Pharmacological Therapy of Lupus Nephritis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Downloaded from www.jama.com at Johns Hopkins University, on November 23, 2005 GRAND ROUNDS CLINICIAN’S CORNER AT THE JOHNS HOPKINS BAYVIEW MEDICAL CENTER Pharmacological Therapy of Lupus Nephritis Derek M. Fine, MD Kidney involvement is common in systemic lupus erythematosus, occurring CASE PRESENTATION in up to 60% of affected adults during the course of their disease. Diffuse Mrs P, a 31-year-old woman, developed proliferative lupus nephritis (World Health Organization class IV), the most a blood pressure of 170/104 mm Hg at ominous variant, has traditionally been treated with cyclophosphamide and 38 weeks of pregnancy. Her obstetri- glucocorticoids. With cyclophosphamide, women of childbearing potential cian performed a laboratory evaluation must weigh the risks of sustained amenorrhea, infertility, increased suscep- ϩ that revealed proteinuria (2 ), throm- tibility to infection, bone marrow suppression, hemorrhagic cystitis, and ma- bocytopenia (platelet count, 121ϫ103/µL lignancy against the benefits of better disease control compared with glu- [normal range: 150-350ϫ103/µL]), a serum creatinine level of 0.8 mg/dL (70.7 cocorticoids alone. Because of the host of adverse effects associated with µmol/L) (normal range: 0.4-1.1 mg/dL cyclophosphamide, alternative approaches to the treatment of lupus nephri- [35.3-97.2 µmol/L]), uric acid level of 9.0 tis are desirable. A 31-year-old woman developed class IV lupus nephritis mg/dL (normal range: 2.4-5.7 mg/dL), in the postpartum period. Seeking to preserve fertility and avoid other known and aspartate and alanine aminotrans- toxicities of cyclophosphamide, she chose to undergo therapy with myco- ferase levels of 170 U/L and 190 U/L, phenolate mofetil. In the treatment of severe lupus nephritis, mycopheno- respectively (normal range: 0-35 U/L). late mofetil has emerged as an alternative to cyclophosphamide, offering a Mrs P was diagnosed with the HELLP major advance in the therapy of lupus nephritis. (hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, low platelets) syndrome1 and underwent an JAMA. 2005;293:3053-3060 www.jama.com emergent cesarean delivery of a healthy male newborn. Despite this interven- quent 2 months. Her transient conges- At the time of Mrs P’s nephrology tion, Mrs P continued to have thrombo- tive heart failure was attributed to post- evaluation, her medications included cytopenia and hypertension. In addi- partum cardiomyopathy. Five months candesartan (32 mg/d) and metopro- tion, she developed temperatures up to after delivery, she presented with fe- lol succinate (150 mg/d). The family 102° F. She was treated empirically with ver, fatigue, arthralgias, malar rash, a medical history was noncontributory. antibiotics and received heparin briefly papular eruption on her forearms, and She had previously worked as a neo- for a presumptive diagnosis of pelvic alopecia. Her platelet count was still low natal nurse and did not smoke or drink. ϫ 3 thrombophlebitis. Fevers continued and (69 10 /µL) and she remained ane- Her child was now 6 months old; she she developed weakness and fatigue. mic (hematocrit, 26% [normal range: and her husband were eager to have Four months after delivery, she de- 38%-47%]). These findings prompted more children. veloped progressive dyspnea on exer- a serological workup that revealed high On physical examination the pa- tion and orthopnea. Echocardiogra- titer positive assay for antinuclear an- tient was afebrile with a blood pres- phy revealed an ejection fraction of tibodies (ANAs) and antibodies to sure of 132/80 mm Hg, a resting pulse 30%. Therapy was initiated with an an- double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Her se- Author Affiliation: Division of Nephrology, Depart- giotensin-converting enzyme inhibi- rum complement levels were low, with ment of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School tor and a loop diuretic, with resolu- the C3 and C4 complements measur- of Medicine, Baltimore, Md. ing 43 mg/dL (normal range: 79-152 Corresponding Author: Derek M. Fine, MD, Division tion of her symptoms and normalization of Nephrology, Department of Medicine, Johns Hop- of her cardiac function over the subse- mg/dL) and 5 mg/dL (normal range: kins University School of Medicine, 1830 E Monu- 12-42 mg/dL), respectively. Her eryth- ment St, Suite 416, Baltimore, MD 21205 (dfine1 @jhmi.edu). See also Patient Page. rocyte sedimentation rate was el- Grand Rounds at The Johns Hopkins Bayview Medi- evated at 107 mm/h (normal range: 4-25 cal Center Section Editors: John H. Stone, MD, MPH, CME available online at mm/h). The diagnosis of systemic lu- Charles Weiner, MD, Stephen D. Sisson, MD, The Johns www.jama.com Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Md; David S. Cooper, MD, pus erythematosus (SLE) was made. Contributing Editor, JAMA. ©2005 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. (Reprinted) JAMA, June 22/29, 2005—Vol 293, No. 24 3053 Downloaded from www.jama.com at Johns Hopkins University, on November 23, 2005 PHARMACOLOGICAL THERAPY OF LUPUS NEPHRITIS of 80/min, and a respiratory rate of plications. Most of the 22 glomeruli in mofetil in lupus nephritis, Mrs P chose 12/min. She had thinning hair and a ma- the sample showed diffuse mesangial ex- to undergo therapy with mycopheno- lar rash, but her skin was otherwise pansion and proliferative changes, with late mofetil. clear. Her cardiac examination re- mesangial and endocapillary prolifera- vealed a regular rate and rhythm, nor- tion. There were segmental necrotizing DISCUSSION mal S1 and S2, and no murmurs. Her lesions in 4 of the glomeruli and fibro- Mrs P’s presentation is instructive be- lungs were clear to auscultation. There cellular crescents in 2, indicating signifi- cause it highlights the fact that SLE can was no organomegaly, and she had no cant activity (representative glomeruli develop during or after pregnancy and clubbing, cyanosis, edema, or arthritis shown in FIGURE 1). In addition, im- that it can mimic preeclampsia and the in her extremities. The neurological ex- munofluorescence revealed a “full HELLP syndrome. Her case also dem- amination was normal. Additional labo- house” of immunoreactants, with onstrates how to approach difficult ratory results were notable for a se- granular staining for IgG, IgA, C3, C1q, therapeutic issues by involving the pa- rum creatinine level of 1.1 mg/dL (97.2 and and light chains. The biopsy tient in the decision-making process. In µmol/L) with a urine protein to creati- was consistent with diffuse prolifera- Mrs P’s case, the particular concern re- nine ratio of 2.5 mg protein/mg creati- tive (World Health Organization lated to the potential for both short- and nine (proteinuria approximately 2.5 [WHO] class IV) glomerulonephritis. long-term adverse effects of cyclophos- g/d). Microscopic examination of her A meeting including the patient, her phamide, particularly those related to urine showed 10 to 15 red blood cells/ husband, the rheumatologist, and the fertility. The choice was between a stan- high power field, but no red cell casts. nephrologists was convened to dis- dard medication associated with sub- Further serological workup revealed an- cuss treatment options. Although cy- stantial risks of toxicity and a newer tibodies to Ro and Sm. clophosphamide was considered the agent with a limited track record. Her A kidney biopsy was performed to de- standard of care in this setting, the pa- case illustrates emerging data that termine the histological nature and se- tient and her husband were con- strongly support mycophenolate mofetil verity of her renal process. However, cerned about the potential effects of that as an alternative to cyclophosphamide given that her platelet count remained medication on fertility, the risk of ma- in the treatment of lupus nephritis. low, biopsy was delayed until after a lignancy, and the possible infectious The diagnosis of SLE was suspected methylprednisolone pulse, 1 g/d for 3 consequences of severe immunosup- in this patient when she developed a days, followed by 60 mg/d of predni- pression. In light of these concerns, malar rash, alopecia, arthralgias, and sone. The methylprednisolone led to a treatment with mycophenolate mofetil worsening fatigue, accompanied by platelet count increase to greater than was considered. Presented with a bal- thrombocytopenia and hemolytic ane- 100ϫ103/µL within 5 days, and the kid- anced discussion of the data now avail- mia. The diagnosis was confirmed by ney biopsy was undertaken without com- able on the use of mycophenolate positive assays for ANAs, antibodies to Figure 1. Light Microscopic Findings of Representative Glomeruli A B Fibrocellular Crescent A, Hyperlobulated glomerulus with global involvement with endocapillary and mesangial hypercellularity with matrix expansion (white arrowheads) and wireloop le- sions (black arrowheads). B, Glomerulus with global endocapillary proliferation, leukocyte influx, mesangial expansion, and crescent formation (hematoxylin-eosin stain; original magnification x 400). 3054 JAMA, June 22/29, 2005—Vol 293, No. 24 (Reprinted) ©2005 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded from www.jama.com at Johns Hopkins University, on November 23, 2005 PHARMACOLOGICAL THERAPY OF LUPUS NEPHRITIS double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), and Table 1. Classification and Treatment of the Different Forms of Lupus Nephritis the findings of her renal biopsy. Her WHO Immunosuppression presentation was confusing because Class* Description Recommendations† both preeclampsia and the HELLP syn- I Minimal mesangial lupus nephritis No specific therapy drome can