................................................... 437 B. The Risk of Public Exposure ............................................................ 440 C. Humiliation, Dread, and the Demands of Dignity ............................ 444 1. H um iliation ................................................................................... 444 2. Terror and Testim ony .................................................................... 447 3 . D ign ity ........................................................................................... 4 50 4. The Indignity of Exclusion ............................................................ 454 IV. COMPELLING NARRATIVE ............................................................ 456 A . Pardon T ales ..................................................................................... 457 B. Bypass Hearings and the Constraints of Genre ................................. 460 1. M anner and M aturity ..................................................................... 461 2. The Structure of Stealth ................................................................. 463 3. Gender and Narrative Demand ...................................................... 464 C. The Expression of Remorse .............................................................. 466 V. PURPOSE AND PUNISHMENT ......................................................... 470 A . D eterrence ......................................................................................... 47 1 * Barbara Aronstein Black Professor of Law, Columbia Law School. I am deeply grateful for the comments of Susan Bandes, Erin Dougherty, Donald Duquette, Robert Ferguson, Katherine Franke, Suzanne Goldberg, Susan Hays, Rachel Rebouch6, Anna Sochynsky and Jeremy Waldron, and for the research assistance of Samantha Harper Knox, Maureen Siedor, and Jean Zachariasiewicz. Thanks also to the Columbia Journalof Gender and Law staff, especially Chinyere Ezie. 410 Columbia Journalof Gender and Law [Vol. 18:2 B . Counseling and Consent ................................................................... 473 C . B ypass Sym bolism ............................................................................ 476 D . P unishm ent ....................................................................................... 477 VI. HARM TO THE LEGAL PROCESS .................................................. 479 A. Fault-Based Divorce: Hearings as Sham .......................................... 480 B . H U A C and Sham e ............................................................................. 484 C . Fairness and Legitim acy ................................................................... 485 D. The Dignitarian Luck of the D raw .................................................... 487 E. The Illegitimacy of Forum Exclusion ............................................... 490 VII. ABORTION POLITICS AND BYPASS PROCESSES .................... 492 V III. C O N C LU SIO N ................................................................................. 497 I. INTRODUCTION How might we think about reforming abortion regulation in a world in which the basic legality of abortion may, as a matter of constitutional law, at last be relatively secure? I have in mind the era just upon us in which the overturn of Roe v. Wade1 no longer looms so threateningly over the reproductive rights community in the United States and is no longer necessarily its central concern. There is now a general and seemingly well- founded optimism that under the Obama administration, those who support and rely on reproductive rights will not have to pray nightly for the health of Supreme Court justices (although we wish them well). As Senator Obama said in 2008 on the 35th anniversary of Roe: With one more vacancy on the Supreme Court, we could be looking at a majority hostile to a woman's fundamental right to choose for the first time since Roe v. Wade. The next president may be asked to nominate that Supreme Court justice. That is what is at stake in this election. 2 It appears that since January 20, 2009, Justice Stevens may, if he wishes, hang out rather than hang on, and the rest of us may now be more confident that vacancies on the court are less likely to put the basic right to abortion in jeopardy. President Obama's first Supreme Court appointment, Sonia Sotomayor, characterized the Court's decision in Planned '410 U.S. 113 (1973). 2 Press Release, Barack Obama, Statement on 35th Anniversary of Roe v. Wade Decision (Jan. 22, 2008), http://www.barackobama.com/2008/01/22/obamastatement on_35th_ annive.php. 2009] DecisionalDignity Parenthoodvs. Casey as "settled" and "the precedent of the court" during her confirmation hearings.3 While confidence in a justice's future decisions is never assured, it seems, for the moment anyway, that Roe will not be overturned. 4 Despite the relief that flows from this greater sense of reproductive security, much legal work still needs to be done to secure healthier reproductive lives for women. Some of that work will remain constitutionally focused. Without the prospect of overturning Roe in the immediate future, pro-life legislators may focus ever more vigorously on whittling down women's access to abortion through the targeted hyper- regulation of abortion provision, access, and consent.5 Ever since the stingy affirmance of Roe in PlannedParenthood v. Casey,6 the Supreme Court has affirmed the constitutionality of almost every regulatory requirement imposed by states on abortion patients, clinics, and doctors. 7 Constant vigilance over Roe may no longer be required, but lawyers still have plenty to do defending its current boundaries. Yet constitutional advocacy is only part of the project for a pro- choice post-Roe agenda.8 This Article considers the possibilities for statutory abortion reform and seeks to extend the audience to include 3 Charlie Savage, Respecting Precedent, or Settled Law, Unless It's Not Settled, N.Y. TIMES, July 14, 2009, available at http://www.nytimes.com/2OO9/07/15/us/politics/ 15abortion.html. 4 See, e.g., Charlie Savage, On Sotomayor, Some Abortion Rights Backers Are Uneasy, N.Y. TIMES, May 27, 2009, available at http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/28/us/ politics/28abortion.html. 5 See generally Center for Reproductive Rights, Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers (TRAP): Avoiding the TRAP (Nov. 1, 2007), http://reproductiverights.org/en/document/targeted-regulation-of-abortion-providers-trap- avoiding-the-trap. 6Planned Parenthood of Se. Pa. v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833, 879 (1992). 7 As a Fourth Circuit judge observed in a South Carolina case, these burdensome regulations-"micromanaging everything from elevator safety to countertop varnish to the location of janitors' closets"-have in a number of states "made abortions effectively unavailable, if not technically illegal." Greenville Women's Clinic v. Comm'r, S.C. Dep't of Health & Envtl. Control, 317 F.3d 357, 371-72 (4th Cir. 2002) (King, J., dissenting) (upholding an elaborate set of state abortion regulations). 8 See Robin West, From Choice to Reproductive Justice: De-Constitutionalizing Abortion Rights, 118 YALE L.J. 1394, 1409-12 (2009) (arguing that the "court-generated rights discourse" has legitimated a minimalist state response to the problems of pregnant women). 412 Columbia Journalof Gender and Law [Vol. 18:2 legislatures in addition to courts. Are there arguments that have been obscured or overlooked in recent years but that, when brought
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ebook Download Old Age, Masculinity, and Early Modern Drama 1St Edition
    OLD AGE, MASCULINITY, AND EARLY MODERN DRAMA 1ST EDITION PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Anthony Ellis | 9781351914031 | | | | | Old Age, Masculinity, and Early Modern Drama 1st edition PDF Book Non-standard behavior may be considered indicative of homosexuality , despite the fact that gender expression, gender identity and sexual orientation are widely accepted as distinct concepts. Discourse Analysis Online. Historian Kate Cooper wrote: "Wherever a woman is mentioned a man's character is being judged — and along with it what he stands for. Research in the United Kingdom found, "Younger men and women who read fitness and fashion magazines could be psychologically harmed by the images of perfect female and male physiques. Here Press. Gender: laughter. Boxing was professionalized in America and Europe in the 19th century; it emphasized the physical and confrontational aspects of masculinity. And you can see that in the media today. While the causes of drinking and alcoholism are complex and varied, gender roles and social expectations have a strong influence encouraging men to drink. Dandies and desert saints: styles of Victorian masculinity. By mid 17th c. Reasons cited for not seeing a physician include fear, denial, embarrassment, a dislike of situations out of their control and the belief that visiting a doctor is not worth the time or cost. Where plays in the past had, for the most part, used mythological or stereotypical characters, now they involved the lower class, the poor, the rich; they involved all genders, classes and races. Acr North American Advances. The group that had finished would move their pageant away from their platform and the next pageant wagon would move into place.
    [Show full text]
  • Princeton Journal of Bioethics Princeton Bioethics Conference Special Publication Presented by the Student Bioethics Forum and FUSION
    Princeton Bioethics Conference November 20, 2010 PJB Princeton Journal of Bioethics Princeton Bioethics Conference Special Publication Presented by The Student Bioethics Forum and FUSION Dedicated to the discussion and contemplation of issues at the intersection of technology and society. Princeton Bioethics Conference The Princeton Journal of Bioethics Tony Trenga ‘11 Editor-in-Chief Brett Lullo ‘11 Layout Editor Angela Dai ‘13 Bruce Easop ‘13 George Maliha ‘13 Joseph Park ‘13 James Williams ‘13 Alina Yang ’13 Editorial Staff Copyright 2010 by the Princeton Journal of Bioethics. All rights reserved. Cover Design: Jared Serwer ’98 Bioethics Emblem: Darryl Bledsoe ‘98 i The Princeton Journal of Bioethics Princeton Bioethics Conference Foreword We are proud to present the attendees of the Princeton Bio- ethics Conference: Undergraduate Voices on the Intersection of Science, Technical Review Board Policy, and Ethics with this special publication of the Princeton Journal of Bioethics. A joint collaboration of the Student Bioethics Forum, The Technical Review Board was created to review the student writing thereby FUSION, and the Princeton Journal of Bioethics, this issue of the ensuring the accuracy and quality of the Journal. We would like to extend our Journal consists of the papers of the undergraduate students present- appreciation to these professionals who donated their time and expertise to our ing at this year’s conference. The articles we have selected discuss endeavor. topics such as drug addiction and the addict’s accountability, Michael Tooley’s “Abortion and Infanticide,” the ethics of the dissemination Martin R. Eichelberger, MD of nootropics, and life-support and end-of-life decision-making.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Cloning and Moral Status Christopher Alexander Pynes
    Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2003 Human Cloning and Moral Status Christopher Alexander Pynes Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES HUMAN CLONING AND MORAL STATUS By CHRISTOPHER ALEXANDER PYNES A Dissertation submitted to the Department of Philosophy in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded: Summer Semester, 2003 Copyright © 2003 Christopher Alexander Pynes All Rights Reserved The members of the Committee approve the dissertation of Christopher Alexander Pynes defended on 19 June 2003. Michael Ruse Professor Directing Dissertation Michael Meredith Outside Committee Member Peter Dalton Committee Member The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee members. To my mother, and for all mothers: past, present, and future. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This dissertation would not have been possible without the guidance of Professors Michael Ruse and Peter Dalton. Michael showed me that getting something written is more important than writing something perfectly; the former is necessary for the latter. Peter Dalton is an exceptional philosopher, and thanks to his guidance I made it through my first few years of graduate school at Florida State. This dissertation has been improved greatly thanks to his thorough comments; I cannot thank him enough, however, the mistakes that remain are all mine. Many people sacrificed so that I could write and finish this dissertation, none more than Darlene Deas. Her loving support throughout the entire dissertation writing process has been nothing less than heroic.
    [Show full text]
  • Backlash in Gender Equality and Women's and Girls' Rights
    STUDY Requested by the FEMM committee Backlash in Gender Equality and Women’s and Girls’ Rights WOMEN’S RIGHTS & GENDER EQUALITY Policy Department for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs Directorate General for Internal Policies of the Union PE 604.955– June 2018 EN Backlash in Gender Equality and Women’s and Girls’ Rights STUDY Abstract This study, commissioned by the European Parliament’s Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs at the request of the FEMM Committee, is designed to identify in which fields and by which means the backlash in gender equality and women’s and girls’ rights in six countries (Austria, Hungary, Italy, Poland, Romania, and Slovakia) is occurring. The backlash, which has been happening over the last several years, has decreased the level of protection of women and girls and reduced access to their rights. ABOUT THE PUBLICATION This research paper was requested by the European Parliament's Committee on Women's Rights and Gender Equality and commissioned, overseen and published by the Policy Department for Citizen's Rights and Constitutional Affairs. Policy Departments provide independent expertise, both in-house and externally, to support European Parliament committees and other parliamentary bodies in shaping legislation and exercising democratic scrutiny over EU external and internal policies. To contact the Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs or to subscribe to its newsletter please write to: [email protected] RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH ADMINISTRATOR Martina SCHONARD Policy Department for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs European Parliament B-1047 Brussels E-mail: [email protected] AUTHORS Borbála JUHÁSZ, indipendent expert to EIGE dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Preventing Unsafe Abortion and Its Consequences Priorities for Research and Action
    Priorities for Action Research and Abortion Preventing and Unsafe its Consequences nsafe abortion is a significant yet preventable cause of maternal mortality and morbidity. The Ugravity and global incidence of unsafe abortion Preventing call for a better understanding of the factors behind the persistence of unsafe abortion and of the barriers to preventing unsafe abortion and managing its conse- Unsafe Abortion quences. This volume brings together the proceedings from an inter-disciplinary consultation to assess the and its global and regional status of unsafe abortion and to identify a research and action agenda to reduce unsafe abortion and its burden on women, their families, and Consequences public health systems. The volume addresses a compre- hensive range of issues related to research on prevent- ing unsafe abortion, outlines regional priorities, and Priorities for identifies critical topics for future research and action on preventing unsafe abortion. Research and Action Iqbal H. Iqbal Shah H. Warriner Ina K. Editors Ina K. Warriner Iqbal H. Shah cover 4.indd 1 31/01/2006 13:34:26 Preventing Unsafe Abortion and its Consequences Priorities for Research and Action Editors Ina K. Warriner Iqbal H. Shah A-Intro.indd 1 09/02/2006 10:44:45 Suggested citation: Warriner IK and Shah IH, eds., Preventing Unsafe Abortion and its Consequences: Priorities for Research and Action, New York: Guttmacher Institute, 2006. 1. Abortion, Induced - adverse effects 2. Abortion, Induced - epidemiology 3. Women’s health services 4. Health priorities
    [Show full text]
  • Exactly Who Are Men Here Waiting For... 135 Upvotes | 10 July, 2020 | by the Purring Jew
    exactly who are men here waiting for... 135 upvotes | 10 July, 2020 | by the_purring_jew ...to start the campaign for "mandatory" paternity testing and paper abortions? where is the lobbying group and the non-profit? why arent you all banding together to propose legislation? or at least some of you? who are you waiting on to do it? Archived from theredarchive.com www.TheRedArchive.com Page 1 of 65 Comments Smoogs2 • 68 points • 10 July, 2020 01:30 PM* I'm not sure it's a matter of waiting for anything? It's just a philosophical framework being used to debate. There is no requirement to do anything if you say... wish humans colonize Mars. That being said.... https://mensrights.com/mandatory-dna-testing/ You also don't have to wait for anything? Here is one of the lobbying groups for mandatory paternity testing from a member of the board of directors of the national organization Fathers & Families. [deleted] 10 July, 2020 01:53 PM* [deleted] rhyth7 • 18 points • 10 July, 2020 04:58 PM People have rallied for less. They're rallying about masks right now. Smoogs2 • 12 points • 10 July, 2020 01:58 PM It doesn't make very much sense to me? It's like asking "what are you waiting for by wanting humans to colonize Mars?" Firstly, you can want humans to go to Mars without doing shit besides shitposting online about the benefits of human space exploration as a philosophical concept and secondly, there are already entities that exist who are pursuing the idea. yasee • 11 points • 10 July, 2020 04:35 PM I don't really agree with the tone of the OP but this rally outside of hospitals and court houses is what activists do.
    [Show full text]
  • The Rational Male Free
    FREE THE RATIONAL MALE PDF Rollo Tomassi | 302 pages | 01 Oct 2013 | Createspace Independent Publishing Platform | 9781492777861 | English | United States The Rational Male - Positive Masculinity by Rollo Tomassi Some of it might end you hating women instead of realizing how they work. However, in this rational male summary, I will only put my thoughts of it at the The Rational Male of the post and highlighted in between. Disclaimer : I still recommend reading the whole book. You might get the message wrong. See it as a glimpse into it or to cement your buying decision. It basically revolves around desire and power dynamics which have been shifted to the feminine in our society. Being a man is not inherently bad. The Rational Male book goes over the reasons why that is. Why women go for jerks, even though they always say differently. It teaches you the necessary information about both sexes and how to navigate the sexual marketplace. Plus, mistakes you have been making in your approach and living with women in general. This term describes a man being obsessed with one woman which a lot of guys seem to have these days. In short: There are almost 4 billion women out there, why do you think only this one will do? And a lot of guys fall into that trap with just a random woman they happen to get into, just because she probably took a few facials, he feels like she is the one. The secret to relationships lies in one simple power dynamic which has been touched by other Authors multiple times: The person with the least interest in the relationship has the power.
    [Show full text]
  • Interpretation of the Problem of Abortion: the Issue of Foetus-Killing in the Light of Traditional and Contemporary Ethics
    INTERPRETATION OF THE PROBLEM OF ABORTION: THE ISSUE OF FOETUS-KILLING IN THE LIGHT OF TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY ETHICS A thesis submitted to Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Tejasha Kalita Roll No. 07614101 Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati Guwahati 781039 January 2013 TH-1177_07614101 TH-1177_07614101 TH-1177_07614101 Dedicated to My Parents and Husband TH-1177_07614101 Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Guwahati 781039 Assam, India Declaration I, hereby, declare that the thesis entitled “ Interpretation of the Problem of Abortion: the Issue of Foetus Killing in the Light of Traditional and Contemporary Ethics ” is the result of investigation carried out by me in the Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, India under the supervision of Dr. Archana Barua. In keeping with the general practice of reporting observations, due acknowledgement has been made wherever the work described is based on the findings of other investigations. Tejasha Kalita January 2013 iv TH-1177_07614101 Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati Department of Humanities & Social Sciences Guwahati - 781 039 (Assam), INDIA Dr. Archana Barua Phone: +91-361-2582552 Professor Fax: +91-361-2582599 E-mail: [email protected] Certificate This is to certify that the thesis entitled “ Interpretation of the Problem of Abortion: the Issue of Foetus Killing in the Light of Traditional and Contemporary Ethics ” submitted by Ms. Tejasha Kalita for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Philosophy in the Department of Humanities and Social Sciences of Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati embodies bonafide record of research work carried out under my supervision and guidance.
    [Show full text]
  • IF MEN HAVE ALL the POWER HOW COME WOMEN MAKE the RULES *And Other Radical Thoughts for Men Who Want More Fairness from Women by JACK KAMMER
    from The author of Good Will Toward Men Instructions for ebook - Use right/left arrow keys to turn pages. - Escape key exits Full Screen mode for access to printing and other options. If Men Have All The This ebook is designed for reading on-screen. It is also available in two Power other forms: - a printer-friendly ebook that fits all 224 pages on 56 How Come Women sheets of paper. - a traditional paperback (makes a great gift). Make the All versions of the book are available at www.RulyMob.com Rules?* 2nd Edition by Jack Kammer If you know a publisher who might like this book, please forward it to him or her with a suggestion to contact the author at PO Box 18236, Halethorpe MD 21227 USA. The next page gives some insight into the difficulty of finding a publisher — and ironically proves the premise of the book. If you would care to send the author a few dollars or if you would like to purchase a paperback please visit RulyMob.com To send the author your comments, please use rulymob.com/commentform.htm “While there’s much truth at the heart of this, I didn’t particularly like the one-liner approach, and the contempt this book would inspire among the women in house would be immense. I’ll let one of my male competitors be the one who gets pummeled.” —Rick Horgan, VP & Executive Editor of Warner Books, Inc. in a letter to the author’s agent concerning the first edition of this book, for which we never could find a publisher March 19, 1998 Also by Jack Kammer Good Will Toward Men, St.
    [Show full text]
  • The Law and Ethics of Abortion BMA Views
    The law and ethics of abortion BMA views September 2020 – post-ARM update British Medical Association bma.org.uk British Medical Association The law and ethics of abortion – BMA views 1 Contents Key points ..............................................................................................................................2 1. About this guidance ......................................................................................................3 1.1 The BMA view on abortion .........................................................................................................3 2. The law on abortion .......................................................................................................4 Map of the law on abortion .......................................................................................................................4 2.1 The law in England, Scotland and Wales ...............................................................................5 2.1.1 24-week time limit ..................................................................................................6 2.1.2 Early medical abortion (EMA) ..............................................................................6 2.1.3 Temporary changes in response to the COVID-19 pandemic ...............7 2.1.4 Abortion for serious fetal abnormality ............................................................7 2.1.5 The requirement for two signatures ................................................................8 2.1.5.1 Pre-signing of forms ......................................................................8
    [Show full text]
  • |||GET||| Girly Man 1St Edition
    GIRLY MAN 1ST EDITION DOWNLOAD FREE Charles Bernstein | 9780226044293 | | | | | Why girls can be boyish but boys can't be girlish My son freely and easily identifies as a boy. This section needs additional citations for verification. They were afraid of everything. He, a scrupulous monitor of fairness in matters large and small, will ask whether there are also things people think girls shouldn't wear. Steele told me this view of pink was mainly "for young girls. Wikimedia Commons Wikiquote. Cut their hair short? While the majority of men are heterosexualsignificant minorities are homosexual or bisexual. Categories : Male Men. Event occurs at This difference in the relative amounts of these sex steroids is largely responsible for the physiological differences that distinguish men from women. Girls who act like boys are moving up the social ladder. Model A describes total separation of male and female roles, while Model B Girly Man 1st edition the complete dissolution of barriers between gender roles. Had second-wave feminists explicitly singled out pink in that way? I, remorsefully, will have to tell him "no. Indeed, Steele told me that as Barbie, the doll, got more "pink and shiny and glittery" over the years, "she also became significantly more infantile looking, with a younger, smilier face. Harvard University Press. Gender discrimination Gender equality Girly Man 1st edition marking in job titles Gender pay gap Hegemonic masculinity Occupational sexism Sexual harassment. In all cultures in the past, and still among traditional and non-Western cultures, getting married is the most common and definitive distinction between boyhood and manhood.
    [Show full text]
  • Abortion, Moral and Religious Aspects
    EthxWeb Search Results Search Detail: Result=("12.3".PC.) AND (@YD >= "20050000") 2=1 : " Documents: 1 ­ 214 of 214 Document 1 Nobis, Nathan Abortion, metaphysics and morality: a review of Francis Beckwith's defending life: a moral and legal case against abortion choice. The Journal of medicine and philosophy 2011 Jun; 36(3): 261­73 Abstract: In Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice (2007) and an earlier article in this journal, "Defending Abortion Philosophically"(2006), Francis Beckwith argues that fetuses are, from conception, prima facie wrong to kill. His arguments are based on what he calls a "metaphysics of the human person" known as "The Substance View." I argue that Beckwith's metaphysics does not support his abortion ethic: Moral, not metaphysical, claims that are part of this Substance View are the foundation of the argument, and Beckwith inadequately defends these moral claims. Thus, Beckwith's arguments do not provide strong support for what he calls the "pro­life" view of abortion. Georgetown users check Georgetown Journal Finder for access to full text Document 2 Foster, Angel M; Dennis, Amanda; Smith, Fiona Do religious restrictions influence ectopic pregnancy management? A national qualitative study. Women's health issues : official publication of the Jacobs Institute of Women's Health 2011 Mar­Apr; 21(2): 104­9 Abstract: In the United States, ectopic pregnancies are relatively common and associated with significant maternal morbidity and mortality. The Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services (the Directives) govern the provision of care in Catholic­affiliated hospitals and prohibit the provision of abortion in almost all circumstances.
    [Show full text]