The Quarterly RRAonLeadership: The Year of the Digital Leader RRAonLeadership: The Year of the Digital Leader

Welcome to the first issue of the RRA Quarterly—a collection of timely and thought-provoking articles, interviews and surveys that address the concerns of global leaders today.

Our first issue focuses on perhaps the most disruptive force now at work in the business world: digital transformation. Managing digital transformation particularly is challenging because it requires companies to rethink what “digital” means in the first place and how they respond to it. Ten years ago, digital basically was a set of platforms and technologies—web sites and e-commerce and so on. Today, it’s not just entirely new products and services but, more important, a completely different set of relationships among companies, customers, suppliers and other stakeholders, driven by shared information, fluid decision making and flattened hierarchies. It tests not just what leaders do but what leaders are.

The spoils go to those who can best imagine state-of-the-art products and creative relationships—and then successfully rewire their enterprises as needed. Not surprisingly, those with a track record of success at this are few and far between— and not always found in the places you might think.This issue’s articles on chief digital officers, digital leadership across the C-suite and the next generation of e-commerce grew out of our ongoing conversations with some of the world’s most innovative and successful executives. We hope these insights contribute to the discussions within your organization as well. The Quarterly Table of Contents

4 Do You Have the Digital Leaders You Need? These days, you can’t have a business conversation without discussing digital—social, local, mobile, big data, the cloud. But that’s just talk.

6 Got Digital? Digital Matters: The digitization of information is causing market disruption, upending traditional business models and changing the way people interact. As a result, organizations across sectors and regions of the world need leaders – starting in the boardroom – who can help frame the strategy to transform the business and leverage digital technologies effectively.

10 The Rise of the Chief Digital Officer The challenges and opportunities for businesses in this digital age are enormous. Companies need to be fleet-footed to keep pace with changing technology and consumer behavior.

14 The Search Is On: Seven Questions to Ask When Recruiting E-commerce Leaders As business shifts into E-commerce 3.0, corporate leaders and hiring executives at consumer retailers, as well as organizations in financial services, technology, healthcare, government and even nonprofit, are seeking guidance on the kind of talent they need to lead their e-commerce businesses.

20 The Future of Automotive Leadership: From Car Guy to Mobility Leader It’s not easy these days being an automotive executive. More than ever, they must apply multi-phase thinking and take courageous action to adapt a strategy for success in a changing environment—and that’s just the beginning of what is expected of them. Do You Have the Digital Leaders You Need?

These days you can’t have a business conversation without discussing digital — social, local, mobile, big data, the cloud. But that’s just talk. We wanted to discover what companies are really doing about this new world, so we analyzed the backgrounds of the CEOs and directors of America’s largest companies.

The answer is surprising.

Only nine companies — less than two percent of the Fortune 500 — are what we would call “highly digital.” To be highly digital, by our definition a company must pass four tests: it generates a high percentage of revenues digitally; its leadership (both the CEO and the Board) has deep digital experience; it does business significantly enabled by digital channels; and it’s recognized as transformational in its industry.

If you narrow the scope to the Fortune 100, the data are still relatively weak. Seven percent of companies are highly digital. Perhaps, more surprisingly, only 13 percent have highly digital boards of directors.

You might focus exclusively on company leadership, but, of course, boards matter: they provide strategic counsel to the CEO and, crucially, they plan for CEO succession. To guide companies in innovative ways, boards must know what innovative looks like.

It’s clear the tide is turning — and it’s turning fast. We believe it’s no coincidence that the largest and most successful companies in our economy are leading this change. Just consider what some established companies have done recently to address their digital capabilities gap at the highest levels of leadership and governance.

At HP, Meg Whitman, the former CEO of eBay, has moved from board director to CEO. At old line retailer JCPenney, Ron Johnson, the former head of Apple’s retail operation, was recently appointed CEO — though the news of late calls into question how well these marriages of new and old worlds will fare.

Predictably, companies with the most digital boards are in sectors of the economy where digital matters most, either because it’s the core of the business or because it’s disrupting the core business. It’s no news to confirm that technology companies — such as Amazon, Apple, Cisco, Dell, HP, , , , and Oracle — have boards awash in digital expertise.

Perhaps the most significant finding is that there are boards on their way to becoming highly digital in sectors where you would least expect them, such as consumer packaged goods: the boards at Pepsi and Procter & Gamble. In retail, there’s Wal-Mart. In distribution, there’s Ingram Micro and Sysco. In financial services, there’s . And in services, there’s FedEx — though you might argue that FedEx has always operated as a highly digital company that happens to have planes and trucks attached.

Given the increasing influence, even dominance, of social and mobile technologies, we expect to see a similar evolution take place in more “unlikely” sectors: healthcare, industrial goods, natural resources.

­4 | Quarterly Report At the board level, when done right, certain patterns emerge: leading companies have jumped in with both feet. Leaders have recruited between two and four directors (or more) with hands- on or board-level digital experience. A token digital director is no longer sufficient. While many recruits are digital CEOs, companies are widening their aperture to consider more youthful, non- CEO candidates. Disney added Sheryl Sandberg of Facebook; Wal-Mart added Marissa Mayer of Google; and eBay has added Katie Mitic, also of Facebook. In other cases, candidates are coming from non-public, venture-backed firms.

Some CEOs are learning by doing. Bill Ford of Ford Motor is a director at eBay; and Bob Iger of Disney serves as a director of Apple.

If you’re in a leadership role at an F500 company, we think it’s clear where your priorities should lie. Those companies “born digital” — such as Amazon, Google, and Facebook — inevitably have top talent to match their businesses. Companies in technology, media, and communications, for example, which have not attracted such talent, are paying the price. Just look at the damage done to high-tech players in the mobile industry when leadership misses a major technology trend like the advent of the smartphone.

So what should you do about this? If you’re leading the show, it’s high time to make a clear-eyed gap analysis and course-correct accordingly. If you’re in middle management, start lobbying for leadership to match the challenges your company will face. Here are some pointers from what we’ve learned:

■■ Recruit at least one digital director to your board. You have to start somewhere. We cannot imagine how a company could fail to benefit from such experience, perspective, and guidance.

■■ Not all digital experience is created equal. Make sure your prospective C-level or director candidate is aligned with the types of digital opportunities and challenges your company faces.

■■ Within your executive team or your board, identify the functions where the impact will be greatest; then make sure you have a candidate who has the capabilities to align with those functions.

■■ No board director or senior executive will have impact, no matter the expertise, without cultural fit. This is an eternal verity, but it applies here.

Finally, ask yourself the obvious question: do you want to be a leader or a follower? Our research shows that the winners are those who’ve tackled these key issues early and decisively.

Over the next couple of years, we predict enormous changes in C-suite and board composition based on digital chops. The question is clear: Do you have the digital leaders you need?

Authors

Jeffrey F. Rayport is an Operating Partner at Castanea Partners, a private equity firm focused on retail, information, and marketing services. Tuck Rickards is Managing Director, Technology and Digital Transformation, at Russell Reynolds Associates.

Quarterly Report | 5 Got Digital?

Digital Matters Market Disruption. The digitization of information is upending traditional business models, changing the way people interact:

■■ Publishing: ebooks replacing paper

■■ Retail: online purchasing lowering brick-and-mortar sales

■■ Music: artists selling directly through iTunes Dig•i•tal [dij-i-tl] Universal Impact. All organizations across every industry are impacted in some way: the translation of analog information ■■ Marketing: “mass customization” of advertising (numbers, words, ■■ Operations: supply chain optimization sounds, shapes, images and more) ■■ Customer service: self-service into electronic data that easily Growing Expectations of Corporate Leaders. Shareholders, employees and customers can be stored and increasingly demand that their leaders understand and leverage digital technologies effectively shared across networks and across the business. devices.

“Highly Digital” Defined “Highly Digital” companies satisfy … and are in short supply. four criteria …

High % Highly Digital of Digital F100 Boards Revenue 13%

Sitting CEO/Board Digital Leadership Channels Experience Highly Highly Digital F500 Digital F100 Company Companies Companies Recognized 2% 7% as Transition Leader

Highly Digital Company Examples: Highly Digital Board Examples: Amazon, Apple, Cisco, Dell, eBay, Google, Technology: Apple, Cisco, Dell, Google, Microsoft, Oracle and Yahoo!, seven of which HP, Intel, Microsoft, Oracle are in the F100. Retail: Amazon, Wal-Mart Financial Services: Berkshire Hathaway Consumer Goods: Procter & Gamble Source: Russell Reynolds Associates Analysis Business Services: FedEx

­6 | Quarterly Report Key Findings Disruption and Digital Status Linked. For example, Technology and Retail well-represented on the list. Non-digital Companies Boosting Digital Board Status. For example, Berkshire Hathaway, FedEx and Procter & Gamble.

Digital Boards Have Three Common Themes:

■■ Commitment: Four to six digital board members, not one or two.

■■ Digital experience: Experience with companies like Amazon, Apple, Cisco, eBay, Facebook, Google, Intuit and Microsoft highly sought after

■■ CEO experience: CEO experience for most digital board members

Five to Ten Companies Boosting Digital Board Status:

■■ Disney, Ingram Micro, and Sprint Nextel to , Coca-Cola, Ford, Morgan Stanley, PepsiCo and Sysco

■■ One to two digital directors

■■ Several CEOs who now are board members in highly digital companies: Bill Ford (eBay), Bob Iger (Apple)

Trends and Implications for Recruiting Digital Leadership The Tide is Turning. Some of the largest and most successful companies are working to narrow the digital capabilities gap.

Some Sectors Moving Faster than Others:

■■ Forerunners: consumer-facing businesses like technology, media and communications, retail, and financial services

■■ Gradual growers: automotive (connected vehicles) to B2B markets and services

Limited Supply Driving Younger Talent from Unique Sources:

■■ Non-CEOs: Marissa Mayer (Google) to Wal-Mart and Katie Mitic (Facebook) to eBay

■■ Venture capital/private equity-backed companies, not just F500 digital companies

■■ Related businesses that have been through digital transformations

More Selective Screening:

■■ Functional experience, social media marketing, cloud, mobile)

■■ Transformation experience (pure play vs. established company transformation)

■■ Cultural fit (mandatory)

■■ Shared vision of making a meaningful impact

Quarterly Report | 7 Highly Digital COMPANY INDUSTRY BOARD MEMBERS DIGITAL CREDENTIALS Boards in the F100 Apple Technology Tim Cook IBM, Compaq Arthur Levinson Google Bill Campbell GO Corp, Intuit Robert Iger Walt Disney

Cisco Technology John Chambers Cisco Carol Bartz Yahoo!, Sun Microsystems, Intel, NetApp Michael Capellas HP, Compaq, First Data John Hennessy Google, Atheros Communications Arun Sarin Vodafone, Infospace, AirTouch Yahoo! Steven West nCUBE, Entera, Hitachi Data Systems, EDS Brian Halla LSI Logic, Intel, National Semiconductor

Dell Technology Michael Dell Dell James Breyer Apple, Facebook, RealNetworks, HP Shantanu Narayen Adobe, Pictra, Silicon Graphics, Apple

Google Technology Google Google Google, Novell, Siebel, Apple Amazon, Move.com, Sun Microsystems Diane Greene VMware, EMC Corp., Sybase, Intuit GluMobile, Netflix Ram Shirarm Amazon.com, Junglee, Netscape John Hennessy Cisco, Atheros Communications Paul Otellini Intel

Hewlett-­Packard Technology Meg Whitman eBay, Walt Disney, Zipcar Marc Andressen Netscape, Ning, America Online, eBay Raymond Lane Oracle, EDS, Quest Software Lawrence Babbio Verizon, Bell Atlantic

Intel Technology Paul Otellini Intel, Google Susan Decker Yahoo!, , LegalZoom.com John Donahoe eBay David Pottruck Schwab

Microsoft Technology Microsoft, Corbis Steve Balmer Microsoft Reed Hastings Neflix, Facebook John Thompson IBM, Virtual Instruments, Symantec

Oracle Technology Larry Ellison Oracle George Conrades IBM, BBN, Akamai Bruce Chizen Adobe Naomi Seligman Akamai, D&B

Amazon.com Retail Tom Alberg Advanced Digital Information William Gordon EA, Zynga, Callaway Digital Arts Blake Krikorian Sling Media,Telescript, Clicker Media Jonathan Rubinstein HP, Palm, Apple, FirePower Systems Patricia Stonesifer Microsoft, Viacom

Wal-­Mart Retail James Breyer Dell, Apple, Facebook Michele Burns Cisco James Cash Microsoft Marissa Mayer Google Gregory Penner Baidu.com, 99Bill Corporation

­8 | Quarterly Report Highly Digital COMPANY INDUSTRY BOARD MEMBERS DIGITAL CREDENTIALS Boards in the F100 Berkshire Financial Services Stephen Burke Comcast, NBCUniversal, Walt Disney Hathaway Susan Decker Yahoo!, Pixar, LegalZoom Bill Gates Microsoft, Corbis Charlotte Guyman Microsoft IAC/InterActiveCorp., Convera Thomas Murphy DoubleClick, Walt Disney Walter Scott Level 3 Communications

Procter & Consumer Goods Scott Cook Intuit, eBay Gamble Jonathan Rodgers TV One, Discovery Networks, Comcast Meg Whitman eBay, Walt Disney, HP, Zipcar

FedEx Business Services James Barksdale Netscape John Edwardson CDW Shirley Ann Jackson IBM, NYSE Euronext Gary Loveman Caesars Entertainment F100 Boards Ingram Micro Technology John Ingram Ingram Content Group, Ingram Digital Addressing the Scott McGregor Xerox, Microsoft, Digital Equipment Corp. Alain Monie Amazon.com Digital Gap Linda Levinson Connexus, American Express, DemandTec

Sprint Nextel Media and Daniel Hesse Sprint, AT&T Communications Robert Bennentt Discovery, Demand Media, Liberty Media Frank Ianna Aala, AT&T, Tellabs William Nuti NCR, Cisco

Walt Disney Media and Robert Iger Apple Communictions Judith Estrin Cisco, FedEx Sheryl Sandberg Facebook, Google, eHealth, Starbucks

American Financial Services Peter Chernin News Corporation, E*TRADE, Sky Global Express Ted Leonsis Mobile Posse, America Online, LaunchBox Charlene Barshefsky Intel

Morgan Stanley Financial Services Roy Boystock Yahoo!, B/Com3 Erskine Bowles Facebook, Belk Donald Nicolaisen Verizon

Prudential Financial Services Gordon Bethune Sprint Nextel Financial Gilbert Casellas Dell, Q-­Linx William Gray III Dell

Coca-­Cola Consumer Goods Robert Kotick Activision Blizzard Barry Diller IAC, Expedia, TripAdvisor, Live Nation

PepsiCo Consumer Goods Shona Brown Google Dina Dublon Microsoft

Sysco Business Services Manuel Fernandez Gartner, Harris Corp., DataQuest Jackie Ward Digg, Computer Generation, Sanmina SCI

Ford Motor Automotive William Clay Ford, Jr. eBay William Helman Zipcar Ellen Marram Fedex, The New York Times

Quarterly Report | 9 Digital Leadership: The Rise of the Chief Digital Officer

The challenges and opportunities for businesses in this digital age are enormous. Companies need to be fleet-footed to keep pace with changing technology and consumer behavior. Business strategies now must be seamlessly interwoven with ever-expanding digital strategies that address not only the web but also mobile, social, local and whatever innovation there may be around the corner. To help meet these challenges, companies are increasingly looking for a chief digital officer (CDO) who can oversee the full range of digital strategies and drive change across the organization. In this issue, members of the Consumer and Technology teams at Russell Reynolds Associates look at the rise of chief digital officers and their potential for CEO succession.

What is a CDO, and why does the role matter? Customers are demanding fresh information and the ability to buy wherever, whenever and however they want. The numbers are hard to debate. More than 200 million iPhone and Android smartphones now are in consumers’ hands, and demand shows no sign of abating. Some 41 million apps are downloaded every day, and social networking is expanding on a geometric scale. Consumers are leveraging their digital resources to download information, compare prices, find the best products and search for deals.

­10 | Quarterly Report It’s no surprise then that the seniority and caliber of digital talent that companies are seeking to recruit are on the increase. Traditionally, digital was positioned as part of the marketing function within the business, responsible for driving the organization’s online presence. The last two years have seen the rise of the chief digital officer, a senior executive who sits at the right hand of the CEO and is seen as instrumental to the future of the organization. For many companies, especially those in the retail and leisure sectors, digital is the fastest-growing revenue stream, and a chief digital officer (or, sometimes, SVP Online) is extremely important in driving that growth. In some sectors, such as traditional media, the CDO often will have been hired to help transform the company as its products evolve digitally.

In both cases, the CDO needs to be someone who not only has digital acumen but also is a seasoned general manager who can operate within a large-scale business and influence effectively across the organization. This is a relatively new type of leader and one who is hard to find, attract and retain. The increasing importance of the role eventually will put CDOs in “We are at the the queue for CEO succession. CDOs will be the executives with the operating experience, beginning of a new management skills, strategic mindset and vision to lead businesses in an increasingly era for social Internet technological future. innovators who are re-imagining and The spike in demand for chief digital officers has been felt globally. In Europe, the number of re-inventing a web search requests for this role has risen by almost a third in the last 24 months. The of people and places, has seen the same growth in half that time. The increase in Asia is less pronounced, where the looking beyond documents and position remains relatively junior, though things there are evolving. The challenge in Asia is more web sites.” about attracting talented executives to join established companies who otherwise might set up John Doerr their own digital enterprise. Partner; Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers The sharp rise in demand for CDOs has been matched by an equally spiraling increase in the level of compensation offered. Today’s high-quality CDOs command double the remuneration levels of their predecessors, reflecting the scarcity of talent and increasing seniority of the role. Pay and benefits put the chief digital officer on par or above other executives at board or sub- board levels. In Asia, this trend has been less pronounced. It will take time for companies there to escalate the digital function to a more senior level—but the continued rise in consumer Internet and mobile use inevitably will drive similar demand.

What’s driving the evolution of the CDO? Social media and the enabling technologies are fundamentally reshaping how consumers behave. Smarter, quicker and more advanced mobile telephony brings with it a wide range of possibilities for business such as media companies, retailers and information providers. Services that combine social and local elements are becoming the norm. All of this is forcing organizations to rethink their market and customer strategies. Some staggering statistics:

■■ In 2010, global revenue for the virtual goods industry was over $7 billion, according to Ted Sorom, CEO of Risty, a virtual currency platform.

■■ In March 2011, Apple announced it had sold its 100 millionth iPhone. As of July 2011, Google’s Android Operating System was on 130 million devices.

■■ In April 2011, it was announced that more than 200 million people had signed up on Twitter, while, in September 2011, it was revealed that there were 100 million active monthly users.

■■ In July 2011, it was reported that the Apple Retail Store was handling 24 million app downloads per day, and the Android Market was handling 17 million app downloads a day.

■■ As of September 2011, there were more than 800 million users on Facebook. On average, Facebook users install over 20 million apps every day. There are more than 350 million active users currently accessing Facebook through mobile devices.

Quarterly Report | 11 What does it take to become a CDO? Given the complexities of their role, successful CDOs require a broad blend of experiences and competencies.

Experience Digital experience, of course, is critical, but different combinations of skills are emerging among chief digital officers. For example:

■■ E-commerce and transactional expertise. The focus here is on driving traffic, conversion and revenue. Often referred to as SVP Online, these CDOs are sought after by companies involved in e-commerce, such as e-tailers and manufacturers that move to direct sales. These CDOs require change management capabilities and the ability to manage channel conflicts.

■■ Online marketing and social media expertise. Here the emphasis is on driving brand awareness, brand activation and consumer engagement. These CDOs are sought after by consumer-branded goods and services companies and require skills relating to new personalized/localized communications as opposed to mass communications.

■■ Transformative product and technology capabilities (i.e., analog to digital). These CDOs are sought after by traditional media companies and require change management capabilities that can impact the whole company.

More generally, CDO candidates should be familiar with web, mobile and social media—and possibly local as well. They should be able to plan and execute long-term strategy around driving customer awareness, engagement, experience and monetization. When it comes to innovation, candidates should have experience developing new channels and business models, as well as innovative products and services. The CDO also must be tech savvy; though knowing how to code may or may not be required, the ability to manage developers and ask the right questions is a minimum requirement.

Importantly, the CDO is not only a digital guru but also a seasoned general manager. He or she should have experience running a P&L. The role frequently is transformational so change management experience is important, either in turnaround or fast-growth situations. In addition, as many companies increasingly have global customers and employees, international experience is key. Therefore, CDOs will need to appreciate that adoption of technologies across a business’ jurisdictions will vary. In other words, one size does not fit all.

Competencies As with any senior leadership position, a range of competencies is required:

■■ Setting strategy. With the digital landscape evolving so quickly, CDOs need to have excellent strategic skills, with the ability to chart the right course and make agile alterations when needed.

■■ Executing for results. Strategic insight must be coupled with a strong execution orientation and an ability to deliver results despite the complex and fluid environment.

■■ Building relationships and using influence. In today’s climate, the culture and practices within a business can change as quickly as those in the external market. Chief digital officers, therefore, must be able to build relationships across all levels and functions of the organization—from the board down to the front line—and effectively manage conflict.

■■ Exhibiting Leadership. CDOs, in turn, must be able to recruit top talent and to lead large and (sometimes) globally distributed teams.

■■ Demonstrating cultural sensitivity. This particularly is important, as those skilled in new digital tools may view the world differently from others in more traditional parts of the business.

12 | Quarterly Report Where can effective CDOs be found? There is a wide range of challenges for those recruiting chief digital officers. One of the most significant issues is that demand is far greater than supply in all areas of the world. This creates retention issues among the best staff, fueling an increasingly competitive war for talent.

After two decades of the Internet, there is a reasonable cadre of mid-level digital managers from product, technology or marketing backgrounds. However, there are relatively few senior general managers or people who have worked across functions or have had extensive board experience. Many candidates have acquired their skills in small, nimble start-up type environments, making them culturally unsuitable for large, structured, matrixed corporates. Indeed, many of those who work in digital want to remain in pure-play arenas. To attract these candidates, companies must rethink how they structure responsibilities.

Perhaps not surprisingly, the greatest supply of candidates is in the United States. However, demand in this region is equally intense, such that finding the right talent in the United States remains challenging. Another issue, as many European and Asian companies note, is that technology executives from the United States often grow up in a particular silo, such as sales or marketing. As a result, while these executives bring tremendous functional expertise, they often lack the broader leadership and influencing skills that are needed for these more senior general management positions.

For some companies, particularly those with more traditional structures and career paths, it can be a challenge to integrate digital talent who will push the boundaries but may lack the maturity needed to function effectively at board or sub-board levels. For CEOs, such appointments require an element of risk taking and may include implementing and explaining strategies that go far beyond the traditional business model. In many cases, CEOs will need to adapt to having a key member of the inner circle who is far younger and has a significantly different business “CDOs who demonstrate background from the rest of the group. their ability to On the candidate side, those looking to move into chief digital officer positions may be reluctant manage change and transform to join established organizations, viewing them as old fashioned. Many candidates come from their businesses cutting-edge, entrepreneurial organizations where executives can have a clear and immediate almost certainly impact, and candidates often desire those same attributes in their next employer. They also will lead the way want compensation packages (particularly equity) highly geared to success, which may test the in the rise of the digital CEO.” compensation bands of traditional companies. Not only must organizations have an open mind to hiring candidates who might not fit the cultural norm of the business, companies also will have to move very quickly when they find and meet talent with potential. The current state of supply and demand almost guarantees that other opportunities will be available to talented candidates.

What does the future hold for the CDO? In many cases, the CDO will be the senior executive handling the fastest growing revenue streams within the business or will be the executive holding the keys to the company’s future— placing him or her squarely in line to replace the CEO. CDOs who demonstrate their ability to manage change and transform their businesses almost certainly will lead the way in the rise of the digital CEO.

Authors

Rhys Grossman co-leads the firm’s Internet and Media Practice. Based in London, he advises clients on search and assessment across the digital media, e-commerce, broadcasting and publishing sectors. Jana Rich co-leads the firm’s Internet and Media practice. Based in , she specializes in recruiting senior-level executives for clients in the Internet, e-commerce, media and entertainment industries.

Quarterly Report | 13 The Search Is On: Seven Questions to Ask When Recruiting E-commerce Leaders

Think of it as E-commerce 3.0 If the first stage of e-commerce was most memorably signaled when Amazon.com opened for business just 16 years ago and the second stage was the subsequent proliferation of all manner of web stores, today another fundamental shift is under way that is transforming the business landscape. In this paper, Margot McShane and the e-commerce team at Russell Reynolds Associates examine the converging trends that are creating a strong demand for experienced e-commerce retailers and outline seven critical questions that CEOs, boards and human capital leaders need to address as they begin their search for an e-commerce head. Many of the areas for discussion here also are relevant for organizations in other sectors that need to re-examine or develop their digital content and distribution channels. Future discussions will evaluate specific issues around e-commerce leadership in financial services, technology, healthcare, government and nonprofit.

A major shift, indeed, is under way in the world of e-commerce. Perhaps the biggest indicator is that large brand name multi-channel retailers with relatively small e-commerce businesses (and, in many cases, consumer products organizations that are selling direct for the first time) are re- engineering their original strategies and are starting to place a much bigger emphasis on their dot-coms. Until now, many retailers simply de-emphasized their e-commerce channels—which

­14 | Quarterly Report is no surprise in an industry where the brick-and-mortar store experience historically has been the single most important facet of the business. These companies now are looking to benefit from the web’s relatively higher growth rate in sales, its potential for greater margins and the realization that multi-channel customers—those who visit the store and shop online—are more valuable than single-channel buyers. In fact, many successful multi-channel retailers are using their web sites to drive an enormous volume of store sales.

There is yet another subset of retailers that avoided e-commerce altogether, many of whom are rethinking their strategy and are considering launching e-commerce platforms. Many of these companies had web sites, some of them excellent, but they often were brand enhancing or informational—not transactional. The New York Times recently picked up on this trend, noting that the luxury fashion business—including brands such as Jimmy Choo and Hugo Boss—is embracing direct e-commerce for the first time.

As business shifts into E-commerce 3.0, corporate leaders and hiring executives at consumer retailers, as well as organizations in financial services, technology, healthcare, government and even nonprofit, are seeking guidance on the kind of talent they need to lead their e-commerce businesses. Regardless of the size of the business, the essential questions retail leaders need to ask themselves before undertaking a search are strikingly similar.

No. 1: Should the head of e-commerce report directly to the C-suite? “Two likely expectations There is no one correct answer, but before beginning the search, it is important to consider of candidates how reporting lines will impact the qualified candidates’ perception of both the role and the will be that P&L organization’s commitment to the e-commerce initiative. Two likely expectations of candidates responsibility will be that profit and loss (P&L) responsibility for e-commerce will come with the job and that the for e-commerce will come with position will report directly to the CEO or president. Without these two conditions in place, it’s the job and that possible that some high-caliber candidates may opt out of the process. This isn’t about ego on the position will their part; having the e-commerce leader report directly into the same level of command as the report directly head of retail and merchandising sends a clear message that the development of e-commerce is a to the CEO or company priority and that the candidate will be the business owner. This type of reporting ensures president.” that the e-commerce leader will be directly involved in executive conversations and planning sessions that drive the direction of the company. It also indicates that e-commerce is a priority for the CEO and the board and broadcasts a message throughout the organization that the leadership team is embracing the channel. This is not to say this model is right for all organizations, but companies should give serious consideration to organizational structure in order to attract the right level of experienced leader. Another way to reassure candidates about the company’s commitment is to establish an on-call board member who can provide reassurance and answer questions about the e-commerce strategy during the final recruitment stages.

No. 2: What are the company’s e-commerce goals? In order to identify and recruit the right talent, clients should be ready to articulate their key goals around e-commerce and determine how they align with the larger business strategies. For example, how big is the e-commerce business expected to get? What are the multi- channel strategies (e.g., order online, return in stores; develop comprehensive CRM strategies to maximize customer loyalty and value)? What is the time frame for getting there? How much of an investment will it take to reach these goals? These strategy points are vital because the candidate who can build a business from scratch typically is very different from one able to triple an existing $50 million enterprise. An alternative candidate would be required to scale a $300 million business into a $1 billion enterprise. Building from scratch vs. optimizing an existing business, or building large-scale, competitive capabilities, requires very distinct skills and demands different talent.

Quarterly Report | 15 Identifying these long-term objectives and strategies is one of the most important challenges for a company embarking on a talent search. For example, it’s becoming increasingly common for a company to consciously hire someone who is “too big” for its existing business with the knowledge that the organization is hiring a leader capable of handling its future size.

No. 3: Does the business’ compensation model support or undermine the “It is important company’s goals? for the e-commerce In an ideal world, a compensation model should be developed before an e-commerce search organization begins. From a basic planning standpoint, that is obvious. However, there is another, more to be fully critical reason. Compensation models that focus almost exclusively on increasing online sales integrated can cause internal strife at the company. Since an online sale may come at the expense of a within a multi-channel store sale, retail-side leaders may feel threatened by e-commerce initiatives in a battle over the retailer—from customer. According to the 2009 State of Retailing Online report from Shop.org, companies have a business, adjusted their management and incentive structures to better align the online division with the cultural and rest of the company and vice versa. One important area to address will be assigning credit for interpersonal standpoint.” in-store revenue generated online. Successful compensation models also may emphasize shared credit for revenue performance and multi-channel sales, as well as companywide strategies around buyer loyalty and customer satisfaction. Not only will a successful compensation model avoid debilitating, money-losing rivalries, but it will incentivize cooperation across business lines. When recruiting e-commerce talent, the candidate will inquire about how his or her bonus will be measured.

No. 4: Will the e-commerce leader command a dedicated team? Establishing who is officially on the e-commerce team (with a solid line to the general manager) vs. who will be part of a shared-services team supporting e-commerce will impact the type of talent companies recruit. If the expectation is that the e-commerce leader will own responsibility for the P&L—but will need to rely on other key functional business heads or other shared resources to do so—it may adversely impact a candidate’s perceived ability to meet the established goals.

One of the most important issues to address early on is the risk related to information technology (IT) resources and accountability. Everyone involved must understand the structure and reporting model of the IT function before the search for an e-commerce leader begins. Particularly in “The most situations where the IT unit reports into multiple heads and the e-commerce leader will not have successful direct or dedicated IT support, some candidates may be concerned that IT will be unable to people in this realm possess completely focus on and execute the e-commerce strategy. both personal In addition, a clear understanding of the structure—be it shared services, a standalone unit confidence and a willingness to or a hybrid—will help focus the search for the right type of leader, placing emphasis either on listen to other exceptional relationship-building skills that will be required with a shared model or on strong ideas.” strategic and operational skills that will be required with a dedicated team (more on this in No. 6). It has proved helpful for an organization to discuss its team model in advance of implementing a search, as this enables a company to clearly identify the required competencies and experience and to set expectations with top candidates.

No. 5: Where will the e-commerce team work—headquarters or dot-com talent centers? For many CEOs, the answer to this question may seem obvious. Most organizations believe it is imperative that the e-commerce organization reside at headquarters in order to build rapport and partnerships with cross-functional colleagues. This will help support an integrated business culture that will legitimize e-commerce within the rest of the organization and ensure that the team stays close to the center of the business.

­16 | Quarterly Report However, some retailers, including one well-known big-box brand, have built e-commerce teams in locations away from the company headquarters, reasoning that attracting top talent to an alternate city would be easier. For example, the San Francisco area, because of its wealth of relevant talent, has become a popular spot for locating these separate e-commerce units. One catalyst for locating the team away from headquarters might be when a medium- sized e-commerce organization is growing to the next level and will require more sophisticated e-commerce expertise and leadership—leadership that may not be easily attracted to the headquarters location. Some retailers have concluded that for an e-commerce organization to thrive, it needs to sit elsewhere to get out of the shadow of the stores—truly making the group a separate division—and that, again, means locating it near e-commerce talent centers.

Locating the e-commerce team off-site does pose risks unless the retailer and candidate understand what is required to make everything work. Given the need for the e-commerce function to be fully integrated within a multi-channel retailer—from a business, cultural and interpersonal standpoint—strong communication and a structured schedule with in-person meetings are critical to success, especially at the beginning.

No. 6: What are the most essential skills and competencies to look for in candidates? Web experience and a proven track record of scaling an e-commerce business, of course, constitute the foundation of any viable candidate. However, outstanding e-commerce general managers will possess several specific competencies and leadership traits:

They must be strategic in mindset. An ideal e-commerce candidate envisions long-term market potential and business opportunities; generates strategies for addressing future market scenarios; and positions the business to capitalize on these opportunities using innovative and analytical thinking. Strategic executives will be adept at employing research and customer data and at drawing upon best practices to drive the business. The strategic leader also seeks out opportunities that are game-changing for the business.

They must have operational expertise. Strategic thinking is indispensable, but an e-commerce leader also must have an excellent track record of driving results. The ideal candidate cannot only project the vision and mission of the organization but needs to know how to turn those goals into viable plans. Personality traits that serve this role well are pragmatism and adaptability, and the candidate will possess the ability to focus and execute in a competitive and fast- paced environment. In addition, successful leaders in this field will make useful and sensible recommendations outside their area of expertise to their colleagues. The ideal candidate is one who accepts responsibility for results and expects the rest of the e-commerce team to follow suit. Successful operational leaders can balance the drive for business urgency with the ability to motivate, attract and retain strong talent that will form the backbone of a successful team.

“Right-sizing the They must be skilled at influencing colleagues and building relationships. This trait is critical candidate for for success in e-commerce, a unit that often requires strong partnerships with merchandising, the opportunity marketing, technology and retail operations. Without effective and strong coalitions, e-commerce is critically important.” will not thrive. We’ve found that the most successful people in this realm possess both personal confidence and a willingness to listen to other ideas. They are tenacious but also have high emotional intelligence, traits that allow them to push the business forward while building consensus along the way.

Quarterly Report | 17 So while many organizations believe that success almost always originates from strong strategic thinking and operating skills, it often is true that the difference between a moderately successful and a very successful e-commerce organization is the high degree of integration of the online team—a feat driven by a persuasive e-commerce leader who particularly is skilled at influencing and building relationships.

No. 7: What are the most common pitfalls when recruiting e-commerce leaders? The new hire isn’t a good cultural fit. One of the most important competencies in an e-commerce leader is the ability to be a change agent but also mesh culturally within the organization. What will make a successful e-commerce leader is the ability to deftly navigate the existing culture while simultaneously executing the e-commerce strategy.

“It is easy to fall Under- or over-hiring: If an organization is going to go through the considerable effort of in love with a conducting a comprehensive search, it stands to reason that retaining the successful hire would candidate based on be extremely desirable. This is why right-sizing the candidate for the opportunity is critically title or the brand important. As laid out in No. 2, it’s important for organizations to thoroughly evaluate their needs name of his or her employer.” so that they pick the right candidate. No two e-commerce businesses are the same—success at one dot-com doesn’t necessarily translate to another. Generally speaking, evidence of past success does predict future success, but it’s important to know more than the broad strokes of a candidate’s experience. In order to make sure a candidate’s past will translate well to a new business, context is essential. For example, how big was the e-commerce business at the previous company upon arrival? Inquire about revenue and order volume because large revenue dollars can mask operational inefficiencies. This will help determine if the candidate has the required experience for a complex logistical environment.

Other questions to ask include: What were the market trends at the time? And what were the goals of that business? The overall object is to determine how analogous the candidate’s past role was in relation to what the future position requires, and the answers to these questions will help make sure the candidate is a good business fit. It is easy to fall in love with a candidate based on title or the brand name of his or her employer, but drilling deeper benefits everyone in the end.

In summary Every business situation is unique, but these issues tend to remain constant as companies undertake a thorough search for new e-commerce leadership and talent. It’s important for CEOs and key hiring managers to address these issues before embarking on a search. The answers to these questions will streamline the search process and help define the type of leader required for the role, ensuring that the organization ends up with a robust pool of top-flight candidates.

Author

Margot McShane is a consultant in the Consumer Sector at Russell Reynolds Associates. She specializes in conducting senior-level searches for Internet, retail and consumer products clients across a range of categories. Margot leverages her extensive retail experience to provide innovative leadership solutions and strategies for her clients.

­18 | Quarterly Report The Future of Automotive Leadership: From Car Guy to Mobility Leader It’s not easy these days being an automotive executive. More than ever, leaders must apply multi-phase thinking and take courageous action to adapt a strategy for success in a changing environment—and that’s just the beginning of what is expected of them.

A small typology by Walter Friederichs, Ph.D.

Quarterly Report | 19 The car market is changing stealthily yet dramatically—transforming itself from the distinct automotive industry to a more fragmented mobility industry. The winners in this process will be the manufacturers, suppliers and traders whose leaders are involved in shaping this change across industries. As a result, the competencies these top managers will need to possess when it comes to expertise, performance and personality have become more complex than ever. The industry no longer can rely solely on the specifically focused car guy of yore. Traditional automotive and technical experts will continue to be essential, but, increasingly, the expertise and knowledge of a true mobility leader must emerge to meet the leadership needs of this evolving industry.

The future of mobility leadership Love of the automobile and gasoline coursing their veins always will be part of their DNA, but executives and top-tier managers also will need to gather specific skills and experience from other industries such as energy, information and communications, chemicals, logistics and transportation, tourism and finance. True mobility service provider executives will need skills pertaining to goods with a “use by” date—for example, strong knowledge of logistics, travel services or equipment rental will be essential; and having the right financial skills may mean mastering complex booking systems like those created for the aviation industry.

Sagacity, not dogma New analytical skills and a different approach will be needed to determine which facts are important and which are not. Too often, managers judge data and numbers by their source—the higher the source’s status, the better the information must be. As the auto industry undergoes substantial change, executives need to avoid being guided by past accomplishments and, instead, evaluate data without prejudice when making decisions. Sagacity is what is called for, not dogma. As an example, Google is a company that regularly examines its own performance without bias and develops new business by asking how customers can better achieve their objectives. The automotive industry improves its cars in a similar way, but this competency must be expanded and utilized more extensively to identify and develop emerging business areas.

It’s not easy being strategic Executives must be strategists, which sounds easy but isn’t. Strategists are given to autonomous thought, and they express their ideas with passion and conviction—especially when their opinion diverges from popular or mainstream views. A strategist has to be controversial, staying focused on the business issue and never getting personal. A strategist also must be able to build consensus for change and then walk the talk to ensure execution. As an example: If a carmaker wants to copy Zipcar’s metropolitan car-sharing model, internal objections against moving from the automotive business to the mobility business must be overcome. This means—and this is quite possibly the hardest part—being able to realize and appreciate that Generation Y consumers probably are more interested in choosing the right mode of transport at any given time than having the car of their dreams parked in the garage.

Without equal footing, there can be no partnership There can be no doubt that sound relationship management is more than the ability to accommodate diverging views. Capable networkers exert influence, develop sustainable relationships, and can persuade and convince others to pursue common objectives. These leaders must be able to communicate the need to expand their company beyond its traditional reach and build trust in their vision and judgment in order to execute the strategy.

This becomes dramatically more important when alliances and partnerships gain weight. Today, executives must be able to initiate steps and be willing to show their hand to other companies. To this end, the executive has to have what it takes to correctly judge other companies and

20 | Quarterly Report individuals. A partnership’s leaders must jointly develop the trust required for each party to open up. Executives will need to operate on an equal footing with external partners. Perhaps one of the most successful recent examples is aviation’s Star Alliance. This association is not aimed at taking over other companies but, instead, brings providers together in a mutually beneficial partnership.

Want to be radical? Show some courage! If you want to be successful in a sea-change environment, then radical thinking is an indispensable trait. Executives who are willing to question even solidly performing enterprises and then experiment with new approaches will be more successful in unsteady periods.

The capacity to deal with complexity will become increasingly important. Executives will have to pursue numerous tasks simultaneously; they must be able to focus on what is important while still being able to efficiently switch priorities in midstream. Multi-phase thinking will be the new catch phrase. Executives will have to think far ahead of the curve when it comes to anticipating events, and those making the big points here will be the ones who are sufficiently self-assured and are able to encourage and promote product diversity. BMW could be on the right course with its novel battery-powered two-wheeler, the Mini Scooter E Concept. Targeted for young adults, this scooter is seen as both an alternative to the electric car and a shot in the arm for the ailing motorcycle industry.

When the business world experiences rapid and drastic change, people have to be ready and willing to accept fresh concepts. Likewise, a leader’s identity needs to be so solidly established that he or she can communicate confidently and candidly across generations and cultures. Executives also must be able to adapt to social and cultural differences. The most successful executives will be those who demonstrate empathy and cultural sensitivity and do so with the right motivation—to drive successful execution of the strategy; executives responding to others’ preferences and expectations simply to gain popularity may not prove tough enough to be an effective leader. At its most elemental, what leaders need to accomplish is listening and responding to others’ personal needs in the interest of the company and then gaining their support for company goals.

Failure can be as valuable as innovation One quality that often is underrated in the auto industry is risk taking. Risk taking must go hand in hand with the willingness to delegate—not just duties and accountability but also power and decision-making authority. Executives will be more successful when they promote the creativity of others and stop regarding lateral thinkers as troublemakers. These new leaders must encourage their teams to test out novel behaviors and innovative approaches. When risks are agreed upon and discussed in advance, there’s no place for penalizing failure. The very impressive yardstick in this respect is Tata Motors: Every year, a prize is awarded by the company for an innovation that seriously was pursued but, alas, failed.

Author

Walter Friederichs, Ph.D., leads the firm’s global Automotive Practice and recruits candidates for top management and board positions in a range of industries at Russell Reynolds Associates.

Quarterly Report | 21 Leadership, Succession and Search | Russell Reynolds Associates is a global leader in assessment, recruitment and succession planning for CEOs, boards of directors and key roles within the C-suite. With more than 300 consultants in 41 offices around the globe, our dynamic teams and action-oriented approach help our clients develop goals, define appropriate roles and fill leadership gaps. We work closely with both public and private organizations across all industries and regions to build boards and executive teams that can meet the challenges and opportunities presented by the digital, economic, environmental and political trends reshaping the business landscape. www.russellreynolds.com

Americas New York Mumbai Copenhagen 200 Park Avenue Unit 9(A), Grand Hyatt Plaza Kongens Nytorv 3 Atlanta Suite 2300 Santacruz (East) DK-1050 Copenhagen K 1180 Peachtree St., NE New York, NY 10166-0002 Mumbai 400 055 Denmark Suite 2250 United States of America India Tel: +45-33-69-23-20 Atlanta, GA 30309-3521 Tel: +1-212-351-2000 Tel: +91-22-6733-2222 United States of America Frankfurt Tel: +1-404-577-3000 Palo Alto New Delhi OpernTurm 260 Homer Avenue, Suite 202 203, Eros Corporate Tower 60306 Frankfurt am Main Boston Palo Alto, CA 94301-2777 Nehru Place Germany One Federal Street, 25th Floor United States of America New Delhi 110 019 Tel: +49-69-75-60-90-0 Boston, MA 02110-1007 Tel: +1-650-233-2400 India United States of America Tel: +91-11-4603-4600 Hamburg Tel: +1-617-523-1111 San Francisco Stadthausbrücke 101 Street Seoul 1-3/Fleethof Buenos Aires Suite 2900 16F West Tower 20355 Hamburg Buenos Aires Plaza San Francisco, CA 94111-5829 Mirae Asset Centre 1 Building Germany Manuela Sáenz 323 United States of America 26 Eulji-ro 5-gil, Jung-gu Tel: +49-40-48-06-61-0 Seventh Floor, Suites 14 and 15 Tel: +1-415-352-3300 Seoul 100-210 C1107BPA, Buenos Aires Korea London Argentina São Paulo Tel: +82-2-6030-3200 Almack House Tel: +54-11-4118-8900 Edifício Eldorado Business Tower 28 King Street Av. Nações Unidas, 8.501 11º Shanghai London SW1Y 6QW Calgary 05425-070 São Paulo Room 4504, Jin Mao Tower United Kingdom Suite 750, Ernst & Young Tower Brazil 88 Century Avenue Tel: +44-20-7839-7788 440-2nd Avenue SW Tel: +55-11-3566-2400 Pudong, Shanghai 200121 Calgary, Alberta T2P 5E9 China Madrid Canada Stamford Tel: +86-21-6163-0888 Calle Miguel Angel, 11, 7° Tel: +1-403-776-4192 301 Tresser Boulevard 28010 Madrid Suite 1210 Singapore Spain Chicago Stamford, CT 06901-3250 2 Shenton Way Tel: +34-91-319-7100 155 North Wacker Drive United States of America #08-01 SGX Centre 1 Suite 4100 Tel: +1-203-905-3341 Singapore 068804 Milan Chicago, IL 60606-1732 Singapore Via Mascheroni, 5 United States of America Toronto Tel: +65-6225-1811 20123 Milan Tel: +1-312-993-9696 Scotia Plaza, Suite 3410 Italy 40 King Street West Sydney Tel: +39-02-430-015-1 Dallas Toronto, ON Level 40 Aurora Place 8401 N. Central Expressway M5H 3Y2 88 Phillip Street Munich Suite 650 Canada Sydney NSW 2000 Maximilianstraße 12-14 Dallas, TX 75225-4404 Tel: +1-416-364-3355 Australia 80539 München United States of America Tel: +61-2-9258-3100 Germany Tel: +1-214-220-2033 Washington, D.C. Tel: +49-89-24-89-81-3 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Tokyo Houston Suite 400 Izumi Garden Tower 14F Paris 600 Travis Street, Suite 2200 Washington, DC 20006-5810 1-6-1 Roppongi 7, Place Vendôme Houston, TX 77002-2910 United States of America Minato-ku, Tokyo 106-6014 75001 Paris United States of America Tel: +1-202-654-7800 Japan France Tel: +1-713-754-5995 Tel: +81-3-5114-3700 Tel: +33-1-49-26-13-00 Los Angeles Asia/Pacific Stockholm 11100 Santa Monica Blvd. Europe Hamngatan 27 Suite 350 Beijing SE-111 47 Stockholm Los Angeles, CA 90025-3384 Unit 3422 China World Tower 1 Amsterdam Sweden United States of America No. 1 Jian Guo Men Wai Avenue World Trade Center Tel: +46-8-545-074-40 Tel: +1-310-775-8940 Beijing 100004 Tower H, 18th Floor China Zuidplein 148 Warsaw Mexico City Tel: +86-10-6535-1188 1077 XV Amsterdam Belvedere Plaza Torre Reforma The Netherlands ul. Belwederska 23 Paseo de la Reforma Hong Kong Tel: +31-20-305-7630 00-761 Warsaw 115-1502 Room 1801, Alexandra House Poland Lomas de Chapultepec 18 Chater Road Central Barcelona Tel: +48-22-851-68-38 11000 México, D.F. Hong Kong Edificio Prisma México China Avda. Diagonal, 613, 2˚A Zürich Tel: +52-55-5249-5130 Tel: +852-2523-9123 08028 Barcelona Löwenstrasse 28 Spain CH-8001 Zurich Minneapolis/St. Paul Melbourne Tel: +34-93-494-9400 Switzerland 225 South Sixth Street, Suite 2550 Level 51, Rialto Towers Tel: +41-44-447-30-30 Minneapolis, MN 55402-3900 525 Collins Street Brussels United States of America Melbourne, VIC 3000 Boulevard St. Michel 27 Tel: +1-612-332-6966 Australia B-1040 Brussels Tel: +61-3-9603-1300 Belgium Tel: +32-2-743-12-20

©2013 Russell Reynolds Associates, Inc. Russell Reynolds is a trademark of Russell Reynolds Associates.

­22 | Quarterly Reoprt