Annual report

2011-2012

Contents

Introduction...... 3

Staffing...... 5

Staff News ...... 6

Honorary degrees ...... 7

Students...... 8

Undergraduate Student News ...... 8

Postgraduate Student News ...... 9

Continuing Professional Legal Education ...... 10

Internationalisation...... 11

Developing links: International visits and collaborations ...... 11

Internationalisation within the curriculum ...... 14

SCHOOL’S RESEARCH AND ACADEMIC ACTIVITIES...... 16

Awards and Funding ...... 17

Research Seminars ...... 18

Postgraduate Research Community...... 19

Lectures and Conferences ...... 20

Knowledge Transfer at International Fora ...... 22

APPENDICES...... 24

Appendix A: Annual Calendar of Events...... 25

Appendix B: Internationalisation...... 28

Appendix C: Graduations...... 30

Appendix D: Publications...... 31

Introduction

The 12 month period from 1 st August 2011 to 31 st July 2012 covered by this report was a busy one with the normal highs and lows that make up a successful academic year.

Our students continue to excel both in terms of LLB performance with 22% securing overall Firsts but also with several successes in national mooting competitions, further details below. At postgraduate level we had the first Diploma Awards Ceremony since the repatriation of the Diploma and continue to be the leading provider in Scotland. Lord Gill presented the awards and delivered the charge to the students. In the autumn the LLM Graduation was marked by the award of an honorary LLD to Judge Bruno Simma, then a judge at the International Court of Justice in The Hague. Furthermore, two new LLM Programmes, Intellectual Property and the Digital Economy and International Law and Security , were launched in September.

In terms of academic events the year was marked by the 25 th James Wood Lecture delivered in the autumn by Baroness Brenda Hale, Justice of the Supreme Court, and the first Andrew Dewar Gibb Lecture delivered in the spring by Lady Hazel Cosgrove. A number of other lectures, seminars and workshops were organised bringing to the University of Glasgow and to the School of Law academics, practitioners and judges from the UK and abroad.

As evidenced by the list of publications annexed to the Report, academic staff have been productive publishing seventeen books and a significant number of articles in leading national and international journals. The work of colleagues in the School has been recognised nationally and internationally by either election to prestigious bodies or awards for outstanding contributions to innovative teaching programmes.

The internationalisation of the School of Law continues with several new academic appointments coming from European Universities. For our undergraduate students the School participated in Summer Schools organised in Italy and The Netherlands. We have also been active in recruiting non-UK students. The recruitment activities have focussed on Germany, Norway, China and Brazil. Several agreements have been signed with non-UK Schools of Law primarily facilitating mobility of undergraduate and postgraduate students. The School has continued to welcome foreign visitors who are accommodated in the School for periods ranging from a month to a year.

3

The highlight of the year in terms of a significant appointment was the recruitment of a distinguished academic to the Regius Chair in Law which has been vacant of a number of years. James Chalmers, an expert in Criminal Law, and formerly from the University of Edinburgh, was appointed to a Chair of Law and nominated to the Scottish Executive as the University’s candidate for the Regius Chair. The appointment enables the School to initiate in January 2013, the tercentenary celebrations of the establishment of the Regius Chair. During the following 12 months, a number of events will be organised to focus attention on the School’s excellent scholarship in terms of research and teaching as well as the achievements of its alumni. The celebrations will be launched on Thursday 17 January 2013 with the inaugural lecture of Professor James Chalmers, Regius Chair in Law.

Professor Rosa Greaves Head of School August 2012

4 Staffing

As we have come to expect the year was marked by a number of staff departures and arrivals.

Outgoing :

• Antonios Tzanakopoulos - left in September 2011 to take up a temporary post as a lecturer at University College London. He has now been appointed to a permanent post at the University of Oxford (but remaining on a 0.2% contract at Glasgow).

• Dr Aileen McHarg left in March 2012 to take up a Chair in Public Law at the University of Strathclyde.

• Professor Scott Veitch resigned as from June 2012 to remain as the Paul K C Chung Professor in Jurisprudence at the University of Hong Kong , a post he has occupied since 2010 after taking a period of leave of absence from the University of Glasgow.

• Professor Nicholas Tsagourias left in August 2012 to take up a post as Professor of International Security at the University of Sheffield.

We wish them all success in their new endeavours.

Incoming:

Professor James Chalmers has taken up the Regius Chair of Law. He was previously at the University of Edinburgh

Dr Marco Goldoni from the University of Antwerp, has taken up a Lectureship in Legal Theory.

Mr Thomas Heraghty has taken up the post of Assessment Administrator

Dr Irini Papincolopulu has taken up a lectureship in International Law. She has just completed a period of two years at the University of Oxford as a Marie Curie Fellow.

5 Staff News

Professor Emilios Christodoulidis has been elected member of the Executive Committee (representing the UK for a period of 4 years) of the International Association of Social and Legal Philosophy (IVR). Currently celebrating its centenary, the IVR is the main international association for legal philosophy. The Association numbers over 30 national branches and its bi-annual conferences are attended, on average, by 800-900 scholars.

Professor Lorne Crerar has been appointed for a term of 3 years as the Chair of the Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE). He has been a member of the HIE board since April 2008 and is also chair of the HIE Risk and Assurance Committee.

Professor Mark Godfrey , (then Senior Lecturer in Scots Law) was appointed Editor of The Journal of Legal History as from November 2011. The Journal was established in 1980 and is dedicated to publication on the sources and development of the common law, both in the British Isles and overseas, on the history of the laws of Ireland, Scotland, and Wales, and on Roman Law and the European legal tradition. It is the leading European journal in the field published in English.

Professor Jim Murdoch, Professor of Public Law at the University of Glasgow has been awarded the Pro Merito medal of the Council of Europe. The medal is the highest distinction granted by the Secretary General to individuals or organisations in recognition of their commitment to the Council of Europe’s values and work. The medal was presented to Jim for his work in human rights education and, in particular, the Human Rights Project, now in its 20th year.

Professor Jim Murdoch being awarded the Pro- Merito medal by the Deputy Secretary General, Maud de Boer- Buquicchio

6

Professor Christian Tams has successfully become a member of the Royal Society of Edinburgh Young Academy of Scotland for an initial term of 3 years. The Society has nominated 68 members who were selected from over 300 applicants. The Young Academy was launched at a ceremony in November 2011 in Edinburgh.

Dr Antonios Tzanakopoulos has won the Georges Tenékidès Prize for best doctoral thesis in international law and international relations in the biennium 2009-10. The prize is awarded by the Hellenic Society of International Law and International Relations.

Honorary degrees

Judge Bruno Simma from the International Court in The Hague was awarded an Honorary Degree at the postgraduate graduation in December 2011.

7 Students

Undergraduate Student News

English Speaking Union Essex Court Chambers National Mooting Competition

Katherine Docherty, Francesca Ruddy, HRH Prince Philip

In June 2011, after seven months of moot rounds against universities throughout the country, two final year students, Katherine Docherty and Francesca Ruddy were delighted to win the Final of the English Speaking Union (ESU)/Essex Court Chambers National Mooting Competition, held in the Royal Courts of Justice in London. Beating opponents from the University of Cambridge and BPP Law School (London) they mooted on Equity in front of a three-judge bench.

This is the first time in the prestigious competition’s 40 year history that the coveted silver mace has come to Glasgow. The students each received a cash prize and a cheque for the School of Law. After being congratulated in the Scottish Parliament and by prominent legal figures such as Lord Bonomy, Lord Gill and Lady Smith, they were invited to the ESU prize-giving ceremony at Buckingham Palace in November and were honoured to receive an award from Prince Phillip, Duke of Edinburgh.

8

OUP-BPP Mooting Competition

Katherine Docherty and Bobby Lindsay won the Oxford University Press - BPP National Mooting Competition for 2011-2012, held at the BPP Law School in Holborn, London. Katy and Bobby were one of four teams in the final, having started out competing as one of 58 UK universities in the competition. This is the second time in a decade that Glasgow has won this UK-wide mooting competition (previously won for Glasgow by Raymond Baudon and Louise Beattie in 2003).

Placements

We continue to be effective in our activity outwith the school facilitating approximately 50 student placements with several key firms and organisations including: Citizens’ Advice Bureau, Airdrie In-Court Advice Service, Govan Law Centre, Witness Service (Victim Support). Law students are also invited to apply for placements sourced by Club 21, normally at city law firms. The Employability team is monitoring the links and the optimum number of “placement partners” in order to realise the best fit of placements to number of interested students. The placements are very popular as they add a positive dimension to the student’s CV and we are continue to seek placement partners to add to our portfolio.

Postgraduate Student News

Diploma students were once again very successful in the Client Consultation Competition and the two students, Andrew Gow and Rachel McKay, who won the internal heats, represented the University at the Scottish finals in Dundee and again for Scotland in the international competition in Dublin.

For the first time, Diploma students took part in the Scottish Negotiation competition, which was held in Aberdeen. Pamela Sealey and Jane Farnsworth won the national event and went onto represent Scotland in the international finals in Belfast.

Andreas Jauch, a postgraduate student studying for an LLM in Intellectual Property and the Digital Economy (IPDE programme), benefitted from a summer 2012 internship with the IP team at the Glasgow Office of Pinsent Masons. In 2012-13 a boutique Scottish IP law firm – Cloch Solicitors – will also be offering one student on the IPDE programme a two-week summer internship working in the field of IP law.

In March 2012, a group of students from the International Law/International Law & Security LLM programmes organised a trip to The Hague, where they visited various institutions such as the International Criminal Court (ICC), the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) and the International Court of Justice (ICJ).

9 Scottish Competition Law Forum 2012

In May 2012, the University of Glasgow hosted the Scottish Competition Law Forum 2012 student debate. Teams were made up of 2-4 members following undergraduate or postgraduate studies with some element of competition law. The University of Glasgow was represented in the debate (on the topic This house believes no cartel can be justified ) by two teams of students. Members of the winning team consisting of Lindsay Morison, Rachel Malloch, Martin Langvik and Paul Silviu who are all students taking postgraduate courses in competition law, were invited to spend a day with one of the Scottish competition law practitioner firms, Pinsent Masons. The judge hearing the debates was Dr Philip Marsden, Director of the Competition Law Forum and Senior Research Fellow of the British Institute of International and Comparative law.

Continuing Professional Legal Education We have continued to revise and develop the portfolio of courses that we offer to legal professionals so that they remain innovative and dynamic. As from May 2012 the School commenced the delivery of Trainee/Continuing Professional Development (TCPD) courses. The School organised and delivered 26 courses specifically designed for the legal and other professions. The School is now offering courses approved by the Law Society of Scotland (LSS) not only for TCPD and Continuing Professional Development (CPD) but also offers the opportunity to choose courses which will lead to an LLM in Contemporary Law and Practice. In this manner trainees and solicitors are able to meet the professional requirements of the LSS as well as the academic standards for an award of a postgraduate degree. The autumn/winter programme of courses, which offers 55 different sessions, is due to commence in September 2012.

Our courses are delivered by expert academics or Diploma tutors who are practitioners and trained in teaching skills. It is a key objective of the School to become the provider in Scotland not only of the best qualified law practitioners but also to be recognised as a centre of excellence for the provision of courses for law trainees, legal practitioners and other professionals

10

Internationalisation

The School of Law’s international profile reflects its continuing successes in attracting overseas students, sending undergraduate students abroad, and in developing staff collaboration in postgraduate recruitment, teaching and research.

The results of the International Student Barometer for 2011 indicated the University of Glasgow is rated 1st in the UK for international student satisfaction: in Law, more than 90% of the international students in the School of Law report satisfaction with their learning experience at Glasgow, while an impressive 99% of international students report themselves as being satisfied with the expert lecturers in the School of Law.

Developing links: International visits and collaborations

In October, a group of 10 senior law students from the University of Sarajevo visited the School on a two- week study programme. This was part of a programme involving Glasgow, Hamburg (Bucherius) and Virginia Law Schools following a series of intensive classes which were delivered in Sarajevo earlier this year. The lectures were delivered by academics and practising lawyers, including Professor Ian Forrester. The focus of the programme is public law and European law. Funding comes from a range of European government and private charities.

The ‘Globalisation and Legal Theory’ doctoral programme is a collaboration between the Universities of Antwerp, Glasgow, Kiel and Tilburg . Erasmus Mundus, with eight students, three of who will be supervised in Glasgow and a full 'intensive training programme' has been devised for its first year, including a week- long seminar in November in Glasgow with the participation of all students and teaching staff. The objective for this programme is to secure Erasmus Mundus Action 1B funding in due course. It a unique experiment at PhD level and we have been approached by Bologna who wish to participate in the partnership . One particular feature of the programme is that it involves regular exchange between PhD students and staff across the four participating universities through co-supervision, annual doctoral colloquia and joint seminar series.

The Law School has developed an integrated programme targeted at the US graduate market. The integrated programme permits graduates to enrol on the 2-year accelerated LLB degree followed by 1 year LLM and thus graduating with 3 years of Law studies. The School of Law intends to seek recognition of this integrated degree from the New York Bar Association which would enable the graduates to receive credit for relevant courses taken at Glasgow.

11 The joint programme will offer a fee discount for the combined integrated programme. The combination of professional accreditation with a Masters level qualification is unusual and has considerable potential, especially if promoted to partner institutions in the US.

In January a delegation from the University of Xi'an Jiaotong (XJTU) visited the University with specific interest in exploring possibilities for their law students to study at the School of Law. An agreement has been signed enabling their postgraduate students to come to the School for one year LLM study, sandwiched between their 2 and 3 year masters programme. Agreements have also been signed with two leading Chinese Law Schools with the intention of facilitating Chinese students coming to the University of Glasgow to study for one of our LLM programmes.

Following a visit by Professor Greaves to Brazil in April, an agreement is being entered into with the University of Sao Paulo (USP) for student exchange. Another agreement is being finalised with Pontificia Universidade Catlolica de Sao Paulo (PUC) to enable PUC students to join the Glasgow LLM and then to complete their LLB at PUC with credit awarded by PUC for the Glasgow LLM.

In May 2012 the Law School hosted a visit by academic and administrative staff from the Faculty of Law, University of Oslo . While undergraduate collaboration already occurs through the Erasmus/Study Abroad programme, the visit highlighted areas of potential collaboration at postgraduate level. In the short-term some form of collaboration with regard to PG research, such as a joint PGR conference, seems feasible.

12 In July 2012, Prof Victoria Marich, for the St Petersburg University of Management and Economics (SPbUME ) returned to Glasgow to follow up on the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding, earlier in the year, by signing a Study Abroad agreement for undergraduates from the 11 campuses that cover the length and breadth of the Russian Federation. While here she met with staff from the School of Law, School of Education and the Adam Smith Business School to discuss the possibilities of joint research, 1+1 PGT arrangements and staff development for SPbUME academic staff. The College of Social Sciences looks forward to working with SPbUME in the future.

From left to right: Prof Iain MacNeil (Alexander Stone Chair of Commercial Law), Angela Melley (College International Development Manager), Prof James Conroy (College International Lead), Dr Mark Aleksanyan (Lecturer in Accounting & Finance), Prof Victoria Marich (Vice-Rector for International Relations (SPbUME)), Prof Andrea Nolan (Sr Vice-Principal), Prof Rosa Greaves (Head of School of Law)

A team of five students and Professor Jim Murdoch were invited by the Council of Europe to teach a human rights course at the European Humanities University (EHU) in Vilnius, a university funded by Western governments and donors for law students from Belarus. The intensive one week course focused on the fundamentals of human rights law and the process of taking a case to Strasbourg. This is the third time Glasgow students have taught this course in Lithuania and continues a productive partnership between the school of law and EHU.

A number of recent graduates and Diploma students have been involved in the creation of human rights teaching materials for the Council of Europe. In November the team took part in a symposium in Strasbourg on freedom of expression in the classroom. In April the team were part of a working group in Lucerne alongside education students from Swiss and Croatian Universities. The ongoing project is currently being tested in Scottish schools and a conference will be held in Glasgow in January 2013.This Symposium is the first of a series of annual events organised within the life-cycle of the project “Learning the key principles and the functioning of the European system of protection of human rights” (2010-2014) on different topics of interest for educators and lawyers, education policy makers as well as law students and teachers. The

13 Symposium addressed the broad topic of promoting freedom of expression, not only in the classroom (in respect of senior students in secondary level education) and in the education context but also more generally in helping spread awareness of and respect for the standards and values expressed in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and other standard-setting bodies of the Council of Europe. Link to the website : http://webtv.coe.int/index.php?VODID=235

Internationalisation within the curriculum

21 students - including UG students , LLM by Research students and MSC students of European Politics and Law took part in a Study Visit to Brussels in December 2011. The group was sponsored by David Martin MEP and visited, in addition to the European Parliament, the European Commission (Competition Directorate), Council of the EU, White and Case LLP, Join Law Societies Brussels Office, Scottish Government EU Office and Scotland Europa.

The ‘study abroad’ programme for level 3 students saw a further increase in participation: some 55% of all level 3 students on the Honours programme now spend all or part of their year abroad.

Calgari Summer School Ten undergraduate students and four members of staff took part in the first ERAMUS Intensive programme- funded summer school in Sardinia, Italy in July. This involved a collaboration between Cagliari (Italy); Juan Carlos (Spain); Marburg (Germany) and Glasgow.

Staff and students enjoying the Calgari sunshine 14

Nijmegen Summer School For the first time this year three of our second year students were invited to participate in the annual University of Nijmegen Summer School on European and Comparative Competition Law. Chosen on the basis of their student record in related subjects, on their interest in pursuing further studies in competition law and on their wish to participate as evidenced by a short written essay, Fraser Grier, Michelle Korman and Claire Martin represented the School of Law. The three students worked with students from forty other European Universities and participated enthusiastically in the traditional Moot Court Competition which concludes the Summer School. The organisers reported to us that 'after a fairly brilliant performance, the students from the Glasgow School of Law emerged triumphant, beating the team from Munster in an action-packed final'. The University of Nijmegen very generously covered the costs of the fees of the students, their accommodation and their travel and the School would like to record its thanks to our partner University for this support and particularly to Dr Henri De Waele who is a now an annual visitor to the School where he is part of the teaching team of the second year EU Law course. Dr De Waele facilitated the involvement of the Glasgow students and we look forward to hosting him again in January 2013.

15

SCHOOL’S RESEARCH AND ACADEMIC ACTIVITIES

16

Awards and Funding

Throughout the year, several members of the School staff have secured funding for research work, seminars and events:

• Dr R G Anderson and Mr J MacLeod have been awarded the sum of £4,062 by the Modern Law Review for research on Private Law in Multilingual Jurisdictions . The event, which forms part of the Scottish Association of Comparative Law's programme, took place in June 2012 with visiting speakers from Jersey, Quebec, South Africa and Switzerland.

• Prof R Deazley (PI) has received an amount of £15,000 from the Engineering & Physical Sciences Research Council for ISG - EPSRC: CREATe Startup Activities.

• Dr J Finlay has been awarded a Fellowship worth £46,601 by the Arts and Humanities Research Council for research on Legal Practice in Eighteenth-century Scotland .

• Dr A M Godfrey has received an award from the Gerda Henkel Foundation for the sum of 36,900 euros jointly with Professor Remco van Rhee of the University of Maastricht to conduct a three- year collaborative research project on The Comparative History of Central Courts in Europe and the Americas . The project will focus on the period 1400 and 1700, tracing the origins and jurisdiction of European and American central courts and tribunals, and how they became accepted and embedded within the existing structures of jurisdiction and courts.

• Dr A M Godfrey has been awarded the sum of £23,062 from the Johan Wolfgang Goethe - Universitat, for research on Extrajudicial and Judicial Conflict Resolution in Early Modern Scotland.

• Dr Jane Mair (Glasgow) with Prof Fran Wasoff (Edinburgh) have been awarded (c£74,000) from the ESRC small grants fund for a project entitled All Settled? Private ordering in Scots family law with a

start date of 1 April 2012.

Professor Ronan Deazley led a consortium of 7 Universities to secure the establishment of an Centre for Creative, Regulation, Enterprise and Technology (CREATe) funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council to a total of £5m .

The School has been successful in securing the following doctorial scholarships for postgraduate students: Paul Scott, Gregor Clunie and Paul McClelland from the Modern Law Review.

17 Research Seminars

A series of Research Seminars, organised by academic members of staff including:

11 October Glasgow ILA series: Prof Robert Wai, Osgoode Hall, York University, Canada. ‘Private Power and Transnational Law’

12 October Prof Hans Lindahl, University of Tilburg, ‘Legal Intentionality and the Politics of A- Legality’

21 October School of Law Workshop: Prof Nicholas Tsagourias, University of Glasgow ‘Cyber War and International Law’

9 November Prof Johanna Gibson, Queen Mary, ‘Properties of Taste: Intellectual Property, Fashion and Aesthetic Development’

29 November Glasgow Conversations in International Law: Dr Andrew Lang, (LSE) , Prof Chantal Thomas, (Cornell) , Scott Newton (SOAS) . ‘World Trade Law and Human Rights After Neoliberalism: the Evolution of the Structures of Knowledge’

1 December Lecture by Judge Bruno Simma, ’Reflections on A Decade at the World Court’

18 January Prof Gareth Davies, University of Amsterdam, ‘Immigration and the family rights of citizens at the Court of Justice’

1 February Prof Christopher J. Buccafusco, IIT Chicago-Kent College of Law, ‘Experimental Tests of Creativity and Innovation in Intellectual Property’

7 February Prof Luc Wintgens, University of Brussels , ‘Legisprudence’

10 February Dr Gleider Hernandez, University of Durham , ‘International Court of Justice’

29 February Prof Phil Handler (Manchester) , ‘Intoxication and Criminal Responsibility in England’

7 March Professor Elspeth Christie Reid, University of Edinburgh

14 March Remco van Rhee, Maastricht University , ‘Romano-canonical influence on the development of the law of civil procedure

18 Postgraduate Research Community

PG Colloquium

Organised by the postgraduate students in the School of Law, in association with the Centre for Law and Cosmopolitan Values at the University of Antwerp, the conference on the 6-8 June 2012 featured keynote speakers including Judge Sanji Monageng Attorney-Judge at the International Criminal Court at The Hague. While the main emphasis has in the past been legal theory a very conscious effort has been made to broaden the scope with this year the theme was 'International Justice'.

Professor Rosa Greaves, Judge Sanji Monageng and Professor Anne Anderson

The School’s PhD programme continues to attract candidates of extremely high calibre from around the world. Five candidates completed their programmes successfully in the year 2011-12, and were awarded the degree of PhD. Twelve new candidates were admitted for the coming academic year, one of whom was awarded an Adam Smith Scholarship from the College of Social Sciences. Our candidates are supported financially in attending conferences and events where they have the opportunity to present their research, or which are important to their research. In June we hosted the annual Glasgow/Antwerp/Helskinki PhD Colloquium. This event is run by and for PhD candidates, and attended too by academic staff. In addition to the three partner institutions candidates from as far afield as New York and West Africa attended the event. A number of our PhD candidates past and present have been successful in finding academic posts over the year, including, through open and transparent recruitment processes at the School of Law.

19

Lectures and Conferences

21 October Dr. Russell Buchan and Professor Nicholas Tsagourias , Topic : Conference on 'Cyber War and International Law'.

24 October Intellectual Property Conference, ISO 10668 (Brand Value) – Innovation in Practice

28 October James Wood Lecture- 25th Anniversary –Baroness Hale - Topic : Is it still a Man's World? Women, Children, Citizenship and Migration.

Lord Hope introducing Lady Hale at the 25 th Annual James Wood lecture

29 November Glasgow Conversations in International Law, Topic: World Trade Law and Human Rights After Neoliberalism: the Evolution of the Structures of Knowledge, Speakers : Andrew Lang (LSE); Chantal Thomas (Cornell); Grietje Baars (City University); Paavo Kotiaho (Helsinki) and

Robert Knox (LSE) 1 December Lecture by Bruno Simma awarded an Honorary Degree Topic: Reflections on a Decade at the World Court.

20

20 January Public Lecture by Advocate General, Lord J Wallace on Scotland’s Constitutional Future 27 January Legal Implications of Independence/Devolution Max (co-organised with Edinburgh Centre for Constitutional Law and partially sponsored by the Clark Foundation) 5 March Public Lecture by the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon MSP- Scotland’s Constitutional – a means to an end. 12 March Andrew Dewar Gibb Commemorative Lecture sponsored by the Leslie and Alma Wolfson Trust, given by Lady Hazel Cosgrove. 16/17 March The 2012 Frankfurt Investment Law Workshop was held in Frankfurt/Main and was co- organised by Professor Christian Tams. 16 March Legal Implications of Independence/Devolution Max (co-organised with Edinburgh Centre for Constitutional Law and partially sponsored by the Clark Foundation) 18 May Workshop on Collective Security: Law, Theory and Practice 21/22 May Workshop on the Meaning of Marriage 6 June Scottish Association of Comparative Law Conference, T opic: Private Law in Multi-lingual Context 6-8 June PGR Colloquium on Political Trials and International Justice

21 Knowledge Transfer at International Fora

Staff were invited as keynote speakers or to present papers throughout the world and here is a selection of that activity.

Carruthers, J.M., keynote address on Family Law (subject of International Family Relocation) - VI Seminario de Derecho Internacional Privado, Universidad Complutense De Madrid, Spain.

Crawford, E.B ., delivery of research papers at University of Genoa (November 2011) and Mediterranean Conference Centre, Valletta (May 2012) on 'Mediation in the European Union'.

Dukes, R., 'Sinzheimer and the Constitutional Function of Labour Law', presented at University of Avignon, September 2011

Dukes, R., 'Systems of Worker Representation at Enterprise Level: the UK Report', presented at the Japan Institute of Labour Policy and Training, Tokyo, February 2012

Elliston, S., The regulation of Stem Cell Research , Amman, Jordan organised by Professor Awidi, Professor of medicine, haematology and oncology, Jordan University , Amman , Jordan and the Jordan National Commission for Education, Culture & Science 6th August 2011

Finlay, J., Jurisdictional complexity in post-Union Scotland’, Gerda Henkl meeting, University of Ghent.

Godfrey, A.M., Keynote Evening Lecture at the Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Summer Course in European Legal History at the Max Planck Institute for European Legal History, Frankfurt am Main.

Godfrey, A.M., Invited Lecture in series on “Religion, Law, Politics” of the Exzellenzcluster Religion und Politik, Institute of Legal History, University of Münster. 8 May 2012.

Godfrey, A.M., Invited Lecture in series Zürcher Ausspracheabende für Rechtsgeschichte, Institute of Legal Science, University of Zürich, “Justice, Feud and the State in Early Modern Scotland.” 24 April 2012.

Greaves, R.M., invited to deliver a paper entitled “ recent Developments in EU Competition Law: Air Malta State Aid Decision” at the Maltese Association for European Law ( AMSDE), July 2012.

Mair, J., Two papers on The Reconciliation of Private and Professional Responsibilities at 2-day seminars on EU Gender Equality for EU judges at ERA, Trier - October 2011 and May 2012.

Mclean, S.A . presented a paper to meeting of the Centre for Reproductive Rights at the European Parliament in March 2012 Mclean, S.A . presented a paper at the University of Trento, Italy in May 2012 and also at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid.

Papanicolopulu, I., “The Law Applicable to Persons at Sea”, lecture at the Netherlands Institute for the Law of the Sea (NILOS), University of Utrecht (Utrecht, Netherlands), 6 June 2012.

Papanicolopulu, I., “Human Rights and the Law of the Sea”, lecture at the International Maritime Law Institute (Malta), 5 April 2012.

22 Papanicolopulu, I., “A Missing Part of the Law of the Sea Convention: Addressing Issues of State Jurisdiction over Persons at Sea”, paper presented at the Law of the Sea Institute Conference “The Limits of Maritime Jurisdiction”, Wollongong (Australia), 28 November - 2 December 2011.

Rahmatian, A., Talk: “Death of the Author” und die eigenwillige “Romantic Author”-Diskussion im Anglo- Amerikanischen Copyright - at the Friedrich Schiller Universität Jena, Rechtswissenschaftliche Fakultät (Faculty of Law), Univ.-Prof. Dr. Volker Jänich, Jena, Germany, 17 November 2011.

Rahmatian, A., International Association for the Advancement of Teaching and Research in Intellectual Property (ATRIP), Chicago, July 29 to August 1, 2012, giving paper: ‘Turning Belief into Science? The Law- and-Economics Analysis of Intellectual Property Rights’ .

Tams, C., Conference on The Armenian Genocide: From recognition to Repatriation , Beruit, February 2012, giving a paper ‘ Questions Related to Implementation of Responsibility’.

Tams, C., Keynote speaker at the Preferential Trade and Investment Agreements: A New Ordering Paradigm for International Investment Relations? Frankfurt Investment Law Workshop 2012 ,in Leiden.

Tams, C., and Tzanakopoulos, A . , International Legal Positivism in a Postmodern World (University of Freiburg | University of Amsterdam): ‘International Legal Positivism and the Use of Force’ [with CJ Tams] (Amsterdam, The Netherlands, November 2011).

Tzanakopoulos, A . , Strengthening the Rule of Law through the United Nations Security Council: The Security Council, Sanctions, and the Rule of Law (Australian Government—Asia Pacific Civil-Military Centre of Excellence | Australian National University): ‘Disobeying Sanctions’ (Permanent Mission of Australia to the UN, New York, US, May 2012).

Tzanakopoulos, A . , Transparency in International Law (University of Basel | Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies Geneva): ‘Transparency in the UN Security Council’ (Thun, Switzerland, January 2012).

23

APPENDICES

24 Appendix A: Annual Calendar of Events

2011

5 October Law Fair

11 October Glasgow ILA series – Speaker: Prof Robert Wai, Osgoode Hall, York University, Canada. Topic: ‘Private Power and Transnational Law’.

12 October Research Seminar Series. Speaker: Professor Hans Lindahl of the University of Tilburg , Topic: ‘Legal Intentionality and the Politics of A-Legality’

13 October Glasgow 40 event, A Question of Status: Palestinian Statehood, UN Membership and their Implications.

13 October Glasgow Forum for Scots Law , Title: 'Leases', Speaker : Dr Peter Webster, solicitor and former judicial assistant, Supreme Court

20 0ctober Copyright and Fair Use in the US: ‘Transformativeness’ Twenty Years On Prof Peter Jaszi, Washington College of Law, American University

21 October Dr. Russell Buchan and Professor Nicholas Tsagourias , Topic : Conference on 'Cyber War and International Law'.

24 October Intellectual Property Conference, ISO 10668 (Brand Value) – Innovation in Practice

27 October IP Lunchtime Seminar Series, Speake r: Philip Hannay (Macdonald Henderson Solicitors), Topic : Intellectual Property Governance

27 October Glasgow Forum for Scots Law, Speaker: Ross Anderson, Topic: UK Codification of

Commercial Law: the Funds-Attached Rule in comparative perspective

28 October James Wood Lecture – Lady Baroness Hale, Topic: Is it still a Man's World? Women, Children, Citizenship and Migration.

7 November Award ceremony for Diploma students

8 November Futures Event: Working for the Government

10 November Glasgow Forum for Scots Law, Speaker: Bonnie Holligan, PhD candidate, University of Edinburgh, Topic: Bona Fide Purchase of Corporeal Moveables and the

Vindicatory Action

17 November Glasgow 40 event

22 November Sheriff Moot

24 November IP lunchtime lecture, Speaker: Rosalind McInnes, Topic: Reality TV & the Law

25

29 November Glasgow Conversations in International Law, Topic: World Trade Law and Human Rights After Neoliberalism: the Evolution of the Structures of Knowledge, Speakers : Andrew Lang (LSE); Chantal Thomas (Cornell); Grietje Baars (City

University); Paavo Kotiaho (Helsinki) and Robert Knox (LSE)

1 December Graduation for Postgraduate law students

Lecture by Judge Bruno Simma, Topic: Reflections on a Decade at the World Court

1 December Glasgow Forum for Scots Law , Speaker : Stephen Bogle

2 December Glasgow ILA Workshop: Beyond 'Austinian Handicap': Theorising Enforcement in International Law

5 December Glasgow Alumni Dinner, Brussels

8 December School/Glasgow 40 - social event

2012

12 January Glasgow Forum for Scots Law

18 January Research Series: Speaker : Prof Gareth Davies, University of Amsterdam, Topic: The family rights of European children

20 January Public Lecture by Advocate General, Lord J Wallace on Scotland’s Constitutional Future

27 January Legal Implications of Independence/Devolution Max (co-organised with Edinburgh Centre for Constitutional Law and partially sponsored by the Clark Foundation)

31 January Futures Event, Topic : Thinking of a career at the Bar? Speaker : Douglas Lloyd (Pupil at 15 New Street Chambers, London)

Futures Event, Topic: Your Future Working in Brussels, Speaker : Catherine Howdle, EU Policy Advisor, The Law Societies, Brussels

1 February Research Series: Speaker: Prof Christopher Buccafusco, IIT Chicago-Kent College of Law, Topic : Experimental Tests of Creativity & Innovation in IP

8 February Research Series: Professor Luc Wintgens, University of Brussels, Topic : ‘Can rules be

more rational than the ruler?’

5 March Public Lecture by the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon MSP- Scotland’s Constitution – a means to an end.

9 February Glasgow Forum for Scots Law , Speaker: Dr Andreas Rahmatian, T opic: The Institutional Writers' Phenomenon in Scots Law 26 9 February Life in Law: Speaker: The Solicitor General, Lesley Thomson QC

10 February Research Series, Speaker: Dr Gleider Hermandez, University of Durham, Topic: ‘The Judicial Character of the International Court of Justice’

23 February Glasgow Forum for Scots Law, Speaker: Dr Andrew Simpson (University of Aberdeen), T opic: David Chalmers' (c1533-1592) defence of the legal rights of women.

29 February Research Series, Prof Phil Handler (Manchester), T opic: Intoxication and Criminal Responsibility in England

1 March Glasgow Forum for Scots Law , Speaker: Neil Campbell, Solicitor, Legal Assistant, Scottish Law Commission, Topic: Positive Prescription of Moveables

8 March Research Series, Speaker: Prof Elspeth Reid, University of Edinburgh, Title: 'The treatment of political speech in the Russian law of defamation'

12 March Andrew Dewar Gibb Commemorative Lecture sponsored by the Leslie and Alma Wolfson Trust, given by Lady Hazel Cosgrove.

14 March Research Series, Speaker: Remco van Rhee, Maastricht University, Title: 'Romano- canonical influence on the development of the law of civil procedure'

14 March Alexander Stone Moot Final, judged by the Rt Hon Lord Bonomy

16 March Legal Implications of Independence/Devolution Max (co-organised with Edinburgh Centre for Constitutional Law and partially sponsored by the Clark Foundation)

19 March Dean’s Cup Moot, Lord Tyre

5 April Glasgow Forum for Scots Law, Speaker: Korrasut Khopuangklang, University of Edinburgh, Topic: Promise

18 May Workshop on Collective Security: law, theory and practice

21/22 May Workshop on the Meaning of Marriage

6 June Scottish Association of Comparative Law Conference, T opic: Private Law in Multi- lingual Context, Speakers: Sir Philip Bailhache; Professor Eric Clive; Professor Max Loubser; Professor Jorg Schmi & Prof Lionel Smith

6-8 June PGR Colloquium on Political Trials and International Justice

22 June Graduation for Undergraduate Law students

27 Appendix B: Internationalisation

Undergraduate International Student Exchange

Total number of incoming students: 115 Total number of outgoing students: 83

From Europe: 92 To Europe: 54

From USA / Canada: 6 To USA / Canada: 9

From rest of world: 17 To rest of world: 20

Postgraduate

Total number of taught postgraduate students: 98

From UK: 29

From Europe: 23

From rest of world: 46

In total, there were taught masters students enrolled in the LLM programmes from 28 different countries.

Postgraduate class of 2011 At the December graduation with Honorary graduand Judge Bruno Simma flanked by Professor Christian Tams and Professor Rosa Greaves.

28 Visiting Staff

The School of Law hosted visits from:

o Associate Professor Colin Gavaghan, University of Otago, New Zealand

o Dr Jiin Ger, Scholar, China. Researching in medical law

o Dr Tom Hickey, Scholar, National University of Ireland

o Dr Gaetano Marzulli, Scholar, University of Bari, Italy

o Mr Sacha Meuter, PhD student, Fribourg University

o Professor Kerry Petersen, Professor of Law, La Trobe University, Melbourne

o Professor Wei Sen, Professor of Law at Central China Normal University. Research interests are in the field of copyright law

o Professor Kersuke Ueda, Professor of Law, Kinki University Law School, Japan. Research field is constitutional law with particular focus on cabinet government.

o Dr Ana Maria Encarnacion Valcarel Universidad Cardenal Herrara, CEU Valencia

o Dr Li Yunhua, Wuhan University China: The Legal System of Employment-related Rights

29 Appendix C: Graduations

Undergraduate 161 LLB Honours graduates

20 Joint Honours: 2 with First Class Honours

19 Law and Languages: 4 with First Class Honours

122 Single Honours: 29 with First Class Honours

32 LLB Ordinary graduates

LLB Ordinary with Distinction = 14

LLB Ordinary with Merit = 14

LLB Ordinary with Merit = 4

Postgraduate

LLM Graduates 98: 10 with Distinctions

MRes 2

PhD 5

Diploma in Legal Practice 163 in total

12 distinction

105 with merit

46 Qualified

30

Appendix D: Publications

Anderson, G ., Bell, C., Craig, S. , McHarg, A. , Mullen, T. , Tierney, S., and Walker, N. (2012) The independence referendum, legality and the contested constitution: widening the debate. UK Constitutional Law Group Blog .

Anderson, R.G. (2012) Symposium on reform of security over moveable property: a critique. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (2). pp. 267-272. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2012.0106)

Anderson, R.G . (2012) Scottish share pledges in the Supreme Court. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (1). pp. 99- 104. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2012.0084)

Anderson, R.G., and Biemans, J. (2012) Reform of the law of assignation in security: lessons from the Netherlands. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (1). pp. 24-57. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2012.0082)

Anderson, R.G. (Ed.) (2011) Avizandum Scots Commercial and Consumer Law Statutes 2011-2012. Avizandum, Edinburgh, UK. ISBN 9781904968467

Anderson, R.G. (2011) UK sales: loss of the right to reject goods: judgment of the Scottish Outer House of 5 February 2010. Zeitschrift fur Europaisches Privatrecht, 2011 (3). pp. 655-668. ISSN 0943-3929

Burrows, N ., and Robison, M. (2012) The motherhood penalty: the contribution of Europe. In: Nic Shuibhne, N. and Gormley, L.W. (eds.) From Single Market to Economic Union : Essays in memory of John A. Usher. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 201-220. ISBN 9780199695706

Carruthers, J.M. ‘The Brussels I Regulation Recast’ 2011 S.L.T. 31 – 35 (Issue 7) ISSN 0036-908X.

Chalmers, J. (2011) Regulating adolescent sexuality: English and Scottish approaches compared. Child and Family Law Quarterly , 23 (4). pp. 450-464. ISSN 1358-8184

Chalmers, J. , and Leverick, F. (2011) When should a retrial be permitted after a conviction is quashed on appeal? Modern Law Review , 74 (5). pp. 721-749. ISSN 0026-7961 (doi:10.1111/j.1468-2230.2011.00868.x)

Chalmers, J. (2011) Partial Defences to Murder in Scotland: An Unlikely Tranquillity . In: Bohlander, M. and Reed, A. (eds.) Loss of Control and Diminished Responsibility: Domestic, Comparative and International Perspectives on the Coroners and Justice Act 2009. Ashgate, Farnham, pp. 167-181. ISBN 9781409431756

Chalmers, J. (2011) Trusts . In: Black, G (ed.). Business Law in Scotland. 2nd ed. W. Green, Edinburgh, pp. 426-456. ISBN 9780414018273

Christodoulidis, E . (2011) Depoliticising poverty: Arendt in South Africa. Stellenbosch Law Review, 22 (3). pp. 501-520. ISSN 1016-4359

Christodoulidis, E. (2011) The degenerative constitutional moment: Bruce Ackerman and 'The Decline and Fall of the American Republic'. Modern Law Review, 74 (6). pp. 962-973. ISSN 0026-7961 (doi:10.1111/j.1468-2230.2011.00880.x)

Connelly, C. (2012) “Domestic Abuse: The Violence of Privacy”, in Scottish Life and Society: A Compendium of Scottish Ethnology (Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press)

Connelly, C. (2011) Specialist responses to domestic abuse. In: Hughes, H. (ed.) Domestic Abuse and Scots Law. W. Green, Edinburgh. ISBN 9780414017887

31 Connelly, C. (2011) “Specialist Responses to Domestic Abuse “, in “Domestic Abuse and Scots Law” H. Hughes, ed., (Edinburgh, W. Green).

Craig, S., and Fletcher, M. (2012) The supervision of immigration and asylum appeals in the UK: taking stock. International Journal of Refugee Law, 24 (1). pp. 60-84. ISSN 0953-8186 (doi:10.1093/ijrl/eer040)

Craig, S. (2012) Judicial review: How much is too much? A view of Eba, Cart and MR (Pakistan) from the asylum and immigration perspective. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (2). pp. 210-223. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2012.0104)

Crawford, E.B., and Carruthers, J.M. (2011) Dual locality events: marriage by telephone. Scots Law Times, 2011 (29). pp. 227-234. ISSN 0036-908X

Deazley, R., and Sullivan, R. (2011) Copyright, licences, and statutory fraud. Journal of Media Law, 3 (2). pp. 287-303. ISSN 1757-7632 (doi:10.5235/175776311799280782)

Deazley, R. (2011) Review of 'Copyright law and the public interest in the nineteenth century' by Isabella Alexander. Modern Law Review, 74 (3). pp. 499-501. ISSN 0026-7961 (doi:10.1111/j.1468-2230.2011.856- 7.x)

Dukes, R., and Christodoulidis, E. (2012) Habermas and the European social dialogue: deliberative democracy as industrial democracy? International Union Rights Journal, 18 (4). pp. 20-21.

Dukes, R., ( 2012) Systems of employee representation at the enterprise: UK report. in Blanpain, R., Nakakuo, H. and Araki, T. (eds.) Systems of Employee Representation at the Enterprise: A Comparative Study. Series: Bulletin of comparative labour relations (81). (Kluwer).

Farmer, L. (2012) W.E. Vaughan, 'Murder Trials in Ireland, 1836-1914'; Eleanor Gordon and Gwyneth Nair, 'Murder and Morality in Victorian Britain: the Story of Madeleine Smith': Reviews. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (1). pp. 143-145. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2012.0099)

Farmer, L. (2012) Of treatises and textbooks: the literature of criminal law in nineteenth century Britain. In: Dubber, M. and Fernandez, A. (eds.) Law Books in Action. Hart Publishing, Oxford, UK, pp. 145-164.

Farmer, L. (2012) Scots criminal law. In: Mulhern, M. (ed.) Law: A Compendium of Scottish Ethnology. Series: Scottish Life and Society . Tuckwell Press / European Ethnological Research Centre, East Linton, UK, pp. 177-190.

Finlay, J. (2012) The Community of the College of Justice: Edinburgh and the Court of Session 1687-1808 (296pp). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. (ISBN 978 0 7846 4577 0).

Finlay, J. (2012) Trusts. Dundee University Press, Dundee, UK. ISBN 9781845861292

Finlay, J. (2011) Arbitration in Eighteenth-Century Scotland. Juridical Review, 2011 . pp. 277-291. ISSN 0022- 6785

Finlay, J. (2011) Religion in the history of family law in Scotland. In: Mair, J. and Orucu, E. (eds.) The Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search. Series: European family law (30). Intersentia, Cambridge, OR, USA, pp. 267-302. ISBN 9781780680156

Finlay, J. (2011) Scots lawyers and House of Lords appeals in Eighteenth-Century Britain. Journal of Legal History, 32 (3). pp. 249-277. ISSN 0144-0365 (doi:10.1080/01440365.2011.627151)

32 Godfrey, A. M., (2012) The courts of Scotland. In: Mulhern, M.A. (ed.) The Law. Series: Scottish Life and Society: A Compendium of Scottish Ethnology (13). European Ethnological Research Centre, Edinburgh, pp. 131-154. ISBN 9781906566043

Greaves, R. (2012) A private right conferred directly by EU trade mark law: an analysis of the concept of 'distinctiveness' under EU Law. In: Nic Shuibhne, Niamh and Gormley, L.W. (eds.) From Single Market to Economic Union. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 135-153. ISBN 9780199695706

Leverick, F. (2012) Sentence discounting for guilty pleas: a question of guidelines. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (2). pp. 233-238. ISSN 1364-9809

Leverick, F. (2011) The Supreme Court's role in Scottish criminal matters. Counsel, Nov . pp. 27-28. ISSN 0268-3784

Leverick, F. (2011) The Supreme Court strikes back. Edinburgh Law Review, 15 (2). pp. 287-292. ISSN 1364- 9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2011.0031)

MacNeil, I. (2012) [Contributions]. In: Birds, J., Hildyard, R., Miles, R., Boardman, N. and Davis-White, M. (eds.) Annotated Companies Legislation. 2nd ed. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK. ISBN 9780199652693

MacNeil, I. (2012) An Introduction to the Law on Financial Investment. Hart, Oxford. ISBN 9781849460507

MacNeil, I. (2011) Takeovers and mergers. In: Birds, J., Boyle, A.J., Clark, B., MacNeil, I., McCormack, G., Twigg-Flesner, C. and Villiers, C. (eds.) Boyle and Birds' Company Law. 8th edition. Jordans, Bristol, UK, pp. 803-856. ISBN 9781846612879

MacNeil, I. (2011) The public issue of securities. In: Birds, J., Boyle, A.J., Clark, B., MacNeil, I., McCormack, G., Twigg-Flesner, C. and Villiers, C. (eds.) Boyle and Birds' Company Law. 8th edition. Jordans, Bristol, UK, pp. 749-802. ISBN 9781846612879

Mair, J. (2012) Marriage: a lasting legal relationship. In: Mulhern, M.A. (ed.) Scottish Life and Society: The Law: A Compendium of Scottish Ethnology. Birlinn. ISBN 9781906566043

Mair, J. (2011) Alison Cleland and Elaine E. Sutherland (eds.), 'Children's Rights in Scotland': Review. Edinburgh Law Review, 15 (1). pp. 153-154. ISSN 1364-9809

McCarthy, F. (2011) Property. In: Miller, A (ed.) Greens Scottish Human Rights Service. W. Green, Edinburgh, C701-C722.

McCarthy, F . (2011) Cohabitation: lessons from north of the border. Child and Family Law Quarterly, 23 (3). pp. 277-301. ISSN 1358-8184

McCarthy, F. (2011) Delict. In: Black, G. (ed.) Business Law in Scotland. W. Green, Edinburgh, UK, pp. 328- 363. ISBN 9780414018273

McCarthy, F. (2011) Playing the percentages: New Zealand, Scotland and a global solution to the consequences of non-marital relationships? New Zealand Universities Law Review, 24 (4). pp. 499-522. ISSN 0549-0618

McCarthy, F. (2011) Prayers in the playground: religion and education in the United Kingdom and beyond. In: Mair, J. and Orucu, E. (eds.) The Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search. Series: European family law (30). Intersentia, Cambridge, OR, USA, pp. 235-262. ISBN 9781780680156

33 McLean, S.A., (2012) ‘Ethical dilemmas in obstetrics and gynaecology’, in Edmonds, K. (ed .) Dewhurst's Textbook of Obstetrics and Gynaecology . Wiley, Chichester. 805-814

McLean, S.A., (2011) End-of-life Decision-making in Canada – The Report by the Royal Society of Canada Expert Panel’, Bioethics, Special Issue, Volume 25, Issue Supplement s1, 1-73 (co-author)

McLean, S.A., ‘Decisions and dilemmas at the end of life, in Mulhearn, M. (ed.) Law: A Compendium of Scottish Ethnology , Volume 13, Edinburgh, John Donald, 2012, 737-749

Metzger, E. (2012) Law and procedure, Rome: Civil procedure [additions and revisions to]. In: Hornblower, S., Spawforth, A. and Eidinow, E. (eds.) Oxford Classical Dictionary. 4th edition. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199567386

Metzger, E. (2012) Remedy of prohibition against Roman judges in civil trials. In: Brand, P. and Getzler, J. (eds.) Judges and Judging in the History of the Common Law: From Antiquity to Modern Times. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp. 177-191. ISBN 9781107018976

Moncrieff, L., (2011), 'The Molotov Milkshake: Corporate Social Responsibility and the Market', Law and Critique, Vol. 22, Issue 3.

Mullen, T. (2011) Devolution in Scotland: Increasing autonomy? European Public Law, 17 (3). pp. 399-414. ISSN 1354-3725

Murdoch, J., and Reed, R. (2011) Human Rights Law in Scotland. 3rd edition. Bloomsbury Professional, Edinburgh. ISBN 9781847665560

Murdoch, J. (2011) Freedom of Thought, Conscience and Religion: a Guide to the Implemention of Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Series: Human Rights Handbooks, 9 . Council of Europe, Strasbourg.

Örücü, E ., ( 2012) ‘Multiculturalism: ‘Spice’ of Lives, ‘Bane of Legal Systems?’ in S Garner & Kavak, Ş (eds) Debating Multiculturalism, Dialogue Society, London , ISBN 978-0-9569304-5-3, 57-70

Örücü, E ., (2011) ‘An assessment of the developments in the Turkish Civil Code: family law and succession’ in FJA van der Velden and F İbılı (eds) Turks personen- en familierecht in de Nederlandse rechtspraktijk , (Kluwer), pp. 11-40. ISBN 9789013098037 Nur 822-110

Örücü, E .,( 2011) ‘Introduction to the Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search’ in J. Mair & E. Örücü (eds) The Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search Family Law Series: 30(CEFL/ Intersentia, Antwerp), pp. 3-11. ISBN 978- 1-78068-015-6

Örücü, E .,( 2011) ‘How Far Can Religion be Accommodated in Laic Family Law of Turkey?’ in J. Mair & E. Örücü (eds) The Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search Family Law Series: 30 (CEFL/ Intersentia, Antwerp), pp. 117-157. ISBN 978-1-78068-015-6

Mair, J. & Örücü, E., (eds) (2011) The Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search Family Law Series: 30 (CEFL/ Intersentia, Antwerp). ISBN 978-1-78068-015-6

Örücü, E., (2011) ‘The Turkish Constitution Revamped yet Again’ 17:1 European Public Law , pp. 11-24

Papanicolopulu, I., (2012) “Mediterranean Sea” , in WOLFRUM (ed.), Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law , Vol. VII, Oxford University Press, pp. 61-70. 34 Milano, E., and Papanicolopulu, I., “State Responsibility in Disputed Areas on Land and at Sea” , in Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht , vol. 71, 2011, p. 587 Papanicolopulu, I., (2011) “Submission to Arbitration of the Dispute on the Marine Protected Area around the Chagos Archipelago” , in The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law, vol. 26, pp. 667–678

Papanicolopulu, I., (2011,“The European Union and the Regulation of Underwater Noise Pollution” , in VIDAS & SCHEI (eds.), The World Ocean in Globalization: Challenges and Responses , Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden/Boston, pp. 457-471

Scovazzi, T., Papanicolopulu, I., and Francalanci, G., (2011) “Albania-Greece” , in COLSON & SMITH (eds.), International Maritime Boundaries , vol. VI, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden/Boston, pp. 4462-4476

Scovazzi, T., Papanicolopulu, I., and Francalanci, G., (2011) Cyprus-Egypt” , in COLSON & SMITH (eds.), International Maritime Boundaries , vol. VI, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden/Boston,2011, pp. 4445- 4454 Pavlakos, G. (2012) Correctness and Cognitivism: Remarks on Robert Alexy's argument from the claim to correctness. Ratio Juris, 25 (1). pp. 15-30. ISSN 0952-1917 Rahmatian, A. (2012) The English pound in an independent Scotland. Journal of International Banking Law and Regulation, 27 (9). pp. 336-339. ISSN 1742-6812

Rahmatian, A. (2011) The Hargreaves Review on copyright licensing and exceptions: a missed moment of opportunity. Entertainment Law Review, 22 (8). pp. 219-223. ISSN 0959-3799

Rasulov, A,. (2012) ‘The Doctrine of Sources in the Discourse of the Permanent Court of International Justice’, in Malgosia Fiztmaurice and Christian Tams (eds.), The Legacies of the Permanent Court of International Justice.

Rasulov, A,. (2012) ‘New Approaches to International Law: Images of a Genealogy’, in Jose Maria Beneyto and David Kennedy (eds.), New Approaches to International Law: The European and the American Experiences (TMC Asser-Springer), pp. 151-191.

Rasulov, A ,.( 2011) ‘The Nameless Rapture of the Struggle: Towards a Marxist Class-Theoretic Approach to International Law’, 19 Finnish Yearbook of International Law (2008), pp. 243-294.

Rennie, R. (2012) The 20 Year Rule and the McLetchie Amendment. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (1). pp. 114- 116. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/elr.2012.0084)

Rennie, R. (2012) The end of immunity for expert witnesses. Scots Law Gazette, 37

Rennie, R. (2011) Enforcement of missives. Scots Law Times, 2011 (24). pp. 169-173. ISSN 0036-908X

Rennie, R. (2011) Pre-2004 real burdens - the end game. Scots Law Times, 2011 (23). pp. 163-168. ISSN 0036-908X

Rennie, R. (2011) Annotations on the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011. Sweet and Maxwell. ISBN 9780414012646

Rennie, R. (2011) Interest enforced. Scots Law Times (28). pp. 217-221. ISSN 0036-908X

Rennie, R. (2011) Interpretation of commercial missives. Scots Law Times, 37 . pp. 273-279. ISSN 0036-908X

Robinson, O., (2012) Matters Criminal, Stair Society, vol.59, 2012, xxxii + 490 pp

35 Sloan, J., and Cerda, A.S. (2012) The impact of the distinction between situations and cases on the participation of victims in the International Criminal Court. In: McCorkindale, C. and Clunie, G. (eds.) The Public in Law. Ashgate, Aldershot, UK, pp. 235-262. ISBN 978-1-4094-1909-9

Sloan, J. (2012) Civilized nations. In: Wolfrum, R. (ed.) The Max-Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.

Sloan, J. (2011) The Militarisation of Peacekeeping in the 21st Century. Hart, Oxford. ISBN 9781849461146

Gerner-Beuerle, C., Kershaw, D., and Solinas, M . (2011) Is the board neutrality principle rule trivial? Amnesia about corporate law in European takeover regulation. European Business Law Review, 22 (5). pp. 559-622. ISSN 0959-6941

Solinas, M. (2012) Analysis: right of appropriation and legal change. Edinburgh Law Review, 16 (3). pp. 445- 450. ISSN 1364-9809 (doi:10.3366/ELR.2012.0122)

Solinas, M. (2011) The law of shares transfer in England after the enactment of the Companies Act 2006. Contratto e Impresa Europa, 2 . pp. 581-603. ISSN 1127-2872

Tams, C.J., and Tzanakopoulos, A., The Settlement of International Disputes: Basic Documents (Hart, Oxford 2012) (Series: Documents in International Law) xx + 838 pp

Tams, C.J., and Joetten, S. (2012) Die Charta der Vereinten Nationen und die Allgemeine Erkl. In: Pollmann, A. and Lohmann, G. (eds.) Menschenrechte: Ein Interdisziplin. Metzler, Stuttgart, Germany, pp. 116-122.

Tams, C. (2012) Prospects for humanitarian uses of force. In: Cassese, A. (ed.) Realizing Utopia: The Future of International Law. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, pp. 359-374. ISBN 9780199647088

Tams, C., and Devaney, J. (2012) Applying necessity and proportionality to anti-terrorist self-defence. Israel Law Review, 45 (1). pp. 91-106. ISSN 0021-2237

Simma, B., and Tams, C.J., Reacting against Treaty Breaches, in Hollis, D. (ed.), The Oxford Guide to Treates (Oxford, Oxford University Press)

Tams, C., and Tzanakopoulos, A. (2011) IGH: Gutachten zur Unabhängigkeit Kosovos. Vereinte Nationen, 59 (2). pp. 80-82. ISSN 0042-384X

Tams, C . (2011) Re-Introducing Walther Schücking. European Journal of International Law, 22 . pp. 725-739. ISSN 0938-5428

Tams, C.J. and Hofmann, R. (eds.) International Investment Law and General International Law: From Clinical Isolation to Systemic Integration? Nomos, Baden-Baden, Germany. ISBN 9783832967291

Tomkins, A., Fenwick, H., and Lazarus, L. (2011) Terrorist asset-freezing: continuing flaws in the current scheme. International Review of Law, Computers and Technology, 25 (3). pp. 117-128. ISSN 1360-0869 (doi:10.1080/13600869.2011.617433)

Tzanakopoulos, A . (2012) Domestic Courts as the “Natural Judge” of International Law: A Change in Physiognomy. In: Crawford, J. and Nouwen, S. (eds.) Select Proceedings of the European Society of International Law, Volume 3, 2010. Hart, Oxford, pp. 155-168. ISBN 9781849462020

36 Tzanakopoulos, A. (2012) Collective Security and Human Rights. In: de Wet, E. and Vidmar, J. (eds.) Hierarchy in International Law: The Place of Human Rights. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 42-70. ISBN 978-0-19-964707-1

Tzanakopoulos, A. (2012) Judicial dialogue in multi-level governance: the impact of the Solange Argument. In: Fauchald, O.K. and Nollkaemper, A. (eds.) The Practice of International and National Courts and the (De- Fragmentation of International Law. Hart, Oxford, pp. 185-215. ISBN 9781849462471

Tzanakopoulos, A . (2011) The Distomo Case: Greece to Intervene in the Sovereign Immunity Dispute between Germany and Italy before the ICJ. EJIL: Talk! .

37