LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEEN CITY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 21st November 2017 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 1, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 1101/51610 RETAIL WAREHOUSE POUNDSTRETCHER LTD T 134,000 134,000 390 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

2 1136/51614 STAFF ACCOMMODATION ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 33,000 33,000 80 WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

3 36758/52073 POLICE STATION SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY P 27,000 27,000 CONINGHAM TERRACE FINANCE DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

4 33005/52048 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 37,000 37,000 FORMARTINE ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

5 1150/51611 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 6,500 6,500 95 HAYTON ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

6 88473/51612 RESTAURANT CRAIGTON FOODS LTD T 120,000 120,000 KITTYBREWSTER RETAIL PARK BEDFORD ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

7 1242/51613 WAREHOUSE THORNBRIDGE SAWMILLS LTD O 56,500 56,500 15 ST MACHAR DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

8 1299/52258 WORKSHOP ETC BT PLC P 156,000 156,000 FROGHALL TERRACE C/O TELEREAL SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

9 1421/52040 FACTORY HALL & TAWSE JOINERY LTD P 283,000 283,000 GRANITEHILL ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A

10 1476/52178 OFFICES ETC ENERMECH LIMITED P 525,000 525,000 ENERMECH HOUSE HOWES ROAD ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

11 1489/52036 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 34,500 34,500 SPEY ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

12 38304/52042 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL T 2,500 2,500 8 BACK HILTON ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

13 1598/51615 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 20,750 20,750 UNIT 15 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 15 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

27/06/2017 Page 1 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 1660/52026 DEPOT ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 467,000 467,000 38 POWIS TERRACE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

15 1697/52033 OFFICES ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 119,000 119,000 OLD ABERDEEN HOUSE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM DUNBAR STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

16 1726/51609 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 7,500 7,500 2 SEATON DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

17 34397/52049 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 38,000 38,000 GREENFERN ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

18 1882/51602 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD T 111,000 111,000 WHITEMYRES AVENUE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

19 1887/52028 OFFICE ROBERTSON CONSTRUCTION EASTERN LTD T 27,750 27,750 1ST FLOOR WHITEMYRES BUSINESS CENTRE WHITEMYRES AVENUE GVA A ABERDEEN

20 39136/52027 OFFICES ROBERTSON FACILITIES MANAGEMENT T 14,500 14,500 GROUND FLOOR WHITEMYRES BUSINESS CENTRE WHITEMYRES AVENUE GVA A ABERDEEN

21 1888/51601 WORKSHOP ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 41,000 41,000 WHITEMYRES AVENUE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

22 1895/52141 WORKSHOPS ETC DINGBRO LTD P 221,000 221,000 WHITEMYRES AVENUE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

23 1904/51603 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 222,000 222,000 WHITEMYRES PLACE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

24 34646/51753 SUPERSTORE ALDI STORES LTD P 233,000 233,000 FORRESTERHILL ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A

25 41661/52016 OFFICE ETC NHS EDUCATION FOR SCOTLAND T 192,000 192,000 1ST FLOOR (PART) FOREST GROVE HOUSE FORRESTERHILL ROAD GVA A ABERDEEN

26 2014/52237 OFFICES THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 2,570,000 2,570,000 WOODHILL HOUSE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES WESTBURN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

27 36859/52240 HOTEL PREMIER TRAVEL INN LTD T 135,000 135,000 THE COCKET HAT PER GERALD EVE NORTH ANDERSON DRIVE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 2 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 54177/52186 PUBLIC HOUSE ETC MITCHELLS & BUTLERS P 85,000 85,000 THE COCKET HAT PER ESTATE MANAGER NORTH ANDERSON DRIVE PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

29 2045/51599 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 8,700 8,700 113 ROUSAY DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

30 34923/52172 HOTEL CAIRN HOTEL GROUP P 100,000 100,000 SUMMERHILL HOTEL AND SCOTT'S BAR THE LANG STRACHT ABERDEEN GVA A

31 2099/51597 HOTEL THE FIRM OF P 160,000 160,000 ATHOLL HOTEL ATHOLL HOTEL ABERDEEN 54 KING'S GATE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

32 39117/52131 OFFICE ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING T 25,750 25,750 SUITE 1 BELGRAVE HOUSE 7 BELGRAVE TERRACE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

33 34517/52144 OFFICE ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING LTD T 18,750 18,750 SUITE 2 T/A SOURCE PROPERTY SERVICES BELGRAVE HOUSE 7 BELGRAVE TERRACE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

34 84938/52072 OFFICE SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY T 14,500 14,500 ROSEMOUNT POLICE OFFICE FINANCE DEPARTMENT BELGRAVE TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

35 2227/52108 SHOP ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING P 25,250 25,250 138 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

36 2267/52126 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY ABACUS PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY T 26,750 26,750 VIEW HOUSE 2A VIEW TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

37 2311/52074 OFFICE PETREX DEVELOPMENTS LTD T 28,250 28,250 41 ALBERT STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

38 2341/52275 OFFICE CBRE LTD T 52,000 52,000 1ST FLOOR 1 ALBYN TERRACE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

39 31957/52160 OFFICE HALLIDAY FRASER MUNRO O 169,000 169,000 6 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

40 2402/52154 OFFICE MACKINNONS T 93,000 93,000 14 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

41 2415/52204 OFFICE GRAHAM & SIBBALD T 27,250 27,250 21 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

27/06/2017 Page 3 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

42 2449/51975 OFFICE CONCEPT GROUP LTD P 50,500 50,500 66 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN GVA A

43 58623/51977 OFFICE ERNST & YOUNG T 335,000 335,000 GROUND FLOOR BLENHEIM HOUSE FOUNTAINHALL ROAD GVA A ABERDEEN

44 2499/52263 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY NURSERIES DIRECT LTD P 25,500 25,500 65 OSBORNE PLACE ABERDEEN BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A

45 31647/51465 OFFICE SENERGY (GB) LTD T 325,000 325,000 2-3 QUEEN'S TERRACE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

46 38642/52106 OFFICE HALL MORRICE LLP T 125,000 125,000 6 QUEEN'S TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

47 2518/51561 OFFICE ABERDEEN ASSET MANAGEMENT PLC P 155,000 155,000 9-10 QUEEN'S TERRACE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

48 2566/52098 OFFICE SKIBO TECHNOLOGIES LTD T 35,750 35,750 5 RUBISLAW PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

49 2586/52012 OFFICE THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 61,500 61,500 9 RUBISLAW TERRACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A

50 34580/52183 OFFICE DRUM PROPERTY GROUP LTD T 17,250 17,250 12 RUBISLAW TERRACE LANE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

51 2670/51558 CAFE STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 32,500 32,500 496 UNION STREET C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

52 2697/52209 OFFICE ETC LAURIE AND COMPANY T 46,000 46,000 17 VICTORIA STREET SOLICITORS LLP ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

53 2747/52010 OFFICE THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 380,000 380,000 1 ALBYN PLACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A

54 2770/51661 OFFICE RYDEN T 81,000 81,000 25 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

55 33748/52227 OFFICES BG GROUP LTD T 359,000 359,000 26 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 4 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 2772/52229 OFFICE BG GROUP LTD T 220,000 220,000 27 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

57 2773/51476 OFFICE CARLTON ROCK LTD P 316,000 316,000 28 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

58 2773/52230 OFFICE BG GROUP LTD T 316,000 316,000 28 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

59 33954/51474 OFFICE STRONACHS LLP T 115,000 115,000 33 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

60 2780/51475 OFFICE STRONACHS LLP T 194,000 194,000 34 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

61 2785/52002 OFFICE K P M G T 361,000 361,000 37 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GVA A

62 2789/51717 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 150,000 150,000 40 ALBYN PLACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A

63 33084/51498 OFFICE A B ROBB LTD T 18,000 18,000 10B QUEEN'S GARDENS ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

64 39107/52243 OFFICE PINSENT MASONS LLP T 316,000 316,000 13 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A

65 2904/52283 HOTEL MALMAISON ABERDEEN LTD T 480,000 480,000 MALMAISON 49 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

66 2910/52218 OFFICE MILLSTREAM ASSOCIATES LTD P 121,000 121,000 10 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

67 33321/51484 OFFICE CRAIG GROUP LTD T 116,000 116,000 12 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

68 73463/51478 OFFICE CARLTON ROCK LTD P 237,000 237,000 20 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

69 2925/51485 OFFICE RSM CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS T 52,500 52,500 52 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

27/06/2017 Page 5 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

70 2927/51477 OFFICE HELLISTER LTD P 44,250 44,250 54 QUEEN'S ROAD PER AB ROBB LTD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

71 2931/52410 OFFICE ARTHUR J GALLAGHER INSURANCE T 20,250 20,250 1ST FLOOR BROKERS LTD 56 QUEEN'S ROAD C/O GERALD EVE LLP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

72 2932/52195 OFFICE ARTHUR J GALLAGHER INSURANCE T 17,750 17,750 2ND FLOOR BROKERS LTD 56 QUEEN'S ROAD C/O GERALD EVE LLP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

73 48360/52020 OFFICE MACLAY MURRAY & SPENS LLP T 102,000 102,000 66 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A

74 2942/52256 OFFICE 3I PLC P 207,000 207,000 GROUND FLOOR 70 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

75 2948/51598 OFFICE ETC FAIRHURST P 81,500 81,500 88 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

76 2951/52159 OFFICE OPTIMUS (ABERDEEN) LTD O 190,000 190,000 GORDON HOUSE 27 RUBISLAW DEN NORTH ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

77 33002/52124 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY ABACUS PRE SCHOOL NURSERY P 23,700 A 23,700 416 KING STREET 6,200 R 6,200 ABERDEEN 17,500 N 17,500 RYDEN LLP A

78 48664/52093 OFFICE PETROFAC TRAINING LTD O 22,000 22,000 1ST FLOOR (PART) MARINE HOUSE BLAIKIE'S QUAY CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

79 53063/52089 OFFICE PETROFAC TRAINING LTD O 2,300 2,300 1ST FLOOR MARINE HOUSE BLAIKIE'S QUAY CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

80 49623/52039 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL T 2,590,000 2,590,000 MARISCHAL COLLEGE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM BROAD STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

81 3333/52043 TOWN HOUSE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 608,000 608,000 CASTLE STREET PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

82 81264/51564 GAMING CLUB GROSVENOR CASINOS LIMITED T 283,000 283,000 G CASINO 5 EXCHEQUER ROW ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

83 83312/52034 OFFICES ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 244,000 244,000 FREDERICK STREET CENTRE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM FREDERICK STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 6 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

84 3479/52009 OFFICE TRILLIUM (PRIME) LTD T 645,000 645,000 GREYFRIARS HOUSE GALLOWGATE ABERDEEN GVA A

85 38615/52041 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 20,000 20,000 SUITE 1 (PART) PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ARCHIBALD SIMPSON HOUSE 27 KING STREET RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

86 33149/52045 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 67,500 67,500 SUITE 2 PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ARCHIBALD SIMPSON HOUSE 27 KING STREET RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

87 38224/52047 OFFICES ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 16,250 16,250 SUITE 6-8 PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ARCHIBALD SIMPSON HOUSE 27 KING STREET RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

88 3588/52070 BINGO HALL GALA LEISURE LTD P 167,000 167,000 KINGSWAY 106 KING STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

89 76503/51751 SUPERMARKET ALDI STORES LTD T 260,000 260,000 UNIT 9-10 BEACH BOULEVARD RETAIL PARK LINKS ROAD GVA A ABERDEEN

90 80741/52148 OFFICE TEAM MARINE T 32,750 32,750 NORTH ESPLANADE EAST ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

91 3795/52068 HEADQUARTERS SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY P 650,000 650,000 QUEEN STREET FINANCE DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

92 3852/51444 OFFICE DET NORSKE VERITAS T 245,000 245,000 CROMARTY HOUSE INDUSTRY HOLDINGS LTD 67 REGENT QUAY ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

93 4026/51565 CAR PARK NATIONAL CAR PARKS LTD T 131,000 131,000 SHIPROW ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

94 83804/51566 HOTEL ACCOR UK ECONOMY HOTELS LIMITED T 265,000 265,000 IBIS HOTEL 15 SHIPROW ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

95 3976/51563 SHOP POUNDSTRETCHER PROPERTIES LIMITED T 64,500 64,500 43 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

96 86487/51722 BETTING OFFICE PADDY POWER BOOKMAKERS T 32,500 32,500 53 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

97 83342/52171 OFFICE MAERSK FPSOS UK LTD T 107,000 107,000 3RD FLOOR CITY WHARF SHIPROW CLUTTONS LLP A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 7 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

98 85267/52099 OFFICE PETERSON SBS LTD T 74,500 74,500 2ND FLOOR PROVENDER HOUSE 37 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

99 38577/52104 OFFICE PETERSON SBS LTD T 22,750 22,750 GROUND FLOOR (SUITE 2) THE COURTYARD CLARENCE STREET RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

100 4050/52100 OFFICE PETERSONS SBS T 11,250 11,250 2ND FLOOR (SUITE 1) NAUTILUS HOUSE 35 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

101 47891/52102 OFFICE PETERSON SBS LTD T 15,250 15,250 2ND FLOOR (SUITE 3) NAUTILUS HOUSE 35 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

102 48978/52101 OFFICE PETERSON (UK) LTD T 11,250 11,250 2ND FLOOR (SUITE 2) PER LINSEY MACMILLAN NAUTILUS HOUSE 35 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

103 4055/52105 OFFICES PETERSON (UK) LTD T 40,250 40,250 3RD FLOOR PER LINSEY MACMILLAN NAUTILUS HOUSE 35 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

104 35475/51660 OFFICE EUROLINE SHIPPING CO LTD T 26,250 26,250 DOCK GATES HOUSE WATERLOO QUAY ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

105 87854/52078 OFFICE DOF SUBSEA T 258,000 258,000 2ND FLOOR HORIZONS HOUSE 81 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

106 87851/52080 OFFICE DOF SUBSEA T 244,000 244,000 3RD FLOOR HORIZONS HOUSE 81 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

107 87852/52107 OFFICE DOF SUBSEA T 185,000 185,000 4TH FLOOR HORIZONS HOUSE 81 WATERLOO QUAY RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

108 4109/51766 SITE & TANKS OMYA UK LTD T 53,500 53,500 WATERLOO STATION ABERDEEN GVA A

109 4144/52284 HOTEL PREMIER TRAVEL INN LTD P 440,000 440,000 INVERLAIR HOUSE PER GERALD EVE 10 WEST NORTH STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

110 4189/51623 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 75,000 75,000 2 CANAL ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

111 34976/52052 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 11,250 11,250 84 SPRING GARDEN PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 8 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

112 33032/52032 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 93,000 93,000 74 SPRING GARDEN PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

113 4603/51682 OFFICE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR DEFENCE P 41,500 41,500 63 BELMONT STREET DE OPERATIONS NORTH ABERDEEN GVA A

114 31517/52200 OFFICE REGUS BUSINESS CENTRES (UK) LTD T 446,000 446,000 REGUS HOUSE PER DRON & WRIGHT 1 BERRY STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

115 31130/52169 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 125,000 125,000 UNIT 3 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A

116 31135/52146 SHOP CHISHOLM & HUNTER T 144,000 144,000 UNIT 6 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

117 31816/51621 SHOP KURT GEIGER T 120,000 120,000 UNIT 11 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

118 31247/51746 SHOP RIVER ISLAND CLOTHING CO LTD T 330,000 330,000 UNIT 19B BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GVA A

119 31157/51618 SHOP MENKIND STORES LTD T 51,000 51,000 UNIT 35 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

120 84032/51620 RESTAURANT DI MAGGIO'S FOODCOURT LTD T 77,500 77,500 FOOD UNIT 1 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

121 84034/51619 RESTAURANT ED'S EASY DINER GROUP LTD T 57,000 57,000 FOOD UNIT 3 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

122 4631/52198 HOTEL TRAVELODGE HOTELS LTD T 210,000 210,000 TRAVELODGE PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL 9 BRIDGE STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

123 4980/52272 OFFICE SOCIAL CARE AND SOCIAL WORK T 220,000 220,000 GROUND FLOOR WING A IMPROVEMENT SCOTLAND AB1 (CARE INSPECTORATE) CRIMON PLACE GVA A ABERDEEN

124 87756/52008 OFFICE THE LORD ADVOCATE T 202,000 202,000 1ST FLOOR WING B AB1 CRIMON PLACE GVA A ABERDEEN

125 4800/52277 OFFICE INGEN-IDEAS LTD T 45,500 45,500 GROUND FLOOR 111 GALLOWGATE ABERDEEN GVA A

27/06/2017 Page 9 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

126 4807/51549 SHOP ETC L'OCCITANE LTD T 37,750 37,750 1-5 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

127 4808/52257 OFFICE SANTANDER UK PLC P 83,500 83,500 93 GEORGE STREET C/O CB RICHARD ELLIS ABERDEEN FAO AP RATES TEAM COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

128 4835/51616 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 21,750 21,750 178 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

129 4880/51683 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 135,000 135,000 12 GOLDEN SQUARE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A

130 4915/51581 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 11,000 11,000 24 GUILD STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

131 4916/52262 OFFICES MAPELEY STEPS LIMITED T 197,000 197,000 1ST FLOOR (PART) C/O MAPELEY ESTATES LTD CUSTOM HOUSE 28 GUILD STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

132 4787/52121 OFFICE PIPMATO LTD P 18,750 18,750 2 IMPERIAL PLACE PER PETERKINS ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

133 33392/51568 OFFICE IN SHOPS CENTRES PLC T 300,000 300,000 MANAGERS OFFICE UNIT 18 ABERDEEN MARKET MONTAGU EVANS A MARKET STREET

134 54497/51567 SHOP IN SHOPS CENTRES PLC T 44,000 44,000 LOWER FLOOR ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET MONTAGU EVANS A

135 48135/52122 OFFICE ETC PIPMATO LTD P 50,000 50,000 10 NORTH SILVER STREET PER PETERKINS ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

136 5144/52123 OFFICE PIPMATO LTD P 15,250 15,250 GROUND FLOOR PER PETERKINS 12 NORTH SILVER STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

137 5145/52119 OFFICE PIPMATO LTD P 15,750 15,750 1ST FLOOR PER PETERKINS 12 NORTH SILVER STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

138 5146/52120 OFFICE PIPMATO LTD P 10,000 10,000 2ND FLOOR PER PETERKINS 12 NORTH SILVER STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

139 5168/51559 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 32,250 32,250 14 ROSE STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

27/06/2017 Page 10 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

140 33242/52140 SHOP PLENDERLEATH RUNCIE LLP T 40,750 40,750 ANDERSON HOUSE ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

141 5172/52157 OFFICE LEDINGHAM CHALMERS LLP T 404,000 404,000 GROUND A JOHNSTONE HOUSE 50 ROSE STREET RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

142 48870/51974 OFFICE THE CARE INSPECTORATE T 204,000 204,000 1ST FLOOR A JOHNSTONE HOUSE 50 ROSE STREET GVA A ABERDEEN

143 5174/51560 OFFICE FRP ADVISORY LLP T 37,250 37,250 2ND FLOOR B JOHNSTONE HOUSE 50 ROSE STREET MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

144 5229/51985 OFFICE HMRC T 297,000 297,000 RUBY HOUSE ESTATES & SUPPORT SERVICES 8 RUBY PLACE ABERDEEN GVA A

145 5229/52253 OFFICE HMRC T 297,000 297,000 RUBY HOUSE ESTATES & SUPPORT SERVICES 8 RUBY PLACE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

146 38233/51622 SHOP BRIDAL FASHIONS LTD T 20,500 20,500 UNIT 8 T/A BERKETEX BRIDE 32 ST ANDREW STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

147 40572/51550 SHOP STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 68,000 68,000 UNIT W9B C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

148 83747/51551 SHOP H & M HENNES & MAURITZ (UK) LTD T 322,000 322,000 UNIT E6 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

149 5280/51656 HAIRDRESSING SALON FEDERICO BERTON & KERRY BERTON T 35,500 35,500 4 SCHOOLHILL T/A ISPIRO ABERDEEN

150 5346/51553 GAMING CLUB GALA CASINOS LTD P 90,000 90,000 GALA CASINO 61 SUMMER STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

151 33750/52242 OFFICE ARTHUR J GALLACHER INSURANCE T 34,750 34,750 11 THISTLE STREET BROKERS LTD ABERDEEN C/O GERALD EVE LLP GERALD EVE LLP A

152 5374/52305 OFFICE M7 REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT PARTNERS P 865,000 865,000 GRAMPIAN HOUSE V PROPCO LTD UNION ROW ABERDEEN

153 81087/51562 OFFICE ABERDEEN ASSET MANAGEMENT PLC T 400,000 400,000 4TH FLOOR UNION PLAZA 1 UNION WYND MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 11 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

154 81091/51555 OFFICE ABERDEEN ASSET MANAGEMENT PLC T 178,000 178,000 5TH FLOOR NORTH UNION PLAZA 1 UNION WYND MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

155 86737/51554 CAR SPACES ABERDEEN ASSET MANAGEMENT PLC T 16,000 16,000 (16 SPACES) UNION PLAZA 1 UNION WYND MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

156 81088/52179 OFFICE BURNESS PAULL LLP T 600,000 600,000 5TH FLOOR SOUTH UNION PLAZA 1 UNION WYND CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

157 31640/51576 RESTAURANT CRAIGTON FOODS LTD T 194,000 194,000 117 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

158 5475/51548 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 46,000 46,000 50 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

159 5484/51720 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 180,000 180,000 78 UNION STREET PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A

160 33082/52168 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 56,500 56,500 98 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A

161 5489/51479 OFFICES ETC PETERKINS P 153,000 153,000 100 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

162 5541/51552 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 45,500 45,500 198 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

163 5548/51556 CAFE STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 42,000 42,000 208 UNION STREET C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

164 5561/51976 OFFICE DIGBY BROWN SOLICITORS T 41,000 41,000 GROUND FLOOR 220 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

165 5584/51557 SHOP SAVE THE CHILDREN UK T 17,250 17,250 252A UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

166 5595/52278 BANK NATWEST GROUP PROPERTY P 109,000 109,000 262 UNION STREET PER DTZ ABERDEEN GVA A

167 5612/52247 OFFICE ROPETUNE LTD P 65,000 65,000 4 UNION TERRACE PER RYDEN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 12 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

168 33910/52194 OFFICE ROPETUNE LTD P 51,500 51,500 1ST FLOOR PER RYDEN 5 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

169 5613/52134 OFFICE ROPETUNE LTD P 53,000 53,000 2ND FLOOR PER RYDEN 5 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

170 5614/52135 OFFICE ROPETUNE LTD P 53,000 53,000 3RD FLOOR PER RYDEN 5 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

171 5615/52136 OFFICE ROPETUNE LTD P 52,500 52,500 4TH FLOOR PER RYDEN 5 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

172 5615/52246 OFFICE HAYS PLC T 52,500 52,500 4TH FLOOR 5 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

173 5616/52137 OFFICE ROPETUNE LTD P 39,500 39,500 5TH FLOOR PER RYDEN 5 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

174 35065/51466 OFFICES LLOYDS REGISTER EMEA O 617,000 617,000 DENBURN HOUSE GLOBAL PROCUREMENT & ESTATES 20 UNION TERRACE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

175 5655/51547 CAFE STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 38,000 38,000 2-4 UPPERKIRKGATE C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

176 5682/51462 OFFICE CONOCOPHILLIPS (UK) LTD T 2,270,000 2,270,000 RUBISLAW HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

177 36206/52207 OFFICE CONOCOPHILLIPS (UK) LTD T 186,000 186,000 GROUND FLOOR (PART) ROYFOLD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A ABERDEEN

178 53953/52206 OFFICE CONOCOPHILLIPS (UK) LTD T 335,000 335,000 1ST FLOOR ROYFOLD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A ABERDEEN

179 39291/52094 OFFICE CHEVRON NORTH SEA LTD T 3,730,000 3,730,000 SUITE C PER GERALD EVE LLP SEAFIELD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A ABERDEEN

180 39291/52095 OFFICE CHEVRON NORTH SEA LTD T 111,000 111,000 SUITE C PER GERALD EVE LLP SEAFIELD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A ABERDEEN

181 82929/52096 OFFICES CHEVRON NORTH SEA LTD T 313,000 313,000 SUITE A & SUITE D PER GERALD EVE LLP SEAFIELD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 13 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

182 83671/52225 OFFICE SHELL PROPERTY CO LTD T 960,000 960,000 2ND FLOOR PER GRAHAM PIRIE SEAFIELD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

183 88812/52087 OFFICE CHEVRON NORTH SEA LTD T 90,000 90,000 PART SUITE D PER GERALD EVE LLP SEAFIELD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A ABERDEEN

184 88813/52086 OFFICE CHEVRON NORTH SEA LTD T 1,240,000 1,240,000 1ST FLOOR PER GERALD EVE LLP SEAFIELD HOUSE ANDERSON DRIVE CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A ABERDEEN

185 88815/52088 OFFICE CHEVRON NORTH SEA LTD T 2,340,000 2,340,000 CHEVRON HOUSE PER GERALD EVE LLP ANDERSON DRIVE ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

186 53992/52125 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY ABACUS PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY T 22,750 22,750 GATE HOUSE WEST LODGE, WOODEND QUEEN'S ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

187 5719/52162 RESEARCH CENTRE THE JAMES HUTTON INSTITUTE P 810,000 810,000 THE JAMES HUTTON INSTITUTE COUNTESSWELLS ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

188 70363/51499 GUEST ACCOMMODATION MANORISMS LLP P 63,000 63,000 100 KEPPLESTONE MANOR QUEEN'S HIGHLANDS ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

189 5752/52271 HOTEL G1 GROUP PLC P 121,000 121,000 THE PALM COURT 81 SEAFIELD ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

190 5881/52190 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY CYNTHIA T BLACK P 32,000 32,000 356 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A

191 6134/51463 OFFICE ETC SENERGY HOLDINGS LTD P 59,000 59,000 7 BON-ACCORD SQUARE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

192 6136/52212 OFFICE DONALD MACFARLANE & GRAHAM LAING P 9,500 9,500 BASEMENT T/A G I PROPERTIES 13 BON-ACCORD SQUARE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

193 6137/52215 OFFICE DONALD MACFARLANE & GRAHAM LAING P 47,000 47,000 GROUND FLOOR REAR T/A G I PROPERTIES 13 BON-ACCORD SQUARE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

194 6138/52213 OFFICE DONALD MACFARLANE & GRAHAM LAING P 16,500 16,500 1ST FLOOR T/A G I PROPERTIES 13 BON-ACCORD SQUARE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

195 6139/52214 OFFICE DONALD MACFARLANE & GRAHAM LAING P 13,500 13,500 2ND FLOOR T/A G I PROPERTIES 13 BON-ACCORD SQUARE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

27/06/2017 Page 14 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

196 6197/51480 OFFICE JAMES & GEORGE COLLIE T 105,000 105,000 1-7 EAST CRAIBSTONE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

197 83058/52285 HOTEL HAZLEDENE STRAWBERRYBANK P 485,000 485,000 PARK INN ABERDEEN (HOTEL) LTD 1 JUSTICE MILL LANE T/A PARK INN ABERDEEN ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

198 83954/51678 OFFICE CENTRICA PLC T 1,300,000 1,300,000 3RD FLOOR IQ BUILDING 15 JUSTICE MILL LANE GVA A ABERDEEN

199 48719/52199 HOTEL TRAVELODGE HOTELS LTD T 280,000 280,000 TRAVELODGE PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL 21 JUSTICE MILL LANE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

200 6429/52014 OFFICE SCOTTISH LEGAL AID BOARD T 12,250 12,250 353 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

201 6444/51750 SHOP SKILLS DEVELOPMENT SCOTLAND T 62,500 62,500 383 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

202 31217/51578 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 30,000 30,000 469 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

203 6494/51657 OFFICE WILLIAMSON & DUNN P 47,250 47,250 3 WEST CRAIBSTONE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

204 87208/51579 RESTAURANT AMARONE RESTAURANTS LTD T 70,000 70,000 CAFE ANDALUZ 5 BON-ACCORD STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

205 6604/52255 OFFICE BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PLC T 265,000 265,000 NEW TELECOM HOUSE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL 73 COLLEGE STREET RATING UK LLP ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

206 52804/52245 OFFICE WOOD GROUP PSN LTD O 160,000 160,000 6TH FLOOR PER GAYLE LESLIE NEW TELECOM HOUSE 73 COLLEGE STREET CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

207 52804/52254 OFFICE BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PLC T 160,000 160,000 6TH FLOOR COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL NEW TELECOM HOUSE RATING UK LLP 73 COLLEGE STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

208 86989/52261 OFFICE BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PLC T 160,000 160,000 4TH FLOOR COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL NEW TELECOM HOUSE RATING UK LLP 73 COLLEGE STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

209 87915/52259 OFFICE B P EXPLORATION OPERATING CO LTD O 80,000 80,000 2ND FLOOR F A O GPM & S DEPT NEW TELECOM HOUSE 73 COLLEGE STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 15 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

210 87917/52252 OFFICE B P EXPLORATION OPERATING CO LTD O 80,000 80,000 3RD FLOOR F A O GPM & S DEPT NEW TELECOM HOUSE 73 COLLEGE STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

211 82418/52251 OFFICE B P EXPLORATION OPERATING CO LTD O 80,000 80,000 8TH FLOOR F A O GPM & S DEPT NEW TELECOM HOUSE 73 COLLEGE STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

212 6813/52219 OFFICE CNR INTERNATIONAL (UK) LTD T 1,220,000 1,220,000 ST MAGNUS HOUSE 21 GUILD STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

213 79403/51580 BUS STATION STAGECOACH SCOTLAND LTD T 108,000 108,000 UNION SQUARE GUILD STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

214 81939/51573 HOTEL JURYS INNS GROUP LTD T 665,000 665,000 JURYS INN UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

215 55643/52015 OFFICE SCOTTISH CHILDREN'S REPORTER T 111,000 111,000 GROUND ADMINISTRATION THE EXCHANGE NO 2 PER HEAD OF PROPERTY MARKET STREET GVA A ABERDEEN

216 80886/52310 OFFICE ODS PETRODATA LTD T 164,000 164,000 2ND FLOOR THE EXCHANGE NO 1 MARKET STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

217 50786/52177 OFFICE NOBLE DENTON CONSULTANTS LTD T 161,000 161,000 5TH FLOOR THE EXCHANGE NO 1 MARKET STREET CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

218 39195/52092 OFFICES PETROFAC FACILITIES MANAGEMENT T 1,800,000 1,800,000 3RD FLOOR BRIDGE VIEW NORTH ESPLANADE WEST CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

219 50132/51680 OFFICES NHS NATIONAL SERVICES SCOTLAND T 291,000 291,000 1ST FLOOR (PART) BRIDGE VIEW NORTH ESPLANADE WEST GVA A ABERDEEN

220 88500/52147 OFFICE PD & MS ENERGY (ABERDEEN) LTD T 790,000 790,000 GF - 5TH FLOOR ARDENT WEST NORTH ESPLANADE WEST RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

221 82012/52211 OFFICES FRONTICA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LTD T 530,000 530,000 FREEDOM HOUSE OLD FORD ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

222 87503/52216 OFFICE ENQUEST HEATHER LTD T 1,230,000 1,230,000 GF, 4TH PART,5-7TH FLOOR ANNAN HOUSE 33 PALMERSTON ROAD F G BURNETT LTD A ABERDEEN

223 87512/51932 OFFICE AMEC FOSTER WHEELER GROUP O 790,000 790,000 3RD FLOOR ANNAN HOUSE 33 PALMERSTON ROAD GVA A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 16 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

224 87510/52270 OFFICE ENQUEST HEATHER LTD T 83,500 83,500 4TH FLOOR PART ANNAN HOUSE 33 PALMERSTON ROAD F G BURNETT LTD A ABERDEEN

225 48507/52201 OFFICE REGUS G T 400,000 400,000 LEVEL 3 C/O DRON & WRIGHT RIVERSIDE HOUSE RIVERSIDE DRIVE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

226 50071/52202 OFFICE REGUS G T 196,000 196,000 LEVEL 5 C/O DRON & WRIGHT RIVERSIDE HOUSE RIVERSIDE DRIVE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

227 43973/52210 OFFICE ALERT INVESTMENTS LTD P 45,500 45,500 1ST FLOOR BON ACCORD HOUSE RIVERSIDE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

228 83270/52184 OFFICE PETROFAC FACILITIES MANAGEMENT LTD T 550,000 550,000 3RD & PART 4TH FLOOR CONSORT HOUSE STELL ROAD CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

229 82079/51737 SHOP RIVER ISLAND CLOTHING CO LTD T 169,000 169,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GVA A

230 82086/51747 SHOP ROX (UK) LIMITED T 67,000 67,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GVA A

231 83611/52170 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 84,000 84,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A

232 82088/51569 SHOP H & M HENNES & MAURITZ (UK) LTD T 255,000 255,000 20 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

233 82103/51571 SHOP HOUSE OF FRASER STORES LTD T 70,000 70,000 1 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

234 83519/51570 STORE HOUSE OF FRASER STORES LTD T 6,900 6,900 REAR OF 4 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

235 82110/51572 CAFE STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 63,500 63,500 1 FIRST LEVEL MALL C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

236 85486/51735 RESTAURANT CARLUCCIO'S T 144,000 144,000 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GVA A

237 7214/51736 BETTING OFFICE PADDY POWER BOOKMAKERS T 49,500 49,500 175 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

27/06/2017 Page 17 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

238 7220/51575 SHOP ANN SUMMERS T 82,000 82,000 183 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

239 7230/51574 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 40,000 40,000 209 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

240 7245/51577 RESTAURANT AMARONE RESTAURANTS LTD T 93,500 93,500 257 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

241 7326/51585 HALL THE SALVATION ARMY TRUSTEE CO P 11,500 11,500 45 GLENBERVIE ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

242 7338/52037 OFFICES ETC SCOTTISH ENVIRONMENT P 398,000 398,000 INVERDEE HOUSE PROTECTION AGENCY BAXTER STREET ABERDEEN GVA A

243 7377/51584 GARAGE ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 126,000 126,000 54 MENZIES ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

244 7468/51586 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD P 8,700 8,700 4 SOUTH ESPLANADE EAST ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

245 7511/52150 OIL STORAGE DEPOT ASCO UK LTD T 54,000 54,000 TORRY QUAY ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

246 7669/51583 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD P 3,000 3,000 156 OSCAR ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

247 7685/52051 SCHOOL ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 53,000 53,000 BRAESIDE PRIMARY PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM BRAESIDE PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

248 7691/52189 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY CINDY BLACK & KENNETH BLACK P 18,000 18,000 GREAT WESTERN PRE-SCHOOL 323 BROOMHILL ROAD ABERDEEN BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A

249 7789/52153 OFFICE MACKINNONS P 29,250 29,250 379 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD CULTS RYDEN LLP A

250 7810/52226 TRAINING CENTRE SHELL UK LTD T 190,000 190,000 WOODBANK HOUSE PER GRAHAM PIRIE NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PITFODELS GERALD EVE LLP A

251 69643/52031 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL T 2,700 2,700 KAIM COURT PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM 24 PITMEDDEN TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 18 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

252 7969/52029 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 24,500 24,500 FAULDS ROW PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

253 8025/52046 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 13,750 13,750 TORRY SOCIAL SERVICES PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM BALNAGASK CIRCLE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

254 8014/52030 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 3,700 3,700 3 FINNAN PLACE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

255 8021/51582 GARAGE ETC ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 229,000 229,000 GIRDLENESS ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

256 8067/52071 POLICE STATION SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY P 54,500 54,500 230 ABBOTSWELL CRESCENT FINANCE DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

257 32889/51931 OFFICE AMEC FOSTER WHEELER GROUP LTD T 665,000 665,000 CITYGATE ALTENS FARM ROAD NIGG GVA A

258 34671/52309 OFFICE AMEC FOSTER WHEELER GROUP LTD T 196,000 196,000 PHASE 2, UNIT 3 ALTENS FARM ROAD NIGG GVA A

259 8105/52223 OFFICES SHELL UK T 4,880,000 4,880,000 1 ALTENS FARM ROAD EXPLORATION & PRODUCTION NIGG PER GRAHAM PIRIE GERALD EVE LLP A

260 8113/52091 TRAINING CENTRE PETROFAC TRAINING HOLDINGS LTD P 373,000 373,000 SCOTA HOUSE BLACKNESS AVENUE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

261 8173/51589 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 226,000 226,000 CRAIGSHAW DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

262 85551/51970 OFFICE AMEC FOSTER WHEELER GROUP LTD T 610,000 610,000 UNIT 1 CITY VIEW CRAIGSHAW DRIVE GVA A ABERDEEN

263 86423/51971 OFFICE AMEC FOSTER WHEELER GROUP LTD T 675,000 675,000 UNIT 3 CITY VIEW CRAIGSHAW DRIVE GVA A ABERDEEN

264 42618/51587 OFFICE ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 25,500 25,500 2ND FLOOR ANCHOR HOUSE CRAIGSHAW BASE CRAIGSHAW ROAD MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

265 33068/51588 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 467,000 467,000 ANCHOR HOUSE CRAIGSHAW BASE CRAIGSHAW ROAD MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 19 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

266 48557/51973 OFFICE BUREAU VERITAS UK LIMITED T 212,000 212,000 PAVILION 1 CRAIGSHAW ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A

267 48954/52233 OFFICE WOOD GROUP PSN LTD T 203,000 203,000 PAVILION 2 PER GAYLE LESLIE CRAIGSHAW ROAD ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

268 49658/51596 OFFICE ETC STV NORTH LTD T 149,000 149,000 PAVILION 3 CRAIGSHAW ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

269 8264/52161 OFFICES ETC STENA DRILLING LTD T 423,000 423,000 GREENBANK CRESCENT ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

270 8275/51443 WAREHOUSE ETC JCM LOAD MONITORING LTD T 26,000 26,000 UNIT 6 LOGMAN CENTRE GREENBANK CRESCENT ABERDEEN

271 8288/51592 WAREHOUSE STAGECOACH SCOTLAND LTD T 42,250 42,250 GREENBANK PLACE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

272 8297/51591 WAREHOUSE ETC ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 49,750 49,750 14 GREENBANK ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

273 52591/52264 OFFICE YORSIPP (TRUSTEES) LTD P 63,000 63,000 THE WHEELHOUSE GREENWELL ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

274 52593/52268 WORKSHOP ETC CAMPBELL & SELLAR (PROPERTIES) LTD P 9,800 9,800 GREENWELL ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

275 81750/52266 SHOWROOM CAMPBELL & SELLAR (PROPERTIES) LTD P 44,250 44,250 GREENWELL ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

276 87097/52265 OFFICE CAMPBELL & SELLAR (PROPERTIES) LTD P 18,250 18,250 WEST LODGE GREENWELL ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

277 8343/52149 WAREHOUSE ETC ASCO MARINE LIMITED T 114,000 114,000 UNIT 6A-6B SOUTH MIDDLETON BASE GREENWELL ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

278 84870/52228 OFFICE WOOD GROUP PSN LTD T 24,000 24,000 1ST FLOOR WEST PER GAYLE LESLIE JOHN WOOD HOUSE GREENWELL ROAD CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

279 8357/52238 OFFICES PROSAFE (UK) HOLDINGS LTD P 260,000 260,000 PROSAFE CENTRE GREENWELL ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

27/06/2017 Page 20 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

280 8358/52057 OFFICE ETC MTM CONSTRUCTION P 21,750 21,750 CITRUS HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

281 87992/52058 OFFICE MTM CONSTRUCTION P 31,000 31,000 1ST FLOOR REAR CITRUS HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

282 84499/52061 OFFICE ETC MTM CONSTRUCTION P 7,800 7,800 ROOM 23 & 25 CITRUS HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

283 39163/52155 WAREHOUSE ETC NORM SOLUTIONS LTD T 102,000 102,000 GREENWELL ROAD C/O ENVIROCO LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

284 84505/52059 OFFICE MTM CONSTRUCTION P 22,750 22,750 1ST FLOOR FRONT CITRUS HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

285 85929/52060 OFFICE MTM CONSTRUCTION P 10,750 10,750 ROOM 119,121 & 123 CITRUS HOUSE GREENBANK ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

286 8388/52075 OFFICE ETC TAYLORS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD P 351,000 351,000 HARENESS CIRCLE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

287 8419/52164 WORKSHOP FRANK'S INTERNATIONAL LTD P 640,000 640,000 HARENESS CIRCLE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

288 89504/52115 OFFICE RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 45,500 45,500 NORTH WING (GROUND) IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

289 89507/52114 OFFICE RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 45,000 45,000 NORTH WING (1ST FLOOR) IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

290 89508/52112 CAR PARK RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 7,500 7,500 (30 SPACES) NORTH WING IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

291 89510/52117 WORKSHOP RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 24,500 24,500 WORKSHOP TO SOUTH IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

292 89511/52118 WORKSHOP RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 24,750 24,750 WORKSHOP 3 IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

293 89512/52111 CAR PARK RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 1,750 1,750 ( 7 SPACES) IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

27/06/2017 Page 21 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

294 89513/52116 WORKSHOPS RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 40,000 40,000 WORKSHOP 1 & 2 IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

295 89515/52113 OFFICE RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 2,500 2,500 MEZZANINE OFFICE TO REAR IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

296 89516/52110 CAR PARK RICHARD IRVIN SERVICES GROUP P 1,000 1,000 ( 4 SPACES) IRVIN HOUSE HARENESS ROAD RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

297 49870/51464 OFFICE WOOD GROUP PSN LTD T 1,130,000 1,130,000 TRAFALGAR HOUSE 2 PER GAYLE LESLIE HARENESS ROAD ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

298 87971/51461 OFFICE WOOD GROUP PSN LTD T 3,550,000 3,550,000 WOOD GROUP P S N PER GAYLE LESLIE CITY PARK 1 HARENESS ROAD CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A ABERDEEN

299 8424/51674 WORKSHOP ETC A B B LTD P 278,000 278,000 HARENESS ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A

300 8428/51765 WAREHOUSE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT T 104,000 104,000 HARENESS ROAD PROPERTY DIVISION ABERDEEN GVA A

301 34298/51595 YARD ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD O 24,750 24,750 FORMER LAURIES MOTEL HARENESS ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

302 8602/51593 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 159,000 159,000 HILLVIEW ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

303 8470/51594 DEPOT STAGECOACH BLUEBIRD P 82,500 82,500 HILLVIEW ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

304 50285/52103 WAREHOUSE ETC PETERSON (UK) LTD T 590,000 590,000 MINTO AVENUE PER LINSEY MACMILLAN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

305 8493/52224 STORAGE BASE SHELL UK LTD T 1,070,000 1,070,000 MINTO AVENUE PER GRAHAM PIRIE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

306 8520/51738 DEPOT AMEC INTERNAL ASSET MANAGEMENT LTD P 159,000 159,000 MINTO DRIVE ABERDEEN GVA A

307 8532/51726 WORKSHOP BECK PROSPER LTD T 94,500 94,500 MINTO DRIVE ABERDEEN GVA A

27/06/2017 Page 22 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

308 8550/52082 WORKSHOP ETC WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD P 394,000 394,000 SOUTER HEAD ROAD PER RYDEN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

309 36268/52076 OFFICE ETC WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD P 1,580,000 1,580,000 WEATHERFORD CENTRE PER RYDEN SOUTER HEAD ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

310 27900/51590 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD T 210,000 210,000 WELLINGTON ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

311 34853/51473 OFFICE MESSRS BAMBERGER & OTHERS P 266,000 266,000 LOIRSTON HOUSE TRUSTEES OF THE M B FOUNDATION WELLINGTON ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A

312 33112/51763 WAREHOUSE MAKRO SELF SERVICE T 321,000 321,000 UNIT C WHOLESALERS LTD WELLINGTON ROAD INDUSTRIAL PARK WELLINGTON CIRCLE GVA A ABERDEEN

313 33113/52090 OFFICE ETC PETROFAC FACILITIES MANAGEMENT LTD T 815,000 815,000 WELLINGTON ROAD INDUSTRIAL PARK WELLINGTON CIRCLE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A

314 33154/52249 OFFICE ETC WELLINGTON PROPERTY HOLDINGS LTD P 132,000 132,000 WELLINGTON ROAD INDUSTRIAL PARK WELLINGTON CIRCLE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

315 8611/52145 FACTORY BALMORAL PARK LTD P 1,260,000 1,260,000 BALMORAL PARK WELLINGTON CIRCLE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

316 8840/52205 WORKSHOP ETC DOWDING & MILLS ENGINEERING P 161,000 161,000 KIRKTON AVENUE SERVICES DYCE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

317 8846/52173 OFFICE ETC JAMES HAY PENSION TRUSTEES LTD P 150,000 150,000 (SITE 23) KIRKTON AVENUE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

318 39254/52127 OFFICE UPPERMILL FARMS LTD P 250,000 250,000 WEATHERFORD HOUSE LAWSON DRIVE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

319 8916/52055 TRAINING CENTRE SPARROWS OFFSHORE SERVICES LTD T 75,000 75,000 QUARRY CROFT FAO FACILITIES MANAGER CLINTERTY BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

320 85552/52241 HOTEL MARRIOTT HOTELS LTD P 485,000 485,000 COURTYARD BY MARRIOTT ABERDEEN AIRPORT ARGYLL WAY GERALD EVE LLP A DYCE

321 85553/52409 HOTEL PREMIER TRAVEL INN LTD P 254,000 254,000 PREMIER INN ABERDEEN AIRPORT (DYCE) PER GERALD EVE ARGYLL WAY DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 23 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

322 54500/52196 HOTEL TRAVELODGE HOTELS LTD T 61,000 61,000 TRAVELODGE PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL ABERDEEN AIRPORT HOTEL BURNSIDE DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A DYCE

323 8967/51721 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 36,500 36,500 BURNSIDE ROAD PER NELSON BAKEWELL DYCE GVA A

324 48111/52062 OFFICES ETC EXPRO NORTH SEA LTD T 850,000 850,000 LION & CHURCHILL BUILDINGS DYCE AVENUE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

325 82610/51606 OFFICE CIP PROPERTY ALPT LTD P 346,000 346,000 UNIT 1 GF NORTH ABERDEEN BUSINESS PARK DYCE AVENUE MONTAGU EVANS A DYCE

326 8992/52493 HOTEL TOPLAND NO 20 LTD P 335,000 A 335,000 HALLMARK HOTEL ABERDEEN AIRPORT 10,000 R 10,000 FARBURN TERRACE 325,000 N 325,000 DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

327 87299/52151 WAREHOUSE ASCO UK LTD T 1,090,000 1,090,000 UNITS A, B & C 11 HARVEST AVENUE D2 BUSINESS PARK, DYCE RYDEN LLP A

328 30721/52065 WORKSHOP ETC EXPRO NORTH SEA LTD T 307,000 307,000 JAMES YOUNG & CARNEGIE BUILDINGS HOWEMOSS AVENUE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

329 30205/51671 WAREHOUSE BELRON UK LTD T 9,200 9,200 UNIT 44 HOWEMOSS AVENUE DYCE GVA A

330 35094/52139 OFFICE ETC FRONTICA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LTD P 510,000 510,000 FYVIE BUILDING HOWEMOSS AVENUE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

331 87573/52138 OFFICE FRONTICA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LTD P 775,000 775,000 CRAIGIEVAR HOUSE HOWEMOSS AVENUE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

332 35926/52156 OFFICE ETC CLARIANT PRODUCTION UK LTD T 96,000 96,000 HOWEMOSS AVENUE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

333 9027/52175 WORKSHOP ETC NORTH SEA LIFTING LTD P 44,750 44,750 HOWEMOSS CRESCENT DYCE RYDEN LLP A

334 9036/52276 OFFICE SCOPUS ENGINEERING LTD T 122,000 122,000 HOWEMOSS DRIVE DYCE GVA A

335 9038/52066 WORKSHOP ETC A R R CRAIB TRANSPORT LTD P 159,000 159,000 HOWEMOSS DRIVE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

27/06/2017 Page 24 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

336 9040/51930 WORKSHOP GE OIL & GAS PRESSURE CONTROL LTD P 63,000 63,000 HOWEMOSS DRIVE DYCE GVA A

337 9067/52067 WAREHOUSE ETC A R R CRAIB TRANSPORT LTD P 121,000 121,000 HOWEMOSS DRIVE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

338 9110/51460 WAREHOUSE MACTECH (EUROPE) LTD T 42,250 42,250 HOWEMOSS DRIVE DYCE

339 9113/52097 OFFICE ETC CLARIANT PRODUCTION UK LTD T 110,000 110,000 HOWEMOSS PLACE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

340 9120/52050 WORKSHOP ETC WEIR ENGINEERING SERVICES LIMITED T 143,000 143,000 HOWEMOSS TERRACE PER COMPANY SECRETARY DYCE GVA A

341 9122/52079 WORKSHOP ETC WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD T 327,000 327,000 HOWEMOSS TERRACE PER RYDEN DYCE RYDEN LLP A

342 86682/52203 OFFICE REGUS BUSINESS CENTRES (UK) LTD T 261,000 261,000 CIRRUS BUILDING PER DRON & WRIGHT UNIT 6 INTERNATIONAL AVENUE GERALD EVE LLP A ABZ BUSINESS PARK, DYCE

343 86116/52166 WORKSHOP GEOLINK (UK) LTD T 153,000 153,000 UNIT 8 KIRKHILL PLACE DYCE GVA A

344 9152/52064 OFFICE ETC EXPRO NORTH SEA LIMITED T 14,250 14,250 SITE 7 KIRKHILL PLACE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

345 9161/52063 WORKSHOP ETC EXPRO NORTH SEA LTD T 292,000 292,000 KIRKHILL PLACE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

346 31826/52077 WORKSHOP ETC WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD T 890,000 890,000 RAITH'S INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER RYDEN KIRKTON DRIVE DYCE RYDEN LLP A

347 9186/52152 OFFICE RAITHS FARM PROPERTIES LIMITED P 14,750 14,750 UNIT 14 (PART) ASHLEY BASE PITMEDDEN ROAD RYDEN LLP A DYCE

348 81950/52128 OFFICE RAITHS FARM PROPERTIES LIMITED P 25,500 25,500 UNIT 14 (PART) ASHLEY BASE PITMEDDEN ROAD RYDEN LLP A DYCE

349 9203/52244 HOTEL MARRIOTT HOTELS LTD P 600,000 600,000 (RIVERVIEW DRIVE) ABERDEEN MARRIOTT HOTEL MARRIOTT HOTEL OVERTON CIRCLE GERALD EVE LLP A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 25 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

350 9212/52129 WORKSHOP ETC DRIL-QUIP (EUROPE) LTD P 545,000 545,000 STONEYWOOD PARK DYCE J & E SHEPHERD A

351 9215/52130 WORKSHOP ETC DRIL-QUIP (EUROPE) LTD P 770,000 770,000 STONEYWOOD PARK DYCE J & E SHEPHERD A

352 38004/52133 YARD DRIL-QUIP (EUROPE) LTD P 43,750 43,750 STONEYWOOD PARK NORTH DYCE J & E SHEPHERD A

353 9258/51605 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 8,500 8,500 127 VICTORIA STREET DYCE MONTAGU EVANS A

354 31828/52221 OFFICE GLOBAL ENERGY HOLDINGS LIMITED T 123,000 123,000 UNIT 7 INSPEC HOUSE WELLHEADS DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A DYCE

355 80524/52231 OFFICE BP PROPERTIES LTD T 3,410,000 3,410,000 1 WELLHEADS AVENUE DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

356 9302/51733 WORKSHOP ETC SCOT JCB LTD T 60,000 60,000 UNIT 2 (PART) DYCE INDUSTRIAL PARK WELLHEADS CRESCENT GVA A DYCE

357 9325/52132 WORKSHOP DRIL-QUIP (EUROPE) LTD P 167,000 167,000 DYCE INDUSTRIAL PARK WELLHEADS CRESCENT DYCE J & E SHEPHERD A

358 84558/52232 OFFICE BP EXPLORATION T 314,000 314,000 DYCE INDUSTRIAL PARK OPERATING COMPANY LIMITED WELLHEADS PLACE DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A

359 32676/52311 WORKSHOP ETC PENTAIR VALVES LTD P 156,000 156,000 WELLHEADS TERRACE DYCE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

360 9388/51860 AIRPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,580,000 3,580,000 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PROPERTY DEPARTMENT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

361 9388/51862 AIRPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,570,000 3,570,000 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PROPERTY DEPARTMENT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

362 9392/51851 OFFICES ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 30,250 30,250 TERMINAL BUILDING PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

363 36196/51776 OFFICES ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 40,000 40,000 TERMINAL BUILDING PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

27/06/2017 Page 26 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

364 34852/51804 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 10,250 10,250 144 & 131 (PART) PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

365 86140/51805 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,300 4,300 217 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

366 38646/51807 ROOM ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 9,000 9,000 220 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

367 48256/51806 OFFICES ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 17,500 17,500 218-219 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

368 34004/51808 OFFICES ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 11,250 11,250 221-222 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

369 85549/51803 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 7,600 7,600 0231 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

370 85555/51834 TICKET DESK ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 11,000 11,000 HA004 & HJ004 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

371 75763/51839 TICKET DESK ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 10,750 10,750 HI 112 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

372 75764/51838 TICKET DESK ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 17,000 17,000 HI 111 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

373 75765/51833 TICKET DESK ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 10,000 10,000 HA 002 & HJ 001 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

374 80697/51830 SITE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 7,600 7,600 CHECK-IN MACHINES (4) PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

375 54055/51852 PASSENGER LOUNGE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 57,000 57,000 VA004 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

376 57223/51853 PASSENGER LOUNGE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 86,500 86,500 VA005 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

377 75823/51832 DESK SPACE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 5,100 5,100 HA 001 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 27 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

378 49204/51842 PASSENGER LOUNGE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 51,500 51,500 NORTHERN GATEROOM A & B PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

379 33938/51855 SITE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,250 3,250 P234B PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL BUILDING ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

380 58963/51813 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 12,500 12,500 BUILDING 71015 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

381 88336/51790 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 9,700 9,700 MODULAR BUILDING STAND 13 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BESIDE VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

382 84204/51848 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 5,000 5,000 ROOM 5 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

383 38179/51856 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 23,750 23,750 ROOM 7-10 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

384 38449/51844 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,300 4,300 ROOM 14 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

385 80700/51845 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,800 4,800 ROOM 18 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

386 53833/51846 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,900 4,900 ROOM 19 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

387 85899/51857 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 7,300 7,300 ROOM 21B PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

388 88137/51847 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,500 3,500 ROOM 28 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT VISCOUNT HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

389 38663/51809 RETAIL UNIT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 5,400 5,400 A 13 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

390 38379/51810 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 13,250 13,250 B 1 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

391 88335/51777 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 5,400 5,400 B 5 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 28 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

392 88335/51858 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 10,750 10,750 B 5 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

393 35716/51811 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 16,000 16,000 B 7-B 9 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

394 9438/51799 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 35,250 35,250 B 3-B 4 & B19-B21 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

395 9438/51801 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 40,500 40,500 B 3-B 4 & B19-B21 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

396 86598/51812 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 16,250 16,250 B17- B18 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

397 39250/51825 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 8,100 8,100 C 1 & C22A PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

398 80740/51828 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 5,800 5,800 C 9A PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

399 85585/51826 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 16,000 16,000 C 3, C 4 & C5 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

400 9442/51827 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 21,750 21,750 C 6 & C17-19 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

401 70403/51829 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 15,250 15,250 C15-16 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

402 9443/51786 OFFICE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 12,250 12,250 WA 8 & 16 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

403 87398/51787 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 8,500 8,500 WA 9 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

404 78363/51854 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,000 4,000 WA 10A PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

405 87735/51859 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,400 4,400 WA 10B PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 29 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

406 33841/51779 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 8,100 8,100 WA 14 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

407 9444/51788 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 25,250 25,250 WB 6-10 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

408 74783/51789 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,100 4,100 WB11 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

409 81406/51785 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 3,600 3,600 WA 7 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

410 35953/51778 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,100 4,100 WA 11 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

411 9445/51780 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 6,100 6,100 WA 15 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

412 54504/51773 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,000 4,000 WA 17 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

413 9446/51782 STORE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 4,000 4,000 WA 18 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

414 9448/51783 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 12,000 12,000 WA 19-21 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

415 9449/51784 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 8,300 8,300 WA 22 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BROOMFIELD HOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

416 9451/51794 HELIPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 955,000 955,000 SITE 75001 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FORTIES ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

417 86573/51791 DEPOT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 129,000 129,000 BUILDING 7/3 &7/4 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FORTIES ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

418 49846/51798 HANGAR ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 66,500 66,500 BUILDING 76010 (DOVE HANGAR) PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

419 88622/51861 WAREHOUSE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 212,000 212,000 W1, G1-11 & F1-6 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BUILDING 75009 DUNLIN ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 30 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

420 40020/51800 WAREHOUSE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 320,000 320,000 W2, G30-34 & F30-39 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BUILDING 75009 DUNLIN ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

421 40020/51843 WAREHOUSE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 111,000 111,000 W2, G30-34 & F30-39 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BUILDING 75009 DUNLIN ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

422 83332/51840 GARAGE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 10,750 10,750 NO 2 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BUILDING 76006 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

423 48717/51841 GARAGE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 28,500 28,500 NO 3 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BUILDING 76006 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

424 9460/51792 HANGAR ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 87,000 87,000 BUILDING 77005 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FORTIES ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

425 80924/51793 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 24,000 24,000 BUILDING 77005 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FORTIES ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

426 49848/51795 TRAINING CENTRE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 41,000 41,000 SITE 77007 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FORTIES ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

427 9461/51814 DEPOT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 30,250 30,250 BUILDING 73002 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ARGYLL CLOSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

428 9462/51815 DEPOT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 41,750 41,750 BUILDING 73003 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ARGYLL CLOSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

429 9463/51816 DEPOT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 41,000 41,000 BUILDING 73004 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ARGYLL CLOSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

430 9464/51817 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 29,750 29,750 BUILDING 73006 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT THISTLE ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

431 9465/52018 OFFICE ETC TRAC INTERNATIONAL LTD P 94,000 94,000 3 THISTLE ROAD DYCE GVA A

432 82507/51754 YARD TRAC INTERNATIONAL LTD P 7,900 7,900 (PART) 4 THISTLE ROAD DYCE GVA A

433 9475/51818 OFFICE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 9,300 9,300 BUILDING 74010 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT THISTLE ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 31 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

434 9476/51796 DEPOT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 71,500 71,500 BUILDING 74001 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT MONTROSE ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

435 9481/51849 DEPOT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 140,000 140,000 SITE 74003 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT MONTROSE ROAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

436 83011/51850 COMPOUND ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 7,750 7,750 SITE 74006/2 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT MONTROSE CLOSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

437 52572/51821 HANGAR ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 50,000 50,000 BUILDING 79006 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FARBURN TERRACE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

438 86531/51837 HELIPAD ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 7,000 7,000 HELICOPTER HOTSPOT PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FARBURN TERRACE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

439 87653/51774 SITE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 15,000 15,000 SITE 79003 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FIXED WING PARKING STANCE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

440 48811/51822 HELIPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 338,000 338,000 BUILDING 79009 & 79017 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FARBURN TERRACE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

441 48810/51823 HANGAR ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 170,000 170,000 BUILDING 79015 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT WELLHEADS DRIVE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

442 84268/51820 HELIPORT ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 200,000 200,000 BUILDING 79001 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT TERMINAL 2 FARBURN TERRACE, ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

443 88332/51797 WAREHOUSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 15,500 15,500 BUILDING 79004 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT CORDYCE VIEW ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

444 9501/51819 HANGAR ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 127,000 127,000 BUILDING 78004 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT FOINAVON CLOSE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

445 9502/51824 OFFICE ETC ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 27,000 27,000 BUILDING 79024 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT WELLHEADS DRIVE ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

446 9503/51775 CONTROL TOWER ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 155,000 155,000 (ABERDEEN) PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BUILDING 76013 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

447 9504/51802 NAVIGATION AIDS ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 9,500 9,500 (ABERDEEN) PROPERTY DEPARTMENT SITE 76014 & 76016 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT DUNLOP HEYWOOD A DYCE

27/06/2017 Page 32 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

448 81856/51831 COMPOUND ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD P 2,900 2,900 ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PROPERTY DEPARTMENT DYCE DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

449 9527/52025 OFFICE OCS GROUP LTD P 11,500 11,500 46 AUCHMILL ROAD BUCKSBURN GVA A

450 9566/52069 HEADQUARTERS SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY P 221,000 221,000 INVERURIE ROAD FINANCE DEPARTMENT BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

451 35401/51604 RESTAURANT MCDONALDS PROPERTY CO LTD P 62,500 62,500 (SCLATTIE ROUNDABOUT) INVERURIE ROAD BUCKSBURN MONTAGU EVANS A

452 70283/51723 DEPOT GAP GROUP PROPERTIES LTD P 53,000 53,000 TWIN SPIRES MUGIEMOSS ROAD BUCKSBURN GVA A

453 9589/51734 WORKSHOP ETC VP PLC P 90,500 90,500 MUGIEMOSS ROAD BUCKSBURN GVA A

454 48467/52197 HOTEL TRAVELODGE HOTELS LTD T 78,000 78,000 TRAVELODGE INVERURIE ROAD BUCKSBURN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

455 86026/52174 OFFICE TRANSOCEAN DRILLING UK LTD T 1,280,000 1,280,000 DEEPWATER HOUSE UNIT 3 KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK JONES LANG LASALLE A KINGSWELLS

456 86738/51459 HOTEL DE VERE VILLAGE URBAN RESORT T 600,000 600,000 VILLAGE URBAN RESORT UNIT 6 KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A KINGSWELLS

457 86948/52176 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY KINGSWELLIES NURSERY LTD T 81,500 81,500 KINGSWELLIES NURSERY KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK RYDEN LLP A KINGSWELLS

458 38844/52188 SHOP CYNTHIA & KENNETH BLACK O 14,000 14,000 UNIT 3 T/A FIRM OF KINGSWELLS VILLAGE CENTRE GREAT WESTERN PRE-SCHOOL KINGSWOOD DRIVE BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A KINGSWELLS

459 38278/52187 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY CYNTHIA T BLACK P 59,000 59,000 KINGSWELLS VILLAGE CENTRE T/A GREAT WESTERN PRE-SCHOOL KINGSWOOD DRIVE KINGSWELLS BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A

460 64264/51957 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 50,500 50,500 CLAYMORE DRIVE C/O GVA BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

461 82237/51958 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 45,000 45,000 UNIT 1 & 2 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 33 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

462 81774/51954 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 40,750 40,750 UNIT 11 & 12 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

463 82680/51953 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 21,250 21,250 UNIT 8 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

464 82240/51952 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 21,250 21,250 UNIT 6 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

465 82755/51956 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 32,000 32,000 UNIT 9 & 10 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

466 86328/51949 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 20,250 20,250 UNIT 7 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

467 81773/51955 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 44,750 44,750 UNIT 3-5 C/O GVA ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

468 9710/52038 SCHOOL ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 9,700 9,700 ST NICHOLAS PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM BRAEHEAD BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

469 35731/51608 RESTAURANT MCDONALD'S PROPERTY CO LTD P 60,000 60,000 BROADFOLD ROAD BRIDGE OF DON MONTAGU EVANS A

470 9722/52142 FACTORY VETCO GRAY UK LIMITED P 525,000 525,000 BROADFOLD ROAD BRIDGE OF DON GVA A

471 85296/51972 OFFICE BMT CORDAH LTD O 44,000 44,000 2ND FLOOR (PART) BROADFOLD HOUSE BROADFOLD ROAD GVA A BRIDGE OF DON

472 9729/52143 WAREHOUSE SIG PLC T 97,000 97,000 BROADFOLD ROAD BRIDGE OF DON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

473 83669/51948 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 81,000 81,000 OCEAN TOOLS HOUSE C/O GVA CLAYMORE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

474 9737/51978 OFFICE GE OIL & GAS UK LTD T 1,510,000 1,510,000 SILVERBURN HOUSE 1 CLAYMORE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON GVA A

475 48283/52192 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY THE BRIDGES PARTNERSHIP LLP P 47,500 47,500 SILVERBURN LODGE CLAYMORE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A

27/06/2017 Page 34 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

476 60423/52193 OFFICE THE BRIDGES PARTNERSHIP LLP P 41,750 41,750 GROUND FLOOR SILVERBURN LODGE CLAYMORE DRIVE BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A BRIDGE OF DON

477 84452/52191 OFFICE THE BRIDGES PARTNERSHIP LLP P 33,750 33,750 1ST FLOOR (ROOM F) SILVERBURN LODGE CLAYMORE DRIVE BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A BRIDGE OF DON

478 35213/51991 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 130,000 130,000 OFFSHORE HOUSE C/O GVA CLAYMORE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

479 36413/51962 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 234,000 234,000 ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK C/O GVA CLAYMORE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

480 42396/51947 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 66,000 66,000 DFC HOUSE C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

481 36787/51961 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 150,000 150,000 ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK C/O GVA 1 CLAYMORE AVENUE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

482 81878/51939 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 209,000 209,000 2 CLAYMORE AVENUE C/O GVA BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

483 81878/52083 WORKSHOP ETC RUBBERATKINS SMALL T 209,000 209,000 2 CLAYMORE AVENUE SELF-ADMINISTERED SCHEME BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

484 82344/51950 WAREHOUSE ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 333,000 333,000 HYDRO HOUSE C/O GVA CLAYMORE AVENUE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

485 86809/51675 WORKSHOP ETC GLOBAL PORT SERVICES T 137,000 137,000 8 CLAYMORE AVENUE (SCOTLAND) LTD BRIDGE OF DON GVA A

486 86809/51946 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 137,000 137,000 8 CLAYMORE AVENUE C/O GVA BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

487 81770/51951 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 150,000 150,000 CLAYMORE DRIVE C/O GVA BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

488 36341/52021 OFFICES ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 31,250 31,250 UNIT 1-2 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

489 49593/51988 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 89,500 89,500 UNIT 1-4 C/O GVA SILVERFIELD HOUSE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 35 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

490 53659/51989 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 22,000 22,000 UNIT 5 C/O GVA SILVERFIELD HOUSE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

491 54363/51907 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 21,250 21,250 UNIT 6 C/O GVA SILVERFIELD HOUSE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

492 38121/52022 OFFICES ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 25,000 25,000 UNIT 3 & 4 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

493 36519/52013 OFFICE ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 42,250 42,250 UNIT 5, 6 & 7 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

494 36519/52035 OFFICE ETC CSE-CONTROLS LTD T 42,250 42,250 UNIT 5, 6 & 7 THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE GVA A BRIDGE OF DON

495 36342/52023 OFFICES ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 30,750 30,750 UNIT 8-9 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

496 38123/51995 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 15,000 15,000 UNIT 10 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

497 38122/52017 OFFICE ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 14,000 14,000 UNIT 11 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

498 36343/52019 OFFICES ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 37,250 37,250 UNIT 12-14 C/O GVA THE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE CLAYMORE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

499 9783/51684 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 18,500 18,500 18 ELLON ROAD PER NELSON BAKEWELL BRIDGE OF DON GVA A

500 31510/51924 RESEARCH CENTRE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 382,000 382,000 ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK C/O GVA EXPLORATION DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

501 31510/52085 RESEARCH CENTRE WEATHERFORD (UK) LTD T 382,000 382,000 ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK PER RYDEN EXPLORATION DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

502 80732/51993 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,500 6,500 SUITE F2 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

503 49178/51963 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 58,000 58,000 1ST FLOOR NORTH C/O GVA THE HUB, ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 36 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

504 84627/51981 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 63,000 63,000 GROUND FLOOR C/O GVA THE HUB, ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

505 85227/52024 CAFE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 15,250 15,250 GRUB C/O GVA THE HUB, ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

506 85190/51911 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 3,600 3,600 MEETING ROOM C/O GVA THE HUB, ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

507 85355/51964 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 23,250 23,250 1ST FLOOR SOUTH C/O GVA THE HUB, ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

508 32998/51982 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 9,300 9,300 SUITE G1 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

509 36543/52006 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 8,100 8,100 SUITE G2 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

510 33848/51914 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 12,250 12,250 SUITE G4 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

511 32738/51967 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 8,100 8,100 SUITE G6 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

512 52114/51835 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 8,100 8,100 SUITE G3 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

513 32736/51994 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,500 6,500 SUITE F3 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

514 84723/51913 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 10,000 10,000 SUITE F4 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

515 55123/51992 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,500 6,500 SUITE F1 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

516 33877/51983 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 10,250 10,250 SUITE F5 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

517 39425/51997 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,500 6,500 SUITE F8 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 37 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

518 83343/52007 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,700 6,700 SUITE F6 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

519 78923/51996 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,500 6,500 SUITE F7 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

520 36765/51990 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 25,750 25,750 UNIT G10 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

521 36765/52208 OFFICE MURGITROYD & CO T 25,750 25,750 UNIT G10 THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE MCCAFFERY & CO A BRIDGE OF DON

522 38677/52005 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 16,750 16,750 SUITE F11 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

523 49164/51998 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 35,500 35,500 UNIT G9 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

524 36766/51969 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 5,200 5,200 THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE C/O GVA EXPLORATION DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

525 38120/51999 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 38,250 38,250 SUITE F9 & F10 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

526 49646/51966 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 11,000 11,000 SUITE G5 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

527 53460/52000 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 9,000 9,000 UNIT G8 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

528 54009/51968 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 8,100 8,100 SUITE G7 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

529 87468/52001 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 6,000 6,000 UNIT G11 C/O GVA THE ENTERPRISE CENTRE EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

530 31711/51959 WORKSHOP ETC ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 44,500 44,500 EUROPA HOUSE C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

531 83187/51984 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 505,000 505,000 E1 NORTHPOINT C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 38 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

532 83187/52167 OFFICE ITS TESTING SERVICES (UK) LTD O 505,000 505,000 E1 NORTHPOINT ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A BRIDGE OF DON

533 80734/51986 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 43,750 43,750 E3 WEST NORTHPOINT C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

534 72003/51979 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 56,000 56,000 E3 EAST NORTHPOINT C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

535 82816/52004 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 41,000 41,000 E3 SOUTH NORTHPOINT C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

536 83958/52003 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 103,000 103,000 E5 NORTHPOINT C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

537 87641/51980 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 42,500 42,500 E5 MIDPOINT C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & ENERGY PARK EXPLORATION DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

538 33981/51987 OFFICE ABERDEEN ENERGY PARK LTD P 124,000 124,000 OCEAN INSTALLER HOUSE C/O GVA EXPLORATION DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

539 9791/52084 OFFICE BIS SALAMIS M & I LTD P 216,000 216,000 4 GREENHOLE PLACE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

540 9794/52269 WORKSHOP LEWIS PARKER & RODDY PARKER P 58,000 58,000 INTOWN ROAD T/A AUTO SPRAY BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

541 9795/52267 GARAGE AUTOSPRAY (ABERDEEN) LIMITED T 58,000 58,000 INTOWN ROAD BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

542 49753/52044 OFFICES ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 401,000 401,000 BALGOWNIE 1 PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM CONFERENCE WAY BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

543 30454/51912 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 226,000 226,000 CAMPUS 1 C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PARK BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

544 32686/51891 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 20,750 20,750 UNIT 1 C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

545 85189/51938 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,700 3,700 MEETING ROOM C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 39 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

546 35344/51885 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 20,750 20,750 UNIT 2 C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

547 35345/51940 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,000 10,000 UNIT 3A C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

548 35346/51945 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,250 10,250 UNIT 3B C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

549 32903/51886 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 20,750 20,750 UNIT 4 C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

550 35709/51895 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 21,000 21,000 UNIT 5A C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

551 35148/51906 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 40,750 40,750 UNIT 6 C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

552 34342/51887 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,250 10,250 UNIT 7A C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

553 35888/51890 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,250 10,250 UNIT 7B C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

554 32904/51892 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 20,750 20,750 UNIT 8 C/O GVA CROMBIE LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

555 38350/51899 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 147,000 147,000 UNIT G C/O GVA KETTOCK LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

556 35335/51888 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 33,750 33,750 UNIT F C/O GVA KETTOCK LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

557 49148/52011 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 34,250 34,250 UNIT A C/O GVA KETTOCK LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

558 52836/51836 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 29,000 29,000 UNIT B C/O GVA KETTOCK LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

559 39229/51896 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 103,000 103,000 UNIT C, D & E C/O GVA KETTOCK LODGE, CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 40 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

560 27831/51944 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 67,000 67,000 CAMPUS 3 C/O GVA BALGOWNIE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

561 27831/52081 OFFICES REACTIVE DOWNHOLE TOOLS LTD T 67,000 67,000 CAMPUS 3 BALGOWNIE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

562 34341/51439 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY STOMPERS NURSERY T 100,000 100,000 STOMPERS NURSERY BALGOWNIE LODGE, CAMPUS 3 BALGOWNIE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON

563 34341/51898 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 100,000 100,000 STOMPERS NURSERY C/O GVA BALGOWNIE LODGE, CAMPUS 3 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

564 32685/51943 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 36,250 36,250 UNIT 1 C/O GVA GLOVER PAVILION, CAMPUS 3 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

565 33885/51941 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 27,500 27,500 UNIT 2 C/O GVA GLOVER PAVILION, CAMPUS 3 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

566 32905/51894 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 51,000 51,000 UNIT 3 C/O GVA GLOVER PAVILION, CAMPUS 3 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

567 36967/51882 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,400 2,400 UNIT 1 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

568 36431/51883 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,800 2,800 UNIT 2 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

569 38191/51884 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,800 2,800 UNIT 3 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

570 36274/51925 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 5,700 5,700 UNIT 4-5 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

571 36184/51901 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 7,600 7,600 UNIT 10-11 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

572 36275/51935 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,200 2,200 UNIT 7 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

573 36433/51936 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,200 2,200 UNIT 8 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 41 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

574 30453/51965 WORKSHOP ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 62,500 62,500 CAMPUS 3 SITE B1 C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PARK BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

575 40079/51908 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,600 3,600 UNIT 9 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

576 36185/51869 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,700 3,700 UNIT 13 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

577 36191/51909 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,600 3,600 UNIT 16 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

578 38572/51910 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,600 3,600 UNIT 19 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

579 38628/51937 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,200 2,200 UNIT 18 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

580 36192/51904 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,800 2,800 UNIT 22 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

581 48294/51902 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,800 2,800 UNIT 20 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

582 36195/51905 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,800 2,800 UNIT 23 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

583 36969/51915 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,400 2,400 UNIT 24 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

584 36183/51876 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 6,700 6,700 JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 C/O GVA BALGOWNIE DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

585 39212/51934 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,600 2,600 UNIT 17 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

586 49476/51903 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 2,800 2,800 UNIT 21 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

587 47872/51870 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,700 3,700 UNIT 14 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 42 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

588 50083/51900 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,600 3,600 UNIT 6 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

589 80771/51871 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,700 3,700 UNIT 15 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

590 48969/51868 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 3,700 3,700 UNIT 12 C/O GVA JAMES GREGORY CENTRE CAMPUS 2 BALGOWNIE DRIVE RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

591 31411/51960 OFFICES ETC ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 179,000 179,000 CAMPUS 1 C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PARK BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

592 36767/51897 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 284,000 284,000 CAMPUS 1 C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PARK BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

593 38666/51872 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 14,500 14,500 DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 C/O GVA BALGOWNIE ROAD BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

594 38770/51927 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,750 10,750 UNIT A1 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

595 38667/51928 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,750 10,750 UNIT A2 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

596 38668/51916 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 11,000 11,000 UNIT A3 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

597 50785/51929 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,750 10,750 UNIT A4 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

598 38670/51917 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 22,000 22,000 UNIT A5 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

599 38671/51918 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 11,000 11,000 UNIT A6 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

600 39231/51874 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 21,500 21,500 UNIT A7-A8 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

601 88194/51919 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 16,000 16,000 UNIT A9 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 43 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

602 38907/51873 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 33,000 33,000 UNIT B1-B2 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

603 38768/51877 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 32,750 32,750 UNIT B3-B4 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

604 40839/51923 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 22,250 22,250 UNIT B8-B9 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

605 75403/51867 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 11,000 11,000 UNIT B10 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

606 40937/51920 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 22,000 22,000 UNIT B6-B7 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

607 48916/51875 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,750 10,750 UNIT B5 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

608 38672/51926 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 47,000 47,000 UNIT C1-C6 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

609 44138/51880 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 23,000 23,000 D1-D3 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

610 87816/51881 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 23,000 23,000 D4-D6 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

611 42815/51878 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 32,750 32,750 UNIT E1-E3 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

612 40206/51921 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 22,000 22,000 UNIT E10-E11 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

613 83344/51879 OFFICES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 32,750 32,750 UNIT E4-E6 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

614 40840/51922 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 33,000 33,000 UNIT E7-E9 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

615 40841/51933 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 10,750 10,750 UNIT E12 C/O GVA DAVIDSON HOUSE, CAMPUS 1 BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

27/06/2017 Page 44 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

616 58804/51942 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 21,750 21,750 CAMPUS 1 C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PARK BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

617 48132/51889 OFFICE ABERDEEN INNOVATION PARK LTD P 136,000 136,000 MILLENNIUM HOUSE CAMPUS 1 C/O GVA ABERDEEN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PARK BALGOWNIE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

618 30475/52185 PUBLIC HOUSE ETC MITCHELLS & BUTLERS P 84,000 84,000 BUCKIE FARM PER ESTATE MANAGER THE PARKWAY PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BRIDGE OF DON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

619 30486/51607 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 18,000 18,000 UNIT 3 JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON MONTAGU EVANS A

620 33254/52239 PUBLIC HOUSE ETC WHITBREAD PLC P 250,000 250,000 MILL OF MUNDURNO PER BRIAN OWEN MURCAR GERALD EVE BRIDGE OF DON GERALD EVE LLP A

621 9996/52158 OFFICE INTERMOOR LTD T 403,000 403,000 DENMORE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TERN PLACE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

622 9996/52220 OFFICE ACTEON GROUP PROPERTIES LTD P 403,000 403,000 DENMORE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TERN PLACE BRIDGE OF DON GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

623 33978/52217 OFFICE ETC OCEANSCAN LTD P 75,500 75,500 DENMORE ROAD BRIDGE OF DON GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

624 10027/52054 WORKSHOP SPARROWS OFFSHORE SERVICES LTD T 295,000 295,000 SETON HOUSE, UNIT 16-17 FAO FACILITIES MANAGER NEWTON OF MURCAR INDUSTRIAL ESTATE DENMORE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

625 10032/52053 WORKSHOP ETC SPARROWS OFFSHORE SERVICES LTD T 213,000 213,000 SCOTT HOUSE FAO FACILITIES MANAGER NEWTON OF MURCAR INDUSTRIAL ESTATE DENMORE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

626 37049/52056 WORKSHOP ETC SPARROWS OFFSHORE SERVICES LTD T 127,000 127,000 FOVERAN HOUSE, UNIT 9-10 FAO FACILITIES MANAGER DENMORE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE DENMORE ROAD RYDEN LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

627 34147/52222 WORKSHOP DENMORE PRESS P 43,750 43,750 DENMORE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE TERN PLACE BRIDGE OF DON BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A

27/06/2017 Page 45 of 45