Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. Minutes of the 134th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal
Committee-2 (MMR & Konkan Division) held on 8th,9th & 10th
June , 2020. through Video Conferencing:
Day III 10th June 2020
The tenure of SEIAA/SEAC’s in the State of Maharashtra ended on 16th
March 2020. The MoEF&CC informed to the Maharashtra SEIAA by an e-mail stating that, the tenure of SEIAA, Maharashtra has been extended up to
16.06.2020 In view of above communication and present pandemic situation of
COVID-19, Maharashtra SEIAA directed SEAC-2 to appraise the proposals by using information technology facilities. Hence, SEAC-2 initiated to appraise the proposal received by the SEIAA through Videoconferencing technology on Cisco
WebEx platform from 8th,9th & 10th June , 2020.
Following members of SEAC-2 were present for videoconference.
Shri. Mohan Adtani Chairman Shri. Bharat Bhushan Expert Member Dr. V.A. Mhaisalkar Expert Member Dr. Rakesh Kumar Expert Member Dr. V Jyotiprakash Expert Member Shri. Upendra D. Kulkarni Expert Member Shri. Narendra Toke Member Secretary
Chairman welcomed the members to the 134th SEAC-II Meeting.
The minutes of the meeting are finalised during videoconference. Due to present pandemic situation minutes could not be physically signed.
Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020.
Item No- 17 SIA/MH/NCP/41154/2019 Proposed Slum Rehabilitation Development is located at CTS No. 410 C/1(Pt) & 446 C/2 (Pt) at Relief Road, Oshiwara, Jogeshwari (West), Mumbai by Gajanan Builders. (ToR)
PP submitted letter of absence, hence the matter is deferred.
......
Item No- 18. SIA/MH/MIS/53158/2019 Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) Housing Scheme, located at Plot No. 3, Sector 16A, Kharkopar Railway Station (East), Ulwe Node, Navi Mumbai, Taluka: Panvel, District: Raigad, Maharashtra
Introduction:-
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Environmental consultant M/s Ultratech . ltd. PP informed that this is a PMAY scheme. The details of the project are
1. Plot Area 48,167.81 Sq.mt.
2. FSI Area 80,757.19 Sq. mt.
3. Non FSI Area 76,932.49 Sq. mt.
4. Total Built up Area 1,57,689.68 Sq.mt.
(FSI & Non FSI) Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 5. Building Configuration 21 nos. of Residential Buildings(EWS): Ground + 14 floors each Flats: 2352 Nos. Shops: 36 Nos.
Commercial: Ground floor Community Center
6. Total Population 9516 Nos.
7. Water Requirement 1327 KLD
8. Sewage generation 1105 KLD
9. STP capacity and Sewage (1105 KLD) will be discharged into Technology existing Nodal STP of 32
MLD capacity near Ulwe, Sector 6 for treatment
10. STP location --
11. RG area required RG area requirement: 7225.17 Sq.mt. (15 %) and Provided RG area provision: 7671.98 Sq.mt. (15.93 %)
12. Energy requirement Connected load :6654 KW
Maximum demand : 4436 KW
13. Total Energy Saving 20 %
Energy saving by Solar 5 %
14. No. of DG sets and 4 DG sets of capacity 125 kVA each,4 DG sets of capacity capacity 100 kVA each & 3 DG sets of capacity 400 kVA each
15. Solid waste generation Non-biodegradable waste: 2546 Kg/day
Biodegradable waste : 1697 Kg/day
16. OWC Capacity Area for solid waste management: 152 Sq.mt.
17. Parking 4 Wheeler: 695 Nos.
2 Wheeler: 84Nos.
18. EMP Cost Construction Phase: Rs. 84.34 Lacs
Operation Phase:
Capital cost : Rs. 315.20 Lacs
Operational and Maintenance cost : Rs. 16.64 Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. Lacs/ annum
19. Rain water Harvesting Provision of 3 Nos. of RWH tank of capacity 550 KL
20. Number of recharge Nil pits and sizes of the
pits
21. Details of UGT tanks – Domestic : 819 KL Number and capacity Flushing : 273 KL
Firefighting: 1200 KL
22. CER CER plan as per the MoEF & CC circular dated 01/05/2018 Project Cost: Rs. 382.83 Crores
Cost for CER: Rs. 5.74 Crores (1.5% of project cost)
Deliberation:- The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and
documents submitted by the proponent. All issues related to environment,
including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were
discussed. Committee noted that the project is under 8a (B2) category of EIA
Notification, 2006. Consolidated statements, synopsis of compliances, form 1, 1A,
presentation & plans submitted are taken on the record.
During discussion following points emerged:
1. PP to ensure that STP to be kept open minimum upto 40%.
2. PP to adopt following segregation & treatment method for the sewage
generated from the residential complex.
A) Grey water :- The waste water emanating from bathroom, kitchen sinks,
wash basins, showers, dish washers should be collected separately and
treated on site ,suitably to a level for reuse for flushing of toilets in
apartment buildings and gardening. Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. B) Black Water: - The waste water emanating from Flushing of toilets shall
be collected separately and conveyed through sewer to the nodal STP for
treatment and reuse for central garden, gardening etc.
3. PP to adopt water conservation measures by providing Low Flow Devices
(LFD) as plumbing fixtures.
4. PP to obtain Tree NOC from tree authority.
5. PP to submit legible contour map along with ground Monitoring results as
per protocol.
6. PP to ensure that the energy savings from renewable sources shall be
minimum 5.03 %.
7. PP to follow the methodology adopted by Metro rail in respect of study of
vibrations due to the metro rail in Mumbai.
8. No Occupation Certificate (OC) to be granted to the project unless the
proposed Nodal STP at Kharghar is commissioned and put into Operation.
9. During presentation it is mentioned that plot is out of CRZ area. PP to
submit the layout superimposing it on approved CZMP .
10. PP to convert 25% of car parking into two wheeler parking as per Socieo
Economic survey carried out.
11. PP to provide thick Miawaki Plantation all along the perimeter of the plot.
12. PP to calculate the reduction in potable water consumption due to provision
of Grey water treatment plant at site. The same shall be implemented.
13. PP to add ground water survey report in the EIA by taking samples from
existing nearby dug wells/bore wells. If these are not available then PP to
arrange to make samples available by digging at site.
14. The PP to get NOC from competent authority with reference to Thane
creek flamingo sanctuary if the project site falls within 10 Km radius from
the said sanctuary boundary, if applicable. The planning authority to
ensure fulfilment of this condition before granting CC. Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 15. PP to submit CER prescribed by MoEF&CC circular dated 1.5.2018 relevant
to the area and people around the project. The specific activities to be
undertaken under CER to be carried out in consultation with Municipal
Corporation or collector or Environment Department.
Decision:-
After deliberation, Committee decided to recommend the proposal for
Environmental Clearance to SEIAA, subject to compliance of above point
......
Item No- 19 SIA/MH/MIS/155873/2020 Construction of Essential Staff Quarters for MMRDA at Malvani, Mumbai by MUMBAI METROPOLITAN REGION DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (MMRDA)
Introduction:-
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Environmental consultant M/s Adiyta Environmental services Pvt Ltd. PP informed that this is SRA Development Project. The details of the project are ,
1. Proposed area Area of Plot: 13,840.227 sq. m. Gross construction area: 24,488.93 sq. m. FSI: 23,247.48 sq. m. Non-FSI: 1,241.45 sq. m. 2. Planning Authority Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) 3. Users / Workforce / Total Population Residents = 950 nos. 4. Water requirement Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. Source: MCGM for domestic and drinking purpose and Recycled water from STP will be used for flushing and landscaping purpose Requirement: Fresh water requirement (through municipal water supply) for domestic purpose: 84 cmd Recycled water requirement from STP: For Flushing: 42 cmd and for Gardening: 2 cmd Total water requirement: 128 cmd 5. Sewage generation: 109 cmd 6. STP capacity & Technology: STP of capacity 110 cmd (MBBR technology) 7. RG on Mother Earth RG of 25% of plot will be provided on ground (mother earth). Proposed RG area is 3,462 sq. m 8. Energy requirement Source: Public distribution system Connected load: 1113.24 kW Transformers: 2 X 630 kVA Emergency back-up for services and common areas: provision of 1 DG set of capacity 250 kVA 9. Energy saving 5% of the lighting load of total demand load will be supplied from solar PV panels which will be installed on rooftop/ external lighting. 10. Solid waste generation Total solid waste: 523 kg/day Dry waste: 209 kg/day Wet waste: 314 kg/day 11. Parking 4-wheeler: 220 nos. 2-wheeler: 110 nos. 12. Rainwater Harvesting Provision of 4 rainwater harvesting tanks of capacity 10 cum (2 nos.), 13 cum and 5 cum and 10 nos. RWH pits. Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020.
13. EMP Budget
Environment Protection Capital Cost Recurring Cost per annum Measure (Rs. in Lakh) (Rs. in Lakh)
Sewage Treatment Plant 80.00 12.00 Solid Waste Management 10.00 2.00 Rainwater Harvesting 20.00 2.00 Green Belt & Landscaping 25.00 2.00 Energy saving features 20.00 1.00 Environmental Monitoring 0.00 2.00 Environmental Monitoring Cell 0.00 2.00 TOTAL 155.00 23.00 14. CER requirement CER applicability for the proposed project: 2% of capital investment as per MoEF&CC Office Memorandum on CER dated 1st May 2018. Project cost : Rs 85 crore CER amount : Rs 170 lakh The allocated amount for CER will be spent during 7 years in proportion to the project accomplished. Following activities are envisaged under the proposed CER program: Tree plantation ,Sanitation facilities, Upgradation in health care system Deliberation:- The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. Committee noted that the project is under 8a (B2) category of EIA Notification, 2006. Consolidated statements, synopsis of compliances, form 1, 1A, presentation & plans submitted are taken on the record.
During discussion following points emerged:
1. As the area of plot mentioned in the application is only 13840.227 sqm
which is actually not a separate plot but part of a big chunk of plot on
which other operational activities of Metro Project will come up. The PP to Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. get this plot area of 13840.227 sqm officially sub-divided in the land
records department.
2. PP to ensure that STP to be kept open minimum upto 40%.The discharge of
treated sewage to be reduced to 35% .
3. PP to adopt water conservation measures by providing Low Flow Devices
(LFD) as plumbing fixtures.
4. PP to ensure that the energy savings from renewable sources shall be 5 %.
5. As presented PP to use fly ash, Crushed sand instead of natural sand for
construction.
6. PP to obtain Tree NOC from Competent authority.
7. PP to submit an affidavit that no nalla is passing through the plot
8. PP to abide with conditions of all Government authorities.
9. The PP to get NOC from competent authority with reference to Thane
creek flamingo sanctuary if the project site falls within 10 Km radius from
the said sanctuary boundary, if applicable. The planning authority to ensure
fulfilment of this condition before granting Commencement Certificates.
10. PP to submit CER prescribed by MoEF&CC circular dated 1.5.2018 relevant
to the area and people around the project. The specific activities to be
undertaken under CER to be carried out in consultation with Municipal
Corporation or collector or Environment Department.
Decision:-
In view of above discussion and subject to compliance of above points, the proposal is recommended to SEIAA for grant of Environmental Clearance.
......
Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. Item No- 20
SIA/MH/MIS/148738/2020 Proposed Expansion of EWS Mass Housing Scheme Under Prime Minister Awas Yojna Housing Project at S.No. 86 and 95, Shirdhon, Taluka - Kalyan, District- Thane. By KONKAN HOUSING & AREA DEVELOPMENT BOARD, MUMBAI (A MHADA UNIT) TOR
Introduction :-
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Environmental consultant M/s Fine Envirotech Engineers . PP presented the details
1) Total Plot Area 3,93,600 sq.m
2) FSI 4,71,500.65 sq.m
3) Non FSI 23,922.35 sq.m
4) Total Buildup 4,95,423.00 sq.m Area 5) Building 85 nos. of EWS and LIG Buildings (Ground +7Upper Configuration Floors) 6) Total Population 47955
7) Water 7084 KLD Requirement 8) Sewer Generation 5,356 KLD It is proposed to install STP-I of capacity 1750 kld , 9) STP Capacity & STP –II of capacity 2600 kld and STP III of Technology capacity 1100 kld based on MBBR technology of capacity 10) STP Location will be on ground and details will be provided in EIA RG Provided The proposed project is having 77,837.71sq.mt of RG 11) area for the development of Green belt in the premises. There will be total 3900nos Connected 26424.96 kW 12) Energy Load Requirement Demand 17616.64kW Load Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 13) §25 Nos.of DG set of capacity1 No of 250kVA + 1 No of 200kVA + 2 Nos of 180kVA + 14 Nos of 160kVA + No of DG sets & 4 Nos of 100kVA + 3 Nos of 62.5kVA will be Capacity provided.
14) Solid waste 27,711 kg/day Generation 15) Bio Degradable 17,747 kg/day Waste 16) OWC Capacity -- 17) Parking Total 9891 nos. of 2 wheelers parking will be provided. 18) 36 Lakhs during Construction 83.06 lakhs During EMP Cost Capital Operation & O & M Cost ( Lakhs /annum)-23 lakhs 19) Rainwater 10 Nos Harvesting 20) No. of Pits = 10 No of Pits & Size Size of Pits =1.5 M X 1.5 M X 1.5 M of Pits
21) Domestic Water tank - 19,73,400 Details of UGT- Flushing Water tank – 9,86,700 No & Capacity Fire Fighting Water tank – 52,00,000
22) CER 0.5 % of the Total Project Cost
Deliberation:-
The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. Committee noted that the project is under 8a (B2) category of EIA Notification, 2006. Consolidated statements, synopsis of compliances, form 1, 1A, presentation & plans submitted are taken on the record.
After discussion, Committee approved the ToR with following observations & additions, which is valid upto 09/06/2023. EIA will be apprised as & when submitted. Meanwhile PP should comply following points. Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 1. PP to submit revised Architect Certificate stating the construction done so
far in comparison with Ec granted to the project. The certificate should
clearly specify configuration wise, FSI, Non FSI wise, Building wise
construction completed so far.
2. PP to submit certificate of assurance of water supply to the said project.
3. PP to submit structural stability report from local body as the construction
is being carried for 7 floors instead of G+4, earlier sanctioned, on the same
Plinth..
4. PP to submit copy of earlier layout super imposing the new layout in
comparison with RG area and other amenities.
5. PP to adopt water conservation measures by providing Low Flow Devices
(LFD) as plumbing fixtures.
6. PP to submit socioeconomic study along with behavior pattern of the
proposed occupiers of the flats and develop a protocol for sustainable
operation of Environment Infrastructure.
7. PP to submit specific DMP , if the STP operation fails what are the
measures proposed .
8. PP to integrate EMP with all attributes of Environment.
9. PP to carry out Detailed Geo-Hydrological Study to ascertain the
usefulness of rain water harvesting with Technical details.
10. PP to ensure ECBC norms are complied.
11. PP to submit & upload wind analysis, shadow analysis, traffic analysis, light
and ventilation analysis and measures to reduce heat island effect.
Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 12. PP to carryout detailed hydrological study of adjacent area covering 300
meter area all around the proposed project. PP to also study contour of the
whole catchment and of the plot area and design the storm water network
accordingly.
13. PP to ensure that the Nallah which is flowing W-N-S in the plot is neither
diverted nor covered and that its natural flow is maintained. It may be
suitably widened, delisted or deepened as per remarks of the planning
authority.
14. PP to submit the design & cross section of STPs indicating minimum 40%
area open to sky for adequate ventilation.
15. PP to submit the detailed EMS system to be followed in the proposed
project. The system should be divided in two parts , during construction &
after construction, as mentioned during the meeting.
16. As agreed during presentation a separate report on sustainable
maintenance of Environment infrastructure , along with budgetary
provisions made and to be transferred to the housing societies for
further period 10 years after formation of housing Societies , to be
included in the report.
17. PP to verify the distance of project site from Flamingo Sanctuary, . PP to
submit & upload the same.
18. PP to submit report with emphasis on migrant labours, transit
accommodation, in situ arrangement for labours with PHC /Dispensary.
Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 19. PP to submit CER as per MoEF&CC circular dated 1.5.2018 relevant to the
area and people around the project or Environment Department may direct
PP to undertake CER work in identified area.
20. PP to also refer standard ToR published by MoEF vide order dated
10/04/15 in addition to above
Decision:-
ToR to be accorded to the said project. After deliberation, Committee decided to recommend the proposal for grant of ToR to SEIAA, subject to compliance of above points.
......
Item No- 21 SIA/MH/MIS/144985/2020, Ammendment in Environmental Clearance Grand Memorial of Bharatratna Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Memorial, Mumbai, by MMRDA.
Introduction :-
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Environmental consultant M/s Mahabal Enviro Engineers pvt. ltd. The details of proposal are ,
1. Plot area : 48,414.83 m2 2. FSI : 25,635.18 m2 3. Non-FSI : 24,702.32 m2 4. Total BUA : 50,337.50 m2 5. Building Configuration: Entrance Plaza: Ground floor (6.30 m), Dr. B. A. Ambedkar Research Centre: 2 B+ G floor (12.4 m), Auditorium and Exhibition Block: 2B + G + 1st floor (17 m), Dr. B. A. Ambedkar Monument: Ground floor structure Monument with pedestal building (Base height: 30.45 m and statue height: 106.7 m) Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 6. Total Population : Total population: 5,500 souls. (During Normal day) 7. Water Requirement: 315 KLD (Domestic: 68 KLD, Flushing: 58 KLD, Water body + back wash: 42 KLD and Gardening: 148 KLD) 8. Sewage Generation: 115 KLD 9. STP capacity & Technology: 1 STP of total 120 KLD capacity with MBR technology 10. STP Location : Basement (120 m2) 11. RG Required & Provided: RG required: 11,911.56 m2 & RG on ground: 12,870.64 m2 12. Energy Requirement: Demand Load- 1.6 MW 13. Energy Saving (total): Total Savings- 20.46 % (By Solar- 2.5%) 14. No. of DG Set and Capacity: 1 Nos., 1 x 750 kVA 15. Biodegradable waste Generation: 825 kg/day 16. OWC Capacity: 1,000 kg/day 17. Parking: 4W provided: 467 Nos., 2W provided: 126 Nos. & Public transport: 5 Nos. 18. EMP Cost: Capital Cost: 378 Lakh, O&M: 78.5 Lakh/yr. 19. Rainwater Harvesting: 1 RWH tank with 200 KL total capacity 20. Details of UG Tanks: UG Tanks are provided 21. CER: Project cost: Project cost: 709 Cr, CER to spend: Rs. 3.5 Crores (0.5% Brownfield) PP stated that Environmental Clearance has already obtained , however the present application is only for increase in height of statue by 30 meters and change in FSI & NON FSI component of project. Deliberation:- The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. Committee noted that the project is under 8a (B2) category of EIA Notification, 2006. Consolidated statements, synopsis of compliances, form 1, 1A, presentation & plans submitted are taken on the record.
During discussion following points emerged:
1. PP to ensure that STP to be kept open minimum upto 40%. Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 2. The discharge of treated sewage to be reduced to 35% .
3. PP to adopt water conservation measures by providing Low Flow Devices
(LFD) as plumbing fixtures.
4. PP to explore the possibility that the energy savings from renewable
sources to be achieved to 5 % from 2.5%
5. PP to submit monitoring results , copies of compliance reports submitted to
Regional Office, MoEFCC along with observation of Regional Office.
6. PP to explore installation of solar tree concept in the project.
7. The PP to get NOC from competent authority with reference to Thane
creek flamingo sanctuary if the project site falls within 10 Km radius from
the said sanctuary boundary, if applicable. The planning authority to ensure
fulfilment of this condition before granting Commencement Certificates.
8. PP to submit CER prescribed by MoEF&CC circular dated 1.5.2018 relevant
to the area and people around the project. The specific activities to be
undertaken under CER to be carried out in consultation with Municipal
Corporation or collector or Environment Department.
Decision:-
In view of above discussion and subject to compliance of above points, the proposal is recommended to SEIAA for grant of Environmental Clearance.
Item No- 22 SIA/MH/MIS/144234/2020 REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT BY Thane Municipal Corporation
PP was absent hence matter was deferred.
......
Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. Item No- 23 SIA/MH/MIS/131903/2019 Environment Clearance for “Metro Rail infrastructure project” proposed at Survey no.-589A, Aarey, Goregaon East, Mumbai Maharashtra 400065 developed by MMRDA.
Introduction:- Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Environmental consultant M/s Enviro Analyst & Engineers Pvt Ltd. The details of the project are
Sr. Description Details No. 1 Project Environment Clearance for Proposed “METRO RAIL Name with INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT” located at Survey no. - 589A site address (Part) Pahadi, Goregaon East, Mumbai Maharashtra 400065 by MMRDA. 2 Plot area 20,387.30 sq.m. 3 FSI 88,758.08 sq.m. 4 Non FSI 21,134.74 sq.m. 5 Total Built up 1, 09,892.08 sq.m. area 6 Building configuration Building Name & Number of floors Height Number (mtrs.) One Building Basement + Ground + 156.70 1st to 32nd Upper floors
7 No. of Flats - 60 no’s Tenements & Commercial area – 57517.80 sq.mt. Shops 8 Total 5500 nos. population 9 Total Water During dry season: Requirements Domestic water requirement 275 KLD CMD Flushing water requirement 180 KLD
Miscellaneous water 10 KLD requirement
HVAC makeup water 200 KLD requirement
Irrigation water requirement 60 KLD
Total water demand 715 KLD Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020.
During wet season: 655 KLD 10 Sewage 400 KLD generation 11 STP Capacity 400 KLD & MBBR & Technology 12 STP location Ground 13 Total Solid Dry waste – 952 kg/day Waste Wet waste – 447 kg/day Quantities Total solid waste – 1399 kg/day OWC 120 Area required for machines – 3 sq.m. for each machine Disposal: Dry garbage will be segregated & disposed off to recyclers/Vans Processed in OWC. The manure obtained shall be used for Gardening; Excess manure shall be sold to nearby end users. 14 RG area RG Required = 5094.50 sq.m. (25%) required & RG Proposed = 5949.19 sq.m. (29.5%) provided – RG on Mother Earth = 2571.20 sq.m. mother earth RG a = 1203.60 sq.m.(615.00 Sq.m. Paved RG ) RG b = 471.77 sq.m. RG c = 895.83 sq.m. RG on Podium RG d = 3377.99 sq.m. 15 Power During operation phase – requirement Total Connected Load KW Total Demand Load KW 7546 6037
16 Energy Energy saving through solar KWH/Day – 540 Efficiency Total solar saving – 1.6 % 17 D.G. set 8 x 975 kVA capacity
18 Parking 4W & 4W – 250 Nos. 2W 2W – 54 Nos. 19 Rain water Rain water collection tank – 1 Nos. and 2 days water storage harvesting 130 cum capacity of tanks. scheme Location – Under ground 20 Project Cost 972 Crore in (Cr.) Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 21 EMP cost Set up cost – 331.5 lakhs O&M – 39.35 lakhs/annum DMP – Budget Provision – 1464, 01,688.00 Cr. O&M – 1, 33, 72,528.00 Cr. 22 CER As per OM of MoEFCC
Proposal was earlier considered in 131st meeting of SEAC-2. SEAC pointed out that,
1. The land CTS no A589 on, which present project is proposed NDZ in
current DP, UD while draft notification 06-08-2019 proposed to change
the reservation from NDZ to residential zone excepting reservation for
cemetery in this plot, PP is not supposed to take any construction activity
till the final notification is published by UD converting land from NDZ to
residential zone.
2. PP to clarify what is the plot area of 589(A)-plot. The area as per proposal
and as per U.D Notification does not tally. It is therefore not becoming
clear as to for how much plot area, the EC is to be granted.
3. PP to ensure that project should be net zero discharge.
4. The nalla flowing through plot not to be closed by cement slab nor it should
be diverted. PP to ensure that crossing over nalla should be of box culvert.
PP to provide 6 mtr road alongside nalla for maintenance and upkeep of
nallah.
5. PP to submit the nalla remark received by vide letter date 17-08-2019.
6. Committee noted that, nalla drawing shown in PPT is not matching with nalla
remark drawing received from MCGM, PP to submit actual layout matching
the nallah flow as per actual on the spot.
7. PP to ensure that E-waste disposal should be as per E-waste management
rule 2016.
8. PP to submit the copy of HRC NoC. Minutes of the 134rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee-2 (MMR & th th th Konkan Division) held on 8 ,9 & 10 June , 2020. 9. PP to submit the CFO NoC.
10. Civil aviation NOC for proposed helipad on top of building as well as point of
height of building.
Deliberation:- The PP along with Consultant presented the compliance of above points during meeting. The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. Committee noted that the project is under 8a (B2) category of EIA Notification, 2006. Consolidated statements, synopsis of compliances, form 1, 1A, presentation & plans submitted are taken on the record.
During discussion following points emerged:
1. PP submitted the compliance of above points.
2. PP submitted nalla remarks dated 17.10 2019 however mentioned that they
have approached MCGM for Revised Nalla remark on 07th may 2020 which
is awaited.
3. The Committee during earlier appraisal of the Project had pointed out that
the Nallah passing through the plot is neither to be diverted nor closed
except that crossing over the Nallah may be through box culverts of
sufficient strength and that the PP was to provide clear driveway along the
Nallah for its maintenance and upkeep. The MCGM has also not given any
Nalla remarks granting permission for diverting/closing of Nallah. The
project therefore cannot be considered as proposed.
Decision:-
In view of above discussion the proposal is deferred and will be considered after compliance of above points.
......