Maine State Legislature
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MAINE STATE LEGISLATURE The following document is provided by the LAW AND LEGISLATIVE DIGITAL LIBRARY at the Maine State Law and Legislative Reference Library http://legislature.maine.gov/lawlib Reproduced from electronic originals (may include minor formatting differences from printed original) Journal and Legislative Record House of Representatives One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Legislature State of Maine Daily Edition First Regular Session beginning December 5, 2018 pages 1 - JOURNAL AND LEGISLATIVE RECORD - HOUSE, April 23, 2019 Bill "An Act Regarding the Presumption of Abandonment Representative PIERCE: Thank you, Madam Speaker. It of Gift Obligations" is my great honor to welcome the Class A State Championship (H.P. 1164) (L.D. 1612) boys Nordic team to the State House today. I commend them Sponsored by Speaker GIDEON of Freeport. for their dedication to their sport and their commitment to their Cosponsored by Senator LIBBY of Androscoggin and fellow teammates. When you think about Nordic skiing, Representatives: BAILEY of Saco, DILLINGHAM of Oxford, sometimes it can feel like a solace event, I bet, through the HANDY of Lewiston, Senators: CARSON of Cumberland, woods of Maine, but as a group they banded together and won DOW of Lincoln, KEIM of Oxford. the state championship and they will forever have that in their Committee on JUDICIARY suggested and ordered memory. It is great to have them here and I congratulate them printed. on their accomplishments. REFERRED to the Committee on JUDICIARY and Subsequently, this Expression of Legislative Sentiment ordered printed. was PASSED and sent for concurrence. Sent for concurrence. _________________________________ _________________________________ By unanimous consent, all matters having been acted Bill "An Act To Authorize the Use of Autocycles" upon were ORDERED SENT FORTHWITH. (H.P. 1170) (L.D. 1627) _________________________________ Sponsored by Representative BRYANT of Windham. The SPEAKER: Just an announcement from the Chair Cosponsored by Senator MIRAMANT of Knox and as we move into our divided reports for today; a reminder of Representatives: ALLEY of Beals, DUNPHY of Old Town, the rules of decorum on the Floor of the House during debate. HEPLER of Woolwich, HICKMAN of Winthrop, PERKINS of As I anticipate that there may be items in front of us today with Oakland, Senator: President JACKSON of Aroostook. a significant amount of debate, please feel welcome to argue Submitted by the Secretary of State pursuant to Joint Rule your points and policy matters with all of your facts and 204. passion but please also remember not to impugn the character Committee on TRANSPORTATION suggested and of any other Member of the body or to question the motive of ordered printed. any other Member of the body as we do so. And on that note, REFERRED to the Committee on TRANSPORTATION just to let people know in advance that I'll be monitoring that and ordered printed. pretty strictly so do not be surprised if you hear me ask you to Sent for concurrence. defer during the course of debate if we are unable to stick to _________________________________ those rules. And, again, a reminder to please direct comments Bill "An Act To Enact Laws Governing Private Vehicle towards the rostrum rather than towards your fellow Members. Rentals" Your fellow Members are listening, I know, and with that the (H.P. 1167) (L.D. 1615) Chair would point to page 13 of the Calendar, reports of Sponsored by Representative STANLEY of Medway. committees and first reading of accompanying bills and Cosponsored by Representatives: COLLINGS of Portland, resolves, divided report. MAREAN of Hollis. _________________________________ Committee on TRANSPORTATION suggested. REPORTS OF COMMITTEE On motion of Representative McLEAN of Gorham, the Bill Divided Reports was REFERRED to the Committee on HEALTH COVERAGE, Majority Report of the Committee on EDUCATION AND INSURANCE AND FINANCIAL SERVICES, ordered printed CULTURAL AFFAIRS reporting Ought to Pass as Amended and sent for concurrence. by Committee Amendment "A" (H-120) on Bill "An Act To _________________________________ Protect Maine Children and Students from Preventable By unanimous consent, all matters having been acted Diseases by Repealing Certain Exemptions from the Laws upon were ORDERED SENT FORTHWITH. Governing Immunization Requirements" _________________________________ (H.P. 586) (L.D. 798) Signed: SPECIAL SENTIMENT CALENDAR Senators: In accordance with House Rule 519 and Joint Rule 213, MILLETT of Cumberland the following items: CARSON of Cumberland Recognizing: the Falmouth High School Boys Nordic Ski Team, which Representatives: won the Class A State Championship. Members of the team KORNFIELD of Bangor include Ethan Livingood, Nate Livingood, Vance Boyd, Ben BRENNAN of Portland Rooks, Marcus Goodbody, Jake Mitchell, Joe Dye and Charlie DODGE of Belfast Geci; and coaches Kaitlyn Bernard and Ian Tovell. We extend FARNSWORTH of Portland our congratulations and best wishes; INGWERSEN of Arundel (HLS 282) McCREA of Fort Fairfield Presented by Representative PIERCE of Falmouth. Cosponsored by Senator BREEN of Cumberland, Minority Report of the same Committee reporting Ought Representative CROCKETT of Portland. Not to Pass on same Bill. On OBJECTION of Representative PIERCE of Falmouth, Signed: was REMOVED from the Special Sentiment Calendar. Senator: READ. POULIOT of Kennebec The SPEAKER: The Chair recognizes the Representative from Falmouth, Representative Pierce. H-392 JOURNAL AND LEGISLATIVE RECORD - HOUSE, April 23, 2019 Representatives: The other issue we need to be thinking about is the DRINKWATER of Milford psychological impact. Maine is at the top nationally with a FECTEAU of Augusta mental health crisis in our schools currently. So now we are RUDNICKI of Fairfield entertaining legislation that could potentially expel 6,000 SAMPSON of Alfred children, give or take a few thousand. How is that going to help our mental health crisis? Let's think about the fact that we READ. are in a death spiral as a state. We need more people coming Representative KORNFIELD of Bangor moved that the to this state. Yet young families who are looking at where they House ACCEPT the Majority Ought to Pass as Amended could go to have their families, they look at all these sorts of Report. information -- this sort of information, along with a lot of other The SPEAKER: The Chair recognizes the things, and I know personally in my district I have run into - just Representative from Alfred, Representative Sampson. knocking on doors - five different families who have just moved Representative SAMPSON: Thank you, Madam Speaker here because, when I asked them, because of the freedoms and Ladies and Gentlemen of the House. So, as we launch you have in this state. These are young people transplanted into this debate, I would like to ask this question; what is the from California and other states. This is going to slam the door problem we are trying to fix with this piece of legislation and shut on that because they're not going to be interested in this. how does this bill actually fix it? We are actually targeting 5% What about the fiscal impact? And I'd like to draw your of our population and specifically our little people, K-12. And attention to the yellow paper on your desk of the potential fiscal these are individuals who have been previously identified impact that it will have on this -- on our schools, and this is just because they have chosen not to consent to vaccinations. K-12, this isn't talking about the universities, this isn't talking However, we need to specify what we are talking about here. about the healthcare professionals that are going to be This 5%, according to the CDC, and during the hearing we impacted. This is talking about just K-12, students that may heard a number of physicians and the CDC themselves agree not be coming to our schools, and if you understand anything that this 5% makes up the following, and I think we need to about per pupil allocation, this is something you could take into understand this as we are deliberating this. First of all, they consideration. So somewhere between zero dollars, which is can be the fully vaccinated except they're missing one booster; basically what the fiscal note to this bill states, that this is going does that mean they're unvaccinated? They could be fully to have insignificant impact, up to maybe $80 million impact. vaccinated but opting out of one vaccination, for example the So we need to take that into consideration and you can look at chickenpox varicella; does that mean they're unvaccinated? your own towns in your district that would be impacted and the They could be on a delayed schedule; does that mean they're number of children. These are the 5% that I already talked unvaccinated? And then there's the smaller component of about. parents that have signed off on the religious or philosophical Finally, I'd like to just mention that there are many, many exemption, like I did, because I was too lazy and I didn't want issues here that we should be considering before we issue this to spend the money to go see the doctor to get the updated kind of legislation. We have not done our due diligence. We vaccination record, and because it is in law that we can check don't know the specifics about these 5%. For all we know, we that off, I checked that off and enrolled my child in could have 98% compliance in this state; we don't know and kindergarten. So, those people, we don't even know how we haven’t bothered to stop and think about how can we find many of them actually have vaccinations. that information out? I actually submitted legislation to So what I would challenge folks here, is that we are entertain this but it was rejected.