LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEEN CITY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE Hearing on 21st November 2017 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 1, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 1 1101/51610 RETAIL WAREHOUSE POUNDSTRETCHER LTD T 134,000 134,000 390 GREAT NORTHERN ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 2 1136/51614 STAFF ACCOMMODATION ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 33,000 33,000 80 WESTERN ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 3 36758/52073 POLICE STATION SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY P 27,000 27,000 CONINGHAM TERRACE FINANCE DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 4 33005/52048 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 37,000 37,000 FORMARTINE ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 5 1150/51611 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 6,500 6,500 95 HAYTON ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 6 88473/51612 RESTAURANT CRAIGTON FOODS LTD T 120,000 120,000 KITTYBREWSTER RETAIL PARK BEDFORD ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 7 1242/51613 WAREHOUSE THORNBRIDGE SAWMILLS LTD O 56,500 56,500 15 ST MACHAR DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 8 1299/52258 WORKSHOP ETC BT PLC P 156,000 156,000 FROGHALL TERRACE C/O TELEREAL SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 9 1421/52040 FACTORY HALL & TAWSE JOINERY LTD P 283,000 283,000 GRANITEHILL ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A 10 1476/52178 OFFICES ETC ENERMECH LIMITED P 525,000 525,000 ENERMECH HOUSE HOWES ROAD ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A 11 1489/52036 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 34,500 34,500 SPEY ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 12 38304/52042 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL T 2,500 2,500 8 BACK HILTON ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 13 1598/51615 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 20,750 20,750 UNIT 15 KITTYBREWSTER SHOPPING CENTRE 15 CLIFTON ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 27/06/2017 Page 1 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 14 1660/52026 DEPOT ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 467,000 467,000 38 POWIS TERRACE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 15 1697/52033 OFFICES ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 119,000 119,000 OLD ABERDEEN HOUSE PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM DUNBAR STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 16 1726/51609 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 7,500 7,500 2 SEATON DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 17 34397/52049 OFFICE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 38,000 38,000 GREENFERN ROAD PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 18 1882/51602 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD T 111,000 111,000 WHITEMYRES AVENUE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 19 1887/52028 OFFICE ROBERTSON CONSTRUCTION EASTERN LTD T 27,750 27,750 1ST FLOOR WHITEMYRES BUSINESS CENTRE WHITEMYRES AVENUE GVA A ABERDEEN 20 39136/52027 OFFICES ROBERTSON FACILITIES MANAGEMENT T 14,500 14,500 GROUND FLOOR WHITEMYRES BUSINESS CENTRE WHITEMYRES AVENUE GVA A ABERDEEN 21 1888/51601 WORKSHOP ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 41,000 41,000 WHITEMYRES AVENUE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 22 1895/52141 WORKSHOPS ETC DINGBRO LTD P 221,000 221,000 WHITEMYRES AVENUE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 23 1904/51603 SHOWROOM ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD P 222,000 222,000 WHITEMYRES PLACE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 24 34646/51753 SUPERSTORE ALDI STORES LTD P 233,000 233,000 FORRESTERHILL ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A 25 41661/52016 OFFICE ETC NHS EDUCATION FOR SCOTLAND T 192,000 192,000 1ST FLOOR (PART) FOREST GROVE HOUSE FORRESTERHILL ROAD GVA A ABERDEEN 26 2014/52237 OFFICES THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 2,570,000 2,570,000 WOODHILL HOUSE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES WESTBURN ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 27 36859/52240 HOTEL PREMIER TRAVEL INN LTD T 135,000 135,000 THE COCKET HAT PER GERALD EVE NORTH ANDERSON DRIVE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 27/06/2017 Page 2 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 28 54177/52186 PUBLIC HOUSE ETC MITCHELLS & BUTLERS P 85,000 85,000 THE COCKET HAT PER ESTATE MANAGER NORTH ANDERSON DRIVE PROPERTY DEPARTMENT ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 29 2045/51599 BETTING OFFICE LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD T 8,700 8,700 113 ROUSAY DRIVE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 30 34923/52172 HOTEL CAIRN HOTEL GROUP P 100,000 100,000 SUMMERHILL HOTEL AND SCOTT'S BAR THE LANG STRACHT ABERDEEN GVA A 31 2099/51597 HOTEL THE FIRM OF P 160,000 160,000 ATHOLL HOTEL ATHOLL HOTEL ABERDEEN 54 KING'S GATE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 32 39117/52131 OFFICE ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING T 25,750 25,750 SUITE 1 BELGRAVE HOUSE 7 BELGRAVE TERRACE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN 33 34517/52144 OFFICE ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING LTD T 18,750 18,750 SUITE 2 T/A SOURCE PROPERTY SERVICES BELGRAVE HOUSE 7 BELGRAVE TERRACE RYDEN LLP A ABERDEEN 34 84938/52072 OFFICE SCOTTISH POLICE AUTHORITY T 14,500 14,500 ROSEMOUNT POLICE OFFICE FINANCE DEPARTMENT BELGRAVE TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 35 2227/52108 SHOP ABERDEEN PROPERTY LEASING P 25,250 25,250 138 ROSEMOUNT PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 36 2267/52126 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY ABACUS PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY T 26,750 26,750 VIEW HOUSE 2A VIEW TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 37 2311/52074 OFFICE PETREX DEVELOPMENTS LTD T 28,250 28,250 41 ALBERT STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 38 2341/52275 OFFICE CBRE LTD T 52,000 52,000 1ST FLOOR 1 ALBYN TERRACE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A 39 31957/52160 OFFICE HALLIDAY FRASER MUNRO O 169,000 169,000 6 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 40 2402/52154 OFFICE MACKINNONS T 93,000 93,000 14 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 41 2415/52204 OFFICE GRAHAM & SIBBALD T 27,250 27,250 21 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 27/06/2017 Page 3 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 42 2449/51975 OFFICE CONCEPT GROUP LTD P 50,500 50,500 66 CARDEN PLACE ABERDEEN GVA A 43 58623/51977 OFFICE ERNST & YOUNG T 335,000 335,000 GROUND FLOOR BLENHEIM HOUSE FOUNTAINHALL ROAD GVA A ABERDEEN 44 2499/52263 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY NURSERIES DIRECT LTD P 25,500 25,500 65 OSBORNE PLACE ABERDEEN BUSINESS RATES ADVICE.COM A 45 31647/51465 OFFICE SENERGY (GB) LTD T 325,000 325,000 2-3 QUEEN'S TERRACE ABERDEEN CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD A 46 38642/52106 OFFICE HALL MORRICE LLP T 125,000 125,000 6 QUEEN'S TERRACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 47 2518/51561 OFFICE ABERDEEN ASSET MANAGEMENT PLC P 155,000 155,000 9-10 QUEEN'S TERRACE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 48 2566/52098 OFFICE SKIBO TECHNOLOGIES LTD T 35,750 35,750 5 RUBISLAW PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 49 2586/52012 OFFICE THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP P 61,500 61,500 9 RUBISLAW TERRACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A 50 34580/52183 OFFICE DRUM PROPERTY GROUP LTD T 17,250 17,250 12 RUBISLAW TERRACE LANE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 51 2670/51558 CAFE STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 32,500 32,500 496 UNION STREET C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 52 2697/52209 OFFICE ETC LAURIE AND COMPANY T 46,000 46,000 17 VICTORIA STREET SOLICITORS LLP ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 53 2747/52010 OFFICE THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 380,000 380,000 1 ALBYN PLACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A 54 2770/51661 OFFICE RYDEN T 81,000 81,000 25 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 55 33748/52227 OFFICES BG GROUP LTD T 359,000 359,000 26 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 27/06/2017 Page 4 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 56 2772/52229 OFFICE BG GROUP LTD T 220,000 220,000 27 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 57 2773/51476 OFFICE CARLTON ROCK LTD P 316,000 316,000 28 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 58 2773/52230 OFFICE BG GROUP LTD T 316,000 316,000 28 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 59 33954/51474 OFFICE STRONACHS LLP T 115,000 115,000 33 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 60 2780/51475 OFFICE STRONACHS LLP T 194,000 194,000 34 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 61 2785/52002 OFFICE K P M G T 361,000 361,000 37 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN GVA A 62 2789/51717 BANK THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP T 150,000 150,000 40 ALBYN PLACE PER NELSON BAKEWELL ABERDEEN GVA A 63 33084/51498 OFFICE A B ROBB LTD T 18,000 18,000 10B QUEEN'S GARDENS ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 64 39107/52243 OFFICE PINSENT MASONS LLP T 316,000 316,000 13 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A 65 2904/52283 HOTEL MALMAISON ABERDEEN LTD T 480,000 480,000 MALMAISON 49 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 66 2910/52218 OFFICE MILLSTREAM ASSOCIATES LTD P 121,000 121,000 10 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 67 33321/51484 OFFICE CRAIG GROUP LTD T 116,000 116,000 12 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 68 73463/51478 OFFICE CARLTON ROCK LTD P 237,000 237,000 20 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 69 2925/51485 OFFICE RSM CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS T 52,500 52,500 52 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 27/06/2017 Page 5 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 70 2927/51477 OFFICE HELLISTER LTD P 44,250 44,250 54 QUEEN'S ROAD PER AB ROBB LTD ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 71 2931/52410 OFFICE ARTHUR J GALLAGHER INSURANCE T 20,250 20,250 1ST FLOOR BROKERS LTD 56 QUEEN'S ROAD C/O GERALD EVE LLP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 72 2932/52195 OFFICE ARTHUR J GALLAGHER INSURANCE T 17,750 17,750 2ND FLOOR BROKERS LTD 56 QUEEN'S ROAD C/O GERALD EVE LLP ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 73 48360/52020 OFFICE MACLAY MURRAY & SPENS LLP T 102,000 102,000 66 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN GVA A 74 2942/52256 OFFICE 3I PLC P 207,000 207,000 GROUND FLOOR 70 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 75 2948/51598 OFFICE ETC FAIRHURST P 81,500 81,500 88 QUEEN'S ROAD ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 76 2951/52159 OFFICE OPTIMUS (ABERDEEN) LTD O 190,000 190,000 GORDON HOUSE 27 RUBISLAW DEN NORTH ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 77 33002/52124 PRE-SCHOOL NURSERY ABACUS PRE SCHOOL NURSERY P 23,700 A