LISTING OF CITATIONS - CITY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 22nd June 2021 at 10.00 am in Council Chamber, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 1056/75182 SHOP CHALMERS BAKERY LTD P 11,250 11,250 429 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

2 1069/70425 SHOP LLOYDS PHARMACY LTD O 12,750 12,750 451 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

3 1090/78433 SHOP FARMFOODS LTD T 15,250 15,250 160 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

4 1102/72724 SHOP J & S ACCESSORIES LTD T 32,750 32,750 412 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN WYMRE A

5 1221/75064 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 11,750 11,750 39 HIGH STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

6 1223/75065 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 12,250 12,250 61 HIGH STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

7 33006/70656 BETTING OFFICE CORAL RACING LTD T 5,800 5,800 GRANITEHILL ROAD CORAL GALA GROUP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

8 1454/70663 SHOP T M RETAIL GROUP T 13,000 13,000 5 BYRON SQUARE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

9 39356/70508 SHOP AMERICAN GOLF DISCOUNT T 51,500 51,500 UNIT 1 HAUDAGAIN RETAIL PARK GREAT NORTHERN ROAD COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

10 39357/70403 SHOP HIGH SEAT LTD T 50,500 50,500 UNIT 2 HAUDAGAIN RETAIL PARK GREAT NORTHERN ROAD COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

11 1594/75250 OFFICE ETC HORDENE LTD P 11,750 11,750 UNIT 1 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 1 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

12 38901/75313 OFFICE ETC HORDENE LTD P 11,750 11,750 UNIT 2 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 3 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

13 1595/75507 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 12,500 12,500 UNIT 3 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 5 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 1 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 1596/75518 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 12,500 12,500 UNIT 4 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 7 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

15 1597/75522 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 31,000 31,000 UNIT 5-7 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 11 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

16 1597/77873 SHOP DP REALITY LTD T 31,000 31,000 UNIT 5-7 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE T/A DOMINO'S PIZZA 11 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

17 1599/75760 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 32,000 32,000 UNIT 16 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 15A CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

18 1599/79185 SHOP CROWN PAINTS LTD T 32,000 32,000 UNIT 16 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 15A CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON A

19 1600/75481 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 13,000 13,000 UNIT 8 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 17 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

20 1601/75758 BETTING OFFICE HORDENE LTD P 26,750 26,750 UNIT 9-10 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 21 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

21 1601/78343 BETTING OFFICE WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 26,750 26,750 UNIT 9-10 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE PROPERTY DEPARTMENT 21 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

22 1602/75745 OFFICE HORDENE LTD P 25,750 25,750 UNIT 11-12 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 23 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

23 1603/75520 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 12,250 12,250 UNIT 13 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 27 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

24 1604/75505 SHOP HORDENE LTD P 13,000 13,000 UNIT 14 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 29 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

25 1645/71943 SHOP STEVEN F WEBSTER LTD P 7,200 7,200 4 HILTON DRIVE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

26 1672/70798 SHOP THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 16,750 16,750 89A ROSEHILL DRIVE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

27 1676/76364 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 18,000 18,000 99 ROSEHILL DRIVE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 2 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 1676/77442 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 18,000 18,000 99 ROSEHILL DRIVE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

29 1709/75066 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 14,000 14,000 606 KING STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

30 1711/71915 SHOP STEVEN F WEBSTER LTD P 10,000 10,000 624 KING STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

31 1791/76372 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 31,750 31,750 SCHOOL ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

32 1791/77446 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 31,750 31,750 SCHOOL ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

33 1804/73695 SHOP THE SPITAL GRUB LTD T 15,000 15,000 148 SPITAL ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

34 1828/75106 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 12,000 12,000 8 GREENFERN PLACE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

35 1830/71730 SHOP THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 11,250 11,250 10 GREENFERN PLACE PER GERALD EVE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

36 1840/70653 SHOP CORAL RACING LTD O 24,750 24,750 14 GREENFERN PLACE CORAL GALA GROUP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

37 1842/78369 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 22,000 22,000 16 GREENFERN PLACE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

38 1843/73632 SHOP SCOTTISH MIDLAND CO-OPERATIVE T 19,500 19,500 18 GREENFERN PLACE SOCIETY LTD ABERDEEN T/A SEMI-CHEM RYDEN LLP A

39 1848/78014 SHOP INDIGO SUN RETAIL LTD T 31,750 31,750 15 GREENFERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

40 1917/74013 SHOP P 8,100 8,100 NO 4 PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM CORNHILL SHOPPING ARCADE CORNHILL DRIVE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

41 1922/74102 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 8,100 8,100 NO 8 PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM CORNHILL SHOPPING ARCADE CORNHILL DRIVE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 3 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

42 1952/70641 SHOP MARTIN MCCOLL LIMITED T 24,500 24,500 87 BACK HILTON ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

43 32654/79207 SHOP JOHNSONS APPARELMASTER LTD T 16,000 16,000 UNIT 1 BERRYDEN RETAIL PARK BERRYDEN ROAD GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

44 36152/70822 BETTING OFFICE DONE BROTHERS (CASH BETTING) LTD T 26,000 26,000 UNIT 6 T/A BETFRED BERRYDEN RETAIL PARK BERRYDEN ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

45 1974/74586 OFFICE ETC ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 16,250 16,250 33 CARNIE DRIVE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

46 94295/78395 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 21,250 21,250 FORESTERHILL HEALTH CENTRE FORESTERHILL ROAD ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

47 2020/70473 SHOP ALLDAYS STORES LTD T 18,250 18,250 UNIT 2 LEWIS ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

48 2040/75107 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 10,000 10,000 103 ROUSAY DRIVE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

49 2051/73455 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 5,600 5,600 3 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

50 2052/73528 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 11,750 11,750 4 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

51 2054/73530 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 11,500 11,500 5 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

52 2055/73540 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 11,500 11,500 6 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

53 2056/75786 SHOP DINGBRO LTD T 35,000 35,000 7 SUMMERHILL COURT T/A AUTOSAVE COMPONENTS ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

54 2057/73542 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 11,250 11,250 12 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

55 30740/73525 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 11,500 11,500 11 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 4 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 2058/73537 SHOP METROPOLITAN PROPERTY P 11,750 11,750 14 SUMMERHILL COURT REALIZATION LTD ABERDEEN FRESHWATER GROUP (COMMERCIAL DEPT) RYDEN LLP A

57 2061/78392 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE LTD T 12,500 12,500 20 SUMMERHILL COURT PER GREGOR FORRESTER ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

58 2062/77878 SHOP D P REALTY T 13,000 13,000 21 SUMMERHILL COURT T/A DOMINO'S PIZZA ABERDEEN WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

59 2166/78370 SHOP ABERDEEN BLIND CO LTD T 15,750 15,750 32 ESSLEMONT AVENUE ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

60 32619/78011 SHOP INDIGO SUN RETAIL LTD T 29,500 29,500 UNIT A-C 105 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

61 2203/75086 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 6,700 6,700 181 ROSEMOUNT PLACE C/O J G ROSS ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

62 2209/75020 SHOP PATRICIA E MACLAREN P 8,100 8,100 201 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

63 2210/77804 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 18,000 18,000 203 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

64 2227/75698 SHOP ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING P 28,000 28,000 138 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

65 2230/78398 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE LTD T 5,100 5,100 142 ROSEMOUNT PLACE PER GREGOR FORRESTER ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

66 2235/75241 SHOP GARIOCH DEVELOPMENT CO LTD P 6,600 6,600 198 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

67 2372/76972 OFFICE SIMPSON & MARWICK T 41,500 41,500 4 ALFORD PLACE ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

68 2372/79834 OFFICE SIMPSON & MARWICK T 41,500 41,500 4 ALFORD PLACE ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

69 2525/75703 SHOP UNION FOUNTAIN LIMITED P 8,600 8,600 11A ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 5 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

70 2533/74952 SHOP GEORGE BURNETT P 18,000 18,000 29 ROSE STREET T/A THISTLE SPORTS (ABERDEEN) LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

71 2534/73645 SHOP C CAMPBELL P 15,000 15,000 49 ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

72 2535/75216 HAIRDRESSING SALON C CAMPBELL P 9,700 9,700 51G ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

73 2536/75188 SHOP C CAMPBELL P 9,300 9,300 51H ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

74 2537/74970 SHOP C CAMPBELL P 9,100 9,100 53G ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

75 2538/73649 SHOP C CAMPBELL P 14,000 14,000 55D ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

76 2542/79624 SHOP MEARNS PROPERTY LTD P 30,500 30,500 207 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

77 2548/70886 SHOP WHITTALLS WINE MERCHANTS 2 LTD T 13,250 13,250 229 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

78 2556/75749 SHOP A W HERD & SONS LTD P 22,500 22,500 277 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

79 2557/75802 SHOP ASHVIEW INVESTMENTS P 12,000 12,000 279 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

80 2557/79693 SHOP CALA HOMES (NORTH) UK T 12,000 12,000 279 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

81 2558/76952 SHOP ATLANTIS BATHROOMS & KITCHENS T 15,750 15,750 281 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

82 2559/75667 SHOP FIRM OF CHARLES MICHIE P 16,750 16,750 287 ROSEMOUNT PLACE PER JOHN C MICHIE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

83 30348/74788 SHOP GARIOCH PENSION FUND P 11,750 11,750 30 THISTLE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 6 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

84 2654/75281 SHOP GARIOCH DEVELOPMENT CO LTD P 9,600 9,600 36A THISTLE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

85 2664/73369 SHOP NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD P 19,250 19,250 478 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

86 2664/78335 SHOP JOHNSONS APPARELMASTER LTD O 19,250 19,250 478 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

87 2668/73399 OFFICE NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD P 49,000 49,000 484 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

88 2668/78557 OFFICE DWP O 49,000 49,000 484 UNION STREET C/O LAND SECURITIES TRILLIUM ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

89 2721/74767 SHOP TRUSTEES OF GARIOCH PENSION FUND P 3,800 3,800 6 WAVERLEY PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

90 2737/75045 SHOP A & A TAYLORS DISCRETIONARY TRUST P 8,800 8,800 28 ALBYN GROVE C/O TAYLORS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

91 2826/71764 SHOP THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD P 27,000 27,000 15 FOUNTAINHALL ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

92 2843/76368 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 46,750 46,750 2 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

93 2843/77407 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 46,750 46,750 2 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

94 2845/78383 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE LTD T 7,800 7,800 16 HOLBURN STREET PER GREGOR FORRESTER ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

95 2959/75090 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 10,750 10,750 65 ST SWITHIN STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

96 2960/76674 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 11,750 11,750 8 ST SWITHIN STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

97 2960/77508 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 11,750 11,750 8 ST SWITHIN STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 7 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

98 3023/74442 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 10,000 10,000 152 GALLOWGATE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

99 33999/73975 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 5,200 5,200 GOLF ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

100 3056/75092 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 4,000 4,000 332 KING STREET C/O J G ROSS ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

101 3313/70667 SHOP FORBUOYS LTD T 10,250 10,250 33 CASTLE STREET T/A RS MCCOLL ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

102 36827/79705 HAIRDRESSING SALON DPGF LTD P 3,100 3,100 89 KING STREET ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

103 3608/78450 SHOP WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 10,500 10,500 188 KING STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

104 3697/76333 SHOP THE JESSOP GROUP LTD T 22,250 22,250 33 MARKET STREET T/A JESSOP PHOTO VIDEO CENTRE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

105 88453/70971 SHOP NISBETS PLC T 52,000 52,000 UNIT E CITY WHARF SHIPROW CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

106 88453/77344 SHOP NISBETS PLC T 52,000 52,000 UNIT E CITY WHARF SHIPROW CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

107 3957/78005 SHOP VISIT T 29,750 29,750 23 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

108 3959/75063 SHOP INSTANT CASH LOANS LTD T 24,500 24,500 27 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

109 3961/70467 SHOP BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION T 23,000 23,000 31 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

110 3962/70498 SHOP AMPLIFON LIMITED T 26,750 26,750 33 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

111 3962/79572 SHOP SHARDEL LTD P 26,750 26,750 33 UNION STREET ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 8 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

112 3975/70318 SHOP ANNIE MO'S P 75,000 75,000 39 UNION STREET ABERDEEN

113 3976/74934 SHOP PRESTIGIC HOLDINGS LIMITED P 68,500 68,500 43 UNION STREET RETIREMENT BENEFITS SCHEME ABERDEEN PER SAM TRUSTEES LIMITED RYDEN LLP A

114 30225/73573 SHOP NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD P 24,500 24,500 47 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

115 30225/76949 SHOP FIRST ABERDEEN LTD T 24,500 24,500 47 UNION STREET ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

116 4009/75132 SHOP SCOTTISH MIDLAND CO-OP T 33,500 33,500 49 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

117 87635/73604 SHOP FLOWER OF SCOTLAND LTD P 27,250 27,250 51 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

118 86487/79246 BETTING OFFICE PADDY POWER BOOKMAKERS T 29,750 29,750 53 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

119 4011/70379 SHOP PLC T 46,000 46,000 55 UNION STREET T/A BAKERS OVEN NORTH ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

120 52545/76339 SHOP SPORTSDIRECT.COM RETAIL LTD T 275,000 275,000 57 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

121 52545/77574 SHOP SPORTSDIRECT.COM RETAIL LTD T 275,000 275,000 57 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

122 53996/70881 SHOP POUNDLAND LTD T 150,000 150,000 57 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

123 4042/77824 SHOP WQP PROVENDER LTD P 22,750 22,750 NAUTILUS HOUSE 35 WATERLOO QUAY ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

124 4269/78449 SHOP WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 17,250 17,250 231 GEORGE STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

125 4340/71191 CLINIC RICHARD BUCKLE T 45,000 45,000 230 GEORGE STREET T/A ABERDEEN ORTHODONTICS ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 9 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

126 4340/77962 CLINIC RICHARD BUCKLE T 45,000 45,000 230 GEORGE STREET T/A ABERDEEN ORTHODONTICS ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

127 4341/74769 SHOP GARIOCH PENSION FUND P 8,700 8,700 242 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

128 4344/73512 SHOP MCCALLS LTD T 11,250 11,250 256 GEORGE STREET PER IAIN HAWTHORNE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

129 4359/70658 SHOP CORAL RACING LTD T 12,000 12,000 344 GEORGE STREET CORAL GALA GROUP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

130 27875/74026 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 5,100 5,100 396 GEORGE STREET PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

131 4367/70898 SHOP ALLDAYS STORES LTD T 17,000 17,000 446 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

132 4459/75730 SHOP ETC HENRY J LUMSDEN P 10,750 10,750 128 JOHN STREET T/A LUMSDEN SECURITY ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

133 4538/75377 SHOP MORNING NOON & NIGHT LTD T 7,900 7,900 12 SOUTH MOUNT STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

134 4538/79787 SHOP KELLY OF CULTS LTD P 7,900 7,900 12 SOUTH MOUNT STREET ABERDEEN GALBRAITH A

135 4555/75262 SHOP ESSON PENSION FUND P 14,750 14,750 12A BACK WYND PER ESSON PROPERTIES LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

136 4556/75183 SHOP ESSON PENSION FUND P 22,250 22,250 12B BACK WYND PER ESSON PROPERTIES LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

137 4556/76154 SHOP A G A RANGEMASTER LTD T 22,250 22,250 12B BACK WYND ABERDEEN WYMRE A

138 4558/75254 SHOP ESSON PROPERTIES LTD P 28,250 28,250 14 BACK WYND ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

139 31884/73688 SHOP ETC ESSON PROPERTIES LTD P 45,250 45,250 15 BACK WYND ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 10 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

140 4560/79007 SHOP WHITE STUFF LIMITED T 41,250 41,250 22 BACK WYND ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

141 35756/75435 SHOP ESSON PROPERTIES LTD P 8,000 8,000 THE PEND BACK WYND ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

142 34799/74040 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 37,250 37,250 PATAGONIAN HEIGHTS PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM 17 BELMONT STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

143 4595/77108 SHOP DAVID M STEWART & P 27,500 27,500 35 BELMONT STREET MRS JUNE A STEWART ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

144 4595/77421 SHOP DAVID M STEWART & P 27,500 27,500 35 BELMONT STREET MRS JUNE A STEWART ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

145 4624/79348 SHOP CRAIG WILLOX T 25,750 25,750 22 BELMONT STREET T/A BOOKS AND BEANS ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

146 38745/76307 SHOP JACK WILLS LTD T 54,000 54,000 UNIT 13 THE ACADEMY BELMONT STREET WYMRE A ABERDEEN

147 38481/72757 SHOP COSTA LTD T 15,000 15,000 UNIT 15 THE ACADEMY BELMONT STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

148 31127/72739 SHOP MR PRETZEL (UK) RETAIL LTD T 29,750 29,750 UNIT 1 ABERDEEN WYMRE A

149 31127/78501 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 29,750 29,750 UNIT 1 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

150 31128/78562 SHOP VODAFONE LIMITED T 90,000 90,000 UNIT 2 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

151 31130/78403 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 118,000 118,000 UNIT 3 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

152 31130/79630 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 118,000 118,000 UNIT 3 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A

153 31133/78563 SHOP THE CARPHONE WAREHOUSE T 134,000 134,000 UNIT 4 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

08/03/2021 Page 11 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

154 31211/78404 SHOP WATERSTONES BOOKSELLERS LTD T 264,000 264,000 UNIT 5 & 33 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

155 31135/75007 SHOP CHISHOLM & HUNTER T 135,000 135,000 UNIT 6 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

156 31135/78497 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 135,000 135,000 UNIT 6 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

157 31136/77011 SHOP ARCADIA GROUP PLC T 138,000 138,000 UNIT 7 T/A WALLIS FASHION GROUP LTD BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SGP PROPERTY SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

158 31136/78487 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 138,000 138,000 UNIT 7 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

159 31137/78564 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 111,000 111,000 UNIT 8 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

160 31137/79400 SHOP SWAROVSKI UK LTD T 111,000 111,000 UNIT 8 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN JONES LANG LASALLE A

161 31138/71904 SHOP JACK WILLS LTD T 199,000 199,000 UNIT 9 & 10 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

162 31138/76341 SHOP JACK WILLS LTD T 199,000 199,000 UNIT 9 & 10 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

163 31138/78520 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 199,000 199,000 UNIT 9 & 10 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

164 31816/78388 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 102,000 102,000 UNIT 11 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

165 31816/78995 SHOP KURT GEIGER T 102,000 102,000 UNIT 11 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

166 33773/78367 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 30,750 30,750 UNIT 12A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

167 33773/78994 SHOP TGFS (THE GOOD FOOD SHOP) LTD T 30,750 30,750 UNIT 12A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

08/03/2021 Page 12 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

168 33506/78366 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 58,000 58,000 UNIT 13 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

169 33531/75734 SHOP JOJO MAMAN BEBE LIMITED T 57,500 57,500 UNIT 14 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

170 32891/78516 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 41,000 41,000 UNIT 15 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

171 31726/78495 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 51,000 51,000 UNIT 16 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

172 31240/70934 SHOP HOBBS LTD T 126,000 126,000 UNIT 17-18 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

173 31240/78489 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 126,000 126,000 UNIT 17-18 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

174 87416/70505 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 PHOTO-ME GEORGE STREET EXIT BON ACCORD CENTRE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

175 87416/79474 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 PHOTO-ME GEORGE STREET EXIT BON ACCORD CENTRE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

176 31245/77010 SHOP REDCASTLE LTD T 368,000 368,000 UNIT 19A PER ARCADIA GROUP LTD BON ACCORD CENTRE T/A TOP SHOP ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

177 31245/78378 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 368,000 368,000 UNIT 19A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

178 31247/78401 SHOP RIVER ISLAND T 342,000 342,000 UNIT 19B PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

179 31142/78400 SHOP AURORA T 177,000 177,000 UNIT 20 T/A OASIS BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

180 31143/78494 SHOP AURORA T 159,000 159,000 UNIT 21 T/A WAREHOUSE BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

181 31145/78509 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 137,000 137,000 UNIT 22 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 13 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

182 31146/77060 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 159,000 159,000 UNIT 23 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

183 31212/77012 SHOP ARCADIA GROUP PLC T 347,000 347,000 UNIT 24 T/A BURTON RETAIL BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SGP PROPERTY SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

184 31212/78406 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 347,000 347,000 UNIT 24 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

185 31147/76310 SHOP THE DISNEY STORE T 198,000 198,000 UNIT 25 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

186 31147/78410 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 198,000 198,000 UNIT 25 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

187 31148/75642 SHOP SMIGGLE UK LTD T 68,000 68,000 UNIT 26A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

188 31148/78355 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 68,000 68,000 UNIT 26A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

189 31149/70815 SHOP SIGNET GROUP PLC T 110,000 110,000 UNIT 26B BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

190 31149/78364 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 110,000 110,000 UNIT 26B BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

191 31129/76181 SHOP WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD T 90,500 90,500 UNIT 27 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN DELOITTE LLP A

192 31129/78498 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 90,500 90,500 UNIT 27 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

193 31129/79950 SHOP WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD T 90,500 90,500 UNIT 27 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN DELOITTE LLP A

194 31131/78363 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 125,000 125,000 UNIT 28 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

195 31132/77107 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 106,000 106,000 UNIT 29 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 14 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

196 31134/78506 SHOP EE LTD T 113,000 113,000 UNIT 30 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

197 31139/70905 SHOP VISION EXPRESS (UK) LTD T 233,000 233,000 UNIT 31-32 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

198 31139/78512 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 233,000 233,000 UNIT 31-32 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

199 31140/78486 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 53,500 53,500 UNIT 34 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

200 31157/78518 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 48,750 48,750 UNIT 35 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

201 31630/70731 SHOP TOBAR GROUP TRADING LTD T 48,000 48,000 UNIT 36 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

202 31630/78505 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 48,000 48,000 UNIT 36 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

203 31150/78523 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 57,000 57,000 UNIT 37 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

204 31150/79661 SHOP GAME RETAIL LTD T 57,000 57,000 UNIT 37 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

205 31151/78519 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 63,000 63,000 UNIT 38 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

206 31631/78413 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 96,000 96,000 UNIT 39 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

207 31962/78502 SHOP NEXT PLC T 640,000 640,000 BON ACCORD CENTRE ESTATES DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

208 31154/78362 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 112,000 112,000 UNIT 44-45 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

209 31155/78361 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 49,000 49,000 UNIT 46 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 15 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

210 31742/72736 SHOP JIGSAW T 92,500 92,500 UNIT 19 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

211 31742/78411 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 92,500 92,500 UNIT 19 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

212 87222/70391 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 PHOTO-ME LOCH STREET EXIT BON ACCORD CENTRE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

213 87222/79476 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 PHOTO-ME LOCH STREET EXIT BON ACCORD CENTRE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

214 31248/77036 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD P 560,000 560,000 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

215 31248/78418 SHOP NEW LOOK RETAILERS LTD T 560,000 560,000 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

216 31249/78521 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 573,000 573,000 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

217 87668/72538 STANCE MILLIE'S COOKIES LTD T 18,000 18,000 MILLIE'S COOKIES LOWER MALL BON ACCORD CENTRE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

218 82764/71301 STANCE KAAYA SMILE LTD O 18,000 18,000 KAAYA UPPER MALL BON ACCORD CENTRE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

219 72205/76232 STANCE SKY RETAIL STORES LTD T 18,000 18,000 SKY RETAIL LOWER MALL BON ACCORD CENTRE WYMRE A ABERDEEN

220 4633/73514 SHOP MCCALL'S LTD P 11,250 11,250 11A BRIDGE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

221 4636/73517 SHOP MCCALL'S LTD T 48,500 48,500 15 BRIDGE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

222 4637/73617 SHOP AITKEN & NIVEN T 14,000 14,000 19 BRIDGE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

223 4667/70419 SHOP AMPLIFON LIMITED T 18,000 18,000 1A CHAPEL STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

08/03/2021 Page 16 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

224 4667/73609 SHOP DRUM PROPERTY GROUP LTD P 18,000 18,000 1A CHAPEL STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

225 95768/76655 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 19,000 19,000 13 CHAPEL STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

226 95768/79915 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 19,000 19,000 13 CHAPEL STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

227 88623/76658 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 13,750 13,750 15 CHAPEL STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

228 95684/77021 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 16,250 16,250 1A THISTLE STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

229 95685/76575 SHOP KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 18,000 18,000 1B THISTLE STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

230 4690/77913 SHOP ABERDEEN SOLICITORS' P 89,000 89,000 40 CHAPEL STREET PROPERTY CENTRE LTD ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

231 4727/75275 SHOP TRUSTEES OF GARIOCH PENSION FUND P 11,000 11,000 9 DIAMOND STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

232 4807/79005 SHOP ETC L'OCCITANE LTD T 36,500 36,500 1 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

233 4808/79245 OFFICE SANTANDER UK PLC P 57,500 57,500 93 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

234 4808/79921 OFFICE ASHOK KUMAR SOOD P 57,500 57,500 93 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN

235 4809/78572 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 21,250 21,250 101 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

236 33475/78490 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 23,500 23,500 105 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

237 4812/78499 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 20,000 20,000 119 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 17 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

238 35047/79061 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 22,250 22,250 123 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

239 4814/79271 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 21,000 21,000 127 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

240 33088/70927 SHOP SAVERS HEALTH & BEAUTY T 42,250 42,250 129 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

241 33088/79272 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 42,250 42,250 129 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

242 33997/78457 SHOP BLACKS OUTDOOR RETAIL LTD T 53,500 53,500 135 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

243 36248/76742 SHOP MAGNET GROUP T 46,750 46,750 139 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

244 36248/77210 SHOP MAGNET GROUP T 46,750 46,750 139 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

245 36248/79273 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 46,750 46,750 139 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

246 4822/75061 SHOP ABERDEEN PICTURE PALACES LTD P 13,000 13,000 193 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

247 36920/77761 SHOP INDIGO SUN RETAIL LTD T 19,500 19,500 209 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

248 4832/78176 SHOP JOHN LEWIS PLC P 1,450,000 1,450,000 88 GEORGE STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

249 4833/70414 SHOP GREGGS PLC T 29,750 29,750 166 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

250 4839/76133 SHOP NEVISPORT LTD T 38,500 38,500 186 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

251 4841/79425 SHOP FORPROP LIMITED P 22,000 22,000 196 GEORGE STREET ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 18 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

252 36384/71959 SHOP TOFT & TOFT LTD T 23,250 23,250 UNITS 3-4 T/A HANON-SHOP.COM GREEN ABERDEEN WYMRE A

253 4916/79918 HAIRDRESSING SALON OSMANS CUTS LTD T 15,250 15,250 26 GUILD STREET ABERDEEN

254 4933/76456 SHOP SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD T 42,000 42,000 54 GUILD STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

255 4933/77782 SHOP SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD T 42,000 42,000 54 GUILD STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

256 5035/79554 SHOP JO MALONE LTD T 44,000 44,000 41 LOCH STREET ABERDEEN JONES LANG LASALLE A

257 33392/79147 OFFICE THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,500 3,500 MANAGERS OFFICE UNIT 18 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

258 89632/79119 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 4,800 4,800 UNIT 1 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

259 89635/79112 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,200 6,200 UNIT 2 & 3 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

260 89638/79110 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,000 6,000 UNIT 4 & 5 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

261 89641/79097 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 13,000 13,000 UNIT 8-11 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

262 89643/79370 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 7,100 7,100 UNIT 12-13 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

263 89645/79371 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 4,300 4,300 UNIT 14 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

264 89647/79098 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 8,200 8,200 UNIT 15 & 16 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

265 89654/79372 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,600 3,600 UNIT 17 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 19 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

266 89695/79158 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 23,500 23,500 UNIT 19 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

267 89696/79149 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 5,000 5,000 UNIT 20 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

268 89697/79159 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,200 3,200 UNIT 22 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

269 89698/79162 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 9,100 9,100 UNIT 23 & 24 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

270 89699/79089 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 7,200 7,200 UNIT 25 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

271 89700/79135 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 4,500 4,500 UNIT 26 & 27A ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

272 89701/79090 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,200 2,200 UNIT 27B ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

273 89703/79103 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,200 2,200 UNIT 28 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

274 89704/79092 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,500 2,500 UNIT 29 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

275 89707/79120 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,300 6,300 UNIT 32 & 33 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

276 89708/79126 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,300 6,300 UNIT 34-36 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

277 89709/79096 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,600 2,600 UNIT 37 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

278 89710/79099 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,300 6,300 UNIT 38 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

279 89711/79100 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 5,800 5,800 UNIT 39 & 40 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 20 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

280 89712/79150 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 41 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

281 89713/79109 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 16,000 16,000 UNIT 42-47 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

282 89714/79122 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,200 3,200 UNIT 48 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

283 89715/79129 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 4,300 4,300 UNIT 49 &52 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

284 89717/79113 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,500 3,500 UNIT 50 & 51 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

285 89727/79107 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,900 2,900 UNIT 53 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

286 89728/79130 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 2,700 2,700 UNIT 54 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

287 89730/79093 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 7,100 7,100 UNIT 55, 57 & 58 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

288 89732/79111 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,300 3,300 UNIT 59 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

289 89733/79106 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 8,600 8,600 UNIT 60 & 61 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

290 89736/79102 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,000 3,000 UNIT 62 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

291 89737/79125 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 9,800 9,800 UNIT 63 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

292 89738/79121 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 12,000 12,000 UNIT 64-67 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

293 89739/79124 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 8,600 8,600 UNIT 68-71 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 21 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

294 89740/79091 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,700 6,700 UNIT 72-74 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

295 89741/79088 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,000 3,000 UNIT 75 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

296 89742/79137 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,400 3,400 UNIT 76 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

297 89743/79094 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,600 3,600 UNIT 77A ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

298 89744/79138 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,600 3,600 UNIT 77 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

299 89748/79095 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 5,900 5,900 UNIT 78 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

300 89685/79369 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 7,300 7,300 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 1 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

301 89686/79367 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,500 3,500 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 2 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

302 89687/79368 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 4,100 4,100 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 3 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

303 89688/79363 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 6,300 6,300 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 4 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

304 89690/79364 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 5,000 5,000 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 5 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

305 89691/79366 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 4,500 4,500 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 6 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

306 89693/79365 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 24,750 24,750 LOWER GROUND FLOOR UNIT 7 ABERDEEN MARKET RYDEN LLP A MARKET STREET

307 89642/79139 STORE THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 375 375 NO. 1 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 22 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

308 89644/79144 STORE THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 375 375 NO. 2 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

309 89648/79146 STORE THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 375 375 NO. 3 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

310 89731/79133 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 3,000 3,000 UNIT 56 ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

311 54497/79142 SHOP THE MARKET VILLAGE COMPANY T 46,250 46,250 LOWER FLOOR ABERDEEN MARKET MARKET STREET RYDEN LLP A

312 5092/76220 SHOP CAVERSHAM FINANCE LTD T 34,500 34,500 18 MARKET STREET T/A BRIGHTHOUSE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

313 5105/75664 SHOP ALISTAIR J EWEN P 15,000 15,000 30 MARKET STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

314 5121/79740 SHOP ROSEMOUNT TAVERNS LTD P 18,000 18,000 47 NETHERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN J & E SHEPHERD A

315 5122/79215 SHOP HOLLAND & BARRETT RETAIL LTD T 15,750 15,750 49 NETHERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

316 5133/74971 SHOP RONALD MURDOCH P 9,400 9,400 30 NORTHFIELD PLACE T/A SIGN DESIGNS (ABERDEEN) LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

317 33242/74909 SHOP MESSRS ANDERSON P 48,000 48,000 ANDERSON HOUSE ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

318 30435/71727 FUNERAL REST ROOM CO-OPERATIVE FUNERAL SERVICES LTD P 72,500 72,500 44 ROSE STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

319 5181/75117 SHOP CANCER RESEARCH UK T 15,750 15,750 19 ROSEMOUNT VIADUCT ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

320 36984/75270 SHOP CRAIGDON MOUNTAIN SPORTS P 34,250 34,250 3 ST ANDREW STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

321 5242/71794 SHOP TUI UK RETAIL LTD T 110,000 110,000 3 ST NICHOLAS STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

08/03/2021 Page 23 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

322 88496/76985 SHOP SCHUH LTD T 159,000 159,000 UNIT 3 7 ST NICHOLAS STREET ABERDEEN BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

323 88668/70933 SHOP JV LTD T 157,000 157,000 UNIT 2 7 ST NICHOLAS STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

324 88718/76347 SHOP TSB BANK PLC T 195,000 195,000 UNIT 4 7 ST NICHOLAS STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

325 88718/77503 SHOP TSB BANK PLC T 195,000 195,000 UNIT 4 7 ST NICHOLAS STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

326 5248/71887 SHOP MARKS & SPENCER PLC T 1,150,000 1,150,000 2 ST NICHOLAS STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

327 5249/76453 SUPERMARKET SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD T 164,000 164,000 UNIT W1 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

328 5249/76646 SUPERMARKET SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD T 164,000 164,000 UNIT W1 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

329 5249/79277 SUPERMARKET ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 164,000 164,000 UNIT W1 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

330 82392/79295 STORE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 20,000 20,000 BASEMENT UNIT W1 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

331 5250/75611 SHOP SPORTSWIFT LTD T 107,000 107,000 UNIT W2 T/A CARD FACTORY ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

332 5250/79413 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 107,000 107,000 UNIT W2 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

333 38984/70878 SHOP HUTCHISON 3G UK LTD T 71,000 71,000 UNIT W3 PER GERALD EVE ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

334 38984/78522 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 71,000 71,000 UNIT W3 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

335 5252/79412 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 71,000 71,000 UNIT W4 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 24 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

336 5252/79911 SHOP ELEGANCE BROW & BEAUTY T 71,000 71,000 UNIT W4 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN J & E SHEPHERD A

337 5253/75153 SHOP SIGNET GROUP PLC T 72,500 72,500 UNIT W5 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

338 5253/79411 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 70,500 70,500 UNIT W5 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

339 5254/75339 SHOP KAST RETAIL LTD T 145,000 145,000 UNIT W6 T/A QUIZ ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN BUSINESSRATESADVICE.COM A

340 5254/79300 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 145,000 145,000 UNIT W6 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

341 5255/79301 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 71,000 71,000 UNIT W7 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

342 5256/77014 SHOP THE BODY SHOP INTERNATIONAL PLC T 90,500 90,500 UNIT W8 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

343 5256/79270 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 90,500 90,500 UNIT W8 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

344 5257/70873 SHOP THE PERFUME SHOP LTD T 32,750 32,750 UNIT W9A ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

345 5257/79299 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 32,750 32,750 UNIT W9A ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

346 40572/77122 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 54,500 54,500 UNIT W9B ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

347 5258/70903 SHOP SUPERDRUG STORES PLC T 176,000 176,000 UNIT E1 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

348 5258/79291 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 176,000 176,000 UNIT E1 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

349 5259/76777 SHOP OFFICE HOLDINGS T 156,000 156,000 UNIT E2-E3 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

08/03/2021 Page 25 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

350 5259/79414 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 156,000 156,000 UNIT E2-E3 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

351 5260/79200 SHOP HOLLAND & BARRETT RETAIL LTD T 91,000 91,000 UNIT E4 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

352 5261/72753 SHOP W H SMITH GROUP PLC T 213,000 213,000 UNIT E5 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

353 5261/79292 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 213,000 213,000 UNIT E5 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

354 38071/79063 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 165,000 165,000 UNIT E8 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

355 83747/75361 SHOP DEICHMANN SHOES LTD T 230,000 230,000 UNIT E6 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

356 83747/79334 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 230,000 230,000 UNIT E6 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

357 95529/77137 STORE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 40,000 40,000 BASEMENT UNIT E6 ST NICHOLAS CENTRE EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

358 5266/79659 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 18,000 18,000 (KIOSK) ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

359 5266/80024 SHOP EUROCHANGE T 18,000 18,000 (KIOSK) ADMINISTRATION ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN

360 87223/70507 STANCES PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 4,500 4,500 PHOTO-ME & CANDY VAN ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

361 87223/79288 STANCES ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 4,500 4,500 PHOTO-ME & CANDY VAN ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

362 87223/79473 STANCES PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 4,500 4,500 PHOTO-ME & CANDY VAN ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

363 94009/79294 STANCE ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 18,000 18,000 MOBILE TECHNICIAN ST NICHOLAS CENTRE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 26 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

364 4563/75401 SHOP ESSON PROPERTIES LTD P 30,750 30,750 43 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

365 5276/79790 SHOP KELLY OF CULTS LTD P 11,750 11,750 59 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN GALBRAITH A

366 5280/75660 HAIRDRESSING SALON FEDERICO BERTON & KERRY BERTON T 35,500 35,500 4 SCHOOLHILL T/A ISPIRO ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

367 5280/79962 HAIRDRESSING SALON WORDIE PROPERTIES LIMITED P 35,500 35,500 4 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

368 5281/79960 HAIRDRESSING SALON WORDIE PROPERTIES LIMITED P 37,000 37,000 8 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

369 5282/79959 SHOP WORDIE PROPERTIES LIMITED P 33,500 33,500 14 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

370 5284/79958 SHOP WORDIE PROPERTIES LIMITED P 15,750 15,750 22 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

371 5285/78440 SHOP WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 39,500 39,500 24 SCHOOLHILL PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

372 5285/79948 SHOP WORDIE PROPERTIES LIMITED P 39,500 39,500 24 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

373 5288/71714 SHOP OLIVER BONAS T 91,000 91,000 46 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN FRASER & CO A

374 5288/75232 SHOP ESSON PROPERTIES LTD P 91,000 91,000 46 SCHOOLHILL ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

375 5333/79955 RESTAURANT MADAME MEWS LTD T 17,750 17,750 7 SUMMER STREET ABERDEEN

376 5353/76665 OFFICE ETC KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 37,750 37,750 1 THISTLE STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

377 5354/79071 OFFICE KAY ROSS & DAUGHTER P 36,250 36,250 2 THISTLE STREET PER CKD GALBRAITH ABERDEEN GALBRAITH A

08/03/2021 Page 27 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

378 5383/77657 SHOP LUSH RETAIL LTD T 42,500 42,500 81 UNION STREET ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

379 5383/77661 SHOP LUSH RETAIL LTD T 42,500 42,500 81 UNION STREET ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

380 5384/70853 SHOP KRM (GREAT BRITIAN) LTD T 75,000 75,000 85 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

381 5385/79681 SHOP DR MARTENS LTD T 92,000 92,000 87 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

382 5390/79546 SHOP BNP PARIBAS SECURITIES SERVICES P 650,000 650,000 91 UNION STREET TRUST COMPANY (JERSEY) LTD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

383 5391/76342 BANK HSBC BANK PLC T 215,000 215,000 95 UNION STREET PER CB RICHARD ELLIS ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

384 5391/77851 BANK HSBC BANK PLC T 215,000 215,000 95 UNION STREET PER CB RICHARD ELLIS ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

385 5400/70901 SHOP HUTCHISON 3G UK LTD T 82,000 82,000 105 UNION STREET PER GERALD EVE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

386 5400/75220 SHOP DEEDREAM LIMITED P 82,000 82,000 105 UNION STREET C/O TAYLORS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

387 5401/78453 SHOP JD SPORTS FASHION PLC T 105,000 105,000 107 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

388 31639/79247 SHOP SHOE ZONE LTD T 150,000 150,000 111 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

389 5403/70909 SHOP AURUM HOLDINGS LTD T 79,000 79,000 121 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

390 5405/70880 SHOP CANCER RESEARCH UK T 81,000 81,000 125 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

391 5405/75752 SHOP THE UNION STREET TRUST P 81,000 81,000 125 UNION STREET C/O TEMPLE PROPERTY SOLUTIONS LTD ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 28 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

392 5405/79132 SHOP CANCER RESEARCH UK T 81,000 81,000 125 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

393 48975/75531 SHOP HEATHER LTD P 35,250 35,250 1ST FLOOR & 2ND FLOOR 125 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

394 48975/76121 SHOP BRAVISSIMO LTD T 35,250 35,250 1ST FLOOR & 2ND FLOOR 125 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

395 5406/79239 SHOP EE LTD T 73,500 73,500 127 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

396 5411/79178 OFFICE NATIONWIDE BUILDING SOCIETY T 190,000 190,000 133 UNION STREET ABERDEEN LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON A

397 5412/76163 SHOP PRIMARK STORES LIMITED P 1,080,000 1,080,000 143 UNION STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

398 5413/77762 SHOP DUNCAN & TODD LTD T 47,750 47,750 UNIT 1A TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET GRAHAM & SIBBALD A ABERDEEN

399 5415/78484 SHOP HOLLAND & BARRETT RETAIL LTD T 50,000 50,000 UNIT 2 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

400 5416/77131 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 52,000 52,000 UNIT 3 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

401 5417/76891 SHOP TZ STORES LTD T 57,000 57,000 UNIT 4 T/A FLYING TIGER TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET DALTON WARNER DAVIS A ABERDEEN

402 5419/77087 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 205,000 205,000 UNIT 5-6 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

403 5420/75516 SHOP DEBENHAMS PROPERTIES LIMITED T 800,000 800,000 UNIT 7 PER KEVIN WALSH TRINITY CENTRE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 155 UNION STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

404 5420/78465 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 800,000 800,000 UNIT 7 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

405 5421/77009 SHOP SCHUH LTD T 60,000 60,000 UNIT 8 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 29 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

406 5421/77132 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 60,000 60,000 UNIT 8 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

407 5422/76976 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 47,250 47,250 UNIT 9 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

408 5423/70377 SHOP ETC GREGGS PLC T 58,500 58,500 UNIT 10 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

409 35474/70906 SHOP SUPERDRUG STORES PLC T 117,000 117,000 UNIT 13 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

410 5427/75492 SHOP SPORTSWIFT LTD T 89,500 89,500 UNIT 18 T/A CARD FACTORY TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

411 5428/70796 SHOP SIGNET GROUP PLC T 33,750 33,750 UNIT 19 T/A ERNEST JONES TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

412 5430/70396 SHOP SIGNET GROUP PLC T 33,250 33,250 UNIT 21 T/A H SAMUEL TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

413 5431/76999 SHOP TRESPASS EUROPE LTD T 94,000 94,000 UNIT 22-25 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET DALTON WARNER DAVIS A ABERDEEN

414 5433/77088 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 21,000 21,000 UNIT 26 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

415 5434/79241 SHOP TIMPSON LTD T 28,750 28,750 UNIT 27 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

416 82845/71302 SHOP KAAYA ENTERPRISES LTD T 27,500 27,500 UNIT 28 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN

417 82845/78446 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 27,500 27,500 UNIT 28 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

418 5438/76147 SHOP WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD T 35,500 35,500 UNIT 30 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET DELOITTE LLP A ABERDEEN

419 5438/76188 SHOP WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD T 35,500 35,500 UNIT 30 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET DELOITTE LLP A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 30 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

420 5438/79952 SHOP WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD T 35,500 35,500 UNIT 30 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET DELOITTE LLP A ABERDEEN

421 94781/79449 STANCE LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 15,000 15,000 SITE 14B TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

422 51844/79415 STANCE LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 15,000 15,000 SITE 6 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

423 88719/78470 STANCE LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 15,000 15,000 SITE 10 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

424 64284/78458 STANCE LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 15,000 15,000 ZUMO TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

425 72223/76231 STANCE SKY UK LTD T 15,000 15,000 SITE 7 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET WYMRE A ABERDEEN

426 72223/79660 STANCE LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 15,000 15,000 SITE 7 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

427 81780/79447 STANCE LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 15,000 15,000 SITE 4 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A ABERDEEN

428 82440/70385 STANCES PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 6,000 6,000 SITE 12A & LEVEL 2 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

429 82440/79479 STANCES PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 6,000 6,000 SITE 12A & LEVEL 2 TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

430 92147/80025 KIOSK EUROCHANGE T 20,000 20,000 SITE 13 ADMINISTRATION TRINITY CENTRE 155 UNION STREET ABERDEEN

431 5442/77085 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 316,000 316,000 3-7 UNION BRIDGE UNION STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

432 5442/79646 SHOP POUNDLAND LTD T 316,000 316,000 3-7 UNION BRIDGE UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

433 5446/77090 SHOP LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L P 247,000 247,000 11 UNION BRIDGE UNION STREET ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

08/03/2021 Page 31 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

434 5446/78044 SHOP HMV RETAIL LTD T 247,000 247,000 11 UNION BRIDGE PER TWICE2MUCH LTD UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

435 35566/78455 SHOP BLACK OUTDOOR RETAIL T 58,500 58,500 159 UNION STREET FAO HEATHER RYDER ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

436 33052/78476 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 88,500 88,500 161 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

437 35567/79657 BANK BARCLAYS BANK PLC T 102,000 102,000 163 UNION STREET ABERDEEN JONES LANG LASALLE A

438 5450/79974 SHOP OPTICAL EXPRESS (GYLE) LTD T 70,000 70,000 40 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

439 5474/78415 SHOP WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 36,500 36,500 48 UNION STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

440 5475/79004 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 45,500 45,500 50 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

441 5479/70904 SHOP SPECSAVERS OPTICAL STORES LTD T 69,000 69,000 56 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

442 5482/78548 BANK CLYDESDALE BANK PLC T 205,000 205,000 62 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

443 5485/76379 SHOP BRIDGEPORT ESTATES LTD P 38,500 38,500 82 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

444 5485/79799 SHOP PROFESSIONAL REPAIR LTD T 38,500 38,500 82 UNION STREET ABERDEEN

445 5486/76319 SHOP BRIDGEPORT ESTATES LTD P 34,250 34,250 86 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

446 5486/79169 SHOP TIMPSON LIMITED T 34,250 34,250 86 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

447 5487/71917 SHOP MICHAEL JAMES (JEWELLERS) LTD O 35,250 35,250 88 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

08/03/2021 Page 32 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

448 33082/79516 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 56,500 56,500 98 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A

449 54143/76997 SHOP MOLTON BROWN T 51,500 51,500 118 UNION STREET ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

450 54143/79777 SHOP MILVERTON PROPERTIES LTD P 51,500 51,500 118 UNION STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

451 5498/79006 SHOP POUNDSTRETCHER LTD T 155,000 155,000 122 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

452 5505/76380 SHOP BRIDGEPORT ESTATES LTD P 33,500 33,500 128 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

453 5505/79196 SHOP RAMSDENS FINANCIAL LTD T 33,500 33,500 128 UNION STREET ABERDEEN LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON A

454 5506/70659 SHOP MARTIN THE NEWSAGENT LTD T 29,000 29,000 130 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

455 40390/75094 SHOP INSTANT CASH LOANS LTD T 47,000 47,000 132 UNION STREET T/A THE MONEY SHOP ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

456 5508/75189 SHOP ALL SAINTS RETAIL LTD T 84,500 84,500 136 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

457 5508/79692 SHOP JAMIESON & CARRY P 84,500 84,500 136 UNION STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

458 5516/75789 SHOP JAMIESON & CARRY P 115,000 115,000 140 UNION STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

459 5536/70837 BETTING OFFICE DONE BROTHERS T 39,000 39,000 164 UNION STREET (CASH BETTING) LTD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

460 5538/76375 SHOP FLIGHT CENTRE (UK) LTD T 77,500 77,500 172 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

461 5540/76233 SHOP 1US (ABERDEEN) LTD T 36,000 36,000 196 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

08/03/2021 Page 33 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

462 5541/79008 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 40,250 40,250 198 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

463 5543/75062 SHOP BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION T 45,250 45,250 202 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

464 5558/76123 SURGERY JASWINDER S DHARIWAL T 35,000 35,000 218 UNION STREET T/A SMILE DENTAL CARE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

465 5561/75465 OFFICE DIGBY BROWN SOLICITORS T 42,000 42,000 GROUND FLOOR 220 UNION STREET ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

466 5561/76212 OFFICE H & N DEVELOPMENTS LLP P 42,000 42,000 GROUND FLOOR 220 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

467 5568/76157 SHOP FLOWER OF SCOTLAND LTD P 41,250 41,250 226 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

468 5570/79407 OFFICE SKIPTON BUILDING SOCIETY P 42,750 42,750 230 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

469 5575/74998 SHOP BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION T 81,500 81,500 CALEDONIAN HOUSE 238 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

470 5579/79176 OFFICE NATIONWIDE BUILDING SOCIETY P 49,500 49,500 250 UNION STREET ABERDEEN LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON A

471 5584/73501 SHOP JOHN SEABROOK & JOHN C REAL P 21,250 21,250 252A UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

472 5585/73503 SHOP JOHN SEABROOK & JOHN C REAL P 16,250 16,250 252B UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

473 5589/75666 SHOP GROSVENOR (ABERDEEN) LTD T 36,250 36,250 256 UNION STREET T/A SIGNATURE 2 ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

474 5595/76216 BANK NATWEST GROUP PROPERTY P 121,000 121,000 262 UNION STREET ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

475 5600/72754 SHOP W H SMITH GROUP PLC T 54,000 54,000 408 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 34 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

476 5601/79816 SHOP JOHN MATHIESON (FOOTFITTERS) LTD P 36,000 36,000 414 UNION STREET ABERDEEN DM HALL LLP A

477 5608/70407 SHOP GREGGS PLC T 41,500 41,500 446 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

478 80799/71280 SHOP ANTHONY JAMES DAWSON & OTHERS T 16,000 16,000 450 UNION STREET PER JAMES & GEORGE COLLIE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

479 5643/73418 HAIRDRESSING SALON UNION SALON LIMITED T 17,000 17,000 44 UNION TERRACE T/A ELLEES HAIR DESIGN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

480 5661/77819 SHOP ANDREW BEGG & PARTNERS P 34,250 34,250 24 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

481 31194/78565 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 17,750 17,750 34 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

482 31194/79442 SHOP ABERDEEN JOURNALS LTD T 17,750 17,750 34 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

483 33798/78504 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 24,750 24,750 38 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

484 33799/71894 SHOP STA TRAVEL LTD T 26,750 26,750 30 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

485 33799/78491 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 26,750 26,750 30 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

486 5669/77947 SHOP DIGNITY FUNERALS LTD T 21,250 21,250 42 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

487 5669/78514 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 21,250 21,250 42 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

488 5670/78493 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 20,000 20,000 46 UPPERKIRKGATE ABERDEEN EYCO CHARTERED SURVEYORS A

489 5702/75743 SHOP JOHN & CHARLES MICHIE & P 8,500 8,500 136 QUEEN'S ROAD RUSSELL & SYLVIA DUTHIE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 35 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

490 5703/75736 SHOP JOHN & CHARLES MICHIE & P 10,000 10,000 142 QUEEN'S ROAD RUSSELL & SYLVIA DUTHIE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

491 5725/77058 GARDEN CENTRE BENJAMIN REID & CO T 99,000 99,000 PINEWOOD NURSERY COUNTESSWELLS ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

492 5746/70627 SHOP MARTIN MCCOLL LTD P 19,250 19,250 161 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

493 5750/72634 SURGERY TOWN & COUNTRY VETERINARY GROUP P 10,000 10,000 5 RUBISLAW PARK ROAD ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

494 5829/74506 SALON ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 6,700 6,700 24 CLAREMONT STREET PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

495 5849/74134 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 4,800 4,800 4 GRANTON PLACE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

496 5853/75869 SHOP GROUP LTD P 80,000 80,000 6 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

497 5867/70852 OFFICE TUV SUD LTD T 31,750 31,750 166 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

498 5900/75095 SHOP J G ROSS (HOLDINGS) LTD P 8,800 8,800 58 HOLBURN STREET C/O J G ROSS ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

499 5904/78454 SHOPS ALPINE BIKES LTD T 37,750 37,750 70 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

500 5979/79793 STUDIO FORDEK LTD P 22,750 22,750 122 BROOMHILL ROAD ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

501 6041/73403 SHOP N SAINSBURY & SONS P 21,750 21,750 196 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

502 6049/75410 SHOP GRAMPIAN CREDIT UNION LTD T 15,000 15,000 224 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

503 6064/78385 SHOP ALISON WALLER P 9,600 9,600 286 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 36 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

504 33733/76080 SHOP SLATER MENSWEAR LTD P 81,000 81,000 10 BON-ACCORD STREET ABERDEEN WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

505 36456/70554 SHOP EFB HOLDINGS LLP T 43,250 43,250 10 BON-ACCORD STREET WHITTALLS WINE MERCHANTS ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

506 36456/76081 SHOP SLATER MENSWEAR LTD P 43,250 43,250 10 BON-ACCORD STREET ABERDEEN WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

507 6279/75407 SHOP ULTRA CATERING LTD T 17,250 17,250 53 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

508 6293/75720 SHOP JOHN C A MICHIE & P 26,500 26,500 115 HOLBURN STREET CHARLES A MICHIE ABERDEEN PER JOHN MICHIE F G BURNETT LTD A

509 6323/79163 SHOP ALISON WALLER P 9,400 9,400 263 HOLBURN STREET T/A PERFECT BRIDAL ROOMS LIMITED ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

510 6324/78384 SHOP ALISON WALLER P 21,500 21,500 265 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

511 6353/78405 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE P 1,500 1,500 471 HOLBURN STREET ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

512 6428/75735 SHOP GROSVENOR (ABERDEEN) LTD T 33,250 33,250 349 UNION STREET T/A SIGNATURE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

513 6430/70752 OFFICE YORKSHIRE BUILDING SOCIETY P 26,250 26,250 355 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

514 6441/76327 SHOP SCOTTISH ENTERPRISE T 44,000 44,000 377 UNION STREET PER TINA CRAIG ABERDEEN WYMRE A

515 6444/71099 SHOP SKILLS DEVELOPMENT SCOTLAND T 60,500 60,500 383 UNION STREET ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

516 6445/75744 SHOP TRUSTEES OF THE LATE P 86,500 86,500 387 UNION STREET CHARLES A MICHIE ABERDEEN PER JOHN MICHIE F G BURNETT LTD A

517 6453/79296 SHOP VIRGIN MONEY PLC T 39,250 39,250 395 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

08/03/2021 Page 37 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

518 6454/70596 OFFICE RAEBURN CHRISTIE CLARK & WALLACE T 38,000 38,000 399 UNION STREET ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

519 88740/76811 STORE BRITISH OVERSEAS BANK NOMINEES LTD P 450 450 LEVEL B4 & WGTC NOMINEES LTD THE CAPITOL 431 UNION STREET CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

520 88740/77026 STORE PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP T 450 450 LEVEL B4 THE CAPITOL 431 UNION STREET CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

521 88740/77490 STORE PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP T 450 450 LEVEL B4 THE CAPITOL 431 UNION STREET CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

522 88740/77497 STORE BRITISH OVERSEAS BANK NOMINEES LTD P 450 450 LEVEL B4 & WGTC NOMINEES LTD THE CAPITOL 431 UNION STREET CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

523 6475/72704 OFFICE BRITISH AIRWAYS PENSION P 35,500 35,500 463 UNION STREET TRUSTEES LTD ABERDEEN WYMRE A

524 31217/78954 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 35,500 35,500 469 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

525 61103/78442 BETTING OFFICE WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 53,000 53,000 475 UNION STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

526 6488/75992 POST OFFICE POST OFFICE COUNTERS LTD P 74,000 74,000 489 UNION STREET PER POST OFFICE PROPERTY HOLDINGS ABERDEEN BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

527 33842/73506 SHOP MCCALL'S LTD P 12,000 12,000 2 BATH STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

528 33132/73623 SHOP IAIN HAWTHORNE P 11,750 11,750 6 BATH STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

529 6668/75515 SHOPS MORNING NOON & NIGHT LTD P 12,250 12,250 131 CROWN STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

530 6745/78553 SHOP ETC YEARGRAPH LTD P 19,750 19,750 7 DEE STREET ABERDEEN J & E SHEPHERD A

531 6847/72756 SHOP W H SMITH RETAIL HOLDINGS O 93,500 93,500 JOINT STATION ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 38 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

532 6873/75550 SHOP CHALMERS BAKERY LTD T 4,600 4,600 152 MARKET STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

533 82077/75931 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 250,000 250,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL GL HEARN LIMITED A

534 82077/79422 SHOP CULT RETAIL LLP T 250,000 250,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN HARPER DENNIS HOBBS A

535 82078/75920 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 295,000 295,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

536 82078/76338 SHOP REPUBLIC.COM RETAIL LTD T 295,000 295,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

537 82078/77557 SHOP REPUBLIC.COM RETAIL LTD T 295,000 295,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

538 82306/75352 SHOP DEICHMANN SHOES LTD T 283,000 283,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

539 82306/75889 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 283,000 283,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

540 82079/75909 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 368,000 368,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

541 82079/79238 SHOP RIVER ISLAND T 368,000 368,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL PROPERTY DEPARTMENT UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

542 82080/75918 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 286,000 286,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

543 82080/79170 SHOP FAT FACE LTD T 286,000 286,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

544 82081/75943 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 305,000 305,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

545 82081/76087 SHOP ZARA UK LTD T 305,000 305,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

08/03/2021 Page 39 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

546 82082/75945 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 174,000 174,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

547 82082/79282 SHOP JOULES LTD T 174,000 174,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

548 83308/70617 SHOP VF NORTHERN EUROPE LTD T 173,000 173,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

549 83308/75970 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 173,000 173,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

550 83308/77582 SHOP VF NORTHERN EUROPE LTD T 173,000 173,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

551 82083/75872 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 172,000 172,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

552 82916/75939 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 173,000 173,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

553 82916/79384 SHOP LEVI STRAUSS LTD T 173,000 173,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

554 83641/75955 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 136,000 136,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

555 83641/79394 SHOP ESTEE LAUDER T 136,000 136,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN JONES LANG LASALLE A

556 85910/75932 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 225,000 225,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

557 85910/79253 SHOP THE WHITE COMPANY T 225,000 225,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

558 82085/75873 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 190,000 190,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

559 82085/79435 SHOP BESTSELLER RETAIL UK LTD T 190,000 190,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN HARPER DENNIS HOBBS A

08/03/2021 Page 40 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

560 84740/75996 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 75,000 75,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

561 84740/76061 SHOP SATSUMAHILL PROPERTIES LTD T 75,000 75,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL T/A HOTEL CHOCOLAT UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN ALLSOP LLP A

562 82086/75877 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 143,000 143,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

563 82086/76175 SHOP ROX (UK) LIMITED T 143,000 143,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN AVISON YOUNG A

564 82087/75935 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 189,000 189,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

565 83611/75948 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 180,000 180,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

566 83611/79628 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 180,000 180,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A

567 83492/75958 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 182,000 182,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

568 83492/79204 SHOP THE CARPHONE WAREHOUSE T 182,000 182,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

569 83999/75953 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 182,000 182,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

570 83999/76230 SHOP THE DUNE GROUP T 182,000 182,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

571 82088/75969 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 355,000 355,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

572 82088/78969 SHOP H & M HENNES & MAURITZ (UK) LTD T 355,000 355,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

573 82436/75870 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 322,000 322,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

08/03/2021 Page 41 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

574 82436/77000 SHOP AFH STORES (UK) LTD T 322,000 322,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

575 84105/75976 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 203,000 203,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

576 82089/75011 SHOP BOUX AVENUE LTD T 191,000 191,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

577 82089/75878 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 191,000 191,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

578 82090/72718 SHOP PAPERCHASE PRODUCTS LIMITED T 174,000 174,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

579 82090/75924 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 174,000 174,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

580 82091/70439 SHOP T M LEWIN & SONS LTD T 176,000 176,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL ACCOUNTS DEPARTMENT UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

581 82091/75959 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 176,000 176,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

582 83114/75946 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 180,000 180,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

583 83114/79786 SHOP SKETCHERS USA LTD T 180,000 180,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

584 82094/73368 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 310,000 310,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

585 82094/77008 SHOP APPLE RETAIL UK LTD T 310,000 310,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL C/O BAYRAM VICKERY MEECH UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

586 83106/75927 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 160,000 160,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

587 83106/79418 SHOP FOSSIL UK LTD T 160,000 160,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN HARPER DENNIS HOBBS A

08/03/2021 Page 42 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

588 82098/75887 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 325,000 325,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

589 82098/78485 SHOP NEXT PLC T 325,000 325,000 GROUND LEVEL MALL ESTATES DEPARTMENT UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

590 82130/75888 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R5 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

591 82130/79026 STANCE COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 27,000 27,000 R5 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

592 82906/75871 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R4 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

593 82939/75874 STANCES UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 6,000 6,000 UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

594 87838/79249 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R9 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

595 87838/79924 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R9 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

596 88481/75902 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R7 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

597 84029/70542 SHOP GREGGS PLC T 24,500 24,500 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

598 84029/76014 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 24,500 24,500 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

599 83266/75951 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R6 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

600 85579/75961 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 27,000 27,000 R11 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

601 85579/79025 STANCE KRISPY KREME UK LTD T 27,000 27,000 R11 GROUND LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 43 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

602 82076/72755 KIOSK W H SMITH RETAIL HOLDINGS T 30,000 30,000 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

603 82076/75944 KIOSK UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 30,000 30,000 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

604 87837/72700 STANCE MR PRETZEL (UK) RETAIL LTD T 33,000 33,000 R1 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE WYMRE A ABERDEEN

605 87837/79947 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 33,000 33,000 R1 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

606 82103/75950 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 150,000 150,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

607 82103/79684 SHOP COTTON ON UK (PTY) LIMITED T 150,000 150,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN HARPER DENNIS HOBBS A

608 82100/70884 SHOP THE PERFUME SHOP LTD T 82,500 82,500 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

609 82100/75988 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 82,500 82,500 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

610 82101/75954 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 128,000 128,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

611 82101/76128 SHOP PYRRHA LTD T 128,000 128,000 THE ATRIUM T/A PANDORA UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN WYMRE A

612 82093/70647 SHOP BARRHEAD TRAVEL SERVICES LTD T 165,500 165,500 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN BUSINESSRATESADVICE.COM A

613 82093/75962 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 165,500 165,500 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

614 83519/75930 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 4,900 4,900 STORE 36 REAR OF THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

615 83519/79654 STORE THE PERFUME SHOP LTD T 4,900 4,900 STORE 36 REAR OF THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 44 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

616 84354/75960 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 33,000 33,000 R2 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

617 84354/79029 STANCE KRISPY KREME UK LTD T 33,000 33,000 R2 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

618 82307/75875 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 122,000 122,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

619 82307/76468 SHOP MONSOON ACCESSORIZE LTD T 122,000 122,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

620 82307/77571 SHOP MONSOON ACCESSORIZE LTD T 122,000 122,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

621 82092/75968 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 360,000 360,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

622 82092/78394 SHOP NEW LOOK RETAILERS LTD T 360,000 360,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

623 82095/75963 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 320,000 320,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

624 82095/79235 SHOP COTSWOLD OUTDOOR LIMITED T 320,000 320,000 THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

625 86600/70930 STORE PIZZA EXPRESS (RESTAURANTS) LTD T 2,200 2,200 STORE 24 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

626 86601/75926 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,200 2,200 STORE 25 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

627 87534/75914 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,600 2,600 STORE 26 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

628 87534/79032 STORE KRISPY KREME UK LTD T 2,600 2,600 STORE 26 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

629 87535/75929 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,500 2,500 STORE 27 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 45 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

630 87535/79030 STORE KRISPY KREME UK LTD T 2,500 2,500 STORE 27 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE MONTAGU EVANS A ABERDEEN

631 87536/75892 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 3,000 3,000 STORE 29 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

632 86784/75977 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,050 2,050 STORE 30 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

633 87537/70405 STORE COAST TO COAST T 2,500 2,500 STORE 31 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

634 87537/75907 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,500 2,500 STORE 31 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

635 86603/78111 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,600 2,600 STORE 32 REAR OF FS13 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

636 85652/76001 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 4,900 4,900 STORE 15 REAR OF FS14 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

637 85653/75919 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 4,900 4,900 STORE 16 REAR OF FS14 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

638 85653/79233 STORE JOULES LTD T 4,900 4,900 STORE 16 REAR OF FS14 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

639 85654/75942 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 4,400 4,400 STORE 17 REAR OF FS14 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

640 82594/75936 SALON UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 70,000 70,000 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

641 84335/75606 STORE TGI FRIDAYS UK LTD T 1,550 1,550 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 1 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

642 84335/75941 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 1,550 1,550 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 1 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

643 84336/75890 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,350 2,350 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 3 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 46 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

644 84336/76109 STORE COSTA LTD T 2,350 2,350 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 3 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

645 84337/75978 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,300 2,300 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 4 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

646 84337/76112 STORE COSTA LTD T 2,300 2,300 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 4 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

647 84339/75894 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 1,550 1,550 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 5 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

648 84340/70871 STORE YO! SUSHI UK LIMITED T 2,400 2,400 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 7 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

649 84340/75896 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,400 2,400 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 7 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

650 84340/77671 STORE YO! SUSHI UK LIMITED T 2,400 2,400 CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 7 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

651 90592/75901 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,350 2,350 STORE 33 REAR OF THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

652 90593/75906 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,350 2,350 STORE 34 REAR OF THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

653 90594/75922 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,350 2,350 STORE 35 REAR OF THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

654 90594/79637 STORE COSTA LTD T 2,350 2,350 STORE 35 REAR OF THE ATRIUM UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

655 84628/75721 HAIRDRESSING SALON HAIR UNION SQUARE LTD T 65,500 65,500 FIRST LEVEL MALL T/A SAKS HAIR & BEAUTY UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

656 84628/76016 HAIRDRESSING SALON UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 65,500 65,500 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

657 82111/75964 SHOP UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 240,000 240,000 SOUTH TERRACE UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

08/03/2021 Page 47 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

658 82111/78468 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 240,000 240,000 SOUTH TERRACE UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

659 82126/70501 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

660 82126/75966 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 3,000 3,000 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

661 82126/79470 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 EAST MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

662 82127/70380 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

663 82127/76017 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 3,000 3,000 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

664 82127/79468 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 3,000 3,000 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

665 84355/75898 STANCE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 10,000 10,000 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

666 83231/75947 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,550 2,550 STORE 10 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

667 83231/78941 STORE LTD T 2,550 2,550 STORE 10 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

668 83232/75879 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,550 2,550 STORE 11 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

669 91873/70502 STORE WAGAMAMA LTD T 6,100 6,100 STORE 39 REAR OF FS2 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A ABERDEEN

670 91873/75993 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 6,100 6,100 STORE 39 REAR OF FS2 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

671 92073/75851 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 6,100 6,100 STORE 38 REAR OF FS2 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

08/03/2021 Page 48 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

672 92073/79036 STORE COSTA LTD T 6,100 6,100 STORE 38 REAR OF FS2 FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

673 83233/75967 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,550 2,550 STORE 12 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

674 83234/75882 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 2,550 2,550 STORE 13 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

675 83235/75952 STORE UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD P 5,100 5,100 STORE 14 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GL HEARN LIMITED A ABERDEEN

676 83235/78953 STORE TGI FRIDAYS UK LTD T 5,100 5,100 STORE 14 REAR OF FS2A FIRST LEVEL MALL UNION SQUARE GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

677 7207/70890 SHOP SALLY SALON SERVICES LTD T 64,500 64,500 167 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

678 7207/79134 SHOP SALLY SALON SERVICES LTD T 64,500 64,500 167 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

679 7208/79181 BANK SANTANDER UK PLC T 71,500 71,500 171 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

680 7214/79212 BETTING OFFICE POWER LEISURE BOOKMAKERS LTD T 36,500 36,500 175 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

681 7218/76618 SHOP AKZO NOBEL CIF NOMINEES LTD & P 64,000 64,000 181 UNION STREET AKZO NOBEL (CPS) PENSION SCHEME ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

682 7218/77281 SHOP AKZO NOBEL CIF NOMINEES LTD & P 64,000 64,000 181 UNION STREET AKZO NOBEL (CPS) PENSION SCHEME ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

683 53825/70650 SHOP NHS GRAMPIAN T 32,500 32,500 181B UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

684 53825/72748 SHOP NHS GRAMPIAN T 32,500 32,500 181B UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

685 53825/76617 SHOP AKZO NOBEL CIF NOMINEES LTD & P 32,500 32,500 181B UNION STREET AKZO NOBEL (CPS) PENSION SCHEME ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 49 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

686 53825/77787 SHOP AKZO NOBEL CIF NOMINEES LTD & P 32,500 32,500 181B UNION STREET AKZO NOBEL (CPS) PENSION SCHEME ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

687 7220/79033 SHOP ANN SUMMERS T 56,000 56,000 183 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

688 7222/72587 SHOP G & J INVESTMENTS (ABERDEEN) LTD P 35,750 35,750 187 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

689 7226/76356 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 59,000 59,000 201 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

690 7226/77870 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 59,000 59,000 201 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

691 7228/78443 BETTING OFFICE WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 22,250 22,250 207 UNION STREET PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

692 7230/79034 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 26,500 26,500 209 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A

693 7232/77937 SHOP MACADAM LEISURE LTD P 18,750 18,750 215 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

694 7233/77938 SHOP MACADAM LEISURE LTD P 24,000 24,000 219 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

695 7236/76392 SHOP SCOTTISH EQUITABLE PLC P 23,250 23,250 225 UNION STREET ABERDEEN WYMRE A

696 7238/80008 SHOP GILLILAND INVESTMENTS LTD P 41,000 41,000 229 UNION STREET ABERDEEN SANDERS CARTWRIGHT A

697 7239/75187 SHOP AFZAL KHUSHI & AKMAL KHUSHI P 29,750 29,750 231 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

698 7241/76334 SHOP CRUISE CLOTHING LTD T 83,000 83,000 247 UNION STREET PER GL HEARN MANAGEMENT LTD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

699 7241/78087 SHOP CRUISE CLOTHING LTD T 83,000 83,000 247 UNION STREET PER GL HEARN MANAGEMENT LTD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 50 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

700 7251/78017 SHOP LASERCARE CLINICS (HARROGATE) LTD T 45,500 45,500 261 UNION STREET ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A

701 7253/73373 SHOP MUNRO'S TRAVEL GROUP P 33,500 33,500 265 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

702 49620/73646 SHOP IAIN C C HAWTHORNE P 6,000 6,000 5 WINDMILL BRAE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

703 7323/70662 BETTING OFFICE CORAL RACING LTD P 5,700 5,700 33 GLENBERVIE ROAD CORAL GALA GROUP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

704 7368/74057 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 4,100 4,100 22 MENZIES ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

705 7528/75548 SHOP CO-OPERATIVE FUNERAL SERVICES LTD T 9,500 9,500 59 VICTORIA ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

706 7535/75109 SHOP J G ROSS (BAKERS) LTD T 9,000 9,000 83 VICTORIA ROAD ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

707 7596/74068 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 9,500 9,500 64 VICTORIA ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

708 7598/76365 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 14,000 14,000 70 VICTORIA ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

709 7598/77404 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 14,000 14,000 70 VICTORIA ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

710 7640/70665 SHOP CORAL RACING LTD P 3,900 3,900 25 BALNAGASK ROAD CORAL GALA GROUP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

711 7707/77803 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 28,750 28,750 475 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

712 7707/78475 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 28,750 28,750 475 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GL HEARN LIMITED A

713 7708/77805 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 20,500 20,500 477 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

08/03/2021 Page 51 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

714 7708/77848 SHOP DUNCAN & TODD LTD T 20,500 20,500 477 GREAT WESTERN ROAD T/A DOUGLAS DICKIE ABERDEEN OPTICIANS GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

715 7709/77806 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 22,250 22,250 479 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

716 7710/77802 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 22,000 22,000 481 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

717 7711/77807 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 20,500 20,500 481A GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

718 7712/77808 SHOP CITY ANGEL LTD P 24,750 24,750 483 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

719 7716/76358 BANK TSB BANK PLC T 38,000 38,000 497 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

720 7716/77403 BANK TSB BANK PLC T 38,000 38,000 497 GREAT WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

721 31175/77879 SHOP DP REALITY LTD T 23,250 23,250 UNIT 1 T/A DOMINO'S PIZZA THE COURTYARD NORTH DEESIDE ROAD WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A CULTS

722 31176/76111 SHOP COSTA LTD T 26,750 26,750 UNIT 2-3 THE COURTYARD NORTH DEESIDE ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A CULTS

723 31178/79421 SHOP SCOTT GILMOUR LTD T 16,000 16,000 UNIT 5 T/A SCOTT GILMOUR OPTOMETRISTS THE COURTYARD NORTH DEESIDE ROAD KNIGHT FRANK LLP A CULTS

724 35238/79525 VETERINARY SURGERY ABERVET 2015 LTD T 7,900 7,900 UNIT 8 THE COURTYARD NORTH DEESIDE ROAD WHITESTONE COMMERCIAL LTD A CULTS

725 7784/70795 SHOP LLOYDS PHARMACY LTD P 22,250 22,250 359 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD CULTS COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

726 7785/78412 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE LIMITED T 5,000 5,000 363 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD CULTS KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

727 7795/76507 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 32,250 32,250 389 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD CULTS CBRE LTD A

08/03/2021 Page 52 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

728 7795/77428 BANK BANK OF SCOTLAND P 32,250 32,250 389 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD CULTS CBRE LTD A

729 7807/79788 POST OFFICE KELLY OF CULTS LTD P 10,750 10,750 324 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD CULTS GALBRAITH A

730 31855/70669 BETTING OFFICE CORAL RACING LTD T 5,800 5,800 AUCHINYELL ROAD CORAL GALA GROUP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

731 7921/75662 STUDIO MICHELLE ROSS T 14,750 14,750 1A RUTHRIE TERRACE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

732 7922/75830 OFFICE GARIOCH DEVELOPMENT CO LTD P 7,300 7,300 1B RUTHRIE TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

733 7944/74060 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 4,300 4,300 1 RAMSAY CRESCENT PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

734 7952/70649 SHOP R S MCCOLL T 2,900 2,900 8 ABBOTSWELL CRESCENT MARTIN MCCOLL LIMITED ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

735 7953/70648 SHOP T M RETAIL GROUP P 2,900 2,900 8A ABBOTSWELL CRESCENT ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

736 7979/70668 SHOP MARTIN RETAIL GROUP PLC T 6,900 6,900 KINCORTH SHOPPING CENTRE PROVOST WATT DRIVE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

737 7982/76351 BANK TSB BANK PLC T 11,750 11,750 5-6 KINCORTH SHOPPING CENTRE PROVOST WATT DRIVE CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

738 7982/77399 BANK TSB BANK PLC T 11,750 11,750 5-6 KINCORTH SHOPPING CENTRE PROVOST WATT DRIVE CBRE LTD A ABERDEEN

739 7997/70644 SHOP MARTIN RETAIL GROUP PLC T 12,750 12,750 56 GARDNER DRIVE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

740 7999/74455 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 4,900 4,900 62 GARDNER DRIVE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

741 8014/73946 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 3 FINNAN PLACE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 53 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

742 8015/74047 SHOP ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 5,300 5,300 7 FINNAN PLACE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A

743 8027/70622 SHOP MARTIN THE NEWSAGENT LTD T 10,000 10,000 242 NORTH BALNAGASK ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

744 8111/70654 SHOP MARTIN RETAIL GROUP PLC T 10,250 10,250 BERVIE BROW ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A

745 8480/70623 POST OFFICE MARTIN MCCOLL LIMITED T 11,000 11,000 5 LOIRSTON ROAD COVE BAY GERALD EVE LLP A

746 8672/75536 SHOP MORNING NOON & NIGHT LTD P 26,000 26,000 47 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD BIELDSIDE RYDEN LLP A

747 8677/72636 SURGERY TOWN & COUNTRY VETERINARY GROUP T 14,000 14,000 SUMMERVILLE 91 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD BIELDSIDE F G BURNETT LTD A

748 8758/78414 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE LTD T 7,800 7,800 163 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PER GREGOR FORRESTER PETERCULTER KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

749 8765/76349 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 19,250 19,250 241 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PETERCULTER CBRE LTD A

750 8765/77398 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 19,250 19,250 241 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PETERCULTER CBRE LTD A

751 8766/79792 VETERINARY SURGERY KELLY OF CULTS LTD P 12,000 12,000 257 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PETERCULTER GALBRAITH A

752 8771/79789 SHOP KELLY OF CULTS LTD P 5,600 5,600 299 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PETERCULTER GALBRAITH A

753 8774/74484 DAY CENTRE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 6,400 6,400 315 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM PETERCULTER RYDEN LLP A

754 8872/79264 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED T 58,500 58,500 UNIT 1-2 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

755 8873/78339 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 25,250 25,250 UNIT 3 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

08/03/2021 Page 54 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

756 8874/75646 SHOP SPORTSWIFT T 24,500 24,500 UNIT 4 T/A CARD FACTORY DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GERALD EVE LLP A DYCE

757 8874/78328 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 24,500 24,500 UNIT 4 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

758 8875/78344 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 25,250 25,250 UNIT 5 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

759 95820/78351 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 46,250 46,250 UNIT 6-7 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

760 8877/78347 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 7,300 7,300 UNIT 10 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

761 38534/77847 SHOP DUNCAN & TODD LTD T 18,500 18,500 UNIT 12 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A DYCE

762 8879/78348 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 18,500 18,500 UNIT 13 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

763 8880/78349 SHOP ASDA STORES LTD P 17,250 17,250 UNIT 14 DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DYCE

764 87829/70513 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 1,000 1,000 PHOTO-ME DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A DYCE

765 87829/79472 STANCE PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC T 1,000 1,000 PHOTO-ME DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE RIVERVIEW DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A DYCE

766 35564/79518 RESTAURANT MICHELLE NICHOLS & LAUREN MCGEGOR T 47,000 47,000 ROHAAN CAFE BAR T/A ROHAAN CAFE BAR BURNSIDE DRIVE DYCE

767 9252/76355 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 30,500 30,500 99 VICTORIA STREET DYCE CBRE LTD A

768 9252/77409 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 30,500 30,500 99 VICTORIA STREET DYCE CBRE LTD A

769 9529/75249 SHOP CHALMERS BAKERY LTD P 7,200 7,200 30 AUCHMILL ROAD BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 55 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

770 82761/70694 SALON CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 23,500 23,500 UNIT C 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

771 82761/77966 SALON CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 23,500 23,500 UNIT C 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

772 74384/70699 SHOP CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 10,500 10,500 UNIT D 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

773 74384/77339 SHOP CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 10,500 10,500 UNIT D 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

774 83509/70693 SHOWROOM CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 39,750 39,750 UNIT B 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

775 83509/76329 SHOWROOM F W CYCLES (UK) LTD T 39,750 39,750 UNIT B 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

776 83509/77901 SHOWROOM CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 39,750 39,750 UNIT B 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

777 83509/78045 SHOWROOM F W CYCLES (UK) LTD T 39,750 39,750 UNIT B 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

778 74704/70321 SHOP MAJESTIC WINE WAREHOUSES LTD T 24,000 24,000 UNIT A 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

779 74704/70695 SHOP CLYDESDALE YORKSHIRE BANK P 24,000 24,000 UNIT A 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A

780 74704/79687 SHOP MAJESTIC WINE WAREHOUSES LTD T 24,000 24,000 UNIT A 876 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN WYMRE A

781 9555/73680 SHOP CHALMERS BAKERY LTD P 15,250 15,250 77 GREENBURN DRIVE BANKHEAD RYDEN LLP A

782 9562/70426 SHOP LLOYDS PHARMACY LTD P 9,500 9,500 9 INVERURIE ROAD BUCKSBURN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

783 9608/70907 FUNERAL REST ROOM CO-OPERATIVE FUNERAL SERVICES LTD P 14,000 14,000 10 OLDMELDRUM ROAD BUCKSBURN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

08/03/2021 Page 56 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

784 9609/76350 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 18,750 18,750 12 OLDMELDRUM ROAD BUCKSBURN CBRE LTD A

785 9609/77445 BANK TSB BANK PLC P 18,750 18,750 12 OLDMELDRUM ROAD BUCKSBURN CBRE LTD A

786 9655/75687 SHOP GEORGE A GAULD P 1,800 1,800 FIVE MILE HOUSE KINGSWELLS ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A

787 31857/72632 VETERINARY SURGERY TOWN & COUNTRY VETERINARY GROUP T 21,750 21,750 UNIT 1 KINGSWELLS VILLAGE CENTRE KINGSWELLS AVENUE F G BURNETT LTD A KINGSWELLS

788 86725/71227 OFFICE PRIME FOUR MANAGEMENT LTD P 39,500 39,500 A FOURCOURT PAVILIONS KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK CBRE LTD A KINGSWELLS

789 86725/77350 OFFICE PRIME FOUR MANAGEMENT LTD P 39,500 39,500 A FOURCOURT PAVILIONS KINGSWELLS CAUSEWAY PRIME FOUR BUSINESS PARK CBRE LTD A KINGSWELLS

790 84721/75722 SHOP KDP (ABERDEEN) LTD T 23,000 23,000 KINGSWOOD DRIVE T/A DICKIES PHARMACY KINGSWELLS F G BURNETT LTD A

791 38272/70459 SHOP CO-OPERATIVE GROUP T 45,500 45,500 UNIT 1-2 PROPERTY DIVISION KINGSWELLS VILLAGE CENTRE KINGSWOOD DRIVE COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A KINGSWELLS

792 38844/75365 SHOP CYNTHIA & KENNETH BLACK O 16,000 16,000 UNIT 3 T/A FIRM OF KINGSWELLS VILLAGE CENTRE GREAT WESTERN PRE-SCHOOL KINGSWOOD DRIVE BUSINESSRATESADVICE.COM A KINGSWELLS

793 82314/75626 GARDEN CENTRE DOBBIES GARDEN CENTRE PLC P 468,000 468,000 DOBBIES GARDEN WORLD NEWPARK FARM, WHITEMYRES THE LANG STRACHT GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN

794 9692/75227 SHOP CLIFTVYLLE PROPERTIES LTD P 8,700 8,700 UNIT 6 SCLATTIE PARK BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

795 9694/74924 SHOP CLIFTVYLLE PROPERTIES LTD P 16,250 16,250 UNIT 3-4 SCLATTIE PARK BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

796 9695/75026 SHOP CLIFTVYLLE PROPERTIES LTD P 8,600 8,600 UNIT 2 SCLATTIE PARK BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

797 9697/70913 SHOP THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD T 18,250 18,250 (SUPERMARKET) SCLATTIE PARK BUCKSBURN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

08/03/2021 Page 57 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

798 9697/75229 SHOP CLIFTVYLLE PROPERTIES LTD P 18,250 18,250 (SUPERMARKET) SCLATTIE PARK BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

799 9700/75491 SHOPS MORNING NOON & NIGHT LTD P 11,250 11,250 8 SCLATTIE PARK BUCKSBURN RYDEN LLP A

800 9765/78387 SHOP THE BARBERS POLE LTD T 9,000 9,000 25 ELLON ROAD PER GREGOR FORRESTER BRIDGE OF DON KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

801 9766/79357 SHOP DPGF LTD P 8,900 8,900 CROOKFOLD 27 ELLON ROAD BRIDGE OF DON KNIGHT FRANK LLP A

802 9812/71742 SHOP CO-OPERATIVE GROUP FOOD LIMITED T 29,000 29,000 21 SCOTSTOWN ROAD BRIDGE OF DON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

803 9813/78437 SHOP WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD T 11,500 11,500 23 SCOTSTOWN ROAD PROPERTY DEPARTMENT BRIDGE OF DON GL HEARN LIMITED A

804 9815/78472 SHOP BOOTS UK LIMITED P 11,000 11,000 27 SCOTSTOWN ROAD BRIDGE OF DON GL HEARN LIMITED A

805 9819/71065 SHOP J J & C LOW P 10,750 10,750 6 SCOTSTOWN ROAD T/A THE ASHVALE FISH RESTAURANT BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

806 9820/73747 SHOP WOVAX LTD P 9,700 9,700 6A SCOTSTOWN ROAD C/O ASHVALE FISH RESTAURANT BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

807 9821/71066 SHOP J J LOW & C LOW P 11,500 11,500 8 SCOTSTOWN ROAD BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

808 9901/70642 SHOP T M RETAIL GROUP T 34,500 34,500 UNIT 5 SHOPPING CENTRE BRAEHEAD WAY GERALD EVE LLP A BRIDGE OF DON

809 71963/79237 SHOP HOLLAND & BARRETT RETAIL LTD T 31,250 31,250 UNIT 1 TESCO SUPERSTORE LAUREL DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DANESTONE

810 77824/79114 SHOP TIMPSON LIMITED T 12,000 12,000 UNIT 3 TESCO SUPERSTORE LAUREL DRIVE GL HEARN LIMITED A DANESTONE

811 80875/76391 SHOP SCOTLAND LTD T 27,500 27,500 UNIT 5 TESCO SUPERSTORE LAUREL DRIVE WYMRE A DANESTONE

08/03/2021 Page 58 of 59 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

812 74306/78012 SHOP INDIGO SUN RETAIL LTD T 30,250 30,250 UNIT 7 TESCO SUPERSTORE LAUREL DRIVE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A DANESTONE

813 31003/79620 SHOP INDEPENDENT VET CARE LTD T 25,750 25,750 UNIT 1 ARDENE HOUSE VETERINARY PRACTICE JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON WHITESTONE COMMERCIAL LTD A

814 30486/78975 SHOP LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 26,500 26,500 UNIT 3 JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON MONTAGU EVANS A

815 31004/76377 SHOP SUBWAY LTD T 25,750 25,750 UNIT 4 JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON WYMRE A

816 34018/77880 SHOP D P REALTY LIMITED T 26,000 26,000 UNIT 5 JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES A

817 31005/75222 SHOP THE ASHVALE T 25,750 25,750 UNIT 6 JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

818 83055/75595 SHOP SCOTTISH MIDLANDS T 35,000 35,000 UNIT 1A CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY JESMOND DRIVE BRIDGE OF DON RYDEN LLP A

08/03/2021 Page 59 of 59